Human Relations Commission

Human Relations Commission (HRC) Recommendations For City of DeKalb July 7, 2020 The recent months of local and national protests organized in response to the tragic and avoidable deaths of citizens by police have focused attention on reducing police violence and improving community and police relationships. The DeKalb community has also been protesting these tragedies and has also called for changes to current policing methods. Utilizing several community forums, town hall meetings and the media, the community has identified a number of recommendations to reduce police violence and improve the relationships between the police and community. The number of recommendations received and the wide involvement of DeKalb residents has likely been one of the largest community responses to any issue in the city’s history. The DeKalb community is to be commended for this high level of participation by so many voices. The HRC wishes to thank the community for its concerns, ideas for change and energy to see these changes enacted. Since so many recommendations and comments have been made by the public, the HRC believes that the city should review all of these recommendations. Therefore, the HRC recommendations are more focused upon organizational processes and individual attitudes that are needed to accomplish this thorough and fair review of the community’s recommendations. Therefore, the Human Relations Commission at its July 7, 2020 meeting voted to present the following recommendations and concerns to the City of DeKalb.  HRC RECOMMENDATIONS 1. As stated, the HRC strongly believes that the City of DeKalb should review all community recommendations in recognition of the need for changes overwhelmingly expressed at our recent community events. 2. The HRC strongly recommends that the city increase its commitment to a community policing model and the full implementation of its components. The demilitarization of police and the change from a “warrior” culture to a “guardian” culture will have an immediate impact on the public’s perception of our police force. Our community has seen the positive outcomes from our police department’s involvement in various community projects (e.g. Project H.O.P.E., The COMPASS Program, and Camp Power). Added community involvement through a more comprehensive community policing model will have a positive impact and engender more trust. Experience has shown that walking the neighborhoods, becoming a known individual and knowing residents by name may transform police/community relations. 3. The HRC also recommends that those community recommendations that have already been completed or are in process, should be immediately communicated to the DeKalb community via all media avenues. Some of the following may have been addressed by the City and Police Department. If so, the HRC recognizes the City for having made these changes, but still lists them as top concerns for the HRC.  2 Rec. 3 Cont. a. Replace officers with social workers as first responders for non- violent mental health, drug and public nuisance cases. b. Prohibit the use of no-knock warrants. c. Establish clear criteria for traffic stops, frisks, detainment, and a system for monitoring and evaluating such stops. d. Prohibit the use of military grade equipment in response to peaceful protests, including grenade launchers, bayonets, tear gas, pepper spray, rubber bullets, skip fire rounds & concussion sound devices. e. Expand cultural competency training for City Staff and Police/Fire Personnel. f. Ensure that ongoing training for City Staff and Police/Fire Personnel include training on implicit bias, antiracism work and conflict de-escalation. g. Provide transparency and thorough background checks in the hiring of officers. h. Assure accountability for officer misconduct and, in particular, for use of excessive force. 4. The HRC recommends that the Campaign Zero organization document (included in the July 13, 2020 City Council Meeting packet) be used by the Mayor, City staff, Police Dept. and City Council as a good starting point for further information and research data to assist in reviewing the recommendations and formulating changes to be made.  3 Rec. 4 Cont. The Campaign Zero document also uses many of the same categories for change that were utilized by the HRC to sort the community recommendations into categories. There are other national organizations that addresses changes needed for police departments that could also be reviewed for assistance. The Campaign Zero organization (www.joincampaignzero.org/solutions) is simply a recommended resource that would serve as a starting point on reviewing our community recommendations. Other valuable resources include: 8 Abolition, Poor Peoples Campaign, National Black Lives Matter, and the Illinois NAACP and Illinois Association of Chief of Police agreed principles. 5. It is recommended that the recommendations that require changes to State of Illinois statutes be identified and lobbying begin with appropriate State of Illinois Representatives, Illinois Police Associations, etc. and a staff member be appointed to be the lead in this effort. 6. The HRC recommends that the city provide updates to the community through all media to inform them about progress on the review and investigation and decisions of changes based upon the recommendations. 7. The HRC also recommends that city updates be presented to the HRC at its regularly scheduled meetings. 8. The HRC recommends that the City use resources in the community to assist with the task of reviewing and deciding upon recommendations (e.g. community social service agencies). The City has individuals and organizations that can provide assistance with this review. The HRC is but one organization that is ready to assist. The  Rec. 8 Cont. 4 community has many others that can be consulted about a particular recommendation or need for more information. 9. The HRC recommends that, if the city determines that the review of these recommendations or review of some groupings of recommendations would best be conducted by establishing a smaller task/coordinating group, then besides the task group members being selected from the City staff, Police Department, and a City Council liaison, that such a smaller task group include two community representatives. 10.The HRC recommends that whether a recommendation is assigned to a staff member, small group or other entity, that such individuals or groups need to: a. Research the recommendation using recognized organizations and/or knowledgeable individuals/professionals. b. Identify other municipalities that have implemented the recommendations and, if at all possible, visit the municipalities. c. Share the information with all stakeholders. d. Decide, only after the above steps are completed, whether the recommendation under study can be implemented as stated or with some modifications or record why the recommendation is not possible. 11.The HRC recommends that the City use an operating principle to not discard or discount any recommendation because it, at first, seems “impossible”. Outright discarding of recommendations defeats the honest effort needed  5 Rec. 11 Cont. to consider how the city can implement a recommendation or at least, modify it so the community can be certain that the city made sincere efforts to review and implement as many recommendations as possible. 12. The HRC also strongly recommends that the Police Department Not be allowed to reject the consideration of any recommendation. This is particularly significant with any changes that would require contract negotiations. Our police union must be responsive to reforms. 13. The HRC recommends that the community recommendations be considered and implemented as quickly as possible. 14. Finally, it is recommended that an Action Plan be developed to prioritize the recommendations with timelines and staff or groups assigned to coordinate and report the review of the recommendations. These prioritized recommendations and their timelines should also be made public. Respectfully, City of DeKalb Human Relations Commission Larry Apperson, Chair Nadine Franklin Norden Gilbert David Barrow Joe Gastiger Lisa King HRC Categorization of DeKalb Community Input on Improving Police and Community Relationships This document compiled by the Human Relations Committee (HRC) lists: 1. All the recommendations stated at the DeKalb County Community Forum on June 4, 2020; HRC Special Meeting on June 16, 2020; Black Lives Matter Town hall Meeting on June 18, 2020; the June 22, 2020 City of DeKalb Committee of the Whole Meeting; and the Black Lives Matter Lists of Demands reported in the June 25, 2020 Daily Chronicle and 2. All those recommendations that were received in a written format. The specific HRC Recommendations to the City of DeKalb are attached to this listing of community recommendations. Note: The HRC categories were selected by first grouping similarly themed recommendations together and then selecting a title that encompassed these grouped recommendations. Category titles also tried to incorporate some words from nationally reported categories. This was done to allow for anyone to search the main title words and locate more information on the category title topic. Note: The HRC regrets any errors in accurately reflecting the verbal recommendations as they were turned into written ones. The numbers in ( ) indicate number of similar statements. Mental Health Personnel to Respond to Non-violent Calls 1. Have Social Workers go to non-violent calls.(1) Utilizing mental and Social health workers as partners in police action. (1) 2. Decriminalization of mental illnesses.(taking into custody those with mental illness, charging and jailing vs mental health treatment & care.) 3. Armed officers should be partnered with an unarmed individual (community professional) only when responding to a call where there is a danger of violence. 4. Replace officers with social workers as first responders for non- violent mental-health, drug, and domestic cases. Police response should only be considered as a last resort. 5. The City and Police Dept. to review how to add mental health and social workers as on-call professionals to assist police in responding to domestic disputes and those with mental or emotional disabilities. It is recommended that the DeKalb County Mental Health and other local mental health agencies be consulted.  2 Transfer of Dollars to Increase Support of Social Services 1. More social services. (1) Increased social services. (1) 2. Find ways to divest from policing and instead make meaningful investments in health care, education and counseling services. 3. The system should be rebuilt from the ground up by dismantling the municipal police and starting over. (3 similar) 4. Cut the police department’s budget by 50% and put it into community services. 5. Reallocate funds to more social services specializing in areas of abuse, rape, drug abuse, and adolescence behavior, etc. will relieve some of the burden on police as the catch all responders. 6. Defund does not mean unfund, but rather allocate funds to services to help police and citizens. 7. Cut the Police Department’s Patrol Division’s Budget by 50% and divert those funds to hiring social workers, providing de-escalation training for officers and social workers, investing in the DeKalb County Community Mental Health Board, and the Annie Glidden North Revitalization Project. 8. Do not gut the programs from the police department that contribute to the quality of life in the community. 9. Support initiatives that are in partnership with other community institutions. 10. Look at how City Budget is supporting community values of social services, community needs, etc. Limit Use of Force/De-militarization of Police/Increase Community Policing Limit Use of Force 1. Ban use of excessive force. (1) No tolerance for excessive force. (2)  3 2. Prohibit police maneuvers that restrict the flow of blood or oxygen to the brain, and treat the use of excessive force as a federal civil rights violation. 3. Adopt the rules for police that are a part of the Justice in Policing Act of 2020 (choke hold use, dashboard & body camera use, national registry that tracks officers with records of misconduct, end the use of no-knock warrants in drug cases, ban racial profiling, require training, make lynching a federal hate crime, end qualified immunity for officers and make them personally liable for constitutional violations such as excessive force and require state and local law enforcement agencies to report use of force data by race, sex, disability status, religion and age).(4) 4. Compare our police practices to those of Campaign Zero rec. practices. 5. An increased amount of transparency of the police force. (1) Increasing transparency in the officer hiring process. (1) 6. Continue the review of the Police Department Policies and Procedures with a diverse citizen’s committee to identify those that may allow or result in discriminatory actions or excessive use of force. 7. Adjust the official DeKalb City Police Department procedures for the use of force to include predetermined consequences for the use of excessive force, including drafting zero –tolerance consequences for an injuring or potentially life-threatening violation. 8. Initiate mandatory, public reports for any time an officer unholsters a weapon, lethal or less lethal, as well as any use of force. The report will include justification for the action. 9. There must be no tolerance of excessive force; to this end, Jeffery Weese should be immediately terminated. (1) Press charges against and fire Sgt. Jeffery Weese for the use of an illegal chokehold without severance pay.(1) Punishment for other officers involve in incident that contributed to excessive force. (1) 10.Provide public with answers all the way through investigation and conclusions of complaints against police.  4 11.Need to track who is being stopped (race, sex, age, etc.) and reasons for stop. 12.Do not hire police officers with previous misconduct records.(1) Disqualify any candidate who has been formally judged to have exerted excessive force. (1) 13.Look into hiring police with non-traditional police backgrounds. 14.Possible licensing police officers. 15.Create a hiring policy that overtly strives to build a police force that represents the diversity in our community. 16.Implement mandatory dash-cam and body cameras for officers.(1) All officers in DeKalb must have full body camera coverage (on) any and every time they interact with citizens and must immediately be indicted and terminated in the event they tamper with, disable, or obstruct the camera (view).(1) 17.Police must be required to report any police use of force and be required to intervene if a fellow officer is applying excessive force. (1) Create an obstruction-free path for citizens to hold officers accountable who use excessive force or who do not intervene when excessive force is used. (1) Require a public report whenever force is used or threatened. (1) 18.Examine the underlying philosophy for use of force policies and procedures (for assumptions and actions that contribute to the use of excessive force). 19. Mandatory, public reports for any case that requires or received medical treatment as a result of an arrest, unless the arrested individual requests that information remains private. 20.Require police, or any other party aiding in de-escalation, to exhaust all other alternatives to de-escalation, starting from least to most invasive, before firing any weapon.  5 21. Any officer who uses, or has a past history of using excessive force needs to be indicted and fired without severance pay.(1) Retroactive firing of police officers with records of excessive force abuse. (1) 22. Any officer who uses, or has a past history of using a chokehold needs to be indicted and fired without severance pay. 23. Any officer who does not intervene and de-escalate police use of excessive force must be indicted and fired without severance pay. 24. Require police to present a clear and understood warning before firing any weapon. 