Board of Architectural Review

Members Present: Wallace, Harrison, Faust, White, Ewing (Chair) Staff Present: Dowd, Stubblefield, Risse, Jordan (Recording) RESULTS BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW August 26, 2015 4:30 P.M. 2 GEORGE STREET 1. Approval of the minutes for the May 28, 2014 meeting. MOTION: Approval. MADE BY: Faust SECOND: White VOTE: FOR 4 AGAINST 0 (Wallace abstained) 2. 133 Cannon Street- - TMS # 460-11-04-06 APP. NO. 158-26-1 Request approval for demolition of existing residence. Category 4- (Cannon-Elliottborough) c. 1890 Old City District Owner: Zion Olivet United Presbyterian Church Applicant: David Quick/ LS3P MOTION: Deferred by Applicant. 3. 134 Cannon Street- - TMS # 460-11-04-155 APP. NO. 158-26-2 Request approval for demolition of existing church. Not Rated (Cannon-Elliottborough) c. post-1955 Old City District Owner: Zion Olivet United Presbyterian Church Applicant: David Quick/ LS3P MOTION: Deferred by Applicant. 4. 56 Tradd Street- - TMS # 458-09-03-172 APP. NO. 158-26-3 Request final approval for hardscape improvements. Category 2 (Charlestowne) c. 1740 Old and Historic District Owner: Kathryn and Joseph Householder Applicant: Derek Wade/ Carolina Landscape MOTION: Final approval with restudy of fountain. MADE BY: White SECOND: Faust VOTE: FOR 5 AGAINST 0 5. 74 Halsey Boulevard (Lot 8)- - TMS # 457-02-04-078 APP. NO. 156-26-4 Request conceptual approval for new construction of single family residence. (Harleston Village) Old and Historic District Owner: SIG Halsey, LLC Applicant: Bill Huey + Associates MOTION: Conceptual approval with final review by staff. MADE BY: White SECOND: Harrison VOTE: FOR 5 AGAINST 0 BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW August 26, 2015 Page |2 6. President Street (House 1) - - TMS # 460-07-04-192 APP. NO. 158-26-5 Request conceptual approval for new construction of single-family residence. (Westside) Old City District Owner: Shaft, LLC Applicant: John Douglas Tucker, Architect MOTION: Deferral with staff comments and Board comment regarding drawing quality. MADE BY: Faust SECOND: White VOTE: FOR 5 AGAINST 0 7. President Street (House 2) - - TMS # 460-07-04-221 APP. NO. 158-26-6 Request conceptual approval for new construction of single-family residence. (Westside) Old City District Owner: Shaft, LLC Applicant: John Douglas Tucker, Architect MOTION: Deferral taking into consideration staff comments, except #5. MADE BY: White SECOND: Faust VOTE: FOR 5 AGAINST 0 8. President Street (House 3) - - TMS # 460-07-04-220 APP. NO. 158-26-7 Request conceptual approval for new construction of single-family residence. (Westside) Old City District Owner: Shaft, LLC Applicant: John Douglas Tucker, Architect MOTION: Deferral based on staff comments. MADE BY: Harrison SECOND: White VOTE: FOR 5 AGAINST 0 9. President Street (House 4) - - TMS # 460-07-04-109 APP. NO. 158-26-8 Request conceptual approval for new construction of single-family residence. (Westside) Old City District Owner: Shaft, LLC Applicant: John Douglas Tucker, Architect MOTION: Conceptual approval with staff comments 1, 3 & 4, with restudy of issue noted in comment #2 moving forward. MADE BY: Faust SECOND: White VOTE: FOR 5 AGAINST 0 10. President Street (House 5) - - TMS # 460-07-04-110 APP. NO. 158-26-9 Request conceptual approval for new construction of single-family residence. (Westside) Old City District Owner: Shaft, LLC Applicant: John Douglas Tucker, Architect MOTION: Conceptual approval with staff comments 1, 3 & 4, with restudy of issue noted in comment #2 moving forward. MADE BY: White SECOND: Faust VOTE: FOR 5 AGAINST 0 BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW August 26, 2015 Page |3 11. President Street (House 6) - - TMS # 460-07-04-111 APP. NO. 158-26-10 Request conceptual approval for new construction of single-family residence. (Westside) Old City District Owner: Shaft, LLC Applicant: John Douglas Tucker, Architect MOTION: Deferral with conditions noted except #1. MADE BY: Harrison SECOND: White VOTE: FOR 5 AGAINST 0 12. President