Board of Architectural Review

Members present: Huey, Williams, Martin, Gardner, Farrier (Chair) Staff present: Turner, Dowd, Lanier, Howle, Jordan (Recorder) AGENDA BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW-SMALL July 14, 2016 4:30 P.M. 2 GEORGE STREET 1. 106 Grove Street- - TMS # 463-15-01-046 APP. NO. 167-14-1 Request approval for partial demolition of one-story building. Not Rated (Wagener Terrace) date unknown; poss. pre-1944 N of Line/ S of Mt. Pleasant Owner: Alec Bradford/ 106 Grove Street LLC Applicant: Justin Feit/Feit Design LLC MOTION: Withdrawn by Staff (Not in BAR purview) 2. 55 East Bay Street- - TMS # 458-13-01-068 APP. NO. 167-14-2 Request approval for demolition of one-story kitchen addition. Category 2 (Charlestowne) c. 1782-85 Old and Historic District Owner: William and Elizabeth Fort Applicant: John Young/ Dufford Young Architects MOTION: Approval with staff conditions noted. MADE BY: Martin SECOND: Williams VOTE: FOR 5 AGAINST 0 3. 55 East Bay Street- - TMS # 458-13-01-068 APP. NO. 167-14-3 Request preliminary approval for new construction of kitchen addition. Category 2 (Charlestowne) Old and Historic District Owner: William and Elizabeth Fort Applicant: John Young/ Dufford Young Architects MOTION: Preliminary approval with final review by staff. MADE BY: Martin SECOND: Williams VOTE: FOR 5 AGAINST 0 4. 10 Sires Street- - TMS # 460-08-03-100 APP. NO. 167-14-4 Request approval for demolition of residence. Category 4- (Cannon-Elliottborough) c. 1852-72 Old City District-Lower Owner: Renew Urban Applicant: Samuel S. Logan MOTION: Denial of wholesale demolition of structure; approval of demo of more recent addition at rear (as described by staff); with staff requirement for weatherization and stabilization plan. MADE BY: Huey SECOND: Martin VOTE: FOR 5 AGAINST 0 BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW-SMALL July 14, 2016 Page |2 5. 10 Sires Street- - TMS # 460-08-03-100 APP. NO. 167-14-5 Request conceptual approval for new construction of residence. Category 4- (Cannon-Elliottborough) Old City District-Lower Owner: Renew Urban Applicant: Samuel S. Loga MOTION: Deferred by Applicant. 6. 23 Montagu Street- - TMS # 457-03-04-100 APP. NO. 167-14-6 Request preliminary approval for renovation to existing historic structure and new construction of two-story rear addition. Category 3 (Harleston Village) c. 1843-44 Old and Historic District Owner: Robert Robertson Applicant: Samuel S. Logan MOTION: Deferred by Staff. 7. 46 South Battery- - TMS # 457-16-01-053 APP. NO. 167-14-7 Request approval for demolition of cmu garage. Category 2 (Charlestowne) c. 1835 Old and Historic District Owner: Brys and Zoe Stephens Applicant: Glenn Keyes Architects MOTION: Approval. MADE BY: Martin SECOND: Gardner VOTE: FOR 5 AGAINST 0 8. 46 South Battery- - TMS # 457-16-01-053 APP. NO. 167-14-8 Request conceptual approval for new construction of pool house. Category 2 (Charlestowne) Old and Historic District Owner: Brys and Zoe Stephens Applicant: Glenn Keyes Architects MOTION: Conceptual approval with final review by staff. MADE BY: Huey SECOND: Williams VOTE: FOR 5 AGAINST 0 9. 900 King Street (Enston Homes Memorial Hall) APP. NO. 167-14-9 - - TMS # 463-16-01-001 Request final approval for renovations to include reconstruction of metal detailing on tower, replacement of metal shingles, reinstallation of weathervane, new framing and miscellaneous repairs. Category 1 (North Central) c. 1887 Landmark Overlay Owner: Housing Authority of Charleston Applicant: Glenn Keyes Architects MOTION: Final approval with final review by staff; with condition requiring mock- up as noted by staff. MADE BY: Huey SECOND: Martin VOTE: FOR 5 AGAINST 0 BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW-SMALL July 14, 2016 Page |3 10. 