City Council Business Meeting
Regular MeetingCharlotte, NC · April 24, 2017
Minutes
City of Charlotte
Charlotte-Mecklenburg Government Center
600 East 4th Street
Charlotte, NC 28202
Meeting Minutes
Monday, April 24, 2017
5:00 PM
Council Chambers
City Council Business Meeting
Mayor Jennifer W. Roberts
Mayor Pro Tem Vi Lyles
Council Member Dimple Ajmera
Council Member Al Austin
Council Member Ed Driggs
Council Member Julie Eiselt
Council Member Claire Fallon
Council Member Patsy Kinsey
Council Member LaWana Mayfield
Council Member James Mitchell
Council Member Greg Phipps
Council Member Kenny Smith
City Council Business Meeting Meeting Minutes April 24, 2017
DINNER BRIEFING
CALL TO ORDER
The City Council of the City of Charlotte, North Carolina convened for a Dinner
Briefing on Monday, April 24, 2017 at 5:15 p.m. in Room 267 of the Charlotte
Mecklenburg Government Center with Mayor Jennifer Roberts presiding.
ROLL CALL
Present: 11 - Mayor Jennifer Roberts, Council Member Dimple Ajmera, Council Member Al
Austin, Council Member Julie Eiselt, Council Member Claire Fallon, Council
Member Patsy Kinsey, Council Member Vi Lyles, Council Member LaWana
Mayfield, Council Member James Mitchell, Council Member Greg Phipps, and
Council Member Kenny Smith
AUN: 1- Council Member Ed Driggs
1. 15-5421 Agenda Overview
There was no agenda overview presented.
2. 15-5422 Mayor and Council Consent Item Questions
There were no Consent item questions.
3. 15-5269 Sixth and Tryon Proposed Development Concept
Debra Campbell, Assistant City Manager and Beth Hardin, University of North
Carolina at Charlotte provided background on the Steering Committee’s work
and partner interests as well as discussed the proposed conceptual plan, key
considerations, and next steps.
Council member Driggs arrived at 5:30 p.m.
ROLL CALL
Present: 12 - Mayor Jennifer Roberts, Council Member Dimple Ajmera, Council Member Al
Austin, Council Member Ed Driggs, Council Member Julie Eiselt, Council Member
Claire Fallon, Council Member Patsy Kinsey, Council Member Vi Lyles, Council
Member LaWana Mayfield, Council Member James Mitchell, Council Member Greg
Phipps, and Council Member Kenny Smith
4. 15-5483 Extraterritorial Jurisdiction Policing
Bob Hagemann, City Attorney, Chief Kerr Putney, Police and Ann Wall, Assistant
City Manager provided the history of police consolidation in the extraterritorial
jurisdiction (ETJ) unincorporated areas of Charlotte, Cornelius, Davidson,
Huntersville, Mint Hill and Pineville.
5. 15-5408 Extraordinary Events Ordinance
This agenda item was Pulled by Staff. It will be brought back at a later date.
City of Charlotte Page 1 Printed on 4/25/2017
City Council Business Meeting Meeting Minutes April 24, 2017
6. 15-5423 Answers to Mayor and Council Consent Item
Questions
There were no Consent item questions.
CLOSED SESSION
A motion was made by Council Member Mayfield and seconded by Council
Member Smith to Go into Closed Session pursuant to G.S. 143-318.11 (a) (4) to
discuss matters relating to the location of industries or businesses in the City of
Charlotte, including potential economic development incentives that may be
offered in negotiations. The motion carried unanimously.
RECESS
The meeting recessed at 6:25 p.m. to go into closed session in Room 267. The
closed session recessed at 7:05 p.m. to move to the Meeting Chamber for the
regularly scheduled Business Meeting.
BUSINESS MEETING
CALL TO ORDER
The City Council of the City of Charlotte, North Carolina reconvened for a
Business Meeting on Monday, April 24, 2017 at 7:13 p.m. in the Meeting Chamber
of the Charlotte Mecklenburg Government Center with Mayor Jennifer Roberts
presiding.
ROLL CALL
Present: 11 - Mayor Jennifer Roberts, Council Member Al Austin, Council Member Ed Driggs,
Council Member Julie Eiselt, Council Member Claire Fallon, Council Member Patsy
Kinsey, Council Member Vi Lyles, Council Member LaWana Mayfield, Council
Member James Mitchell, Council Member Greg Phipps, and Council Member Kenny
Smith
AUN: 1- Council Member Dimple Ajmera
INTRODUCTIONS
INVOCATION
Council member Smith led the Invocation
Council member Ajmera arrived at 7:15 p.m.
ROLL CALL
Present: 12 - Mayor Jennifer Roberts, Council Member Dimple Ajmera, Council Member Al
Austin, Council Member Ed Driggs, Council Member Julie Eiselt, Council Member
Claire Fallon, Council Member Patsy Kinsey, Council Member Vi Lyles, Council
Member LaWana Mayfield, Council Member James Mitchell, Council Member Greg
Phipps, and Council Member Kenny Smith
City of Charlotte Page 2 Printed on 4/25/2017
City Council Business Meeting Meeting Minutes April 24, 2017
PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
Students from Winding Spring Elementary led the Pledge of Allegiance to the
Flag.
Council member James Mitchell was recognized for his participation with after
school enrichment programs.
CONSENT
7. 15-5424 Consent agenda items 19 through 34 may be
considered in one motion except for those items
removed by a Council member. Items are removed
by notifying the City Clerk.
.
Approval of the Consent Agenda
A motion was made by Council Member Kinsey and seconded by Council
Member Eiselt to Approve the Consent Agenda as presented with the exception
of Item Nos. 24, 28, and 29 which were pulled by staff. The motion carried
unanimously.
CITIZENS' FORUM
Mayor Roberts explained the rules and procedures of the Citizens Forum.
The following speakers addressed City Council:
1. Carter Brydon - Pro-Choice / Pro-Life Discussion
2. Phil Fortuna - City of Charlotte Auction Process
3. Karen Jensen - Transparency in Police and City Government
4. Leila Forbes - Charlotte Abortion Clinic Protests
5. Rose Brown - Feeding America's Heart and Soul
6. Alixandra Taylor - Harassment and Intimidation at Private Medical Facilities
7. Bill Davis - The Magnificent Tree Canopy in Charlotte
8. Patrick George - The Magnificent Tree Canopy in Charlotte
9. Nicole Mitchell - Entrepreneurship - DECA
10. Klaus Schick - Pro-Choice / Pro-Life Discussion
ZONING
8. 15-5453 Rezoning Petition 2016-134
A motion was made by Council Member Kinsey and seconded by Council
Member Fallon to Return this Rezoning Petition to the Zoning Committee for
Review.
A subsequent substitute motion made this motion moot. No vote was taken.
City of Charlotte Page 3 Printed on 4/25/2017
City Council Business Meeting Meeting Minutes April 24, 2017
A substitute motion was made by Council Member Mayfield and seconded by
Council Member Ajmera Not to Refer this Rezoning Petition back to the Zoning
Committee. The motion carried by the following vote:
Yeas: 9- Council Member Ajmera, Council Member Austin, Council Member Driggs,
Council Member Eiselt, Council Member Lyles, Council Member Mayfield, Council
Member Mitchell, Council Member Phipps, and Council Member Smith
Nayes: 2- Council Member Fallon, and Council Member Kinsey
A motion was made by Council Member Mayfield and seconded by Council
Member Austin to Approve this Rezoning Petition, as modified. The motion
carried by the following vote:
Yeas: 9- Council Member Ajmera, Council Member Austin, Council Member Driggs,
Council Member Eiselt, Council Member Lyles, Council Member Mayfield, Council
Member Mitchell, Council Member Phipps, and Council Member Smith
Nayes: 2- Council Member Fallon, and Council Member Kinsey
A motion was made by Council Member Mayfield and seconded by Council
Member Lyles to Adopt the Statement of Consistency for this Zoning Decision.
The motion carried unanimously.
PUBLIC HEARING
9. 15-5353 Public Comment on Charlotte BIKES
Ben Miller, Transporation presented an overview of Charlotte BIKES Plan.
The following speaker(s) addressed City Council regarding this item:
Kate Cavazza
Eric Zaverl
Haley Beaupre
Martin Zimmerman
Annie Grace Wood
Tate Moody
Brooks Moody
Heidi Ruckterstuhl
Celeste Longshore
Mia Platt
Ainsley Chambers
Gram Chambers
Liam Platt
Vaugh Vega
Tony Lathrop
Charlotte BIKES is scheduled for adoption on May 22, 2017.
City of Charlotte Page 4 Printed on 4/25/2017
City Council Business Meeting Meeting Minutes April 24, 2017
10. 15-5376 Public Hearing on a Resolution to Close a Portion of
Tomlin Way Court
A motion was made by Council Member Mayfield and seconded by Council
Member Eiselt to Close the Public Hearing. The motion carried unanimously.
A motion was made by Council Member Mayfield and seconded by Council
Member Eiselt to Approve this Public Hearing Item. The motion carried
unanimously.
11. 15-5406 Public Hearing on the Fiscal Year 2018 Annual Action
Plan for Housing and Community Development
A motion was made by Council Member Mayfield and seconded by Council
Member Mitchell to Close the Public Hearing. The motion carried unanimously.
