Board of Architectural Review

Board Members Present: Gardner (Chair), Huey, Martin , Claypoole, and Wilson Staff Members Present: Dowd, Bennett, Jordan (Recorder) RESULTS BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW-SMALL June 15, 2017 4:30 P.M. 2 GEORGE STREET 1. Approval of minutes from the August 11, 2016 meeting. PP NO. 176-15-1 MOTION: Approval with one correction. MADE BY: Huey SECOND: Martin VOTE: FOR 5 AGAINST 0 2. Approval of minutes from the August 25, 2016 meeting. APP NO. 176-15-2 MOTION: Approved. MADE BY: Huey SECOND: Wilson VOTE: FOR 5 AGAINST 0 3. 3380 Ashley River Road - - TMS #359-00-00-012 APP NO. 176-15-3 Request approval of sample panels for new visitor’s center, education center, and gate house at Drayton Hall. Category 1 (none) c. 1740 Landmark Overlay Owner: Drayton Hall Preservation Trust Applicant: Glenn Keyes Architects MOTION: Final approval with staff comments with #2 and #6 amended. Window frame to match siding color on gate house; Final Review by Staff. MADE BY: Martin SECOND: Claypoole VOTE: FOR 5 AGAINST 0 4. 5 East Battery - - TMS # 457-16-04-087 APP NO. 176-15-4 Request conceptual approval for new construction of elevator tower at rear, addition to dependency, replacement of modern infill at ground floor piazza, and reopening of historic arches at ground floor of the carriage house. Category 2 (Charlestowne) c. 1848 Old and Historic District Owner: Maison Cinq, LLC Applicant: Glenn Keyes Architects MOTION: Conceptual approval with staff comments 2-4 with not taking elevator to roof at this time; but elevator could be reviewed at later date. MADE BY: Huey SECOND: Martin VOTE: FOR 5 AGAINST 0 5. 959 Ashley Avenue - - TMS # 463-11-01-040 APP NO. 176-15-5 Request approval for demolition of two car garage. Category 4 (Wagner Terrace) c. 1951-55 N of Line/S of Mt. Pleasant Owner: Amanda and Paul Gurski Applicant: Matthew Kauzlaric/Jodi Crosby MOTION: Final approval for demolition. MADE BY: Huey SECOND: Wilson VOTE: FOR 5 AGAINST 0 BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW-SMALL June 15, 2017 Page |2 6. 891 Rutledge Avenue- - TMS # 463-08-03-014 APP NO. 176-15-6 Request approval for demolition of garage/shed. Category 4 (Wagener Terrace) c. pre-1944 N of Line/S of Mt. Pleasant Owner: John and Ann Stafford Applicant: E.E. Fava Architects MOTION: Final approval for demolition with condition that intact historic materials be salvaged. MADE BY: Martin SECOND: Claypoole VOTE: FOR 5 AGAINST 0 7. 97 King Street - - TMS # 457-12-04-059 APP NO. 176-15-7 Request final approval to replace existing aluminum clad windows with new wood windows, replace existing door with new wood true divided lite door, and add new window openings on south and north elevations. Category 3 (Charlestowne) c. 1902-44 Old and Historic District Owner: Dottie and Stan Shelton Applicant: E.E. Fava Architects Withdrawn for staff review 8. 59A King Street - - TMS # 457-16-01-014 APP NO. 176-15-8 Request conceptual approval for exterior renovation to include replacing windows in walled courtyard with steel windows and doors, replacing shutters, replacing shingle roof with copper roof, installing a retractable awning at the courtyard, and constructing elevated HVAC stand at rear. Not Rated (Charlestowne) c. post-1955 Old and Historic District Owner: Tony and Marilyn Horwath Applicant: Beau Clowney Architects Withdrawn for staff review _____ 9. 316 King Street - - TMS # 457-04-04-012/112 APP NO. 176-15-9 Request final approval for new siding on north elevation, new metal stairs at east elevation, and new windows and doors on east elevation. Not Rated (none) c. 1903 Old and Historic District Owner: Indigo Realty Company Applicant: Sophia Delgado/The Middleton Group Withdrawn for staff review 10. 