Muyni
← Back to Davenport

Historic Preservation Commission

Regular Meeting

Davenport, IA · June 10, 2025

AgendaPacketMinutes

Minutes

HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION MEETING MINUTES CITY OF DAVENPORT, IOWA TUESDAY, JUNE 10, 2025; 5:00 PM CITY HALL | 226 WEST 4TH STREET | COUNCIL CHAMBERS I. Call to Order Chairperson Hustedde called the meeting to order. Present: Hustedde, Kretz, Eaton (Virtual), Hoff, Adams, Gomez, McGivern Staff Present: Berkley, Reu, Werderitch II. Secretary's Report 1. Consideration of the May 13, 2025 meeting minutes. Motion by Hoff, second by Gomez, to approve the May 13, 2025 meeting minutes. Minutes were unanimously approved by voice vote (7-0). III. Communications IV. Old Business V. New Business 1. Case DNRHP25-01: Request for demolition of the detached garage at 633 Ripley Street. The Louis and Clara (Heuer) Naeckel House is a contributing structure in the Hamburg Local Landmark Historic District. William Rogers, petitioner, on behalf of Cristina E Bucksbaum Revocable Trust. [Ward 3] Staff provided an overview of the request. Due to deterioration and structural concerns, the property owner is petitioning demolition of the 20'x18' garage. Following demolition, the owner intends to return the area covered by the garage and concrete driveway to green space. For the demolition of a structure within a local historic district, the Commission can approve demolition if there is an economic hardship or if the structure substantially violates building and fire codes. Staff recommended that the Historic Preservation Commission approve demolition of the detached garage at 633 Ripley Street, subject to the following finding: The structure violates the 2021 International Residential Code. William Rogers, applicant, was in attendance to answer questions. The owner commented on the severe state of deterioration. Commissioners inquired about the possibility of salvaging the building materials for future use in another project. Motion by Gomez, second by Adams, to approve Case DNRHP25-01 in accordance with the submitted materials. Motion passed by a roll call vote (7-0). 2. Case DNRHP25-02: Request for demolition of the Warming House at 2200 West River Drive. Credit Island is a locally listed historic landmark. City of Davenport, petitioner. [Ward 3] Staff introduced the Parks and Recreation Department’s request to demolish the Credit Island Warming Shelter. The brick structure has become unsafe due to falling bricks, cracked supports, and a crumbling roof. The park shelter is currently fenced-off to protect public safety. Once demolished, the debris will be disposed and the area will be returned to green space. Credit Island is located within the Mississippi River floodway. The warming house is often inaccessible due to frequent flooding events, making maintenance and improvements difficult for park staff. Staff recommended that the Historic Preservation Commission approve demolition of the Credit Island Warming House at 2200 West River Drive. Findings: 1. The structure violates the 2021 International Building Code. 2. Per the Iowa Flood Center, the park shelter has a 50% annual chance of flooding in any given year. 3. Credit Island is a locally listed historic landmark due to its association with both events and persons that have made a contribution to the history of the city and nation. The park shelter is not historically significant based on its own merits. William Fisher, Senior Parks Manager, was in attendance to answer questions and explain the rationale for demolition. He described the history of flooding on the island and challenges in maintaining the Warming House. The Commission discussed the importance of the City setting an example of being a good steward of historic resources. The Commission directed the Parks and Recreation Department to provide a comprehensive plan for park maintenance. Motion by McGivern, second by Hoff, to table Case DNRHP25-02. The purpose was to allow the Parks and Recreation Department additional time to respond to the comments made during the meeting. Motion passed by a roll call vote (7-0). 3. Case COA25-05: Request for the installation of a new roof at 730 Gaines Street. The Christian H.H. and Fanny (Voigt) Jipp House and Grocery is located within the Hamburg Local Landmark Historic District. Gateway Redevelopment Group, petitioner. [Ward 3] Staff presented a summary of the request to install a new roof over the main house and retail store. The Yankee gutter system will remain following completion of the project. The existing roofing material is a cedar shake shingle, which was installed in 2005. The replacement product is Owen's Cornings TruDef Duration Series. This is an architectural asphalt shingle. The color and material will match the detached barn/garage structure at the rear of the property. Staff then outlined the history of building permits at the property referencing asphalt shingles. Staff recommended approval of the Certificate of Appropriateness to install a new roof at 730 Gaines Street in accordance with the submitted material. The project was reviewed for conformance with the Standards for Review, Chapter 14.01.060 C and D of the Davenport Municipal Code. The project meets the following standards: a. Every reasonable effort shall be made to make the minimal number of changes necessary to maintain a designated property in a good state of repair, thereby minimizing the impact of the proposed alteration. Jack Haberman, applicant, was in attendance to answer questions and explain the history of the architectural salvage store. The Commission asked questions about the type of architectural shingle used and its resemblance to the material on the adjacent barn structure. Motion by Gomez, second by Adams, to approve Case COA25-05 in accordance with the submitted materials. Motion passed by a roll call vote (6-0). Commissioner Kretz abstained. 4. Case COA25-06: Request to replace the original cast iron entry at 526 West 2nd Street. The Iowa Reform Building is a locally listed historic landmark. VJEA LLC, petitioner. [Ward 3] Staff introduced the project and outlined the scope of work. Boyler's Ornamental Iron has been contracted to refurbish and fabricate the original cast iron entryway. Due to deterioration and safety concerns, the property owner installed wooden steps into the apartment unit as a temporary measure until the historic iron entry could be reinstalled. Staff view the project as a replacement in-kind. Staff made a recommendation to approve the Certificate of Appropriateness to replace the original cast iron entry at 526 West 2nd Street in accordance with the submitted material. The project was reviewed for conformance with the Standards for Review, Chapter 14.01.060 C and D of the Davenport Municipal Code. The project meets the following standards: 1. Every reasonable effort shall be made to make the minimal number of changes necessary to maintain a designated property in a good state of repair, thereby minimizing the impact of the proposed alteration. 2. Deteriorated architectural features should, where possible, be repaired rather than replaced. Where the severity of deterioration requires replacement, the new feature shall match the old in design, color, texture and other visual qualities and, where possible, materials. Replacement of missing features shall be substantiated by documentary, physical or pictorial evidence. Krisha Saldivar, representative of the applicant, was in attendance to answer questions. Motion by Eaton, second by Gomez, to approve Case COA 25-06 in accordance with the submitted materials. Motion passed by a roll call vote (7-0). 5. Case COA25-07: Request for site improvements, restoration of existing structures, and new construction at 2800 Eastern Avenue. The Iowa Soldiers' Orphans' Home Historic District is a locally and nationally listed historic district. Annie Wittenmyer Family LLC, petitioner. [Ward 5] Staff presented a summary of improvements to the historic district. The developer, Annie Wittenmyer Family LLC, is utilizing both state and federal historic preservation tax credits to help finance the project. This provides an additional level of oversight regarding historic preservation of the campus, as the National Park Service reviews the development for compliance with The Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation. Staff summarized exterior alterations to the Children’s Cottage, Green House Building, Ice House Building, Garage Building, Boy’s Training Building, Cottages (1-10), and general site improvements. Additional site-wide building maintenance will include masonry work, window repair/replacement, and installation of new roofs. Staff made a recommendation to approve the Certificate of Appropriateness for site improvements, restoration of existing structures, and new construction at 2800 Eastern Avenue in accordance with the submitted material, subject to the following conditions: 1. Per the requirements of the National Park Service, the housing project shall be in compliance with The Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation. 2. As the design for the rehabilitation project progresses, any substantial modifications shall require a separate Certificate of Appropriateness Application and review by the Historic Preservation Commission. The project was reviewed for conformance with the Standards for Review, Chapter 14.01.060 C and D of the Davenport Municipal Code. The project meets the following standards: 1. Every reasonable effort shall be made to make the minimal number of changes necessary to maintain a designated property in a good state of repair, thereby minimizing the impact of the proposed alteration. 2. Deteriorated architectural features should, where possible, be repaired rather than replaced. Where the severity of deterioration requires replacement, the new feature shall match the old in design, color, texture and other visual qualities and, where possible, materials. Replacement of missing features shall be substantiated by documentary, physical or pictorial evidence. 3. Activities that cause deterioration of a designated property and its architectural features shall be discouraged. In those cases where the damage would be irreversible, such as sand-blasting and wet blasting fire-hardened bricks, the activities shall be prohibited. If cleaning is to be done, the gentlest means possible shall be encouraged. 4. New additions and related new construction shall not be discouraged when such improvements do not destroy historic material and such design is compatible with the size, massing, scale, color, materials and character of the property, neighborhood and district, if applicable. Chris Ales, developer, was in attendance to discuss the overall site improvements, requirements for National Park Service grants, and phasing of the development. The Commission agreed with staff’s recommended conditions. Should the project substantially deviate from the presented plans, those items shall be brought back for formal review and consideration. Otherwise, the project can proceed with staff’s oversight. Motion by Kretz, second by Gomez, to approve Case COA 25-07 in accordance with the submitted materials and conditions. Motion passed by a roll call vote (7-0). VI. Other Business 1. Party in the Park After discussion, the Commission decided to participate in the July 17th and August 7th Party in the Park events. The Commission intends to partner with the Davenport Public Library Special Collections for the events. VII. Open Forum for Comment Jan Stoffer, Director of Operations & Administration, for the Butterworth Center Deere-Wiman House invited the Commission to the annual Porch Party on September 21 st. VIII. Adjourn Motion by McGivern, second by Hoff, to adjourn the meeting. Motion passed by a voice vote (7- 0). The meeting adjourned at 6:22pm. IX. Next Commission Meeting: July 8, 2025

Agenda

HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION MEETING CITY OF DAVENPORT, IOWA Tuesday, June 10, 2025; 5:00 PM City Hall | 226 West 4th Street | Council Chambers I. Call to Order II. Secretary's Report 1. Consideration of the May 13, 2025 meeting minutes. III. Communications IV. Old Business V. New Business 1. Case DNRHP25-01: Request for demolition of the detached garage at 633 Ripley Street. The Louis and Clara (Heuer) Naeckel House is a contributing structure in the Hamburg Local Landmark Historic District. William Rogers, petitioner, on behalf of Cristina E Bucksbaum Revocable Trust. [Ward 3] 2. Case DNRHP25-02: Request for demolition of the Warming House at 2200 West River Drive. Credit Island is a locally listed historic landmark. City of Davenport, petitioner. [Ward 3] 3. Case COA25-05: Request for the installation of a new roof at 730 Gaines Street. The Christian H.H. and Fanny (Voigt) Jipp House and Grocery is located within the Hamburg Local Landmark Historic District. Gateway Redevelopment Group, petitioner. [Ward 3] 4. Case COA25-06: Request to replace the original cast iron entry at 526 West 2nd Street. The Iowa Reform Building is a locally listed historic landmark. VJEA LLC, petitioner. [Ward 3] 5. Case COA25-07: Request for site improvements, restoration of existing structures, and new construction at 2800 Eastern Avenue. The Iowa Soldiers' Orphans' Home Historic District is a locally and nationally listed historic district. Annie Wittenmyer Family LLC, petitioner. [Ward 5] VI. Other Business 1. Party in the Park VII. Open Forum for Comment VIII. Adjourn IX. Next Meeting: July 8, 2025

Packet

HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION MEETING CITY OF DAVENPORT, IOWA Tuesday, June 10, 2025; 5:00 PM City Hall | 226 West 4th Street | Council Chambers I. Call to Order II. Secretary's Report 1. Consideration of the May 13, 2025 meeting minutes. III. Communications IV. Old Business V. New Business 1. Case DNRHP25-01: Request for demolition of the detached garage at 633 Ripley Street. The Louis and Clara (Heuer) Naeckel House is a contributing structure in the Hamburg Local Landmark Historic District. William Rogers, petitioner, on behalf of Cristina E Bucksbaum Revocable Trust. [Ward 3] 2. Case DNRHP25-02: Request for demolition of the Warming House at 2200 West River Drive. Credit Island is a locally listed historic landmark. City of Davenport, petitioner. [Ward 3] 3. Case COA25-05: Request for the installation of a new roof at 730 Gaines Street. The Christian H.H. and Fanny (Voigt) Jipp House and Grocery is located within the Hamburg Local Landmark Historic District. Gateway Redevelopment Group, petitioner. [Ward 3] 4. Case COA25-06: Request to replace the original cast iron entry at 526 West 2nd Street. The Iowa Reform Building is a locally listed historic landmark. VJEA LLC, petitioner. [Ward 3] 5. Case COA25-07: Request for site improvements, restoration of existing structures, and new construction at 2800 Eastern Avenue. The Iowa Soldiers' Orphans' Home Historic District is a locally and nationally listed historic district. Annie Wittenmyer Family LLC, petitioner. [Ward 5] VI. Other Business 1. Party in the Park VII. Open Forum for Comment VIII. Adjourn IX. Next Meeting: July 8, 2025 City of Davenport Department: Development & Neighborhood Services Action / Date Contact Info: Matt Werderitch | 563-888-2221 6/10/2025 Subject: Consideration of the May 13, 2025 meeting minutes. Recommendation: Approve the minutes. Background: The May 13, 2025 meeting minutes are attached. Attachments: 1. Meeting Minutes 5-13-25 HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION MEETING MINUTES CITY OF DAVENPORT, IOWA TUESDAY, MAY 13, 2025; 5:00 PM CITY HALL | 226 WEST 4TH STREET | COUNCIL CHAMBERS I. Call to Order Chairperson Hustedde called the meeting to order. Present: Hustedde, Kretz, Eaton, Hoff, Adams, Gomez Excused: McGivern Staff Present: Berkley, Werderitch II. Secretary's Report 1. Consideration of the April 8, 2025 meeting minutes. Motion by Gomez, second by Kretz, to approve the April 8, 2025 meeting minutes. Minutes were unanimously approved by voice vote (6-0). III. Communications Due to scheduling conflicts, the Downtown Davenport Architectural Walking Tour will be cancelled this summer. Staff hope to bring the program back next year. IV. Old Business V. New Business 1. Case COA25-04: Request for exterior alteration at 714 Gaines Street. The Postel Rental House is a contributing building in the Hamburg Local Landmark Historic District. Xaveria Mayes, petitioner. [Ward 3] Staff provided an overview of the request. A recent windstorm caused a large tree to collapse onto the rear of the home, resulting in substantial damage to the roof, siding, fascia, gutters, and windows. The property owner received a Structural Damage Claim from State Farm Insurance to address necessary repairs to the exterior. As a result, the homeowner is petitioning repairs to the facade only in the areas damaged by the storm. There are no alterations proposed to the front elevation facing Gaines Street. Staff made a recommendation to approve the Certificate of Appropriateness in Case COA25-04 in accordance with the submitted material. The project was reviewed for conformance with the Standards for Review, Chapter 14.01.060 C and D of the Davenport Municipal Code. The project meets the following standards: 1. Every reasonable effort shall be made to make the minimal number of changes necessary to maintain a designated property in a good state of repair, thereby minimizing the impact of the proposed alteration. The property owner was not in attendance to answer questions. Motion by Adams, second by Gomez, to approve Case COA25-04 in accordance with the submitted materials, subject to the following condition: 1. City Staff shall have administrative review and approval of replacement window units damaged by the tree collapse. Replacement window units shall match the old in design, color, texture and other visual qualities and, where possible, materials. VI. Other Business 1. Party in the Park After discussion, the Commission decided to participate in the July 17th and August 7th Party in the Park events. The Commission intends to partner with the Davenport Public Library Special Collections for the events. 2. 2025 Preserve Iowa Summit Staff and Commissioner Gomez will register for general admission and attend the June 5th and 6th events. Chairperson Hustedde will attend the Certified Local Government Roundtable on Saturday June 7th. VII. Open Forum for Comment VIII. Adjourn Motion by Gomez, second by Kretz, to adjourn the meeting. Motion passed by a voice vote (6- 0). The meeting adjourned at 5:30pm. IX. Next Commission Meeting: June 10, 2025 City of Davenport Department: Development & Neighborhood Services Action / Date Contact Info: Matt Werderitch | 563-888-2221 6/10/2025 Subject: Case DNRHP25-01: Request for demolition of the detached garage at 633 Ripley Street. The Louis and Clara (Heuer) Naeckel House is a contributing structure in the Hamburg Local Landmark Historic District. William Rogers, petitioner, on behalf of Cristina E Bucksbaum Revocable Trust. [Ward 3] Recommendation: Staff recommends that the Historic Preservation Commission approve demolition of the detached garage at 633 Ripley Street. Finding: The structure violates the 2021 International Residential Code. Background: Architectural Style and Significance: According to the National Register of Historic Places Inventory-Nomination Form, the property at 633 Ripley is a contributing structure in the Hamburg Historic District. This includes both the single-family home and the detached garage. The two-story Queen Anne residence was constructed circa 1901. Architectural details include a double-door entry, oriel window, bay windows, chambered corner with brackets, dormers, decorative windows, decorative gables, and a front porch. The 360-square-foot garage, located in the rear yard, was constructed in 1920. It is a wood- framed structure wrapped in wood siding and resting on a concrete foundation. The shed roof is covered with asphalt shingles. Several windows have been removed from the structure, likely due to structural issues occurring on the south and east walls. Any demolition or partial demolition of a nationally or locally registered property requires review and approval from the Historic Preservation Commission. Demolition Request: Due to deterioration and structural concerns, the property owner is petitioning demolition of the 20'x18' garage. Following demolition, the owner intends to return the area covered by the garage and concrete driveway to green space. The following scope of work is proposed: 1. Demolish garage. Properly dispose of all debris and any hazardous material. Recycle metal to the greatest practical degree. 2. Demolish and dispose of garage concrete floor, footings, concrete rubble retaining wall, and driveway. 3. Remove and dispose of the affected trees and rootballs. 4. Placement of fill dirt to level the drive and the backyard. 5. Provide and place approximately 2" of black dirt over the affected area. 6. Finish grade the affected area. While it is not within the scope of work at this time, a Certificate of Appropriateness Application is required for the construction of any new garage. Demolition Review Process (Section 14.01.070): No demolition permits shall be issued for local landmarks or properties within designated historic districts prior to the commission, or the City Council upon appeal, issuing a certificate of economic hardship. The commission shall review all the evidence and information submitted by the applicant and receive testimony from other interested parties. If the commission finds that the building substantially violates the City building, fire and/or housing codes or the property owner cannot obtain a reasonable economic return therefrom, then the commission shall issue the demolition permit. The commission shall act on each application within 60 days after the receipt of a complete application. Staff Review: For the demolition of a structure within a local historic district, the Commission can approve demolition if there is an economic hardship or if the structure substantially violates building and fire codes. Staff researched city records and present the following information: 1. The home and garage are listed as contributing structures in the Hamburg Local Landmark Historic District. 