Columbus City Council
Regular MeetingColumbus, OH · September 14, 2009
Minutes
Office of City Clerk
City of Columbus 90 West Broad Street
Columbus OH
43215-9015
columbuscitycouncil.org
Minutes - Final
Columbus City Council
ELECTRONIC READING OF MEETING DOCUMENTS
AVAILABLE DURING COUNCIL OFFICE HOURS. CLOSED
CAPTIONING IS AVAILABLE IN COUNCIL CHAMBERS. ANY
OTHER SPECIAL NEEDS REQUESTS SHOULD BE DIRECTED
TO THE CITY CLERK'S OFFICE AT 645-7380 BY FRIDAY
PRIOR TO THE COUNCIL MEETING.
Monday, September 14, 2009 5:00 PM City Council Chambers, Rm 231
REGULAR MEETING NO. 40 OF COLUMBUS CITY COUNCIL, SEPTEMBER
14, 2009 at 5:00 P.M. IN COUNCIL CHAMBERS.
ROLL CALL
Present: 7 - Andrew Ginther, Charleta Tavares, Hearcel Craig, Priscilla Tyson, Michael
Mentel, A. Troy Miller, and Eileen Paley
READING AND DISPOSAL OF THE JOURNAL
A motion was made by President Pro-Tem Craig, seconded by Ginther, to
Dispense with the reading of the Journal and Approve. The motion carried by
the following vote:
Affirmative: 7- Andrew Ginther, Charleta Tavares, Hearcel Craig, Priscilla Tyson, Michael
Mentel, A. Troy Miller, and Eileen Paley
C0023-2009 THE FOLLOWING COMMUNICATIONS WERE RECEIVED IN THE
CITY CLERK'S OFFICE AS OF WEDNESDAY SEPTEMBER 9, 2009:
New Type: C1, C2
To: Lofinos Columbus Foods Inc
DBA Save A Lot
677 Harrisburg Pike
Columbus OH 43223
Permit # 52450680015
New Type: C1, C2
To: Lofinos Columbus Foods II LLC
DBA Save A Lot
1254 Morse Rd
Columbus OH 43229
Permit # 5245073
New Type: C1, C2
To: Lofinos Columbus Foods Inc
DBA Save A Lot
City of Columbus Page 1
Columbus City Council Minutes - Final September 14, 2009
154 N Wilson Rd
Columbus OH 43204
Permit # 52450680005
New Type: C1, C2
To: Lofinos Columbus Foods II LLC
DBA Save A Lot
1179 E Main St
Columbus OH 43205
Permit # 52450730005
New Type: C1, C2
To: Lofinos Columbus Foods Inc
DBA Save A Lot
2054 Lockbourne Rd
Columbus OH 43207
Permit # 52450680010
Transfer Type: D1
To: Quezadiaz Inc
2159 N High St
Columbus OH 43201
From: Donatos Pizzeria LLC
DBA Donatos
5525 New Albany Rd E
Columbus OH 43054
Permit # 7138021
Transfer Type: D1, D3, D3A, D6
To: TNT Repose LLC
DBA Somewhere Else
1312 S High St & Patio
Columbus OH 43206
From: Somewhere Else TNT LLC
Martin Management Services Inc Rcvr
DBA Somewhere Else
1312 S High St & Patio
Columbus OH 43206
Permit # 8774047
Transfer Type: D5, D6
To: GMRI Inc
DBA Olive Garden Italian Restaurant 1820
4860 N Hamilton Rd
Columbus OH 43230
From: Rare Hospitality International Inc
City of Columbus Page 2
Columbus City Council Minutes - Final September 14, 2009
DBA Longhorn Steakhouse
2520 E Dublin Granville Rd
Columbus OH 43231
Permit # 32385120595
Stock Type: D5, D6
To: Mi Mexico Inc
DBA Mi Mexico Restaurant
4775 E Main St
Columbus OH 43213
Permit # 60230810001
Advertise: 09/19/2009
Return: 09/28/2009
RESOLUTIONS OF EXPRESSION
MILLER
0133X-2009 To Honor And Recognize The Bishop Hartley's Girls Track & Field
Team For Winning The 2009 Division II Girls Track State
Championship.
A motion was made by Miller, seconded by Tyson, that this matter be
Adopted. The motion carried by the following vote:
Affirmative: 7- Andrew Ginther, Charleta Tavares, Hearcel Craig, Priscilla Tyson, Michael
Mentel, A. Troy Miller, and Eileen Paley
PALEY
0138X-2009 To recognize the Columbus Department of Public Utilities' Southerly
Wastewater Treatment Plant staff for winning the National Association
of Clean Water Agencies (NACWA) Platinum Peak Performance
Award.
A motion was made by Paley, seconded by Ginther, that this matter be
Adopted. The motion carried by the following vote:
Affirmative: 7- Andrew Ginther, Charleta Tavares, Hearcel Craig, Priscilla Tyson, Michael
Mentel, A. Troy Miller, and Eileen Paley
TYSON
0139X-2009 To proclaim the month of September as Sickle Cell Disease
Awareness Month in the City of Columbus.
A motion was made by Tyson, seconded by Tavares, that this matter be
Adopted. The motion carried by the following vote:
City of Columbus Page 3
Columbus City Council Minutes - Final September 14, 2009
Affirmative: 7- Andrew Ginther, Charleta Tavares, Hearcel Craig, Priscilla Tyson, Michael
Mentel, A. Troy Miller, and Eileen Paley
ADDITIONS OR CORRECTIONS TO THE AGENDA
FR FIRST READING OF 30-DAY LEGISLATION
A MOTION WAS MADE BY COUNCILMEMBER PALEY, SECONDED BY
COUNCILMEMBER TYSON TO WAIVE THE READING OF THE TITLES OF
FIRST READING LEGISLATION. THE MOTION CARRIED THE FOLLOWING
VOTE: AFFIRMATIVE: 7 NEGATIVE: 0
FINANCE: MENTEL, CHR. TAVARES CRAIG PALEY
FR 1035-2009 To authorize the Office of the City Auditor, Division of Income Tax to
modify an existing contract for temporary services with Abacus
Corporation to allow rate of pay adjustments based upon the
employee's experience and/or time in service.
