Downtown Advisory Committee
Regular MeetingCarbondale, IL · November 12, 2014
Agenda
1. Active Outdoor Branding Social Offerings Aesthetics Openness Power Point
Documents:
ACTIVE OUTDOOR BRANDING SOCIAL OFFERINGS AESTHETICS OPENNESS
POWER POINT.PDF
2. Alumni Community Survey Power Point
Documents:
ALUMNI COMMUNITY SURVEY POWER POINT .PDF
3. Past-Present-Future Power Point
Documents:
PAST-PRESENT-FUTURE POWER POINT .PDF
4. Report On DAC Meeting Number 7
Documents:
REPORT ON DAC MEETING NUMBER 7 .PDF
Packet
1. Active Outdoor Branding Social Offerings Aesthetics Openness Power Point
Documents:
ACTIVE OUTDOOR BRANDING SOCIAL OFFERINGS AESTHETICS OPENNESS
POWER POINT.PDF
2. Alumni Community Survey Power Point
Documents:
ALUMNI COMMUNITY SURVEY POWER POINT .PDF
3. Past-Present-Future Power Point
Documents:
PAST-PRESENT-FUTURE POWER POINT .PDF
4. Report On DAC Meeting Number 7
Documents:
REPORT ON DAC MEETING NUMBER 7 .PDF
Lessons learned from the DAC
Branding – Social Offerings –Aesthetics ‐ Openness
The Knight Foundation tasked the Gallup
Organization to determine “what makes a community
a desirable place”? 43,000 people were interviewed in
26 American communities.
Here are the three top “drivers”:
1. Social offerings – entertainment venues and places to
meet
2. Aesthetics – physical beauty and green space
3. Openness – how welcoming a community is
.
What are the unique and historic attributes that can
lead to a brand?
How can our youth population of 70% millennials be
better integrated into our city?
Our community is in the top 5% in educational –
unique in the region and state.
What about the rising level of international students
and entrepreneurial immigrants? Will they feel
welcome?
Near in neighborhoods want a walkable city
How can kids from different backgrounds meet?
The Illinois Central
Railroad – 143 trains
a day in the early
part of the 20th
Century – 53
passenger trains
daily.
Carbondale was
Division
Headquarters
C’Dale ‐ node on the
world wide web of
the 19th Century
Southern
Illinois
University with
over 18,000
students
R. Buckminster
Fuller is the
symbol of a
world class
university
We create spaces that honor our history
We create social offerings where there is
entertainment and places to randomly meet
We make these spaces beautiful
We make sure that everyone has access to them and
feels welcome in our town
CARBONDALE HAS NO PARK
Carterville Skate Park
Carbondale Skaters
Maasai Cricket warriors
Bangkok and Southeast Asia
Geodesic fixture
Bentonville, Arkansas ‐ Sculpture
Amsterdam ‐ umbrellas
Tensegity Balls
Historical marker – Dome strength
test, Carbondale
Wooden slat Dome ‐ Berlin
Ohio Dome
Morgantown, WV Market Place
Railroad bike rack
Railroad themed way‐finder
Our committee’s ideas, along with the comments
from Carbondale citizens have been terrific
Whatever we incorporate in our final
recommendations must have a view towards
synergy.
Let’s take heed of SIU President Randy Dunn
who urged us to think BIG.
WELCOME!
Carbondale Downtown Master Plan
Advisory Committee
Public Meeting – Economic, Civic, and
Neighborhood Viability
Carbondale Community High School
November 12, 2014
ALUMNI COMMUNITY SURVEY
PAUL SIMON PUBLIC POLICY INSTITUTE
SIU ALUMNI ASSOCIATION
“WHAT IS YOUR PRIMARY REASON FOR VISITING CARBONDALE?”