12. 15-5407 Southeastern Metal Products Business Investment
Grant
A motion was made by Council Member Mitchell and seconded by Council
Member Austin to Close the Public Hearing. The motion carried by the following
vote:
Yeas: 8- Council Member Ajmera, Council Member Austin, Council Member Eiselt, Council
Member Fallon, Council Member Kinsey, Council Member Lyles, Council Member
Mitchell, and Council Member Phipps
Nayes: 3- Council Member Driggs, Council Member Mayfield, and Council Member Smith
A motion was made by Council Member Mitchell and seconded by Council
Member Austin to Approve this Public Hearing Item. The motion carried by the
following vote:
Yeas: 8- Council Member Ajmera, Council Member Austin, Council Member Eiselt, Council
Member Fallon, Council Member Kinsey, Council Member Lyles, Council Member
Mitchell, and Council Member Phipps
Nayes: 3- Council Member Driggs, Council Member Mayfield, and Council Member Smith
POLICY
13. 15-5425 City Manager’s Report
Marcus Jones, City Manager reported on Latrobe Drive. He stated that he is
trying to come up with a comprehensive approach to addressing the issues.
14. 15-5397 Housing Funding Support Requests for Fiscal Year
2017
The following speaker(s) addressed City Council regarding this item:
Maggie Storch
A motion was made by Council Member Mayfield and seconded by Council
Member Kinsey to Approve this Policy Item. The motion carried unanimously.
City of Charlotte Page 5 Printed on 4/25/2017
City Council Business Meeting Meeting Minutes April 24, 2017
BUSINESS
15. 15-5387 Airport Revenue Bond Issuance and Bond Order
Revisions
A motion was made by Council Member Mayfield and seconded by Council
Member Ajmera to Approve this Business Item. The motion carried unanimously.
16. 15-5389 CATS Blue Line Extension Short-term Financing
A motion was made by Council Member Kinsey and seconded by Council
Member Austin to Approve this Business Item. The motion carried unanimously.
17. 15-5411 Appointments to Neighborhood Matching Grants Fund
One appointment in the Business Representative category for a full two-year term
beginning April 16, 2017 and ending April 15, 2019. Marlon Nesbeth was
appointed. One appointment in the Neighborhood Representative category for a
partial term beginning immediately and ending April 15, 2018. Colin Pinkney
was appointed.
18. 15-5426 Mayor and City Council Topics
The City Council members may share information and raise topics for discussion.
CONSENT
19. 15-5138 Charlotte-Mecklenburg Police Department Central
Division Office Design Services, Condemnation, and
Business Relocation Payments
A motion was made by Council Member Kinsey and seconded by Council
Member Eiselt to Approve this Consent Item.The motion carried unanimously.
20. 15-5378 Police Promotional Processes Services
A motion was made by Council Member Kinsey and seconded by Council
Member Eiselt to Approve this Consent Item.The motion carried unanimously.
21. 15-5384 Fire Station 27 Renovation
A motion was made by Council Member Kinsey and seconded by Council
Member Eiselt to Approve this Consent Item.The motion carried unanimously.
22. 15-5306 Fire Hazardous Materials Truck
A motion was made by Council Member Kinsey and seconded by Council
Member Eiselt to Approve this Consent Item.The motion carried unanimously.
23. 15-5148 Coliseum Creek Stream Restoration Project
A motion was made by Council Member Kinsey and seconded by Council
Member Eiselt to Approve this Consent Item.The motion carried unanimously.
City of Charlotte Page 6 Printed on 4/25/2017
City Council Business Meeting Meeting Minutes April 24, 2017
24. 15-5207 Independence Boulevard Area Sidewalk and Bike
Facilities
Indexes: Transportation & Planning
This item was Pulled by Staff
25. 15-5404 Oracle Products and Related Services
A motion was made by Council Member Kinsey and seconded by Council
Member Eiselt to Approve this Consent Item.The motion carried unanimously.
26. 15-5321 American Airlines Sprinkler System Reimbursement
A motion was made by Council Member Kinsey and seconded by Council
Member Eiselt to Approve this Consent Item.The motion carried unanimously.
27. 15-5380 Aviation Passenger Loading Bridge Baggage Slide
Contract
A motion was made by Council Member Kinsey and seconded by Council
Member Eiselt to Approve this Consent Item.The motion carried unanimously.
28. 15-3868 Airport Joint Operations Center
This item was Pulled by Staff
29. 15-5086 CATS Express Bus and Institution Shuttle Services
This item was Pulled by Staff
30. 15-5250 Charlotte Water Corrosion Protection Services
A motion was made by Council Member Kinsey and seconded by Council
Member Eiselt to Approve this Consent Item.The motion carried unanimously.
31. 15-5377 Resolution of Intent to Abandon a Portion of an
Alleyway off of Keeter Drive
A motion was made by Council Member Kinsey and seconded by Council
Member Eiselt to Approve this Consent Item.The motion carried unanimously.
32. 15-5379 Resolution of Intent to Abandon a Portion of Booker
Avenue
A motion was made by Council Member Kinsey and seconded by Council
Member Eiselt to Approve this Consent Item.The motion carried unanimously.
33. 15-5399 Refund of Property and Business Privilege License
Taxes
A motion was made by Council Member Kinsey and seconded by Council
Member Eiselt to Approve this Consent Item.The motion carried unanimously.
City of Charlotte Page 7 Printed on 4/25/2017
City Council Business Meeting Meeting Minutes April 24, 2017
34. 15-5405 Meeting Minutes
A motion was made by Council Member Kinsey and seconded by Council
Member Eiselt to Approve this Consent Item.The motion carried unanimously.
ADJOURNMENT
The meeting adjourned at 9:32 p.m.
City of Charlotte Page 8 Printed on 4/25/2017
Agenda
City of Charlotte
Charlotte-Mecklenburg Government Center
600 East 4th Street
Charlotte, NC 28202
Meeting Agenda
Monday, April 24, 2017
Council Chambers
City Council Business Meeting
Mayor Jennifer W. Roberts
Mayor Pro Tem Vi Lyles
Council Member Dimple Ajmera
Council Member Al Austin
Council Member Ed Driggs
Council Member Julie Eiselt
Council Member Claire Fallon
Council Member Patsy Kinsey
Council Member LaWana Mayfield
Council Member James Mitchell
Council Member Greg Phipps
Council Member Kenny Smith
City Council Business Meeting Meeting Agenda April 24, 2017
5:00 P.M. DINNER BRIEFING,
CHARLOTTE-MECKLENBURG GOVERNMENT CENTER,
ROOM 267
1. Agenda Overview
Staff Resource(s):
Marcus Jones, City Manager
2. Mayor and Council Consent Item Questions
Staff Resource(s):
Kim Eagle, City Manager’s Office
Time: 5 minutes
Synopsis
Mayor and Council may ask questions about Consent agenda items. Staff will address questions at the
end of the dinner meeting.
3. Sixth and Tryon Proposed Development Concept
Staff Resource(s):
Debra Campbell, City Manager’s Office
Lee Keesler, Charlotte Mecklenburg Library
Beth Hardin, University of North Carolina at Charlotte
Time: 30 minutes
Explanation
§ Sixth and Tryon is a conceptual idea for a public sector-led redevelopment of two blocks in the
North Tryon Street area. The two blocks consists of property between North Tryon and College
Street and 6th and 8th Streets.
§ A Steering Committee was formed in 2015 consisting of key landowners that included the City,
County, Library, and private sector.
§ As primary landowners, the Committee’s charge was to develop a proposed redevelopment
framework for this two block area consistent with the North Tryon Vision Plan.
§ Committee members will provide background on the committee’s work and partner interests as
well as discuss the proposed conceptual plan, key considerations, and next steps. A similar
presentation was given to the Board of County Commission on March 14, 2017.
Future Action
The presentation is for informational purposes only.
City of Charlotte Page 2 Printed on 4/22/2017
City Council Business Meeting Meeting Agenda April 24, 2017
4. Extraterritorial Jurisdiction Policing
Staff Resource(s):
Ann Wall, City Manager’s Office
Bob Hagemann, City Attorney’s Office
Kerr Putney, Police
Time: 20 minutes
Explanation
§ The Mecklenburg County Board of Commissioners voted on Tuesday, April 18, to give notice to the
City of their intent to terminate a 1996 interlocal agreement that states the Charlotte-Mecklenburg
Police Department (CMPD) polices in the unincorporated areas of the county.
§ CMPD serves the city of Charlotte and Extraterritorial Jurisdiction (ETJ) unincorporated areas of
Charlotte, Cornelius, Davidson, Huntersville, Mint Hill, and Pineville.
§ The presentation will provide the history of police consolidation and service of the ETJ.
Future Action
The presentation is for informational purposes only.
5. Extraordinary Events Ordinance
Staff Resource(s):
Bob Hagemann, City Attorney’s Office
Kerr Putney, Police
Time: 30 minutes
Explanation
§ At the Dinner Briefing on February 13, 2017, City Council reviewed the Extraordinary Events
ordinance, including its origin, substance, and usage.
§ Based on feedback from the City Council, an ordinance has been drafted that would repeal the
current Extraordinary Events ordinance and amend the Picketing and Public Assembly ordinances
to prohibit a list of items that can be used as weapons in large event settings.
Future Action
Unless City Council directs otherwise, the proposed ordinance will be on the Council’s May 8, 2017 agenda
for action.