2. The garage was built in 1920, approximately 19 years after the construction of the single-family home. 3. Building materials consist of wood framed walls, concrete foundation, asphalt shingles, and wood siding. 4. The garage is 360 square feet (20' x 18'). 5. There does not appear to be a master builder, craftsman, architect, engineer, or landscape architect associated with the garage. 6. According to the Scott County Parcel Report, the net assessed value is $140,710. 7. A structural report from a licensed architect or engineer has not been conducted. However, the following observations were noted during a site visit: 1. The garage is visibly slanting towards the north. 2. The wood siding is in a state of deterioration. Most notably on the rear facade. 3. The east elevation is missing siding, leaving the framework and structure open to the elements. 4. Windows have been removed from the north, south, and east elevations. Window openings appear warped and skewed. 5. There are holes in the ceiling of the structure, enabling water to enter into the garage and deteriorate the foundation from within. Attachments: 1. Application 2. Historic Property Inventory Sheet 3. Scott County Parcel Report 4. Section 14.01.070 Commission's Demolition Review Process Scope of Work for All Demo Processes Project will include: demolition and removal of dilapidated garage and broken concrete pad, including fifty-four(54’) feet of broken concrete drive from the back door of the house to the garage. Demolish dilapidated garage and concrete to include: -Demolish garage. Properly dispose of all debris and any hazardous material. Recycle metal to the greatest degree practical. -Demolish and dispose of garage concrete floor, footings, concrete rubble retaining wall, and driveway. -Remove and dispose of the affected trees and rootballs. -Placement of fill dirt to level the drive and the back yard. -Provide and place approximately 2" of black dirt over the affected area. -Finish grade the affected area. United States Department of the Interior National Park Service / National Register of Historic Places Registration Form NPS Form 10-900 OMB No. 1024-0018 Hamburg Historic District (amended) Scott County, Iowa Name of Property County and State _________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ Address Historic Name significant date/s Materials of walls, foundations, State #, Map #, FS # architectural style/type roof 2016 district status History of property (owners/residents, census data including Architectural data (architect/builder, 1983 district status birthplace of self (and parents), Sanborn map info), Current use features, modifications), Garage data 627 Ripley St Louis P. and Clara L. (Krause) c.1909 Walls: stucco Best House Spanish Mission Revival (2 story) Foundation: stucco State #82-02495 Roof: hip roof - asphalt shingles (earlier one-story house on lot) Architect/builder: Clausen & Clausen Map #065 1910 Sanborn map: house - 2 1/2 story - extant Porch: entry porch - stucco columns 1910 census: Best, Louis P (62, own income) - born in Germany (Germany, Windows: 1/1 wood windows Field Site #C-12 Germany); wife: Clara (46) - born in Germany (Germany, Germany) Architectural details: decorative Parcel #G0054-10B c.1909 - current house built for Louis P. Best; 1909-1927- Louis P. and parapets and columns, brackets under Clara Best (The Robert Krause Co, retired businessman); 1927-1937 - eaves, dormer, stucco Updated district status: owned by Thomas and Frida Agar - 1928 permit to remodel into Modifications: Historic: -; Non-historic: - 2 contributing buildings apartments - listed after as Grandview Apartments Garage: detached - converted to apts (A, C) 1937-1943 - series of owners (insurance co) - Grandview Apartments; Date: c.1909 1943-1960s - owned by Archie Swanson - Grandview Apartments - 8 Walls: frame - stucco 1983 NRHP status: units, 1951 - permit to convert 3-car portion of garage to additional apt Foundation: concrete (one already on 2nd) Roof: hip roof - asphalt shingles Contributing (key) 1956 Sanborn map: flats (apartments) (9 units - 2 1/2 story - extant Notes: detailing similar to house, Current use: apartments (7 units + 2 units in garage) dormer, arch connects house to garage Other site features: - 633 Ripley St Louis and Clara (Heuer) c.1901 Walls: frame - wood Naeckel House Queen Anne (2 story) Foundation: stone State #82-02497 Roof: combination hip/gable - asphalt shingles Map #066 (earlier 1 1/2 story house on lot - vacated W. 7th St) Architect/builder: - c.1901 - house built for Louis and Clara Naeckel Porch: entry porch - round wood Field Site #C-13 1910 Sanborn map: house - 2 1/2 story - extant columns on brick piers Parcel #G0054-09 1910 census: Naeckel, Louis (45, paint store) - born in US - IA (Germany, Windows: 1/1 wood windows - wood Germany); wife: Clara (42) - born in US - IA (Germany, Germany) surrounds Updated district status: c.1902-1938 - Louis and Clara Naeckel (Charles Naeckel and Sons - Architectural details: double-door entry, 2 contributing buildings paint/wallpaper/glass) oriel window, bay windows, chamfered (A, C) 1938-1948 - Louis Naeckel (president, Charles Naeckel and Sons); 1950- corner with brackets, dormers, 1960s - owned by R.M. Van Atta - used as rental - remodeled to duplex in decorative windows, decorative gables, 1983 NRHP status: 1950 porches 1956 Sanborn map: house (2 units) - 2 1/2 story - extant Modifications: Historic: -; Non-historic: Contributing Current use: single family - rental 1950 - remodeled to duplex Garage: detached - frame Date: c.1920s Walls: frame - wood Foundation: concrete Roof: shed roof - asphalt shingles Notes: windows Other site features: - 703 Ripley St Struck-Herzog House c.1897 Walls: frame - wood Queen Anne (2 story) Foundation: stone State #82-02498 Roof: combination hip/gable - asphalt shingles Map #067 (earlier 1 story house on lot) Architect/builder: Aufderhiede, Benjamin c.1896-98 - house built for Henry C. Struck Jr and wife Johanna at 625 (architect) Field Site #C-14 Ripley (two lots to south); 625: 1898-1908 - Henry and Johanna Struck Porch: full porch - Corinthian columns - Parcel #G0043-41B (cashier - Davenport Savings Bank) extended into porte cochere to north in 1910 Sanborn map: house - 2 1/2 story - extant 1992 - Corinthian columns Updated district status: 1910 census: Herzog, Theodore (43, cigar salesman) - born in US - IA Windows: 1/1 wood windows - wood 1 contributing building (Germany, Germany); wife: Ida (41) - born in US - IA (Germany, Germany) surrounds (A, C) 1909 - 625 lot bought by Louis Best for new house - bought this lot in 3- Architectural details: corner round tower, 1909 and moved house - sold to Herzog in 8-1909; 1909-1920 - Theodore octagonal turret, decorative windows, 1983 NRHP status: and Ida Herzog (cigar salesman) decorative gables 1920-1943 - Otto and Caroline Rohr (furnished rooms); owned by Richard Modifications: Historic: -; Non-historic: - Contributing (key) H. Muehlenberg - used as rental/rooms Garage: attached carport - frame 1956 Sanborn map: house - 2 1/2 story - extant Other site features: - 1974 - converted from duplex to 1 unit with five sleeping rooms; 1981 - converted to single family Current use: single family house - owner occupied Section 7, page 69 5/27/25, 2:00 PM Beacon - Scott County / City of Davenport, Iowa - Property Data\Parcel Report: G0054-09 Scott County / City of Davenport, Iowa Summary - Auditor's Office Parcel ID G0054-09 Alternate ID G21003 Property Address 633 RIPLEY ST DAVENPORT IA 52803 Sec/Twp/Rng 26-78-03 Brief Sec:26 Twp:78 Rng:03BEG AT NW COR OF LOT8 BLK 33 ORIGINALTOWN-N 60' TO Tax Description S/L OFOF MCINTOSH'S 2ND ADD-E 175 1/2' -S 60'-W 175 1/2' TO PT OF BEG (Note: Not to be used on legal documents) Deed Book/Page 2024-16648 Contract Book/Page Gross Acres 0.00 Net Acres 0.00 Adjusted CSR Pts 0 District DAD - DAVENPORT DAVENPORT School District DAVENPORT SCHOOL Subdivision Owners - Auditor's Office Deed Holder CRISTINA E BUCKSBAUM REV TR 633 N RIPLEY ST DAVENPORT IA 52803 Contract Holder Mailing Address CRISTINA E BUCKSBAUM REV TR 633 N RIPLEY ST DAVENPORT IA 52803 Property Record Card (Davenport) View/Print Historical Property Record Card Request Mailing Address Change (Davenport) Link to Request Mailing Address Change Form Land - Assessor's Office Map Area G21 Lot Dimensions Regular Lot: 60.00 x 176.00 Lot Area 0.24 Acres;10,560 SF Land Sizes Used For Assessment Purposes Only. Not A Survey Of The Property. Residential Dwelling - Assessor's Office https://beacon.schneidercorp.com/Application.aspx?AppID=1024&LayerID=21532&PageTypeID=4&PageID=9191&KeyValue=G0054-09 1/5 5/27/25, 2:00 PM Beacon - Scott County / City of Davenport, Iowa - Property Data\Parcel Report: G0054-09 Residential Dwelling Occupancy Single-Family Style 2 Story Frame Year Built 1901 Exterior Material Wood Total Gross Living Area 2,630 SF Attic Type Fully Finished; 495 SF Number of Rooms 0 above; 0 below Number of Bedrooms 3 above; 0 below Basement Area Type Full Basement Area 1,012 Basement Finished Area Plumbing 1 Standard Bath - 3 Fi 1 Toilet Room (1/2 Bat 1 Sink Central Air Yes Heat FHA - Gas Fireplaces 1 Freestanding; Porches 1S Brick Open (161 SF); 1S Frame Open (24 SF); Decks Additions 1 Story Frame (90 SF); 1 Story Frame (54 SF); 1 Story Frame (39 SF); 1 Story Frame (22 SF); 1 Story Frame (18 SF); 1 Story Frame (112 SF) (112 Bsmt SF); Garages 360 SF (20F W x 18F L) - Det Frame (Built 1920); Photos - Assessor's Office Sketches - Assessor's Office https://beacon.schneidercorp.com/Application.aspx?AppID=1024&LayerID=21532&PageTypeID=4&PageID=9191&KeyValue=G0054-09 2/5 5/27/25, 2:00 PM Beacon - Scott County / City of Davenport, Iowa - Property Data\Parcel Report: G0054-09 Permits - Assessor's Office Permit # Date Description Amount M015016 10/19/2015 Furnace 3,100 193842 04/23/2004 Misc 2,500 174362 04/03/1998 Roof 9,385 Sales - Assessor's Office Multi Date Seller Buyer Recording Sale Condition - NUTC Type Parcel Amount 9/25/2024 BUCKSBAUM CHRISTINA E CRISTINA E BUCKSBAUM 2024- Quit Claim Deed QCD $0.00 REVOCABLE TRUST 016648 3/27/1998 BOWMAN, ANNE C BOWMAN, BUCKSBAUM, CRISTINA E 1998- NORMAL ARMS-LENGTH WD $74,000.00 LEONARD J 017003 TRANSACTION 3/19/1982 BOWMAN, ANNE C BOWMAN, 1982- NONE X $0.00 LEONARD J 009737 Recent Sales in Area Sale date range: From: To: 05/27/20 05/27/20 Search Sales by Neighborhood Search Sales by Subdivision Distance: Units: 1500 Feet Search Sales by Distance Valuation - Assessor's Office 2025 2024 2023 2022 2021 Classification Residential Residential Residential Residential Residential + Assessed Land Value $15,750 $15,750 $15,750 $6,300 $6,300 + Assessed Building Value $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 + Assessed Dwelling Value $124,960 $120,750 $120,750 $93,170 $93,170 = Gross Assessed Value $140,710 $136,500 $136,500 $99,470 $99,470 - Exempt Value $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 = Net Assessed Value $140,710 $136,500 $136,500 $99,470 $99,470 Taxation - Auditor\Treasurer's Office 2023 2022 2021 Pay 2024-2025 Pay 2023-2024 Pay 2022-2023 x Rollback (estimated) 46.34 54.65 54.13 + Taxable Land Value $7,299 $3,443 $3,410 + Taxable Building Value $0 $0 $0 + Taxable Dwelling Value $55,959 $50,917 $50,433 = Gross Taxable Value $63,258 $54,360 $53,843 - Homestead 65+ Exemption $0 $0 $0 - Military Exemption $0 $0 $0 = Net Taxable Value $63,258 $54,360 $53,843 x Levy Rate (per $1000 of value) 37.63357 39.08417 39.64283 = Gross Taxes Due $2,380.62 $2,124.62 $2,134.49 - Ag Land Credit $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 - Family Farm Credit $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 - Homestead Credit $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 - Disabled and Senior Citizens Credit $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 - Business Property Credit $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 = Net Taxes Due $2,380.00 $2,124.00 $2,134.00 https://beacon.schneidercorp.com/Application.aspx?AppID=1024&LayerID=21532&PageTypeID=4&PageID=9191&KeyValue=G0054-09 3/5 5/27/25, 2:00 PM Beacon - Scott County / City of Davenport, Iowa - Property Data\Parcel Report: G0054-09 Tax History - Treasurer's Office Year Due Date Amount Paid Date Paid Receipt 2023 March 2025 $1,190 Yes 3/21/2025  662510 September 2024 $1,190 Yes 9/19/2024 2022 March 2024 $1,062 Yes 2/12/2024  653766 September 2023 $1,062 Yes 9/22/2023 2021 March 2023 $1,067 Yes 3/6/2023  654022 September 2022 $1,067 Yes 9/23/2022 2020 March 2022 $948 Yes 3/7/2022  651815 September 2021 $948 Yes 10/5/2021 2019 March 2021 $928 Yes 3/29/2021  656954 September 2020 $928 Yes 9/14/2020 2018 March 2020 $958 Yes 3/16/2020  659489 September 2019 $958 Yes 9/20/2019 2017 March 2019 $938 Yes 3/4/2019  673629 September 2018 $938 Yes 8/27/2018 2016 March 2018 $971 Yes 3/5/2018 632688 September 2017 $971 Yes 8/21/2017 2015 March 2017 $935 Yes 1/30/2017 802971 September 2016 $935 Yes 8/31/2016 2014 March 2016 $1,052 Yes 1/6/2016 731406 September 2015 $1,052 Yes 9/29/2015 2013 March 2015 $1,034 Yes 3/27/2015 642946 September 2014 $1,034 Yes 9/2/2014 2012 March 2014 $1,068 Yes 1/30/2014 627480 September 2013 $1,068 Yes 8/30/2013 Special Assessments - Treasurer's Office Project: 20200731 - Davenport Utility Fee Accepted Date: 7/31/2020 Parcel Number: G0054-09 Amortization Date: 12/1/2021 Amortized Interest: 0 Number of Years: 0 Payoff: $0.00 Tenant Name: Payment Due Date Principal Left Tax Billed Amortized Interest Interest Admin Fees Receipt Date Paid Unpaid Balance        Total  Number   1 9/30/2021 $105.99 $105.99 $0.00 $0.00 $5.00 $110.99 176687 9/13/2020 $0.00 Total $105.99 $0.00 $0.00 $5.00 $110.99 $0.00 Davenport Data Correction Feedback Form Link to Data Correction Feedback Form Treasurer Data Correction Feedback Form Link to Treasurer Data Correction Feedback Form Pay Property Taxes Click here to pay your Property Taxes online for this parcel Davenport Tax Credit Applications Apply for Homestead, Sales Questionnaire or Military Tax Credits Scott County Land Records A free search tool that allows you to search Scott County Recorder’s records from 1971 to the present. For records prior to 1971, please contact the Scott County Recorder’s Office at (563) 326-8621. Search Scott County Land Records https://beacon.schneidercorp.com/Application.aspx?AppID=1024&LayerID=21532&PageTypeID=4&PageID=9191&KeyValue=G0054-09 4/5 5/27/25, 2:00 PM Beacon - Scott County / City of Davenport, Iowa - Property Data\Parcel Report: G0054-09 Property Fraud Alert Property Fraud Alert is a free notification service that alerts subscribers when a document has been recorded in the Scott County Recorder's Office. This service is FREE, and you choose how you are notified; by text, email and/or phone. Property Fraud Alert Visit Property Fraud Alert or call the Scott County Recorder's Office at (563) 326-8621 to sign up. No data available for the following modules: Comp Search (Residential Report), Comp Search (Commercial Report), Comp Search (Land Report), Property Record Card (Scott), Request Mailing Address Change (Scott), DBA (Doing Business As) - Assessor's Office, Commercial Buildings - Assessor's Office, Agricultural Buildings - Assessor's Office, Yard Extras - Assessor's Office, Tax Sale Certificates - Treasurer's Office, Scott County Data Correction Feedback Form, Scott County Assessment Appeals Process, Davenport Assessment Appeals Process, Scott County Forms and Applications, Scott County Sales Questionnaire. DISCLAIMER: The information in this web site represents current data from a working file Contact Us where some data is updated regularly and some annually. Information is believed reliable, but its accuracy cannot be guaranteed. The site is used to inform the public, but some data, files, records, or documents may not be complete, full, or whole in nature. No warranty, expressed or implied, is provided for the data herein or its use. | User Privacy Policy | GDPR Privacy Notice Last Data Upload: 5/27/2025, 6:04:25 AM https://beacon.schneidercorp.com/Application.aspx?AppID=1024&LayerID=21532&PageTypeID=4&PageID=9191&KeyValue=G0054-09 5/5 14.01.070 DAVENPORT CODE 14.01.070 14.01.070. Commission's demolition review process. [Ord. No. 2019-02 § 4] The demolition of a designated local landmark or a property within a designated historic district shall be prohibited unless, upon application for and approval of, the commission issues a certificate of economic hardship allowing said demolition. The owner(s) of record or the City may apply for a demolition permit for designated properties. A. Demolition application process. Demolition applications shall be made to the office of construction code enforcement. The office of construction code enforcement shall forward all demolition permit requests for local landmarks and properties within designated historic districts to the commission secretary within two business days of their receipt. No demolition permits shall be issued for local landmarks or properties within designated historic districts prior to the commission, or the City Council upon appeal, issuing a certificate of economic hardship, excluding the circumstances described in Section 14.01.090 of this chapter. B. Criteria for demolition request. The commission shall request and receive from the applicant all information it deems necessary to adequately consider the demolition of a designated property. This may include, but is not limited to, the following: 1. A report from a licensed engineer or architect with experience in rehabilitation as to the structural soundness of the building(s) on the property, their suitability for rehabilitation, and possible new uses for the property; and 2. The assessed value of the land and improvements thereon according to the two most recent assessments; and 3. The real estate taxes paid during the previous two years; and 4. All appraisals obtained by the owner or applicant in connection with his purchase, financing or ownership of the property; and 5. Any listing of the property for sale or rent, price asked and offers received, if any; and 6. All building, fire and housing code violations which have been listed on the property for the past two years; and 7. Any federal, state or local citation(s) which have determined the building to be a nuisance under applicable law; and 8. Estimated market value of the property after completion of the proposed demolition and after renovation of the existing property for reuse; and 9. If the property is income-producing; 14:14 14.01.070 HISTORIC PRESERVATION 14.01.080 a. Annual gross income from the property for the previous two years; and b. Itemized operating and maintenance expenses for the previous two years; and c. Annual cash flow, if any, for the previous two years; and d. Proof that efforts have been made by the owner to obtain a reasonable return on his investment. C. Notification of proposed demolition. The commission agenda shall be posted on the first floor City hall bulletin board used for such purposes no less than one business day prior to the scheduled time of the meeting and shall serve as notice to the general public of the pending meeting. D. Commission review process. The commission shall review all the evidence and information submitted by the applicant and receive testimony from other interested parties. If the commission finds that the building substantially violates the City building, fire and/or housing codes or the property owner cannot obtain a reasonable economic return therefrom, then the commission shall issue the demolition permit. The commission shall act on each application within 60 days after the receipt of a complete application. E. Notification of determination. The commission secretary shall notify the owner(s) of record by regular mail within 15 business days of the commission's decision. The office of construction code enforcement shall be notified within two business days of the commission's action. If the certificate of economic hardship is issued, the commission secretary shall inform the chief building official of said approval. If the certificate of economic hardship is denied, the chief building official shall be instructed to withhold the demolition permit pending possible appeal of the commission's determination. Notified parties will be informed of their right to appeal the commission's decision. 14.01.080. Appeal of commission's decision on demolition. [Ord. No. 2019-02 § 4] A. Application to appeal. The owner may appeal the commission's determination regarding a proposed demolition of a local landmark. A written appeal must be submitted to the City Clerk's office within 30 calendar days of the commission's decision. B. Appeal fee. A fee of $75 shall be paid by the petitioner to the City Clerk at the time of filing a written appeal. C. Notification of appeal. The City Clerk shall notify the commission secretary within three business days of the filing of a written appeal. The commission secretary shall inform the office of construction code 14:15 14.01.080 DAVENPORT CODE 14.01.090 enforcement of the pending appeal and instruct the chief building official to withhold the demolition permit until the City Council has ruled on same. The commission secretary shall also inform the owner(s) of record of the subject property of the date, time and location of the City Council meeting scheduled to hear the appeal. The City Council agenda shall serve as notice to the general public of the appeal and shall be posted on the first floor City hall bulletin board used for such purposes no less than one calendar day prior to the scheduled time of the meeting. D. Review process. The City Council, within 30 calendar days of the filing of a written appeal or at a later time at the request of the petitioner, shall either accept or reject the commission's determination. In considering the commission's determination, the City Council may receive and review all relevant information, testimony and/or evidence submitted for its consideration, including that reviewed by the commission, and any additional material. E. Notification of decision. The owner(s) of record shall be notified by regular mail of the City Council's decision within 15 business days. The office of construction code enforcement shall be notified within two business days of the City Council's decision. The publishing of the City Council meeting minutes shall serve as notice to the general public. The City Council's decision shall be the final City action. 