“WHEN YOU LAST VISITED CARBONDALE, HOW WOULD YOU RATE THE
FOLLOWING SERVICES?” (1=POOR; 4 = EXCELLENT)
Average Rating
Parking 2.62
Traffic 2.83
Shopping 2.3
Dining 2.57
Entertainment 2.47
Hotels/Lodging 2.53
1 2 3 4
“WOULD YOU ENCOURAGE A YOUNG PERSON TO PURSUE A
DEGREE AT SIU?”
No Most of the respondents would
9%
recommend SIU (91%)
More than half (51%) would
recommend Carbondale as a place to
visit
Only a quarter (27%) would
recommend Carbondale as a place to
live
Yes
91%
TRANSPORTATION
PREFERENCES, BEHAVIOR, AREAS OF NEED IN CARBONDALE
“DO YOU PREFER LIVING IN A PLACE WHERE MOST PEOPLE RELY ON CARS
TO GET AROUND OR IN A PLACE WHERE MOST PEOPLE HAVE
TRANSPORTATION OPTIONS SO THEY DO NOT NEED TO RELY ON CARS?”
More than half of the alumni surveyed
(57%) would rather live in a place where
Rely on they did not have to rely on cars
cars
43% 61% of the most recent group of
graduates (2011-2015) would rather live
Options in a place where they don’t have to rely
57%
on cars
“AS A STUDENT AT SIU, HOW DID YOU GET AROUND MOST
DAYS?”
Other
(please
specify)
4%
Riding a More than half of the Alumni polled
bike (54%) primarily got around
14% Carbondale on foot, by bike, or with
By car public transportation
42%
Only 39% of the most recent group
of Alumni (graduation year between
Walking 2011-2015) primarily used a car to
39% get around Carbondale
By public
transportat
ion, such as
the Saluki
Express
1%
“HOW WOULD YOU RATE DOWNTOWN CARBONDALE ON THE
FOLLOWING?” (RANKED FROM WORST TO LESS BAD)
A convenient and Opportunities to live A wide range of Bicycle trails and
reliable public and work without transportation lanes
transportation relying only on a car options
system
Excel Excel
Excel Excel lent
lent
lent lent 4%
4%
3% 5%
Poor Poor Poor
Goo Poor
25% Goo 23% Goo 24% Goo
d 30%
d d d
24% 23% 26% 28%
Fair Fair Fair Fair
48% 42% 47% 44%
#1 #2 #3 #4
DOWNTOWN CARBONDALE
TIME SPENT DOWNTOWN, AREAS OF NEED, ARTS & LEISURE, AESTHETIC APPEAL
“AS A STUDENT IN CARBONDALE, HOW OFTEN DID YOU SPEND
FREE TIME IN THE DOWNTOWN AREA?”
One or more Never
times a year 2%
Once a month 4%
5%
A few times a
month 74% of alums spent
15%
time downtown at
least once a week
More than
once a week
Once a week 55%
19%
“DO YOU THINK THERE SHOULD BE MORE, LESS, OR THERE IS THE
RIGHT AMOUNT OF EACH OF THE FOLLOWING IN CARBONDALE?”
(RANKED ACCORDING TO PERCENTAGE OF PEOPLE WHO SAID THERE SHOULD BE MORE,TOP 5)
#1 Small, local businesses #2 Shops or restaurants within walking
distance
Right
Amount Right
21% Amount
Less 23% Less
3% 3%
More More
76% 74%
“DO YOU THINK THERE SHOULD BE MORE, LESS, OR THERE IS THE
RIGHT AMOUNT OF EACH OF THE FOLLOWING IN CARBONDALE?”
(RANKED ACCORDING TO PERCENTAGE OF PEOPLE WHO SAID THERE SHOULD BE MORE,TOP 5)
#3 Places to walk or exercise for fun #3 Locally grown produce
Right
Amount Right
31% Amount
31%
More More
66% Less 66% Less
3% 3%
“DO YOU THINK THERE SHOULD BE MORE, LESS, OR THERE IS THE
RIGHT AMOUNT OF EACH OF THE FOLLOWING IN CARBONDALE?”