Attachment(s)
Proposed Ordinance
EE Repeal and Chapter 19 Amendments
6. Answers to Mayor and Council Consent Item Questions
Staff Resource(s):
Kim Eagle, City Manager’s Office
Time: 10 minutes
Synopsis
Staff responses to questions from the beginning of the dinner meeting.
City of Charlotte Page 3 Printed on 4/22/2017
City Council Business Meeting Meeting Agenda April 24, 2017
Call to Order
Roll Call
Introductions
Invocation
Pledge of Allegiance
City of Charlotte Page 4 Printed on 4/22/2017
City Council Business Meeting Meeting Agenda April 24, 2017
7. Consent agenda items 19 through 34 may be considered in
one motion except for those items removed by a Council
member. Items are removed by notifying the City Clerk.
Consideration of Consent Items shall occur in the following order:
A. Items that have not been pulled, and
B. Items with citizens signed up to speak to the item.
6:30 P.M. CITIZENS' FORUM
City of Charlotte Page 5 Printed on 4/22/2017
City Council Business Meeting Meeting Agenda April 24, 2017
ZONING
8. Rezoning Petition 2016-134
Action:
Render a decision on petition 2016-134 by CapRock, LLC
- From B-1(neighborhood business) and R-12MF (multi-family residential)
- To UR-2(CD) (urban residential, conditional), five-year vested rights
Staff Resource(s):
Ed McKinney, Planning
Tammie Keplinger, Planning
Explanation
§ The public hearing on this rezoning petition was held on February 20, 2017.
§ The property is approximately 5.81 acres located on the north side of Joy Street between Ashley
Road and Wilson Avenue. (Council District 3 - Mayfield)
§ The petition proposes to allow up to 132 multi-family apartments, including up to 60 age-restricted
units, at a density of 22.72 units per acre on vacant lots in the Westerly Hills neighborhood.
§ The City Council deferred the decision on this petition to April 24, as requested by the petitioner,
on April 17, 2017, to work on the remaining outstanding issues and to submit a revised site plan.
§ The Zoning Committee found the majority of the proposed multi-family to be consistent with the
Central District Plan; a small portion of the site to be inconsistent with the Central District Plan;
and the density to be inconsistent with the General Development Policies (GDP). Therefore, the
petition was found to be reasonable and in the public interest based on the majority of the site
being consistent with the Planning’s land use recommendation as multi-family.
§ The Zoning Committee voted 6-0 to recommend APPROVAL of this petition with the noted
modifications.
§ The revised site plan and a summary of changes will in the Council-Manager Memo on Thursday,
April 20, 2017.
Attachment(s)
Zoning Committee Statement of Consistency
Zoning Committee Recommendation
Staff Analysis
Vicinity Map
Locator Map
2016-134_reco_04-04-2017-final
2016-134 vicinity map
2016-134 rezoning map revised2
City of Charlotte Page 6 Printed on 4/22/2017
City Council Business Meeting Meeting Agenda April 24, 2017
PUBLIC HEARING
City of Charlotte Page 7 Printed on 4/22/2017
City Council Business Meeting Meeting Agenda April 24, 2017
9. Public Comment on Charlotte BIKES
Action:
Receive public comments on Charlotte BIKES.
Committee Chair:
Vi Lyles, Transportation and Planning
Staff Resource(s):
Danny Pleasant, Transportation
Ben Miller, Transportation
Explanation
§ Charlotte BIKES is the update to the 2008 Charlotte Bicycle Plan and sets a vision of an inclusive
cycling environment where people of all ages and abilities can use their bikes for transportation,
fitness, and fun.
§ Charlotte BIKES identifies goals and shorter-term strategies and initiatives to both expand the
city’s network of bicycle facilities as well as create a culture which recognizes and welcomes
bicycling as a safe and affordable means of transportation.
§ Charlotte BIKES is an extension of the recently adopted Transportation Action Plan.
Community Input
§ Since March of 2016, City staff has gathered public input at events throughout the city, including
large transportation fairs, small pop-up meetings, and individual stakeholder interviews.
§ A public draft of Charlotte BIKES was released for review and comment on February 13, 2017.
§ The Bicycle Advisory Committee was a key stakeholder and focus group for the development of
Charlotte BIKES.
Charlotte BIKES Recommendations
§ The content and strategies of Charlotte BIKES are organized around the six “E’s” of a
bicycle-friendly city:
- Education
- Engineering
- Encouragement
- Enforcement
- Equity
- Evaluation and planning
§ Three key recommendations from the plan include:
- Creating a bicycle network and bicycle-related programming that benefits people of all
ages, abilities and neighborhoods in Charlotte,
- Incorporating the latest in bikeway design guidance, and
- Funding a bicycle program that addresses all aspects of creating a bicycle-friendly city.
Transportation and Planning Committee Discussion
§ The Transportation and Planning Committee discussed Charlotte BIKES twice in 2016 (May 9 and
September 12) and twice in 2017 (February 13 and March 27).
§ On March 27, 2017, the Committee members reviewed a summary of the key content and
recommendations from Charlotte BIKES.
§ On March 27, 2017, the Committee voted unanimously (Ajmera, Kinsey, Lyles, Phipps, and Smith)
to recommend Charlotte BIKES to the full City Council for public comment.
Next Steps
§ The Transportation and Planning Committee will consider approving a recommendation on
Charlotte BIKES at its regular meeting on May 8, 2017.
City of Charlotte Page 8 Printed on 4/22/2017
City Council Business Meeting Meeting Agenda April 24, 2017
§ Charlotte BIKES is scheduled for adoption on May 22, 2017.
Attachment(s)
The Charlotte BIKES Plan can be found online at:
<http://charlottenc.gov/Transportation/Programs/Documents/_Charlotte%20BIKES9_PublicCommentDraf
t.pdf>
City of Charlotte Page 9 Printed on 4/22/2017
City Council Business Meeting Meeting Agenda April 24, 2017
10. Public Hearing on a Resolution to Close a Portion of Tomlin
Way Court
Action:
A. Conduct a public hearing to close a portion of Tomlin Way Court, and
B. Adopt a resolution to close a portion of Tomlin Way Court.
Staff Resource(s):
Danny Pleasant, Transportation
Jeff Boenisch, Transportation
Explanation
§ North Carolina General Statute 160A-299 outlines the procedures for permanently closing streets
and alleys.
§ The Charlotte Department of Transportation received a petition to abandon public right-of-way and
requests this City Council action in accordance with the statute.
§ The action removes land from public right-of-way status and attaches it to the adjacent property.
§ The attached resolution refers to exhibits and metes and bounds descriptions that are available in
the City Clerk’s Office.
§ A portion of Tomlin Way Court is located in Council District 3.
Petitioners
New Forum, Inc. - Charles T. Hodges
Right-of-Way to be Abandoned
The portion of Tomlin Way Court is a privately maintained right-of-way located within the Ayrsley
development near the intersection of I-485 and S. Tryon Street.
Reason
A right-of-way abandonment petition was filed with the city after the developer discovered set-back
challenges within the existing plans to situate a loading dock and loading area at the corner of the
property that abuts Tomlin Way Court. This abandonment request will enable the developer to retain the
loading dock/area in its original desired location and achieve the goal of obtaining connectivity through
the site by way of a public access easement. The public access easement will be put in place subsequent
to the approval of the abandonment.
Notification
As part of the City’s notification process, and in compliance with North Carolina General Statute
160A-299, the Charlotte Department of Transportation submitted this abandonment petition for review by
the public and City Departments.
Adjoining property owner(s)
NEXTGEN WS, LLC - No objections
BX Holdings, LLC - No objections
Hanson-Tomlin, LLC - No objections
Neighborhood/Business Association(s) - N/A
Private Utility Companies - No objections
City Departments
Review by City departments identified no apparent reason this closing would:
§ Be contrary to the public interest;
City of Charlotte Page 10 Printed on 4/22/2017
City Council Business Meeting Meeting Agenda April 24, 2017
§ Deprive any individual(s) owning property in the vicinity of reasonable means of ingress and
egress to his property as outlined in the statutes; and
§ Be contrary to the adopted policy to preserve existing rights-of-way for connectivity.
Attachment(s)
Map
Resolution
CityCouncilROWAbandonmentMap_2017-02 (2)
Resolution to Close a portion of Tomlin Way Court
City of Charlotte Page 11 Printed on 4/22/2017
City Council Business Meeting Meeting Agenda April 24, 2017
11. Public Hearing on the Fiscal Year 2018 Annual Action Plan for
Housing and Community Development
Action:
Hold a public hearing on the proposed Fiscal Year 2018 Annual Action Plan for Housing and
Community Development.
Staff Resource(s):
Pamela Wideman, Housing and Neighborhood Services
Warren Wooten, Housing and Neighborhood Services
Policy
§ The U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) mandates the development of an
Annual Action Plan to receive federal funding for housing and community development activities.
§ The FY18 Annual Action Plan for Housing and Community Development (Plan) is the City’s strategy
for the use of federal funds in providing housing and community development activities.
§ The Plan, which follows the federal fiscal year (October 1 - September 30), supports the City’s
housing policy to preserve existing housing, expand the supply of low and moderate-income
housing, and support family self-sufficiency.
Explanation
§ The Plan includes housing and community development needs and resources for the City and
Regional Housing Consortium.
