Board of Architectural Review

Board Members: Jay Claypoole (Chair), Glen Gardner, Bill Huey, Julia Martin, Fillmore Wilson Staff: Alex Howle, Peggy Jordan (recorder), Erin Minnigan RESULTS BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW-SMALL March 15, 2018 4:30 P.M. 2 GEORGE STREET 1. 73 Cooper Street - - TMS # 459-05-04-059 APP. NO. 183-15-1 Request approval for demolition of residence. Category 4- (East Side) c.1872-85 N. of Line/S. of Mt. Pleasant Owner: Charles Ryan Hyler Applicant: Charles Ryan Hyler MOTION: Denial of full demolition. Approval of partial demolition of portion shown as a porch on the 1928 Sanborn Map and requirement to provide stabilization plans to staff within 30 days. MADE BY: Martin SECOND: Wilson VOTE: FOR 5 AGAINST 0 2. 3 Desportes Court - - TMS # 460-16-03-047 APP. NO. 183-15-2 Request approval for demolition of residence. Category 4- (Radcliffeborough) c.1875-85 Old and Historic District Owner: Heidi Brown Applicant: AJ Architects / Ashley Jennings MOTION: Approval of demolition with staff conditions and recommendation. MADE BY: Martin SECOND: Wilson VOTE: FOR 5 AGAINST 0 3. 3 Desportes Court - - TMS # 460-16-03-047 APP. NO. 183-15-3 Request conceptual approval for new construction of a single family residence. Category 4- (Radcliffeborough) c.1875-85 Old and Historic District Owner: Heidi Brown Applicant: AJ Architects / Ashley Jennings MOTION: Conceptual approval with staff comments 1-5 and Board suggestion to lower ceiling height. MADE BY: Huey SECOND: Martin VOTE: FOR 5 AGAINST 0 4. 147 Spring Street - - TMS # 460-11-04-090 APP. NO. 183-15-4 Request after-the-fact approval for demolition of rear addition. Category 4 (Cannon-Elliottborough) c.1890s Old City District Owner: Henry Wilborn Applicant: Henry Wilborn MOTION: Denial of after-the-fact demolition of rear addition, with drawings to be submitted to staff detailing exact reconstruction. MADE BY: Gardner SECOND: Wilson VOTE: FOR 5 AGAINST 0 BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW-SMALL March 15, 2018 Page |2 5. 147 Spring Street - - TMS # 460-11-04-090 APP. NO. 183-15-5 Request conceptual approval for renovation of existing structure and new construction of rear addition. Category 4 (Cannon-Elliottborough) c.1890s Old City District Owner: Henry Wilborn Applicant: Byers Collaborative MOTION: No action taken. 6. 100 Meeting Street - - TMS # 458-09-03-001 APP. NO. 183-15-6 Request final approval to install window graphics and wayfinding signs. Category 1 (French Quarter) c. 1822 Old and Historic District Owner: South Carolina Historical Society Applicant: Glenn Keyes Architects MOTION: Final approval with staff comments and final review by staff with clarification that this approval is not transferable, due to the civic nature of the building. MADE BY: Martin SECOND: Gardner VOTE: FOR 5 AGAINST 0 7. 12 Lamboll Street - - TMS # 457-16-01-030 APP. NO. 183-15-7 Request conceptual approval of renovation of residence. Category 3 (Charlestowne) mid-19th century Old and Historic District Owner: James Pallotta Applicant: McAlpine Architecture / David Baker MOTION: Conceptual approval with staff comments and final review by staff. MADE BY: Huey SECOND: Wilson VOTE: FOR 5 AGAINST 0 8. 17 Council Street - - TMS # 457-11-04-012 APP. NO. 183-15-8 Request conceptual approval for renovation of existing residence, including modification of fenestration. Not Rated (Charlestowne) Early 20th Century Old and Historic District Owner: Dennis Ward and Peter Hyman Applicant: Renew Urban Charleston MOTION: Conceptual approval with staff comments except 1 and 3, excluding shutters pending providing evidence to staff of historic shutters; any replacement of front entry elements subject to site visit with staff; final review by staff. MADE BY: Huey SECOND: Martin VOTE: FOR 5 AGAINST 0 9. 15 Council Street - - TMS # 457-11-04-011 APP. NO. 183-15-9 Request preliminary approval to elevate an existing house. Not Rated (Charlestowne) Early 20th Century Old and Historic District Owner: Gardenia Investments, LLC. Applicant: Robert Morris Deferred by Applicant BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW-SMALL March 15, 2018 Page |3 10. 22 Elliott Street - - TMS # 458-09-03-111 APP. NO. 183-15-10 Request conceptual approval for modifications to previously-approved rear addition. Category 3 (Charlestowne) c.1793-1800;1949;1990 Old and Historic District Owner: Seven Pines, LLC. Applicant: Simons Young & Associates MOTION: Conceptual approval with staff comment #6. MADE BY: Huey SECOND: Wilson VOTE: FOR 5 AGAINST 0 11. 45 Reid Street - - TMS #459-09-03-014 APP. NO. 183-15-11 Request conceptual approval for new construction of two residential structures. (East Side) Old City District Owner: Rich Crepeau Applicant: Synchronicity / Luke Jarrett Deferred by Staff for Zoning Review 12. 32 Ashton Street - - TMS # 460-11-01-066 APP. NO. 183-15-12 Request conceptual approval for new construction of a residential structure at rear of property. Category 4- (Westside) c. 1885 Old City District Owner: Jason Pennington Applicant: John Sullivan/S. Arch Studio MOTION: Deferral for height, scale, and mass, and issues with general architectural direction, with staff comments 1, 3 modified to exclude last sentence, 5, and 6. MADE BY: Martin SECOND: Wilson VOTE: FOR 5 AGAINST 0 13. 67 Pitt Street - - TMS # 460-16-03-069 APP. NO. 183-15-13 Request conceptual approval for new construction of a residential structure at rear of property. Category 4 (Radcliffeborough) c.1895-1905 Old and Historic District Owner: Richard Ritter Applicant: Elizabeth P. Drake MOTION: Denial due to height, scale, mass contradicting the ordinance, and issues with general architectural direction and staff comments 1-2. MADE BY: Huey SECOND: Martin VOTE: FOR 5 AGAINST 0 14. 52 Bull Street - - TMS # 457-03-02-029` APP. NO. 183-15-14 Request final approval to remove non-historic shed, and construct rear addition, new shed, and hardscape features. Category 4 (Harleston Village) pre-1902 Old and Historic District Owner: Bruce Caulk Applicant: American Vernacular / Julie O’ Connor MOTION: Deferral with staff comments except 3 and 7, and 4 modified to only include comments of the windows; final review by staff. MADE BY: Huey SECOND: Martin VOTE: FOR 5 AGAINST 0 BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW-SMALL March 15, 2018 Page |4 15. 175 Queen Street - - TMS # 457-12-01-005 APP. NO. 183-15-15 Request conceptual approval to elevate an existing structure. Not Rated (Harleston Village) pre-1888 Old and Historic District Owner: Aldiza, LLC. Applicant: Julia F. Martin Architects Deferred by Applicant