25. Provide mental health support for police officers. 26. Ban the City of DeKalb (or its police) from working, or collaborating in any way, with Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE). (3) 27. Address “stop and frisk”/Terry stops and avoid harassment on the basis of race.(1) Establish clear criteria for traffic stops, frisks, detainment, and a system for monitoring and evaluating such stops. (1) 28. Add whistleblower protection for police who report witnessing excessive force or racial targeting. Demilitarization 1. Change the police culture from one of the “Warrior Mindset” to that of a “Guardian Mindset” 2. Prohibit the use of no-knock warrants 3. Withdraw from any federal programs that provide military equipment to law enforcement.(2) 4. Make police less paramilitary. 5. Police should divest themselves of all military type weapons and equip- ment. (2)  6 6. Police should carry less ammunition. 7. Issuing 6-shot, .38 caliber revolvers to police, banning reloads and back-up guns would both lessen the officers’ natural tendency to regard 8. the available massive firepower as a main component of their occupation and would present a far less hostile and threatening image to the public …. 9. No additional points for hiring in regard to military experience. 10.Resource officers removed from schools. 11.Police need to be banned from any school that serves children under 18 years of age. 12.The City enact prohibitions against police use of military grade equipment in response to peaceful demonstrations/protests. This prohibition to include use of grenade launchers, bayonets, tear gas, pepper spray, rubber bullets, skip fire rounds, and concussion sound devices. 13.Police should wear police uniforms, not military-style BDUs (Battle Dress Uniforms). 14.Body armor (protective vests) should be worn under the uniform to avoid the appearance of hostility or aggression. 15.Changing the name of the Police Headquarters to something less intimidating. Move to a more community-based policing strategy 1. Move to Fuller Use of Community Policing (Guardian culture, etc.) 2. Require police officers to live in the community they serve. (1) Preference to applicants willing to live within the community. (1) 3. Police should be out walking a beat more often with less use of the police vehicle.(2)  7 4. More officers participating in events in non-uniform. 5. Police and public should have a shared value system. 6. Use the best practices of other communities. 7. Implement the community-led public safety model of law enforcement.(2) Independent Investigations & Prosecutions 1.Hold police accountable for their actions by ending the qualified immunity doctrine that prevents law enforcement officers from being held accountable when they violate the law. 2.Hold police accountable for what they do and treat them the same as civilians. No slap on the wrists. Police are civilians. 3.Support the national Justice in Policing Act 2020. (re: Indp. Invest.) 4.Prosecute officers independently, under a state’s attorney subcontract, to prevent people who work with the police from prosecuting the police. (likely means use of non-DeKalb County State’s Attorney office). (1) Utilize an entity independent of the police in the review and prosecution of police officers. (1) Training 1. Continue Cultural competency training for City Staff and Police/Fire Personnel. (2) Training for everyone, including City Council. (1) 2. Education and training on implicit bias.(3) 3. The city to require de-escalation training (2). 4. Continue training of officers in philosophy and techniques of anti- racism, human rights and respect.  8 5. A review of the State of Illinois Police Training Academy that details each training component including the diversity and de-escalation training. Lobby appropriate state authorities to make changes, if necessary. (1) 6. Review the DeKalb County Sheriff’s Police Academy for the need for more diversity and de-escalation training. (1) 7. Current and future officers must complete crisis intervention training and de-escalation training. 8. Training on the impact of trauma (from aggressive police interventions). Community Oversight & Representation 1. A standing citizen advisory board on citizen and police interaction and relations. (1) Establish a citizens’ community council. (1) 2. Create a Citizens’ Review Board that represents the diversity of the community and that has a significant role in overseeing the hiring process and in monitoring the use of force and citizen complaints. 3. Public input into the hiring of the new police chief and quickly. (1) Bring back the interview panels for hiring police chief. (1) (Police Chief) hired by community. (1) 4. Database of photographs and a system of all police officers so the community can identify them. 5. Not allow the Mayor to pick people for committees. 6. Do not select “buddies” for committee assignments. 7. Continue local practice of independent investigation and review of policing discipline matters and keep the Fire and Police Commission as a local appeal board for such matters. 8. More diversity reflected in the decision-making room.  9 9. Have equal opportunities for minorities to become officers. 10.Interview minority applicants regardless of qualifying test results. 11.Rebuild community trust with police (by making changes wanted by community). 12.Look into hiring (for police force, those) with non-traditional police backgrounds. 13.Possibly licensing police officers. 14.Public disclosure of all complaints filed against officers.(3) End of Police Involvement in Creating Revenue or Costing Cities for their Violations of Constitutional Rights. 1.End For-Profit Policing (refer to Campaign Zero for further info.) 2.End the Cash Bail System. (at County Jail and locally) (1) End cash bail for nonviolent crimes. (1) 3.Settlements of use of force should come from police pensions as opposed to through taxpayer’s (funds). 4.Requiring officers to have their own liability insurance. 5.Take fines from the police department and put it in the community. 6.Revisit the NIU/DeKalb Co-policing agreement. Work on specificity of liability claims that leave the city open for liability. (payments) Investment in Social Services, Recreational Opportunities, Housing-leases, Economic Improvement for Those in Poverty Conditions, Jobs, Education, etc. 1. Reallocation of funds to solve the root problems of poverty, poor education, and other problems that foster crime.  10 2. Spending more money on preventative measures to minimize the police force. 3. Restructure the allocation of the money throughout the city and reimagine how a different set up could serve the community. 4. Community members are losing possible hires due to DeKalb having a stigma that it is a racist community. 5. The poverty level is how we should allocate resources. 6. Implement a common lease. 7. The City of DeKalb will partner with the DeKalb Tenant Association to establish and enforce a common lease.(1) Working with a tenants’ to ensure that renters are aware of their rights. (1) 8.Ensuring lease provisions with strong renter protection against unpredictable or unreasonable fees/penalties and against failure to provide livable conditions. 9.Demo 912 Edgebrook Housing. 10.Demo Campus Cinema and turn it into a community center (1) or food center (1). 11. More parks in the AGN area. 12. Rent Control 13.Build more affordable housing. 14. City of DeKalb to establish a minimum wage in DeKalb. 15. Work with local institutions to revise local support of housing, education, jobs, and healthcare services. 16. Remove those systems/procedures that perpetuate individuals stuck in a muli-generational cycle of poverty.  11 Police Contract Changes 1.Extensive vetting of officer and not allowing (hiring individuals with) any excessive force background. 2.Get rid of any clause for the deletion of records after three years in the Collective bargaining agreement. 3.Consequences for actions individuals (police) take. 4.Mayor will re-open police contract regarding firing officers. 5.Monthly psych exams for officers. 6.Recruits should have a psych and trauma evaluation. Then have a support system in place for police during their tenure. 7.More vigorous temperament screening. 8.The law MUST apply to police also, there MUST be appropriate justice for their victims. 9.Hold police accountable for their actions by ending the “qualified immunity” doctrine that prevents law enforcement officers from being held accountable when they violate the law. (1) Reform qualified immunity and other obstacles to holding officers accountable. (1) 10.Review the Police/City Union Contract to determine if there are sections that shield abusive officers from public accountability. If such clauses are identified, to work in negotiations to eliminate such clauses. Justice System Reforms 1. Work with criminal justice system (i.e. courts, judges and prosecutors) to implement restorative justice model, complementing traditional methods of justice. Do not continue a strict retributive theory of punishment – i.e. when an offender breaks the law, requiring they suffer in return.  12 2. Sentencing is whole another issue. (Unequal sentencing of POC.) (1) Our Justice system has failed us. (1) Work with criminal justice system. (1) 3. Eliminate the negative interactions of incarceration with poverty, homelessness, and mental health. 4. Reduce bureaucracy in the law enforcement and criminal justice system. Statements of Concern & Others The following statements stated either a general concern without indicating a specific recommendation or were unclear in the wording/intent and/or could be a part of every recommendation. Consequently, these statements were not able to be placed under one of the above categories. However, several state important issues that are worthy of addressing as a community. 1. Distrust of police by the black community. (Yes, a fact that could apply to all recommendations. If most of recs. under all categories implemented, then the distrust likely be reduced.) 2. We need to not have a quick solution. We need a permanent solution (Amen!) 3. Needs to be taken more seriously. (Unfortunately, not specific to an action, but all recommendations need to be taken very seriously!) 4. Address the white supremacy groups in the area. (Yes, an issue. Benefit from knowing how this individual believes this issue could be addressed.) 5. Several recommendations were listed under the call for the BLM to meet with: City Council and Police Department, City Council and Community members, and the County Board and officials of the 23rd Circuit Judicial System along with interested community members to discuss and implement a number of recommendations appearing in various above categories. From: Praying With Our Feet, A DeKalb County Jewish Committee for Social Justice Date: July 6, 2020 “...morally speaking, there is no limit to the concern one must feel for the su ering of human beings, ... indi erence to evil is worse than evil itself, ... in a free society, some are guilty, but all are responsible.” ― Abraham Joshua Heschel We, the members of Praying With Our Feet, support the goals presented by Black Lives Matter of DeKalb. It is tragic that it has taken this long for our country to take e ective action. Countless lives have been traumatized and lost. As the spotlight of public awareness is sharply focused on these ongoing atrocities, we have an unprecedented opportunity and responsibility. Now is the time to act. As members of this community, we will personally work to see that speci c and e ective changes are swiftly put in place in order to protect Black, Indigenous, and People of Color (BIPOC) in our community. It is now time to move to the next step: public bodies making and implementing actionable changes. We will o er strong support to those proposing such steps. It is time for the City of DeKalb and DeKalb County to each work with BLM and community members to begin crafting policies consistent with the goals of BLM and then begin working to ensure that the policies are actually implemented. We propose that the City Council meet with BLM and the Police Department to discuss and decide on speci c and e ective ways to implement the following: ● Increasing transparency in the o cer hiring process and assuring public disclosure of complaints ● Creating a hiring policy that overtly strives to build a police force that represents the diversity in our community, that gives preference to applicants willing to live within the community, and that investigates past records and disquali es any candidate who has been formally judged to have exerted excessive force ● Adjusting the o cial DeKalb City Police Department procedures for use of force to include predetermined consequences for use of excessive force, including drafting zero-tolerance consequences for an injuring or potentially life-threatening violation ● Creating an obstruction-free path for citizens to hold o cers accountable who use excessive force or who do not intervene when excessive force is used ● Requiring a public report whenever force is used or threatened ● Establishing clear criteria for tra c stops, frisks, detainment, and a system for monitoring and evaluating such stops ● Utilizing an entity independent of the police in the review and prosecution of police o cers ● Creating a Citizens’ Review Board that represents the diversity of the community and that has a signi cant role in overseeing the hiring process and in monitoring the use of force and citizen complaints ● Utilizing mental and social health workers as partners in police action ● Making a commitment to not cooperate with the U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement agency (ICE) ● Eliminating all police-owned military equipment We propose that the City Council meet with BLM and community members to discuss and decide on speci c and e ective ways to implement the following: ● Ensuring lease provisions with strong renter protection against unpredictable or unreasonable fees/penalties and against failure to provide livable conditions ● Working with a tenants’ association to ensure that renters are aware of their rights We propose that the County Board and o cials of the 23rd Circuit Judicial System meet with BLM and interested community members to create and then implement strategies for the following: ● Making a commitment to not cooperate with the U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement agency (ICE) ● Ending cash bail for nonviolent crimes We propose that we all band together to advocate with the state, local, and federal government as appropriate for the following: ● Adding whistleblower protection for police who report witnessing excessive use of force or racial targeting ● Reforming quali ed immunity and other obstacles to holding police o cers accountable We would like to o er our support and willingness to publicly advocate for these necessary changes. We will be researching other communities’ implementation strategies and their e ectiveness. We feel these issues must be faced immediately, and we would like to join with BLM activists, community members, and government o cials to determine together how to build our community into a place where each resident can live safely and with dignity. Sincerely, Praying With Our Feet, A DeKalb County Jewish Committee for Social Justice Rabbi Julie Pelc Adler Joshua Rodriguez Harvey Blau Laurie Rodriguez Robert Feldacker Herbert Rubin David Gorman Irene Rubin Jason Hanna Linda Schwartz Jane Lux Carol Zar Linda Mogren Jerrold Zar  Input to Human Relations Commission, City of DeKalb Policy Reform on Racial Inequality and Injustice Meeting of July 7, 2020 To: City of Dekalb Human Relations Commission Subject: Recommendations on Policy Reform on Race Relations This is intended to summarize my input