§ The Regional Housing Consortium is a partnership among the City, Mecklenburg County and the
towns of Cornelius, Pineville, Matthews, Mint Hill, Huntersville, and Davidson.
§ In FY 2018, the City expects to receive a total of $10,283,239 in federal funding allocations:
- Community Development Block Grant (CDBG): $5,351,235
- HOME Investment and Partnerships (HOME): $2,299,536
- Emergency Solution Grants: $466,608
- Housing Opportunity for Persons with AIDS (HOPWA): $2,165,860
§ These estimated allocations are based on FY 2017 levels.
§ The final budget is expected to be determined in the next 60 to 90 days. Changes to the final
budget will be handled administratively.
Community Input
§ Public forums were convened on February 14 and February 21, 2017, to receive input for the Plan’s
development.
§ A copy of the draft Plan was placed in Charlotte Housing Authority’s main office, Old City Hall, and
several libraries throughout the City.
Council Input
§ On March 8, 2017, the Housing & Neighborhood Development Committee was briefed on the Plan
and voted unanimously (Mayfield, Ajmera, Driggs and Kinsey voted yes; Austin was not present) to
proceed to public hearing.
Next Steps
§ The Plan is scheduled for adoption on May 8, 2017, and will be submitted to HUD on or before May
15, 2017.
Fiscal Note
Funding: HUD
Attachment(s)
FY 2018 Action Plan Presentation
City of Charlotte Page 12 Printed on 4/22/2017
City Council Business Meeting Meeting Agenda April 24, 2017
Action Plan FY18 Presentation
City of Charlotte Page 13 Printed on 4/22/2017
City Council Business Meeting Meeting Agenda April 24, 2017
12. Southeastern Metal Products Business Investment Grant
Action:
A. Conduct a public hearing for approval of an economic development Business Investment
Grant for Southeastern Metal Products, LLC, and
B. Approve the City’s share of a Business Investment Grant to Southeastern Metal Products
for a total estimated amount of $71,609 over five years.
Staff Resource(s):
Patrick Mumford, Economic Development
Kevin Dick, Economic Development
Explanation
§ On December 15, 2016, Southeastern Metals announced its selection of Charlotte for an
investment of $4.1 million for the expansion of its manufacturing operation.
- The expansion will create 70 new jobs.
- A competitive location was also considered in Cherokee County, South Carolina.
§ The City’s share of the Business Investment Grant is estimated to be $71,609; Mecklenburg
County is estimated to be $122,022, for a total estimated amount of $193,631 over five years.
- On November 28, 2016, the City Council indicated its intent to approve a Business
Investment Grant to Southeastern Metal Products in a closed session.
- On December 6, 2016, the Mecklenburg Board of County Commissioners also indicated its
intent to approve a Business Investment Grant to the company in a closed session and will
consider its portion of the grant at its meeting on May 2, 2017.
- In addition to the grant for the expansion, the State of North Carolina also approved
$91,000 in community college training funds.
§ Along with its capital investment, Southeastern Metal Products has committed to:
- 70 new jobs to be hired locally over five years with an average annual wage of $40,242
(This is 83 percent of the regional average wage, and it exceeds the manufacturing sector
average wage).
Background
§ Southeastern Metal Products, a Charlotte company for 65 years, provides manufacturing and
engineering services for high quality sheet metal stamping and fabrication. Customers include John
Deere and Caterpillar.
- The company will expand its 100,000 square-foot manufacturing plant by adding 42,000
square feet to allow for increased production.
- The plant is located at 1420 Metals Drive off North Graham Street in the Business
Investment Zone.
Business Investment Grant
§ The request meets the City Council-approved criteria for a five-year, 90 percent local expansion
grant.
§ The general terms and conditions of this grant include:
- The company will be asked to coordinate job fairs and recruitment events with the City and
County for both temporary and permanent jobs. Community organizations and residents
will receive ample notice of these employment activities.
- Actual grant payments are based on the value of the investment as appraised by the
Mecklenburg County Tax Office.
- All property taxes due from Southeastern Metal Products must be paid before a grant
payment is made.
- If Southeastern Metal Products removes the investment from Charlotte during the grant
term, it shall pay back 100 percent of the investment grant paid to date.
City of Charlotte Page 14 Printed on 4/22/2017
City Council Business Meeting Meeting Agenda April 24, 2017
- If Southeastern Metal Products moves the investment from Charlotte within five years of the
end of the Business Investment Program (BIP) grant term, a portion of the grant must be
repaid as follows:
§ Within One Year of the end of the BIP Term - 90 percent of grant payments
§ Within Two Years of the end of the BIP Term - 75 percent of grant payments
§ Within Three Years of the end of the BIP Term - 60 percent of grant payments
§ Within Four Years of the end of the BIP Term - 45 percent of grant payments
§ Within Five Years of the end of the BIP Term - 30 percent of grant payments
Fiscal Note
Funding: Business Investment Grant
City of Charlotte Page 15 Printed on 4/22/2017
City Council Business Meeting Meeting Agenda April 24, 2017
POLICY
13. City Manager’s Report
City of Charlotte Page 16 Printed on 4/22/2017
City Council Business Meeting Meeting Agenda April 24, 2017
14. Housing Funding Support Requests for Fiscal Year 2017
Action:
A. Approve a waiver of Housing Locational Policy for Old Concord Apartments a proposed
multi-family development on N. Tryon along the CATS Blue Line Light Rail Extension,
B. Approve the Housing and Neighborhood Development Committee’s recommendation of
Housing Trust Fund allocations for the following multi-family Tax Credit developments
for a total of $13,859,000 to:
1. Bingham Park Seniors, $1,413,000 (60 units),
2. Catawba II, $1,072,000 (39 units),
3. Gibbon Trace, $960,000 (96 units),
4. Nevin Road, $1,700,000 (68 units),
5. North Chase Seniors, $2,000,000 (69 units),
6. Northlake Seniors, $1,750,000 (70 units),
7. Old Concord Apartments, $2,400,000 (78 units),
8. Rosewood Commons, $1,425,000 (85 units),
9. Samuel Street Seniors, $1,139,000 (43 units), and
C. Approve the Housing and Neighborhood Development Committee’s recommendation of
fund allocations for the following Supportive Housing developments for a total of $1
million to:
1. St. John’s Place, $500,000 (32 units)
2. The Men’s Shelter of Charlotte, $500,000 (230 beds)
Committee Chair:
LaWana Mayfield
Staff Resource(s):
Pamela Wideman, Housing and Neighborhood Services
Zelleka Biermann, Housing and Neighborhood Services
Explanation
Action A: Waiver of the Housing Locational Policy.
§ The Housing Locational Policy serves as a guide for development of new affordable housing.
§ This proposed multi-family development requires a waiver due to its proximity along the CATS Blue
Light Rail Extension.
Action B: Approval of HTF allocations
§ Awarding of these grants aligns with work from the Community Letter’s objective of creating 5,000
affordable and workforce housing units within a three-year period.
§ For FY 2017, developers requested HTF dollars for nine developments to support their North
Carolina Housing Tax Credit Applications for proposed rental multi-family housing developments.
§ All nine developments, which include a total of 608 units, meet the City’s submission requirements
and are recommended for funding based on the preliminary site scores issued by the North
Carolina Housing Finance Agency (NCHFA), zoning and planning guidelines, and compliance with
the Housing Locational Policy.
Action C: Approval of CDBG allocation for supportive housing
§ Two supportive housing developments also requested funding for acquisition and renovation of
existing structure. These developments combine affordable housing with supportive services for a
population includes elderly, homeless, and disabled.
§ Community Development Block Grants will be used to fund improvements for St. John’s Place,
City of Charlotte Page 17 Printed on 4/22/2017
City Council Business Meeting Meeting Agenda April 24, 2017
while HTF dollars will be allocated for those at The Men’s Shelter.
Background
§ On November 26, 2001, City Council established a Housing Trust Fund (HTF) to provide financing
for affordable housing in the Charlotte community. Currently, $22 million is available in the HTF.
§ On May 9, 2016, the City Council adopted the U. S. Department of Housing and Urban
Development’s Annual Action Plan (Plan). The Plan:
- Identifies the need for affordable, safe, and decent housing for low and moderate-income
families, and
- Reaffirms three basic goals of the City’s Housing Policy:
§ Preserve the existing housing stock
§ Expand the supply of affordable housing
§ Support family self-sufficiency initiatives
· Award of HTF allocations demonstrates local alignment with state supported developments and
allows for the local leveraging of tax credit awards.
· The NCHFA is scheduled to announce tax credit awards in August 2017. Due to the competitiveness
and limited amount of available tax credits, and the NCHFA’s desire to disperse awards throughout
the state, NCHFA will not award tax credits to all of the recommended developments. Approved
HTF funding for those developments that do not receive a tax credit award will be returned to the
HTF for future allocations.
Committee Discussion
§ On March 22, 2017, the City Council reviewed the proposed 2017 Housing Funding Support
Requests and was briefed about the nine developments that will need a waiver of the Housing
Locational Policy. The Committee voted unanimously (Austin, Ajmera, Driggs, Kinsey, and
Mayfield) to approve all nine recommended tax credit and two supportive housing developments.
City Council Discussion
§ Staff briefed City Council on the FY 2017 Housing Funding Support Requests recommendations on
April 3, 2017.
Charlotte Business INClusion
All HTF funded projects and developers are subject to MWSBE goals determined by the amount of award
being financed.