56 Tradd Street - - TMS # 458-09-03-172 APP NO. 176-15-10 Request preliminary approval for replacement of doors and windows on piazza and piazza infill. Category 2 (Charlestowne) c. 1740 Old and Historic District Owner: Joe and Kathy Householder Applicant: Classic Remodeling and Construction MOTION: Preliminary approval with Staff comments 2-5 and clarification of condition #2 such that the glazing extends to top of original piazza above. Final review by staff. MADE BY: Martin SECOND: Huey VOTE: FOR 5 AGAINST 0 BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW-SMALL June 15, 2017 Page |3 11. 19 Gadsden Street - - TMS # 457-03-03-031 APP NO. 176-15-11 Request conceptual approval for replacement of fixed door with new window in existing opening to match existing windows. Category 2 (Harleston Village) c. 1828-30 Old and Historic District Owner: Athalie and John Derse Applicant: Ryan Magee/Magee Ratcliff Construction, LLC MOTION: Conceptual approval with conditions noted. Final review by staff. MADE BY: Martin SECOND: Huey VOTE: FOR 4 AGAINST 0 Recusal – Gardner Acting Chair - Claypoole 12. 92 Tradd Street- - TMS # 457-12-04-039 APP NO. 176-15-12 Request final approval for hardscape changes to include new patio, walkway, and walls. Category 2 (Charlestowne) c. 1762; 1850 Old and Historic District Owner: Jack McSpadden Applicant: Diandre Sunner/Carolina Landscape MOTION: Final approval with staff comments #1 and #2; staff comments #3 and 4 regarding lighting and rear gate respectively. Final review by staff. MADE BY: Huey SECOND: Wilson VOTE: FOR 5 AGAINST 0 13. 38 Charlotte Street - - TMS # 459-13-01-102 APP NO. 176-15-13 Request conceptual approval for new construction of single family residence at rear. Category 4 (Mazyck-Wraggborough) Old and Historic District Owner: Bob and Barbara Wilson Applicant: Cobb Architects Deferred by staff 14. 7 New Street - - TMS # 457-12-03-106 APP NO. 176-15-14 Request conceptual approval for new construction of single family residence. (Charlestowne) Old and Historic District Owner: Socorro Partners, LLC Applicant: Barbara Looney MOTION: Deferral based on additional required submittal information; Staff comments 1-4; Staff #5: restudy North and South fenestrations. Board comments: consider hipped roof on front mass; flat roof at rear with HVAC on flat roof; step in rear of North elevation; try to lower finished floor elevation to reduce height. MADE BY: Martin SECOND: Huey VOTE: FOR 5 AGAINST 0 15. Carrere Court- - TMS # 460-15-02-009/070 APP NO. 176-15-15 Request conceptual approval for new construction of three single family residences. (Cannon-Elliottborough) Old City District-Lower Owner: Birchin Lane Realty Applicant: Rush Dixon Architects MOTION: Deferral for height and mass with staff comments #4 and #5; encouraged by design direction and details. MADE BY: Huey SECOND: Martin VOTE: FOR 5 AGAINST 0 BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW-SMALL June 15, 2017 Page |4 16. 96 Nassau Street--TMS# 459-05-04-179 APP NO. 176-15-15 Request conceptual approval for new construction of duplex and single family residence. (East Side) Old City District-Lower Owner: Matt Anderson Applicant: Ashley Jennings/AJ Architects MOTION: Conceptual approval of front house with condition to restudy scale of front elevation fenestration and staff comments 1-8. Deferral of rear house to study site and building height; with condition 1-4 of staff comments. MADE BY: Huey SECOND: Claypoole VOTE: FOR 4 AGAINST 0 Recusal – Martin 17. 