Resilience & Sustainability Advisory Committee
Regular MeetingCharleston, SC · February 13, 2020
Minutes
Resiliency and
Sustainability
Advisory
Committee
Meeting
February 13, 2020
Today’s Agenda
1. Welcome and Moment of Silence
2. Sustainability Next Steps
a. Greenhouse Gas Inventory
b. Green Plan Audit
c. Climate Action Plan
3. SC Resilience Revolving Fund Act Update
4. Environmental Initiatives at the South Carolina Ports Authority
5. Earth Day 2020 Resolutions
6. Public Comment Period
Sustainability Next Steps
Greenhouse Gas Inventory
Greenhouse Gas Inventory
● Started January 2020
● Time length: 4-6 months
GHG Data Inventories
● 2002
● 2006
● 2010
● 2018 coming soon!
Download at: https://www.charleston-sc.gov/DocumentCenter/View/1462/Green-Plan-Inventory-and-Metrics?bidId=
Sustainability Next Steps
Green Plan Audit
Green Plan Audit
Goal is to prioritize top
initiatives from 2010 to
consider for potential
action
Focus first on sectors
showing highest GHG
emissions,Bldgs + Transp.
https://www.charleston-sc.gov/DocumentCenter/View/25231/Green-Plan-Audit
Top Priorities from Green Plan
Improved Transportation:
● Support employer-based programs that encourage alternative transportation
● Set high standards for the purchase, use, and maintenance of City vehicles
● Create education programs both internally and with the public
Top Priorities from Green Plan
Better Buildings:
● New City buildings and renovations to meet LEED certification
● Incentivize private development to meet LEED certification
● Require private development to meet LEED certification or adopt stronger
energy codes
Sustainability Next Steps
C limate Action Plan
Climate Action Planning
Started January
2020
Currently:
80% emissions reduction
by 2050
Will re -evaluate target
Will draw inspiration from
2010 Charleston Green Plan
Start CAP in quarter 2
Earth Day Resolutions
Celebrations last all month long!
50th ● West Ashley Farmers Market
● Downtown Farmers Market
Anniversary of ● Tree Planting Event
● MUSC Local Food Fest
Earth Day ● County Paper Shred Events
● C of C Street Fair & Events
April 22 ● Community Cleanups & Events
with Keep Charleston Beautiful,
Surfrider, DNR, Waterkeeper
Let’s Make Earth Day Resolutions!
Past Resolutions to Update New Resolutions to Consider
● Recycling- blue bin items and printer ● Recycling bulk mattresses & hazardous
cartridges materials like batteries, light bulbs
● Advertise CARTA routes on City ● Fleet electrification transition and
events purchasing standards
● “Lights out in buildings at night” ● EV charging stations and EV ready
campaign parking
● City construction meets LEED ● Climate action pledge
certification ● Eliminating styrofoam
● Enforce the current idling ordinance ● Promoting reusable bags
● Purchasing recycled paper for copiers ● Energy efficiency month- October
● Printing 2-sided, scrap paper pile ● Electric vehicle awareness
● Decrease plastic bag use
ALL IDEAS WELCOME and ENCOURAGED
SC Resilience Revolving Fund
Act Update
B y: Jason C rowley, C oastal C onservation League
South Carolina Resilience Revolving Fund S.259
If enacted, the “South Carolina Resilience Revolving Fund Act” will advance the ability to leverage state
and federal funding to provide low interest loans to perform flooded-home buyouts and floodplain
restoration, and authorizes the Disaster Recovery Office within the Department of Administration to
undertake certain actions to effectively operate the fund.
Purpose and Need:
• South Carolina has faced four major flooding events between 2015 and 2018, which caused over
one billion dollars in total damages, required hundreds of millions of dollars in state spending,
and flooded thousands of homes.
• Flooding has affected all regions of South Carolina from the Upstate, to the Midlands, and
throughout the Coastal Plain, and has harmed the property and health of residents in each of
these regions.
• Neighborhoods and homes have been constructed in floodplains, and when these homes are
inevitably flooded there are limited resources available to relocate residents out of the floodplain
afterward.
• Many flooded homeowners are forced to rebuild in the same vulnerable location and are trapped
in a cycle of repeated flooding and rebuilding.
• Homeowners without flood insurance or financial assistance are unable to rebuild at all.
• Federal funding to conduct flood mitigation typically requires a ratio match at the local level, and
applications are more competitive when funding is available for this match, however, few local
governments have the resources to readily provide funds for a match.
• Moving citizens out of the floodplain lowers State and local spending on recovery after a flood
emergency, allows for the water-absorbing benefits of the floodplain to be restored, and reduces
the risk to the rest of the community.
• There is a critical need for additional funds to buyout repeatedly flooded properties for
homeowner voluntarily requesting assistance and restore the natural functions of the floodplain.
• Both actions are essential to the resilience of the State to future flood events and necessary to
maintain a high quality of life for its residents.