Fiscal Note
Funding: Housing Diversity Community Investment Plan and Community Development Block Grants
Attachment(s)
Presentation at the Council Workshop on April 3, 2017
April 3 Workshop - FY2017 Housing Funding Support Requests
City of Charlotte Page 18 Printed on 4/22/2017
City Council Business Meeting Meeting Agenda April 24, 2017
BUSINESS
15. Airport Revenue Bond Issuance and Bond Order Revisions
Action:
A. Approve the issuance of up to $390 million General Airport Revenue Bonds,
B. Approve the issuance of up to $175 million in an Airport Revenue Bond Anticipation Note
program, and
C. Adopt the amended and restated Airport Bond Order.
Staff Resource(s):
Randy Harrington, Management and Financial Services
Brent Cagle, Aviation
Robert Campbell, Management and Financial Services
Mike Hill, Aviation
Explanation
§ On March 27, 2017, City council authorized the application to the Local Government Commission
for debt issuance to fund Aviation Community Investment Plan projects and refunding existing
debt.
§ On April 10, 2017, City Council held a public hearing regarding the debt issuance.
§ This action authorizes staff to complete the transactions and issue the debt as planned, including
$390 million to fund current and recently completed projects and refund existing debt (for
savings). The action also includes $175 million in construction period financing for capital projects
on a short-term basis.
§ The action also authorizes the execution of a restated and amended bond order that reflects the
current marketplace and 2016 Airline Lease Agreement.
§ Upon approval from City Council, the amended Bond Order will require consent of 51 percent of the
existing and new bond holders, which is anticipated.
§ With City Council approval, it is anticipated the Local Government Commission will approve this
action at its May meeting.
§ Closing is anticipated on June 1, 2017, for the General Airport Revenue Bonds and June 8, 2017,
for the Bond Anticipation Note.
§ Improvements will be made to the terminal, airfield, parking lots, and maintenance facilities.
Fiscal Note
Funding: Airport Debt Service Fund
Attachment(s)
Projects List
Amended and Restated Bond Order
Series Resolutions
Project List
Charlotte Airport 1985 Bond Order - rev. to v9
Airport Bond Series Resolutions
City of Charlotte Page 19 Printed on 4/22/2017
City Council Business Meeting Meeting Agenda April 24, 2017
16. CATS Blue Line Extension Short-term Financing
Action:
A. Authorize the City Manager to extend the draw period under 2013F short-term Transit
Certificate of Participation to June 1, 2021,
B. Approve and adopt related covenant changes in the 2013F financing documents to
comply with the extension of the draw period, and
C. Authorize repayment of the outstanding 2013D and 2013E Certificates of Participation.
Staff Resource(s):
John Lewis, CATS
Randy Harrington, Management and Financial Services
Robert Campbell, Management and Financial Services
Explanation
§ The need to extend the short-term financing is not caused by delays in opening the Blue Line
Extension and does not affect the project budget.
§ Based on the timing of remaining federal and state grant receipts, and the cash flow needs, it has
been determined that a portion of the short-term financing needs to remain available past May
2017.
§ The lender, Bank of America-Merrill Lynch, has agreed to extend Series 2013F through June 1,
2021, if necessary, with no other changes to the terms.
§ These changes require amendments to the legal documents to reflect the new draw period and
principal payback schedule for 2013F.
§ The $100,000 in outstanding 2013D & 2013E Certificates of Participation will be repaid and those
series will be closed.
§ It is anticipated that the Local Government Commission will approve this action at its May 2017
meeting.
Background
§ In 2013, the City executed a short-term financing program to support the cash flow needs of the
CATS Blue Line Extension project and cover the timing gap between project expense payments and
the receipt of federal and state grant reimbursements.
§ This program provided a total of $425 million in available funding in four series with an initial term
set to end in May 2017.
§ Of the $425 million available, approximately $125 million has been drawn.
Fiscal Note
Funding: CATS Debt Service Fund
Attachment
Resolution
Approving Resolution - Amendment to Covenants Agreement - Transit 2017
City of Charlotte Page 20 Printed on 4/22/2017
City Council Business Meeting Meeting Agenda April 24, 2017
17. Appointments to Neighborhood Matching Grants Fund
Action:
Vote on blue ballots and return to Clerk at dinner.
Staff Resource(s):
Stephanie Kelly, City Clerk’s Office
Explanation
§ One appointment in the Business Representative category for a full two-year term beginning April
16, 2017 and ending April 15, 2019.
- Marlon Nesbeth, nominated by Council members Ajmera, Austin, Kinsey, Mayfield and
Mitchell.
§ One appointment in the Neighborhood Representative category for a partial term beginning
immediately and ending April 15, 2018.
- Anchia Kinard, nominated by Council members Austin and Kinsey.
- Colin Pickney, nominated by Council members Austin, Fallon and Mayfield.
Attachment(s)
Neighborhood Matching Grants Fund Applicants
18. Mayor and City Council Topics
The City Council members may share information and raise topics for discussion.
City of Charlotte Page 21 Printed on 4/22/2017
City Council Business Meeting Meeting Agenda April 24, 2017
CONSENT
City of Charlotte Page 22 Printed on 4/22/2017
City Council Business Meeting Meeting Agenda April 24, 2017
19. Charlotte-Mecklenburg Police Department Central Division
Office Design Services, Condemnation, and Business
Relocation Payments
Action:
A. Approve the condemnation of the parcel located at 700 West 5th Street for the City of
Charlotte’s use for the construction of the Central Division Station,
B. Authorize the City Manager to approve Business Relocation Payments associated with the
Charlotte-Mecklenburg Central Division Station project, and
C. Approve a contract in the amount of $1,586,600 with ADW Architects, PA for
architectural services for the Charlotte-Mecklenburg Police Department Central Division
Station.
Staff Resource(s):
Kerr Putney, Police
Jennifer Smith, Engineering and Property Management
Katrina Graue, Police
Tony Korolos, Engineering and Property Management
Explanation
Action A: Condemnation
§ The efficient site layout for the CMPD Central Division Station uses one City-owned property and
one adjacent property. An agreed-upon value for the adjacent property could not be reached so
approval of condemnation is requested.
- Project: Charlotte-Mecklenburg Police Department Central Division Station, Parcel #1
- Owner(s): Faith F. Sinkoe et al.
- Property Address: 700 West 5th Street
- Total Parcel Area: 7,625 square feet (0.175 acres)
- Property to be acquired by Fee: 7,625 square feet (0.175 acres) in Fee Simple
- Structures/Improvements to be impacted: Two-story office/warehouse building
- Landscaping to be impacted: None
- Zoned: Uptown Mixed-Use District
- Use: Commercial
- Tax Code: 078-121-01
- Appraised Value: $724,400
- Counter Offer: $1,258,125
- Property Owner’s Concerns: The property owner is concerned with the compensation
amount offered.
- City’s Response to Property Owner’s Concerns: Staff informed the property owner that
an appraisal could be attained, at the expense of the owner, in order to justify their counter
offer.
- Recommendation: To avoid delay in the project schedule, staff recommends proceeding
with condemnation during which time negotiations may continue, mediation is available and
if necessary, just compensation will be determined in court.
- Council District: 2
Action B: Business Relocation Payments
§ The property located at 700 West 5th Street will be acquired to build the CMPD Central Division. As
a result, CHL Motorsports, Inc. will be required to relocate their business, and The Famous Mart,
Inc. will be required to relocate their personal property.
§ All business relocations required for capital improvement projects are completed in accordance
City of Charlotte Page 23 Printed on 4/22/2017
City Council Business Meeting Meeting Agenda April 24, 2017
with the Uniform Relocation Assistance and Real Property Acquisition Policies Act of 1970 as
amended (Uniform Act).
- The Uniform Act intends to ensure owners of real property that is to be acquired and
businesses that are to be displaced as a direct result of improvement projects are treated
fairly, consistently and equitably.
- The Uniform Act also intends to ensure the agencies acquiring this property implement
these regulations in a manner which is efficient and cost effective.
§ Businesses required to move as a result of City projects are eligible for reimbursement of actual
and reasonable moving and related expenses, as defined in the Uniform Act.
§ Reimbursements for the relocation, which include searching expenses, moving and reestablishment
of the business, are estimated to exceed $100,000 and require City Council approval.
Action C: Design Services
§ The contract with ADW Architects, PA will provide architectural design services for a new
three-story, 31,000-square-foot facility located on City-owned property at the intersection of 5th
and 6th Streets for the Charlotte-Mecklenburg Police Department (CMPD) Central Division and
potentially space for another City Department.
§ The contract will provide architectural design services, including but not limited to:
- Site and building planning and design,
- Construction documents,
- Project administration, and
- Construction administration.
§ On March 22, 2016, the City issued a Request for Qualifications (RFQ) for architectural services; 15
proposals were received from interested professional service providers.
§ ADW Architects, Inc. is the best qualified firm to meet the City’s needs on the basis of
demonstrated competence, qualifications, experience, and responsiveness to RFQ requirements.
§ The initial $13,500,000 was funded through the Fiscal Year 2016 Community Investment Plan. An
additional $12,500,000 of funding was proposed at the March 22, 2017 Budget Workshop as part
of the Fiscal Year 2018 Community Investment Plan.
§ It is anticipated that City Council will award a construction contract in spring of 2018.