14.01.090. Exclusions. [Ord. No. 2019-02 § 4] A designated property may be altered, relocated, demolished or secured and maintained under the following circumstances and shall not be subject to any of the terms of this chapter. A. Certificate of public hazard. If emergency circumstances affect a designated property which requires immediate relief, including demolition, the fire marshal and chief building official shall certify that such conditions exist and said conditions shall be eliminated as quickly as is practicable. Emergencies are defined as life or health-threatening conditions requiring immediate attention. A certificate of public hazard may be issued after the fact documenting the reasons for loss of the designated property. This section shall apply only in cases where it is impractical for the commission to consider a certificate of economic hardship prior to demolition. B. Conflict with other regulations. The clauses and sections in other City Council-adopted codes and regulations which address life-safety, fire safety and legal nuisances, shall be excluded from the standards and provisions herein. In the event the City's legal, fire, housing or building officials determine that a structure or portion thereof is a life-safety hazard, a fire safety hazard or a nuisance, the fire, housing and building codes shall supersede this chapter. 14:16 14.01.090 HISTORIC PRESERVATION 14.01.100 C. Ordinary repair and maintenance. This chapter is not meant to prevent ordinary repair and maintenance activities of private property not requiring a building or sign permit. 14.01.100. Historic structure demolition review process. [Ord. No. 2019-02 § 4] A. If the owner(s) of record or agent applies for a demolition permit to a building or structure listed on the National Register of Historic Places, which to date has not been designated as a local landmark, the office of construction code enforcement shall not issue the permit but instead shall direct the applicant to the commission secretary. Once the office of construction code enforcement refers the matter to the commission secretary, all demolition activity shall stop, if started, until after the commission or the City Council acts on the matter. The commission secretary shall place the demolition request on the agenda for the commission's next meeting. B. In making its determination on whether to recommend continuance of the demolition stoppage and consideration by the City Council for designation as a local landmark, the commission shall consider the criteria as stated in Section 14.01.070B of this chapter. The commission, by a three-fourths vote of its members present may request the City Council to review a proposed demolition permit for a structure listed on the National Register of Historic Places which has not, to date, been designated as a local landmark. In the event the commission votes to delay demolition, the commission shall have staff prepare an individual property nomination for designation as a local landmark as outlined in Section 14.01.040. Said nomination shall be considered by the commission in a timely manner. In the event the commission vote to nominate the property as a local landmark fails, the demolition permit may be issued and the matter does not proceed to the City Council. In the event the commission votes first to delay demolition and then to nominate the property for designation as a local landmark, the commission shall submit written documentation to the City Council that the building is presently on the National Register of Historic Places, that the criteria for designation as a local landmark as listed in Section 14.01.040 have been met and that the provisions of Section 14.01.090 of the chapter are not applicable, as well as forward any application material submitted by the petitioner or prepared by staff relevant to either the demolition request or the landmark nomination. C. The City Council shall give appropriate notice that a public hearing will be held on the demolition application and nomination for landmark designation. At the public hearing, the City Council shall hear all written and oral statements of the interested parties. The City Council shall base its 14:17 14.01.100 DAVENPORT CODE 14.01.110 decision on all relevant evidence presented at the public hearing, including whether Section 14.01.090 of the chapter is applicable. The City Council shall determine by a majority of the entire Council either to allow the structure to be demolished or to approve the structure for local landmark status. If the local landmark status is approved the owner shall not be issued a demolition permit by the City. Every effort shall be made by all parties to complete the designation process in the most timely fashion. The City Council shall act either allowing the structure to be demolished or designating it a local landmark within 120 days from the date of the commission's first public hearing. 14.01.110. Penalty. [Ord. No. 2019-02 § 4] A. In the event work is being performed without the required certificate of appropriateness or the certificate of economic hardship, the commission or the commission secretary shall ask that a stop work order be issued. In the event work is being performed which is not in accordance with its certificate of appropriateness, the commission shall also ask that a stop work order be issued. In addition to other penalties and remedies, the City shall issue a stop work order, and all work shall cease on the designated property. No additional work shall be undertaken as long as such stop work order is in effect. B. In the event work has been completed without the required certificate of appropriateness or certificate of economic hardship, the owner, the tenant, if a participating party to said work, and the person(s) performing such work shall be guilty of a misdemeanor or municipal infraction. Every day each such violation shall continue to exist shall constitute a separate violation. C. Enforcement. The City's director of community and economic development department, or his/her designee, shall be responsible for the enforcement of the provisions of this chapter. 14:18 City of Davenport Department: Development & Neighborhood Services Action / Date Contact Info: Matt Werderitch | 563-888-2221 6/10/2025 Subject: Case DNRHP25-02: Request for demolition of the Warming House at 2200 West River Drive. Credit Island is a locally listed historic landmark. City of Davenport, petitioner. [Ward 3] Recommendation: Staff recommends that the Historic Preservation Commission approve demolition of the Credit Island Warming House at 2200 West River Drive. Findings: 1. The structure violates the 2021 International Building Code. 2. Per the Iowa Flood Center, the park shelter has a 50% annual chance of flooding in any given year. 3. Credit Island is a locally listed historic landmark due to its association with both events and persons that have made a contribution to the history of the city and nation. The park shelter is not historically significant based on its own merits. Background: Architectural Significance: Credit Island was designated as a local historic landmark on February 3, 1999. Its historical significance is derived from its use as a fur trading post where tribes traded on credit, and as the site of the Battle of Credit Island in the War of 1812. The Works Progress Administration did extensive work at the island in 1935, including the grading of roads and other infrastructure improvements. Former uses of the island include an amusement park, golf course, and aviation airstrip. The property is currently owned by the City of Davenport and serves as a public park and natural area. Demolition Request: The City of Davenport Parks and Recreation Department is petitioning for the complete demolition and removal of the Warming House, located near the lagoon on the southern tip of Credit Island. The brick structure has become unsafe due to falling bricks, cracked supports, and a crumbling roof. The park shelter is currently fenced-off to protect public safety. Once demolished, the debris will be disposed and the area will be returned to green space. Any demolition or partial demolition of a nationally or locally registered property requires review and approval from the Historic Preservation Commission. While it is not within the scope of work at this time, a Certificate of Appropriateness Application is required for the construction of any new park structures. Demolition Review Process (Section 14.01.070): No demolition permits shall be issued for local landmarks or properties within designated historic districts prior to the commission, or the City Council upon appeal, issuing a certificate of economic hardship. The commission shall review all the evidence and information submitted by the applicant and receive testimony from other interested parties. If the commission finds that the building substantially violates the City building, fire and/or housing codes or the property owner cannot obtain a reasonable economic return therefrom, then the commission shall issue the demolition permit. The commission shall act on each application within 60 days after the receipt of a complete application. Staff Review: For the demolition of a structure within a local historic district, the Commission can approve demolition if there is an economic hardship or if the structure substantially violates building and fire codes. Staff researched city records and present the following information: 1. Credit Island is a locally listed historic landmark due to its association with both events and persons that have made a contribution to the history of the city and nation. 2. Credit Island is located within the Mississippi River floodway. The warming house is often inaccessible due to frequent flooding events, making maintenance and improvements difficult for park staff. 3. Based on available aerial photographs and river gauge information from the US Army Corps of Engineers, the pavilion is prone to frequent flooding. Recent aerial photos show the pavilion was flooded in 2016, 2017, 2018, 2019, 2021, 2022, 2023, and 2024. According to the historic flood gauge data on the Lock and Dam 15, the pavilion was flooded 17 of the last 20 years. Flooding occurs most frequently during spring-to- autumn periods when the pavilion would be expected to have the highest use. 4. The Warming House is approximately 1,419 square feet (33' x 43'). 5. Based on available aerial images, the warming house was constructed between 1930- 1950. During this time period, the Works Progress Administration performed numerous infrastructure projects on the island. 6. Building materials consist of brick columns and chimneys, wood framing, concrete foundation, and an asphalt shingle roof. 7. There does not appear to be a master builder, craftsman, architect, engineer, or landscape architect associated with the warming house. 8. The Credit Island Master Plan, completed in 2011, states, "Look at opportunities to improve experience at lagoon through renovations or demolition of existing pavilion and adjust first floor elevation to reduce impacts of minor flooding at pavilion area." 9. The Historic Preservation Commission approved Case COA17-01 for the rehabilitation of the warming house. The project scope included replacing the concrete floor, repairing/replacing soffit, and repairing/repointing brick. This project ultimately did not move forward due to frequent flooding and financial constraints. 10. A structural report from a licensed architect or engineer has not been conducted. However, the following observations were noted during a site visit: 1. Graffiti covers large portions of both the interior and exterior. 2. There is missing masonry on the chimneys and structural columns. 3. Masonry surfaces are deteriorated from repetitive flooding events. 4. Wood fascia is in a state of deterioration. Several sections of fascia are missing. 5. The floor of the shelter is covered in mud and debris from previous flooding events. The condition of the concrete floor was unclear to staff. 6. The asphalt shingle roof is severely degraded, with sections peeling away from the structure. Attachments: 1. Application 2. Credit Island Park Flood Map 3. Credit Island-Recent Flood Events 4. Credit Island Master Plan-Area 4 5. Credit Island Local Landmark Nomination 6. Section 14.01.070 Commission's Demolition Review Process APPLICATION FOR CITY OF DAVENPORT Development & Neighborhood Services _ Planning DEMOLITION REQUEST 1200 E. 46th St HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION Davenport, IA 52807 SUBMITTAL DATE MEETING DATE Office 563.326.6198 Individual Landmark planning@davenportiowa.com SITE ADDRESS & PARCEL NUMBER and/or HISTORIC NAME APPLICANT INFORMATION 2200 W River Drive - Credit Island Applicant Name | Company Name BRIEF OVERVIEW OF THE PROJECT (not a scope of work) Davenport Parks and Recreation The brick structure on the west side of the island, south of the Address lagoon has become unsafe. Bricks are falling, the supports are cracked, and the roof is crumbling. Parks and Recreation is looking 1316 E 29th Street to remove the brick structure known as the "warming house" City | State | Zip APPLICABILITY PRIOR to a demolition permit for a Historic Resource: Davenport, IA 52803 A Demolition Request must be reviewed & approved by the HPC Phone PRIOR to the commencement of any demolition work per 14.01.070. Demolition of a designated local landmark or a property within a Secondary Phone designated historic distrcit shall be prohibited unless the Historic Preservation Commission receives a request and approves said request E-Mail Address with the issuance a certificate of economic hardship Owners of record or the City may apply for a demolition permit william.fisher@davenportiowa.com Acceptance of Applicant ALL SUBMITTALS SHALL INCLUDE: SUBMITTED I, the undersigned, certify that the information on this application to the best of my knowledge is true and correct. I further certify that I have a legal interest in Scope of Work for all demo processes, attached as .PDF the property in question, and/or that I am legally able to represent all other Photos of all existing building/sign façades/elevations persons or entities with interest in this property, and acknowledge formal procedure and submittal requirements. Evidence of 'Economic Hardship' • Professional's structural soundness & reuse suitability report In addition to the application fee, I understand I am responsible for attendance • Assessed Value & taxes paid, prior 2 years at the meeting as shown on the historic preservation commission calendar. • Appraisals regarding purchase, financing & ownership The City reserves the right to require further site studies as necessary. • Property listings of sale/rent prices & offers received • Building/Fire/Housing/State/Federal code violations & nuisances William Fisher • Estimated market value post demolition & post reuse renovation Type Applicant's Name If used as an income property: (prior 2 years) • Annual gross income • Operating/maintenance expenses 05/30/2025 • Annual cash flow Applicant's Signature Date • Proof of efforts to obtain reasonable return on investment DEVELOPMENT TEAM (over the entire ownership time frame) Property Owner Formal Procedure 17.01.070. NONE A. Application Process Address No demolition permits shall be issued for local landmarks or properties within designated historic districts prior to the Commission, or the City Council upon appeal, issuing a certificate of economic hardship, with the exception of Section 14.01.090 Exclusions. Phone Secondary Phone B. Review Criteria The Commission shall request and receive from the applicant all information it deems necessary to adequately consider the demolition. E-Mail Address C. Notification The Commission agenda shall be posted on first floor City Hall no less than one business day prior to the scheduled time of the meeting and shall serve as notice to the general public of the meeting. Project Manager/Other D. Review Process The Commission shall review all the evidence and information submitted by the applicant and receive testimony form other interested parties. If the Commission finds that the building substantially violates the City Building, Fire, and or Housing Codes, or the property owner cannot Address obtain a reasonable economic return therefrom, then the Commission shall authorize the issuance of the demolition permit by the Building Department. The Commission shall act on each application within 60 days after receipt of a completed application. Phone Secondary Phone E. Notice of Determination The Commission shall notify the owner(s) of record within 15 days of the Commission's decision. E-Mail Address Submit this form with attachments to: planning@davenportiowa.com Credit Island – Warming House Credit Island – Warming House Credit Island – Warming House Credit Island – Warming House CRS Activity 420 Open Space Preservation Park Area 1: Credit Island Park Eligible Acres: 274.45 S OHIO AVE KE SUNNYSIDE AVE SUNNYSIDE AVE OT S FAIRMOUNT ST A AV ZONE AE JO E ZONE AE HN FE W LL RD RIV DR ISLAND ER ZONE AE DR FLOODWAY CREDIT DR ST IV ER WR SS TA RK KIMMEL DR ZONE AE MI L ZONE AE LER AVE FLOODWAY T OA DS Legend RA ILR ST Credit Island Park RD CO O N Ineligible Areas C S Flood Hazard Areas Zone Subtype 1 PCT ANNUAL CHANCE FLOOD HAZARD WA PE LLO 0.2 PCT ANNUAL CHANCE FLOOD HAZARD ¯ AV E AREA WITH REDUCED FLOOD RISK DUE TO LEVEE FLOODWAY Date: 12-30-2022 Credit Island – Recent Flooding Events July 2016 July 2017 Credit Island – Recent Flooding Events July 2018 October 2019 Credit Island – Recent Flooding Events October 2020 April 2021 Credit Island – Recent Flooding Events May 2022 April 2023 Credit Island – Recent Flooding Events June 2024 Re-Investment $ Element Total Area 4: Lagoon: Renovation of Pavilion $ 160,000 Construct new 'historic' pavilion to accommodate park education programs $ 275,000 Screen Lagoon Outlet Pipe $ 5,000 Limited access to lagoon shoreline: $ 10,000 Canoe Launch $ 20,000 Limestone Block Fishing Areas (assumes 5) $ 20,000 Designated Trail $ - Implement No Mow areas WPA restroom: $ 15,000 ADA access from parking lot $ 40,000 Alternative to alleviate low level flood impact $ 20,000 Misc. - interpretive signage/wayfinding/gateway features $ - Electrical - Holiday Lighting, etc. Included in Area 1 $ 565,000 Area 4 Total 14.01.070 DAVENPORT CODE 14.01.070 14.01.070. Commission's demolition review process. [Ord. No. 2019-02 § 4] The demolition of a designated local landmark or a property within a designated historic district shall be prohibited unless, upon application for and approval of, the commission issues a certificate of economic hardship allowing said demolition. The owner(s) of record or the City may apply for a demolition permit for designated properties. A. Demolition application process. Demolition applications shall be made to the office of construction code enforcement. The office of construction code enforcement shall forward all demolition permit requests for local landmarks and properties within designated historic districts to the commission secretary within two business days of their receipt. No demolition permits shall be issued for local landmarks or properties within designated historic districts prior to the commission, or the City Council upon appeal, issuing a certificate of economic hardship, excluding the circumstances described in Section 14.01.090 of this chapter. B. Criteria for demolition request. The commission shall request and receive from the applicant all information it deems necessary to adequately consider the demolition of a designated property. This may include, but is not limited to, the following: 1. A report from a licensed engineer or architect with experience in rehabilitation as to the structural soundness of the building(s) on the property, their suitability for rehabilitation, and possible new uses for the property; and 2. The assessed value of the land and improvements thereon according to the two most recent assessments; and 3. The real estate taxes paid during the previous two years; and 4. All appraisals obtained by the owner or applicant in connection with his purchase, financing or ownership of the property; and 5. Any listing of the property for sale or rent, price asked and offers received, if any; and 6. All building, fire and housing code violations which have been listed on the property for the past two years; and 7. Any federal, state or local citation(s) which have determined the building to be a nuisance under applicable law; and 8. Estimated market value of the property after completion of the proposed demolition and after renovation of the existing property for reuse; and 9. If the property is income-producing; 14:14 14.01.070 HISTORIC PRESERVATION 14.01.080 a. Annual gross income from the property for the previous two years; and b. Itemized operating and maintenance expenses for the previous two years; and c. Annual cash flow, if any, for the previous two years; and d. Proof that efforts have been made by the owner to obtain a reasonable return on his investment. C. Notification of proposed demolition. The commission agenda shall be posted on the first floor City hall bulletin board used for such purposes no less than one business day prior to the scheduled time of the meeting and shall serve as notice to the general public of the pending meeting. D. Commission review process. The commission shall review all the evidence and information submitted by the applicant and receive testimony from other interested parties. If the commission finds that the building substantially violates the City building, fire and/or housing codes or the property owner cannot obtain a reasonable economic return therefrom, then the commission shall issue the demolition permit. The commission shall act on each application within 60 days after the receipt of a complete application. E. Notification of determination. The commission secretary shall notify the owner(s) of record by regular mail within 15 business days of the commission's decision. The office of construction code enforcement shall be notified within two business days of the commission's action. If the certificate of economic hardship is issued, the commission secretary shall inform the chief building official of said approval. If the certificate of economic hardship is denied, the chief building official shall be instructed to withhold the demolition permit pending possible appeal of the commission's determination. Notified parties will be informed of their right to appeal the commission's decision. 