SAFETY : GINTHER, CHR. PALEY CRAIG MENTEL
FR 1166-2009 To authorize and direct the Mayor of the City of Columbus to accept a
COPS Hiring Recovery Program Grant from the U.S. Department of
Justice, Office of Community Oriented Policing Services through the
2009 American Recovery and Reinvestment Act, to authorize an
appropriation of the grant award amount of $12,742,800.00 from the
unappropriated balance of the General Government Grant Fund to the
Division of Police for the approved grant expenditures.
($12,742,800.00)
DEVELOPMENT: GINTHER, CHR. CRAIG TYSON MENTEL
FR 1145-2009 To adopt the Livingston East Area Plan as a guide for development,
redevelopment, and planning of future public improvements.
UTILITIES: PALEY, CHR. CRAIG GINTHER MENTEL
FR 0976-2009 To authorize the Director of Public Utilities to execute a planned
contract modification of the construction administration - construction
inspection services agreement with DLZ Ohio, Inc., for additional
inspection services for the Stanton Area Sewer Improvements for an
extended construction phase; to authorize the transfer and
appropriation of $26,869.35 from the Sanitary Sewer Reserve Bond
Fund to the Voted Sanitary Sewer Bond Fund; to authorize the
expenditure of $ 26,869.35 from within the Voted Sanitary Sewer
City of Columbus Page 4
Columbus City Council Minutes - Final September 14, 2009
Bond Fund; to amend the 2009 Capital Improvements Budget, for the
Division of Sewerage and Drainage. ($26,869.35)
FR 1050-2009 To authorize and direct the Finance and Management Director to
enter into a contract for the purchase of Luminaires with General
Supply and Services, Inc. dba Gexpro for the Division of Power and
Water and to authorize the expenditure of $222,448.00 from the
Electricity Operating Fund. ($222,448.00)
FR 1062-2009 To authorize the Director of Public Utilities to enter into a planned
modification ("Phase 2") to modify the maximum monetary obligation
under the Environmental Management Development and
Implementation Assistance contract with GSP/OH, Inc., for the
Division of Power and Water and Division of Sewerage and Drainage,
to authorize the expenditure of $150,000.00 from Water Systems
Operating Fund, and $150,000.00 from the Sewer Systems Operating
Fund. ($300,000.00)
FR 1064-2009 To authorize the Director of Finance and Management to establish a
purchase order with W.M. Wilson Company Inc. for the purchase of
Adsco Expansion Joints for the Division of Sewerage and Drainage,
and to authorize the expenditure of $22,074.00 from the Sewerage
System Operating Fund. ($22,074.00)
FR 1065-2009 To authorize the Director of Finance and Management to enter into a
purchase order with Ace Truck Body, Inc. for the purchase of an
Eleven Foot Dump Body with Attachments for the Division of Power
and Water and to authorize the expenditure of $27,671.00 from the
Water Operating Fund. ($27,671.00)
FR 1074-2009 To authorize the Director of Finance and Management to establish a
purchase order for the purchase of one Combination Sewer Cleaner in
accordance with a State of Ohio contract with Jack Doheny Supplies
Ohio Inc for the Division of Sewerage and Drainage, and to authorize
the expenditure of $307,844.90 from the Sewerage System Operating
Fund. ($307,844.90)
FR 1080-2009 To authorize the Director of Public Utilities to enter into a cooperative
agreement with the Geological Survey, United States Department of
Interior, for Investigation of Water Resources in Central Ohio, and
Ground Water Levels in Franklin County for the Division of Power and
Water, and the Scioto River at Columbus for the Division of Sewerage
and Drainage; and to authorize the expenditure of $345,051.00 from
the Sewer System Operating Fund, Storm Sewer Operating Fund, and
the Water System Operating Fund. ($345,051.00)
FR 1083-2009 To authorize the Director of Finance and Management to establish a
purchase order with Anderson Concrete Corporation for the purchase
City of Columbus Page 5
Columbus City Council Minutes - Final September 14, 2009
of Ready Mix Concrete for the Division of Sewerage and Drainage,
and to authorize the expenditure of $10,000.00 from the Sewerage
System Operating Fund. ($10,000.00)
FR 1084-2009 To authorize the Finance and Management Director to establish a
Blanket Purchase Order for water meters and appurtenances from
Universal Term Contracts with Badger Meter Inc. and Hersey Meters
Co., LLC for the Division of Power and Water; and to authorize the
expenditure of $250,000.00 from Water Systems Operating Fund.
($250,000.00)
FR 1087-2009 To authorize the Director of Finance and Management to establish a
purchase order with Vulcan Industries Inc. for the purchase of a
Vulcan Screening Press Unit for the Division of Sewerage and
Drainage, and to authorize the expenditure of $29,045.00 from the
Sewerage System Operating Fund. ($29,045.00)
FR 1089-2009 To authorize the Director of Finance and Management to enter into a
purchase order with Fyda Freightliner Columbus, Inc. for the purchase
of a Tandem Axle Conventional Dump Truck for the Division of Power
and Water and to authorize the expenditure of $110,025.00 from the
Water Operating Fund. ($110,025.00)
FR 1091-2009 To authorize the Director of Public Utilities to execute a planned
modification of an existing contract with the Paul Peterson Company
to obtain traffic control services for the Division of Power and Water;
and to authorize the expenditure of $20,000.00 from the Electricity
Operating Fund. ($20,000.00)
FR 1112-2009 To authorize the Director of Public Utilities to execute a planned
contract modification (#2) for professional engineering services with
Camp, Dresser, McKee, Inc., in connection with the Sewer System
Capacity Model Update; to authorize the appropriation and transfer of
$2,627,494.32 from the Sanitary Sewer Reserve Fund to the Voted
Sanitary Sewer Bond Fund; to authorize the appropriation of $360.00
and the transfer of $127,307.62 within the Voted Sanitary Sewer Bond
Fund; to authorize the expenditure of $2,754,801.94 within the Voted
Sanitary Sewer Bond Fund; and to amend the 2009 Capital
Improvements Budget, for the Division of Sewerage and Drainage.