§ An update was provided to City Council on the CMPD Central Division Office project during the
Dinner Briefing on April 10, 2017. Additional follow-up responses to questions posed by City
Council during the Dinner Briefing are included as an attachment.
Background
§ The CMPD Central Division comprises of 100 staff members who serve 4.2 square miles of area
inside I-277 and portions of Southend.
§ In February 2010, CMPD adopted the Facilities Strategic Plan, which outlines division facility goals
through 2025. In this plan, CMPD prioritized the transition from renting leased spaces to occupying
City-owned facilities. This recommendation supports CMPD’s objectives to be highly visible and
accessible within the community, reduce operating costs, and accommodate future personnel
growth.
§ The CMPD Central Division currently leases a facility from Bank of America at 119 E 7th Street.
This lease will expire on July 31, 2018.
§ After considering 10 other sites and exploring public/private partnership opportunities in 2014 and
2015, staff determined that the City-owned land and adjoining privately-owned property between
W 5th Street and W 6th Street would be the most conducive for development and provide cost
savings due to reduced land acquisition.
§ Construction is anticipated to begin on the new Central Division Station in summer of 2018 and to
be completed in early 2020.
Charlotte Business INClusion for Design Contract
The City negotiates subcontracting participation after the proposal selection process (Part C: Section
2.1(h) of the Charlotte Business INClusion Policy). ADW Architects, PA has committed 14.45%
City of Charlotte Page 24 Printed on 4/22/2017
City Council Business Meeting Meeting Agenda April 24, 2017
($229,200) of the total contract amount to the following certified firms:
§ AME Consulting Engineers, Inc. (SBE) ($210,600) (mechanical, electrical and plumbing design
services/fire protection design services)
§ R.M. Rutherford and Associates, Inc. (SBE) ($18,600) (cost estimation services)
A Charlotte Business INClusion goal will be part of the construction contract anticipated for City Council
consideration in spring 2018.
Fiscal Note
Funding: General Community Investment Plan
Attachment(s)
Map
Resolution
City Council CMPD Central Division Questions/Answers from the April 10 Dinner Briefing
Location Map - CMPD Central Division Office Design Services - Condemnation - Business Relocation Payments
Condemnation resolution
Central Division Station DB Follow-up_4-24-17
20. Police Promotional Processes Services
Action:
Approve a unit price contract with EB Jacobs, LLC for Police Promotional Processes Services for
a term of four years.
Staff Resource(s):
Kerr Putney, Police
Katrina Graue, Police
Eugene Trombini, Police
Explanation
§ The Charlotte-Mecklenburg Police Department (CMPD) holds promotional processes annually, using
an assessment center to ensure a fair and high-quality process for candidates.
§ The vendor will provide services for sergeant, lieutenant, and captain promotional processes to
include designing test questions and assessment exercises, as well as train assessors.
§ On February 6, 2017, the City issued a Request for Proposals (RFP); six proposals were received
from interested service providers.
§ EB Jacobs, LLC best meets the City’s needs in terms of qualifications, experience, cost, and
responsiveness to RFP requirements.
§ On February 27, 2017, the City Council approved a contract with Developmental Associates for
sergeant promotional assessment center services. Developmental Associates will continue to
conduct the current sergeant promotional assessment center through August 7, 2017.
§ Estimated annual contract expenditures are $159,000 over the four year term.
Charlotte Business INClusion
No subcontracting goal was established because there are no subcontracting opportunities (Part C: Section
2.1(a) of the Charlotte Business INClusion Policy).
Fiscal Note
Funding: Police Operating Budget
City of Charlotte Page 25 Printed on 4/22/2017
City Council Business Meeting Meeting Agenda April 24, 2017
21. Fire Station 27 Renovation
Action:
Award a contract in the amount of $189,652.10 to the lowest responsive bidder D. E. Brown
Construction, Inc. for the Fire Station 27 project.
Staff Resource(s):
Jon Hannan, Fire
Gina Shell, Engineering and Property Management
William Haas, Engineering and Property Management
Kevin Gordon, Fire Department
Explanation
§ The renovation will add approximately 400 square feet to Fire Station 27 located at 111 Ken
Hoffman Drive, off North Tryon Street near Harris Boulevard and include general renovation
activities, such as roofing, site grading, plumbing, and electrical.
§ On March 8, 2017, the City issued an Invitation to Bid for the Fire Station 27 Addition project; two
bids were received from interested service providers.
§ D. E. Brown Construction, Inc. was selected as the lowest responsive, responsible bidder.
§ The City solicited bids only from City certified SBEs for this project, therefore the prime D.E. Brown
Construction, Inc. is a City certified SBE. D.E. Brown Construction, Inc. will self-perform:
- 17.91% ($33,959) acoustical ceiling, bath accessories/miscellaneous, concrete,
doors/hardware and framing/drywall.
§ The project is anticipated to be complete by fourth quarter 2017.
Charlotte Business INClusion
The City solicited bids only from City certified SBEs for this project, therefore the prime D.E. Brown
Construction, Inc. is a City certified SBE (Part A: Section 2.3 of the Charlotte Business INClusion Policy).
Additionally, D.E. Brown Construction, Inc. has committed 17.67% ($33,513.75) of the total contract
amount to the following certified firms:
§ All Points Waste Service, Inc. (SBE, MBE) ($800) (construction debris removal)
§ Corner Stone Construction Services, Inc. (SBE) ($14,985) (roofing)
§ Electric System Specialists, Inc. (SBE) ($14,605) (electrical)
§ MAKK Services Unlimited, Inc. (SBE, MBE) ($500) (cleaning)
§ Mountain Oak Millwork, LLC (SBE, WBE) ($1,320) (casework)
§ Treadaway & Sons Painting & Wallcovering (SBE) ($1,303.75) (painting)
Fiscal Note
Funding: General Community Investment Plan
Attachment(s)
Map
Location Map - Fire Station 27 Addition
City of Charlotte Page 26 Printed on 4/22/2017
City Council Business Meeting Meeting Agenda April 24, 2017
22. Fire Hazardous Materials Truck
Action:
A. Approve the purchase of a fire hazmat truck from a cooperative purchasing contract as
authorized by G.S. 143-129(e)(3),
B. Approve a unit price contract with Emergency Vehicles Inc. for the purchase of fire
hazmat trucks for a term of one year under the Houston-Galveston Area Council Buy
contract FS12-15, and
C. Authorize the City Manager to extend the contract for additional one-year terms as long
as the cooperative contract is in effect, at prices and terms that are the same or more
favorable than those offered under the cooperative contract.
Staff Resource(s):
Jon Hannan, Fire
Kevin Gordon, Fire
Cooperative Purchasing Exemption
NC S.L. 2001-328, effective January 1, 2002, authorizes competitive group purchasing.
Explanation
§ The Charlotte Fire Department uses a hazardous materials truck for day-to-day mitigation for calls
where hazardous materials are present.
§ The new hazardous materials truck will replace a 1997 model truck, currently in use. The truck
being replaced will be used as a reserve apparatus.
§ Emergency Vehicles Inc. has a cooperative contract awarded through the Houston-Galveston Area
Council Buy that offers competitively-obtained contracts to public agencies nationwide to provide
goods to public agencies at best value.
§ The unit price for the hazmat truck is $776,342. Fire anticipates purchasing one hazmat truck as
part of the Fiscal Year 2017 Capital Equipment Replacement Program and additional purchases will
be subject to the availability of additional funds.
Charlotte Business INClusion
These are cooperative purchasing contracts and are exempt (Part A: Appendix 27 of the Charlotte
Business INClusion Policy).
Fiscal Note
Funding: General Capital Equipment Replacement Fund
City of Charlotte Page 27 Printed on 4/22/2017
City Council Business Meeting Meeting Agenda April 24, 2017
23. Coliseum Creek Stream Restoration Project
Action:
Award a contract in the amount of $4,297,184.35 to the lowest responsive bidder Eagle Wood,
Inc., for the Coliseum Creek Stream Restoration project.
Staff Resource(s):
Jennifer Smith, Engineering and Property Management
Matthew Gustis, Engineering and Property Management
Explanation
§ The Coliseum Creek Stream Restoration project will restore or enhance portions of an unnamed
tributary to Sugar Creek while generating stream mitigation credits.
§ The drainage area is approximately 290 acres and includes the old Charlotte Coliseum property,
Renaissance Park, and Renaissance Park Golf Course.
§ The project includes restoration of 5,789 feet of streams that will improve water quality and reduce
stream bank erosion within the Sugar Creek watershed.
§ The project area is bordered by Billy Graham Parkway to the north, Sugar Creek to the south, and
West and South Tryon Street to the east.
§ On January 17, 2017, the City issued an Invitation to Bid; five bids were received from interested
service providers.
§ Eagle Wood, Inc. was selected as the lowest responsive, responsible bidder.
§ The project is scheduled to be complete by first quarter 2020.