14.01.080. Appeal of commission's decision on demolition. [Ord. No. 2019-02 § 4] A. Application to appeal. The owner may appeal the commission's determination regarding a proposed demolition of a local landmark. A written appeal must be submitted to the City Clerk's office within 30 calendar days of the commission's decision. B. Appeal fee. A fee of $75 shall be paid by the petitioner to the City Clerk at the time of filing a written appeal. C. Notification of appeal. The City Clerk shall notify the commission secretary within three business days of the filing of a written appeal. The commission secretary shall inform the office of construction code 14:15 14.01.080 DAVENPORT CODE 14.01.090 enforcement of the pending appeal and instruct the chief building official to withhold the demolition permit until the City Council has ruled on same. The commission secretary shall also inform the owner(s) of record of the subject property of the date, time and location of the City Council meeting scheduled to hear the appeal. The City Council agenda shall serve as notice to the general public of the appeal and shall be posted on the first floor City hall bulletin board used for such purposes no less than one calendar day prior to the scheduled time of the meeting. D. Review process. The City Council, within 30 calendar days of the filing of a written appeal or at a later time at the request of the petitioner, shall either accept or reject the commission's determination. In considering the commission's determination, the City Council may receive and review all relevant information, testimony and/or evidence submitted for its consideration, including that reviewed by the commission, and any additional material. E. Notification of decision. The owner(s) of record shall be notified by regular mail of the City Council's decision within 15 business days. The office of construction code enforcement shall be notified within two business days of the City Council's decision. The publishing of the City Council meeting minutes shall serve as notice to the general public. The City Council's decision shall be the final City action. 14.01.090. Exclusions. [Ord. No. 2019-02 § 4] A designated property may be altered, relocated, demolished or secured and maintained under the following circumstances and shall not be subject to any of the terms of this chapter. A. Certificate of public hazard. If emergency circumstances affect a designated property which requires immediate relief, including demolition, the fire marshal and chief building official shall certify that such conditions exist and said conditions shall be eliminated as quickly as is practicable. Emergencies are defined as life or health-threatening conditions requiring immediate attention. A certificate of public hazard may be issued after the fact documenting the reasons for loss of the designated property. This section shall apply only in cases where it is impractical for the commission to consider a certificate of economic hardship prior to demolition. B. Conflict with other regulations. The clauses and sections in other City Council-adopted codes and regulations which address life-safety, fire safety and legal nuisances, shall be excluded from the standards and provisions herein. In the event the City's legal, fire, housing or building officials determine that a structure or portion thereof is a life-safety hazard, a fire safety hazard or a nuisance, the fire, housing and building codes shall supersede this chapter. 14:16 14.01.090 HISTORIC PRESERVATION 14.01.100 C. Ordinary repair and maintenance. This chapter is not meant to prevent ordinary repair and maintenance activities of private property not requiring a building or sign permit. 14.01.100. Historic structure demolition review process. [Ord. No. 2019-02 § 4] A. If the owner(s) of record or agent applies for a demolition permit to a building or structure listed on the National Register of Historic Places, which to date has not been designated as a local landmark, the office of construction code enforcement shall not issue the permit but instead shall direct the applicant to the commission secretary. Once the office of construction code enforcement refers the matter to the commission secretary, all demolition activity shall stop, if started, until after the commission or the City Council acts on the matter. The commission secretary shall place the demolition request on the agenda for the commission's next meeting. B. In making its determination on whether to recommend continuance of the demolition stoppage and consideration by the City Council for designation as a local landmark, the commission shall consider the criteria as stated in Section 14.01.070B of this chapter. The commission, by a three-fourths vote of its members present may request the City Council to review a proposed demolition permit for a structure listed on the National Register of Historic Places which has not, to date, been designated as a local landmark. In the event the commission votes to delay demolition, the commission shall have staff prepare an individual property nomination for designation as a local landmark as outlined in Section 14.01.040. Said nomination shall be considered by the commission in a timely manner. In the event the commission vote to nominate the property as a local landmark fails, the demolition permit may be issued and the matter does not proceed to the City Council. In the event the commission votes first to delay demolition and then to nominate the property for designation as a local landmark, the commission shall submit written documentation to the City Council that the building is presently on the National Register of Historic Places, that the criteria for designation as a local landmark as listed in Section 14.01.040 have been met and that the provisions of Section 14.01.090 of the chapter are not applicable, as well as forward any application material submitted by the petitioner or prepared by staff relevant to either the demolition request or the landmark nomination. C. The City Council shall give appropriate notice that a public hearing will be held on the demolition application and nomination for landmark designation. At the public hearing, the City Council shall hear all written and oral statements of the interested parties. The City Council shall base its 14:17 14.01.100 DAVENPORT CODE 14.01.110 decision on all relevant evidence presented at the public hearing, including whether Section 14.01.090 of the chapter is applicable. The City Council shall determine by a majority of the entire Council either to allow the structure to be demolished or to approve the structure for local landmark status. If the local landmark status is approved the owner shall not be issued a demolition permit by the City. Every effort shall be made by all parties to complete the designation process in the most timely fashion. The City Council shall act either allowing the structure to be demolished or designating it a local landmark within 120 days from the date of the commission's first public hearing. 14.01.110. Penalty. [Ord. No. 2019-02 § 4] A. In the event work is being performed without the required certificate of appropriateness or the certificate of economic hardship, the commission or the commission secretary shall ask that a stop work order be issued. In the event work is being performed which is not in accordance with its certificate of appropriateness, the commission shall also ask that a stop work order be issued. In addition to other penalties and remedies, the City shall issue a stop work order, and all work shall cease on the designated property. No additional work shall be undertaken as long as such stop work order is in effect. B. In the event work has been completed without the required certificate of appropriateness or certificate of economic hardship, the owner, the tenant, if a participating party to said work, and the person(s) performing such work shall be guilty of a misdemeanor or municipal infraction. Every day each such violation shall continue to exist shall constitute a separate violation. C. Enforcement. The City's director of community and economic development department, or his/her designee, shall be responsible for the enforcement of the provisions of this chapter. 14:18 City of Davenport Department: Development & Neighborhood Services Action / Date Contact Info: Matt Werderitch | 563-888-2221 6/10/2025 Subject: Case COA25-05: Request for the installation of a new roof at 730 Gaines Street. The Christian H.H. and Fanny (Voigt) Jipp House and Grocery is located within the Hamburg Local Landmark Historic District. Gateway Redevelopment Group, petitioner. [Ward 3] Recommendation: A recommendation is made to approve the Certificate of Appropriateness to install a new roof at 730 Gaines Street in accordance with the submitted material. The project was reviewed for conformance with the Standards for Review, Chapter 14.01.060 C and D of the Davenport Municipal Code. The project meets the following standards: 1. Every reasonable effort shall be made to make the minimal number of changes necessary to maintain a designated property in a good state of repair, thereby minimizing the impact of the proposed alteration. Background: Site History: Christian Jipp, an immigrant from Schleswig-Holstein worked as a clerk at various retail shops along the Mississippi riverfront from 1860 to 1867. In 1868, Jipp built a grocery store at the corner of southwest corner Gaines Street and West 8th Street. He lived in the back of the store with his wife Henrietta and their three children Ella, Rhoda and Meta, for 10 years until he could afford to build the attached house in 1878. The grocery store was one of the first retail businesses to progress up the hill from the riverfront and was a symbol of the growth of Davenport in the 1860s. The store was sold to Kroeger and Koch in 1906 but remained a grocery until 1958 when it was converted to a laundromat. The laundromat closed in the early 1980s and remained boarded up for over 20 years. The Gateway Redevelopment Group (GRD) began working with City Officials in 2004 to rescue the property from demolition. The GRD’s mission is enhancing neighborhoods by facilitating the rehabilitation and reoccupation of abandoned buildings in the Hamburg Historic District. The structure was designated as a local landmark in 2005 and is listed as a contributing structure in the Hamburg Historic District. The building is currently being used as an architectural rescue shop. Architecture: The commercial grocery store portion of the structure was completed in 1868. It is considered the first retail building constructed on the bluff overlooking Davenport. The two-story Italianate home was attached later in 1878. It is a brick structure on a stone foundation. The following building materials are listed on the historic property inventory sheet: brick walls, stone foundation, asphalt shingles, and wood windows. An accessory structure, which is designed as a historic carriage house, was added in 2011. Request: Installation of a new roof and decking over the main house and retail store. The Yankee gutter system will remain following completion of the project. The existing roofing material is a cedar shake shingle, which was installed in 2005. The replacement product is Owen's Cornings Tru- Def Duration Series. This is an architectural asphalt shingle. The color and material will match the detached barn/garage structure at the rear of the property. Scope of Work: 1. Remove existing roof by stripping off old cedar shake shingles. 2. Remove underlayment, flashing, and damaged decking. 3. Install synthetic underlayment across the entire roof. 4. Install new drip edge around eaves and rakes. 5. Install new shingles per manufacturer's guidelines. 6. Clean and reinstall Yankee gutter system and downspouts. Project Review: The Christian H.H. and Fanny (Voigt) Jipp House and Grocery was built circa 1867. Staff believe the original structure was covered with cedar shake shingles as this was the predominant material during this time period. According to City permits, the structure was first resurfaced using an asphalt shingle in 1939. There were subsequent permits issued referencing asphalt shingles in 1941, 1942, 1953, 1956, 1972, 1975, and 1976. Asphalt shingles were invented in the United States in 1903, but were not commonly used until the 1920s to 1930s. This is due to increased production and advancements in manufacturing, which made asphalt shingles more affordable, durable, and readily accessible. In addition, the National Board of Fire Underwriters promoted asphalt shingles as a safer, fire-resistant alternative to wood shingles. Due to these factors, asphalt shingles were a logical replacement material for the wood shakes in 1939. In an effort to bring back the historic character of the structure, the Historic Preservation Commission approved a Certificate of Appropriateness in 2005 to have the structure redone using cedar shake shingles. The average lifespan of a cedar shake roof is typically between 20 to 30 years. Factors such as quality of material, roof pitch, and drainage can influence the longevity of the roof. As evidenced by the formation of moss, there are likely issues with moisture that have led to further deterioration of the material. This may partially be attributed to the large tree overhanging the retail portion of the structure. Staff are supportive of the project as it will keep the structure in a good state of repair. In addition, the character-defining Yankee gutter system will be retained following the work. Changing building materials can be appropriate when the original material is no longer present. While staff believe the original roofing material was wood shingles, the structure has been covered with asphalt shingles for approximately 66 years. The replacement wood shingle roof installed in 2005 was historically accurate, but the material itself was not original. Therefore, the preservation of this material is not warranted. This is considered a rehabilitation project that keeps the property in a state of utility. The character-defining features, such as the Italianate home and commercial space, will be preserved. Attachments: 1. Application 2. Permit History 3. Historic Property Inventory Sheet 4. Section 14.01.060. Certificate of Appropriateness Review Process APPLICATION FOR CITY OF DAVENPORT Development & Neighborhood Services _ Planning CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS 1200 E. 46th St HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION Davenport, IA 52807 RESOURCE TYPE SUBMITTAL DATE MEETING DATE Office 563.326.6198 Local Hamburg Distrcit 05/28/2025 06/10/2025 planning@davenportiowa.com SITE ADDRESS & PARCEL NUMBER and/or HISTORIC NAME APPLICANT INFORMATION Christian Jipp home and grocery Application Name | Company Name BRIEF OVERVIEW OF THE PROJECT (not a scope of work) Gateway Redevelopment Group Replace cedar shingle roof with fiberglass architectural shingles Address 732 N Gaines St City | State | Zip APPLICABILITY PRIOR to any work on applicable Historic Resources: Davenport, IA 52803 A Certificate of Appropriateness must be submitted & approved Phone PRIOR to the commencement of the following: (563) 271-8344  Any Building or Sign Permit changing the exterior (except demo) Secondary Phone  New construction/Addition or exterior alteration of a structure  Sign installation or alteration E-Mail Address Demolition of any local or national historic resources shall require marionjack@msn.com a Historic Demolition Request Application Acceptance of Applicant ALL SUBMITTALS SHALL INCLUDE: SUBMITTED I, the undersigned, certify that the information on this application to the best of my knowledge is true and correct. I further certify that I have a legal interest in Full Scope of Work (SOW) attached as a .PDF all work & materials shall be described & itemized/listed in detail the property in question, and/or that I am legally able to represent all other persons or entities with interest in this property, and acknowledge formal Photos or renderings of all existing building/sign façades procedure and submittal requirements. Proposed color building/sign elevations to scale I understand I am responsible for attendance at the meeting as shown on the rendered showing existing and/or proposed building materials historic preservation commission calendar. The City reserves the right to Material specs: type, dimensions, color & manufacturer require further site studies as necessary. MINOR & MAJOR ADDITIONS, SITE IMPROVEMENTS, & By checking this box and typing my name below, NEW BUILDINGS SHALL INCLUDE ADDITIONAL ITEMS*: I am electronically signing this application. Dimensioned Site Plan (proposed & existing buildings/site items) Jack Haberman 05/23/2025 Grading Plan with 2 foot intervals (if needed) Mechanical Screening shall be shown Type Applicant's Name here to serve as a signature Date Materials Board of sample building materials proposed DEVELOPMENT TEAM * Major Additions & New Buildings may require more extensive information Property Owner Application Fee: NONE Formal Procedure (1) Application: Address • Prior to submission of the application, the applicant shall correspond with Planning staff to discuss the request, potential alternatives and the process. • The submission of the application does not constitute official acceptance by the City of Davenport. Planning staff will review the application for completeness and notify the applicant Phone Secondary Phone that the application has been accepted or additional information is required. Inaccurate or incomplete applications may result in delay of applicant's scheduled meetings. (2) Scope of Commission's Consideration: E-Mail Address • Only work described in the application may be approved. • If insufficient information exists to make a proper judgment on the application, the Commission may continue the consideration a maximum of 60 days, excluding applicant's continuances. Project Manager/Other (3) Post Commission Ruling: • An approved Cert. of Appropriateness does not constitute a City permit or license and does vest against any other land development regulation or regulatory approval. Applicant must contact Address necessary development authorities. • Appeals to determinations are $75 made to City Council and shall be in writing submitted to the Zoning Administrator within 30 calendar days of Commission’s decision. Phone Secondary Phone E-Mail Address Submit this form with attachments to: planning@davenportiowa.com revised Jan. 2025 ESTIMATE Rolando Palma Company. EST0940 1670 w 49th st. Davenport, IA 52806 DATE 563-940-1339 05/28/2025 https://www.rolandoroofing.net TOTAL rolandopalma1980@gmail.com USD $15,498.00 TO Jack Haberman 730 Gaines st. Davenport, Iowa 52802 (563) 271-8344 marionjack@msn.com DESCRIPTION RATE QTY AMOUNT Roof shingles replacement. $15,498.00 1 $15,498.00 ROLANDO PALMA COMPANY TO: HOUSE ROOF SHINGLES REPLACEMENT. 1- STORY DWELLING STRUCTURE. TEAR OFF EXISTING CEDAR SHAKE SHINGLES AND WIRE MASH TO ROOF DECK. NEW 1"½ ALUMINUM DRIP EDGE ON COLOR OF BROWN ON ALL EAVES AND RAKES. ICE AND WATER BARRIER TO CODE (3' FEET) ON ALL EAVES AND (3') ON VALLEYS. INSATLL SYNTHETIC UNDERLAYMENT MECHANICALLY ATTACHED TO DECK WITH ⅜ STAPLES. STARTER ON ALL EAVES AND RAKES. INSTALL LOW SLOPE ROLL MODIFIED SHINGLE ON BACK SECTION. REMOVE & RESET GUTTER SYSTEM. INSATLL NEW PRO EDGE HIP AND RIDGE CAP. INSTALL NEW FLASHING JACKS TO ALL EXHAUST VENT PIPES. INSTALL NEW OWEN'S CORNINGS TRU-DEF DURATION SERIES OR GAF ARCHITECTURAL SHINGLES. COLOR:_________________________. TO MATCH OTHER STRUCTURES AS CLOSEST POSSIBLE. CLASS: 3 130 MILES WIND RESISTANCE. STANDARD NON PRO-RATED LIFETIME WARRANTY. 