• In order to carry out these purposes, the State must establish a funding source providing
additional capital to execute buyouts of repeatedly flooded homes and ensure increased flood
resilience in the State.
Revolving Fund Authority:
• The Department of Administration’s Disaster Recovery Office would be the primary authority
responsible for administering the fund. An annual report will be submitted to the Governor, Lt.
Governor, State Treasurer, and General Assembly. The State Fiscal Accountability Authority will
have final approval over any loan decisions.
• The authority is authorized to make and service below-market interest rate loans and grants as
financial incentives to eligible fund recipients for the purchase of flooded properties and land to
complete floodplain restorations. Eminent domain cannot be exercised.
• To operate the Fund, the authority will:
o Prioritize the buyout of blocks or groups of homes so that no more than 15% of the funds
disbursed in a fiscal year go toward single home buyouts (this would not prevent the fund
for being used for individual home buyouts);
o Prioritize buyout of single-family primary residences and multi-family residences;
o Consider availability of additional funding sources leveraged by a project;
o Prevent the use of the fund for homes built after July 1, 2020.
Loan Criteria and Conditions:
• Loans can be disbursed for buyouts of repetitive loss properties, buyouts of repetitive loss
properties with land intended for floodplain restoration, and floodplain restoration in connection
with buyouts funded through other mechanisms.
• Funds are prioritized for households making less than 125% of the median household income in
an eligible fund recipient’s area.
• Each recipient will be offered a package of grants and loans to fund the approved project which
will carry a low overall effective interest rate— no higher than 40% of the market interest rate as
defined by the 10-year US Treasury Yield Curve.
• The percentage of grants as an optional funding incentive can be no less than 5% and no greater
than 25% of the total sum, and the grant percentage will be increased to promote applicants to
incorporate beneficial flood mitigation into each project, including:
o ensuring residents relocate outside of the floodplain
o aiding residents in relocating outside of the floodplain and within the tax base
o aiding residents in relocating outside of the floodplain and within an area designated as
an Opportunity Zone
o conducting floodplain restoration after the property is converted to open space to
reestablish the full water storing benefits of the floodplain
o completing a buyout of an area larger than 10 acres
• All acquired properties will be returned to open space and all future development on the parcel is
prohibited in perpetuity through easement by requirement of the bill.
• No more than $500,000 can be spent on each housing unit receiving loan funds.
Qualification for a Loan, Minimum Criteria:
• Any locality wishing to apply for this funding must submit a plan identifying the properties
proposed for the project, how the properties qualify as repetitive loss properties, a plan outlining
a timeline for returning the property to open space within 6 months following the completion of
the buyout, a valid easement holder, an assessment showing the costs and benefits of the
project, and any beneficial flood mitigation practices planned for the project.
Environmental Initiatives at
the South C arolina Ports
Authority
B y: M ark M essersmith, South C arolina Ports Authority
SOUTH CAROLINA PORTS AUTHORITY
Environmental Initiatives
Mark Messersmith
Permitting Manager
Presented To:
City of Charleston
Resilience & Sustainability Committee Meeting
February 13, 2020
SC PORTS AUTHORITY
VISION & VALUES
TO BE THE
PREFERRED PORT
OF THE TOP 10
U. S. C ONTA INER PORTS
3
CHARLESTON
HARBOR
4
TOP 10 U. S. C O N T A I N E R PORTS
CONTAINER VOLUME
TEUS IN MILLIONS
LOS ANGELES 6.7 9.5
LONG BEACH 4.9 8.1
NEW YORK/NEW JERSEY 4.6 7.2
SAVANNAH 2.4 4.4
NWSA (SEA-TAC) 3.1 3.8
CY2009
NORFOLK 1.7 2.9
CY2018
2019
HOUSTON 1.8 2.7
OAKLAND 2.1 2.5
CHARLESTON 1.2 2.3 2.5 million TEU for 2019
JACKSONVILLE 0.8 1.3
0 2 4 6 8 10
4
SC PORTS OVERVIEW
FASTEST GROWING Best Performing Port on All Standard Industry
TOP 10 US
Metrics:
- 45 Minute Gate Turn Times Including Queue
- 35 Moves per Hour Crane Productivity
- 100 Moves per Hour Berth Productivity
CONTAINER PORT
- Lowest Total Cost (stevedoring/terminal/assessments)
Wando Terminal Densification Leading to 2.4
million TEU Capacity by End 2020
2009-2019
52 Foot Harbor Deepening Fully Funded and
Construction Ongoing
Phase 1 of Leatherman Terminal Opening
8%
March, 2021
Significant Push into Retail Distribution and
Export Resin Transloading = Cargo Base
Robust and Effective Inland Port Development
CAGR and Increasing Rail Volume
- 24% Intermodal Container Rail
5
OUTLINE
• Air Emissions / Energy Consumption
• New Marine Container Terminal Innovations
• Inland Ports
• Dominion Energy – LED retrofit
• Air Emission Monitoring and Reduction Efforts
• Habitat Creation Projects
• Responsible Landscape Scale Mitigation
Mobile Sources Include
Ocean Going Vessels
AIR EMISSIONS
Cargo Handling Equipment
Trucks
Rail
Harbor Craft (Tugs/Pilots/etc.)
SCPA Air Emission Reduction Efforts
Inventories
Electrification
Repowers/upgrades
Monitoring
Clean Trucks
Affiliations/Memberships
Mitigation Efforts
HUGH LEATHERMAN TERMINAL ENERGY INNOVATIONS
Hybrid Rubber
Tired Gantry
cranes with
battery – diesel
electric engines
resulting in
approximately
85-98%
emission
reductions from
traditional
equipment
Before Upgrades
SCPA LIGHTING UPGRADES
• Dominion Energy’s EnergyWise
program
• ~$70,000 in lighting incentives
from Dominion
• New LED light fixtures
• Reduces energy consumption
by ~77% or about
826,000kWh/year
• Delivers enhanced operations
for customer
After Upgrades
INLAND PORT GREER
SOUTH CAROLINA
INLAND PORTS
INLAND PORT DILLON
10
CONTAINER BARGE OPERATION
REDUCING EMISSIONS AND CONGESTION
12
SCPA
AIR MONITORING
2017 SCPA Emissions Summary
Source Category NOx CO PM10 PM2.5 HC SO2
Ocean Going
Vessels 1,775.4 217.5 150.8 138.9 120.2 62.6
Tug Boats 94.0 18.7 1.9 1.9 5.9 1.8
Heavy Duty Vehicle
- Trucks 633.1 173.3 32.1 29.5 37.2 1.1
Rail 37.6 6.1 0.8 0.8 2.1 0.0
Container Handling
Equipment 119.7 41.0 5.3 5.2 7.9 0.2
Total 2,659.8 456.5 190.9 176.3 173.3 65.7
NOx emissions are the largest among the pollutants
quantified.
Wando Welch Terminal accounts for the majority of the
emissions.
Ocean Going Vessels account for the largest percentage of
emissions.
Emissions Trends
• 96% SO2 reduction
(primarily from OGV)
• 18% reduction in PM
Tons
• Significant overall
reduction in emissions
since 2005 inventory
Year
2019
DIESEL EMISSION REDUCTION ACT
GRANT FUNDING
• Repowers 12 Tier 2, single speed diesel genset
powered RTG’s
• Provides 12 brand new EcoCrane Hybrid Systems
• Tier 4 variable throttle hybrid battery/genset systems
• Significant emission reduction (tons)
• Annual – 0.987 HC ; 4.13 CO ; 21.43 Nox ; 0.856 PM2.5
• Lifetime – 9.87 HC ; 41.27 CO ; 214.28 NOx; 8.56
PM2.5
Daniel Island Saltwater Mitigation Bank
Location Concept
Location
Downtown
Charleston
DRUM ISLAND MARSH
RESTORATION
Charleston
Construction Plans /
Harbor
Redesigns
Atlantic
True saltwater tidal wetland
Ocean
restoration (22+ acres)
Part of the HLT mitigation
Extensive Modeling package
110,519 CY soil removed
106,171 native plants
$3.4M construction cost
DRUM ISLAND MARSH
RESTORATION
LAND PRESERVATION
AND RESTORATION
More than 2250 acres of land
preserved/restored since 2016
Fairlawn Plantation
Part of the Charleston Harbor deepening project mitigation
Preserves freshwater wetlands to mitigate for indirect
wetland impacts associated with harbor deepening
Restoration of longleaf pine plantation
Conveyance to US Forest Service for inclusion in Francis
Marion National Forest
Lowcountry Land Trust Partnership
Hyde Park Plantation
French Quarter Creek
INLAND PORT
DILLON WETLAND
PRESERVATION
•78 acres
•Restored wetland
connectivity
•Long Term
Stewardship – Pee
Dee Land Trust
South Carolina’s
Watershed Resources Registry
STRIVING TO BE THE GREENEST
PORT IN THE SOUTHEAST
THANK YOU.
Public Comment Period
Agenda
City of Charleston
Resiliency & Sustainability Advisory Committee
Agenda
February 13, 2020, 11:00am
2 George Street, 1st Floor Public Meeting Room
Welcome and Moment of Silence Mayor John Tecklenburg
Sustainability Next Steps: Katie McKain
- GHG Inventory
- Green Plan Audit
- Climate Action Plan
SC Resilience Revolving Fund Act Update Jason Crowley, CCL
Environmental Initiatives at the Mark Messersmith, SPA
South Carolina Ports Authority
Earth Day 2020 Resolutions Katie McKain
Public Comment Period
Get email alerts for Charleston
A daily email when new agendas and minutes are posted.