199 Church Street- - TMS # 458-05-03-127 APP. NO. 167-14-10 Request conceptual approval for replacement of rooftop pergola structure with new enclosed rooftop structure. Not Rated (none) pre-1884 Old and Historic District Owner: Barry Hutto/Andrew Pinckney, LLC Applicant: David Thompson Architect MOTION: Conceptual approval with conditions noted by staff and final review by staff. MADE BY: Huey SECOND: Gardner VOTE: FOR 5 AGAINST 0 11. 40 Pinckney Street- - TMS # 458-05-01-097 APP. NO. 167-14-11 Request conceptual approval for alterations to fenestration on south and west facades. Not Rated (none) pre-1884 Old and Historic District Owner: Barry Hutto/Andrew Pinckney, LLC Applicant: David Thompson Architect MOTION: Conceptual approval with change in scope noted by applicant, with final review by staff. MADE BY: Williams SECOND: Martin VOTE: FOR 5 AGAINST 0 12. 58 America Street- - TMS # 459-09-04-065 APP. NO. 167-14-12 Request conceptual approval for restoration and new construction of addition. Category 4- (East Side) c. 1852-72 Old City District-Lower Owner: James Edwards Applicant: Chris Bonner/Bstudio Architecture MOTION: Deferral with all staff comments except #3 pending further documentation; with resubmittal/final review by staff. MADE BY: Gardner SECOND: Martin VOTE: FOR 5 AGAINST 0 13. 55 King Street- - TMS # 457-16-01-016 APP. NO. 167-14-13 Request conceptual approval for modifications to include new construction of addition. Category 3 (Charlestowne) c. 1762 Old and Historic District Owner: Larry and Eugenia Burtschy Applicant: E.E. Fava Architects MOTION: Conceptual approval with staff conditions noted (including retention of dependency chimney) with final review by staff. MADE BY: Martin SECOND: Gardner VOTE: FOR 5 AGAINST 0 BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW-SMALL July 14, 2016 Page |4 14. 28 Humphrey Court- - TMS # 460-80-01-216 APP. NO. 167-14-14 Request preliminary approval for new construction of single-family residence. (Cannon-Elliottborough) Old City District-Lower Owner: Episcopal Diocese Community Housing Development Organization Applicant: Frank Rupp MOTION: Deferral with all staff comments except elimination of bathroom, and Board comments regarding mass and orientation of houses on lots; with final review by staff. MADE BY: Huey SECOND: Martin VOTE: FOR 5 AGAINST 0 15. 68-72 Cannon Street- - TMS # 460-80-03-033 APP. NO. 167-14-15 Request final approval for hardscaping. Category 4- (Cannon-Elliottborough) c. 1840-1905 Old City District-Lower Owner: George Seago Applicant: Sanford Byers MOTION: Deferred by Staff 16. 67 America Street (1, 3, 5 & 7 Father Grants Court) APP. NO. 167-14-16 - - TMS # 459-09-02-132 Request preliminary approval for revisions to previously-approved project. (East Side) Old City District-Lower Owner: PASTORS, Inc. Applicant: Ron Gossen MOTION: Deferred by Staff 17. 62 Broad Street- - TMS # 458-09-03-004 APP. NO. 167-14-17 Request final approval for rebuilding of approximately 33 feet of ground floor façade; restoration of windows, doors and stucco finish. Category 2 (French Quarter) c. 1800 Old and Historic District Owner: Confederate Home & College Applicant: Jim Wigley MOTION: Deferral for clarification of scope/methods and approval for temporary shoring and stabilization to be coordinated with staff. MADE BY: Martin SECOND: Garner VOTE: FOR 5 AGAINST 0 BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW-SMALL July 14, 2016 Page |5 18. 62 Spring Street- - TMS # 460-08-02-035 APP. NO. 167-14-18 Request preliminary approval for façade and piazza restoration and new porch addition at rear. Category 4- (Cannon-Elliottborough) c. 1852-72 Old City District-Lower Owner: 62 Spring Street LLC Applicant: Luke Jarrett/ Byers Design Group MOTION: Preliminary approval with staff and Board conditions noted and final review by staff. MADE BY: Huey SECOND: Williams VOTE: FOR 5 AGAINST 0 19. 