10- YEARS WORKMANSHIP WARRANTY. BOTH WARRANTIES 1-TIME TRANSFERABLE. THIS BID IS ESTIMATED TO BE ONE LAYER OF CEDAR SHAKE SHINGLES. IF MORE LAYERS ARE TO BE FOUND, THERE WILL BE AN ADDITIONAL CHARGE OF $25.00 PER SQUARE. ROLANDO PALMA COMPANY WILL PROVIDE FIRST 2-SHEETS OF 1/2" OSB.IF MORE NEEDED COST WILL BE $55.00 EACH. CLEAN GUTTERS. CLEAN UP AND HAUL AWAY. ALL WORK TO CONFORM ALL BUILDING CODES. LABOR, MATERIALS, DUMPSTER AND PERMITS ALL INCLUDED IN ESTIMATED COST. 40% DOWN-PAYMENT REQUIRED WHEN MATERIALS ARRIVE TO JOB SITE. REMAINING BALANCE WILL BE DUE IN A PERIOD OF 7- BUSINESS DAYS AFTER COMPLETION OF PROJECT. CONSUMER HAS 3-DAYS TO CANCEL THIS AGREEMENT FROM THE DATE OF SIGNED AGREEMENT. START DATE: LICENSE NUMBER: 50011175 COMPETITION DATE: CONSUMER RIGHTS RECEIVED INITIALS:_______________. BID/AGREEMENT ACCEPTANCE. JACK HABERMAN. SIGNATURE:__________________________. DATE:___________________. ROLANDO PALMA CO. SIGNATURE:__________________________. DATE:____________________. THANK YOU. ROLANDO PALMA CO. SUBTOTAL $15,498.00 TAX $0.00 TOTAL USD $15,498.00 United States Department of the Interior National Park Service / National Register of Historic Places Registration Form NPS Form 10-900 OMB No. 1024-0018 Hamburg Historic District (amended) Scott County, Iowa Name of Property County and State _________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ Address Historic Name significant date/s Materials of walls, foundations, State #, Map #, FS # architectural style/type roof 2016 district status History of property (owners/residents, census data including Architectural data (architect/builder, 1983 district status birthplace of self (and parents), Sanborn map info), Current use features, modifications), Garage data 730 Gaines St Christian H. H. and Fanny c.1867 Walls: brick on frame (Voigt) Jipp House and Grocery Italianate (2 story / 1 story com) Foundation: stone Alt: 732 Gaines St, 701 Roof: gable-front - asphalt shingles W 8th St 1867-1888 - Christian H.H. and Fanny Jipp (house and grocery) Architect/builder: - 1880 census: Jipp, Christian (47, grocer) - born in Germany - Holstein Porch: entry steps State #82-01843 (Germany - Holstein, Germany - Holstein); wife: Fanny (44) - born in Windows: 1/1 wood windows, some 2/2 Germany - Holstein (Germany - Holstein, Germany - Holstein) wood windows - segmental arch brick Map #151 1888-1913 - Christian H.H. Jipp (widower, grocer), also daughters Meta, lintels Field Site #F-24 Ella (teacher), and Rhoda (teacher) Architectural details: two-story house Parcel #G0045-30A 1910 Sanborn map: house/store - 1 story/1 1/2 story - extant with attached one-story grocery store, 1910 census: Jipp, Christ H.H. (77, retired) - born in Germany (Germany, recessed/paneled house entry, cross Germany) gable side section, large storefront Updated district status: 1913-1945 - owned by sisters Meta and Rhoda Jipp (1913-16 - also Ella) - windows 1 contributing building lived here in 1910s-20s; only Rhoda by 1935; commercial space rented to Modifications: Historic: -; Non-historic: - (A, C), 1 non- grocers - Vincent DiMaria from 1920s to 1940s; Garage: detached - storage building contributing building 1945-1958 - Fannie Schirach - lived on first story - rented 2nd story unit and Date: c.2011 commercial/grocery space; 1958-1960s - Elmo E. and Ruth G. Howard - Walls: frame - board and batten 1983 NRHP status: Howard’s Westinghouse Laundromat #2 Foundation: concrete Contributing (key) 1956 Sanborn map: house/store - 1 story/1 1/2 story - extant Roof: side gable - asphalt shingles 2004 - rehabbed by Jack Haberman / Gateway Redevelopment Group - Notes: designed like historic carriage opened Architectural Rescue Shop at The Jipp house - salvaged materials Current use: retail store (Architectural Rescue Shop) Other site features: - 721 W 8th St Hauschild Rental House c.1892 Walls: frame - wood gable-front - 2 story, 3 bay (2 story) Foundation: stone (stucco) State #82-00707 Roof: gable-front - asphalt shingles (1850s-1890s - lot owned with house/lot to west at corner) Architect/builder: - Map #152 1877-1901 - owned by Detlef and Christian Hauschild; 1892 - house here Porch: full porch - square wood columns on Sanborn map, 1894 - first listing for 721 - Herman and Ida Schmidt with inset panels Field Site #F-25 (foreman R & S Factory) - various renters in late 1890s and 1900s; 1901- Windows: 1/1 windows Parcel #G0045-31 02 - owned by Diedrich J. Harfst Architectural details: - 1910 Sanborn map: house - 2 story - extant Modifications: Historic: -; Non-historic: - Updated district status: 1910 census: rented by Ruedy, Louis (33, bookkeeper for Dav Malt Co) - Garage: none 1 contributing building born in US - IA (Germany, Germany); wife: Henrietta M. (29) - born in Other site features: - (A) Germany (Germany, Germany) 1902-1908 - owned by Emilie V. Karlowa - used as rental; 1909-1931 - 1983 NRHP status: owned by Leonhard P. Biller - used as rental; 1931-1937 - owned by Minnie K. Tathwell - used as rental; 1937-1947 - owned by Mary Turner - Contributing used as rental 1947-1960 - Ida Ernst (owner occupied); 1960s - Werner O. Ernst 1956 Sanborn map: house (2 units) - 2 story - extant Current use: single family house - owner occupied 731 W 8th St Hugo G. and Louisa (Krohn) c.1911 Walls: frame - aluminum Braunlich Jr. House Foursquare/Craftsman (2 story) Foundation: stone (stucco) State #82-00710 Roof: hip roof - asphalt shingles (earlier house on lot from 1850s-1890s; vacant lot in 1910) Architect/builder: - Map #153 1910 Sanborn map: vacant - lot Porch: full porch - brick square columns c.1911-1926 - Hugo G. and Louisa Braunlich (sec & treas - H F Brammer - wood detail across top between Field Site #F-26 Mnfg Co); 1926-27 - Mira Muller, 1927-28 - Ferdinand Dietz, 1928-31 - columns Parcel #G0045-32 Clarence and Frances Dusing; 1931-36 - Frances Dusing (widow); 1936- Windows: 3/1 wood windows 1940 - Henry Fischer Architectural details: wide eaves, hip- Updated district status: 1940-1944 - Jennie Thompson; 1944-46 - Oscar and Emilie Leidenfrost; roof dormers, brackets, porch 1 contributing building 1946-48 - Charles G. and Wayne J. Adrian Berg; 1948-50 - Maude Modifications: Historic: -; Non-historic: (A, C), 1 non- Cooper; 1950-1964 - Wayne E. and Lillian M. Clifton 1963 - aluminum siding contributing building 1956 Sanborn map: house - 2 story - extant Garage: detached - two car Current use: single family house - owner occupied Date: c.1977 Walls: frame - aluminum siding 1983 NRHP status: Foundation: concrete Contributing Roof: gable-front - asphalt shingles Other site features: - Section 7, page 101 3/25/25, 9:56 AM City of Davenport, IA Certificate of appropriateness review process. City of Davenport, IA Tuesday, March 25, 2025 Title 14. Historic Preservation Chapter 14.01. HISTORIC PRESERVATION 14.01.060. Certificate of appropriateness review process. [Ord. No. 2019-02 § 4] A. Application for certificate of appropriateness. Upon application for a building or sign permit that involves a designated property, the office of construction code enforcement shall direct the applicant to the commission secretary to begin the certificate of appropriateness application process. A certificate of appropriateness must be obtained from the commission for any activity requiring a building or sign permit, except demolition, that would change the exterior architectural appearance of a structure designated as a local landmark or a structure located within a designated historic district. The activities covered shall include new construction, exterior alterations, relocations, reconstructions and infill development within designated historic districts. This approval must be obtained prior to the commencement of work and does not relieve the applicant from obtaining the other approvals required by the City. B. Notification about application. The commission secretary shall inform the owner(s) of record of the date, time and location of the commission meeting at which the application will be considered. The commission secretary shall also post the commission's agenda on the first floor City hall bulletin board used for such purposes no less than one business day prior to the scheduled time of the meeting. C. Commission review process - Standards for review. In considering an application for a certificate of appropriateness, the commission shall be guided by the following general standards in addition to any other standards or guidelines established by ordinance for a local landmark or historic district. In all cases, these standards are to be applied in a reasonable manner, taking into full consideration the issue of economic feasibility and other technical considerations. 1. Every reasonable effort shall be made to make the minimal number of changes necessary to maintain a designated property in a good state of repair, thereby minimizing the impact of the proposed alteration; and 2. The removal, alteration or concealing of distinguishing exterior architectural features and historic material of a designated property should be avoided when possible; and 3. All designated property shall be recognized as a product and physical record of its time, place and use. Changes that create a false sense of historical development, such as adding conjectural architectural features shall be discouraged; and 4. Most properties change over time, and those changes that have acquired architectural and/or historical significance in their own right shall be recognized, respected and retained; and 5. Distinctive architectural features, construction techniques and/or examples of craftsmanship that characterize a designated property shall be treated with due consideration; and 6. Deteriorated architectural features should, where possible, be repaired rather than replaced. Where the severity of deterioration requires replacement, the new feature shall match the old https://ecode360.com/print/DA4058?guid=35577346 1/3 3/25/25, 9:56 AM City of Davenport, IA Certificate of appropriateness review process. in design, color, texture and other visual qualities and, where possible, materials. Replacement of missing features shall be substantiated by documentary, physical or pictorial evidence; and 7. Activities that cause deterioration of a designated property and its architectural features shall be discouraged. In those cases where the damage would be irreversible, such as sand- blasting and wetblasting fire-hardened bricks, the activities shall be prohibited. If cleaning is to be done, the gentlest means possible shall be encouraged; and 8. Known significant archeological resources possibly affected by a proposed activity shall be protected and preserved. If such resources must be disturbed, mitigation measures shall be undertaken; and 9. New additions and related new construction shall not be discouraged when such improvements do not destroy historic material and such design is compatible with the size, massing, scale, color, materials and character of the property, neighborhood and district, if applicable. D. Design criteria to implement review standards. When the commission is considering an application for a certificate of appropriateness, it shall consider the following architectural design criteria, or elements of design as they relate to the standards for review prescribed in Section 14.01.040C. 1. Height. The height of any proposed addition, construction or reconstruction should be compatible with the designated property and the surrounding structures, if located within a designated historic district; and 2. Proportions. The proportions (width versus height relationship) between doors and windows should be compatible, if not replicated, with the architectural design and character of the designated property; and 3. Scale. A proposed alteration, construction, reconstruction or addition should not negatively impact the scale of the designated property or district; and 4. Materials. Historic or original architectural features, or replacement elements which in all ways replicated the original, should be repaired whenever possible; and 5. Relationship of building masses and spaces. The relationship of a structure within a designated historic district to the rear, side and front yards between it and surrounding structures should be compatible; and 6. Roof shape. The roof design and shape should remain consistent with its original configuration and character; and 7. Site improvements. Landscaping and other site improvements, including off-street parking, should have as minimal of an impact as possible to the designated property's original plan/layout and its visual character. E. Determination by the commission. The commission shall review a completed application for a certificate of appropriateness within 60 calendar days to determine if the proposed activity will change any exterior architectural features of the designated property. The commission shall accept, review and request additional evidence and testimony from the applicant during the public hearing. The commission shall work closely with the applicant and recognize the importance of finding an appropriate way to meet the current needs of the applicant. In addition, the commission shall recognize the importance of approving plans that will be reasonable for the applicant to carry out. The applicant may modify his/her plans as a result of the discussions with the commission and resubmit them for approval. If the commission finds, by a simple majority, that the proposed activity conforms to the standards for review, as defined herein, then a certificate of appropriateness shall be issued approving said activity. If the commission fails to decide on an application within the specified time period, the application shall be deemed approved. If the commission denies the certificate of appropriateness, the applicant shall have the right of appeal to the City Council pursuant to Section 14.01.040I. https://ecode360.com/print/DA4058?guid=35577346 2/3 3/25/25, 9:56 AM City of Davenport, IA Certificate of appropriateness review process. F. Notification of determination. The commission secretary shall notify the owner(s) of record within 15 business days of the commission's action. If the commission denies the certificate of appropriateness, the notification letter shall contain the reasons for denial and inform the applicant of his/her right to appeal. The commission secretary shall also notify the office of construction code enforcement within three business days of the commission's action. If the commission issues the certificate of appropriateness, the commission secretary shall inform the chief building official of said approval and that the proposed work satisfies the intent of this chapter. However, if the commission denies the certificate of appropriateness, the commission secretary shall ask that the building or sign permit not be issued for said work unless an appeal to the City Council results in a reversal of the commission's denial. G. Appeal of commission determination. The owner(s) of record may appeal the commission's decision to the City Council by filing a written appeal with the City Clerk's office within 30 calendar days of the postmark date of the notification of determination. If no written appeals are submitted with the City Clerk's office within 30 calendar days, the commission's determination shall be the final action by the City. H. Appeal fee. A fee of $75 shall be paid by the petitioner at the time of filing a written appeal to said determination with the City Clerk. I. Appeal criteria. The City Council, after hearing all of the evidence, shall review the commission's decision and base its ruling on the following criteria: 1. Whether the commission has exercised its powers and followed the guidelines established by law and ordinance; and 2. Whether the commission's actions were patently arbitrary and capricious. J. Appeal — Public meeting. The City Council shall, by simple majority of the members present, approve or disapprove the issuance of the certificate of appropriateness based upon the appeal criteria described in Section 14.01.040I. https://ecode360.com/print/DA4058?guid=35577346 3/3 City of Davenport Department: Development & Neighborhood Services Action / Date Contact Info: Matt Werderitch | 563-888-2221 6/10/2025 Subject: Case COA25-06: Request to replace the original cast iron entry at 526 West 2nd Street. The Iowa Reform Building is a locally listed historic landmark. VJEA LLC, petitioner. [Ward 3] Recommendation: A recommendation is made to approve the Certificate of Appropriateness to replace the original cast iron entry at 526 West 2nd Street in accordance with the submitted material. The project was reviewed for conformance with the Standards for Review, Chapter 14.01.060 C and D of the Davenport Municipal Code. The project meets the following standards: 1. Every reasonable effort shall be made to make the minimal number of changes necessary to maintain a designated property in a good state of repair, thereby minimizing the impact of the proposed alteration. 2. Deteriorated architectural features should, where possible, be repaired rather than replaced. Where the severity of deterioration requires replacement, the new feature shall match the old in design, color, texture and other visual qualities and, where possible, materials. Replacement of missing features shall be substantiated by documentary, physical or pictorial evidence. Background: Architectural Style and Significance: The Iowa Reform Building is a locally listed historic landmark due to its long association with the German language press, which was popular in Davenport's German-American community from the Civil War until World War II. The structure served as a publishing house for the Iowa Reform newspaper for over 50 years. It ceased publication in 1943 following anti-German attitudes at the end of World War II. Architecturally, the structure is a well-preserved late 19th century commercial building. The English basement with its large windows is a unique characteristic, allowing natural light and ventilation to the basement workrooms and press rooms for the newspaper office. Distinctive features include decorative brick work in the cornice and an original cast iron entryway on the first floor. Request: Boyler's Ornamental Iron provided a scope of work to refurbish and fabricate the original cast iron entryway. Due to deterioration and safety concerns, the property owner installed wooden steps into the apartment unit as a temporary measure until the historic iron entry could be reinstalled. Scope of Work: 1. Custom metal work to refurbish historic staircase: 1. Refurbish original steps and risers of cast iron staircase. 2. Scope includes fabrication of steel stringers for attachment of historic steps and risers. 3. Stringers will be designed for masonry attachment and adjusted to site conditions. 4. Existing steps and decorative risers will be wire brushed after fabrication and given an epoxy coating prior to installation. 5. Installation and mechanical attachments will be made with stainless-steel hardware. 6. All hardware will be touched up to final finish of staircase. 2. Custom Metal Fabrication: 1. On-site repair of existing steel guards and railings. 2. All railings will be made structurally sound. 3. Damaged attachment points into the building and posts will be repaired or welded. 4. Missing sections of steel pipe will be replaced to replicate the original design. 5. All work areas will be touched up following repairs. Project Review: The Iowa Reform Building is a locally and nationally listed landmark due to its cultural significance. However, the historic property inventory sheet identifies the cast iron stairs as a character-defining architectural feature. Therefore, preservation of this component is significant in retaining the character of the landmark. The most prominent architectural detail of the stairs are the ornamental risers, which will be wire brushed after fabrication. Epoxy coating will be applied to the iron to protect against corrosion and extend the lifespan of the material. Staff recommend using black epoxy to replicate the appearance of iron. Finally, the scope of work includes replacing missing steel guards and railings with new components. The design will replicate the dimensions of the existing features. Once completed, staff believe the entryway will replicate the original steps to the greatest extent practicable. Staff consider the scope of work to be a replacement in-kind. The Historic Preservation Ordinance defines 'Replacement-in-kind' as, "Means the act of replacing an architectural feature of a designated structure so as not to alter its visual appearance and character. This is accomplished by using replacement materials that replicate the previous historic feature in design, size, texture and visual appearance." Attachments: 1. Application 2. Photos 3. Historic Property Inventory Sheet 4. Section 14.01.060.C Certificate of Appropriateness Review Process Boyler's Ornamental Iron 4407 State Street Bettendorf, Iowa 52722 Customer Proposal Prepared for: Krista Saldivar 526 1/2 West 2nd Street Davenport, Iowa 52801 rookxravenpropertymanagement@gmail.com Prepared by: Stephen Boyler 563.209.5552 stephen@boylers.com www.Boylers.com Date Proposal 05/30/2025 2138106 Sales Rep Stephen Boyler Phone: 563.209.5552 Email: stephen@boylers.com Boyler's Ornamental Iron 4407 State Street Bettendorf, Iowa 52722 Phone: 563.355.3709 Customer Proposal Krista Saldivar 526 1/2 West 2nd Street Davenport, Iowa 52801 rookxravenpropertymanagement@gmail.com Included Product Description Quantity Unit Unit Price Ext. Price Custom Metal Work Refurbish original steps and risers of 1 ea $2,144.00 $2,144.00 Refurbish Historic cast iron staircase. Scope includes Staircase fabrication of steel stringers for attachment of historic steps and risers. Stringers will be designed for masonry attachment and adjusted to site conditions. Existing steps and decorative risers will be wire brushed after fabrication and given an epoxy coating prior to installation. Installation and mechanical attachments will be made with stainless-steel hardware. All hardware will be touched up to final finish of staircase. Custom Metal Fabrication On-site repair of existing steel guards 1 ea $940.00 $940.00 and railings. All railings will be made structural sound. Damaged attachment points into the building and posts will be repaired or welded. Missing sections of steel pipe will be replaced to replicate original design. All work areas will be touched up following repairs. Subtotal $3,084.00 Subtotal Before Taxes $3,084.00 Sales Tax(7%) $215.88 Total $3,299.88 Deposit Due Prior to Fabrication (33%) $1,088.96 Balance Due After Installation is Completed (67%) $2,210.92 Product Images - Included Below is a listing of photos for the products selected. Custom Metal Work Refurbish Historic Staircase Parts of a Staircase 82-010-213 National Register 11/18/83 ARCHITECTURAL/HISTORICAL SURVEY DAVENPORT, IOWA DAVENPORT COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT Wehner, Nowysz, Pattschull and Pfiffner IOWA DIVISION OF HISTORIC PRESERVATION SITE #82-10-2-W526 MAP #1 Iowa Reform Building 526 W. Second Street (See continuation Original Town 10 sheet) 15 701840 4599270 Louise B. Ruhl Mail to: William H. Huckfeldt 2815 Oak Street Davenport, IA 52804 2 s t o r y commerial b l o c k w i t h E n g l i s h basement 1892 B r i c k w i t h s t o n e and c a s t i r o n 19th Century Commercial R e c t a n g u l a r , r e g u l a r l y spaced D e c o r a t i v e b r i c k work i n c o r n i c e and o r i g i n a l c a s t i r o n e n t r y & 1st floor Minor c h a n g e s of t h e f i r s t f l o o r d o o r and windows None of s i g n i f i c a n c e The building is an extremely well preserved late 19th Century commercial building. The English basement with its areaway and large windows, are a unique feature allowing natural light and ventilation to the basement workrooms and pressrooms for the newspaper office. Insurance Maps of Davenport, Iowa. New York Sandborn Map Co., 1886, 1892, 1910, 1920 and 1930. SIGNIFICANCE This building focuses attention on the German Language press which thrived in Davenport's German-American community from the Civil War until World War II. This building was used for more than 50 years as the publishing house for the Iowa Reform a Democratic and later, Independent, German Language newspaper. Publisher and editor, Adolph Petersen lived above the print shop. It is the one of two buildings associated with the foreign press, and the only one associated with the Iowa Reform still standing. DESCRIPTION Iowa Reform began publishing in July, 1884 as a semi-weekly German language news- paper serving local tri-city Germans. Adolph Petersen, his brother Gerhard, and later Robert Petersen were the publishers and editors of the paper from 1884 until it ceased publication in 1943. The Reform peaked circulation in 1912 with 4,000 subscribers, in the bi-state towns. During World War I, most Iowa German papers ceased publication because of anti-German sentiments but the Reform continued by complying with a government requirement that each issue be translated into English and filed with federal censors. By 1939 the Iowa Reform was the sole surviving German paper in Iowa with a circula- tion of 3,240. The anti-German attitudes of World War II ended the paper in 1943. SOURCES Stewart, Ruth, "The Foreign Language Press in Iowa." Federal Writers Project Collection, University of Iowa Library Special Collections, Box #14, c. 1940, Christiansen, Thomas P. "An Industrial History of Scott County, Iowa, Annals of Iowa (3) (April, 1940) pp. 259-311. "Iowa Reform", Davenport Centennial and Times Fiftieth Anniversary Edition. Davenport Daily Times, July 11, 1936. Martha Bowers MARLYS SVENDSEN -ROESLER SURVEY COMP. 1981 ARCHITECTURAL Local Supportive Poor 1 HISTORICAL Communications Settlement 1609-3 ARCHITECTURAL/HISTORICAL SURVEY DAVENPORT, IOWA DAVENPORT COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT Wehner, Nowysz, Pattschull and Pfiffner IOWA DIVISION OF HISTORIC PRESERVATION #82-10-2-W526 LEGAL DESCRIPTION CONTINUED: Pt of Lot 1 com at SE cor of SD Lot - W79' to beg - N par with W/L of Lot 64' W par with S/L of Lot 23.5' - S64' - E23.5' to beg. Historical Context 8B 4 In the 1890's several local merchants adopted the then new "department store" concept, among them the Petersen and Harned-Von Maur firms. Both erected new buildings in the city center, enabling these firms to dominate the local market well into the 20th century. After World War I, the Petersen firm was sold to Von Maur. The two were operated separately, however, until they were consolidated in the Petersen building in 1928. Other commercial activity in Davenport included a variety of grocery and hardware concerns, as well as numerous small businesses: saloons, restaurants, barbershops, pharmacies, bakeries, millineries and the like. Some of the latter located at neighborhood intersections as typical "corner stores" and continue to serve as such today, particularly on the city's west side. Underpinning the city's commercial life were the financial institutions. The earliest were private banks, offering local specie and an assortment of scrip, all of which suffered when the financial Panic of 1857 arrived in the midwest in 1858-59. With the establishment of the State Bank of Iowa (1859) and passage of the National Banking and Currency Act (1863), local banking resumed on a more reliable footing. In the ensuing years, the Davenport National Bank (1865), Citizens National (1867) and German and Davenport Savings banks (1869) were established as the city's major financial institutions. Another period of new bank organization occurred in the 1880's, including the Scott Co. Savings (1883) and Union Savings (1891) banks. Following passage of the Gold Standard Act of 1900, several local banks merged or were rechartered, and three more were founded. In addition, a number of the major institutions erected new buildings - large structures with modern structural systems and devoutly conservative neoclassical facades - that along with new hotel construction gave downtown Davenport a distinctly modern look. Areas of Significance: Settlement: Resources in this category include properties with general association, such as the Claim House (1329 College) and St. Anthony's Church (4-W116), as well as properties associated with the city's major immigrant groups. The largest and most influential group, the Germans, is represented by such resources as Saengerfest Halle (4W1012), East and Northwest Davenport Turner Halls (11-E2123, WH-1602), the Iowa Reform Building (2-W526) and numerous houses, most located in the Hamburg Historic District, that were once home to important members of the German community. The Irish, the city's second largest immigrant group, are represented primarily by St. Anthony's Church, Sacred Heart Cathedral (10-E406) Hibernia Hall (BR421) and are given further recognition in the Cork Hill Historic District. Davenport's black community, until the 1920's very small and scattered throughout the city, is represented by the 1910 Bethel A.M.E. Church (11-W325). H i s t o r i c a l Context 8B 5 Transportation: The major subthemes in this category are river -and rail transportation. There are no resources directly associated with 19th century river transportation. Most resources associated with railroad developments date from the early 20th century, and include Government Bridge, the CRI&P FreightHouse, Union Station, and the CRI&P elevated track, as well as the homes of pioneer railroad promoters Ambrose Fulton (RD-E1206) and Hiram Price (BR-819). Industry: Most of Davenport's major 19th century industrial plants are long gone, and for the most part resources under this theme are again houses associated with prominent industrial figures, such as Christian Mueller (6-W526) , Willimna Renwick (TT-901), Fritz Voss (3-W1454), Henry Frahm (6-W321) and Henry Klindt (MQ824). Industrial plants include U. N. Roberts (HA-332), Eagle Brewery (5-W1235) and Bettendorf Metal Wheel/French & Hecht Co. (4-E601). Commerce: Bank buildings from the 19th century were replaced in the first decades of the 20th, and include First National (2-W201), North Harrison Trust and Savings (HA-1601), Security Savings (2-W301) and Davenport Bank and Trust (3-W201). Several 19th century hotels remain, among them the notable Burtis-Kimball (4-E202), and Germania-Miller (2W313). The hotel boom of the early 20th century is amply represented in Hotel Davenport (MA-324), the Black Hawk (2-E206) and Mississippi (3-E110). The city's retail and wholesale trades are presented primarily by houses, such as Charles Beiderbecke's (7-W532), August Steffen, Sr.'s (6W420), J. C. Von Maur's (RD-E1800), and J.M.D. Burrows' (CV1533), and by the Petersen's Sons' store (2-W101). Government/Politics: Houses associated with former mayor and prominent political figures such as Henry Vollmer (BR-723), C.A. Ficke (MA-1208), and Hans Reimer Claussen (6-W413) are included in this category, as are the Scott County Jail, City Hall, and a number of fire stations that, in terms of buildings, provide a graphic illustration of the extension of city fire protection to neighborhoods early in the 20th century. Communications: Only a few buildings remain to associate with Davenport's once quite varied newspaper business, among them the Democrat and Leader building (BR-407), the Iowa Reform Building (2-W526), and the Henry Lischer (6-W520) and E. P. Adler (14-E629) houses. Telephone and telegraph systems are represented by Union Electric Telephone and Telegraph (HA-600) and the AT&T Building (MA-529) which date from the early years of telephone service in the city. Religion: This theme has been treated primarily in terms of churches' associations with various segments of the Davenport community, and in terms of size. Thus, the Roman Catholic faith is represented by a large number of structures, associated with the German and Irish communities and with Davenport's status as seat of the Second Iowa Diocese. As Davenport is also headquarters for Protestant Episcopalianism in Iowa, Trinity Cathedral and associated structures are also included. Other denominations represented include the Methodist Episcopal (Bethel AME (11-W325)), and St. John's (BR1325), Presbyterian (10-1702), and Lutheran (St. Paul's, MA-1402). 83-DC-107 Antiques Davenport Scott 526 W. 2nd 1973 United States Department of the Interior NATIONAL PARK SERVICE WASHINGTON, D.C. 20240 NOV 21 1983 The Director of the National Park Service is pleased to inform you that the following properties have been entered in the National Register of Historic Places beginning November 13, 1983 and ending November 19, 1983. For further information call (202) 343-9552. STATE, County/Vicinity, Property,Address,(Date Listed) ALABAMA, Greene County, Eutaw, Pierce, William F., House, 309 Womack Ave. (11/17/83) ALABAMA, Talladega County, Talladega, First Presbyterian Church, 130 North St. E (11/17/83) DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA, Mayflower Hotel, 1127 Connecticut Ave. NW (11/14/83) FLORIDA, Marion County, Mcintosh, Mcintosh Historic District, Roughly bounded by RR Right-of- way, 10th St., Aves. C and H (11/18/83) FLORIDA, Putnam County, Palatka, Palatka North Historic District, Roughly bounded by St. John's River, Bronson, N. 1st, N. 5th, and Main Sts. (11/17/83) FLORIDA, Putnam County, Palatka, Palatka South Historic District, Roughly bounded by St. John's River, Oak, S. 9th, and Morris Sts. (11/17/83) IOWA, Scott County, Davenport, College Square Historic District (Davenport MRA), Roughly bounded by Brady, Main, Harrison, 11th, and 15th Sts. (11/18/83) IOWA, Scott County, Davenport, East 14th Street Historic District (Davenport MRA), 14th St. from Pershing to Arlington Ave. (11/18/83) IOWA, Scott County, Davenport, Hamburg Historic District (Davenport MRA), Roughly bounded by 5th, Vine, Ripley, and 9 1/2 Sts. (11/187831 IOWA, Scott County, Davenport, Iowa Reform Building (Davenport MRA), 526 W. 2nd St. (11/18/83) IOWA, Scott County, Davenport, Motie, Joseph, House (Davenport MRA), 421 E. 10th St. (11/18/83) IOWA, Scott County, Davenport, West Third Street Historic District (Davenport MRA), Roughly 3rd St. between Ripley and Myrtle Sts. (11/18/83) KENTUCKY, Shelby County, Shelbyville vicinity, Allen Dale Farm, Off US 60 (11/17/83) MASSACHUSETTS, Hampshire County, South Hadley, Woodbridge Street Historic District, 3 and 7 Silver St., 25—82 Woodbridge St. (11/14/83) MISSISSIPPI, Amite County, Liberty vicinity, Webb, George, House, E of Old Zion Hill Rd. (11/17/83) MISSISSIPPI, Hinds County, Raymond vicinity, Magnolia Vale, Off MS 18 (11/17/83) MISSISSIPPI, Warren County, Vicksburg, Shlenker House, 2212 Cherry St. (11/17/83) NEW JERSEY, Essex County, Newark, Mutual Benefit Life Insurance Company, 300 Broadway and 2nd St. (11/17/83) NEW MEXICO, Rio Arriba County, Tsama Pueblo, (11/17/83) NEW MEXICO, San Miguel County, San Geronimo, San Geronimo Historic District, Off NM 283 (11/15/83) NORTH CAROLINA, Chatham County, Newkirk State (Site 31 Ch 366), (11/14/83) INDIVIDUAL N O M I N A T I O N S , D A V E N P O R T M U L T I P L E R E S O U R C E NOMINATION MAP NUMBER FOUR Address Easting Northing Key Reference 526 W. 2nd 701,840 4,599,270 A 246 W. 3rd 702,200 4,599,410 B 1401 " 700,720 4,599,300 C 2146 " 699,360 4,599,319 D 2236 " 699,250 4,599,300 E 210 E. 4th 702,580 4,599,250 F 226 W. 4th 702,210 4,599,540 G 320 " 702,070 4,599,530 H 601 " 701,790 4,599,460 I 1012 " 701,260 4,599,480 J 1332 " 700,790 4,599,480 K 2222 " 699,240 4,599,420 L 421 E. 10th 702,860 4,600,200 M 510 W. 10½th 701,970 4,600,250 N 2301 E. 11th 704,900 4,560,400 0 2224 E. 12th 704,860 4,600,570 P 229 Brady 702,450 4,599,370 Q 425 " 702,430 4,599,580 R 502 " 702,400 4,599,660 S 723 " 702,450 4,599,960 T 1527 " 702,410 4,600,820 U 1002 Bridge A v e . 703,710 4,600,300 V 1024 Charlotte 703,680 4,599,970 W 1446 Clay 700,600 4,600,250 X 522 Fillmore 700,720 4,599,660 Y 120 S. H a r r i s o n 702,150 4,599,190 Z 526 Iowa 702,750 4,599,720 AA 212 Main 702,270 4,599,310 BB 214 " 702,270 4,599,320 CC 407 " 702,330 4,599,540 DD 705 " 702,300 4,599,890 EE 105 S. Main 702,325 4,599,110 FF West 6th & M a r q u e t t e 701,070 4,599,730 GG 902 M a r q u e t t e 700,940 4,600,070 HH 1410 " 700,900 4,600,650 II 739 Perry 702,560 4,599,980 JJ 1315 " 702,530 4,600,600 KK INDIVIDUAL NOMINATION UTM'S DAVENPORT MULTIPLE RESOURCE NOMINATION MAP NUMBER FOUR Historic Preservation Ordinance Section 14.01.060 Certificate of Appropriateness Review Process C. Commission review process - Standards for review. In considering an application for a certificate of appropriateness, the commission shall be guided by the following general standards in addition to any other standards or guidelines established by ordinance for a local landmark or historic district. In all cases, these standards are to be applied in a reasonable manner, taking into full consideration the issue of economic feasibility and other technical considerations. 1. Every reasonable effort shall be made to make the minimal number of changes necessary to maintain a designated property in a good state of repair, thereby minimizing the impact of the proposed alteration; and 2. The removal, alteration or concealing of distinguishing exterior architectural features and historic material of a designated property should be avoided when possible; and 3. All designated property shall be recognized as a product and physical record of its time, place and use. Changes that create a false sense of historical development, such as adding conjectural architectural features shall be discouraged; and 4. Most properties change over time, and those changes that have acquired architectural and/or historical significance in their own right shall be recognized, respected and retained; and 5. Distinctive architectural features, construction techniques and/or examples of craftsmanship that characterize a designated property shall be treated with due consideration; and 6. Deteriorated architectural features should, where possible, be repaired rather than replaced. Where the severity of deterioration requires replacement, the new feature shall match the old in design, color, texture and other visual qualities and, where possible, materials. Replacement of missing features shall be substantiated by documentary, physical or pictorial evidence; and 7. Activities that cause deterioration of a designated property and its architectural features shall be discouraged. In those cases where the damage would be irreversible, such as sand-blasting and wet blasting fire-hardened bricks, the activities shall be prohibited. If cleaning is to be done, the gentlest means possible shall be encouraged; and 8. Known significant archeological resources possibly affected by a proposed activity shall be protected and preserved. If such resources must be disturbed, mitigation measures shall be undertaken; and 9. New additions and related new construction shall not be discouraged when such improvements do not destroy historic material and such design is compatible with the size, massing, scale, color, materials and character of the property, neighborhood and district, if applicable. D. Design criteria to implement review standards. When the commission is considering an application for a certificate of appropriateness, it shall consider the following architectural design criteria, or elements of design as they relate to the standards for review prescribed in Section 14.01.040C. 1. Height. The height of any proposed addition, construction or reconstruction should be compatible with the designated property and the surrounding structures, if located within a designated historic district; and 2. Proportions. The proportions (width versus height relationship) between doors and windows should be compatible, if not replicated, with the architectural design and character of the designated property; and 3. Scale. A proposed alteration, construction, reconstruction or addition should not negatively impact the scale of the designated property or district; and 4. Materials. Historic or original architectural features, or replacement elements which in all ways replicated the original, should be repaired whenever possible; and 5. Relationship of building masses and spaces. The relationship of a structure within a designated historic district to the rear, side and front yards between it and surrounding structures should be compatible; and 6. Roof shape. The roof design and shape should remain consistent with its original configuration and character; and 7. Site improvements. Landscaping and other site improvements, including off-street parking, should have as minimal of an impact as possible to the designated property's original plan/layout and its visual character. City of Davenport Department: Development & Neighborhood Services Action / Date Contact Info: Matt Werderitch | 563-888-2221 6/10/2025 Subject: Case COA25-07: Request for site improvements, restoration of existing structures, and new construction at 2800 Eastern Avenue. The Iowa Soldiers' Orphans' Home Historic District is a locally and nationally listed historic district. Annie Wittenmyer Family LLC, petitioner. [Ward 5] Recommendation: A recommendation is made to approve the Certificate of Appropriateness for site improvements, restoration of existing structures, and new construction at 2800 Eastern Avenue in accordance with the submitted material, subject to the following conditions: 1. Per the requirements of the National Park Service, the housing project shall be in compliance with The Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation. 2. As the design for the rehabilitation project progresses, any substantial modifications shall require a separate Certificate of Appropriateness Application and review by the Historic Preservation Commission. The project was reviewed for conformance with the Standards for Review, Chapter 14.01.060 C and D of the Davenport Municipal Code. The project meets the following standards: 1. Every reasonable effort shall be made to make the minimal number of changes necessary to maintain a designated property in a good state of repair, thereby minimizing the impact of the proposed alteration. 2. Deteriorated architectural features should, where possible, be repaired rather than replaced. Where the severity of deterioration requires replacement, the new feature shall match the old in design, color, texture and other visual qualities and, where possible, materials. Replacement of missing features shall be substantiated by documentary, physical or pictorial evidence. 3. Activities that cause deterioration of a designated property and its architectural features shall be discouraged. In those cases where the damage would be irreversible, such as sand-blasting and wetblasting fire-hardened bricks, the activities shall be prohibited. If cleaning is to be done, the gentlest means possible shall be encouraged. 4. New additions and related new construction shall not be discouraged when such improvements do not destroy historic material and such design is compatible with the size, massing, scale, color, materials and character of the property, neighborhood and district, if applicable. Background: Architectural Style and Significance: The Iowa Soldiers' Orphan's Home Historic District (Annie Wittenmyer Complex) is both a locally and nationally designated landmark. While the history of this area is extensive, a brief summary of its significance has been provided here: The grounds for the Orphans’ Home were developed over 15 decades beginning with the establishment of the Civil War Camp Roberts/Camp Kinsman and shifted into various orphanage uses by 1865. The campus’s significance is due to several factors. It is associated with an important social welfare effort – a state-operated orphanage for the children of Civil War veterans and indigent families. This is the first statewide orphanage to open in the country in the post-war period. Annie Wittenmyer, the founder and first matron, became a national figure serving as a major promoter of orphans’ homes. The orphanage also pioneered progressive child welfare initiatives, including the Cottage System of orphanage operation, an early foster care placement program, and one of Iowa’s first Montessori nursery school programs. The residential cottages are examples of simplified Queen Anne Style while the larger buildings are designed in the Romanesque Revival, Colonial Revival and PWA Moderne Styles. There are also examples of English Period Cottages. In addition, the complex contains archaeological significance dating from the early to middle Woodland Period (800 BC – 400 AD). Project Background: To best position the Annie Wittenmyer Campus for future redevelopment, the city intends to sell the land south of the Aquatic Center to a private developer with experience in historic preservation. The development will help promote the City’s objectives and provide several public benefits: enable adaptive reuse of the facilities, provide affordable housing, ensure historic preservation, and maintain open space. The developer, Annie Wittenmyer Family LLC, is utilizing both state and federal historic preservation tax credits to help finance the project. This provides an additional level of oversight regarding historic preservation of the campus, as the National Park Service reviews the development for compliance with The Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation. Request: The developer submitted a Certificate of Appropriateness Application to complete the Family Housing component of the project. The following is a summary of exterior changes to each building. 1. Children's Cottage: 1. The building will be converted into five apartment units. 2. There are four non-original asphalt shingle panels covering a corresponding window well on the west (rear) facade. These non-original building components will be removed. 2. Green House Building: 1. The building will be converted into four apartment units. 2. Apartment B, located on the lower level of the west elevation, will have a set of double steel doors removed. A new set of double doors with windows, similar in style to the adjacent door, will be installed in its place. The purpose of the windows is to provide natural light into the living room. 3. Ice House Building: 1. The building will be converted into six apartment units. 2. A non-original doghouse dormer will be removed from the roof. The area will be covered with matching shingles. 3. The garage doors on the east elevation will be removed and infilled with matching units. Since the interior of this space is an apartment unit, the doors will not be operable. The replacement units will be made of wood and replicate the grid pattern. The second row from the top will have windows, offering natural light for the living spaces within. These measures are being taken to satisfy requirements of the National Park Service, which request that the building resemble its original character and functional appearance. 4. There are missing windows on the west elevation of the one-story addition. If windows exist behind the plywood, then the units will be refurbished and reinstalled. Otherwise, any replacement windows will replicate the material and style of the units on the south elevation. 5. Brick is missing from the porch column on the east elevation. To the greatest extent practicable, this area will be infilled with masonry units that match the size, color, and texture of the original brick. 4. Garage Building: 1. A Certificate of Public Hazard was issued on April 19, 2022 by the Chief Building Official and Fire Marshall. 2. The garage building was subsequently demolished in 2024. 3. A new structure will be constructed in the same location, footprint, and dimensions as the previously demolished garage building. 4. Per a requirement of the National Parks Service, the new structure will replicate the former garage in materials, size, massing, roof shape, color, and other visual qualities. 5. A total of two apartment units will be within the new building. 6. Non-functioning garage doors with windows will be built to match the exterior doors of the Ice House. Likewise, these units will not be operable and serve an aesthetic and historic purpose. 5. Boy's Training Building: 1. The building will be converted into five apartment units. 2. A new entrance will be created on the east elevation, leading to an existing set of double doors. A concrete split staircase will be constructed with a metal hand railing. The design and materials will replicate the existing exterior stairs on the same elevation. 6. Cottages (1-10): 1. A total of twenty-four units will be created within the existing cottage buildings. 2. Cottages 1-4, 6, and 10 will be retrofitted into two apartment units. 3. Cottages 5 and 7-9 will be converted into three apartment units. 4. The steel fire escape slides will be removed from each building. 7. Site Improvements: 1. Parking areas: A total of 96 parking spaces will be provided for the family housing project. Parking stalls are generally located in previously development areas on the property. The functional circulation of vehicles and pedestrians throughout the campus will remain. The site has driveway access to both Eastern Avenue and East 29th Street. 2. Dog walk: A 1,000-square-foot dog walk area will provide an amenity space for pet owners adjacent to the new garage building. Fencing materials have not yet been identified. 3. Dumpster enclosures: A total of three dumpster enclosures are proposed for the family housing project. Details on the type of wall, fence, gate, and landscaping have not yet been provided. General Building Maintenance and Improvements: Masonry: A complete project scope of brick restoration has yet to be identified. However, it is evident that cleaning, tuck pointing, and brick replacement are needed. Staff recommend a mortar analysis be performed prior to tuckpointing the brick facade of each structure. The purpose of a mortar analysis is to determine the three components of historic mortar: the binder, fines, and the sand/aggregate. Using improper mortar can result in brick spalling. The applicant indicated a mortar analysis would be conducted prior to the start of work per requirements of the National Park Service. The work write-up indicates deteriorated brick will be replaced with historic brick. However, additional information on the type, dimensions, color, or texture of the replacement brick has not been submitted for review. Therefore, staff recommend a condition that the replacement brick visually match the existing masonry units. The Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation recommends the following practices for tuckpointing and brick replacement: 1. Replacing in kind an entire masonry feature that is too deteriorated to repair - if the overall form and detailing are still evident - using physical evidence to guide the new work. Examples can include large sections of walls. If using the same kind of material is not technically or economically feasible, then a compatible substitute material may be considered. 2. Repairing masonry walls and other masonry features by repointing the mortar joints where there is evidence of deterioration. 3. Removing deteriorated mortar by carefully hand-raking the joints to avoid damaging the masonry. 4. Duplicating old mortar in strength, composition, color, and texture. 5. Duplicating old mortar joints in width and in joint profile. Windows: The applicant's overall intent is to repair existing windows when available. Any replacement units will resemble existing windows on the structure in material and appearance. However, a window survey documenting the existing condition of each unit within the development has not yet taken place. The purpose of a survey is to identify the extent of deterioration and to provide a decision basis as to whether the windows should be repaired or replaced. The developer intends to perform this analysis and submit it to the National Park Service for review. The Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation recommends the following practices for window repair and replacement: 1. Identifying, retaining, and preserving windows-and their functional and decorative features-that are important in defining the overall historic character of the building. 2. Protecting and maintaining the wood and architectural metal which comprise the window frame, sash, muntins, and surrounds through appropriate surface treatments such as cleaning, rust removal, limited paint removal, and re-application of protective coating systems. 3. Repairing window frames and sash by patching, splicing, consolidating or otherwise reinforcing. Such repair may also include replacement in kind--or with compatible substitute material--of those parts that are either extensively deteriorated or are missing when there are surviving prototypes such as architraves, hoodmolds, sash, sills, and interior or exterior shutters and blinds. 4. Replacing in kind an entire window that is too deteriorated to repair-if the overall form and detailing are still evident-using the physical evidence to guide the new work. If using the same kind of material is not technically or economically feasible, then a compatible substitute material may be considered. Roofs: An assessment on the condition of each roof has not yet been performed. However, it is evident that complete or partial roof replacement is warranted. The developer expressed that roofing material will be replaced in-kind. This includes both pitched and flat-roofed structures on the campus. Flat roofs appear to be covered with a rubber membrane. Whereas, pitched roofs are protected with an asphalt architectural shingle. Staff are supportive of roof replacement materials that will maintain the historic integrity of the structure and keep the building in a good state of repair. Building Code Compliance: Since the existing structures will be retrofitted into housing units, additional code requirements will need to be addressed. The most impactful alterations to the exterior of structures will be venting for kitchens, bathrooms, and laundry rooms. Detailed building plans have not yet identified the locations of venting apparatuses and covers. Attachments: 1. Application 2. Plan Set 3. Photos 4. Section 14.01.060.C Certificate of Appropriateness Review Process APPLICATION FOR CITY OF DAVENPORT Development & Neighborhood Services _ Planning CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS 1200 E. 46th St HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION Davenport, IA 52807 RESOURCE TYPE SUBMITTAL DATE MEETING DATE Office 563.326.6198 Iowa Soldier's Orphan District 05/30/2025 06/10/2025 planning@davenportiowa.com SITE ADDRESS & PARCEL NUMBER and/or HISTORIC NAME APPLICANT INFORMATION Iowa Soldiers' Orphans' Home Application Name | Company Name BRIEF OVERVIEW OF THE PROJECT (not a scope of work) Annie Wittenmyer Family, LLC Historic Adaptive Reuse of Lot 3 as affordable workforce housing Address 1621 Progressive Parkway City | State | Zip APPLICABILITY PRIOR to any work on applicable Historic Resources: Plateville, WI A Certificate of Appropriateness must be submitted & approved Phone PRIOR to the commencement of the following:  Any Building or Sign Permit changing the exterior (except demo) Secondary Phone  New construction/Addition or exterior alteration of a structure  Sign installation or alteration E-Mail Address Demolition of any local or national historic resources shall require a Historic Demolition Request Application Acceptance of Applicant ALL SUBMITTALS SHALL INCLUDE: SUBMITTED I, the undersigned, certify that the information on this application to the best of my knowledge is true and correct. I further certify that I have a legal interest in Full Scope of Work (SOW) attached as a .PDF all work & materials shall be described & itemized/listed in detail the property in question, and/or that I am legally able to represent all other persons or entities with interest in this property, and acknowledge formal Photos or renderings of all existing building/sign façades procedure and submittal requirements. Proposed color building/sign elevations to scale I understand I am responsible for attendance at the meeting as shown on the rendered showing existing and/or proposed building materials historic preservation commission calendar. The City reserves the right to Material specs: type, dimensions, color & manufacturer require further site studies as necessary. MINOR & MAJOR ADDITIONS, SITE IMPROVEMENTS, & By checking this box and typing my name below, NEW BUILDINGS SHALL INCLUDE ADDITIONAL ITEMS*: I am electronically signing this application. Dimensioned Site Plan (proposed & existing buildings/site items) Grading Plan with 2 foot intervals (if needed) Mechanical Screening shall be shown Type Applicant's Name here to serve as a signature Date Materials Board of sample building materials proposed DEVELOPMENT TEAM * Major Additions & New Buildings may require more extensive information Property Owner Application Fee: NONE Formal Procedure City of Davenport (1) Application: Address • Prior to submission of the application, the applicant shall correspond with Planning staff to discuss the request, potential alternatives and the process. • The submission of the application does not constitute official acceptance by the City of Davenport. Planning staff will review the application for completeness and notify the applicant Phone Secondary Phone that the application has been accepted or additional information is required. Inaccurate or incomplete applications may result in delay of applicant's scheduled meetings. (2) Scope of Commission's Consideration: E-Mail Address • Only work described in the application may be approved. • If insufficient information exists to make a proper judgment on the application, the Commission may continue the consideration a maximum of 60 days, excluding applicant's continuances. Project Manager/Other (3) Post Commission Ruling: Chris Ales • An approved Cert. of Appropriateness does not constitute a City permit or license and does vest against any other land development regulation or regulatory approval. Applicant must contact Address necessary development authorities. • Appeals to determinations are $75 made to City Council and shall be in writing submitted to 1101 West 9th Street, Davenport, Iowa 52804 the Zoning Administrator within 30 calendar days of Commission’s decision. Phone Secondary Phone E-Mail Address Submit this form with attachments to: planning@davenportiowa.com revised Jan. 2025 1424d WEST ASHLEY ROAD Annie Wittenmyer Campus BOONVILLE, MO 65233 Family Housing 660-865-6326 Renovation Project Davenport, IOWA REVISIONS -- Annie Wittenmyer 2828 eastern Avenue HANDICAPPED ACCESSIBLE HEARING LOSS ACCESSIBLE ACCESSIBLE ROUTE OUTSIDE BUILDING Davenport, ia SHEET DESCRIPTION JOB NO.:1004.012 DATE: 02/14/2024 DRAWN BY: SM c 2023 meco a/e, llc SHEET No. 1424d WEST ASHLEY ROAD TOTAL PARKING: BOONVILLE, MO 65233 660-865-6326 96 PARKING SPACES (INCLUDING 14 HANDICAPPED) 12" CITY WATER MAIN 12" CITY WATER MAIN 12" CITY WATER MAIN CITY WATER MAIN CITY SAN SEWER MAIN REVISIONS -- N AI M ER AT W Y IT "C 12 MAIN WATER 12" CITY 12" CITY WATER MAIN 12" CITY WATER MAIN Annie Wittenmyer 2828 eastern Avenue Davenport, ia SHEET DESCRIPTION JOB NO.:1004.012 DATE: 02/14/2024 DRAWN BY: SM C101 c 2023 meco a/e, llc SHEET No. 1424d WEST ASHLEY ROAD BOONVILLE, MO 65233 660-865-6326 ICE SERV LECT O.H. E 6" CITY WATER MAIN 6" CITY WATER MAIN E SE RVIC LECT O.H. E PROPOSED SIDEWALK CITY SAN SEWER MAIN GAS CIT GAS Y SA GAS NS GAS EW GAS GA GAS ER S GAS M AIN GAS GAS GAS GA S ICE SERV GA LECT S O.H. E GA GA MAIN S S GA WATER S GA S GA S 6" CITY GA S GA S O.H. ELECT SERVICE GA S GAS GAS GAS GAS GA GA S S 6" CITY WATER MAIN IC E SERV GA LECT 12" CITY WATER MAIN S O.H. E GA GAS GAS GAS GAS S GAS GAS GAS GA GAS S CIT GA YS S AN SE WE GAS GA RM S AIN E GA SE S RV IC GAS GA S .E LE GA CT S O. H GAS 12" CITY WATER MAIN 12" CITY WATER MAIN GAS GAS 6" CITY WATER MAIN U.G. FIBER OPTIC OPTIC GAS GAS FIBER U.G. FIBER OPTIC U.G. U.G. FIBER OPTIC U.G. FIBER OPTIC GAS GAS U.G. FIBER OPTIC GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS CIT GAS GAS YS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS AN GAS GAS GA GAS SE S WE WA T ER MA IN GAS S GA RM AIN GAS GA S REVISIONS Y CIT 6" GA S O PT IC GAS GAS GA S -- ER CITY SAN SEWER MAIN B FI GAS GAS GA . GAS G S .G ICE AS U GA S O.H. ELECT SERV S GA GAS G AS S GAS GA G CITY SAN SEWER MAIN CITY SAN SEWER MAIN AS G S AS GA GAS GA S GAS GAS GAS 6" CITY WATER MAIN G AS G S GAS AS GA S GA G GAS S AS G GA AS S GA GA G G S AS AS S GAS GA S GA G AS ACCESSIBLE ROUTE OUTSIDE BUILDING O.H. ELECT SERVICE S GA GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS TOTAL PARKING: GAS S GA N GAS GAS GAS 96 PARKING SPACES AI M GA S (INCLUDING 14 HANDICAPPED) ER GAS GAS AT W O.H. ELEC S Y T SERVICE GA IT 6" CITY WATER MAIN 6" CITY WATER MAIN 6" CITY WATER MAIN GAS 12 "C GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS 6" CITY WATER MAIN ICE ICE ECT SE O.H. ELECT SERV GAS RV GAS CITY SAN SEWER MAIN 6" CITY WATER MAIN O.H. EL GAS GAS GAS GA S GAS GAS S GA GA GAS S GAS GAS GAS O.H. ELECT SERVICE GAS O.H. ELECT SERVICE GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GA S AIN RM TE WA ITY GAS S 6" C GA S GA GAS GAS MAIN GAS WATER GAS 12" CITY GAS O.H. ELECT SERVICE GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS MAIN WATER GAS GAS GAS 6" CITY EXISTING PARKING LOT GAS GAS GAS O.H. EL GAS Annie Wittenmyer GAS GAS RVICE ECT SE GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS 12" CITY WATER MAIN 12" CITY WATER MAIN 12" CITY WATER MAIN GAS 12" CITY WATER MAIN U.G. COAX CABLE U.G. COAX CABLE U.G. COAX CABLE GAS GAS GAS GAS 2828 eastern Avenue GAS GAS O.H. ELECT SERVICE O.H. ELECT SERVICE GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS O.H. ELECT SERVICE GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS O.H. ELECT SERVICE GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS GAS Davenport, ia SHEET DESCRIPTION JOB NO.:1004.012 DATE: 02/14/2024 DRAWN BY: SM C102 c 2023 meco a/e, llc SHEET No. 1424d WEST ASHLEY ROAD BOONVILLE, MO 65233 660-865-6326 REVISIONS -- Children's Cottage Building Existing Lower Level Floor/Demo PLAN Annie Wittenmyer 2828 eastern Avenue Davenport, ia SHEET DESCRIPTION Existing Floor Plan JOB NO.:1004.012 DATE: 02/14/2024 DRAWN BY: SM 1-AD101 c 2023 meco a/e, llc SHEET No. 1424d WEST ASHLEY ROAD BOONVILLE, MO 65233 660-865-6326 REVISIONS -- Annie Wittenmyer 2828 eastern Avenue Children's Cottage Building Existing 1st Floor/Demo PLAN Davenport, ia SHEET DESCRIPTION Existing Floor Plan JOB NO.:1004.012 DATE: 02/14/2024 DRAWN BY: SM 1-AD102 c 2023 meco a/e, llc SHEET No. 1424d WEST ASHLEY ROAD BOONVILLE, MO 65233 660-865-6326 REVISIONS -- Annie Wittenmyer 2828 eastern Avenue Children's Cottage Building Proposed Lower Level Plan Davenport, ia SHEET DESCRIPTION Proposed Lower Level Plan JOB NO.:1004.012 DATE: 02/14/2024 DRAWN BY: SM 1-A101 c 2023 meco a/e, llc SHEET No. 1424d WEST ASHLEY ROAD BOONVILLE, MO 65233 660-865-6326 REVISIONS -- Annie Wittenmyer 2828 eastern Avenue Davenport, ia Children's Cottage Building Proposed 1st Floor Plan SHEET DESCRIPTION Proposed 1st Floor Plan JOB NO.:1004.012 DATE: 02/14/2024 DRAWN BY: SM 1-A102 c 2023 meco a/e, llc SHEET No. 1424d WEST ASHLEY ROAD BOONVILLE, MO 65233 660-865-6326 REVISIONS -- Apt "A" FLOOR PLAN 3 Bedroom neat rentable area: 1503 sq ft net/ 1650 sq ft gross Annie Wittenmyer 2828 eastern Avenue Davenport, ia SHEET DESCRIPTION Apartment Floor Plan Apt "B" FLOOR PLAN JOB NO.:1004.012 DATE: 02/14/2024 DRAWN BY: SM neat rentable area: 1337 sq ft net/ 1457 sq ft gross 1-A401 c 2023 meco a/e, llc SHEET No. 1424d WEST ASHLEY ROAD BOONVILLE, MO 65233 660-865-6326 REVISIONS -- Apt "C" FLOOR PLAN 2 Bedroom neat rentable area: 1159 sq ft net/ 1261 sq ft gross Annie Wittenmyer 2828 eastern Avenue Davenport, ia Apt "D" FLOOR PLAN SHEET DESCRIPTION Apartment 3 Bedroom Floor Plan neat rentable area: 1210 sq ft net/ 1332 sq ft gross JOB NO.:1004.012 DATE: 02/14/2024 DRAWN BY: SM 1-A402 c 2023 meco a/e, llc SHEET No. 1424d WEST ASHLEY ROAD BOONVILLE, MO 65233 660-865-6326 REVISIONS -- Annie Wittenmyer 2828 eastern Avenue Davenport, ia Greenhouse Existing Greenhouse Existing Basement Floor/Demo Plan 1st Floor/Demo Plan SHEET DESCRIPTION Existing/Demo Floor Plan JOB NO.:1004.012 DATE: 02/14/2024 DRAWN BY: SM 2-AD101 c 2023 meco a/e, llc SHEET No. 1424d WEST ASHLEY ROAD BOONVILLE, MO 65233 660-865-6326 REVISIONS -- Annie Wittenmyer 2828 eastern Avenue Davenport, ia Greenhouse Proposed Greenhouse Proposed Basement Floor Plan 1st Floor Plan SHEET DESCRIPTION Proposed Floor Plan JOB NO.:1004.012 DATE: 02/14/2024 DRAWN BY: SM 2-A101 c 2023 meco a/e, llc SHEET No. 1424d WEST ASHLEY ROAD BOONVILLE, MO 65233 660-865-6326 REVISIONS -- Apartment "A" FLOOR PLAN Apartment "A" HVAC PLAN Scale: 1/4" = 1'-0" Scale: 1/4" = 1'-0" C C C C C C C C C C H H H H H H H H H C C H H C C H H C C H H C H C H C H C H C H C H H C H C H H C C H C H C H C H H H H H H H H H H H H H H H H H H H H H H C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C Apartment "A" Plumbing PLAN Annie Wittenmyer Scale: 1/4" = 1'-0" 2828 eastern Avenue Davenport, ia SHEET DESCRIPTION Apartment Floor Plan Apartment "A" Waste PLAN JOB NO.:1004.012 DATE: 02/14/2024 DRAWN BY: SM Apartment "A" Electric PLAN Scale: 1/4" = 1'-0" 2-A401 c 2023 Scale: 1/4" = 1'-0" meco a/e, llc SHEET No. 1424d WEST ASHLEY ROAD BOONVILLE, MO 65233 660-865-6326 REVISIONS -- Apartment "B" FLOOR PLAN Apartment "B" HVAC PLAN Apartment "B" Electric PLAN Scale: 1/4" = 1'-0" Scale: 1/4" = 1'-0" Scale: 1/4" = 1'-0" H H H H H H H H H C C C C C C C C C C H H H C C C H H H C C C H H C C H H C C H C C H C H C H Annie Wittenmyer C C H C C C H C H C 2828 eastern Avenue C H C H C H C H Davenport, ia C H C H C H C C H C H C H C C C H H H C C H H C C SHEET DESCRIPTION H H Apartment Floor Plan C C C H H H C C C C JOB NO.:1004.012 C H H C H H H DATE: 02/14/2024 DRAWN BY: SM Apartment "B" Waste PLAN C C H H H H H H H H H H H H H H C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C Apartment "B" Plumbing PLAN 2-A402 Scale: 1/4" = 1'-0" c 2023 meco a/e, llc Scale: 1/4" = 1'-0" SHEET No. 1424d WEST ASHLEY ROAD BOONVILLE, MO 65233 660-865-6326 Apartment "C" HVAC PLAN Apartment "C" FLOOR PLAN Scale: 1/4" = 1'-0" REVISIONS Scale: 1/4" = 1'-0" -- C C C C C C C C C C H C C H C H C C H C H C C C C C C C C C C C C C H H H H H H H H H C C H H C C H H C C H C C C H C H C H C H H C C H H H H H C C C C C C Apartment "A" Plumbing PLAN Scale: 1/4" = 1'-0" Annie Wittenmyer 2828 eastern Avenue Davenport, ia SHEET DESCRIPTION Apartment Floor Plan JOB NO.:1004.012 DATE: 02/14/2024 DRAWN BY: SM Apartment "C" Electric PLAN Apartment "C" Waste PLAN 2-A403 c 2023 Scale: 1/4" = 1'-0" meco a/e, llc Scale: 1/4" = 1'-0" SHEET No. 1424d WEST ASHLEY ROAD BOONVILLE, MO 65233 660-865-6326 REVISIONS -- Apartment "D" FLOOR PLAN Apartment "D" HVAC PLAN Apartment "D" Electric PLAN Scale: 1/4" = 1'-0" Scale: 1/4" = 1'-0" Scale: 1/4" = 1'-0" Annie Wittenmyer 2828 eastern Avenue Davenport, ia SHEET DESCRIPTION Apartment Floor Plan JOB NO.:1004.012 DATE: 02/14/2024 DRAWN BY: SM 2-A404 c 2023 meco a/e, llc SHEET No. 1424d WEST ASHLEY ROAD BOONVILLE, MO 65233 660-865-6326 C C C C C C C C C C C H C H H H H H H H H C H C H C C H C H C H C H C H C C H H C H C H C H C C C H C C C H C C H C H H H C C C C C C C H C C H C C H C C C H C H C H REVISIONS C C H C H C -- H C C H H C C H H H H H H H H H H C C C C H C C C C C C C C C C H C H C H C H C C C C C C C C C C H H H H H H H H H H C H H C H H C H C C H C H C H C C C H H H Apartment "D" Plumbing PLAN Apartment "D" Waste PLAN Scale: 1/4" = 1'-0" Scale: 1/4" = 1'-0" Annie Wittenmyer 2828 eastern Avenue Davenport, ia SHEET DESCRIPTION Apartment Floor Plan JOB NO.:1004.012 DATE: 02/14/2024 DRAWN BY: SM 2-A404.1 c 2023 meco a/e, llc SHEET No. 1424d WEST ASHLEY ROAD BOONVILLE, MO 65233 660-865-6326 REVISIONS -- Annie Wittenmyer 2828 eastern Avenue Davenport, ia Ice House Existing Lower Level Floor PLAN SHEET DESCRIPTION Existing Floor Plan JOB NO.:1004.012 DATE: 02/14/2024 DRAWN BY: SM 3-AD101 c 2023 meco a/e, llc SHEET No. 1424d WEST ASHLEY ROAD BOONVILLE, MO 65233 660-865-6326 REVISIONS -- Annie Wittenmyer 2828 eastern Avenue Davenport, ia Ice House Existing 1st FLOOR PLAN SHEET DESCRIPTION Existing Floor Plan JOB NO.:1004.012 DATE: 02/14/2024 DRAWN BY: SM 3-AD102 c 2023 meco a/e, llc SHEET No. 1424d WEST ASHLEY ROAD BOONVILLE, MO 65233 660-865-6326 REVISIONS -- Annie Wittenmyer 2828 eastern Avenue Davenport, ia Ice House Existing 2nd FLOOR PLAN SHEET DESCRIPTION Existing Floor Plan JOB NO.:1004.012 DATE: 02/14/2024 DRAWN BY: SM 3-AD103 c 2023 meco a/e, llc SHEET No. 1424d WEST ASHLEY ROAD BOONVILLE, MO 65233 660-865-6326 REVISIONS -- Annie Wittenmyer 2828 eastern Avenue Davenport, ia Ice House Existing 3rd FLOOR PLAN SHEET DESCRIPTION Existing Floor Plan JOB NO.:1004.012 DATE: 02/14/2024 DRAWN BY: SM 3-AD104 c 2023 meco a/e, llc SHEET No. 1424d WEST ASHLEY ROAD BOONVILLE, MO 65233 660-865-6326 REVISIONS -- Annie Wittenmyer 2828 eastern Avenue Davenport, ia Ice House Proposed Lower Level FLOOR PLAN SHEET DESCRIPTION Proposed Floor Plan JOB NO.:1004.012 DATE: 02/14/2024 DRAWN BY: SM 3-A101 c 2023 meco a/e, llc SHEET No. 1424d WEST ASHLEY ROAD BOONVILLE, MO 65233 660-865-6326 REVISIONS -- 2 Annie Wittenmyer A2-3.1 2828 eastern Avenue Davenport, ia Ice House Proposed 1st FLOOR PLAN SHEET DESCRIPTION Proposed Floor Plan JOB NO.:1004.012 DATE: 02/14/2024 DRAWN BY: SM 3-A102 c 2023 meco a/e, llc SHEET No. 1424d WEST ASHLEY ROAD BOONVILLE, MO 65233 660-865-6326 See Detail 2 A5-3.1 REVISIONS -- Annie Wittenmyer 2828 eastern Avenue Davenport, ia Ice House Proposed 2nd FLOOR PLAN SHEET DESCRIPTION Proposed Floor Plan JOB NO.:1004.012 DATE: 02/14/2024 DRAWN BY: SM 3-A103 c 2023 meco a/e, llc SHEET No. 1424d WEST ASHLEY ROAD BOONVILLE, MO 65233 660-865-6326 REVISIONS -- 1 A2-3.1 Annie Wittenmyer 2828 eastern Avenue Davenport, ia Ice House Proposed Loft & 3rd FLOOR PLAN SHEET DESCRIPTION Proposed Floor Plan JOB NO.:1004.012 DATE: 02/14/2024 DRAWN BY: SM 3-A104 c 2023 meco a/e, llc SHEET No. 1424d WEST ASHLEY ROAD BOONVILLE, MO 65233 660-865-6326 1 Interior Loft Wall Elevation A2-3.1 Location: Loft Walkway along Bedrooms, Apt F Scale: NTS REVISIONS -- Annie Wittenmyer 2828 eastern Avenue Davenport, ia 1 A2-3.1 Exterior Elevation Location: East Exterior Wall on Apt 'D' Scale: NTS SHEET DESCRIPTION Elevations JOB NO.:1004.012 DATE: 02/14/2024 DRAWN BY: SM 3-A201 c 2023 meco a/e, llc SHEET No. A3-3.1 1424d WEST ASHLEY ROAD BOONVILLE, MO 65233 660-865-6326 REVISIONS -- Annie Wittenmyer 2828 eastern Avenue Davenport, ia 1 Ice House West Elevation Section View A3-3.1 SHEET DESCRIPTION West Elevation Section JOB NO.:1004.012 DATE: 02/14/2024 DRAWN BY: SM 3-A301 c 2023 meco a/e, llc SHEET No. 1424d WEST ASHLEY ROAD BOONVILLE, MO 65233 660-865-6326 Apt "A" FLOOR PLAN Apt "A" HVAC PLAN REVISIONS Scale: 3/16" = 1'-0" Scale: 3/16" = 1'-0" -- C C C C H C C H C C H C C C C C C C C C C C C C H C H C C H C H C H C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C H H H H H H H H H H H H H H H H C H C H C H C H C H C C H C H C H H H C C C Apt "A" Plumbing PLAN Annie Wittenmyer Scale: 3/16" = 1'-0" 2828 eastern Avenue Apt "A" Elecric PLAN Davenport, ia Scale: 3/16" = 1'-0" SHEET DESCRIPTION Apartment Floor Plan JOB NO.:1004.012 DATE: 02/14/2024 DRAWN BY: SM 3-A401 c 2023 meco a/e, llc Apt "A" Waste PLAN SHEET No. Scale: 3/16" = 1'-0" 1424d WEST ASHLEY ROAD BOONVILLE, MO 65233 660-865-6326 REVISIONS -- Apt "B" FLOOR PLAN Apt "B" HVAC PLAN Apt "B" Elecric PLAN Scale: 3/16" = 1'-0" Scale: 3/16" = 1'-0" Scale: 3/16" = 1'-0" C C H H C C C C H C C C C C C C C C C C H C H C H H H H C C H C H C H C H C H C H C H C C H C H C H C H C H C Annie Wittenmyer H C H C C H C H C H H H 2828 eastern Avenue C C C C H C H C H H H H H H H H H H H H H H H H H H H H H H H H C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C H C H C C H H C H H H Davenport, ia C C C C Apt "B" Plumbing PLAN Apt "B" Waste PLAN Scale: 3/16" = 1'-0" Scale: 3/16" = 1'-0" SHEET DESCRIPTION Apartment Floor Plan JOB NO.:1004.012 DATE: 02/14/2024 DRAWN BY: SM 3-A402 c 2023 meco a/e, llc SHEET No. 1424d WEST ASHLEY ROAD BOONVILLE, MO 65233 660-865-6326 REVISIONS -- Apt "C" FLOOR PLAN Apt "C" HVAC PLAN Apt "C" Elecric PLAN Scale: 3/16" = 1'-0" Scale: 3/16" = 1'-0" Scale: 3/16" = 1'-0" C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C H H H H H H H H H H H H H H H H H H H H H H C C C C C H H H H C C C C C H H H C H C C C C H H C C C H C C H C C H C C H C H C H C C H H C C H H C C H H C C H H C C H C C H C H C C H H C C H C H C H C H H H C H C H H C C C Annie Wittenmyer 2828 eastern Avenue Davenport, ia Apt "C" Plumbing PLAN Apt "C" Waste PLAN Scale: 3/16" = 1'-0" Scale: 3/16" = 1'-0" SHEET DESCRIPTION Apartment Floor Plan JOB NO.:1004.012 DATE: 02/14/2024 DRAWN BY: SM 3-A403 c 2023 meco a/e, llc SHEET No. 1424d WEST ASHLEY ROAD BOONVILLE, MO 65233 660-865-6326 REVISIONS -- Apt "D" FLOOR PLAN Apt "D" HVAC PLAN Apt "D" Elecric PLAN Scale: 3/16" = 1'-0" Scale: 3/16" = 1'-0" Scale: 3/16" = 1'-0" C H C C H C C H H C H C C H C H H H H H H H H H H H C C C C C C C C C C C C C C H C H C C H H C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C H H H H H H H H H H H C C H C H C H C H C C H C H C H H C H C H C H C H Annie Wittenmyer C H C H C C H C H C C C C C H H H H H 2828 eastern Avenue Davenport, ia Apt "D" Plumbing PLAN Apt "D" Waste PLAN Scale: 3/16" = 1'-0" Scale: 3/16" = 1'-0" SHEET DESCRIPTION Apartment Floor Plan JOB NO.:1004.012 DATE: 02/14/2024 DRAWN BY: SM 3-A404 c 2023 meco a/e, llc SHEET No. 1424d WEST ASHLEY ROAD BOONVILLE, MO 65233 660-865-6326 REVISIONS -- Apt "E" 2nd Level FLOOR PLAN Apt "E" 1st Level FLOOR PLAN Scale: 3/16" = 1'-0" Scale: 3/16" = 1'-0" Annie Wittenmyer 2828 eastern Avenue Davenport, ia Apt "E" 1st Level HVAC PLAN Apt "E" 2nd Level HVAC PLAN Scale: 3/16" = 1'-0" Scale: 3/16" = 1'-0" SHEET DESCRIPTION Apartment Floor Plan JOB NO.:1004.012 DATE: 02/14/2024 DRAWN BY: SM 3-A405 c 2023 meco a/e, llc SHEET No. 1424d WEST ASHLEY ROAD BOONVILLE, MO 65233 660-865-6326 Apt "E" 1st Level Electric PLAN Apt "E" 2nd Level Electric PLAN REVISIONS -- Scale: 3/16" = 1'-0" Scale: 3/16" = 1'-0" C C C C C C C C C C H C C H H C C C C H C C H C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C H C C H H H H H H H H H H H H H H H H H H H C C C H H C C H C H C C H C C H C C H C C C C H C H H H H H C C H H C C C C C C C C H C C H C C C C C C C C C H H H H H H C H Apt "E" 1st Level Plumbing PLAN Apt "E" 2nd Level Plumbing PLAN Scale: 3/16" = 1'-0" Scale: 3/16" = 1'-0" Annie Wittenmyer 2828 eastern Avenue Davenport, ia SHEET DESCRIPTION Apartment Apt "E" 2nd Level Waste PLAN Floor Plan JOB NO.:1004.012 DATE: 02/14/2024 Scale: 3/16" = 1'-0" Apt "E" 1st Level Waste PLAN DRAWN BY: SM 3-A405.1 Scale: 3/16" = 1'-0" c 2023 meco a/e, llc SHEET No. 1424d WEST ASHLEY ROAD BOONVILLE, MO 65233 660-865-6326 REVISIONS -- Apt "F" 1st Level FLOOR PLAN Apt "F" 2nd Level FLOOR PLAN Scale: 3/16" = 1'-0" Scale: 3/16" = 1'-0" Annie Wittenmyer 2828 eastern Avenue Davenport, ia Apt "F" 1st Level HVAC PLAN Apt "F" 2nd Level HVAC PLAN Scale: 3/16" = 1'-0" Scale: 3/16" = 1'-0" SHEET DESCRIPTION Apartment Floor Plan JOB NO.:1004.012 DATE: 02/14/2024 DRAWN BY: SM 3-A406 c 2023 meco a/e, llc SHEET No. 1424d WEST ASHLEY ROAD BOONVILLE, MO 65233 660-865-6326 Apt "F" 1st Level Electric PLAN Apt "F" 2nd Level Electric PLAN REVISIONS -- Scale: 3/16" = 1'-0" Scale: 3/16" = 1'-0" C C C C H C C C H C C H C C C H H C C H H H H H C H H H H H H C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C H H C C H H C C C H H H H C C H C H H C C H C C H C H C H C H C H Annie Wittenmyer 2828 eastern Avenue Davenport, ia Apt "F" Plumbing PLAN Apt "F" Waste PLAN Scale: 3/16" = 1'-0" Scale: 3/16" = 1'-0" SHEET DESCRIPTION Apartment Floor Plan JOB NO.:1004.012 DATE: 02/14/2024 DRAWN BY: SM 3-A406.1 c 2023 meco a/e, llc SHEET No. 1424d WEST ASHLEY ROAD BOONVILLE, MO 65233 660-865-6326 1 Typ Window Dtl 2 Special Window Dtl REVISIONS A5-3.1 Scale: NTS A5-3.1 Location: Under Loft Level Apt 'F' -- Scale: NTS Annie Wittenmyer 2828 eastern Avenue Davenport, ia SHEET DESCRIPTION Details JOB NO.:1004.012 DATE: 02/14/2024 DRAWN BY: SM 3-A501 c 2023 meco a/e, llc SHEET No. 1424d WEST ASHLEY ROAD BOONVILLE, MO 65233 660-865-6326 REVISIONS -- Garage Building Proposed 1ST FLOOR PLAN Annie Wittenmyer 2828 eastern Avenue Davenport, ia Garage Building Proposed Lower Level FLOOR PLAN SHEET DESCRIPTION Proposed Floor Plan JOB NO.:1004.012 DATE: 02/14/2024 DRAWN BY: SM 4-A101 c 2023 meco a/e, llc SHEET No. 1424d WEST ASHLEY ROAD BOONVILLE, MO 65233 660-865-6326 East Exterior Elevation Scale: 1/4" = 1'-0" North Exterior Elevation REVISIONS Scale: 1/4" = 1'-0" -- Annie Wittenmyer 2828 eastern Avenue Davenport, ia South Exterior Elevation SHEET DESCRIPTION Exterior Scale: 1/4" = 1'-0" Elevations West Exterior Elevation JOB NO.:1004.012 DATE: 02/14/2024 DRAWN BY: SM 4-A201 Scale: 1/4" = 1'-0" c 2023 meco a/e, llc SHEET No. 1424d WEST ASHLEY ROAD BOONVILLE, MO 65233 660-865-6326 REVISIONS -- Apartment 'A' FLOOR PLAN Annie Wittenmyer 2828 eastern Avenue Davenport, ia SHEET DESCRIPTION Apartment Floor Plan JOB NO.:1004.012 DATE: 02/14/2024 DRAWN BY: SM 4-A401 c 2023 meco a/e, llc SHEET No. 1424d WEST ASHLEY ROAD BOONVILLE, MO 65233 660-865-6326 REVISIONS -- Annie Wittenmyer 2828 eastern Avenue Davenport, ia Boys Training Building Existing 1ST FLOOR PLAN SHEET DESCRIPTION Existing Floor Plan JOB NO.:1004.012 DATE: 02/14/2024 DRAWN BY: SM 5-AD101 c 2023 meco a/e, llc SHEET No. 1424d WEST ASHLEY ROAD BOONVILLE, MO 65233 660-865-6326 REVISIONS -- Annie Wittenmyer 2828 eastern Avenue Davenport, ia Boys Training Building Existing 2nd FLOOR PLAN SHEET DESCRIPTION Existing Floor Plan JOB NO.:1004.012 DATE: 02/14/2024 DRAWN BY: SM 5-AD102 c 2023 meco a/e, llc SHEET No. 1424d WEST ASHLEY ROAD BOONVILLE, MO 65233 660-865-6326 REVISIONS -- Annie Wittenmyer 2828 eastern Avenue Davenport, ia Boys Training Building Proposed 1ST FLOOR PLAN SHEET DESCRIPTION Propose Floor Plan JOB NO.:1004.012 DATE: 02/14/2024 DRAWN BY: SM 5-A101 c 2023 meco a/e, llc SHEET No. 1424d WEST ASHLEY ROAD BOONVILLE, MO 65233 660-865-6326 REVISIONS -- Annie Wittenmyer 2828 eastern Avenue Davenport, ia Boys Training Building Proposed 2nd FLOOR PLAN SHEET DESCRIPTION Proposed Floor Plan JOB NO.:1004.012 DATE: 02/14/2024 DRAWN BY: SM 5-A102 c 2023 meco a/e, llc SHEET No. 1424d WEST ASHLEY ROAD BOONVILLE, MO 65233 660-865-6326 REVISIONS -- Apt "A" FLOOR PLAN Apt "B" FLOOR PLAN 2 Bedroom ADA Accessible 3 Bedroom neat rentable area: 1386 sq ft net/ 1504 sq ft gross neat rentable area: 1464 sq ft net/ 1577 sq ft gross Annie Wittenmyer 2828 eastern Avenue Davenport, ia SHEET DESCRIPTION Apartment Floor Plan JOB NO.:1004.012 DATE: 02/14/2024 DRAWN BY: SM 5-A401 c 2023 meco a/e, llc SHEET No. 1424d WEST ASHLEY ROAD BOONVILLE, MO 65233 660-865-6326 REVISIONS -- Apt "C" FLOOR PLAN Apt "D" FLOOR PLAN 3 Bedroom 2 Bedroom neat rentable area: 1080 sq ft net/ 1168 sq ft gross neat rentable area: 833 sq ft net/ 930 sq ft gross Annie Wittenmyer 2828 eastern Avenue Davenport, ia SHEET DESCRIPTION Apartment Floor Plan JOB NO.:1004.012 DATE: 02/14/2024 DRAWN BY: SM 5-A402 c 2023 meco a/e, llc SHEET No. 1424d WEST ASHLEY ROAD BOONVILLE, MO 65233 660-865-6326 REVISIONS -- Apt "E" FLOOR PLAN 2 Bedroom neat rentable area: 831 sq ft net/ 915 sq ft gross Annie Wittenmyer 2828 eastern Avenue Davenport, ia SHEET DESCRIPTION Apartment Floor Plan JOB NO.:1004.012 DATE: 02/14/2024 DRAWN BY: SM 5-A403 c 2023 meco a/e, llc SHEET No. 1424d WEST ASHLEY ROAD BOONVILLE, MO 65233 660-865-6326 REVISIONS -- Typical Cottage 2nd Floor Typical Cottage Attic Annie Wittenmyer Typical Cottage 1ST FLOOR Existing Floor/Demo plan Existing Floor/Demo Plan Existing Floor/Demo Plan 2828 eastern Avenue Davenport, ia Typical Cottage #'S 1-5, 7-9 SHEET DESCRIPTION Existing Floor Plan JOB NO.:1004.012 DATE: 02/14/2024 DRAWN BY: SM 6-AD101 c 2023 meco a/e, llc SHEET No. 1424d WEST ASHLEY ROAD BOONVILLE, MO 65233 660-865-6326 REVISIONS -- Corner Cottage (#6) 1ST FLOOR Corner Cottage (#6) 2nd Floor Annie Wittenmyer Existing Floor/Demo plan Existing Floor/Demo Plan 2828 eastern Avenue Davenport, ia SHEET DESCRIPTION Existing Floor Plan JOB NO.:1004.012 DATE: 02/14/2024 DRAWN BY: SM 6-AD102 c 2023 meco a/e, llc SHEET No. 1424d WEST ASHLEY ROAD BOONVILLE, MO 65233 660-865-6326 REVISIONS -- End Cottage (#10) 1ST FLOOR End Cottage (#10) 2nd Floor Annie Wittenmyer Existing Floor/Demo plan Existing Floor/Demo Plan 2828 eastern Avenue Davenport, ia SHEET DESCRIPTION Existing Floor Plan JOB NO.:1004.012 DATE: 02/14/2024 DRAWN BY: SM 6-AD103 c 2023 meco a/e, llc SHEET No. 1424d WEST ASHLEY ROAD BOONVILLE, MO 65233 660-865-6326 REVISIONS -- Annie Wittenmyer Typical Cottage 2nd Floor 2828 eastern Avenue Typical Cottage 1ST FLOOR Proposed Floor plan (#1-5, 7-9) Proposed Floor Plan (#1-4 ONLY) Davenport, ia SHEET DESCRIPTION Proposed Floor Plan JOB NO.:1004.012 DATE: 02/14/2024 DRAWN BY: SM 6-A101 c 2023 meco a/e, llc SHEET No. 1424d WEST ASHLEY ROAD BOONVILLE, MO 65233 660-865-6326 REVISIONS -- Annie Wittenmyer Typical Cottage 2nd Floor Typical Cottage 3rd Floor 2828 eastern Avenue Proposed Floor Plan (#5 & 7-9 ONLY) Proposed Floor Plan (#5 & 7-9 ONLY) Davenport, ia SHEET DESCRIPTION Proposed Floor Plan JOB NO.:1004.012 DATE: 02/14/2024 DRAWN BY: SM 6-A102 c 2023 meco a/e, llc SHEET No. 1424d WEST ASHLEY ROAD BOONVILLE, MO 65233 660-865-6326 REVISIONS -- Corner Cottage (#6)1ST FLOOR Corner Cottage (#6) 2nd Floor Annie Wittenmyer Proposed Floor plan Proposed Floor Plan 2828 eastern Avenue Davenport, ia SHEET DESCRIPTION Proposed Floor Plan JOB NO.:1004.012 DATE: 02/14/2024 DRAWN BY: SM 6-A103 c 2023 meco a/e, llc SHEET No. 1424d WEST ASHLEY ROAD BOONVILLE, MO 65233 660-865-6326 REVISIONS -- End Cottage (#10) 1ST FLOOR End Cottage (#10) 2nd Floor Annie Wittenmyer Proposed Floor plan Proposed Floor Plan 2828 eastern Avenue Davenport, ia SHEET DESCRIPTION Proposed Floor Plan JOB NO.:1004.012 DATE: 02/14/2024 DRAWN BY: SM 6-A104 c 2023 meco a/e, llc SHEET No. 1424d WEST ASHLEY ROAD BOONVILLE, MO 65233 660-865-6326 REVISIONS -- Annie Wittenmyer Apt 'A' Floor plan Apt 'B' Floor plan 2828 eastern Avenue Davenport, ia SHEET DESCRIPTION Apartment Floor Plan JOB NO.:1004.012 DATE: 02/14/2024 DRAWN BY: SM 6-A401 c 2023 meco a/e, llc SHEET No. 1424d WEST ASHLEY ROAD BOONVILLE, MO 65233 660-865-6326 REVISIONS -- Apt 'C' Floor plan Annie Wittenmyer Apt 'D' Floor plan 2828 eastern Avenue Davenport, ia SHEET DESCRIPTION Apartment Floor Plan JOB NO.:1004.012 DATE: 02/14/2024 DRAWN BY: SM 6-A402 c 2023 meco a/e, llc SHEET No. 1424d WEST ASHLEY ROAD BOONVILLE, MO 65233 660-865-6326 REVISIONS -- Annie Wittenmyer Apt 'E' Floor plan Apt 'F' Floor plan 2828 eastern Avenue Davenport, ia SHEET DESCRIPTION Apartment Floor Plan JOB NO.:1004.012 DATE: 02/14/2024 DRAWN BY: SM 6-A403 c 2023 meco a/e, llc SHEET No. 1424d WEST ASHLEY ROAD BOONVILLE, MO 65233 660-865-6326 REVISIONS -- Annie Wittenmyer Apt 'G' Floor plan Apt 'H' Floor plan 2828 eastern Avenue Davenport, ia SHEET DESCRIPTION Apartment Floor Plan JOB NO.:1004.012 DATE: 02/14/2024 DRAWN BY: SM 6-A404 c 2023 meco a/e, llc SHEET No. Historic Preservation Ordinance Section 14.01.060 Certificate of Appropriateness Review Process C. Commission review process - Standards for review. In considering an application for a certificate of appropriateness, the commission shall be guided by the following general standards in addition to any other standards or guidelines established by ordinance for a local landmark or historic district. In all cases, these standards are to be applied in a reasonable manner, taking into full consideration the issue of economic feasibility and other technical considerations. 1. Every reasonable effort shall be made to make the minimal number of changes necessary to maintain a designated property in a good state of repair, thereby minimizing the impact of the proposed alteration; and 2. The removal, alteration or concealing of distinguishing exterior architectural features and historic material of a designated property should be avoided when possible; and 3. All designated property shall be recognized as a product and physical record of its time, place and use. Changes that create a false sense of historical development, such as adding conjectural architectural features shall be discouraged; and 4. Most properties change over time, and those changes that have acquired architectural and/or historical significance in their own right shall be recognized, respected and retained; and 5. Distinctive architectural features, construction techniques and/or examples of craftsmanship that characterize a designated property shall be treated with due consideration; and 6. Deteriorated architectural features should, where possible, be repaired rather than replaced. Where the severity of deterioration requires replacement, the new feature shall match the old in design, color, texture and other visual qualities and, where possible, materials. Replacement of missing features shall be substantiated by documentary, physical or pictorial evidence; and 7. Activities that cause deterioration of a designated property and its architectural features shall be discouraged. In those cases where the damage would be irreversible, such as sand-blasting and wet blasting fire-hardened bricks, the activities shall be prohibited. If cleaning is to be done, the gentlest means possible shall be encouraged; and 8. Known significant archeological resources possibly affected by a proposed activity shall be protected and preserved. If such resources must be disturbed, mitigation measures shall be undertaken; and 9. New additions and related new construction shall not be discouraged when such improvements do not destroy historic material and such design is compatible with the size, massing, scale, color, materials and character of the property, neighborhood and district, if applicable. D. Design criteria to implement review standards. When the commission is considering an application for a certificate of appropriateness, it shall consider the following architectural design criteria, or elements of design as they relate to the standards for review prescribed in Section 14.01.040C. 1. Height. The height of any proposed addition, construction or reconstruction should be compatible with the designated property and the surrounding structures, if located within a designated historic district; and 2. Proportions. The proportions (width versus height relationship) between doors and windows should be compatible, if not replicated, with the architectural design and character of the designated property; and 3. Scale. A proposed alteration, construction, reconstruction or addition should not negatively impact the scale of the designated property or district; and 4. Materials. Historic or original architectural features, or replacement elements which in all ways replicated the original, should be repaired whenever possible; and 5. Relationship of building masses and spaces. The relationship of a structure within a designated historic district to the rear, side and front yards between it and surrounding structures should be compatible; and 6. Roof shape. The roof design and shape should remain consistent with its original configuration and character; and 7. Site improvements. Landscaping and other site improvements, including off-street parking, should have as minimal of an impact as possible to the designated property's original plan/layout and its visual character. City of Davenport Department: Development & Neighborhood Services Action / Date Contact Info: Matt Werderitch | 563-888-2221 6/10/2025 Subject: Party in the Park Recommendation: Hold Discussion. Background: The Historic Preservation Commission will partner with Davenport Public Library-Special Collections and the Scott County Historic Preservation Society to host a table at Party in the Park. The Commission will participate at the following dates & locations: 1. Thursday, July 17, 2025 | Fejervary Park | 5:30 p.m. – 7:30 p.m. 2. Thursday, August 7, 2025 | Credit Island Park | 5:30 p.m. – 7:30 p.m. Party in the Park attendees can enjoy food, entertainment, and a variety of activities for the kids! These events are a great opportunity to meet fellow residents, learn more about surrounding neighborhoods, and engage with local elected officials. Members from city staff will be in attendance to discuss concerns and opportunities facing the community and how to can get involved in your neighborhood. Commissioners should sign up for dates and discuss potential ideas for the table. Attachments: None