to the commission as race relations reforms are considered for recommendation to the City Council. I have previously expressed my suggestions in the Human Relations Commission (HRC) forum on June 16, 2020. Since that time, I have given further thought to the topic and wish to provide this additional input: • Support for the national Justice in Policing Act law enforcement reforms. • Support for the Black Lives Matter (BLM) demands, following June 18th town hall meeting. • Implement the community-led public safety model of law enforcement. Support procedural justice through giving voice to the public – confers legitimacy to the police in a way that civilian oversight cannot. (This ties to demand #11 of recommendations from the BLM movement.) • Work with local institutions to revise local support of housing, education, jobs, and healthcare services. Remove those systems/procedures that perpetuate individuals stuck in a multi- generational cycle of poverty. • Work with criminal justice system (i.e. courts, judges and prosecutors) to implement restorative justice model, complementing traditional methods of justice. Do not continue a strict retributive theory of punishment – i.e. when an offender breaks the law, requiring they suffer in return. We can do better! Intentionally removing ‘systemic racism’ practices will benefit everyone living in this community. I support locally integrating support services and reducing bureaucracy in the law enforcement and criminal justice systems, eliminating negative interactions of incarceration with poverty, homelessness, and mental health. Submitted by – John Rey, 2944 Greenwood Acres Drive, DeKalb, IL 60115 Tuesday, July 7, 2020, JAR HRC Forum July 7 Suggestions.pdf.docx 7/8/2020 This Oregon town of 170,000 replaced some cops with medics and mental health workers. It's worked for over 30 years - CNN US LIVE TV Eugene Police o cer Bo Rankin, left, meets with Cahoots administrative coordinator Ben Brubaker and emergency crisis worker Matt Eads, right, after working a shift together as part of the Community Outreach Response Team in  Eugene. Mandatory Credit: Chris Pietsch/The Register-Guard via USA TODAY NETWORK This town of 170,000 replaced some cops with medics and mental health workers. It's worked for over 30 years By Scottie Andrew, CNN Updated 10:10 PM ET, Sun July 5, 2020 (CNN) — Around 30 years ago, a town in Oregon retrofitted an old van, sta ed it with young medics and mental health counselors and sent them out to respond to the kinds of 911 calls that wouldn't necessarily require police intervention. In the town of 172,000, they were the first responders for mental health crises, homelessness, substance abuse, threats of suicide -- the problems for which there are no easy fixes. The problems that, in the hands of police, have often turned violent. Today, the program, called CAHOOTS, has three vans, more than double the number of sta ers and the attention of a country in crisis. CAHOOTS is already doing what police reform advocates say is necessary to fundamentally change the US criminal justice system -- pass o some responsibilities to unarmed civilians. Cities much larger and more diverse than Eugene have asked CAHOOTS sta to help them build their own version of the program. CAHOOTS wouldn't work everywhere, at least not in the form it exists in in Eugene. But it's a template for what it's like to live in a city with limited police. It's centered around a holistic approach https://www.cnn.com/2020/07/05/us/cahoots-replace-police-mental-health-trnd/index.html 1/9 7/8/2020 This Oregon town of 170,000 replaced some cops with medics and mental health workers. It's worked for over 30 years - CNN US LIVE TV Nurse Celene Eldrich, a volunteer nurse for CAHOOTS, waits to screen guests for health concerns at the Egan Warming Center's Springfield location in March. CAHOOTS comes from White Bird Clinic, a social services center that's operated in Eugene since the late 1960s. It was the brainchild of some counterculture activists who'd felt the hole where a community health center should be. And in 1989, after 20 years of earning the community's trust, CAHOOTS was created. It stands for Crisis Assistance Helping Out on the Streets and cheekily refers to the relationship between the community health center that started it and the Eugene Police Department. Most of the clients White Bird assisted -- unsheltered people or those with mental health issues -- didn't respond well to police. And for the many more people they hadn't yet helped, they wanted to make their services mobile, said David Zeiss, the program's co-founder. "We knew that we were good at it," he said. "And we knew it was something of value to a lot of people ... we needed to be known and used by other agencies that commonly encounter crisis situation." It works this way: 911 dispatchers filter calls they receive -- if they're violent or criminal, they're sent to police. If they're within CAHOOTS' purview, the van-bound sta will take the call. They prep what equipment they'll need, drive to the scene and go from there. The program started small, with a van Zeiss called a "junker," some passionate paraprofessionals and just enough funding to sta CAHOOTS 40 hours a week. It always paired one medic, usually a nurse or EMT, with a crisis responder trained in behavioral health. That holistic approach is core to its model. Per self-reported data, CAHOOTS workers responded to 24,000 calls in 2019 -- about 20% of total dispatches. About 150 of those required police backup. https://www.cnn.com/2020/07/05/us/cahoots-replace-police-mental-health-trnd/index.html 2/9 7/8/2020 This Oregon town of 170,000 replaced some cops with medics and mental health workers. It's worked for over 30 years - CNN CAHOOTS says the program saves the city about $8.5 million in public safety costs every year, plus another $14 million in US ambulance trips and ER costs. LIVE TV It had to overcome mutual mistrust with police White Bird's counterculture roots ran deep -- the clinic used to fundraise at Grateful Dead concerts in the West, where volunteer medics would treat Deadheads -- so the pairing between police and the clinic wasn't an immediately fruitful one. There was "mutual mistrust" between them, said Zeiss, who retired in 2014. "It's true there was a tendency to be mistrustful of the police in our agency and our culture," he said. "It was an obstacle we had to overcome." And for the most part, both groups have: Eugene Police Chief Chris Skinner called theirs a "symbiotic relationship" that better serves some residents of Eugene. "When they show up, they have better success than police o cers do," he said. "We're wearing a uniform, a gun, a badge -- it feels very demonstrative for someone in crisis." It seeks to overturn a disturbing statistic And there's a great deal of people in Eugene in crisis. Lane County, which encompasses Eugene and neighbor city Springfield, has staggering rates of homelessness. The county's per-capita homeless rate is among the nation's highest. Recent data from the county also suggests mental health crises are widespread, too -- the suicide rate, at around 17 deaths per 100,000, is about 40% higher than the national average. Police encounters with the homeless often end in citations or arrests. Of homeless people with mental health conditions, anywhere from 62.0% to 90% of them will be arrested, per one journal review of homelessness studies. They may end up in jail, not in treatment or housing, and thus begins the cycle of incarceration that doesn't benefit either party. Around 25% of people killed by police show signs of mental illness, according to one study CAHOOTS was created in part because of another disturbing statistic -- around 25% of people killed by police show signs of mental illness, according to a journal review of the Washington Post's extensive o cer-involved shootings database. https://www.cnn.com/2020/07/05/us/cahoots-replace-police-mental-health-trnd/index.html 3/9 7/8/2020 This Oregon town of 170,000 replaced some cops with medics and mental health workers. It's worked for over 30 years - CNN The Eugene Police Department has been criticized in years past for shooting and killing people with mental illnesses. US Most recently, in February, the city won a wrongful death lawsuit brought by the familyL Iof V Ea T V who was man shot by police. His loved ones said he was a veteran with PTSD who'd threatened suicide. (Skinner was appointed chief in 2018, three years after the shooting.)  I believe it's time for law enforcement to quit being a catch-base for everything our community and society needs. Eugene Police Chief Chris Skinner Most of CAHOOTS' clients are homeless, and just under a third of them have severe mental illnesses. It's a weight o the shoulders of police, Skinner said. "I believe it's time for law enforcement to quit being a catch-base for everything our community and society needs," Skinner said. "We need to get law enforcement professionals back to doing the core mission of protecting communities and enforcing the law, and then match resources with other services like behavioral health -- all those things we tend to lump on the plate of law enforcement." Its staffers are unarmed There's no such thing as a "typical" CAHOOTS shift these days, said Ben Brubaker, who worked as a CAHOOTS crisis worker before assuming the senior role of clinical co-coordinator at White Bird. Sta ers respond to substance addiction crises, psychotic episodes, homeless residents and threats of suicide. They make house calls to counsel depressed children at their parents' request, and they're contacted by public onlookers when someone isn't in a position to call CAHOOTS themselves. Unlike police, CAHOOTS responders can't force anyone to accept their aid, and they can't arrest anyone. They're not armed, and their uniform usually consists of a White Bird T-shirt and jeans -- the goal is that the more "civilian- like" they look, the less threatened their clients will feel. Their approach is di erent, too. They're taught in training to abandon the "pseudo-professional" a ect that sta ers inadvertently take on in talks with clients. And aside from an extensive background in medical care or mental health, all CAHOOTS employees are judged by their "lived experiences," Brubaker said -- people who've dealt with many of the situations CAHOOTS clients find themselves in are better able to empathize and serve those people, he said. Building that rapport and trust with clients is part and parcel with their clinical work. "That can be tricky," Brubaker said. "We show up in a white van." The demand for its services continues to grow https://www.cnn.com/2020/07/05/us/cahoots-replace-police-mental-health-trnd/index.html 4/9 7/8/2020 This Oregon town of 170,000 replaced some cops with medics and mental health workers. It's worked for over 30 years - CNN US LIVE TV Cahoots crisis councilor Ned White, left, and EMT Rose Fenwick wrap up a day shift with a stop in Eugene in December 2018. For most people they assist, though, that's still preferable to a police cruiser. They can call police or EMS for assistance if the case requires a "higher level of care" than CAHOOTS can provide, he said. But much of it they can do on their own. They can transport clients to hospitals, shelters or White Bird Clinic, where they'll have access to medical and dental care and counseling. Support continues to swell -- CAHOOTS receives about $2 million, which Zeiss says is almost three times what its budget was when he retired in 2014. And CAHOOTS a few years ago expanded to serve neighboring Springfield. But the program is still working with just three vans, which are sta ed 24/7. The workload can be overwhelming, Brubaker said. The high demand, low capacity model is holding CAHOOTS back, said Ibrahim Coulibaly, a former White Bird volunteer who serves as the president of the Lane County NAACP chapter. Expanding CAHOOTS' services so it had its own campus, too, could improve its reach, he said. With more funding, he said, reallocated from the police budget or another source, the program could respond to even more crises, with even more employees and, hopefully, at least one more van. CAHOOTS could use more than another van, though, said June Fothergill, a pastor at a Springfield church who calls CAHOOTS to pick up the homeless people or people with substance use issues that stop by for free meals. Fothergill said while CAHOOTS does its part well -- providing immediate services to someone in crisis -- there's still a void when it comes to long-term solutions. "You can call someone for the crisis, but what are they supposed to do for it -- where can they take them except for jail?" she said. "That doesn't necessarily provide much treatment." https://www.cnn.com/2020/07/05/us/cahoots-replace-police-mental-health-trnd/index.html 5/9 7/8/2020 This Oregon town of 170,000 replaced some cops with medics and mental health workers. It's worked for over 30 years - CNN They're better equipped than police to care for the people she serves, she said. But if there isn't space in a ordableUS LIVE housing, Eugene's detoxing center or mental health facilities, those clients will turn into TV regulars. "They're doing what they can do," she said. "There's wonderful work going on, but it isn't adequate at the moment." It says a partnership with police is essential The idea of "defunding the police" crept into the mainstream just one month ago, since the death of George Floyd sparked nationwide protests against racism and police brutality. But what the term means depends on who you ask. What would the US look like without police? 