64 Spring Street- - TMS # 460-08-02-036 APP. NO. 167-14-19 Request conceptual approval for removal of non-historic additions and renovation. Category 4- (Cannon-Elliottborough) c. 1880’s Old City District-Lower Owner: 64 Spring Street LLC Applicant: Luke Jarrett/Byers Design Group MOTION: Conceptual approval with staff comments 1-6 and Board comments regarding rear porch roof overhang and column alignment. MADE BY: Gardner SECOND: Huey VOTE: FOR 5 AGAINST 0 20. 26 Aiken Street- - TMS # 459-05-04-032 APP. NO. 167-14-20 Request preliminary approval for new construction of duplex. (East Side) Old City District-Lower Owner: SK Property Applicant: Charles Spires/ Byers Design Group MOTION: Deferral with staff and Board comments. MADE BY: Huey SECOND: Williams VOTE: FOR 5 AGAINST 0 21. 79 Cumberland Street (Old Powder Magazine) APP. NO. 167-14-21 - - TMS # 458-09-01-075 Request final approval for hardscape improvements. Category 1 (French Quarter) c. 1713 Old and Historic District Owner: Colonial Dames of South Carolina Applicant: James L. Ward MOTION: Deferral to work with staff to simplify and refine; with final review by staff. MADE BY: Gardner SECOND: Huey VOTE: FOR 5 AGAINST 0 BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW-SMALL July 14, 2016 Page |6 22. 428-430 Meeting Street- - TMS # 459-09-01-033/034 APP. NO. 167-14-22 Request final approval for new construction of addition and renovations to existing structure for new restaurant. Category 4- (East Side) c. 1582-72 Old and Historic District Owner: Xiao Lan, LLC Applicant: Kenny Craft MOTION: Final approval with staff conditions 1, 6 & 7 and Board comment about removal of bathroom window; with final review by staff. MADE BY: Martin SECOND: Gardner VOTE: FOR 5 AGAINST 0 23. Catfiddle (Lot 5)- - TMS # 460-07-04-231 APP. NO. 167-14-23 Request conceptual approval for new construction of residence. (Cannon-Elliottborough) Old City District-Lower Owner: Donna Gates Applicant: Kenny Craft/ T. Podhrazsky MOTION: Conceptual approval with final review by staff. MADE BY: Martin SECOND: Williams VOTE: FOR 5 AGAINST 0 24. 1100-1104 King Street APP. NO. 167-14-24 - - TMS # 463-12-03-116/463-12-03-117 Request conceptual approval for replacement of front façade. Category (North Central) c. 1944-51 Old City District-Upper Owner: Jerald S. Scheer Applicant: Kevan Hoertdoerfer MOTION: Conceptual approval of height, scale and mass; deferral of architectural direction; with encouragement of selective demolition and sensitivity to age and neighborhood context. MADE BY: Martin SECOND: Gardner VOTE: FOR 5 AGAINST 0 25. 212 King Street- - TMS # 457-08-02-021 APP. NO. 167-14-25 Request final approval for alterations to side entry to include new awnings. Category 3 (none) c. 1909 Old and Historic District Owner: 212-214 King Street Associates LLC Applicant: Joseph D. Schmidt/ Evans & Schmidt MOTION: Final approval with staff comments 2 & 3 and Board comments to restudy trellis to simplify or eliminate. MADE BY: Martin SECOND: Huey VOTE: FOR 5 AGAINST 0 BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW-SMALL July 14, 2016 Page |7 26. 63 Radcliffe Street- - TMS # 460-16-01-057 APP. NO. 167-14-26 Request preliminary approval for renovations to existing residence. Category 4- (Radcliffeborough) c. 1885-95 Old and Historic District Owner: Brady & Scott Antonio Applicant: John H. Williams MOTION: Preliminary approval with staff and Board comments and final review by staff. MADE BY: Huey SECOND: Gardner VOTE: FOR 5 AGAINST 0 27. 61 Vanderhorst Street- - TMS # 460-16-03-117 APP. NO. 167-14-27 Request appeal of staff decision regarding window color and final approval of color scheme. Not Rated (Radcliffeborough) c. 1951 Old and Historic District Owner: Vanderhorst Realty Applicant: Simons Young + Associates MOTION: Approval with the following conditions: 1) Windows on sides and rear to be light gray; 2) North side windows and mail kiosk to be gunmetal; 3) Entry door to be gray to match side windows or mill finish. MADE BY: Gardner SECOND: Huey VOTE: FOR 5 AGAINST 0