(RANKED ACCORDING TO PERCENTAGE OF PEOPLE WHO SAID THERE SHOULD BE MORE,TOP 5)
#4 Places to bike #5 New stores and offices being built
Right
Amount
Right 30%
Amount
33%
More
More 60%
63% Less
10%
Less
4%
“HOW WOULD YOU RATE THE QUALITY OF THE FOLLOWING
ASPECTS OF THE CARBONDALE AREA?” (TOP 4 WORST AREAS)
Opportunities for entrepreneurs 4% 28% 44% 24%
Post-graduation job prospects 3% 17% 32% 49%
Internship/assistantship opportunities 7% 32% 38% 23%
Public transportation 3% 34% 46% 17%
Excellent Good Fair Poor
ARTS & LEISURE
AREAS OF NEED, AESTHETIC APPEAL
“IN TERMS OF ARTS AND LEISURE, DO YOU THINK THERE SHOULD BE
MORE, LESS, OR THERE IS THE RIGHT AMOUNT OF THE FOLLOWING IN
CARBONDALE?” (RANKED ACCORDING TO PERCENTAGE OF PEOPLE WHO SAID THERE SHOULD BE MORE,TOP 5)
#1 Street fairs and markets #2 Live entertainment (e.g. music,
comedy)
Right
Amount
Less 19% Right
2% Amount
25%
Less
More 2% More
79% 73%
“IN TERMS OF ARTS AND LEISURE, DO YOU THINK THERE SHOULD BE
MORE, LESS, OR THERE IS THE RIGHT AMOUNT OF THE FOLLOWING IN
CARBONDALE?” (RANKED ACCORDING TO PERCENTAGE OF PEOPLE WHO SAID THERE SHOULD BE MORE,TOP 5)
#3 Full-service restaurants #4 Plays or other performance art
Right Right
Amount, Amount
27% 29%
Less
Less, 1% More, 2% More
72% 69%
“IN TERMS OF ARTS AND LEISURE, DO YOU THINK THERE SHOULD BE
MORE, LESS, OR THERE IS THE RIGHT AMOUNT OF THE FOLLOWING IN
CARBONDALE?” (RANKED ACCORDING TO PERCENTAGE OF PEOPLE WHO SAID THERE SHOULD BE MORE,TOP 5)
#5 Outdoor recreational opportunities #5 Family entertainment
Right
Right Amount
Amount 31%
32%
More More
67% Less 67%
Less
2%
1%
AESTHETIC APPEAL OF SOUTHERN ILLINOIS, SIU, AND
DOWNTOWN CARBONDALE
46%
Ugly 3%
2%
43%
Not ugly nor beautiful 9%
5%
11%
Beautiful 88%
93%
Downtown Carbondale SIU Campus Southern Illinois
NAME ANOTHER COLLEGE TOWN THAT YOU THINK WOULD
PROVIDE A GOOD EXAMPLE FOR CARBONDALE’S DOWNTOWN
MASTER PLAN
QUESTIONS?
Economic Viability:
Funding Opportunities and Progress
Defining “Viability”
Capable of success or continuing effectiveness
Practical
or simply
Can it be successful, while being practical…
Funding Opportunities and Progress
Tax Incentive Financing District #2 (TIF #2)
Transportation Center Investments
Control of US 51 from IDOT
Downtown Parking Garage
Gigabyte City Concept
Downtown WiFi
Relocating/Burying Overhead Utility Lines
Others…
Recommendations
That City Council place a periodic and permanent item
on their agenda to report on the progress of
implementing the Downtown Master Plan
That City Council consider the “viability” of chartering
a Downtown Development Authority
That community leaders take the initiative to solve
selected issues and keep the City informed
Future Highlights
• Encourage entrepreneurs
• Maximize use of external funding
• Invite everyone
• Entice residents back
• Make it walkable
• Preserve the best of what makes a town
special
• Harness civic pride