02:17 Advocates for limiting the role of police have pointed to Eugene as an example of social service providers and law enforcement working in harmony. But a growing group of dissenters feel there's little room for police in the movement to fundamentally change the American criminal justice system. Services like CAHOOTS, they say, may function better and more broadly without the assistance of police. Zeiss isn't sure he agrees. "Partnership with police has always been essential to our model," he said. "A CAHOOTS-like program without a close relationship with police would be very di erent from anything we've done. I don't have a coherent vision of a society that has no police force." He said the current movement has seemingly pitted service providers like CAHOOTS against police, which may stoke suspicion among police over "whether we're really their allies or their competitors," he said. https://www.cnn.com/2020/07/05/us/cahoots-replace-police-mental-health-trnd/index.html 6/9 7/8/2020 This Oregon town of 170,000 replaced some cops with medics and mental health workers. It's worked for over 30 years - CNN "In some sense, that may be true. But I think we still need to focus on being part of a system, and a system that includes US police for some functions," Zeiss said. LIVE TV  Partnership with police has always been essential to our model. I don't have a coherent vision of a society that has no police force. David Zeiss, the program's co-founder Skinner, the Eugene police chief, said reallocating funds from Eugene police would stifle the department, which is already money-tight, and its ability to do the work to defend CAHOOTS when situations turn violent. "Anytime you're thinking about what meaningful change looks like, especially that's sustainable, it takes a significant amount of engagement from stakeholders," he said. "While I totally understand people's desire to do something very, very quickly, we kind of need to keep our eyes on the prize here. If we want to reform police, we have to do it methodically and strategically." It's become central in the 'defund the police' debate Coulibaly said community leaders are in talks over what to do about police -- should their funding go to CAHOOTS, or should more funding be directed toward better educating police about deescalation techniques? They haven't reached a consensus, he said. "If the city doesn't have enough money to fund CAHOOTS, probably they should think about reallocating some of the funds that go to police to support CAHOOTS," he said. Brubaker said the relationship with police remains strong, but CAHOOTS is evaluating the calls for change from the public, who've directed their support toward the program. He said sta are figuring out what shape the program will take going forward, but there's no clear path. "We're not trying to be the face of a mainstream institution," he said. "We're just people serving people." Other cities are trying to develop a similar model The idea of a separate entity in charge of alternative care is more enticing than ever as cities mull over the e cacy of their police departments. CAHOOTS has met the moment. Brubaker said he's consulting with cities on how to implement their own CAHOOTS-inspired program, subbing White Bird Clinic for a local organization that serves a similar role. There are a few criteria, though, that Brubaker considers immutable: The CAHOOTS stand-in should be operated by a local non-profit separate from the government that already has an established, positive rapport with the community, and it should ideally be sta ed by people who reflect the diversity of that community. CAHOOTS consulted Olympia, Washington, on the creation of its own Crisis Response Unit, which is sta ed by two social workers. Denver is piloting a program, also inspired by CAHOOTS, led by a local social justice organization. https://www.cnn.com/2020/07/05/us/cahoots-replace-police-mental-health-trnd/index.html 7/9 7/8/2020 This Oregon town of 170,000 replaced some cops with medics and mental health workers. It's worked for over 30 years - CNN US... but there is no one-size-fits-all solution LIVE TV White Bird Clinic and CAHOOTS coordinators can't go into other communities and set up copies of CAHOOTS. What works in Eugene wouldn't work in New York, or in Miami, or in larger cities more diverse than Eugene (less than 2% of the population is Black, according to census data). Brubaker knows that a "fill-in-the-blank" style of reform wouldn't work. But CAHOOTS does provide a template. "I guess the role that I see for our agency isn't to go in and tell other communities what they need to do and should be doing," he said. "Our role is to assist those communities to have a conversation with each other about what they need and what that response can look like." It's not an immediate fix. Zeiss said it took a lot of "patient plotting" for CAHOOTS to really have an impact. "At this point, we've patiently waited out an entire generation of police o cers," he said. "There's nobody on the Eugene police force today who can remember being a Eugene police o cer without CAHOOTS. It's been that slow of a process." That doesn't mean other cities shouldn't try. "You have to start," he said. "You can start immediately by creating something and expand it as confidence in it grows." Another city's CAHOOTS may not be called CAHOOTS at all, though it'll probably use another cutesy acronym. It's not likely to satisfy advocates who want to defund the police entirely. But, if done right, it could change the lives of some of a city's most vulnerable people. Search CNN... US World Politics Business Opinion Health Entertainment https://www.cnn.com/2020/07/05/us/cahoots-replace-police-mental-health-trnd/index.html 8/9 7/8/2020 This Oregon town of 170,000 replaced some cops with medics and mental health workers. It's worked for over 30 years - CNN US Tech LIVE TV Style Travel Sports Videos Coupons More Weather US FOLLOW CNN Terms of Use Privacy Policy Do Not Sell My Personal Information AdChoices About Us CNN Studio Tours CNN Store Newsletters Transcripts License Footage CNN Newsource Sitemap © 2020 Cable News Network. Turner Broadcasting System, Inc. All Rights Reserved. CNN Sans ™ & © 2016 Cable News Network. https://www.cnn.com/2020/07/05/us/cahoots-replace-police-mental-health-trnd/index.html 9/9 7/8/2020 Solutions — Campaign Zero CAMPAIGN ZERO THE PROBLEM CAMPAIGN SOLUTIONS REPORTS FEEDBACK ZERO PLANNING TEAM DONATE SOLUTIONS  https://www.joincampaignzero.org/solutions#investigations 1/42 7/8/2020 Solutions — Campaign Zero A comprehensive package of urgent policy solutions - informed by data, research and human rights principles - can change the way police serve our communities. Integrating recommendations from communities, research organizations and the President's Task Force on 21st Century Policing, these policies aim to protect and preserve life. https://www.joincampaignzero.org/solutions#investigations 2/42 7/8/2020 Solutions — Campaign Zero SCROLL DOWN TO VIEW EACH POLICY SOLUTION CATEGORY END BROKEN WINDOWS POLICING https://www.joincampaignzero.org/solutions#investigations 3/42 7/8/2020 Solutions — Campaign Zero A decades-long focus on policing minor crimes and activities - a practice called Broken Windows policing - has led to the criminalization and over-policing of communities of color and excessive force in otherwise harmless situations. Nationwide, only 5% of all arrests made in 2018 involved alleged violent crimes and only 4% of what police spend their time doing overall involves enforcing violent crime. Meanwhile, the vast majority of arrests are for low-level, non-violent activities in encounters that often escalate to deadly force. For example, in 2014, police killed at least 287 people who were involved in minor offenses and harmless activities like sleeping in parks, possessing drugs, looking "suspicious" or having a mental health crisis. These activities are often symptoms of underlying issues of drug addiction, homelessness, and mental illness which should be treated by healthcare professionals and social workers rather than the police. 2020 New York Times Analysis of the total proportion of calls for service/911 calls involving violent crime in each city. 2020 New York Times Analysis of how police typically spend their time. https://www.joincampaignzero.org/solutions#investigations 4/42 7/8/2020 Solutions — Campaign Zero POLICY SOLUTIONS End Policing of Minor End Profiling and "Stop- "Broken Windows" Offenses and-Frisk" The following activities do Establish enforceable not threaten public safety and protections against profiling are often used to police black to prevent police from communities. Decriminalize intervening in civilian lives these activities or de- for no reason other than the prioritize their enforcement: "suspicion" of their blackness or other aspects of their • Consumption of Alcohol identity. This should include: on Streets • Marijuana Possession • immigration status, age, housing status, sexual • Disorderly Conduct orientation, gender, • Trespassing gender identity, • Loitering disability, HIV status, race, religion and • Disturbing the Peace national origin as (including Loud Music) protected groups • Spitting • the right for people to • Jaywalking seek court orders to stop • Bicycling on the police departments from Sidewalk profiling • Prostitution • bans on both intentional profiling and practices (Example: Respect State that have a disparate Marijuana Laws Act of 2015) impact on protected groups • ban stops for "furtive" movements such as a reaching for waistband or acting nervous • ban stops for being in a high-crime area https://www.joincampaignzero.org/solutions#investigations 5/42 7/8/2020 Solutions — Campaign Zero • ban stops for matching a generalized description of a suspect (i.e. black male ages 15-25) • require officers to establish objective justification for making a stop and to report every stop including location, race, gender, whether force was used and whether a firearm was found. • end the use of predictive policing technology, which uses systematically biased data to enhance police profiling of black people and communities • prohibit police departments from using resources to investigate, interrogate, detain, detect, report, or arrest persons for immigration enforcement purposes. • prohibit police departments from transferring an individual to federal immigration authorities for purposes of immigration enforcement. • prohibit officers from being placed under the https://www.joincampaignzero.org/solutions#investigations 6/42 7/8/2020 Solutions — Campaign Zero supervision of federal agencies or deputized as special federal officers or special federal deputies. (Examples: End Racial Profiling Act of 2015; NYC Community Safety Act; NYC Stop-and-Frisk Reforms; California Senate Bill 54) Establish Alternative Approaches to Mental Health Crises Mental health crises should not be excuses for heavy-handed police interventions and are best handled by mental health professionals. Establish and fund Mental Health Response Teams to respond to crisis situations. These approaches have been proven to reduce police use of force in these situations by nearly 40 percent and should include: • establish a team of mental health professionals, social workers and/or crisis counselors to send as first responders to calls involving mental health crises, such as the CAHOOTS model implemented in Eugene, OR. • involvement of this multidisciplinary team in planning, implementation and response to crises https://www.joincampaignzero.org/solutions#investigations 7/42 7/8/2020 Solutions — Campaign Zero (Example: CRISES Act in California) Read the Research Below to Learn More About This Issue: POLICE WHY STUDY THE STUDY: WHY ENDING SPEND BROKEN FINDS RACIST, ENDING PUBLIC RACIAL ONLY WINDOWS OVER- CL ASSIST BROKEN DISORDER PROFILING ABOUT IS NOT POLICING ORIGINS WINDOWS DOESN'T AND 4% OF AN INCREASE OF POLICING LEAD TO STOP & THEIR EFFECTIVE CRIME BROKEN WOULD SERIOUS FRISK TIME APPROAC WINDOWS MAKE CRIME RESPOND TO POLICING COMMUN TO POLICING SAFER VIOLENT CRIME. HOW CRISIS EFFECTIV EVIDENCE DATA ON HOW HOW STOPS & INTERVEN OF OF RACIAL COMMUN MEDICAID FRISKS TEAMS AS MARIJUAN WIDESPRE DISPARITI ORGANIZA EXPANSIO HAVE A DECRIMIN RACIAL IN REDUCE AND BEEN RESPONSE VS PROFILING TRAFFIC CRIME SUBSTANC REDUCED TO LEGALIZAT STOPS MORE ABUSE IN NYC MENTAL THAN TREATMEN HEALTH THE REDUCES CRISES POLICE. CRIME HOW POLICE VIOLENCE HARM THE COMMUN MENTAL HEALTH https://www.joincampaignzero.org/solutions#investigations 8/42 7/8/2020 Solutions — Campaign Zero COMMUNIT Y OVERSIGHT Police usually investigate and decide what, if any, consequences their fellow officers should face in cases of police misconduct. Under this system, fewer than 1 in every 12 complaints of police misconduct nationwide results in some kind of disciplinary action against the officer(s) responsible. Communities need an urgent way to ensure police officers are held accountable for police violence. https://www.joincampaignzero.org/solutions#investigations 9/42 7/8/2020 Solutions — Campaign Zero POLICY SOLUTIONS Establish effective civilian oversight structures Establish an all-civilian oversight structure with discipline power that includes a Police Commission and Civilian Complaints Office with the following powers: The Police Commission should: determine policy for the police department based on community input and expertise share policy and policy changes in publicly accessible formats discipline and dismiss police officers hold public disciplinary hearings select the candidates for Police Chief, to be hired by the Mayor evaluate and fire the Police Chief, if needed receive full-time, competitive salaries for all members receive regular training on policing and civil rights not have current, former or family of police officers as members select its members from candidates offered by community organizations The Civilian Complaints Office should: receive, investigate and resolve all civilian complaints against police in 120 days establish multiple in-person and online ways to submit, view and discuss complaints be immediately notified and required to send an investigator to the scene of a police shooting or in-custody death be allowed to interrogate officers less than 48 hours after an incident where deadly force is used access crime scenes, subpoena witnesses and files with penalties for non-compliance make disciplinary and policy recommendations to the Police Chief compel the Police Chief to explain why he/she has not followed a recommendation have the Police Commission decide cases where the Police Chief does not follow recommendations https://www.joincampaignzero.org/solutions#investigations 10/42 7/8/2020 Solutions — Campaign Zero issue public quarterly reports analyzing complaints, demographics of complainants, status and findings of investigations and actions taken as a result be housed in a separate location from the police department be funded at an amount no less than 5% of the total police department budget have at least 1 investigator for every 70 police officers or 4 investigators at all times,whichever is greater have its Director selected from candidates offered by community organizations not have current, former or family of police officers on staff, including the Director (Ex: San Francisco Charter Policies on Police Commission and Office of Citizen Complaints) Remove barriers to reporting police misconduct For all stops by a police officer, require officers to give civilians their name, badge number, reason for the stop and a card with instructions for filing a complaint to the civilian oversight structure. Read the Research Below to Learn More About This Issue: STUDY: REVIEW OF EVALUATING NATIONAL THE HOW CIVILIAN CIVILIAN DIFFERENT DIRECTORY BENEFITS NEWARK'S OVERSIGHT OVERSIGHT CIVILIAN OF OF NEW STRUCTURES STRUCTURE OVERSIGHT CIVILIAN CIVILIAN CIVILIAN 78% MORE IN 50 MODELS OVERSIGHT OVERSIGHT OVERSIGHT LIKELY TO L ARGEST AGENCIES OF THE BOARD SUSTAIN US CITIES POLICE COULD BE MISCONDUC A MODEL COMPL AINT FOR THE NATION https://www.joincampaignzero.org/solutions#investigations 11/42 7/8/2020 Solutions — Campaign Zero THE CONSERVAT CASE FOR CIVILIAN OVERSIGHT LIMIT USE OF FORCE https://www.joincampaignzero.org/solutions#investigations 12/42 7/8/2020 Solutions — Campaign Zero Police should have the skills and cultural competence to protect and serve our communities without killing people - just as police do in England, Germany, Japan and other developed countries. In 2014, police killed at least 253 unarmed people and 91 people who were stopped for mere traffic violations. The following policy solutions can restrict the police from using excessive force in everyday interactions with civilians. POLICY SOLUTIONS Establish standards and Revise and strengthen local reporting of police use of police department use of deadly force force policies A. Authorize deadly force Revised police use of force only when there is an policies should protect human imminent threat to an life and rights. Policies should officer's life or the life of include guidance on another person and such force reporting, investigation, is strictly unavoidable to discipline, and accountability protect life as required under and increase transparency by International Law. Deadly making the policies available force should only be online. This use of force authorized after all other policy should require officers reasonable alternatives have to: been exhausted. (Ex: International Deadly • restrict officers from Force Standard; Tennessee using deadly force unless Deadly Force Law) all reasonable alternatives have been B. Require that an officer's exhausted (Ex: tactical conduct and decisions Philadelphia PD Policy) leading up to using deadly • use minimum amount of force be considered in force to apprehend a judgements of whether such subject, with specific force was necessary. (Ex: guidelines for the types LAPD Use of Force Policy) of force and tools authorized for a given https://www.joincampaignzero.org/solutions#investigations 13/42 7/8/2020 Solutions — Campaign Zero C. Require officers give a level of resistance (Ex: verbal warning, when Seattle PD Policy) possible, before using deadly • utilize de-escalation force and give people a tactics (verbalization; reasonable amount of time to creating distance, time comply with the warning (Ex: and space; tactical Las Vegas Metro PD Policy) repositioning, etc.) D. Require reporting of police whenever possible killings and serious injuries of instead of using force civilians (Ex: The PRIDE Act; (Ex: Seattle PD Policy) Colorado law; CA DOJ • carry a less-lethal OpenJustice database) weapon (Ex: Seattle PD Policy) E. Require the names of both the officer(s) involved and • ban using force on a victim(s) to be released within person for talking back 72 hours of a deadly force or as punishment for incident (Ex: Philadelphia PD running away (Ex: Policy) Cleveland PD Policy) • ban chokeholds, strangleholds (i.e. carotid restraints), hog- tying and transporting people face down in a vehicle (Ex: NYPD Policy) • intervene to stop other officers who are using excessive force and report them to a supervisor (Ex: Las Vegas Metro PD Policy) • have first aid kits and immediately render medical assistance to anyone in police custody who is injured or who complains of an injury https://www.joincampaignzero.org/solutions#investigations 14/42 7/8/2020 Solutions — Campaign Zero (Ex: New Baltimore PD Policy) End traffic-related police Monitor how police use killings and force and proactively hold dangerous high-speed officers accountable for police chases excessive force Prohibit police officers from: A. Report all uses of force to a database with information on • shooting at moving related injuries and vehicles (Ex: Denver PD demographics of the Policy) victims. (Ex: Seattle PD • moving in front of Policy; Indianapolis moving vehicles (Ex: Metropolitan PD reporting Denver PD Policy) website) • high-speed chases of B. Establish an early people who have not and intervention system to correct are not about to commit officers who use excessive a violent felony (Ex: force. These systems have been Milwaukee PD Policy) shown to reduce the average number of complaints against officers in a police department by more than 50%. This system should: • report officers who receive two or more complaints in the past month • report officers who have two or more use of force incidents or complaints in the past quarter • require officers to attend re-training and be monitored by an https://www.joincampaignzero.org/solutions#investigations 15/42 7/8/2020 Solutions — Campaign Zero immediate supervisor after their first quarterly report and terminate an officer following multiple reports C. Require police departments to notify the state when an officer is found to have willfully violated department policy or the law, committed official misconduct, or resigned while under investigation for these offenses. Maintain this information in a database accessible to the public (Ex: Illinois Law) and prohibit these officers from serving as police officers, teachers or other governmental employees (Ex: Connecticut Law). POLICE USE OF FORCE PROJECT Campaign Zero reviewed police department use of force policies in 97 of the 100 largest U.S. cities. More restrictive use of force policies are associated with fewer police-involved killings. Learn more at Visit UseofForceProject.org to Learn More UseofForceProject.org. https://www.joincampaignzero.org/solutions#investigations 16/42 7/8/2020 Solutions — Campaign Zero MODEL USE OF FORCE POLICY We have developed this model use of force policy based on our review and analysis of effective use of force policies across the nation. The policy includes evidence-informed restrictions on police use of force that are designed to significantly reduce police violence in communities. It should be adopted by police chiefs and local elected officials without delay. Read this Additional Research to Learn More About This Issue: STUDY MAPPING ANALYSIS WHY THE DATA HOW STATES SHOWS POLICE OF US SHOWS STRUCTUR WHERE MORE VIOLENCE POLICE NEEDS A THE RACISM POLICE RESTRICTI DATABASE SHOOTING STRICTER MOST CONTRIBU MISCOND USE OF OF DATA STANDARD VIOLENT TO RECORDS FORCE KILLINGS AND FOR USE OFFICERS POLICE ARE KEPT POLICIES BY IMPACT OF ALSO SHOOTING FROM REDUCE POLICE OF DOJ DEADLY INFLUENC PUBLIC POLICE REFORMS FORCE OTHER VIEW KILLINGS OFFICERS BY 72%, TO BE ALSO VIOLENT SAFER FOR OFFICERS https://www.joincampaignzero.org/solutions#investigations 17/42 7/8/2020 Solutions — Campaign Zero BEST ANALYSIS HOW THE THE THE AN WHY PRACTICE OF GOVERNM CHALLENG EFFECTIVE ANALYSIS POLICE TO LIMIT UNDERRE FAILS TO OF OF EARLY OF SHOULD POLICE POLICE COLLECT COLLECTI INTERVEN POLICE BE USE OF KILLINGS COMPREH NATIONAL SYSTEMS SHOOTING PROHIBIT FORCE DATA DATA ON USE OF FOR INVOLVIN FROM POLICE FORCE POLICE MOVING SHOOTING KILLINGS DATA VEHICLES AT MOVING VEHICLES WHY THE HOW EVIDENCE HOW HOW HOW CURRENT CHANGIN POLICE POLICE POLICE COMPREH USE OF THE KILL CHASES VIOLENCE REPORTIN DEADLY DEADLY UNARMED DISPROPO MAY REQUIREM FORCE FORCE BL ACK IMPACT INCREASE REDUCE STANDARD STANDARD PEOPLE BL ACK CRIME IN POLICE NEEDS REDUCED BECAUSE PEOPLE COMMUN SHOOTING TO POLICE OF THEIR CHANGE KILLINGS RACE INDEPENDENT INVESTIGATIONS AND PROSECUTIONS https://www.joincampaignzero.org/solutions#investigations 18/42  PROSECUTIONS 7/8/2020 Solutions — Campaign Zero Local prosecutors rely on local police departments to gather the evidence and testimony they need to successfully prosecute criminals. This makes it hard for them to investigate and prosecute the same police officers in cases of police violence. These cases should not rely on the police to investigate themselves and should not be prosecuted by someone who has an incentive to protect the police officers involved. POLICY SOLUTIONS Lower the standard of proof for Department of Justice civil rights investigations of police officers Allow federal prosecutors to successfully prosecute police officers for misconduct by passing legislation to eliminate the requirement that an officer must "willfully" deprive another's rights in order to violate Section 242. Use federal funds to encourage independent investigations and prosecutions Pass legislation such as the Police Training and Independent Review Act of 2015 or use of existing federal funds to encourage external, independent investigations and prosecution of police killings (see Action Items 2.2.2 and 2.2.3 of the President’s Task Force Report). https://www.joincampaignzero.org/solutions#investigations 19/42 7/8/2020 Solutions — Campaign Zero Establish a permanent Special Prosecutor's Office at the State level for cases of police violence The Special Prosecutor's Office should be: required and authorized to prosecute all cases of where police kill or seriously injure a civilian, in-custody deaths and cases where a civilian alleges criminal misconduct against a police officer equipped with an office and resources to conduct thorough investigations required to have its Chief Prosecutor chosen from a list of candidates offered by community organizations Require independent investigations of all cases where police kill or seriously injure civilians The independent investigators should be: required and authorized to prosecute all cases of where police kill or seriously injure a civilian, in-custody deaths and cases where a civilian alleges criminal misconduct against a police officer required to investigate all cases where police kill chosen at random from a list of the largest ten agencies in the state required to report their findings to the public Read the Research Below to Learn More About This Issue: MODEL THE DATA WHY WHY THE LEGAL LEGISL ATI SHOWING SPECIAL LOCAL STATUS CONSIDER ESTABLISH POLICE PROSECU PROSECUT OF WITH SPECIAL ARE ARE DON'T STATEWID SPECIAL PROSECU RARELY NEEDED CHARGE GRAND PROSECUT FOR CHARGED IN CASES POLICE JURY/PRO AND POLICE WITH OF WITH REFORMS GRAND VIOLENCE CRIMES POLICE CRIMES JURY AFTER VIOLENCE REFORMS POLICE KILLINGS https://www.joincampaignzero.org/solutions#investigations 20/42 7/8/2020 Solutions — Campaign Zero COMMUNIT Y REPRESENTATION While white men represent less than one third of the U.S. population, they comprise about two thirds of U.S. police officers. The police should reflect and be responsive to the https://www.joincampaignzero.org/solutions#investigations 21/42 7/8/2020 Solutions — Campaign Zero cultural, racial and gender diversity of the communities they are supposed to serve. Moreover, research shows police departments with more black officers are less likely to kill black people. POLICY SOLUTIONS Increase the number of Use community feedback police officers who reflect to inform police the communities they department policies and serve practices Require police departments to Require a regular survey (Ex: develop and publicly report a Milwaukee survey) to be strategy and timeline for fielded to the community to achieving a representative gauge their experiences and proportion of police officers perceptions of the police and who are women and people of use this information to color through outreach, inform: recruitment and changes to departmental practices (Ex: police department Connecticut Law) policies and practices police officer evaluations police officer pay incentives Read the Research Below to Learn More About This Issue: DATA WHY HOW HOW EVALUATIN HOW FEWER SHOWING HAVING OFFICERS FEMALE RESIDENC BL ACK BL ACK LEVELS A MORE MASCULIN OFFICERS REQUIREM REPRESEN PEOPLE OF DIVERSE SELF- ARE LESS AS A ON THE ARE RACIAL POLICE IMAGE LIKELY TO STRATEGY POLICE KILLED DIVERSIT Y FORCE MAKES USE TO FORCE BY IN U.S. MATTERS THEM EXCESSIVE IMPROVE REDUCES POLICE POLICE MORE FORCE RACIAL POLICE WHEN DEPARTM LIKELY TO DIVERSIT Y KILLINGS DEPARTME USE OF OF ARE FORCE POLICE BL ACK MORE AGAINST DEPARTME PEOPLE THAN https://www.joincampaignzero.org/solutions#investigations 22/42 7/8/2020 Solutions — Campaign Zero BL ACK 40% MEN BL ACK BODY CAMS/ FILM THE POLICE While they are not a cure-all, body cameras and cell phone video have illuminated cases of police violence and have shown https://www.joincampaignzero.org/solutions#investigations 23/42 7/8/2020 p Solutions — Campaign Zero to be important tools for holding officers accountable. Nearly every case where a police officer was charged with a crime for killing a civilian in 2015 relied on video evidence showing the officer's actions. POLICY SOLUTIONS Body cameras The Right to Record Police Require the use of body Ban police officers from cameras - in addition to taking cell phones or other dashboard cameras - and recording devices without a establish policies governing person's consent or warrant their use to: and give people the right to sue police departments if they record all interactions take or destroy these devices. with subjects who have (Ex: Colorado Law) not requested to be kept anonymous notify subjects that they have the option to remain anonymous and stop recording/storing footage if they choose this option allow civilians to review footage of themselves or their relatives and request this be released to the public and stored for at least two years require body and dash cam footage to be stored externally and ensure district attorneys and civilian oversight structures have access to the footage https://www.joincampaignzero.org/solutions#investigations 24/42 7/8/2020 Solutions — Campaign Zero require police departments, whenever they want to deny a Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) request for body or dash cam footage, to prove in court that the footage constitutes a legitimate FOIA exemption (Ex: Illinois House Bill 4355) permanently delete footage after 6 months if this footage hasn't been specifically requested to be stored include a disciplinary matrix clearly defining consequences for officers who fail to adhere to the agency's body camera policy. consider whether cameras or mandated footage are tampered with or unavailable as a negative evidentiary factor in administrative and criminal proceedings prevent officers from reviewing footage of an incident before completing initial reports, statements or interviews about an incident prohibit footage from being used in tandem with facial recognition https://www.joincampaignzero.org/solutions#investigations 25/42 7/8/2020 Solutions — Campaign Zero software, as fillers in photo arrays, or to create a database or pool of mugshots. (Ex: Baltimore PD Body Cam Policy) update privacy laws to protect civilians from having video or audio recordings released publicly that do not contain potential evidence in a use-of- force incident, discharge of a weapon or death. (Ex: ACLU Model Policy) Read the Research Below to Learn More About This Issue: HOW HOW TO CONSIDERATIO STUDY FINDS DATA COLORADO IMPLEMENT FOR BODY CAMS SHOWING STRENGTHENE BODY CAMS IMPLEMENTING DON'T WHEN AND CIVILIANS' IN A WAY BODY CAMS REDUCE USE HOW OFTEN RIGHT TO THAT OF FORCE, BODY CAM FILM THE PROMOTES BUT ALSO VIDEO GETS POLICE ACCOUNTABIL DON'T RELEASED AND INCREASE PROTECTS CRIMINALIZATI PRIVACY OF COMMUNITIES HOW BODY CRITICAL THE DANGERS WHY BODY CONSIDERATIO CAMS POLICY OF BODY CAMS NEED FOR MAKING IMPACTED ISSUES TO CAMS BEING THE RIGHT BODY CAM USE OF MAKE BODY MISUSED AS A https://www.joincampaignzero.org/solutions#investigations 26/42 7/8/2020 Solutions — Campaign Zero FORCE IN SAN CAMERAS TOOL FOR POLICIES TO FOOTAGE DIEGO EFFECTIVE SURVEILL ANCE BE EFFECTIVE ACCESSIBLE WHY POLICE HOW BODY HOW VIDEO LEARN ABOUT SHOULDN'T CAMERAS EVIDENCE IS BODY GET TO ONLY REDUCE NOW CAMERA REVIEW BODY USE OF INVOLVED IN L AWS IN YOUR CAMERA FORCE WITH MOST CASES STATE FOOTAGE GOOD WHERE BEFORE THEY POLICIES POLICE ARE REPORT CHARGED TRAINING https://www.joincampaignzero.org/solutions#investigations 27/42 7/8/2020 Solutions — Campaign Zero The current training regime for police officers fails to effectively teach them how to interact with our communities in a way that protects and preserves life. For example, police recruits spend 58 hours learning how to shoot firearms and only 8 hours learning how to de-escalate situations. An intensive training regime is needed to help police officers learn the behaviors and skills to interact appropriately with communities. POLICY SOLUTIONS Invest in Rigorous and Intentionally consider Sustained Training 'unconscious' or 'implicit' racial bias Require officers to undergo training - including scenario- Require current and based training - on the prospective police officers to following topics on at least a undergo mandatory implicit quarterly basis and involve racial bias testing, including the community - including testing for bias in shoot/don't youth of color - in their shoot decision-making, and design and implementation: develop a clear policy for considering an officer's level Implicit bias of racial bias in: Procedural justice Relationship-based law enforcement policing certification Community interaction the hiring process Crisis intervention, performance evaluations mediation, conflict decisions about whether resolution, and rumor an officer should be control https://www.joincampaignzero.org/solutions#investigations 28/42 7/8/2020 Solutions — Campaign Zero Appropriate engagement deployed to communities with youth of color Appropriate engagement with LGBTQ, transgender and gender nonconforming individuals Appropriate engagement with individuals who are english language learners Appropriate engagement with individuals from different religious affiliations Appropriate engagement with individuals who are differently abled De-escalation and minimizing the use of force Read the Research Below to Learn More About This Issue: EXPERIME STUDY HOW CHARACT LEARN THE HOW THE SHOWS FINDS RACIAL OF ABOUT PROBLEM WAY OFFICERS PROCEDU BIAS OFFICERS POLICE WITH POLICE TRAINED JUSTICE INFORMS THAT DE- HOW ARE IN TRAINING POLICE PREDICT ESCAL ATIO POLICE CURRENT PROCEDU REDUCES OFFICERS VIOLENCE TRAINING ARE TRAININE JUSTICE POLICE DECISION AGAINST REQUIREM TRAINED IS LESS USE OF TO BL ACK IN YOUR INEFFECT LIKELY TO FORCE SHOOT PEOPLE STATE MAKE AND ARRESTS COMPL AIN OR USE FORCE https://www.joincampaignzero.org/solutions#investigations 29/42 7/8/2020 Solutions — Campaign