Design Review Board

Board Members: Krause (Chairman), Johnston (items 5-18), Smyth, Smith, Liollios City Staff: Meeks, Howle, Jordan (Recorder) CITY OF CHARLESTON DESIGN REVIEW BOARD Results of August 20th, 2018 1. 1515 Savannah Hwy – TMS# 349-01-00-017 Request approval for a completed mock-up panel for a car new car dealership. Owner: Baker Motor Co Applicant: Goff D’Antonio Assoc. Neighborhood/Area: West Ashley MOTION: Deferral due to some missing elements from the drawings, with staff comments 2-7, but Board is OK with the contractor moving forward with ordering materials. MADE BY: AS SECOND: DL VOTE: FOR 4 AGAINST 0 2. 84 Ripley Point Dr – TMS# 421-11-00-061 Request approval for a completed mock-up panel for a new hotel. Owner: Upland Real Properties, LLC Applicant: Goff D’Antonio Assoc. Neighborhood/Area: West Ashley MOTION: Deferral due to general craftsmanship, with staff comments 2-11, but Board is OK with the contractor moving forward with ordering materials. MADE BY: AS SECOND: DL VOTE: FOR 4 AGAINST 0 Board Members: Krause (Chairman), Johnston (items 5-18), Smyth, Smith, Liollios City Staff: Meeks, Howle, Jordan (Recorder) 3. 2228 N Westchester Dr - TMS # 309-15-00-069 Request conceptual approval for construction of a new City maintenance facility. Owner: St. Andrews Public Service District Applicant: Stubbs Muldrow Herin Architects Neighborhood/Area: West Ashley MOTION: Conceptual approval with staff comments 1-10 and Board comments for further analysis of the fuel tanks to determine the appropriate, if any, screening needed, and to increase the landscaping around the metal recycle area and the generator and a fence around the scrap metal ramp where needed. MADE BY: DL_ SECOND: AS VOTE: FOR 4 AGAINST 0 4. Seven Farms Dr. – St Clare of Assisi – TMS # 275-00-00-198 Request conceptual approval for the construction of a new church. Owner: Bishop of Charleston Applicant: Hord Architects/Carter Hord Neighborhood/Area: Daniel Island MOTION: Conceptual approval with staff comment #2 and with Board comments to bring up the level of the landscape, more detail for the bio-swale and roof drainage, to maintain the quality of materials and masonry details, and to show the site, building and landscape lighting at next submittal. MADE BY: AS SECOND: DL VOTE: FOR 4 AGAINST Board Members: Krause (Chairman), Johnston (items 5-18), Smyth, Smith, Liollios City Staff: Meeks, Howle, Jordan (Recorder) 5. Hayes Park on Maybank Hwy. (Site Plan) – TMS# 279-00-00-235, 067 Request conceptual approval for Hayes Park commercial park, overall site plan. Owner: Carolyn Slay Applicant: New Leaf Builders Neighborhood/Area: John’s Island MOTION: Deferral with staff comments 3-8 and with Board comments to not use Trident Maple, provide dumpster and mail locations, and to provide more perspective views through the site to better understand the site and the relationship of the buildings to each other, and to strengthen the architectural language of the site and better relay the overall concept. MADE BY: AS SECOND: MS VOTE: FOR 5 AGAINST 0 6. Agenda items 6 through 18- Hayes Park on Maybank Hwy (buildings) TMS# 279-00-00-235, 067 Request conceptual approval for 13 commercial buildings Owner: Carolyn Slay Applicant: New Leaf Builders Neighborhood/Area: John’s Island MOTION: Collective motion of deferral made for agenda items 6-18 based on general architectural direction and the need to provide the Board with an overall, comprehensive package, containing more views of the site, streetscape, tree canopies and building clusters. MADE BY: AS SECOND: MS VOTE: FOR 5 AGAINST 0