($2,754,801.94)
FR 1113-2009 To authorize the Finance and Management Director to establish
Blanket Purchase Orders with various companies for the purchase of
water meters and appurtenances for the Division of Power and Water;
to authorize the appropriation and transfer of $80,178.20 from the
Water System Reserve Fund to the Water Works Enlargement Voted
Bonds Fund; and to authorize the expenditure of $80,178.20 from the
Water Works Enlargement Voted Bonds Fund for the Division of
City of Columbus Page 6
Columbus City Council Minutes - Final September 14, 2009
Power and Water. ($80,178.20)
FR 1120-2009 To authorize the encumbrance of funds for the Transportation Division
of the City of Columbus; to authorize the City Auditor to transfer and
appropriate $289,598.25 from the Sanitary Sewer Reserve Fund to
the Voted Sanitary Bond Fund; to authorize the expenditure of
$289,598.25 from the Voted Sanitary Bond Fund; and to amend the
2009 Capital Improvements Budget, for the inspection, testing, and
prevailing wage coordination services for the River South Phase II
Rich Street Sanitary Redirect Sewer and Front Street, Main Street &
Ludlow Street Project; ($289,598.25).
FR 1123-2009 To authorize the Director of Public Utilities to execute a contract with
Nickolas Savko & Sons, Inc. for construction of the Doherty Road
Water Line Improvements Project; to provide for inspection and other
related services to the Transportation Division; to authorize the
appropriation and transfer of $446,356.31 from the Water System
Reserve Fund to the Ohio Water Development Authority (OWDA)
Fund; to authorize the appropriation and expenditure of $446,356.31
from the Ohio Water Development Authority (OWDA) Fund; and to
authorize an amendment to the 2009 Capital Improvements Budget.
($446,356.31)
FR 1128-2009 To authorize the Director of Finance and Management to establish a
Blanket Purchase Order with Neenah Foundry Company from an
established Universal Term Contract for the purchase of Construction
Castings for the Division of Sewerage and Drainage, and to authorize
the expenditure of $75,000.00 from the Sewerage System Operating
Fund. ($75,000.00)
FR 1148-2009 To authorize the Director of Public Utilities to enter into an agreement
with JD Power Systems LLC for the removal, transport and
installation of a 75 KW generator for the Division of Sewerage and
Drainage and to authorize the expenditure of $32,499.00 from the
Sewerage System Operating Fund. ($32,499.00)
HEALTH, HOUSING & HUMAN SVC'S TAVARES, CHR. TYSON MILLER
MENTEL
FR 1156-2009 To amend Ordinance 0472-2009, passed April 6, 2009, creating the
Petzinger Road Community Reinvestment Area for the purpose of
including language from the Ohio Revised Code as well as the
inclusion of an additional Section designating the Development
Department's Housing Administrator as the designated Housing
Officer.
FR 1170-2009 To authorize the Director of the Department of Development to enter
into various contracts for the provision of homebuyer education
City of Columbus Page 7
Columbus City Council Minutes - Final September 14, 2009
services; and to authorize the expenditure of $250,000 from the
General Government Grant Fund. ($250,000.00)
RULES & REFERENCE: MENTEL, CHR. GINTHER CRAIG PALEY
FR 1088-2009 To amend Section 1163.03 of the Columbus City Code, 1959, to
adjust the base used in calculating the Power Cost Reserve
Adjustment in the Municipal Electric Rates.
ZONING: TYSON, CHR. CRAIG GINTHER MILLER PALEY TAVARES
MENTEL
FR 0797-2009 To grant a Variance from the provisions of Section 3332.037, R-2F,
Residential District, of the Columbus City Codes for the property
located at 1389 EAST FRANKFUORT STREET (43206), to permit two
existing single-family dwellings on one lot in the R-2F, Residential
District and to declare an emergency. (Council Variance #CV09-010).
FR 1132-2009 To rezone 7324 SKYLINE DRIVE EAST (43235), being 7.01± acres
located at the northeast and northwest corners of Skyline Drive East
and Snouffer Road, From: L-AR-12, Limited Apartment Residential
District, To L-C-4, Limited Commercial District and to declare an
emergency (Rezoning # Z09-014).
CA CONSENT ACTIONS
RESOLUTIONS OF EXPRESSION:
CRAIG
CA 0136X-2009 To honor and recognize Grohio and the Mid-Ohio Regional Planning
Commission.
A motion was made by Ginther, seconded by Miller, that this matter be
Adopted. The motion carried by the following vote:
Abstained: 1- Charleta Tavares
Affirmative: 6- Andrew Ginther, Hearcel Craig, Priscilla Tyson, Michael Mentel, A. Troy
Miller, and Eileen Paley
FINANCE: MENTEL, CHR. TAVARES CRAIG PALEY
CA 1032-2009 To authorize and direct the City Auditor to contract for professional
auditing services with Premiere Accounting Solutions, Inc., CPA's, for
the audits of 10 of the City's subgrantees having a total of 22
contracts, totaling more than $2.3 million and to authorize the
expenditure of $13,520 and to declare an emergency. ($13,520.00)
City of Columbus Page 8
Columbus City Council Minutes - Final September 14, 2009
CA 1106-2009 To authorize and direct the Finance and Management Director to
enter into one (1) contract for the option to purchase OEM Motorcycle
Parts from C & A Harley Davidson, Inc., to authorize the expenditure
of one (1) dollar to establish the contract from the Mail, Print Services
and UTC Fund; and to declare an emergency. ($1.00)
PUBLIC SERVICE & TRANSPORTATION: CRAIG, CHR. MILLER TAVARES
MENTEL
CA 0988-2009 To authorize the Director of Public Service to pay American Electric
Power Company for utility relocation costs incurred in conjunction with
the Lane Avenue Widening Project for the Division of Design and
Construction; to amend the 2009 C.I.B.; and to authorize the
expenditure of $178,500.00 from the Streets and Highways G.O.
Bonds Fund. ($178,500.00)
CA 1031-2009 To Authorize the Director of Public Service to enter into a grant
agreement with the Central Ohio Transit Authority (COTA) and to
receive grant funds up to the amount of $159,206.00 for the Division
of Mobility Options for the Obetz Road Sidewalk Project.
CA 1067-2009 To authorize the Director of Public Service to submit applications for
Round 24 of the Local Transportation Improvement Program and
State Capital Improvement Program and to execute project agreement
forms for approved projects for the Department of Public Service on
behalf of the City of Columbus, and to authorize the Director of
Finance and Management and City Auditor, as appropriate, to sign for
funding use certification, local match availability, and to certify loan
portion repayment; and to declare an emergency. ($0.00)
CA 1071-2009 To accept the plat titled "Upper Albany West Section 4", from M/I
Homes Of Central Ohio, LLC, an Ohio limited liability company, by
Lloyd T. Simpson, Senior Vice President Land-Midwest Region; and to
declare an emergency.