Zero HOW HOW HOW POLICE TRAINING PROCEDU TRAINING REDUCED JUSTICE IN THE POLICE AND US FALLS SHOOTING FAIRNESS SHORT IN TRAINING COMPARE RICHMON IMPACT TO PERCEPTI OTHER OF COUNTRIE POLICE END FOR- PROFIT POLICING https://www.joincampaignzero.org/solutions#investigations 30/42 7/8/2020 Solutions — Campaign Zero Police should be working to keep people safe, not contributing to a system that profits from stopping, searching, ticketing, arresting and incarcerating people. POLICY SOLUTIONS End police department quotas for tickets and arrests Ban police departments from using ticket or arrest quotas to evaluate the performance of police officers (Ex: Illinois law) Limit fines and fees for low-income people Pass policies requiring local governments to: ban issuing fines or arrest warrants for civilians who fail to appear in court for a traffic citation (Ex: Ferguson Policy) ban generating more than 10% of total municipal revenue from fines and fees (Ex: Missouri law) allow judges discretion to waive fines and fees for low-income people or initiate payment plans (Ex: Pennsylvania law) prohibit courts from ordering individuals on parole or probation to pay supervision fees and other correctional fees Prevent police from taking the money or property of innocent people Prohibit police from: seizing property of civilians (i.e. civil forfeiture) unless they are convicted of a crime and the state establishes by clear and convincing evidence that the property is subject to forfeiture keeping any property that has legally been forfeited (instead, this property should go to a general fund) https://www.joincampaignzero.org/solutions#investigations 31/42 7/8/2020 Solutions — Campaign Zero participating in the federal Equitable Sharing program that allows police to engage in civil asset forfeiture (Ex: New Mexico law) Require police departments to bear the cost of misconduct Require the cost of misconduct settlements to be paid out of the police department budget instead of the City's general fund Restrict police departments from receiving more money from the general fund when they go over-budget on lawsuit payments Read the Research Below to Learn More About This Issue: DIFFERENT LEARN HOW HOW HOW TO HOW TO WAYS ABOUT THE POLICE PROFIT REFORM STRUCTURE GOVERNME CIVIL ASSET AND THE INCENTIVES MUNICIPAL FINES PAY POLICE FORFEITURE COURTS INFLUENCE COURTS IN BASED ON MISCONDUC L AWS IN PROFIT POLICING ST. LOUIS A SETTLEMENT YOUR FROM IN TO STOP PERSON'S STATE LOW- FERGUSON PROFITING ABILIT Y TO INCOME OFF OF PAY RESIDENTS LOW- IN ST. INCOME, LOUIS BL ACK COUNT Y RESIDENTS HOW HOW ANALYSIS 10 L ARGEST POLICE PHIL ADELPH OF CIVIL POLICE USE CIVIL POLICE FORFEITURE DEPTS PAID ASSET SEIZE CASH CASH $1B IN FORFEITURE FROM SEIZURES MISCONDUC AS A TOOL POOR, SETTLEMENT TO BL ACK OVER 5 INCREASE PEOPLE YEARS REVENUE https://www.joincampaignzero.org/solutions#investigations 32/42 7/8/2020 Solutions — Campaign Zero DEMILITARIZATION The events in Ferguson have introduced the nation to the ways that local police departments can misuse military weaponry to intimidate and repress communities. In 2014, militarized SWAT https://www.joincampaignzero.org/solutions#investigations 33/42 7/8/2020 Solutions — Campaign Zero teams killed at least 38 people and studies show that more militarized police departments are significantly more likely to kill civilians. The following policies limit police departments from obtaining or using these weapons on our streets. POLICY SOLUTIONS End the Federal Establish Local Restrictions Government's 1033 Program to Prevent Police Providing Military Departments from Weaponry to Local Police Purchasing or Using Departments Military Weaponry End the supply of federal Restrict police departments military weaponry to local from: police departments under the 1033 program. (Ex: Stop • using federal grant Militarizing Law Enforcement money to purchase Act) military equipment (Ex: Montana law) • deploying armored vehicles, weaponized aircraft, drones, Stingray surveillance equipment, camouflage uniforms, and grenade launchers • using SWAT teams unless there is an emergency situation or imminent threat to life and high-ranking officers have given approval (Ex: Cincinnati PD Policy) • conducting no-knock raids (Ex: Oregon law bans all no-knock raids) https://www.joincampaignzero.org/solutions#investigations 34/42 7/8/2020 Solutions — Campaign Zero • accessing federal grant money or purchasing military equipment if the department has been recently found to demonstrate a "pattern or practice" of discriminatory policing • in addition to these restrictions, wherever possible agencies should seek to return to the federal government the military equipment that has already been received (Ex: San Jose) https://www.joincampaignzero.org/solutions#investigations 35/42 7/8/2020 Solutions — Campaign Zero OF EQUIPMEN PERSPECT RECEIVE IN AND RAIDS POLICE THE ON MILITARY REVERSIN MODELS HAVE MILITARIZ FEDERAL MILITARIZ WEAPONS POLICE FOR INCREASE GOVERNM TO MILITARIZA DEMILITAR SINCE HAS COMBAT POLICE THE GIVEN TO DRUGS, DEPARTM 1980'S POLICE NOT DEPARTME TERRORIS STUDY HOW ANOTHER SHOWS MONTANA STUDY MORE IS FINDS MILITARIZ ADDRESSI POLICE POLICE POLICE MILITARIZ ARE MILITARIZA CONTRIBU MORE TO LIKELY TO KILLINGS KILL BY PEOPLE POLICE. FAIR POLICE CONTRACTS https://www.joincampaignzero.org/solutions#investigations 37/42 7/8/2020 Solutions — Campaign Zero SOURCE | EMBED See What Your Local Agency Received from the Department of Defense What military equipment has your local police, sheriff or game warden received from the Pentagon? Click the dropdown to select your state and start sifting through the newly released data from the U.S. Department of Defense’s 1033 program. New York New York received at least $26,498,384.00 in equipment since the beginning of the program. Agency Total Value + ALBANY COUNTY SHERIFF DEPT $794,855.00 + ALBANY POLICE DEPARTMENT $56,762.00 + ALBION POLICE DEPT $129,389.00 + ALLEGANY COUNTY SHERIFF DEPT $132,304.55 + AMHERST POLICE DEPT $114,497.97 + AMSTERDAM POLICE DEPT $4,300.00 + AUBURN POLICE DEPT $1,577.25 + BEACON POLICE DEPT $9,880.00 + BETHLEHEM POLICE DEPT $4,300.00 Read the Research Below to Learn More About This Issue: THE SEE THE A POLICE HOW KEY BEST HOW ORIGINS MILITARY OFFICER'S POLICE CHALLENG PRACTICE SWAT https://www.joincampaignzero.org/solutions#investigations 36/42 7/8/2020 Solutions — Campaign Zero Police unions have used their influence to establish unfair protections for police officers in their contracts with local, state and federal government and in statewide Law Enforcement Officers' Bills of Rights. These provisions create one set of rules for police and another for civilians, and make it difficult for Police Chiefs or civilian oversight structures to punish police officers who are unfit to serve. Learn more about how police union contracts help officers avoid accountability here. POLICY SOLUTIONS Remove barriers to effective misconduct investigations and civilian oversight Remove contract provisions, local policies, and provisions in state Law Enforcement Officers' Bills of Rights laws that: • allow officers to wait 48 hours or more before being interrogated after an incident • prevent investigators from pursuing other cases of misconduct revealed during an investigation • prevent an officer's name or picture from being released to the public • prohibit civilians from having the power to discipline, subpoena or interrogate police officers https://www.joincampaignzero.org/solutions#investigations 38/42 7/8/2020 Solutions — Campaign Zero • state that the Police Chief has the sole authority to discipline police officers • enable officers to appeal a disciplinary decision to a hearing board of other police officers • enable officers to use the contract grievance process to have an outside arbitrator reverse disciplinary decisions and reinstate officers who have committed misconduct • prevent an officer from being investigated for an incident that happened 100 or more days prior • allow an officer to choose not to take a lie detector test without being punished, require the civilian who is accusing that officer of misconduct to pass a lie detector first, or prevent the officer's test results from being considered as evidence of misconduct Keep officers' disciplinary history accessible to police departments and the public Remove contract provisions, local and state policies, and provisions in state Law Enforcement Officers' Bills of Rights laws that allow police officers to: • expunge or destroy records of past misconduct (both sustained and unsustained) from their disciplinary file • prevent their disciplinary records from being released to the public via a Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) request Ensure financial accountability for officers and police departments that kill or seriously injure civilians Remove contract provisions, local policies, and provisions in state Law Enforcement Officers' Bills of Rights laws that: • require officers to be given paid administrative leave or paid desk- duty during an investigation following a police shooting or other use of deadly force • prevent officers from receiving unpaid suspensions as discipline for misconduct or allow officers to use vacation or discretionary https://www.joincampaignzero.org/solutions#investigations 39/42 7/8/2020 Solutions — Campaign Zero time to pay themselves while on suspension • allow officers to receive paid leave or paid desk-duty after being charged with a felony offense DC Council recently passed legislation that bans the inclusion of “all matters pertaining to the discipline of law enforcement officers” in their police union contract. This policy banning police union contracts from including language that impacts the investigation and discipline of law enforcement is a model that other cities and states should adopt. Police accountability should be non- negotiable. Campaign Zero reviewed the police union contracts in 81 of the largest U.S. cities. 72 of the 81 cities' contracts imposed at least one barrier to Visit CheckthePolice.org to Learn More holding police accountable. Learn more at CheckthePolice.org. https://www.joincampaignzero.org/solutions#investigations 40/42 7/8/2020 Solutions — Campaign Zero Read the Research Below to Learn More About This Issue: ANALYSIS: CAMPAIGN THE HOW A THE CASE THE POLICE ZERO ROLE OF POLICE HISTORY FOR SPECIAL DEPTS POLICE POLICE BILLS OF AND POLICE PROTECTI WITH UNION UNIONS RIGHTS OVERVIEW BILLS OF FOR MORE CONTRAC IN PREVENT OF RIGHTS POLICE PROBLEM RECOMME BLOCKING OFFICERS POLICE OFFICERS POLICE FOR POLICE FROM OFFICERS INCLUDED UNION COLUMBU REFORM BEING BILLS OF IN CONTRAC OH HELD RIGHTS POLICE ARE ACCOUNT BILLS OF MORE FOR RIGHTS LIKELY TO POLICE KILL VIOLENCE UNARMED CIVILIANS CITIES HOW HOW HOW STUDY: HOW HOW WITH POLICE BALTIMOR POLICE JOINING POLICE POLICE POLICE BILLS OF POLICE UNION POLICE UNIONS UNION UNION RIGHTS UNION CONTRAC UNIONS IN CONTRAC CONTRAC IMPEDE CONTRAC PROVISIO INCREASE CHICAGO ALLOW ARE ACCOUNT IMPEDES ARE NOT VIOLENT NEGOTIAT FIRED HALF AS IN 14 ACCOUNT BASED MISCOND CONTRAC OFFICERS LIKELY TO STATES ON BY 40% THAT TO GET SUSTAIN SCIENTIFI SHIELD REHIRED AN EVIDENCE OFFICERS EXCESSIV FROM FORCE ACCOUNT COMPL AIN REVIEW HOW AND POLICE RECOMME UNION FOR CONTRAC POLICE LET UNION ARBITRATO CONTRAC DECIDE POLICE DISCIPLIN https://www.joincampaignzero.org/solutions#investigations 41/42 7/8/2020 Solutions — Campaign Zero  TOP Privacy Policy https://www.joincampaignzero.org/solutions#investigations 42/42  | 8TOABOLITION.COM 8 TO ABOLITION Abolitionist Policy Changes to Demand from Your City Officials #8toAbolition While communities across the country mourn the the military industrial complex, both here and loss of George Floyd, Breonna Taylor, Tony McDade, abroad. In abolishing policing, we seek to abolish Jamel Floyd, and so many more Black victims of imperialist forms of police, such as militaries police murder, Campaign Zero released its 8 Can’t responsible for generations of violence against Wait campaign, offering a set of eight reforms Black and brown people worldwide. they claim would reduce police killings by 72%. As police and prison abolitionists, we believe that this As abolitionists, we recognize that reforms that campaign is dangerous and irresponsible, offering do not reduce the power of the police–including a slate of reforms that have already been tried those proposed by 8 Can’t Wait–simply create new and failed, that mislead a public newly invigorated opportunities to surveil, police, and incarcerate to the possibilities of police and prison abolition, Black, brown, indigenous, poor, disabled, trans, and that do not reflect the needs of criminalized gender oppressed, queer, migrant people, and communities. those who work in street economies. We believe in a world where there are zero police murders We honor the work of abolitionists who have because there are zero police, not because police come before us, and those who organize now. A are better trained or better regulated—indeed, better world is possible. We refuse to allow the history has shown that ending police violence blatant co-optation of decades of abolitionist through more training or regulations is impossible. organizing toward reformist ends that erases the work of Black feminist theorists. As the abolitionist We also recognize that all police and prisons organization Critical Resistance recently noted, 8 will not disappear tomorrow. Instead, we believe Can’t Wait will merely “improve policing’s war on in the strategic importance of non-reformist us.” Additionally, many abolitionists have already reforms, or measures that reduce the scale, scope, debunked the 8 Can’t Wait campaign’s claims, power, authority, and legitimacy of criminalizing assumptions, and faulty science. institutions. We also recognize carceral agents’ constant attempts to co-opt and rebrand abolition Abolition can’t wait. through the language of harm reduction, as we are currently witnessing with the #8CantWait At its root, policing is a system designed to uphold campaign. We envision abolition as not only a oppression. One thousand people are killed by matter of tearing down criminalizing systems police every year, and Black people are murdered such as police and prisons that shorten the lives at three times the rate of white people. Up to fifty of Black, brown, and poor people, but also a percent of people murdered by the police have matter of building up life-sustaining systems that disabilities. Up to 40% of police officers have reduce, prevent, and better address harm. We seek perpetrated intimate partner violence, and sexual a reparations model, wherein our communities violence is the second most common form of that have been harmed by policing and mass police brutality, primarily targeting Black women criminalization for centuries are given their due and especially those who are sex workers and drug from every corporation and institution that has users. Many of these incidents of police violence profited from policing. are undocumented by studies and only uplifted through grassroots movements. Black people To build an abolitionist world that prioritizes who are women, trans, gender non-conforming, the lives of Black people, we have drawn upon sex working, and queer are often criminalized for decades of abolitionists’ work to compile this list actions they take to survive gendered violence, of demands targeted toward city and municipal as we have seen in the cases of Tracy McCarter, powers. Honoring the long history of abolitionist Chrystul Kizer, Alisha Walker, GiGi Thomas, Marissa struggle, we join in their efforts to divest from Alexander, Bresha Meadows, Cyntoia Brown, and the prison industrial complex, invest in our many others. We reject the notion of a “perfect communities, and create the conditions for our survivor”; we do not believe anyone deserves to be ultimate vision: a world without police, where no caged, nor do we prescribe to the state’s notions one is held in a cage, and all people thrive and be of “innocence” and culpability. We recognize that well. the system of policing is heavily intertwined with 1 Abolitionist Policy Changes to Demand from Your City Officials The end goal of these reforms is not to create better, friendlier, or more community-oriented police or prisons. Instead, we hope to build toward a society without police or prisons, where communities are equipped to provide for their safety and wellbeing. 