62 Queen Street- - TMS # 458-09-01-082 APP NO. 176-15-17 Request conceptual approval for renovations and new construction of rear addition. Not Rated (French Quarter) c. 1886-88;1944-51 Old and Historic District Owner: Stuart Gross Applicant: Ashley Jennings/ AJ Architects MOTION: Conceptual approval with staff comments #3; Board condition to re- study stair at rear of historic structure; make change to improve blank wall at east elevation. MADE BY: Martin SECOND: Claypoole VOTE: FOR 5 AGAINST 0 18. 203 Ashley Avenue- - TMS # 460-11-04-004 APP NO. 176-15-18 Request preliminary approval for new construction of rear addition and detached dwelling unit. Category 3 (Cannon-Elliottborough) c. 1852-75 Old City District-Lower Owner: Ashley Avenue Properties Applicant: Amy Kay Stoney/ Neil Stevenson Architects MOTION: Preliminary approval with staff comments 4, 5, 6, 7, and 8; Board condition that there is no parking in front of green space at South side; standing seam metal roof is preferable to shingles. Condition #7 – windows can be casements that look like double hung. MADE BY: Martin SECOND: Huey VOTE: FOR 5 AGAINST 0 19. 2 Boyces Wharf - - TMS # 458-09-04-015 APP NO. 176-15-19 Request preliminary approval for renovation and new construct ion of vertical addition. Not Rated (Charlestowne) c. post-1955 Old and Historic District Owner: Mathew Berger Applicant: Jeremy Kruska/Glick-Boehm Architecture Deferred by staff 20. 72 Warren Street- - TMS # 460-16-01-040 APP NO. 176-15-20 Request conceptual approval for new construction of vertical addition over existing one-story portion at rear. Category 4- (Radcliffeborough) c. 1890’s Old and Historic District Owner: Alphonzo Parker Applicant: Frank Stevens MOTION: Deferral with staff conditions 1, 2, and 4. MADE BY: Martin SECOND: Huey VOTE: FOR 5 AGAINST 0 BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW-SMALL June 15, 2017 Page |5 21. 9 Talon Court- - TMS # 460-15-04-006 APP NO. 176-15-21 Request conceptual approval for partial porch enclosure. Category 4- (Radcliffeborough) c. 1900 Old and Historic District Owner: John Miklos Applicant: John Miklos MOTION: Conceptual approval for either option with wall facing Rutledge to be glass and Final review by staff. MADE BY: Huey SECOND: Claypoole VOTE: FOR 5 AGAINST 0 22. 460-462 King Street - - TMS # 460-12-02-034 APP NO. 176-15-22 Request appeal of staff denial for façade signs facing King Street and Ann Street for Office Evolution. Not Rated (Mazyck-Wraggborough) .1902-44;1951-55 Old and Historic District Owner: Andrew Fry Applicant: Shelby M. Bates/Miller Signs MOTION: Denial of appeal. MADE BY: Huey SECOND: Claypoole VOTE: FOR 5 AGAINST 0 23. 40 Bogard Street - - TMS # 460-08-01-088 APP NO. 176-15-23 Request after-the-fact approval for reconstruction of front and rear porches with removal of the stairs on the rear porch. Category 4- (Cannon-Elliottborough) c. 1910 Old City District-Lower Owner: Tommy O’Riley/40 Bogard, LLC Applicant: Tom Bellino/Low County Custom Builders, Inc. MOTION: Denial of after-the-fact approval. With staff comments and to be remedied within 60 days. MADE BY: Claypoole SECOND: Martin VOTE: FOR 5 AGAINST 0 24. 24 Tradd Street - - TMS # 458-09-03-161 APP NO. 176-15-22 Request after-the-fact conceptual approval for new construction of second floor rear addition on roof and rear deck. Not Rated (Charlestowne) c. 1902-44 Old City District-Lower Owner: Jennifer Butler Applicant: John C. Sullivan/S Arch Studio Deferred by Applicant