CA 1072-2009 To accept the plat titled "Easton Square Place Extension Section 1
Dedication and Easements", from Morso Holding Co., a Delaware
corporation, by Gail M. Stern, Senior Vice President - Business and
Development, Legal; and to declare an emergency.
CA 1086-2009 To accept the plat titled "Reynolds Crossing Section 1 Part 2", from
Dominion Homes, Inc., an Ohio Corporation, by Matthew J. Callahan,
Vice President Land Development; and to declare an emergency.
CA 1109-2009 To authorize transfer of $92,982.25 between minor object levels and
the additional appropriation of $117,713.50 within the Municipal Motor
Vehicle License Tax Fund for the purpose of providing payment for
City of Columbus Page 9
Columbus City Council Minutes - Final September 14, 2009
utilities for the Division of Planning and Operations; and to declare an
emergency. ($210,695.75)
SAFETY : GINTHER, CHR. PALEY CRAIG MENTEL
CA 1107-2009 To authorize the Finance and Management Director to enter into
contracts for miscellaneous capital improvement renovations for the
Division of Police; to amend the 2009 Capital Improvement Budget; to
authorize the expenditure of $50,000.00 from the Safety Voted Bond
Fund; and to declare an emergency. ($50,000.00)
CA 1136-2009 To authorize and direct the Director of Finance and Management, on
behalf of the Division of Support Services, to execute those
documents necessary for the purchase of 500 Motorola P25 Flash
Upgrades for XTS5000 Radios for those first responders within the
Metropolitan Statistical Area (MSA) from an established UTC with
Motorola, Inc. utilizing Homeland Security Grant Funds; and to declare
an emergency. ($0.00)
DEVELOPMENT: GINTHER, CHR. CRAIG TYSON MENTEL
CA 0741-2009 To amend the 2009 CIB; to authorize the transfer of cash between
projects within the same fund; to authorize the Director of
Development to enter into a Guaranteed Maximum Price
Reimbursement Agreement under Section 186 of the Columbus City
Charter with NWD Investments, LLC to complete outstanding
improvements in the Arena District; and to authorize the expenditure
of $35,316.80 from the Northland and Other Acquisitions Fund.
($35,316.80)
CA 1188-2009 To set forth a statement of municipal services and zoning conditions to
be provided to the area contained in a proposed annexation
(AN09-005) of 11.457+ Acres in Prairie Township to the city of
Columbus as required by the Ohio Revised Code; and to declare an
emergency.
CA 1190-2009 To authorize the Director of the Department of Development, or his
designee, to sign various loan documents on CDBG, UDAG and USAL
repayment loans closed prior to June 21, 2004 on behalf of the City of
Columbus in connection with the Economic Development Loan
Program; and to declare an emergency.
ADMINISTRATION: MILLER, CHR. PALEY TAVARES MENTEL
CA 1014-2009 To authorize the Director of the Department of Technology and the
Director of the Department of Public Utilities to modify and extend an
annual renewal agreement with Oracle USA, Inc. to provide computer
City of Columbus Page 10
Columbus City Council Minutes - Final September 14, 2009
programming software maintenance on the SPL/WAM system; to
authorize the expenditure of $59,935.78 from the Department of
Technology Internal Service Fund; and to declare an emergency.
($59,935.78)
CA 1053-2009 To authorize the Director of Finance and Management, on behalf of
the Department of Technology, to establish a purchase order with
Ipitek, for the purchase of Digital Video Transmission System
Equipment; and to authorize the expenditure of $68,420.00 from the
Information Services Fund; and to declare an emergency.
($68,420.00)
CA 1117-2009 To authorize the Director of Finance and Management, on behalf of
the Department of Technology, to establish a purchase order with
AT&T for data transport services and local telephone services; and to
authorize the expenditure of $125,000.00 from the Department of
Technology Information Services Fund; and to declare an emergency.
($125,000.00)
CA 1138-2009 To authorize the City Treasurer to modify the existing contract for
credit card processing services with Huntington Merchant Services; to
authorize the expenditure of $31,000 from the General Fund; to
authorize the expenditure of $50,000 from the Development Services
Fund; and to declare an emergency. ($81,000.00)
JUDICIARY & COURT ADMINISTRATION: PALEY, CHR. CRAIG TYSON
MENTEL
CA 1078-2009 To authorize and direct the City Auditor to appropriate and transfer
$100,000 from the Indigent Drivers Alcohol Treatment Fund to the
Municipal Court Special Programs Specialty Docket; and to declare an
emergency. ($100,000)
CA 1085-2009 To authorize and direct the City Auditor to act as the City of Columbus'
authorized representative for the purpose of complying with the
mandatory reporting requirements of Section 111 of the Medicare,
Medicaid, and State Children's Health Insurance Plan Extension Act of
2007; and to declare an emergency.
CA 1092-2009 To authorize the Municipal Court Clerk to modify and extend the
contract with Capital Recovery Systems, Inc. for the provision of
collection services; to authorize an expenditure up to $20,000.00 from
the Clerk's collection fund; and to declare an emergency. ($20,000.00)
A motion was made by Ginther, seconded by Miller, that this matter be
Approved. The motion carried by the following vote:
Abstained: 1- Eileen Paley
City of Columbus Page 11
Columbus City Council Minutes - Final September 14, 2009
Affirmative: 6- Andrew Ginther, Charleta Tavares, Hearcel Craig, Priscilla Tyson, Michael
Mentel, and A. Troy Miller
CA 1094-2009 To authorize and direct the Franklin County Municipal Court Clerk to
modify and extend the contract with Sterling Data Center LLC for the
provision of remote data back-up and recovery services; to authorize
expenditure up to $19,944.00 from the Franklin County Municipal
Court Clerk computer fund; and to declare an emergency.
($19,944.00)
CA 1114-2009 To authorize a supplemental appropriation of $15,885.89 from the
unappropriated balance of the Municipal Court Clerk computer fund; to
authorize and direct the Director of Finance and Management on
behalf of the Municipal Court Clerk to establish a purchase order with
Resource One Computer Systems, Inc. for the purchase of a server;
to authorize an expenditure of $15,885.89 from the Municipal Court
Clerk computer fund; and to declare an emergency. ($15,885.89)
CA 1127-2009 To authorize the acceptance of a grant from the Franklin County
Board of Commissioners, Office of Homeland Security and Justice
Programs; to authorize the appropriation and expenditure of said
funds in the amount of Seven Thousand Eight Hundred
Seventy-seven Dollars for the purchase of equipment for the Domestic
Violence Unit of the City Attorney's Office; and to declare an
emergency. ($7,877.00)
UTILITIES: PALEY, CHR. CRAIG GINTHER MENTEL
CA 0867-2009 To authorize the Director of Public Utilities to settle and release on
behalf of the City of Columbus all claims related to a dispute arising
from the Big Walnut Augmentation/Rickenbacker Interceptor
("BWARI") project; to execute any necessary documents associated
with the settlement and final resolution of the dispute; to authorize the
City Auditor to accept a settlement payment in the amount of
$500,000.00 (Five Hundred Thousand Dollars and no cents); to
deposit the settlement payment into the appropriate fund, and to
declare an emergency.
CA 0942-2009 To authorize the transfer of $34,114.75 within the Voted Street
Lighting and Electricity Distribution Improvement Fund; to authorize
the transfer of $95,838.36 from the Electricity Reserve Fund to the
Voted Street Lighting and Electricity Distribution Improvement Fund;
and to authorize the City Auditor to reimburse the operating fund in the
amount of $129,953.11 for labor and equipment costs incurred in the
installation of various street lighting projects; and to authorize an
amendment to the 2009 Capital Improvements Budget for the Division
of Power and Water. ($129,953.11)
City of Columbus Page 12
Columbus City Council Minutes - Final September 14, 2009
CA 0961-2009 To authorize the Director of Public Utilities to execute a planned
contract modification for the professional design services agreement
with Braun & Steidl Architects, Inc. for the Fairwood Facility
Improvements project; to authorize the appropriation and transfer of
$51,394.00 from the Sanitary Sewer Reserve Fund to the Voted
Sanitary Sewer Bond Fund; to authorize the expenditure of
$51,394.00 from the Voted Sanitary Sewer Bond Fund for the Division
of Sewerage and Drainage. ($51,394.00)
CA 0962-2009 To authorize the Director of Public Utilities to modify the contract with
Malcolm Pirnie, Inc., for Professional Engineering Services for the
Dublin Road Water Plant Chlorine Storage Improvements, for the
Division of Power and Water; to authorize the appropriation and
transfer of $570,000.00 from the Water System Reserve Fund to the
Water Works Enlargement Voted Bonds Fund; and to authorize the
expenditure of $570,000.00 from Waterworks Enlargement Voted
1991 Bonds Fund. ($570,000.00)
CA 1045-2009 To authorize the Finance and Management Director to establish a
Purchase Order with Performance Site Environmental, LLC for
hazardous waste disposal and testing from an existing universal term
contract for the Division of Power and Water; to authorize the
expenditure of $30,000.00 from the Water Systems Operating Fund;
and to declare an emergency. ($30,000.00)
CA 1073-2009 To authorize and direct the Finance and Management Director to
enter into a contract for the option to purchase US Filter/Envirex Parts
with Siemens Water Technologies, to authorize the expenditure of
$1.00 to establish the contract from the Mail, Print Services and UTC
Fund; and to declare an emergency. ($1.00)
CA 1075-2009 To authorize and direct the Finance and Management Director to
enter into a contract for the option to purchase Flow Monitoring Parts
and Services with ADS LLC, to authorize the expenditure of $1.00 to
establish the contract from the Mail, Print Services and UTC Fund;
and to declare an emergency. ($1.00)
CA 1090-2009 To authorize and direct the Finance and Management Director to
enter into a contract for the option to purchase Seepex Pump Parts
with Liberty Process Equipment, Inc. and Buckeye Pumps Inc.; to
authorize the expenditure of $2.00 to establish the contracts from the
Mail, Print Services and UTC Fund; and to declare an emergency.
($2.00)
CA 1093-2009 To authorize and direct the Finance and Management Director to
enter into a contract for the option to purchase Penn Valley Pumps
and Pump Parts with Delaney & Associates, Inc., to authorize the
City of Columbus Page 13
Columbus City Council Minutes - Final September 14, 2009
expenditure of $1.00 to establish the contract from the Mail, Print
Services and UTC Fund Account; and to declare an emergency.
($1.00)
CA 1097-2009 To authorize the Director of Public Utilities to enter into a service
agreement with Invensys Process Systems Inc. for the Maintenance
Manager Service Agreement for the Foxboro I/A System in
accordance with the sole source provisions of the Columbus City
Code; to authorize the expenditure of $34,679.00 from the Sewerage
System Operating Fund, and to declare an emergency ($34,679.00).
CA 1121-2009 To authorize and direct the Finance and Management Director to
enter into five contracts for the option to purchase Pole Line Hardware
for the Department of Public Utilities with Power Line Supply
Company; Consolidated Electrical Distributors; Inc.; The John A
Becker Company; Edison Equipment LLC: and HD Supply Utilities
LTD; to authorize the expenditure of $5.00 to establish the contracts
from the Mail, Print Services and UTC Fund; and to declare an
emergency. ($5.00)
HEALTH, HOUSING & HUMAN SVC'S: TAVARES, CHR. TYSON MILLER
MENTEL
CA 0619-2009 To authorize the Director of the Department of Development to modify
the Victim's Assistance Program grant agreement with the Columbus
Urban League; to authorize the expenditure of $6,341.00 from the
General Fund; and to declare an emergency. ($6,341.00)
A motion was made by Ginther, seconded by Miller, that this matter be
Approved. The motion carried by the following vote:
Abstained: 1- Priscilla Tyson
Affirmative: 6- Andrew Ginther, Charleta Tavares, Hearcel Craig, Michael Mentel, A.
Troy Miller, and Eileen Paley
CA 1104-2009 To authorize and direct the Board of Health to enter into a revenue
contract from the Ohio Department of Health for the provision of
environmental lead risk assessment services, in an amount not to
exceed $10,840; and to declare an emergency. ($10,840)
CA 1140-2009 To authorize and direct the transfer of $42,000.00 within the General
Government Grant Fund, Lead Grant, to provide funding for
expenditures related to the Lead Grant; and to declare an emergency.
($42,000.00)
CA 1142-2009 To authorize the expenditure of $608,023 from the General
Government Grant Fund for the purpose of making loans and grants
for operation of the Affordable Housing Opportunity Fund; and to
declare an emergency. ($608,023)
City of Columbus Page 14
Columbus City Council Minutes - Final September 14, 2009
CA 1146-2009 To authorize and direct the Columbus Health Department to accept a
grant from Action For Children in the amount of $3,830, to authorize
the appropriation of $3,830 from the City's Private Grants Fund; and to
declare an emergency. ($3,830.00)
CA 1147-2009 To authorize and direct the Columbus Health Department to accept a
continuation grant from the Franklin County Department of Job and
Family Services, Family and Children First Council in the amount of
$181,375.00; to authorize the appropriation of $181,375.00 from the
unappropriated balance of the Health Department Grants Fund; and to
declare an emergency. ($181,375.00)
CA 1152-2009 To authorize the Director of the Department of Development to enter
into contracts with various non-profit organizations to support the
operation of the Chores Program; to authorize the expenditure of
$100,000 from the General Government Grant Fund; and to declare
an emergency. ($100,000.00)
CA 1153-2009 To amend Ordinance 1608-2008, passed March 30, 2009, creating
the Hubbard and High Community Reinvestment Area for the purpose
of including language from the Ohio Revised Code as well as the
inclusion of an additional Section designating the Development
Department's Housing Administrator as the designated Housing
Officer; and to declare an emergency.
CA 1165-2009 To authorize and direct the Columbus Health Department to accept a
grant from the Ohio Department of Health in the amount of $241,000;
to authorize the appropriation of $241,000 from the unappropriated
balance of the Health Department Grants Fund; and to declare an
emergency. ($241,000)
CA 1177-2009 To authorize the Director of the Department of Development to modify
the Day Care Program grant agreement with Neighborhood House; to
authorize the expenditure of $5,340.00 from the General Fund; and to
declare an emergency. ($5,340.00)
A motion was made by Ginther, seconded by Miller, that this matter be
Approved. The motion carried by the following vote:
Abstained: 1- Eileen Paley
Affirmative: 6- Andrew Ginther, Charleta Tavares, Hearcel Craig, Priscilla Tyson, Michael
Mentel, and A. Troy Miller
CA 1178-2009 To authorize the Director of the Department of Development to modify
the Young Heroes and Whole School/Whole Child Program grants
with City Year; to authorize the expenditure of $40,052.00 from the
General Fund; and to declare an emergency. ($40,052.00)
A motion was made by Ginther, seconded by Miller, that this matter be
City of Columbus Page 15
Columbus City Council Minutes - Final September 14, 2009
Approved. The motion carried by the following vote:
Abstained: 1- Priscilla Tyson
Affirmative: 6- Andrew Ginther, Charleta Tavares, Hearcel Craig, Michael Mentel, A.
Troy Miller, and Eileen Paley
CA 1179-2009 To authorize the Director of the Department of Development to modify
the Resettlement Program grant agreement with Community Refugee
and Immigration Services; to authorize the expenditure of $42,129.00
from the General Fund; and to declare an emergency. ($42,129.00)
A motion was made by Ginther, seconded by Miller, that this matter be
Approved. The motion carried by the following vote:
Abstained: 1- Charleta Tavares
Affirmative: 6- Andrew Ginther, Hearcel Craig, Priscilla Tyson, Michael Mentel, A. Troy
Miller, and Eileen Paley
CA 1180-2009 To authorize the Director of the Department of Development to modify
the Day Care Program grant agreement with Central Community
House; to authorize the expenditure of $14,685.00 from the General
Fund; and to declare an emergency. ($14,685.00)
A motion was made by Ginther, seconded by Miller, that this matter be
Approved. The motion carried by the following vote:
Abstained: 1- Hearcel Craig
Affirmative: 6- Andrew Ginther, Charleta Tavares, Priscilla Tyson, Michael Mentel, A.
Troy Miller, and Eileen Paley
RECREATION & PARKS: TYSON, CHR. TAVARES PALEY MENTEL
CA 1044-2009 To authorize and direct the Director of Recreation and Parks to grant
consent to Short North Business Association to apply for permission to
sell alcoholic beverages at the HighBall Halloween Masquerade on
High taking place on October 31, 2009. ($0.00)
CA 1118-2009 To accept a grant in the amount of $39,999.65 from and enter into
agreement with the Franklin County Department of Job and Family
Services; to appropriate $39,999.65 to the Recreation and Parks
Grant Fund; and to declare an emergency. ($39,999.65)
CA 1183-2009 To authorize an appropriation of $210,190.48 from the unappropriated
balance of the Recreation and Parks Grant Fund to the Recreation
and Parks Department for various staffing costs during 2009 funded
through grants and donations; and to declare an emergency.
($210,190.48)
APPOINTMENTS
City of Columbus Page 16
Columbus City Council Minutes - Final September 14, 2009
CA A0102-2009 Reappointment of Keith Shumate, Squire, Sanders & Dempsey LLP,
41 South High Street, Columbus, Ohio 43215 to serve on the The City
Records Commission with a new term expiration date of September
12, 2011. (resume attached).
CA A0103-2009 Reappointment of Stanley Harris, National City Bank, 155 E. Broad
Street, Columbus, Ohio 43251 to serve on the Columbus Metropolitan
Housing Authority Board with a new expiration date of October 31,
2014 (resume attached).
A motion was made by Ginther, seconded by Miller, that this matter be Read
and Approved. The motion carried by the following vote:
Abstained: 1- Priscilla Tyson
Affirmative: 6- Andrew Ginther, Charleta Tavares, Hearcel Craig, Michael Mentel, A.
Troy Miller, and Eileen Paley
CA A0104-2009 Reappointment of Jamie Roberson of 750 North High Street #10 H,
Columbus, Ohio 43215 to serve on the Columbus Metropolitan
Housing Authority Board with a new expiration date of October 31,
2014 (resume attached).
A motion was made by Ginther, seconded by Miller, that this matter be Read
and Approved. The motion carried by the following vote:
Abstained: 1- Priscilla Tyson
Affirmative: 6- Andrew Ginther, Charleta Tavares, Hearcel Craig, Michael Mentel, A.
Troy Miller, and Eileen Paley
Passed The Consent Agenda
Affirmative: 7- Andrew Ginther, Charleta Tavares, Hearcel Craig, Priscilla Tyson, Michael
Mentel, A. Troy Miller, and Eileen Paley
EMERGENCY, TABLED AND 2ND READING OF 30-DAY LEGISLATION
FINANCE: MENTEL, CHR. TAVARES CRAIG PALEY
1182-2009 To authorize and direct the City Auditor to appropriate $1,292,182.00
within the Special Income Tax Fund; and to declare and emergency.
($1,292,182.00)
A motion was made by President Mentel, seconded by Tavares, that this
matter be Approved. The motion carried by the following vote:
Affirmative: 7- Andrew Ginther, Charleta Tavares, Hearcel Craig, Priscilla Tyson, Michael
Mentel, A. Troy Miller, and Eileen Paley
1213-2009 To authorize the Director of the Department of Finance and
Management to enter into, grant and accept a Access and
Ingress/Egress Easement Agreement, at no cost to the City, with Time
City of Columbus Page 17
Columbus City Council Minutes - Final September 14, 2009
Warner Entertainment Company, L.P., Gowdy Partners, LLC, Gowdy
Partners II, LLC and Gowdy Partners III, LLC, for the purpose of
providing sufficient access for ingress and egress to W. Third Avenue
and Olentangy River Road, and the extent they may be applicable, to
waive the competitive bidding and Land Review Commission
requirements of the Columbus City Codes (1959) Revised, and to
declare an emergency.
A motion was made by President Mentel, seconded by President Pro-Tem
Craig, that this matter be Approved. The motion carried by the following vote:
Affirmative: 7- Andrew Ginther, Charleta Tavares, Hearcel Craig, Priscilla Tyson, Michael
Mentel, A. Troy Miller, and Eileen Paley
PUBLIC SERVICE & TRANSPORTATION: CRAIG, CHR. MILLER TAVARES
MENTEL
0875-2009 To authorize the Director of Public Service to enter into an agreement
with Ohio Department of Transportation, and to receive approximately
$234,812.00 in federal Safe Routes to School grant funds for the
Division of Mobility Options.
A motion was made by President Pro-Tem Craig, seconded by Ginther, that
this matter be Approved. The motion carried by the following vote:
Affirmative: 7- Andrew Ginther, Charleta Tavares, Hearcel Craig, Priscilla Tyson, Michael
Mentel, A. Troy Miller, and Eileen Paley
0999-2009 To authorize the Director of Public Service to accept and enter into an
LPA agreement for a $200,000.00 grant from the Ohio Department of
Transportation for the Share the Road Project on behalf of the
Department of Public Service, Division of Mobility Options. ($0.00)
A motion was made by President Pro-Tem Craig, seconded by Ginther, that
this matter be Approved. The motion carried by the following vote:
Affirmative: 7- Andrew Ginther, Charleta Tavares, Hearcel Craig, Priscilla Tyson, Michael
Mentel, A. Troy Miller, and Eileen Paley
DEVELOPMENT: GINTHER, CHR. CRAIG TYSON MENTEL
1139-2009 To authorize the Director of the Department of Development to
execute any and all necessary agreements and deeds for conveyance
of title of one vacant parcel of real property (3074-80 East Sixth
Avenue) held in the Land Bank pursuant to the Land Reutilization
Program; and to declare an emergency.
A motion was made by Ginther, seconded by President Pro-Tem Craig, that
this matter be Approved. The motion carried by the following vote:
Affirmative: 7- Andrew Ginther, Charleta Tavares, Hearcel Craig, Priscilla Tyson, Michael
Mentel, A. Troy Miller, and Eileen Paley
1189-2009 To create three residential tax increment financing incentive districts
City of Columbus Page 18
Columbus City Council Minutes - Final September 14, 2009
encompassing certain parcels of real property; to declare
improvements to the parcels within each incentive district to be a
public purpose and exempt from real property taxation; to require the
owners of those parcels to make service payments in lieu of taxes; to
require the distribution of the applicable portion of those service
payments to the Columbus City School District; to establish a
municipal public improvement tax increment equivalent fund for the
deposit of the remainder of those service payments; to specify the
public infrastructure improvements to be made that directly benefit or
serve parcels in the incentive districts; to amend Ordinance No.
0973-2008 passed by the Columbus City Council on July 7, 2008; and
to declare an emergency.
A motion was made by Ginther, seconded by President Pro-Tem Craig, that
this matter be Approved. The motion carried by the following vote:
Affirmative: 7- Andrew Ginther, Charleta Tavares, Hearcel Craig, Priscilla Tyson, Michael
Mentel, A. Troy Miller, and Eileen Paley
1202-2009 To authorize the Director of the Department of Development to enter
into an Enterprise Zone Agreement with Boehringer Ingelheim
Roxane, Inc. and its US Affiliated Companies for a tax abatement of
one hundred percent (100%) for a period of fifteen (15) years in
consideration of the proposed investment of $41.2 million in real
property improvements and the retention of 948 full-time permanent
positions; and to declare an emergency.
A motion was made by Ginther, seconded by Tyson, that this matter be
Approved. The motion carried by the following vote:
Affirmative: 7- Andrew Ginther, Charleta Tavares, Hearcel Craig, Priscilla Tyson, Michael
Mentel, A. Troy Miller, and Eileen Paley
ADMINISTRATION: MILLER, CHR. PALEY TAVARES MENTEL
1099-2009 To authorize the City Auditor to appropriate $1,127,000.00 from within
the unappropriated balance of the Employee Benefits Fund, and to
authorize the expenditure of $1,127,000.00 from the Employee
Benefits Fund, or so much thereof as may be necessary to pay the
unemployment benefit charges to the Ohio Department of Job and
Family Services; and to declare an emergency. ($1,127,000.00)
A motion was made by Miller, seconded by Tyson, that this matter be
Approved. The motion carried by the following vote:
Affirmative: 7- Andrew Ginther, Charleta Tavares, Hearcel Craig, Priscilla Tyson, Michael
Mentel, A. Troy Miller, and Eileen Paley
JUDICIARY & COURT ADMINISTRATION: PALEY, CHR CRAIG TYSON
MENTEL
1102-2009 To authorize the appropriation of $280,000 for 2009 from the
City of Columbus Page 19
Columbus City Council Minutes - Final September 14, 2009
unappropriated balance of the Franklin County Municipal Court
Judges Specialty Docket fund for anticipated expenses associated
with the enhancement of the Soliciation and Addiction Programs; and
to declare an emergency. ($280,000)
A motion was made by Paley, seconded by Ginther, that this matter be
Approved. The motion carried by the following vote:
Affirmative: 7- Andrew Ginther, Charleta Tavares, Hearcel Craig, Priscilla Tyson, Michael
Mentel, A. Troy Miller, and Eileen Paley
1124-2009 To authorize the City Attorney to enter into a contract with J
Investigations and a contract with Urban Advocacy and Investigations
LLC for stalking investigative services, to authorize the expenditure of
an amount not to exceed $69,080.00 from a previouisly authorized
Auditor's Certificate, to waive the competitive procurement provisions
of the Columbus City Codes; and to declare an emergency.
($69,080.00)
A motion was made by Paley, seconded by President Pro-Tem Craig, that this
matter be Approved. The motion carried by the following vote:
Affirmative: 7- Andrew Ginther, Charleta Tavares, Hearcel Craig, Priscilla Tyson, Michael
Mentel, A. Troy Miller, and Eileen Paley
UTILITIES: PALEY, CHR. CRAIG GINTHER MENTEL
1081-2009 To authorize the Director of Public Utilities to enter in a planned
modification with Burch Hydro Inc for Land Application of Biosolids
Services for the Division of Sewerage and Drainage, to authorize the
expenditure of $1,000,000.00 from the Sewerage System Operating
Fund; and to declare an emergency. ($1,000,000.00)
A motion was made by Paley, seconded by Ginther, that this matter be
Approved. The motion carried by the following vote:
Affirmative: 7- Andrew Ginther, Charleta Tavares, Hearcel Craig, Priscilla Tyson, Michael
Mentel, A. Troy Miller, and Eileen Paley
HEALTH, HOUSING & HUMAN SERVICES: TAVARES, CHR.
TYSON MILLER MENTEL
0617-2009 To authorize the Director of the Department of Development to modify
the grants of various social service agencies; to authorize the
expenditure of $1,182,972.00 from the General Fund; and to declare
an emergency. ($1,182,972.00)
A motion was made by Tavares, seconded by Tyson, that this matter be
Approved. The motion carried by the following vote:
Affirmative: 7- Andrew Ginther, Charleta Tavares, Hearcel Craig, Priscilla Tyson, Michael
Mentel, A. Troy Miller, and Eileen Paley
0771-2009 To authorize the Director of the Department of Development to enter
City of Columbus Page 20
Columbus City Council Minutes - Final September 14, 2009
into contract with the Community Shelter Board to support the
Rebuilding Lives program; to authorize the expenditure of $451,367.00
from the General Fund; and to declare an emergency. ($451,367.00)
A motion was made by Tavares, seconded by President Pro-Tem Craig, that
this matter be Approved. The motion carried by the following vote:
Abstained: 1- Priscilla Tyson
Affirmative: 6- Andrew Ginther, Charleta Tavares, Hearcel Craig, Michael Mentel, A.
Troy Miller, and Eileen Paley
1101-2009 To authorize an appropriation of $1,728,023 in various divisions and
object levels of the Department of Development within the General
Government Grant Fund, to provide funding for approved programs;
and to declare an emergency ($1,728,023.00).
A motion was made by Tavares, seconded by Paley, that this matter be
Approved. The motion carried by the following vote:
Affirmative: 7- Andrew Ginther, Charleta Tavares, Hearcel Craig, Priscilla Tyson, Michael
Mentel, A. Troy Miller, and Eileen Paley
1141-2009 To authorize the appropriation of $2,642,649.00 from the General
Government Grant Fund to the Department of Development; to
authorize the Director of the Department of Development to enter into
contract with the Community Shelter Board for the purpose of
continuing the city's support for homeless emergency shelters; to
authorize the expenditure of $2,642,649.00 from the General
Government Grant Fund; and to declare an emergency
($2,642,649.00)
A motion was made by Tavares, seconded by Paley, that this matter be
Approved. The motion carried by the following vote:
Abstained: 1- Priscilla Tyson
Affirmative: 6- Andrew Ginther, Charleta Tavares, Hearcel Craig, Michael Mentel, A.
Troy Miller, and Eileen Paley
1157-2009 To amend ordinance 1192-2007, which provides $364,000 for
infrastructure construction reimbursement from the Voted 2001 and
2004 Streets and Highways Fund and authorizes the Directors of the
Departments of Development and Public Service to enter into a
development agreement with Whitney Young Collaborative LLC, to
extend the expiration date of the agreement from December 31, 2008
to December 31, 2011; and to declare an emergency.
A motion was made by Tavares, seconded by President Pro-Tem Craig, that
this matter be Approved. The motion carried by the following vote:
Affirmative: 7- Andrew Ginther, Charleta Tavares, Hearcel Craig, Priscilla Tyson, Michael
Mentel, A. Troy Miller, and Eileen Paley
RECREATION & PARKS: TYSON, CHR. TAVARES PALEY MENTEL
City of Columbus Page 21
Columbus City Council Minutes - Final September 14, 2009
0870-2009 To authorize the Director of Recreation and Parks to enter into an
agreement with the Ohio Department of Transportation for the
development of a pedestrian/bikeway bridge; to authorize an
expenditure of $663,269.00, and to declare an emergency.
($663,269.00)
A motion was made by Tyson, seconded by President Pro-Tem Craig, that this
matter be Approved. The motion carried by the following vote:
Affirmative: 7- Andrew Ginther, Charleta Tavares, Hearcel Craig, Priscilla Tyson, Michael
Mentel, A. Troy Miller, and Eileen Paley
RULES & REFERENCE: MENTEL, CHR. GINTHER CRAIG PALEY
0674-2009 To increase the city income tax from a rate of two percent (2.0%) to a
rate of two and one-half percent (2.5%) effective October 1, 2009, to
amend sections 361.19, 361.21, and 361.24, Columbus City Codes,
1959, and to declare an emergency.
A motion was made by President Mentel, seconded by Tavares, that this
matter be Taken from the Table. The motion carried by the following vote:
Affirmative: 7- Andrew Ginther, Charleta Tavares, Hearcel Craig, Priscilla Tyson, Michael
Mentel, A. Troy Miller, and Eileen Paley
A motion was made by President Mentel, seconded by Tavares, that this
matter be Approved. The motion carried by the following vote:
Affirmative: 7- Andrew Ginther, Charleta Tavares, Hearcel Craig, Priscilla Tyson, Michael
Mentel, A. Troy Miller, and Eileen Paley
ADJOURNMENT
ADJOURNED: 7:05 P.M.
A motion was made by President Pro-Tem Craig, seconded by Ginther, to
adjourn this Regular Meeting. The motion carried by the following vote:
Affirmative: 7- Andrew Ginther, Charleta Tavares, Hearcel Craig, Priscilla Tyson, Michael
Mentel, A. Troy Miller, and Eileen Paley
City of Columbus Page 22