Charlotte Business INClusion
Established SBE Goal: 22.00%
Committed SBE Goal: 26.85%
Eagle Wood Inc. exceeded the established SBE subcontracting goal, and has committed 26.85%
($1,153,960) of the total contract amount to the following certified firms (Part B: Section 3 of the
Charlotte
Business INClusion Policy):
§ Coastline Partners Equipment Leasing (SBE) ($850,000) (clearing and grubbing)
§ Affordable Source Trucking (SBE) ($278,000) (hauling)
§ On Time Construction (SBE, MBE) ($25,960) (curb and gutter)
Established MBE Goal: 7.00%
Committed MBE Goal: 0.60%
MBE Utilization with non-City certified MBEs: 6.47%*
*At bid, Eagle Wood Inc. committed 6.47% ($278,000) of the total contract amount to the following
NCDOT MBE certified firms:
§ Affordable Source Trucking (SBE, NCDOT MBE) ($278,000) (hauling)
Eagle Wood Inc. failed to meet the established MBE subcontracting goal, but earned the minimum Good
Faith Effort Points (Part B: Section 5 of the Charlotte Business INClusion Policy).
A further detailed write-up of Eagle Wood Inc.’s Good Faith Efforts is attached.
Fiscal Note
Funding: Storm Water Community Investment Plan
Attachment(s)
Map
Good Faith Efforts Summary
City of Charlotte Page 28 Printed on 4/22/2017
City Council Business Meeting Meeting Agenda April 24, 2017
Location Map - Coliseum Creek Stream Restoration
Good Faith Efforts Summary for Coliseum Creek Stream Restoration
City of Charlotte Page 29 Printed on 4/22/2017
City Council Business Meeting Meeting Agenda April 24, 2017
24. Independence Boulevard Area Sidewalk and Bike Facilities
Action:
A. Approve a contract in the amount of $709,684 with AECOM Technical Services of North
Carolina, Inc. (formerly URS) for planning services for the Independence Boulevard
Sidewalk and Bike Facilities-North, and
B. Approve a contract in the amount of $418,521 with Kimley-Horn and Associates, Inc. to
provide planning services for the Independence Boulevard Sidewalk and Bike
Facilities-South.
Staff Resource(s):
Jennifer Smith, Engineering and Property Management
Bette Frederick, Engineering and Property Management
Explanation
§ In November 2016, voters approved $2.0 million bond referendum for the Southeast Corridor
Sidewalk and Bikeway Improvement Program.
§ The Independence Boulevard Sidewalk and Bike Facilities-North and Independence Boulevard
Sidewalk and Bike Facilities-South were selected to move forward as part of the Southeast Corridor
Sidewalk and Bikeway Improvement Program.
§ The goals of the Southeast Corridor Sidewalk and Bikeway Improvement Program are to support
economic development, improve connectivity between neighborhoods and destinations and
promote transportation choices.
§ The contracts will provide planning services for four projects within the Independence Sidewalk and
Bikeways Area. The engineering services include but are not limited to:
- Public involvement,
- Various analysis (e.g. storm drainage, traffic, etc.),
- Conceptual plans, and
- Cost estimates.
§ On February 17, 2014, a Request for Qualifications (RFQ) was advertised for advanced preliminary
planning to begin work on the 2014 Community Investment Plan.
- On April 28, 2014, City Council approved two contracts each in the amount of $175,000 to
Kimley-Horn and Associates, Inc. and URS Inc. (now AECOM) for sidewalk and bikeway
improvement projects. As a part of these contracts, the City included an option to continue
services with the selected consultants as incentive for good performance.
§ AECOM Technical Services of North Carolina, Inc., and Kimley-Horn and Associates, Inc. are the
best qualified firms to meet the City’s needs.
Action A
§ The contract with AECOM Technical Services of North Carolina, Inc. will provide planning for 5.64
miles of sidewalk with two projects identified in the Independence Boulevard Sidewalk and Bike
Facilities-North:
- North Ped Bike Boulevard - Independence Boulevard Area Project (paralleling Independence
Boulevard from Morningside Drive to the proposed Campbell Creek greenway, 4.75 miles).
- Eastway Drive/Wendover Road Connector (Woodland Drive to Monroe Road, .89 miles).
Action B
§ The contract with Kimley-Horn and Associates, Inc. will provide planning services for 4.37 miles of
sidewalk with two projects identified in the Independence Boulevard Sidewalk and Bike
Facilities-South:
- South Ped Bike Boulevard - Independence Boulevard Area Project (paralleling Independence
Boulevard from Briar Creek Greenway to Mason Wallace Park, 3.8 miles).
- Briar Creek Road Connector (Commonwealth Avenue to Monroe Road, .57 miles).
City of Charlotte Page 30 Printed on 4/22/2017
City Council Business Meeting Meeting Agenda April 24, 2017
Charlotte Business INClusion
AECOM:
The City negotiates subcontracting participation after the proposal selection process (Part C: Section 2.1
(h) of the Charlotte Business INClusion Policy). AECOM has committed 13.75% ($97,584) of the total
contract amount to the following certified firms:
§ Neighboring Concepts (MBE) ($33,196) (land development)
§ CES Group Engineers (SBE, WBE) ($29,510) (civil engineering)
§ CMW Design Strategies (SBE) ($26,372) (urban planning)
§ Joel E Wood & Associates (SBE) ($8,506) (geotechnical)
Kimley-Horn & Associates
The City negotiates subcontracting participation after the proposal selection process (Part C: Section 2.1
(h) of the Charlotte Business INClusion Policy). Kimley-Horn has committed 23.57% ($98,655) of the total
contract amount to the following certified firms:
§ CES Group Engineers (SBE, WBE) ($42,000) (survey/mapping)
§ Hinde Engineering (SBE) ($30,320) (planning)
§ Amy K Steinmetz (SBE) ($15,000) (community engagement)
§ Boyle Consulting Engineers (SBE) ($11,335) (geotechnical)
Fiscal Note
Funding: General Transportation Community Investment Plan
Attachment(s)
Map
Location Map - Independence Boulevard Sidewalk and Bike Facilities
City of Charlotte Page 31 Printed on 4/22/2017
City Council Business Meeting Meeting Agenda April 24, 2017
25. Oracle Products and Related Services
Action:
A. Approve the purchase of Oracle products and related services from cooperative
purchasing contracts as authorized by G.S. 143-129(e)(3),
B. Approve a contract with Mythics, Inc. for the purchase of Oracle products and related
services for a term of two years under National Intergovernmental Purchasing Alliance
contract #R141801, effective January 1, 2015,
C. Approve a contract with DLT Solutions LLC for the purchase of Oracle products and
related services for a term of two years under the United States Communities contract
#13120, effective April 23, 2014, and
D. Authorize the City Manager to extend the contract for as long as the cooperative
contracts are in effect, at prices and terms that are the same or more favorable than
those offered under the cooperative contracts.
Staff Resource(s):
Randy Harrington, Management and Financial Services
Jeff Stovall, Innovation and Technology
Kay Elmore, Management and Financial Services
Cooperative Purchasing Exemption
NC S.L. 2001-328, effective January 1, 2002, authorizes competitive group purchasing.
Explanation
§ The City requires professional services for Oracle products, including software implementation
services, in connection with regular software upgrades and other special projects. These services
may be performed directly by Mythics, Inc. or DLT Solutions, LLC.
- Mythics, Inc. has a contract awarded through National Intergovernmental Purchasing
Alliance.
- DLT Solutions, LLC has a contract awarded through the U.S. Communities.
§ The companies will be paid the prices set forth in the contract, copies of which are available
upon request.
§ Annual expenditures are estimated to be $800,000, including the expenses for the ongoing
PeopleSoft maintenance and support services.
Charlotte Business INClusion
These are cooperative purchasing contracts and are exempt (Part A: Appendix 27 of the Charlotte
Business INClusion Policy).
Fiscal Note
Funding: Various Departments’ Operating Budgets
City of Charlotte Page 32 Printed on 4/22/2017
City Council Business Meeting Meeting Agenda April 24, 2017
26. American Airlines Sprinkler System Reimbursement
Action:
Approve a reimbursement agreement with American Airlines for design and installation services
for a fire suppression sprinkler system.
Staff Resource(s):
Brent Cagle, Aviation
Explanation
§ American Airlines’ leased space on the ramp level of Concourse B is being renovated.
§ A fire suppression sprinkler system needs to be installed in order for the building to meet current
code requirements.
§ American Airlines has agreed to pay for design and installation services.
§ Aviation will reimburse American Airlines for the cost of the work, which is estimated at
approximately $120,000.
Fiscal Note
Funding: Aviation Community Investment Plan
City of Charlotte Page 33 Printed on 4/22/2017
City Council Business Meeting Meeting Agenda April 24, 2017
27. Aviation Passenger Loading Bridge Baggage Slide Contract
Action:
A. Approve the purchase of Passenger Loading Bridge Baggage Slides as authorized by the
sole source exemption of G.S. 143-129 (e)(6), and
B. Approve a contract with PAGE Industries, Inc. for the purchase of Passenger Loading
Bridge Baggage Slides for the term of three years, and
C. Authorize the City Manager to renew the contract for up to two, one-year terms with
possible price adjustments and to amend the contract within scope to meet business
needs.
Staff Resource(s):
Brent Cagle, Aviation
Sole Source Exemption
§ G.S. 143-129 (e) (6) provides that formal bidding requirements do not apply when:
- Performance or price competition are not available;
- A needed product is available from only one source or supply; or
- Standardization or compatibility is the overriding consideration.
§ Sole sourcing is necessary for this contract because there is a need to standardize the baggage
slides to reduce replacement part inventory costs.
§ The City Council must approve purchases made under the sole source exception.
Explanation
§ Aviation outfits passenger boarding bridges with baggage slides so airlines can quickly move
luggage and other passenger bags to and from the aircraft.
§ PAGE Industries, Inc. will provide baggage slides, including replacement components to use for
repairs.
§ The company will be paid the unit prices set forth in the contract, a copy of which is available upon
request.
§ Annual expenditures under the contract are estimated to be $50,000.
Charlotte Business INClusion
This is a sole source contract and is exempt (Part A: Appendix 1.27 of the Charlotte Business INClusion
Policy).
Fiscal Note
Funding: Aviation Operating Budget
City of Charlotte Page 34 Printed on 4/22/2017
City Council Business Meeting Meeting Agenda April 24, 2017
28. Airport Joint Operations Center
Action:
A. Approve a contract in the amount of $1,432,770 to RS&H Architects-Engineers-Planners,
Inc. for design services for a Joint Operation Center, and
B. Adopt a budget ordinance appropriating $1,432,770 from the Aviation Discretionary Fund
to the Aviation Community Investment Plan Fund.
Staff Resource(s):
Brent Cagle, Aviation
Explanation
§ The Department of Homeland Security provided a nationwide recommendation that all airports
establish Joint Operations Centers (JOC).
§ The primary purpose of a JOC is to serve as an airport’s emergency coordination center to manage
security, incident response, as well as day-to-day airport operations.
§ The JOC will accommodate airport operations and security, local and federal law enforcement,
airlines, and the Transportation Security Administration.
§ Aviation selected RS&H Architects-Engineers-Planners, Inc. for this project based on its expertise in
the design of large aviation facilities.
§ Design is expected to take approximately eight months and construction will take approximately
18 months.
§ This project is included in the approved Aviation Community Investment Plan.
Charlotte Business INClusion
The City negotiates subcontracting participation after the proposal selection process (Part C: Section
2.1(h) of the Charlotte Business INClusion Policy).
RS&H Architects-Engineers-Planners, Inc. has committed 12.54% ($179,600) of the total contract amount
to the following certified firms:
§ System WorCx, PLLC (SBE) ($122,100) (LEED consulting)
§ Capstone Civil Engineering, Inc. (SBE, MBE) ($50,000) (subsurface investigation)
§ SikesDesign, PLLC (SBE) ($7,500) (landscape design)
Fiscal Note
Funding: Aviation Community Investment Plan
Attachment(s)
Budget Ordinance
Airport ORD042417 - Airport Joint Communications Center
City of Charlotte Page 35 Printed on 4/22/2017
City Council Business Meeting Meeting Agenda April 24, 2017
29. CATS Express Bus and Institution Shuttle Services
Action:
A. Approve the renewal of Cost Sharing agreements for the Express Bus and Shuttle
Services with the following cities, county, institution, and business:
- City of Concord, NC,
- City of Gastonia, NC,
- City of Rock Hill, SC,
- Union County NC,
- Wells Fargo,
- Carowinds,
B. Authorize the City Manager to execute four additional, one-year contract renewals, and
C. Authorize the City Manager to modify or terminate the agreements.
Staff Resource(s):
John Lewis, CATS
Pamela White, CATS
Explanation
§ CATS operates express and LYNX shuttle bus services to four counties surrounding Mecklenburg
County. The current contracts for these services will expire in June 2017.
§ These services reduce single-occupancy vehicles on roadways, which helps with congestion and air
quality initiatives across the region.
§ As part of the Metropolitan Transit Commission adopted policies, Concord, Gastonia, Rock Hill, and
Union County will reimburse the City for 50% of the net operating expense (including overhead)
for regional express bus services between their respective jurisdictions and Uptown Charlotte.
§ The Carowinds services shuttles youth and other Mecklenburg County residents to employment
opportunities at Carowinds and businesses surrounding Carowinds.
§ The Wells Fargo extension to route 42X, shuttles employees to the York County Wells Fargo offices.
§ Wells Fargo will reimburse the City for 100 percent of the net operating expense (including
overhead) for the extension of bus route services to that institution. Carowinds, CATS, and
Housing and Neighborhood Services will equally contribute for the net operating expense (including
overhead) for the bus route services to Carowinds.
§ These services provided over 160,000 rides in fiscal year 2016.
§ Regional Express Service and partner cost are as follows:
- City of Concord: $97,538.76
- City of Gastonia: $98,157
- City of Rock Hill: $124,157
- Union County: $126,394.88
- Wells Fargo: $8,325.76
- Carowinds: $37,960.89
Charlotte Business INClusion
These contracts are interlocal agreements and no competitive process agreements; and are exempt (part
A: Appendix 1.23.8 and 1.23.2 of the Charlotte Business Inclusion Policy).
Fiscal Note
Funding: CATS Operating Budget
City of Charlotte Page 36 Printed on 4/22/2017
City Council Business Meeting Meeting Agenda April 24, 2017
30. Charlotte Water Corrosion Protection Services
Action:
A. Approve a unit price contract with Pond and Company for design, testing, inspection, and
repair of corrosion control systems related to water and sanitary sewer system
throughout Mecklenburg County for an initial term of one year, and
B. Authorize the City Manager to renew the contract up to two additional, one-year terms
with possible price adjustments and to amend the contract consistent with the City’s
business needs and the purpose for which the contract was approved.
Staff Resource(s):
Barry Gullet, Charlotte Water
Carl Wilson, Charlotte Water
Explanation
§ Corrosion control is needed to prevent the deterioration of metal pipe, metallic pipe components,
or metallic pipeline accessories caused by reactions between the metal and corrosive soils or
sources of stray current.
§ To address specific corrosion-related issues, studies are performed at individual project sites to
measure the risk of corrosion and allow for custom designed protective systems. The specific type
of system will depend on the kind of pipe material being used and the severity of the surrounding
environment.
§ The contract with Pond and Company will provide services for the following items:
- Appropriate corrosion control measures for proposed and existing water and sewer pipelines
and facilities, including field and laboratory analysis,
- Development of specifications, plans, and details for specific utility projects,
- Corrosion control system field inspection services, analysis, and performance of minor
repairs and maintenance-related work on existing corrosion protection systems, and
- Construction phase inspection services.
§ On February 3, 2017, the City issued a Request for Qualifications (RFQ) for Professional
Engineering Services for Miscellaneous Corrosion Control Design, Inspection and Monitoring. In
response to the RFQ, the City received three proposals from interested professional service
providers.
§ Pond and Company is the best qualified firm to meet the City’s needs on the basis of demonstrated
competence and qualification of professional services in response to the RFQ requirements.
§ Estimated expenditures are $150,000 annually.
Charlotte Business INClusion
No subcontracting goal was established for this contract because there are no subcontracting
opportunities (Part C: Section 2.1(a) of the Charlotte Business INClusion Policy).
Fiscal Note
Funding: Charlotte Water Community Investment Plan
City of Charlotte Page 37 Printed on 4/22/2017
City Council Business Meeting Meeting Agenda April 24, 2017
31. Resolution of Intent to Abandon a Portion of an Alleyway off
of Keeter Drive
Action:
A. Adopt a Resolution of Intent to Abandon a portion of an alleyway off of Keeter Drive, and
B. Set a public hearing for May 22, 2017.
Staff Resource(s):
Danny Pleasant, Transportation
Jeff Boenisch, Transportation
Explanation
§ A portion of an alleyway off of Keeter Drive is located in Council District 3.
Attachment(s)
Map
Resolution
CityCouncilROWAbandonmentMap_2017-04
Resolution of Intent to Close a portion of an alleyway off of Keeter Drive
32. Resolution of Intent to Abandon a Portion of Booker Avenue
Action:
A. Adopt a Resolution of Intent to Abandon a portion of Booker Avenue, and
B. Set a public hearing for May 22, 2017.
Staff Resource(s):
Danny Pleasant, Transportation
Jeff Boenisch, Transportation
Explanation
§ A portion of Booker Avenue is located in Council District 2.
Attachment(s)
Map
Resolution
CityCouncilROWAbandonmentMap_2017-01
Resolution of Intent to Close a portion of Booker Avenue
City of Charlotte Page 38 Printed on 4/22/2017
City Council Business Meeting Meeting Agenda April 24, 2017
33. Refund of Property and Business Privilege License Taxes
Action:
A. Adopt a resolution authorizing the refund of property taxes assessed through clerical or
assessment error in the amount of $44,089.50, and
B. Adopt a resolution authorizing the refund of business privilege license payments in the
amount of $35.00.
Staff Resource(s):
Randy Harrington, Management and Financial Services
Mark Goodman, Management and Financial Services
Explanation
§ Mecklenburg County notified and provided the City the list of Property Tax and Business Privilege
License Tax refunds due to clerical or assessment error.
Attachment(s)
Taxpayers and Refunds Requested
Business Privilege License Refunds Requested
Resolution Property Tax Refunds
Resolution Business Privilege License Refunds
List of Taxpayers and Refunds Requested
List of Business Privilege License Refunds
Resolution
Resolution Bus
34. Meeting Minutes
Action:
Approve the titles, motions, and votes reflected in the Clerk’s record as the minutes of:
- March 22, 2017, Budget Workshop
- March 27, 2017, Business Meeting
- April 03, 2017, Workshop
Staff Resource(s):
Stephanie Kelly, City Clerk’s Office
City of Charlotte Page 39 Printed on 4/22/2017
City Council Business Meeting Meeting Agenda April 24, 2017
Adjournment
City of Charlotte Page 40 Printed on 4/22/2017