Street (House 7) - - TMS # 460-07-04-113 APP. NO. 158-26-11 Request conceptual approval for new construction of single-family residence. (Westside) Old City District Owner: Shaft, LLC Applicant: John Douglas Tucker, Architect MOTION: Deferral with staff comments and Board comment regarding restudy of pedestrian entry from parking area. MADE BY: White SECOND: Harrison VOTE: FOR 5 AGAINST 0 13. President Street (House 8) - - TMS # 460-07-04-219 APP. NO. 158-26-12 Request conceptual approval for new construction of single-family residence. (Westside) Old City District Owner: Shaft, LLC Applicant: John Douglas Tucker, Architect MOTION: Conceptual approval with staff comments 1, 3 & 4, with restudy of issue noted in comment #2 moving forward. MADE BY: White SECOND: Faust VOTE: FOR 5 AGAINST 0 14. 17 Humphrey Court - - TMS # 460-08-01-161 APP. NO. 156-26-13 Request final approval for new construction of two-story addition to existing single-family residence. Not Rated (Cannon-Elliottborough) c. 2014 Old City District Owner: Scott Watson & Maura Hogan Applicant: Jonathan Thompson/ Thompson Young Design MOTION: Withdrawn for staff review. 15. 14 Percy Street- - TMS # 460-08-03-161 APP. NO. 156-26-14 Request conceptual approval for renovation of historic residence to include removal of non-historic stairs and windows. Category 4- (Cannon-Elliottborough) c. 1880 Old City District Owner: Flyway LLc Applicant: Blake Middleton/ The Middleton Group MOTION: Withdrawn for staff review. BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW August 26, 2015 Page |4 16. 541 King Street- - TMS # 460-12-02-079 APP. NO. 156-26-15 Request conceptual approval for alterations to existing storefront and new construction of timber canopy and stucco wall at rear. Category 4- (Cannon-Elliottborough) c. 1888-1902 Old and Historic District Owner: 539 King Street LLC Applicant: Kevan Hoertdoerfer MOTION: Deferred by staff. 17. 107 King Street - - TMS # 457-12-04-054 APP. NO. 158-26-16 Request conceptual approval for new construction of rear addition and minor modifications to existing structure. Not Rated (Charlestowne) c. 1800 Old and Historic District Owner: Gene Woodard Applicant: Robert Epps/ Epps Architecture MOTION: Deferred by Applicant. 18. 4 Gadsden Street (a.k.a.124 Beaufain Street) - - TMS #457-03-03-001 APP. NO. 158-26-17 Request final approval for new construction of fire stair. Category 2 (Harleston Village) c. 1852 Old and Historic District Owner: Ian Walker Applicant: Russell Rosen MOTION: Final approval with Board comments about rail design and final review of rail design by staff. MADE BY: White SECOND: Harrison VOTE: FOR 5 AGAINST 0 19. 135 Tradd Street - - TMS # 457-11-04-096 APP. NO. 158-26-18 Request conceptual approval for modifications to existing residence to include new 2-story porch. Category 4 (Charlestowne) c. 1906 Old and Historic District Owner: Maureen and Jon Mazzoli Applicant: Julie O’Connor MOTION: Denial of new 2-story porch and west facing French doors; conceptual approval for modifications to existing porch infill and new window on east elevation. MADE BY: White SECOND: Faust VOTE: FOR 5 AGAINST 0 BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW August 26, 2015 Page |5 20. 51 Elizabeth Street- - TMS # 459-09-03-139 APP. NO. 158-26-19 Request Request conceptual approval for renovations to existing residence and hardscape. Category 3 (Mazyck-Wraggborough) c. 1850 Old and Historic District Owner: Jenny and John Grosso Applicant: Mark Moehring/ Archidemic MOTION: Deferral per Board and staff comments; with final review by staff. MADE BY: White SECOND: Harrison VOTE: FOR 5 AGAINST 0 21. 101 Bogard Street- - TMS # 460-11-02-118 APP. NO. 158-26-20 Request after-the-fact approval for new metal roof. Category 4 (Cannon-Elliottborough) c. 1880 Old City District Owner: Jason R. Damelo Applicant: Rajiv K. Gupta MOTION: Denial as it is not in keeping with Board policy statement and national preservation practice; with 45 day limit to install correct roof. MADE BY: White SECOND: Faust VOTE: FOR 5 AGAINST 0