1 // defund the Police zz Reject any proposed expansion to police budgets. zz Demand the highest budget cuts per year, until they slash police budget to zero. zz Slash police salaries across the board until they are zeroed out. zz Immediately fire police officers who have any excessive force complaints. zz No hiring of new officers or replacement of fired or resigned officers. zz Fully cut funding for public relations. zz Suspend the use of paid administrative leave for cops under investigation. zz Require police, not cities, to be liable for misconduct and violence settlements. zz Ban police contracting for nonprofits and institutions. zz Reduce the power of police unions. zz Until the police are fully defunded, make police union contract negotiations public. zz Pressure the AFL-CIO to denounce police unions. zz Prohibit city candidates taking money from police unions and stop accepting union funds. zz Withhold pensions and don’t rehire cops involved in use of excessive force. zz Abolish asset forfeiture programs and laws. zz Deplatform white supremacist public officials. zz Prohibit private-public innovation schemes that profit from temporary technological fixes to systemic problems of police abuse and violence. These contracts and data-sharing arrangements, however profitable for technologists and reformists, are lethal. 2 // Demilitarize Communities zz Disarm law enforcement officers, including the police and private security. zz Remove cops from hospitals. zz Prohibit law enforcement from accessing private patient information. zz End the militarization of Black and brown neighborhoods by ending broken windows policing, “precision policing,” community policing, and all iterations of quality of life policing programs (neighborhood policing, “gang” policing, “repeat-offender” policing, etc). zz Surveillance technologies (CCTV, face printing, DNA and biometric databases, acoustic gunshot detection, drones, AI and risk profiling algorithms, and other forms of predictive policing) are weapons in the hands of law enforcement. End police, military, and immigration enforcement contracts with any private companies that provide these services, and prohibit the experimental design and rollout of in-house systems. zz Dismantle fusion centers, county crime analysis centers, real time crime centers, gun and gang violence intelligence centers, and purge the attendant databases. zz Withdraw participation in police militarization programs and refuse federal grants that entangle municipal police entities with the Department of Homeland Security, the Joint Terrorism Task Force, and FBI. zz Prohibit training exchanges between U.S. law enforcement and global military and policing entities. These relationships circulate deadly techniques and technologies, exporting the American model of racist policing worldwide. zz Repeal all laws that hide, excuse, or enable police misconduct. 2 3 // Remove Police From Schools. zz Remove police, both public and private, from all schools. zz Call on universities to dissolve relationships with police departments. zz Prohibit police departments from using city contracts with universities to do IRB-exempt data analysis, geographic and community profiling, human-computer amelioration studies, and predictive analytics. Instead, divert funds to public service-related studies and community collaborations. zz Remove surveillance tech and metal detectors from all schools. zz End school zero-tolerance disciplinary policies. zz End the use of carceral-lite punishment of students, including suspensions and expulsions, that disproportionately target Black and brown students, especially Black girls. zz Urge states to repeal truancy laws. zz Prohibit the surveillance of Black and brown students by their teachers, counselors, and school officials through programs that criminalize students and exploit relationships of trust with school officials, including Countering Violent Extremism/Targeted Violence and Terrorism Prevention. 4 // Free People from Prisons and Jails. zz Permanently close local jails. zz Pressure state legislatures to end mandatory arrest and failure to protect laws that lead to the criminalization of survivors of gendered violence. zz Reject “alternatives to incarceration” that are carceral in nature, including problem-solving courts and electronic monitoring and coercive restorative justice programs. zz Reduce jail churn by reducing arrests. zz Free all people from involuntary confinement, including but not limited to jails, prisons, immigrant detention centers, psychiatric wards, and nursing homes, starting with vulnerable populations such as those who are aging, disabled, immunocompromised, held on bail, held for parole violations, and survivors. zz Cut funding to prosecutor offices. zz End pre-trial detention. zz End civil commitment. zz Release all people held pre-trial and on parole violations. zz Make all communication to and from prisoners free. zz End immigration detention, end family separation, and let our undocumented community members come home. zz End data and resource sharing with ICE. 5 // Repeal Laws That Criminalize Survival zz Repeal local ordinances that criminalize people involved in the sex trades, drug trades, and street economies. zz Call on Mayors to grant clemencies to criminalized survivors of violence. zz Repeal local ordinances that criminalize the occupation of public spaces—particularly for people experiencing homelessness—under statutes against loitering, loitering for the purposes of sex work, fare beating, panhandling, soliciting, camping, sleeping, and public urination and defecation. zz Refuse to deploy police when they are contacted in relation to the above. zz Repeal statutes that criminalize survivors of gendered violence, including mandatory arrest and failure to protect laws. zz On the road to complete decriminalization, immediately decriminalize all misdemeanor offenses, which currently account for 80% of total court dockets. zz End all fines and fees associated with the criminal legal process, including ticketing, cash bail, court costs, and parole and probation fees. 3 6 // Invest in Community Self-Governance zz Promote neighborhood councils as representative bodies within municipal decision making. zz Invest in multilingual resources for immigrant and asylum-seeking communities. zz Assess community needs and invest in community-based resources, including groups from tenant unions to local shop-owners and street vendors, prioritizing those from marginalized groups. zz Invest in community-based public safety approaches, including non-carceral violence prevention and intervention programs and skills-based education on bystander intervention, consent and boundaries, and healthy relationships. 7 // Provide Safe, accessible Housing for Everyone zz Cancel rent without burden of repayment during COVID-19. zz Repurpose empty buildings, houses, apartments, and hotels to house people experiencing homelessness. zz Prohibit evictions. zz Provide unequivocal support and resources to refugee and asylum seeking communities. zz Allow Community Benefits Agreements to be a community governed means of urban planning. Make public housing accessible to everyone, repealing discriminatory laws barring people from accessing resources based on income, race, gender, sexuality, immigration status, or history of incarceration. zz Support and promote the existence of community land trusts for Black and historically displaced communities. zz Remove cops from all re-entry and shelter institutions. zz Ensure that survivors of gendered violence have access to alternative housing options in the event that their primary housing becomes unsafe. zz Provide non-coercive housing options for young people experiencing abuse or family rejection of their queer or trans identities. 8 // fully Invest in Care, Not Cops zz Allocate city funding towards healthcare infrastructure (including non-coercive mental healthcare), wellness resources, neighborhood based trauma centers, non-coercive drug and alcohol treatment programming, peer support networks, and training for healthcare professionals. Make these services available for free to low-income residents. Adopt a care not cops model. zz Invest in teachers and counselors, universal childcare, and support for all family structures. zz Free and accessible public transit. zz End the use of property taxes to determine school funding. zz Install safe and sanitary gender-inclusive public restrooms. zz Ensure investment in community-based food banks, grocery cooperatives, gardens, and farms. zz Ensure free, and more extensive, public transport, especially servicing marginalized and lower- income communities. zz Invest in youth programs that promote learning, safety, and community care. 4 How to Use This This is an offering for abolitionist vision and transformation. Although there are many policies here, this is not a policy document or website, nor are we an organization or policymakers. We hope this serves as a resource for people to build from and incorporate abolitionist demands into local organizing efforts around municipal, state, and federal policies. Originally, this resource was formed as a direct response to a harmful reformist campaign. We know abolition is far more transformative than 8 points or a website, and hope that these points serve as a resource that demonstrates practical changes we can make now towards abolition. If you or a campaign you’re a part of uses this to shape city based-campaigns, let us know by contacting us! campaigns Care Not Cops | carenotcops.org No New Jails NYC Abolition Plan | nonewjails.nyc No New Jails DC | bit.ly/nnjdc Close the Jails ATL | closethejailatl.org additional resources Transform Harm Resource Hub | transformharm.org Justice LA COVID-19 Decarceration Proposal | justicelanow.org Policing, Prisons, and Punishment Resource Guide | Micah Herskind, medium.com “Police Industrial Complex” Primer from Carceral Tech Resistance Network | carceral.tech We Came to Learn: A Call for Police-Free Schools | advancementproject.org/wecametolearn Reformist Reforms vs. Abolitionist Steps in Policing | criticalresistance.org Collective Action for Safe Spaces 2018 Policy Platform | collectiveactiondc.org She Safe, We Safe Campaign | shesafewesafe.org What the Prison-Abolition Movement Wants | Kim Kelly, teenvogue.com Beyond Bars: Prison Abolition Should Be the American Dream | Reina Sultan, bitchmedia.org Thinking about how to abolish prisons with Mariame Kaba: Podcast & Transcript | NBC News Police “Reforms” You Should Always Oppose | Mariame Kaba, truthout.org Many thanks to contributors, Mon Mohapatra, artist and organizer Leila Raven, mama and organizer Nnennaya Amuchie, organizer and lawyer Reina Sultan, journalist and organizer K Agbebiyi, organizer and social worker Sarah T. Hamid, anti-carceral tech organizer Micah Herskind, organizer and writer Derecka Purnell, lawyer and writer Eli Dru, uncle & organizer Rachel Kuo, organizer & designer 5 01212323 456789ÿ88ÿ87ÿ5ÿ75ÿ5ÿÿÿÿ457 ÿÿÿ5 ÿ5ÿ5 )*+,ÿ)./012ÿ34.ÿ5603.73 809ÿ30ÿ:..;ÿ<=;;063>1?ÿ34.ÿ)@ABCÿD0EE=1>3/ÿ>1ÿF.:A@GÿD0=13/HÿI* 456789ÿ88ÿ87ÿ5ÿ75ÿ5ÿÿ ÿ457  5.6ÿ34.ÿF.:A@GÿI@@>10>7ÿ)@ABCÿ*>J.7ÿ+AK.6ÿ5603.73ÿLAB.G00CÿM60=;, N4K;7,OO999PQAB.G00CPB0EO?60=;7ORSTUVTVVUVWXRYYOZ6.Q[?60=;\4.A2.6] ^5ÿ5ÿ_5_85ÿ̀85ÿ9ÿ5ÿ ÿ#78ÿÿ57#ÿ7 5ÿ5a$7985ÿ$ ÿ%ÿ$%ÿ87% 5 55 ÿ5ÿ̀75ÿ_55 5ÿ5ÿ88% #ÿ8ÿ 57  bc bddebÿfgh bÿhgdb !igj Xÿkÿl1/ÿ0mB.6ÿ940ÿ=7.7Hÿ06ÿ4A7ÿAÿ;A73ÿ4>7306/ÿ0Qÿ=7>1?ÿ.nB.77>J.ÿQ06B.ÿ1..27ÿ30ÿG.ÿ>12>B3.2ÿA12ÿo6.2 9>340=3ÿ7.J.6A1B.ÿ;A/P Tÿkÿl1/ÿ0mB.6ÿ940ÿ=7.7Hÿ06ÿ4A7ÿAÿ;A73ÿ4>7306/ÿ0Qÿ=7>1?ÿAÿB40C.40@2ÿ1..27ÿ30ÿG.ÿ>12>B3.2ÿA12ÿo6.2 9>340=3ÿ7.J.6A1B.ÿ;A/P Uÿkÿl1/ÿ0mB.6ÿ940ÿ20.7ÿ103ÿ>13.6J.1.ÿA12ÿ2.p.7BA@A3.ÿ;0@>B.ÿ=7.ÿ0Qÿ.nB.77>J.ÿQ06B.ÿE=73ÿG.ÿ>12>B3.2ÿA12 o6.2ÿ9>340=3ÿ7.J.6A1B.ÿ;A/P 851111!5177"#$9914% 871456789ÿ88ÿ87ÿ5ÿ75ÿ5ÿÿÿÿ457 ÿÿ&ÿ5 ÿ5ÿ5"8 '1( 01212323 456789ÿ88ÿ87ÿ5ÿ75ÿ5ÿÿÿÿ457 ÿÿÿ5 ÿ5ÿ5 (ÿ*ÿ+,-..ÿ/01,2-.ÿ12134.5ÿ146ÿ7,-ÿ8-,2-145ÿ9--.-ÿ:;,ÿ03.ÿ<.-ÿ;:ÿ14ÿ3==-21=ÿ/0;>-0;=6ÿ?350;<5ÿ.-@-,14/- A1BC Dÿ*ÿ+,;.-/<5-ÿ;E/-,.ÿA,3@15-=BFÿ<46-,ÿ1ÿ.515-G.ÿ1H;,4-Bÿ.<I/;45,1/5Fÿ5;ÿA,-@-45ÿA-;A=-ÿ?0;ÿ?;,>ÿ?350 50-ÿA;=3/-ÿ:,;JÿA,;.-/<5342ÿ50-ÿA;=3/-C K LÿM K!NOMOP Qÿ*ÿR14615;,BFÿA<I=3/ÿ,-A;,5.ÿ:;,ÿ14Bÿ53J-ÿ14ÿ;E/-,ÿ<40;=.5-,.ÿ1ÿ?-1A;4Fÿ=-501=ÿ;,ÿ=-..ÿ=-501=Fÿ1.ÿ?-==ÿ1. 14Bÿ<.-ÿ;:ÿ:;,/-Fÿ?03/0ÿ34/=<6-.ÿS<.537/153;4ÿ:;,ÿ50-ÿ1/53;4C Tÿ*ÿR14615;,BFÿA<I=3/ÿ,-A;,5.ÿ:;,ÿ14Bÿ/1.-ÿ5015ÿ,-U<3,-.ÿ;,ÿ,-/-3@-6ÿJ-63/1=ÿ5,-15J-45ÿ1.ÿ1ÿ,-.<=5ÿ;:ÿ14 1,,-.5Fÿ<4=-..ÿ50-ÿ1,,-.5-6ÿ3463@36<1=ÿ,-U<-.5.ÿ5015ÿ34:;,J153;4ÿ,-J134.ÿA,3@15-C Vÿ*ÿ+<I=3/=Bÿ63.A=1Bÿ;E/-,ÿ,-/;,6.ÿ146ÿ34:;,J153;4ÿ1I;<5ÿ1==ÿ/;JA=1345.ÿ7=-6ÿ12134.5ÿ;E/-,.C Wÿ*ÿX==ÿ;E/-,.ÿ34ÿY-Z1=IÿJ<.5ÿ01@-ÿ:<==ÿI;6Bÿ/1J-,1ÿ/;@-,12-ÿ14Bÿ146ÿ-@-,Bÿ53J-ÿ50-Bÿ345-,1/5ÿ?350 /353[-4.Fÿ146ÿJ<.5ÿ3JJ-6315-=BÿI-ÿ3463/5-6ÿ146ÿ5-,J3415-6ÿ34ÿ50-ÿ-@-45ÿ50-Bÿ51JA-,ÿ?350Fÿ63.1I=-Fÿ;, ;I.5,</5ÿ50-ÿ/1J-,1C \]ÿ*ÿ^-U<3,-ÿA;=3/-ÿ5;ÿA,-.-45ÿ1ÿ/=-1,ÿ146ÿ<46-,.5;;6ÿ?1,4342ÿI-:;,-ÿ7,342ÿ14Bÿ?-1A;4C 4L_L` MMOKNÿaKbaM` \\ÿ*ÿX6;A5ÿ1ÿ/;JJ<435Bc=-6ÿA<I=3/ÿ.1:-5BÿJ;6-=C dÿ\\1ÿ*ÿ^-A=1/-ÿ;E/-,.ÿ?350ÿ.;/31=ÿ?;,>-,.ÿ1.ÿ7,.5ÿ,-.A;46-,.ÿ:;,ÿ4;4c@3;=-45ÿJ-451=ÿ0-1=50Fÿ6,<2Fÿ146 6;J-.53/ÿ/1.-.C dÿ\\Iÿ*ÿ+;=3/-ÿ,-.A;4.-ÿ5;ÿ4;4c@3;=-45ÿJ-451=ÿ0-1=50Fÿ6,<2Fÿ146ÿ6;J-.53/ÿ/1.-.ÿ.0;<=6ÿ;4=BÿI- /;4.36-,-6ÿ1.ÿ1ÿ=1.5ÿ,-.;,5C \eÿ*ÿf<,,-45ÿ146ÿ:<5<,-ÿA;=3/-ÿ;E/-,.ÿJ<.5ÿ/;JA=-5-ÿ/,3.3.ÿ345-,@-453;4ÿ5,134342ÿ146ÿ6-c-./1=153;4 5,134342C \gÿ*ÿ^-U<3,-ÿA;=3/-Fÿ;,ÿ14Bÿ;50-,ÿA1,5Bÿ136342ÿ34ÿ6-c-./1=153;4Fÿ5;ÿ-h01<.5ÿ1==ÿ;50-,ÿ1=5-,4153@-.ÿ;:ÿ6-c -./1=153;4Fÿ.51,5342ÿ:,;Jÿ=-1.5ÿ5;ÿJ;.5ÿ34@1.3@-FÿI-:;,-ÿ7,342ÿ14Bÿ?-1A;4C \(ÿ*ÿf<5ÿ50-ÿ+;=3/-ÿY-A1,5J-45G.ÿ+15,;=ÿY3@3.3;4G.ÿI<62-5ÿIBÿD]iFÿ146ÿ63@-,5ÿ50;.-ÿ:<46.ÿ5;ÿ03,342ÿ.;/31= ?;,>-,.FÿA,;@36342ÿ6-c-./1=153;4ÿ5,134342ÿ:;,ÿ;E/-,.ÿ146ÿ.;/31=ÿ?;,>-,.Fÿ34@-.5342ÿ34ÿ50-ÿY-Z1=I f;<45Bÿf;JJ<435BÿR-451=ÿj-1=50ÿk;1,6Fÿ146ÿ50-ÿX443-ÿl=366-4ÿm;,50ÿ^-@351=3[153;4ÿ+,;S-/5C K!NOPÿbaKnOo 851111!5177"#$9914% 871456789ÿ88ÿ87ÿ5ÿ75ÿ5ÿÿÿÿ457 ÿÿ&ÿ5 ÿ5ÿ5"8 21' 01212323 456789ÿ88ÿ87ÿ5ÿ75ÿ5ÿÿÿÿ457 ÿÿÿ5 ÿ5ÿ5 ()ÿ+ÿ,-./01ÿ2113ÿ4-ÿ51ÿ562213ÿ78-9ÿ62:ÿ;0<--.ÿ4<64ÿ;18=1;ÿ0</.3812ÿ>2318ÿ(?ÿ:168;ÿ-7ÿ6@1A (Bÿ+ÿC<1ÿ0/4:ÿ-7ÿD1E6.5ÿF/..ÿG684218ÿF/4<ÿ4<1ÿD1E6.5ÿC12624ÿH;;-0/64/-2ÿ4-ÿ1;465./;<ÿ623ÿ127-801ÿ6 0-99-2ÿ.16;1A (Iÿ+ÿJ62ÿ4<1ÿ0/4:ÿ-7ÿD1E6.5ÿ78-9ÿF-8K/2@Lÿ-8ÿ0-..65-864/2@ÿ/2ÿ62:ÿF6:LÿF/4<ÿM99/@864/-2ÿ623ÿN>;4-9; O27-8019124ÿPMNOQA NROHCOÿHÿSROOÿTOJUMCOÿVRÿJWVXÿHCÿTVRD,ROUUANVYA 851111!5177"#$9914% 871456789ÿ88ÿ87ÿ5ÿ75ÿ5ÿÿÿÿ457 ÿÿ&ÿ5 ÿ5ÿ5"8 '1'  MINUTES CITY OF DEKALB Human Relations Commission July 7, 2020 The Human Relations Committee (HRC) held a regular meeting on July 7, 2020, in the Second Floor Training Room at the DeKalb Police Department. Chair Larry Apperson called the meeting to order at 6:34 p.m. Before roll call was taken, Chair Apperson, announced he appreciated the public turnout for such an important meeting. Some residents were not able to make it, and from requests made by the public, audio and visual were recorded. A. ROLL CALL The following members of the HRC were present: Larry Apperson (Chair), David Barrow, Nadine Franklin, Joe Gastiger, Norden Gilbert, and Lisa King. Members absent were: Tyrus Wright. Other City officials/staff present: Alderman Scott McAdams, Alderman Carolyn Morris, City Manager Bill Nicklas, Community Services Coordinator Joanne Rouse, Commander Jason Leverton, Management Analyst Jason Blumenthal, and Management Intern Adam Grubbs. B. APPROVAL OF THE AGENDA – ADDITIONS / DELETIONS Motion to approve the agenda was made by Mr. Gastiger and seconded by Ms. King. Motion was approved by a unanimous voice vote. C. APPROVAL OF MINUTES Motion to approve the minutes of March 3, 2020 was made by Mr. Gastiger and seconded by Mr. Barrow. Minutes were approved by a unanimous voice vote. D. PUBLIC PARTICIPATION Chair Apperson called for public comment and stated that anyone who would like to speak will have the chance to. Vivian Meade was the first member of the public who spoke first. Ms. Meade said the meeting should have taken place on a zoom call. She continued by saying that the HRC meeting should not have been hosted at the Police Department. She finished by saying that she and other members of the community felt uncomfortable to attend the meeting because it was at the Police Department, and instead it should be hosted at a bipartisan community center. Chair Apperson responded to her by stating that the Second Floor Training Room at the Police Department is the city’s largest space that they are able to utilize. This was important because of COVID-19 guidelines. He said the point is well taken though. Human Relations Commission Meeting Minutes June 16, 2020 Page 2 of 8 Next to speak was Bessie Chronopoulos. Ms. Chronopoulos began by presenting a document that was a policing program involving mental health from CNN. She talked about how public participation has been difficult with the city, and that the meeting should have been hosted on zoom due to COVID-19 concerns and because many individuals wanted to participate but could not be there. Alderman Carolyn Morris agreed the HRC meeting should have been hosted on zoom. Ms. Morris continued by saying that all meetings should be hosted on zoom at this point of the level of technology seen today. There also should be another space. She thinks the Library is just as big Amber Quitno echoed that the HRC meeting should have been hosted on zoom. Ms. Quitno finished by saying that holding a meeting at the Police Department is intimidating for community members. Erin McNeal said that she wants to push leadership to do the right thing. Ms. McNeal continued by saying the issues that they have been seeing in the city are not new, and it seems to be caused by a lack of leadership. This seems to be a lack of leadership. She finished by saying these issues should have been resolved a long time ago. Ms. Emily said she is tired of hearing excuses that the room was not big enough. Community members wanted to attend, but they felt uncomfortable, and were not sure if there were warrants out for their arrest. She finished by saying the meeting should not have been at the police department. E. OLD BUSINESS 1. Police-Community Relations/Building a Better Community i. Review of Community Recommendations Chair Apperson began by looking at the recommendations. He said that the commission wanted to compile all recommendations from the community forums, town hall meetings, the DeKalb, IL Black Lives Matter (BLM) demands, City Council meetings, and the HRC meeting into the City Council packet and provide it to the DeKalb Aldermen. He continued by saying that the compilation of these documents are just the beginning and they will be continually edited to and added upon to best fit the needs of Dekalb residents. He said that they began by making categories for the recommendations, and that the committee used the categories created by the organization Campaign Zero. The committee liked the Campaign Zero categories because it was a comprehensive list and fit well with the recommendations they have seen from our community members. Chair Apperson then began by listing some of the recommendations the committee Human Relations Commission Meeting Minutes June 16, 2020 Page 3 of 8 had heard from community members. These recommendations included but are not limited to the reallocation of police department funds to incorporate social work, police brutality, the demilitarization of police, use of force limits, increased training, increased oversight from residents on Police business, more representation in positions of power, investing more in social services, a common lease, and job creation. A large issue that the committee discussed was the unjust incarceration rate, department of justice policies, criminal justice systems. These issues may be on the county, state, and federal level. These are being addressed, but the committee may also need to address these on the city level. The committee now has a comprehensive exhaustive list of recommendations that they are now ready to present to City Council at the next Committee of the Whole (COW) City Council meeting on July 13th at 5:00 P.M. Ms. Meade asked how similar the recommendations were to Campaign Zero Chair Apperson answered that Campaign Zero was just a starting point, but the themes the committee saw were like campaign zero Ms. Meade said that the committee did not include banning stop and frisk as a recommendation. Chair Apperson said he did not notice this Ms. Franklin said that it was on the document she created. Chair Apperson said he would be correct this error. He continued saying that as soon as the recommendations were created, the committee received recommendations by email from the DeKalb County Jewish Committee for Social Justice and the former Mayor John Rey. Chair Apperson read the DeKalb County Jewish Committee for Social Justice recommendations. A summary of the recommendations are as follows: Now is the time to act. The community needs swift and effective change. It is now time for Black Indigenous Persons Of Color (BIPOC) to be protected by our community. The community needs to craft policies proposed by BLM and implement them. The City Council, BLM, and police should meet over these policies and discuss them. Ms. Franklin thought it was a great document, Ms. King and Mr. Gastiger agreed with Ms. Franklin. Ms. King thought it was great citizens met together to craft these recommendations. Human Relations Commission Meeting Minutes June 16, 2020 Page 4 of 8 Chair Apperson said that the document is like the recommendations they have crafted, but the wording may be better. Chair Apperson then read the recommendations that Mr. Rey submitted by email. Chair Apperson read off the recommendations. Chair Apperson liked that Mr. Rey focused on the criminal justice system. Chair Apperson commented that these recommendations are similar to what the HRC had discussed previously, that there needs to be change within the criminal justice system. Ms. King then said that the document Ms. Chronopoulos provided was great and that the HRC should include this with the other documents that they would give to the city council. Chair Apperson said if there was no objection, he favored the idea. Ms. King liked this document because it offered a great model to follow and it is clear to understand. Mr. Blumenthal said that he will include this document to the city council packet and will also be found within the minutes of this July 7, 2020 meeting along with all the other recommendations and documents. Chair Apperson confirmed that it would be good to accept all these additional recommendations, models, and information. He said it is good to go on record and say that the document is not static, and it will be continually be changed. Mr. Nicklas reiterated that anything presented at the meeting will be submitted to the city council. Mr. Nicklas also said that all documents can be found on the City of DeKalb website (https://www.cityofdekalb.com/) and also the city council packet. Mr. Barrow gave mention to Chair Apperson that he had put in a lot of time and effort in a short amount of time to put all these documents together. Barrow explained that the HRC members could not meet to work on the recommendations because it violates the Open Meetings Act (OMA). Mr. Barrow continue by saying the HRC had collected recommendations from the community, and they tried to be comprehensive. Mr. Barrow stated the committee are not just collators, but also very passionate individuals who also want change for this community. Mr. Barrow then asked if it was acceptable for him to read the introduction he prepared for the city council at the next council meeting before they submit they review the recommendations. Mr. Gasiger then motioned to change the agenda so that Mr. Barrow could read his introduction, and Ms. King Seconded the motion, all HRC members voted unanimously to pass the motion. Human Relations Commission Meeting Minutes June 16, 2020 Page 5 of 8 Mr. Barrow read the introduction of the presentation to the room. Chair Apperson thanked Mr. Barrow and said it was a great reflection on how the commission feels. He continued by saying that they needed to now put together the HRC recommendation to given to the city council. Mr. Nicklas said that there will be a summary provided to council, which will include resolution and ordinances. It is a large document, but this is just the beginning and there will be more change to come. Chair Apperson was pleased that the city has started to implement some of the recommendations the community has suggested. Mr. Gastiger wanted to highlight some of the changes such as the banning of choke holds, policies of punishment of excessive force and for not intervening in the case of excessive force, cultural biased and diversity training, elimination of no knock warrants, contracting a social worker for certain police calls, reorganizing the police department, and a leasing policy. Mr. Gastiger wanted the public to know that the city has already made some steps to address the issues seen. Chair Apperson then read off the HRC recommendations that they wanted to pass on to the city council. He said that Campaign Zero will be provided to be referenced. There also needs to be an examination of Illinois Statues and lobby to change the statues that the community does not agree with. Chair Apperson noted that not all these compiled recommendations are possible to be implemented immediately, but they will work to get them implemented as quickly as possible. Mr. Gastiger furthered this by stating to the public that there are two phases. Some of these recommendations will take time to research, but some of them can happen tomorrow. There needs to be research to find the best solution. He reiterated that some changes would happen now, but some will take longer to make a decision. Mr. Barrow suggested the recommendations and a timeline should be made public. Public member suggested to give the city a recommended timeline, so they have structure to implement the recommendations on a timely basis. Mr. Norden said we can commit to the recommendations now, but some will still take time to implement. Mr. Barrow said that the recommendations and a timeline need to be made public. Mr. Gastiger noted that the city council can make many changes, but other changes happen from policy changes by the City Manager and the Police Chief. Ms. Chronopoulos stated that all these recommendations and policy changes need to be made more public. She mentioned that the media was in attendance and that the media needs to commit to making these things public. Mr. Human Relations Commission Meeting Minutes June 16, 2020 Page 6 of 8 Gastiger agreed with Ms. Chronopoulos. Ms. Chronopoulos said there needs to be another way to get the information out there to residents besides the internet. Member of the public Maurice McDavid said that there needs to be more communication. He continued by saying the city started a diversity plan when he was a senior in high school, it took 12 years for this to be passed. The community have waited for action for a long time, and the Dekalb community will not be happy until things really change. He said it needs to happen, and it needs to happen in good time. Ms. McNeal said the culture of the community needs to change. One way to do this is by publicizing the recommendations and policies to show the entire community what the priorities are, and hopefully the culture will change. Mr. Nicklas stated he remembers what Mr. McDavid said at the Hopkins Park Townhall Meeting. Mr. Nicklas agrees that it is time for action. Mr. Nicklas met with Chief Redel and Police command staff and there is an agenda piece on this. He provided a draft for recommendations, and he tried to address what he can do in his authority, and he will give what’s not in his authority to the city council. The reorganization of the Police Department is no small feat, but they will do it with regards to the budget process. All changes happen within the budget, one of the budget changes will be Police reorganization. This is the start of action, and it will hopefully lead to more action. Nicklas said the city council meeting will be focused on the compiled documents of recommendations and other information. Mr. Nicklas finished by saying they will begin to create monthly police reports. The DeKalb Police are trying to do their job, but he also wants to keep everyone accountable. Chair Apperson said in the interest in time is there other recommendations the commission wants to make at this time. Mr. Norden made the motion to incorporate item F. to provide transparent and thorough background checks for police hiring and item G. to assure accountability for officer misconduct and particular use for excessive force to recommendation #3. Mr. Gastiger seconded the motion. There was an unanimous vote to pass the motion. Chair Apperson asked if anything else should be included. Ms. King said the abolitionist and campaign zero should be available for the public to see. Ms. King stated there is no reference to these groups, they should include the reference. Human Relations Commission Meeting Minutes June 16, 2020 Page 7 of 8 Mr. Blumenthal clarified that all documents will be available on the City of DeKalb’s website and will be provided in the city council packet. Mr. Gastiger said we should pass along all recommendations, though he did not think that social workers should go to domestic abuse cases, which was a recommendation from the public. People from across the country have worked hard to have police recognize the seriousness in these cases. Mr. Barrow countered saying that the recommendations from the public should be unfiltered and that the city council needs to make the decision on this. Mr. Gastiger said as long as his concern was heard, he has no objection. ii. HRC Recommendations The HRC, led by Chair Apperson, then went through and revised the HRC recommendations to make them clearer. Mr. Norden Motioned to approve the HRC recommendations and to submit them to the city council. Mr. Gastiger seconded the motion. There was an unanimous vote to pass the motion. Ms. King wanted to add that the HRC should start making every meeting zoom compatible. She said residents should still have access even if they can’t physically attend the meeting, and this will also alleviate the issue of the venue being at the Police Department. Residents will be more comfortable to attend online through zoom. Ms. King said they should accommodate the public comments the committee heard that night. Mr. Blumenthal said he will talk to the City Manager and the IT department about this accommodation. The HRC decided that Mr. Barrow with read his introduction to the HRC presentation of the recommendations at the COW city council meeting on July 13th. Chair Apperson announced he may not be around in August due to his wife’s extensive surgery F. NEW BUSINESS None. G. ADJOURNMENT The meeting was adjourned at 9:49 p.m. Motion by Mr. Gastiger, seconded by Chair Apperson. Motion approved by a unanimous voice vote. Human Relations Commission Meeting Minutes June 16, 2020 Page 8 of 8 *PLEASE NOTE* That in addition to these minutes are all public comments that were submitted to the HRC for public comment. This includes the chat feature of the Zoom meeting, as well the link to the video of the HRC meeting at: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K572sFy5hxM&t=1s. _____________________________________________ Jason Blumenthal, Management Analyst Minutes approved by the Human Relations Commission on: