Committee on Public Service

Regular Meeting

Lansing, MI · December 14, 2020

Minutes

MINUTES Committee on Public Service Monday, December 14, 2020 @ 3:00 p.m. https://us02web.zoom.us/j/84668800606 ; ID: 846 6880 0606; Dial In: (646) 876 9923 held virtually in an effort to protect the health and safety of the public & to mitigate the spread of COVID 19 CALL TO ORDER The meeting was called to order at 3:02 p.m. by Council Member Spitzley ROLL CALL-via remote audio/video Council Member Dunbar, Chair, unexcused Council Member Spitzley, Vice Chair remotely from Lansing, Michigan Council Member Spadafore, Member remotely from Lansing, Michigan OTHERS PRESENT Sherrie Boak, Council Office Manager Lisa Hagen, Assistant City Attorney Andy Kilpatrick, Director of Public Service Sean Zielinski Chris Umphlett Dan Dekker Greg Venker, OCA Dan Dekker Chris Umphlett Pat Barnes Minutes MOTION BY COUNCIL MEMBER SPADAFORE TO APPROVE THE MINUTES FROM NOVEMBER 9, 2020 AS PRESENTED. ROLL CALL VOTE, MOTION CARRIED 2-0. Public Comment Mr. Zielinksi spoke on his property at 3328 and 3312 Melody Lane, and an email he sent earlier on his his special assessment. Mr. Umphlett voiced his concerns that he was not aware of all the meetings and was opposed to the process of appeals. Mr. Dekker, 1110 Shelter Lane, did not speak in opposition to his assessment, but the special assessment project in general for all residents. Mr. Fisher, referenced a topographical survey of his property that was sent to Council earlier. Discussion RESOLUTION – Montgomery Drain Special Assessment Council Member Spitzley began by noting the required public hearing was held on 11/9/2020, and Council Member Spadafore and Betz held a neighborhood outreach meeting. The appeals were referred to this Committee on 11/30/2020 where the claimants have their second time to voice their appeal. Council Member Spadafore noted this process is the same that is used for snow and ice removal appeals, and other assessment appeals. Council Member Spitzley asked for confirmation on the adoption of the roll tonight and Council Member Spadafore confirmed. 33-01-01-11-429-311; No representation present. Mr. Kilpatrick outlined the calculation was based on the drainage factors, and the approach was taken for the overall City with a land use factor. Commercial properties are at .9 and residential at .4 which determinations were also based on parcel size. Council Member Spitzley asked Mr. Kilpatrick during each appeal, to state staffs determination on if there is merit to the appeal. Mr. Kilpatrick stated that in this appeal, he did not see merit to the appeal based on what was submitted. MOTION BY COUNCIL MEMBER SPADAFORE TO DENY THE APPEAL BASED ON THE RECOMMENDATION BY PUBLIC SERVICE. Mr. Kilpatrick went onto explain that the City developed a methodology that can stand up to equally applicable and stand up in court, therefore the Committee cannot adjust numbers, as a compassionate decision because then it would not have a fairness standard applied to all properties. Both Council Members stated their appreciation to Mr. Kilpatrick for reviewing all the appeals. ROLL CALL VOTE, MOTION CARRIED 2-0. 33-01-01-11-476-111/33-01-01-11-476-131; Mr. Zielinski was present to speak. First Mr. Kilpatrick acknowledged theses were duplexes next each other and with the information from the Drain office, .9 was applied because they are commercial properties. Mr. Zielinski appealed that they were residential homes and should be treated as such. Mr. Kilpatrick again stated they used the Drain Commission calculations and they do take a factor for roofs, lawns, patios, and driveways. He added is for the land use for a parcel size, rounded down, and they review water quality and quantity. For the assessments it was based on the benefit. Council Member Spadafore asked if the appeals had merit, and Mr. Kilpatrick stated that as far as evaluating the factors it is close to the numbers on the roll. Council Member Spitzley made note that the process is already into the end steps and it is difficult to add in other factors based on size, etc. and asked Mr. Kilpatrick if the assessment has changed what it would be, and did the appeal have merit. Mr. Kilpatrick stated the factor for the size of this parcel was applied correctly, therefore no change in the assessment. Mr. Zielinski did agree based on the factors and calculations laid out. However the residents want to be heard about if they are getting charged for the quantity of the water into the system. Council Member Spadafore explained if they used different factors for this property, they would have to do that for every parcel and that would mean each property would be looked at differently. This group is not he body that would determine if different factors need to be considered. MOTION BY COUNCIL MEMBER SPADAFORE TO DENY THE APPEALS FOR 3328 MELODY AND 3312 MELODY. ROLL CALL VOTE, MOTION CARRIED 2-0. 33-01-01-11-430-282; Mr. Barnes was present and referenced his appeal, outlining his argument on why he thought the assessment was excessive. Mr. Kilpatrick responded that the factor was appropriate to the parcel size. MOTION BY COUNCIL MEMBER SPADAFORE TO DENY THE APPEAL BASED ON THE CALCULATIONS AND FACTORS DETERMINED BY PUBLIC SERVICE. ROLL CALL VOTE, MOTION CARRIED 2-0. Council Member Spitzley asked staff to confirm during the appeals that the factors were appropriately and consistently applied to the property. 33-01-01-11-429-241Chris and Christine Umphlett were present. Mr. Kilpatrick noted the factor was .28 and they understand the owners took lawn into effect, however lawns do create a runoff. Mr. Umpheltt confirmed his calculations were based on impervious areas, and noted that he believed no appeals will be granted based on technical suggestions. Mr. Kilpatrick supported the factors that were used in the assessment. MOTION BY COUNCIL MEMBER SPADADFORE TO DENY THE APPEAL. ROLL CALL VOTE, MOTION CARRIED 2-0. 33-01-01-11-430-311; No representation present. Mr. Kilpatrick referenced the appeal, which cited a financial hardship. Mr. Kilpatrick stated that cannot be considered. MOTION BY COUNCIL MEMBER SPADAFORE TO DENY THE APPEAL. ROLL CALL VOTE, MOTION CARRIED 2-0. 33-01-01-11-427-151; Mr. Kilpatrick referenced the appeal, stating it was general appeal. Mr. Fisher referenced a survey he sent to Council. Mr. Kilpatrick responded that based on size and land use of parcel the calculation was correct. Council Member Spitzley asked if topographical information was being considered, at which Mr. Kilpatrick stated topographical is not considered, nor soil type. That does not factor into the general factor. Mr. Fisher referenced the language on the assessment roll itself. Mr. Kilpatrick explained they are using the rational method for runoff calculations, general size land use factors based on type, and not per parcel individual calculations. Mr. Fisher again appealed for a justification on the benefit. Mr. Kilpatrick clarified that the City had to use the calculations from the Drain Commissioner and Ingham County Drain office. Council Member Spadafore asked Mr. Kilpatrick if staff needs to be clear that it is the land use factor that is determining the cost, and Mr. Kilpatrick agreed. Mr. Spadafore explained to the public that if the City started adjusting to each property, then each parcel is adjusted differently. The question that needs to be answered by staff for each appeal, is whether the factor was correctly applied, and if the appeal has merit. MOTION BY COUNCIL MEMBER SPADAFORE TO DENY THE CLAIM. ROLL CALL VOTE, MOTION CARRIED 2-0. 33-01-01-11-451-021; No representation present. Mr. Kilpatrick confirmed his office looked individual parcels and came up with the same factor that was applied. MOTION BY COUNCIL MEMBER SPADAFORE TO DENY THE CLAIM. ROLL CALL VOTE, MOTION CARRIED 2-0 33-01-01-11-430-031 No representation present. Mr. Kilpatrick referenced the email from the claimant, in which it stated their appeal was because they thought the drain district was of benefit to Frandora Hills. MOTION BY COUNCIL MEMBER SPADAFORE TO DENY THE CLAIM. ROLL CALL VOTE, MOTION CARRIED 2-0 33-01-01-11-428-022; No representation present. Mr. Kilpatrick referenced the appeal which stated no residents should pay, so there was no merit to the appeal. MOTION BY COUNCIL MEMBER SPADAFORE TO DENY THE CLAIM. ROLL CALL VOTE, MOTION CARRIED 2-0 33-01-01-11-429-301; No representation present. Mr. Kilpatrick confirmed the calculations were applied correctly and no merit to the appeal. MOTION BY COUNCIL MEMBER SPADAFORE TO DENY THE CLAIM. ROLL CALL VOTE, MOTION CARRIED 2-0 33-01-01-11-430-191; No representation present. Mr. Kilpatrick confirmed the correct calculations and no merit to the appeal. MOTION BY COUNCIL MEMBER SPADAFORE TO DENY THE CLAIM. ROLL CALL VOTE, MOTION CARRIED 2-0 33-01-01-11-429-291; No representation present. Mr. Kilpatrick stated there was no merit to the appeal. MOTION BY COUNCIL MEMBER SPADAFORE TO DENY THE CLAIM. ROLL CALL VOTE, MOTION CARRIED 2-0. Two appeals on the list were voicemail messages with no details. 33-01-01-11-430-401; No representation present. Mr. Kilpatrick noted the appeal was financial hardship, is a residential spot and not a rental, and did not see merit in the appeal. MOTION BY COUNCIL MEMBER SPADAFORE TO DENY THE CLAIM. ROLL CALL VOTE, MOTION CARRIED 2-0. 33-01-01-13-151-014/33-01-01-13-151-023/33-01-01-14-226-021; No representation present. Mr. Kilpatrick stated that they are appeals in general with the assessment, with no merit. MOTION BY COUNCIL MEMBER SPADAFORE TO DENY THE APPEAL FOR 33-01-01-13-151-014. ROLL CALL VOTE, MOTION CARRIED 2-0. MOTION BY COUNCIL MEMBER SPADAFORE TO DENY THE APPEAL FOR 33-01-01-13-151-023. ROLL CALL VOTE, MOTION CARRIED 2-0. MOTION BY COUNCIL MEMBER SPADAFORE TO DENY THE APPEAL FOR 33-01-01-14-226-021. ROLL CALL VOTE, MOTION CARRIED 2-0. 33-01-01-14-430-471; No representation present. Mr. Kilpatrick recommended denial. MOTION BY COUNCIL MEMBER SPADAFORE TO DENY THE CLAIM. ROLL CALL VOTE, MOTION CARRIED 2-0. 33-01-01-14-226-015/33-01-01-14-226-051/33-01-01-13-151-028/33-01-01-13-151-024/33-01-01-13- 151-00233-01-01-13-151-002; No representation present. Mr. Kilpatrick stated the appeals are general to the overall assessment. MOTION BY COUNCIL MEMBER SPADAFORE TO DENY THE CLAIM FOR 33-01-01-14-226-015. ROLL CALL VOTE, MOTION CARRIED 2-0. MOTION BY COUNCIL MEMBER SPADAFORE TO DENY THE CLAIM FOR 33-01-01-14-226-051. ROLL CALL VOTE, MOTION CARRIED 2-0. MOTION BY COUNCIL MEMBER SPADAFORE TO DENY THE CLAIM FOR 33-01-01-14-226-001. ROLL CALL VOTE, MOTION CARRIED 2-0. MOTION BY COUNCIL MEMBER SPADAFORE TO DENY THE CLAIM FOR 33-01-01-13-151-038. ROLL CALL VOTE, MOTION CARRIED 2-0. MOTION BY COUNCIL MEMBER SPADAFORE TO DENY THE CLAIM FOR 33-01-01-13-151-034. ROLL CALL VOTE, MOTION CARRIED 2-0. MOTION BY COUNCIL MEMBER SPADAFORE TO DENY THE CLAIM FOR 33-01-01-13-151-002. ROLL CALL VOTE, MOTION CARRIED 2-0. 33-01-01-11-476-053/33-01-011-11-476-062; No representation present. Mr. Kilpatrick explained that this appeal was actually that they “did not get the storm water credit”. After review it was found that they did not get the credit given to other properties. The City was provided with the agreement with Ingham County Drain office, therefore the City 10% for other parcels, so in this case the City does recommend the same approach. Council Member Spadafore asked if the appeal should be granted, and Mr. Kilpatrick confirmed they did not get the credit they stated they were to get, and therefore appealing this amount. MOTION BY COUNCIL MEMBER SPADAFORE TO GRANT THE APPEAL BASED ON CONFIRMATION THAT THE PARCELS NEVER GOT THE STORM WATER CREDIT. Mr. Kilpatrick confirmed the roll would be amended before Council to reflect it. Council Member Spadafore stated she was not comfortable on the motion because in this case Committee was not in the position to consider. Council Member Spadafore suggested denying the appeal, and then get a new roll at Council. The factors to consider are if the City is appropriately applying the factors and formulas that were applied to everyone else. It has been articulated that these two parcels were not appropriately assessed because the City was not aware they had not gotten a storm credit. Council Member Spadafore supported his earlier motion to grant the appeal. ROLL CALL VOTE, MOTION CARRIED 2-0. 33-01-01-11-430-292; Mr. Hoffman restated his written appeal, asking for what the benefit to the owners that receive this is, over and above those that are not paying. Mr. Kilpatrick explained there is a benefit on the rain water and the City is taking care of storm water in the storm drain before it gets discharged into the red cedar. Mr. Hoffman again asked for the benefit compared to neighbors and other residents of the City. Council Member Spadafore noted that half the overall assessment is being paid by everyone in the City, and that amount is different than the individual home and business assessments. MOTION BY COUNCIL MEMBER SPADAFORE TO DENY THE APPEAL. ROLL CALL VOTE, MOTION CARRIED 2-0. 33-01-01-11-429-261; No representation present. Mr. Kilpatrick confirmed it was a general appeal, and therefore has no merit. MOTION BY COUNCIL MEMBER SPADAFORE TO DENY THE APPEAL. ROLL CALL VOTE, MOTION CARRIED 2-0. 33-01-01-11-429-261; No representation present. Mr. Kilpatrick stated the appeal was towards the calculations and so the staff reviewed the calculations, and believe they are what they should be. MOTION BY COUNCIL MEMBER SPADAFORE TO DENY THE APPEAL. ROLL CALL VOTE, MOTION CARRIED 2-0. Mr. Kilpatrick asked the Committee to address the revisions on the roll. Council Member Spitzley asked for a discussion at the Council meeting so all members can hear it. Mr. Kilpatrick explained that there were 10 residential parcels that were given a lower factor then they should have and because of that everyone with a credit, $200-$1,000. The recommendation is to not increase those 10 parcels, but the City will cover that error over 30 years, which is $5,000. With the two that were just amended because of the missing storm water credit, and the other amendments, the total assessed is $41,000. This would come from the GF Storm Water account over 30 years. MOTION BY PETER TOAPPROVE THE REVISED ROLL WITH RECOMMENDATION TO COUNCIL TO PASS, AND WHAT EVER HAS TO BE DONE WITH CALCULATION IN GF OVER NEXT 30 YEARS. ROLL CALL VOTE, MOTION CARRIED 2-0. RESOLUTION – Introduction & Set Public Hearing; Ordinance Amendment Chapter 608 Section 608.04; Allow Consumption of Alcoholic Beverages on Public Property in Social District Council Member Spadafore explained this is an ordinance change that does not have an urgent timeline, and does not need to be handled at this time. Council Member Spitzley agreed to move it to the first Committee meeting in 2021. ADJOURN The meeting was adjourned at 4:43 p.m. Submitted by Sherrie Boak, City Council Office Manager, Recording Secretary Lansing City Council Placed on File: February 17, 2021

Agenda

AGENDA Committee on Public Services Monday, December 14, 2020 @ 3:00 p.m. Access the meeting via: https://us02web.zoom.us/j/84668800606 ; ID: 846 6880 0606; Dial In: (646) 876 9923 email comments prior to the meeting at sherrie.boak@lansingmi.gov All Councilmembers will participate virtually & may be contacted prior to the meeting at city.council@lansingmi.gov 483-4177 Council Member Dunbar, Chair Council Member Spitzley, Vice Chair Council Member Spadafore, Member 1) Call to Order 2) Public Comment on Agenda Items(3 minutes) 3) Minutes  November 9, 2020 4) Discussion/Action: A.) RESOLUTION – Montgomery Drain Special Assessment B.) RESOLUTION – Introduction & Set Public Hearing; Ordinance Amendment Chapter 608 Section 608.04; Allow Consumption of Alcoholic Beverages on Public Property in Social District 5) Other 6) Adjourn To mitigate the spread of COVID-19 and to provide essential protections to vulnerable Michiganders and this State’s health care system and other critical infrastructure, it is crucial that all Michiganders take steps to-limit in-person contact, particularly in the context of large groups. Therefore, the above meetings will be conducted via audio/video conference. The meetings are being held virtually in accordance with the Open Meetings Act, as amended in an effort to protect the health and safety of the public. Members of the public wishing to participate in the meeting may do so by logging into or calling into the meetings using the website or phone number above, and meeting ID provided. To provide input or ask questions on any item that is listed on the agenda, members of the public may contact the email address listed above under the meeting link. Persons with disabilities who need an accommodation to fully participate in these meetings should contact the City Council Office at 517-483-4177 (TTY 711) 24 hour notice may be needed for certain accommodations. An attempt will be made to grant all reasonable accommodation requests. DRAFT MINUTES Committee on Public Service Monday, November 9, 2020 @ 4:30 p.m. https://us02web.zoom.us/j/88438369429 ; ID: 884 3836 9429; Dial In: (646) 876 9923 held virtually in an effort to protect the health and safety of the public & to mitigate the spread of COVID 19 CALL TO ORDER The meeting was called to order at 4:30 p.m. ROLL CALL-via remote audio/video Council Member Dunbar, Chair, remotely from Port Austin, Michigan Council Member Spitzley, Vice Chair remotely from Pensacola, Florida Council Member Spadafore, Member remotely from Lansing, Michigan OTHERS PRESENT Sherrie Boak, Council Office Manager Lisa Hagen, Assistant City Attorney Thomas Hickson Andy Kilpatrick, Director of Public Service Minutes MOTION BY COUNCIL MEMBER SPITZLEY TO APPROVE THE MINUTES FROM SEPTEMBER 14, 2020 AS PRESENTED. ROLL CALL VOTE, MOTION CARRIED 3-0. Discussion RESOLUTION – Appointment; Thomas Michael Hickson, Jr., 3rd Ward Member; Board of Public Service; Term to Expire June 30, 2023 Mr. Hickson introduced himself and briefly stated how he became aware of the Board and that when he looked into it, there was a vacancy in the 3rd Ward. He added that he has always had an interest in being in an advisory capacity on streets, bikes, bike lanes, etc. Council Member Dunbar noted that as a Council they make sure they include the Public Service Board budget priority recommendations into their Council budget priorities, so even though it is an advisory board, their input is welcomed. She then asked about the environmental issues he had an interest in, and Mr. Hickson responded that he has been with the DEQ in the past and is aware of programs that are out there putting the City in the forefront of the environmental issues, and he would be an advocate for those. Council Member Dunbar then asked Mr. Kilpatrick about the Board and his thoughts on this appointment. Mr. Kilpatrick confirmed his support of the appointment. Council Member Dunbar then asked Mr. Hickson if he had any connections with the neighborhoods in the 3 rd Ward, at which Mr. Hickson admitted he had not been involved with those groups, but would DRAFT being willing to reach out to those groups and do what it needs to listen to them and provide them with information. Council Member Spitzley spoke in support of Mr. Hickson and the placement of new citizens on the boards. MOTION BY COUNCIL MEMBER SPADAFORE TO APPROVE THE RESOLUTION FOR THE APPOINTMENT OF THOMAS HICKSON TO THE BOARD OF PUBLIC SERVICE. ROLL CALL VOTE, MOTION CARRIE 3-0. Mr. Kilpatrick provided the next meeting date for the Board of Public Service as 11/12/2020. Public Comment No public comment at this time. ADJOURN The meeting was adjourned at 4:40 p.m. Submitted by Sherrie Boak, City Council Office Manager, Recording Secretary Lansing City Council Approved: ___________________ BY THE COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC SERVICE RESOLVED, BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF LANSING PUBLIC IMPROVEMENT IV WHEREAS, pursuant to the Public Improvement III adopted by this council, a public hearing was held on November 9, 2020 Assessment Roll MD-2020 for necessary storm drainage improvements within the Montgomery Drain Drainage District; and WHEREAS, the City Assessor has completed the assessment roll for these improvements, and furnished the following information: PROJECT TITLE: Montgomery Drain Improvements PROPERTY BENEFITTED: All lands in the city of Lansing, within the Montgomery Drain Drainage District, as defined by the Montgomery Drain Drainage Board and the Ingham County Drain Commissioner. ESTIMATED COST OF IMPROVEMENTS: $23,700,614.10 Portion assessed to Property Owners in Assessment District $11,850,307.05 Portion paid by City through Tax levied pursuant to sec 475 of Drain Code $11,850,307.05 NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED the Lansing City Council hereby directs that special assessment roll MD-2020 as returned by the City Assessor, is hereby ratified and confirmed, the special assessments on such roll are hereby levied, and the Mayor is authorized to affix within ten days his warrant directing the City Treasurer to collect said special assessments. The first installment of such special assessments shall be due on the 90th day after the date of this Resolution. Adopted by the Committee of the Whole on ______________________ Approved for Placement on the City Council Agenda: ________________________ James D.Smiertka City Attorney Date: __________ AGENDA ITEM B) Montgomery Drainage District Improvements Special Assessment Details https://www.lansingmi.gov/2054/Montgomery-Drain-Project Montgomery Drain Assessment Methodology The Montgomery Drainage District Drain Board set the City’s apportionment at 64.049% of the overall project cost. This equates to an estimated amount of approximately $23.7 million for the City of Lansing. Given the scope and cost of the Drain Improvements by the Drainage District, the City has recommended assessing 50% of the project cost to benefitted properties within the district. The draft assessment roll distributes these costs by computing the runoff contribution of each parcel (equivalent runoff area/acreage) as a fraction of the overall runoff of the parcels as follow: To calculate the Equivalent Runoff Acreage of a parcel, the total size of parcel within the district (in acres) is multiplied by a factor, based on land use. Land Use Factor – These industry accepted factors are based on the relative storm water contribution of each land use type on a per acre basis. For example, a commercial property contributes three times the amount of storm water that a ¼ acre residential property does (0.9/0.3 = 3). Land Use Factor Park 0.00 Single Family Residential (1/8) acre 0.33 Single Family Residential (1/4) acre 0.30 Single Family Residential (1/3) acre 0.28 Single Family Residential (1/2) acre 0.25 High Density Multi Family Residential/ Apt 0.90 Commercial 0.90 Adjustments – On a case by case basis, a reduction is applied to acreage used for rain gardens and other low impact development features within the project. A reduction of 10% is also applied to the portion of any parcel which drains to a storm water management facility approved by the Ingham County Drain Commission and implemented during development or redevelopment of a site. Once the equivalent runoff acres are calculated for all parcels in the district, these are summed to calculate the total equivalent runoff acreage in the district (122.8 acres) The amount assessed to the parcels is the percentage of each parcel’s equivalent runoff area to the total equivalent runoff area multiplied by the assessed amount ($11,850,307.04). This equates to $96,493.50 per equivalent runoff acre. The individual parcel assessments can be calculated by applying this per acre rate to the equivalent runoff acreage for a parcel. Example Calculations Assessment = Parcel Size x Runoff Factor x Rate Residential (.25 acre lot) 0.25 x .3 x $96,493.50 = $7,237.01 Commercial (1.0 acre lot) 1.00 x .9 x $96,493.50 = $86,844.15 City of Lansing, Michigan Special Assessment Roll for Montgomery Drain Improvments Amt of Special Assessment Roll = $11,845,269.61 Number of Installments = 30 Interest Rate on Installments = 3.176% Recommended (before appeals) TOTAL EASEMENT EQUIVALENT PARCEL OWNER PROPERTY OWNER OWNER OWNER ACRES IN DETENTION LAND USE TOTAL RECOMMENDED PARCEL AREA FOR RUNOFF NUMBER ADDRESS ADDRESS CITY STATE ZIP DISTRICT CREDIT FACTOR APPORTIONMENT ASSESSMENT ACRES LID/R.G.'s ACRES AT-LARGE (ROW) 122.855 50.0000000% Amount 33‐01‐01‐11‐426‐022 124 W MICHIGAN AVE, FL 8TH STONEWOOD DR. LANSING MI 48933 0.435 0.435 33‐01‐01‐11‐426‐035 3211 STONEWOOD DR. 3211 STONEWOOD DR. LANSING MI 48912 0.316 0.316 0.28 0.088 0.072% $8,534.54 33‐01‐01‐11‐426‐037 PO BOX 13007 VACANT LANSING MI 48901 0.413 0.114 0.22 0.025 0.020% $2,419.15 33‐01‐01‐11‐426‐042 3221 STONEWOOD DR. 3221 STONEWOOD DR. LANSING MI 48912 0.426 0.186 0.25 0.047 0.038% $4,485.27 33‐01‐01‐11‐426‐052 3227 STONEWOOD DR. 3227 STONEWOOD DR. LANSING MI 48912 0.263 0.140 0.30 0.042 0.034% $3,782.55 33‐01‐01‐11‐426‐061 3231 STONEWOOD DR. 3231 STONEWOOD DR. LANSING MI 48912 0.230 0.127 0.30 0.038 0.031% $3,675.02 33‐01‐01‐11‐426‐071 3237 STONEWOOD DR. 3237 STONEWOOD DR. LANSING MI 48912 0.230 0.117 0.30 0.035 0.029% $3,385.65 33‐01‐01‐11‐426‐081 3245 STONEWOOD DR. 3245 STONEWOOD DR. LANSING MI 48912 0.258 0.100 0.30 0.030 0.024% $2,893.72 33‐01‐01‐11‐426‐092 3251 STONEWOOD DR. 3251 STONEWOOD DR. LANSING MI 48912 0.215 0.042 0.30 0.013 0.010% $1,215.36 33‐01‐01‐11‐426‐102 3301 STONEWOOD DR. 3301 STONEWOOD DR. LANSING MI 48912 0.215 0.041 0.30 0.012 0.010% $1,186.43 33‐01‐01‐11‐426‐111 3307 STONEWOOD DR. 3307 STONEWOOD DR. LANSING MI 48912 0.230 0.057 0.30 0.017 0.014% $1,649.42 33‐01‐01‐11‐426‐121 3315 STONEWOOD DR. 3315 STONEWOOD DR. LANSING MI 48912 0.230 0.060 0.30 0.018 0.015% $1,736.23 33‐01‐01‐11‐426‐131 1301 COOLIDGE RD. 1301 COOLIDGE RD. EAST LANSING MI 48823 0.259 0.213 0.30 0.064 0.052% $6,163.62 33‐01‐01‐11‐427‐001 3208 STONEWOOD DR. 3208 STONEWOOD DR. LANSING MI 48912 0.240 0.240 0.30 0.072 0.059% $6,944.93 33‐01‐01‐11‐427‐011 3201 HILLGATE CIRCLE 3201 HILLGATE CIRCLE LANSING MI 48912 0.379 0.379 0.28 0.106 0.086% $10,236.05 33‐01‐01‐11‐427‐021 3209 HILLGATE CIRCLE 3209 HILLGATE CIRCLE LANSING MI 48912 0.267 0.267 0.30 0.080 0.065% $7,213.85 33‐01‐01‐11‐427‐031 3213 HILLGATE CIRCLE 3213 HILLGATE CIRCLE LANSING MI 48912 0.313 0.313 0.28 0.088 0.071% $8,453.52 33‐01‐01‐11‐427‐052 PO BOX 26084 1142 HILLGATE WAY LANSING MI 48912 0.209 0.209 0.30 0.063 0.051% $6,047.87 33‐01‐01‐11‐427‐061 1132 HILLGATE WAY 1132 HILLGATE WAY LANSING MI 48912 0.275 0.275 0.30 0.083 0.067% $7,430.00 33‐01‐01‐11‐427‐071 1122 HILLGATE WAY 1122 HILLGATE WAY LANSING MI 48912 0.237 0.237 0.30 0.071 0.058% $6,858.12 33‐01‐01‐11‐427‐081 1986 SUNNYMEDE LN. 1114 HILLGATE WAY LANSING MI 48906 0.191 0.191 0.30 0.057 0.047% $5,527.01 33‐01‐01‐11‐427‐091 1103 SHELTER LN. 1103 SHELTER LN. LANSING MI 48912 0.279 0.279 0.30 0.084 0.068% $7,538.07 33‐01‐01‐11‐427‐101 1115 SHELTER LN. 1115 SHELTER LN. LANSING MI 48912 0.218 0.218 0.30 0.065 0.053% $6,308.31 33‐01‐01‐11‐427‐112 1123 SHELTER LN. 1123 SHELTER LN. LANSING MI 48912 0.238 0.238 0.30 0.071 0.058% $6,887.05 33‐01‐01‐11‐427‐123 1129 SHELTER LN. 1129 SHELTER LN. LANSING MI 48912 0.315 0.315 0.28 0.088 0.072% $8,507.54 33‐01‐01‐11‐427‐132 1139 SHELTER LN. 1139 SHELTER LN. LANSING MI 48912 0.293 0.293 0.28 0.082 0.067% $7,913.36 33‐01‐01‐11‐427‐141 1145 SHELTER LN. 1145 SHELTER LN. LANSING MI 48912 0.230 0.230 0.30 0.069 0.056% $6,655.56 33‐01‐01‐11‐427‐151 2514 GAY LN. 1151 SHELTER LN. LANSING MI 48912 0.230 0.230 0.30 0.069 0.056% $6,655.56 33‐01‐01‐11‐427‐161 1159 SHELTER LN. 1159 SHELTER LN. LANSING MI 48912 0.244 0.244 0.30 0.073 0.060% $7,060.68 33‐01‐01‐11‐427‐171 3240 STONEWOOD DR. 3240 STONEWOOD DR. LANSING MI 48912 0.239 0.239 0.30 0.072 0.058% $6,915.99 33‐01‐01‐11‐427‐181 3232 STONEWOOD DR. 3232 STONEWOOD DR. LANSING MI 48912 0.239 0.239 0.30 0.072 0.058% $6,915.99 33‐01‐01‐11‐427‐191 3226 STONEWOOD DR. 3226 STONEWOOD DR. LANSING MI 48912 0.233 0.233 0.30 0.070 0.057% $6,742.37 33‐01‐01‐11‐427‐201 3218 STONEWOOD DR. 3218 STONEWOOD DR. LANSING MI 48912 0.203 0.203 0.30 0.061 0.050% $5,874.25 33‐01‐01‐11‐428‐012 738 OLD TRAIL DR. 1141 FAIRWAY LN. NAPLES FL 34103 0.369 0.369 0.28 0.103 0.084% $9,965.97 33‐01‐01‐11‐428‐022 1127 FAIRWAY LN. 1127 FAIRWAY LN. LANSING MI 48912 0.490 0.490 0.25 0.123 0.100% $11,816.02 33‐01‐01‐11‐428‐031 1119 FAIRWAY LN. 1119 FAIRWAY LN. LANSING MI 48912 0.226 0.226 0.30 0.068 0.055% $6,539.81 33‐01‐01‐11‐428‐042 1107 FAIRWAY LN. 1107 FAIRWAY LN. LANSING MI 48912 0.284 0.284 0.30 0.085 0.069% $7,673.16 33‐01‐01‐11‐428‐052 1043 FAIRWAY LN. 1043 FAIRWAY LN. LANSING MI 48912 0.136 0.136 0.33 0.045 0.037% $4,329.01 33‐01‐01‐11‐428‐061 3116 FAIRWAY CT. 3116 FAIRWAY CT. LANSING MI 48912 0.247 0.247 0.30 0.074 0.060% $7,147.49 33‐01‐01‐11‐428‐071 3110 FAIRWAY CT. 3110 FAIRWAY CT. LANSING MI 48912 0.201 0.201 0.30 0.060 0.049% $5,816.38 33‐01‐01‐11‐428‐082 3106 FAIRWAY CT. 3106 FAIRWAY CT. LANSING MI 48912 0.276 0.276 0.30 0.083 0.067% $7,457.02 33‐01‐01‐11‐428‐111 3107 FAIRWAY CT. 3107 FAIRWAY CT. LANSING MI 48912 0.338 0.338 0.28 0.095 0.077% $9,128.72 33‐01‐01‐11‐428‐132 3109 FAIRWAY CT. 3109 FAIRWAY CT. LANSING MI 48912 0.423 0.423 0.25 0.106 0.086% $10,200.36 33‐01‐01‐11‐428‐142 1019 FAIRWAY LN. 1019 FAIRWAY LN. LANSING MI 48912 0.377 0.377 0.28 0.106 0.086% $10,182.04 33‐01‐01‐11‐429‐001 1210 FAIRWAY LN. 1210 FAIRWAY LN. LANSING MI 48912 0.290 0.290 0.30 0.087 0.071% $7,835.27 33‐01‐01‐11‐429‐011 1202 FAIRWAY LN. 1202 FAIRWAY LN. LANSING MI 48912 0.231 0.231 0.30 0.069 0.056% $6,684.49 33‐01‐01‐11‐429‐021 1144 FAIRWAY LN. 1144 FAIRWAY LN. LANSING MI 48912 0.248 0.248 0.30 0.074 0.061% $7,176.43 33‐01‐01‐11‐429‐031 1136 FAIRWAY LN. 1136 FAIRWAY LN. LANSING MI 48912 0.248 0.248 0.30 0.074 0.061% $7,176.43 33‐01‐01‐11‐429‐041 3565 E HIAWATHA DR. 1128 FAIRWAY LN. LANSING MI 48864 0.242 0.242 0.30 0.073 0.059% $7,002.80 33‐01‐01‐11‐429‐051 1120 FAIRWAY LN. 1120 FAIRWAY LN. LANSING MI 48912 0.249 0.249 0.30 0.075 0.061% $7,205.36 33‐01‐01‐11‐429‐061 1114 FAIRWAY LN. 1114 FAIRWAY LN. LANSING MI 48912 0.256 0.256 0.30 0.077 0.063% $7,407.92 33‐01‐01‐11‐429‐071 1108 FAIRWAY LN. 1108 FAIRWAY LN. LANSING MI 48912 0.348 0.348 0.28 0.097 0.079% $9,398.80 33‐01‐01‐11‐429‐081 1102 FAIRWAY LN. 1102 FAIRWAY LN. LANSING MI 48912 0.338 0.338 0.28 0.095 0.077% $9,128.72 TOTAL EASEMENT EQUIVALENT PARCEL OWNER PROPERTY OWNER OWNER OWNER ACRES IN DETENTION LAND USE TOTAL RECOMMENDED PARCEL AREA FOR RUNOFF NUMBER ADDRESS ADDRESS CITY STATE ZIP DISTRICT CREDIT FACTOR APPORTIONMENT ASSESSMENT ACRES LID/R.G.'s ACRES 33‐01‐01‐11‐429‐091 1040 FAIRWAY LN. 1040 FAIRWAY LN. LANSING MI 48912 0.220 0.220 0.30 0.066 0.054% $6,366.18 33‐01‐01‐11‐429‐101 1036 FAIRWAY LN. 1036 FAIRWAY LN. LANSING MI 48912 0.268 0.268 0.30 0.080 0.065% $7,755.17 33‐01‐01‐11‐429‐111 1032 FAIRWAY LN. 1032 FAIRWAY LN. LANSING MI 48912 0.212 0.212 0.30 0.064 0.052% $6,134.69 33‐01‐01‐11‐429‐121 1028 FAIRWAY LN. 1028 FAIRWAY LN. LANSING MI 48912 0.216 0.216 0.30 0.065 0.053% $6,250.44 33‐01‐01‐11‐429‐131 1020 FAIRWAY LN. 1020 FAIRWAY LN. LANSING MI 48912 0.184 0.184 0.33 0.061 0.049% $5,856.89 33‐01‐01‐11‐429‐141 1014 FAIRWAY LN. 1014 FAIRWAY LN. LANSING MI 48912 0.184 0.184 0.33 0.061 0.049% $5,856.89 33‐01‐01‐11‐429‐151 3320 MELODY LN. 1008 FAIRWAY LN. LANSING MI 48912 0.160 0.160 0.33 0.053 0.043% $5,092.95 33‐01‐01‐11‐429‐161 425 WALBRIDGE DR. 936 FAIRWAY LN. EAST LANSING MI 48823 0.128 0.128 0.33 0.042 0.034% $4,074.36 33‐01‐01‐11‐429‐171 1001 SHELTER LN. 1001 SHELTER LN. LANSING MI 48912 0.245 0.245 0.30 0.074 0.060% $7,089.61 33‐01‐01‐11‐429‐181 2234 VILLAGE WOODS DR. 1005 SHELTER LN. GRAND BLANC MI 48439 0.259 0.259 0.30 0.078 0.063% $7,494.73 33‐01‐01‐11‐429‐191 1011 SHELTER LN. 1011 SHELTER LN. LANSING MI 48912 0.321 0.321 0.28 0.090 0.073% $8,669.59 33‐01‐01‐11‐429‐201 1019 SHELTER LN. 1019 SHELTER LN. LANSING MI 48912 0.247 0.247 0.30 0.074 0.060% $7,147.49 33‐01‐01‐11‐429‐211 1025 SHELTER LN. 1025 SHELTER LN. LANSING MI 48912 0.245 0.245 0.30 0.074 0.060% $7,089.61 33‐01‐01‐11‐429‐221 1029 SHELTER LN. 1029 SHELTER LN. LANSING MI 48912 0.270 0.270 0.30 0.081 0.066% $7,813.04 33‐01‐01‐11‐429‐231 1035 SHELTER LN. 1035 SHELTER LN. LANSING MI 48912 0.353 0.353 0.28 0.099 0.080% $9,533.84 33‐01‐01‐11‐429‐241 1037 SHELTER LN. 1037 SHELTER LN. LANSING MI 48912 0.388 0.388 0.28 0.109 0.088% $10,479.12 33‐01‐01‐11‐429‐251 1039 SHELTER LN. 1039 SHELTER LN. LANSING MI 48912 0.262 0.262 0.30 0.079 0.064% $7,078.76 33‐01‐01‐11‐429‐261 1049 SHELTER LN. 1049 SHELTER LN. LANSING MI 48912 0.219 0.219 0.30 0.066 0.053% $6,337.25 33‐01‐01‐11‐429‐271 1105 HILLGATE WAY 1105 HILLGATE WAY LANSING MI 48912 0.256 0.256 0.30 0.077 0.063% $7,407.92 33‐01‐01‐11‐429‐281 1115 HILLGATE WAY 1115 HILLGATE WAY LANSING MI 48912 0.307 0.307 0.28 0.086 0.070% $8,291.47 33‐01‐01‐11‐429‐291 1123 HILLGATE WAY 1123 HILLGATE WAY LANSING MI 48912 0.303 0.303 0.28 0.085 0.069% $8,183.44 33‐01‐01‐11‐429‐301 1131 HILLGATE WAY 1131 HILLGATE WAY LANSING MI 48912 0.247 0.247 0.30 0.074 0.060% $7,147.49 33‐01‐01‐11‐429‐311 1139 HILLGATE WAY 1139 HILLGATE WAY LANSING MI 48912 0.237 0.237 0.30 0.071 0.058% $6,858.12 33‐01‐01‐11‐429‐321 1147 HILLGATE WAY 1147 HILLGATE WAY LANSING MI 48912 0.245 0.245 0.30 0.074 0.060% $7,089.61 33‐01‐01‐11‐429‐331 1300 S GENEVA DR. 1155 HILLGATE WAY DEWITT MI 48820 0.219 0.219 0.30 0.066 0.053% $6,337.25 33‐01‐01‐11‐429‐342 1203 HILLGATE WAY 1203 HILLGATE WAY LANSING MI 48912 0.250 0.250 0.30 0.075 0.061% $7,234.30 33‐01‐01‐11‐429‐352 1211 HILLGATE WAY 1211HILLGATE WAY LANSING MI 48912 0.166 0.166 0.33 0.055 0.045% $5,283.93 33‐01‐01‐11‐430‐001 3379 EAGLE CREEK CT NE 1164 SHELTER LN. GRAND RAPIDS MI 49525 0.235 0.235 0.30 0.071 0.057% $6,800.24 33‐01‐01‐11‐430‐011 1152 SHELTER LN. 1152 SHELTER LN. LANSING MI 48912 0.234 0.234 0.30 0.070 0.057% $6,771.30 33‐01‐01‐11‐430‐021 1148 SHELTER LN. 1148 SHELTER LN. LANSING MI 48912 0.234 0.234 0.30 0.070 0.057% $6,771.30 33‐01‐01‐11‐430‐031 1140 SHLETER LN. 1140 SHELTER LN. LANSING MI 48912 0.234 0.234 0.30 0.070 0.057% $6,771.30 33‐01‐01‐11‐430‐041 1132 SHELTER LN. 1132 SHELTER LN. LANSING MI 48912 0.234 0.234 0.30 0.070 0.057% $6,771.30 33‐01‐01‐11‐430‐051 1126 SHELTER LN. 1126 SHELTER LN. LANSING MI 48912 0.234 0.234 0.30 0.070 0.057% $6,771.30 33‐01‐01‐11‐430‐061 3213 HILLGATE CIR. 1118 SHELTER LN. LANSING MI 48912 0.234 0.234 0.30 0.070 0.057% $6,771.30 33‐01‐01‐11‐430‐071 1110 SHELTER LN. 1110 SHELTER LN. LANSING MI 48912 0.234 0.234 0.30 0.070 0.057% $6,771.30 33‐01‐01‐11‐430‐081 1100 SHELTER LN. 1100 SHELTER LN. LANSING MI 48912 0.185 0.185 0.33 0.061 0.050% $5,888.72 33‐01‐01‐11‐430‐091 PO BOX 21216 1056 SHELTER LN. LANSING MI 48909 0.248 0.248 0.30 0.074 0.061% $7,176.43 33‐01‐01‐11‐430‐101 1048 SHELTER LN. 1048 SHELTER LN. LANSING MI 48912 0.248 0.248 0.30 0.074 0.061% $7,176.43 33‐01‐01‐11‐430‐111 1044 SHELTER LN. 1044 SHELTER LN. LANSING MI 48912 0.271 0.271 0.30 0.081 0.066% $7,321.93 33‐01‐01‐11‐430‐121 1036 SHELTER LN. 1036 SHELTER LN. LANSING MI 48912 0.336 0.336 0.28 0.094 0.077% $9,074.71 33‐01‐01‐11‐430‐131 1034 SHELTER LN. 1034 SHELTER LN. LANSING MI 48912 0.330 0.330 0.28 0.092 0.075% $8,912.66 33‐01‐01‐11‐430‐141 1032 SHELTER LN. 1032 SHELTER LN. LANSING MI 48912 0.233 0.233 0.30 0.070 0.057% $6,742.37 33‐01‐01‐11‐430‐151 1030 SHELTER LN. 1030 SHELTER LN. LANSING MI 48912 0.176 0.176 0.33 0.058 0.047% $5,602.24 33‐01‐01‐11‐430‐161 1028 SHELTER LN. 1028 SHELTER LN. LANSING MI 48912 0.199 0.199 0.30 0.060 0.049% $5,758.50 33‐01‐01‐11‐430‐171 1026 SHELTER LN. 1026 SHELTER LN. LANSING MI 48912 0.196 0.196 0.30 0.059 0.048% $5,671.69 33‐01‐01‐11‐430‐181 2080 SHAGBARK LN. 1020 SHELTER LN. LANSING MI 48864 0.221 0.221 0.30 0.066 0.054% $6,395.12 33‐01‐01‐11‐430‐191 1016 SHELTER LN. 1016 SHELTER LN. LANSING MI 48912 0.207 0.207 0.30 0.062 0.051% $5,990.00 33‐01‐01‐11‐430‐201 1010 SHELTER LN. 1010 SHELTER LN. LANSING MI 48912 0.180 0.180 0.33 0.059 0.048% $5,729.57 33‐01‐01‐11‐430‐211 1004 SHELTER LN. 1004 SHELTER LN. LANSING MI 48912 0.180 0.180 0.33 0.059 0.048% $5,729.57 33‐01‐01‐11‐430‐221 1000 SHELTER LN. 1000 SHELTER LN. LANSING MI 48912 0.254 0.254 0.30 0.076 0.062% $7,350.05 33‐01‐01‐11‐430‐231 3115 HOLIDAY DR. 3115 HOLIDAY DR. LANSING MI 48912 0.209 0.209 0.30 0.063 0.051% $6,047.87 33‐01‐01‐11‐430‐241 3201 MELODY LN. 3201 MELODY LN. LANSING MI 48912 0.255 0.255 0.30 0.077 0.062% $7,378.99 33‐01‐01‐11‐430‐251 3207 MELODY LN. 3207 MELODY LN. LANSING MI 48912 0.243 0.243 0.30 0.073 0.059% $7,031.74 33‐01‐01‐11‐430‐261 3211 MELODY LN. 3211 MELODY LN. LANSING MI 48912 0.202 0.202 0.30 0.061 0.049% $5,845.31 33‐01‐01‐11‐430‐271 3215 MELODY LN. 3215 MELODY LN. LANSING MI 48912 0.215 0.215 0.30 0.065 0.053% $6,221.50 33‐01‐01‐11‐430‐282 3301 MELODY LN. 3301 MELODY LN. LANSING MI 48912 0.332 0.332 0.28 0.093 0.076% $8,966.67 33‐01‐01‐11‐430‐292 3307 MELODY LN. 3307 MELODY LN. LANSING MI 48912 0.257 0.257 0.30 0.077 0.063% $7,436.86 33‐01‐01‐11‐430‐301 3313 MELODY LN. 3313 MELODY LN. LANSING MI 48912 0.249 0.249 0.30 0.075 0.061% $7,205.36 33‐01‐01‐11‐430‐311 3321 MELODY LN. 3321 MELODY LN. LANSING MI 48912 0.281 0.281 0.30 0.084 0.069% $7,592.11 33‐01‐01‐11‐430‐321 3331 MELODY LN. 3331 MELODY LN. LANSING MI 48912 0.220 0.220 0.30 0.066 0.054% $6,366.18 33‐01‐01‐11‐430‐331 1017 COOLIDGE RD. 1017 COOLIDGE RD. LANSING MI 48912 0.193 0.193 0.30 0.058 0.047% $5,584.88 33‐01‐01‐11‐430‐341 1023 COOLIDGE RD. 1023 COOLIDGE RD. LANSING MI 48912 0.193 0.193 0.30 0.058 0.047% $5,584.88 33‐01‐01‐11‐430‐351 1029 COOLIDGE RD. 1029 COOLIDGE RD. LANSING MI 48912 0.193 0.193 0.30 0.058 0.047% $5,584.88 TOTAL EASEMENT EQUIVALENT PARCEL OWNER PROPERTY OWNER OWNER OWNER ACRES IN DETENTION LAND USE TOTAL RECOMMENDED PARCEL AREA FOR RUNOFF NUMBER ADDRESS ADDRESS CITY STATE ZIP DISTRICT CREDIT FACTOR APPORTIONMENT ASSESSMENT ACRES LID/R.G.'s ACRES 33‐01‐01‐11‐430‐361 940 S KENTUCKY AVE 1035 COOLIDGE RD. WINTER PARK FL 32789 0.193 0.193 0.30 0.058 0.047% $5,584.88 33‐01‐01‐11‐430‐371 1041 COOLIDGE RD. 1041 COOLIDGE RD. LANSING MI 48912 0.193 0.193 0.30 0.058 0.047% $5,584.88 33‐01‐01‐11‐430‐381 217 82ND ST 1047 COOLIDGE RD. VIRGINIA BEACH VA 23451 0.226 0.226 0.30 0.068 0.055% $6,539.81 33‐01‐01‐11‐430‐391 1053 COOLIDGE RD. 1053 COOLIDGE RD. LANSING MI 48912 0.220 0.220 0.30 0.066 0.054% $6,366.18 33‐01‐01‐11‐430‐401 2406 WILTSHIRE CT, APT 104 1101 COOLIDGE RD. ROCHESTER MI 48309 0.234 0.234 0.30 0.070 0.057% $6,771.30 33‐01‐01‐11‐430‐411 1109 COOLIDGE RD. 1109 COOLIDGE RD. LANSING MI 48912 0.234 0.234 0.30 0.070 0.057% $6,771.30 33‐01‐01‐11‐430‐421 1117 COOLIDGE RD. 1117 COOLIDGE RD. LANSING MI 48912 0.234 0.234 0.30 0.070 0.057% $6,771.30 33‐01‐01‐11‐430‐431 1125 COOLIDGE RD. 1125 COOLIDGE RD. LANSING MI 48912 0.234 0.234 0.30 0.070 0.057% $6,771.30 33‐01‐01‐11‐430‐441 1131 COOLIDGE RD. 1131 COOLIDGE RD. LANSING MI 48912 0.234 0.234 0.30 0.070 0.057% $6,771.30 33‐01‐01‐11‐430‐451 1201 COOLIDGE RD. 1201 COOLIDGE RD. LANSING MI 48912 0.234 0.234 0.30 0.070 0.057% $6,771.30 33‐01‐01‐11‐430‐461 1215 COOLIDGE RD. 1215 COOLIDGE RD. LANSING MI 48912 0.234 0.234 0.30 0.070 0.057% $6,771.30 33‐01‐01‐11‐430‐471 1233 COOLIDGE RD. 1233 COOLIDGE RD. LANSING MI 48912 0.234 0.234 0.30 0.070 0.057% $6,771.30 33‐01‐01‐11‐430‐481 3322 STONEWOOD DR. 3322 STONEWOOD DR. LANSING MI 48912 0.234 0.234 0.30 0.070 0.057% $6,771.30 33‐01‐01‐11‐451‐002 3093 S LINDEN RD STE A 3101 E SAGINAW ST FLINT MI 48507 0.950 0.950 0.1448 0.90 0.725 0.590% $69,900.70 33‐01‐01‐11‐451‐021 PO BOX 475 3125 E SAGINAW ST MILFORD MI 48380 0.986 0.986 0.90 0.887 0.722% $85,596.24 33‐01‐01‐11‐451‐031 539 S MAIN ST 3201 E SAGINAW ST FINDLAY OH 45840 0.507 0.507 0.90 0.456 0.371% $44,013.48 33‐01‐01‐11‐476‐001 1001 FAIRWAY LN. 1009 FAIRWAY LN. LANSING MI 48912 0.251 0.251 0.90 0.226 0.184% $21,789.71 33‐01‐01‐11‐476‐011 1001 FAIRWAY LN. 1001 FAIRWAY LN. LANSING MI 48912 0.307 0.307 0.90 0.276 0.225% $26,651.16 33‐01‐01‐11‐476‐021 3101 E GRAND RIVER AVE 3101 FAIRWAY LN. LANSING MI 48912 3.261 3.261 0.90 2.935 2.389% $283,092.62 33‐01‐01‐11‐476‐031 925 MANOR DR. 3121 E GRAND RIVER AVE WILMETTE IL IL 60091 2.355 2.355 0.90 2.120 1.725% $204,441.32 33‐01‐01‐11‐476‐043 31000 NORTHWESTERN HWY, STE 200 3201 E GRAND RIVER AVE FARMINGTON HILLS MI 48334 1.390 1.390 0.90 1.251 1.018% $120,668.12 33‐01‐01‐11‐476‐053 300 FRANDOR AVE UNIT 2 COOLIDGE RD. LANSING MI 48912 1.412 1.412 0.90 1.271 1.034% $122,577.98 33‐01‐01‐11‐476‐062 300 FRANDOR AVE UNIT 2 3415 E SAGNIAW ST. LANSING MI 48912 2.588 2.588 0.90 2.329 1.896% $224,668.42 33‐01‐01‐11‐476‐071 300 WILMONT RD. 3435 E SAGNIAW ST DEERFIELD MI 48912 1.338 1.338 0.90 1.204 0.980% $116,153.92 33‐01‐01‐11‐476‐082 126 S PUTNAM ST 905 COOLIDGE RD. WILLIAMSTON MI 48895 0.423 0.423 0.90 0.381 0.310% $36,721.31 33‐01‐01‐11‐476‐101 7750 BLACK RIDGE LN 921 COOLIDGE RD. SAINT JOHNS MI 48879 0.580 0.580 0.90 0.522 0.425% $50,350.73 33‐01‐01‐11‐476‐111 3330 MELODY LN. 3328 MELODY LN LANSING MI 48912 0.215 0.215 0.30 0.065 0.053% $6,221.50 33‐01‐01‐11‐476‐121 3320 MELODY LN. 3320 MELODY LN LANSING MI 48912 0.193 0.193 0.30 0.058 0.047% $5,584.88 33‐01‐01‐11‐476‐131 3312 MELODY LN. 6107 FRESNO LN. EAST LANSING MI 48823 0.207 0.207 0.30 0.062 0.051% $5,990.00 33‐01‐01‐11‐476‐141 7643 WILDON WAY 3308 MELODY LN. GRAND LEDGE MI 48837 0.207 0.207 0.30 0.062 0.051% $5,990.00 33‐01‐01‐11‐476‐151 2453 WASHINGTON RD. 3220 MELODY LN. LANSING MI 48911 0.178 0.178 0.33 0.059 0.048% $5,665.90 33‐01‐01‐11‐476‐161 406 SHORELANE DR. 3212 MELODY LN. DEWITT MI 48820 0.166 0.166 0.33 0.055 0.045% $5,283.93 33‐01‐01‐11‐476‐171 2502 LAKE LANSING RD., STE C 3206 MELODY LN. LANSING MI 48912 0.256 0.256 0.90 0.230 0.188% $22,223.77 33‐01‐01‐11‐476‐181 2520 W LIBERTY 3227 HOLIDAY DR. ANN ARBOR MI 48103 0.417 0.417 0.90 0.375 0.305% $36,200.44 33‐01‐01‐11‐476‐191 2520 W LIBERTY 3225 HOLIDAY DR. ANN ARBOR MI 48103 0.476 0.476 0.90 0.428 0.349% $41,322.32 33‐01‐01‐11‐476‐201 2502 LAKE LANSING RD., STE C 3218 HOLIDAY DR. LANSING MI 48912 0.920 0.920 0.90 0.828 0.674% $79,866.67 33‐01‐01‐11‐476‐211 2502 LAKE LANSING RD., STE C 3208 HOLIDAY DR. LANSING MI 48912 0.646 0.646 0.90 0.581 0.473% $56,080.29 33‐01‐01‐11‐476‐221 2502 LAKE LANSING RD., STE C 3120 HOLIDAY DR. LANSING MI 48912 0.578 0.578 0.90 0.520 0.423% $50,177.10 33‐01‐01‐11‐476‐231 2815 HOPKINS AVE. 3106 HOLIDAY DR. LANSING MI 48912 0.292 0.292 0.90 0.263 0.214% $25,348.99 33‐01‐01‐11‐476‐241 1260 TROTTERS LN. 3100 HOLIDAY DR. WILLIAMSTON MI 48895 0.327 0.327 0.90 0.294 0.240% $28,387.39 33‐01‐01‐13‐151‐002 1111 MICHIGAN AVE SUITE #300 3301 E MICHIGAN AVE EAST LANSING MI 48823 9.483 9.483 0.21 0.90 8.346 6.793% $805,003.96 33‐01‐01‐13‐151‐014 330 MARSHALL ST STE 100 3335 E MICHIGAN AVE LANSING MI 48912 0.577 0.577 0.90 0.519 0.423% $50,090.29 33‐01‐01‐13‐151‐023 330 MARSHALL ST STE 100 3433 E MICHIGAN AVE LANSING MI 48912 1.007 1.007 0.1 0.90 0.816 0.664% $78,677.35 33‐01‐01‐13‐151‐034 1111 MICHIGAN AVE SUITE #300 FRIENDSHIP CIRCLE EAST LANSING MI 48823 0.849 0.849 0.90 0.764 0.622% $73,703.05 33‐01‐01‐13‐151‐036 4275 FIVE OAKS DR 200 FRIENDSHIP CIRCLE LANSING MI 48911 3.900 3.900 0.90 3.510 2.857% $338,565.24 33‐01‐01‐13‐151‐038 1111 MICHIGAN AVE SUITE #300 3315 E MICHIGAN AVE EAST LANSING MI 48823 1.301 1.301 0.90 1.171 0.953% $112,941.89 33‐01‐01‐13‐151‐041 2502 LAKE LANSING RD STE C 1275 OAKRIDGE DR LANSING MI 48912 0.774 0.774 0.90 0.697 0.567% $67,192.18 33‐01‐01‐14‐226‐001 300 FRANDOR AVE 3100 E SAGNIAW ST LANSING MI 48912 1.414 1.414 0.90 1.273 1.036% $122,751.60 33‐01‐01‐14‐226‐015 300 FRANDOR AVE 300 FRANDOR AVE LANSING MI 48912 32.000 32.000 0.719 0.90 28.153 22.915% $2,715,553.63 33‐01‐01‐14‐226‐021 3333 BEVERLY RD 3131 E MICHIGAN AVE HOFFMAN ESTATES IL 60179 14.481 14.481 0.90 13.033 10.608% $1,257,118.77 33‐01‐01‐14‐226‐031 2211 YORK RD SUITE #222 3165 E MICHIGAN AVE OAK BROOK IL 60523 3.368 3.368 0.1 0.90 2.728 2.221% $263,143.32 33‐01‐01‐14‐226‐051 300 FRANDOR AVE E MICHIGAN AVE LANSING MI 48912 0.675 0.675 0.675 0.90 33‐01‐01‐14‐226‐061 124 W MICHIGAN AVE, FL 8TH 3201 E MICHIGAN AVE LANSING MI 48912 18.900 18.900 33‐01‐01‐14‐226‐067 1571 OGDEN AVE APT #2635 3220 E SAGINAW ST LA GRANGE PARK IL 60526 1.090 1.090 0.90 0.981 0.798% $94,624.64 33‐01‐01‐14‐226‐071 PO BOX 3967 3130 E SAGINAW ST ORLANDO FL 32802 0.999 0.999 0.90 0.899 0.732% $86,724.79 33‐01‐01‐14‐226‐082 3333 ROWLEY RD 3240 E SAGINAW ST WILLIAMSTON MI 48895 1.035 1.035 0.1739 0.90 0.775 0.631% $74,753.47 33‐01‐01‐14‐256‐001 1111 MICHIGAN AVE SUITE #300 3000 VINE ST EAST LANSING MI 48823 0.618 0.618 0.90 0.556 0.453% $53,649.57 33‐01‐01‐14‐256‐022 13155 NOEL RD STE 100 223 N CLIPPERT ST DALLAS TX 75240 1.112 1.112 0.90 1.001 0.815% $96,534.50 33‐01‐01‐14‐256‐042 4086 LEGACY PKWY 200 N HOMER ST. LANSING MI 48911 0.664 0.664 0.90 0.598 0.486% $57,642.90 33‐01‐01‐14‐256‐064 3400 WEST RD 3003 E MICHIGAN AVE EAST LANSING MI 48823 1.271 1.271 0.036 0.90 1.112 0.905% $107,212.32 33‐01‐01‐14‐256‐071 3400 WEST RD E MICHIGAN AVE EAST LANSING MI 48823 0.705 0.705 0.0971 0.90 0.547 0.445% $52,772.77 TOTAL EASEMENT EQUIVALENT PARCEL OWNER PROPERTY OWNER OWNER OWNER ACRES IN DETENTION LAND USE TOTAL RECOMMENDED PARCEL AREA FOR RUNOFF NUMBER ADDRESS ADDRESS CITY STATE ZIP DISTRICT CREDIT FACTOR APPORTIONMENT ASSESSMENT ACRES LID/R.G.'s ACRES 33‐01‐01‐14‐256‐080 3400 WEST RD 125 N CLIPPERT ST EAST LANSING MI 48823 0.549 0.549 0.90 0.494 0.402% $47,659.57 33‐01‐01‐14‐256‐102 126 PUTNAM ST 203 N CLIPPERT ST WILLIAMSTON MI 48895 0.274 0.274 0.90 0.247 0.201% $23,786.38 33‐01‐01‐14‐256‐111 211 N CLIPPERT ST 211 N CLIPPERT ST LANSING MI 48912 0.129 0.129 0.90 0.116 0.095% $11,198.70 33‐01‐01‐14‐256‐121 215 N CLIPPERT ST 215 N CLIPPERT ST LANSING MI 48912 0.124 0.124 0.90 0.112 0.091% $10,764.64 33‐01‐01‐14‐426‐001 203 S CLIPPERT ST LANSING MI 48933 20.000 20.000 33‐01‐01‐14‐426‐001 203 S CLIPPERT ST LANSING MI 48933 35.440 31.280 0.1 0.90 26.982 21.962% $2,602,611.74 DRAFT SPECIAL ASSESSMENT ROLL FOR MONTGOMERY DRAIN This list serves as a draft roll for the Montgomery Drain assessments. The information is in alphabetical order based on street name. COOLIDGE ROAD EQUIVALENT EQUIVALENT PARCEL ADDRESS TOTAL PARCEL ACRES IN EASEMENT AREA DETENTION LAND USE ASSESSMENT APPROX. TOTAL RUNOFF ACRES RUNOFF NUMBER NUMBER ACRES DISTRICT FOR LID/R.G'S CREDIT FACTOR (% OF TOTAL) ASSESSMENT ACRES 33-01-01-11-476-082 905 0.423 0.423 0.90 0.381 0.310% $36,718.05 33-01-01-11-476-101 921 0.580 0.580 0.90 0.522 0.425% $50,346.26 33-01-01-11-430-331 1017 0.193 0.193 0.33 0.064 0.052% $6,142.82 33-01-01-11-430-341 1023 0.193 0.193 0.30 0.058 0.047% $5,584.38 33-01-01-11-430-351 1029 0.193 0.193 0.30 0.058 0.047% $5,584.38 33-01-01-11-430-361 1035 0.193 0.193 0.30 0.058 0.047% $5,584.38 33-01-01-11-430-381 1047 0.226 0.226 0.30 0.068 0.055% $6,539.23 33-01-01-11-430-391 1053 0.220 0.220 0.30 0.066 0.054% $6,365.62 33-01-01-11-430-401 1101 0.234 0.234 0.30 0.070 0.057% $6,770.70 33-01-01-11-430-411 1109 0.234 0.234 0.30 0.070 0.057% $6,770.70 33-01-01-11-430-421 1117 0.234 0.234 0.30 0.070 0.057% $6,770.70 33-01-01-11-430-431 1125 0.234 0.234 0.30 0.070 0.057% $6,770.70 33-01-01-11-430-441 1131 0.234 0.234 0.30 0.070 0.057% $6,770.70 33-01-01-11-430-461 1215 0.234 0.234 0.30 0.070 0.057% $6,770.70 33-01-01-11-430-471 1233 0.234 0.234 0.30 0.070 0.057% $6,770.70 33-01-01-11-426-131 1301 0.259 0.213 0.30 0.064 0.052% $6,163.08 33-01-01-11-476-053 1.412 1.412 0.90 1.271 1.034% $122,567.10 33-01-01-11-430-371 1041 0.193 0.193 0.33 0.064 0.052% $6,142.82 33-01-01-11-430-351 1201 0.234 0.234 0.30 0.070 0.057% $6,770.70 E. GRAND RIVER AVENUE EQUIVALENT PARCEL ADDRESS TOTAL PARCEL ACRES IN EASEMENT AREA DETENTION LAND USE ASSESSMENT APPROX. TOTAL RUNOFF NUMBER NUMBER ACRES DISTRICT FOR LID/R.G'S CREDIT FACTOR (% OF TOTAL) ASSESSMENT ACRES 33-01-01-11-476-031 3121 2.355 2.355 0.90 2.120 1.725% $204,423.18 33-01-01-11-476-043 3201 1.390 1.390 0.90 1.251 1.018% $120,657.42 E. MICHIGAN AVENUE EQUIVALENT PARCEL ADDRESS TOTAL PARCEL ACRES IN EASEMENT AREA DETENTION LAND USE ASSESSMENT APPROX. TOTAL RUNOFF NUMBER NUMBER ACRES DISTRICT FOR LID/R.G'S CREDIT FACTOR (% OF TOTAL) ASSESSMENT ACRES 33-01-01-14-256-064 3003 1.271 1.271 0.036 0.90 1.112 0.905% $107,202.81 33-01-01-14-226-021 3131 14.481 14.481 0.90 13.033 10.607% $1,257,007.24 33-01-01-14-226-031 3165 3.368 3.368 0.1 0.90 2.728 2.220% $263,119.97 33-01-01-14-226-061 3201 18.900 18.900 0.00 0.000 0.000% $0.00 33-01-01-13-151-002 3301 9.483 9.483 0.21 0.90 8.346 6.793% $804,932.54 33-01-01-13-151-038 3315 1.301 1.301 0.90 1.171 0.953% $112,931.87 33-01-01-13-151-014 3335 0.577 0.577 0.90 0.519 0.423% $50,085.85 33-01-01-13-151-023 3433 1.007 1.007 0.1 0.90 0.816 0.664% $78,670.37 33-01-01-13-226-051 0.675 0.675 0.675 0.90 0.000 0.000% $0.00 33-01-01-13-256-071 0.705 0.705 0.0971 0.90 0.547 0.445% $52,768.09 [SEE NEXT PAGE] DRAFT SPECIAL ASSESSMENT ROLL FOR MONTGOMERY DRAIN This list serves as a draft roll for the Montgomery Drain assessments. The information is in alphabetical order based on street name. E. SAGINAW STREET EQUIVALENT EQUIVALENT PARCEL ADDRESS TOTAL PARCEL ACRES IN EASEMENT AREA DETENTION LAND USE ASSESSMENT APPROX. TOTAL RUNOFF ACRES RUNOFF NUMBER NUMBER ACRES DISTRICT FOR LID/R.G'S CREDIT FACTOR (% OF TOTAL) ASSESSMENT ACRES 33-01-01-11-451-002 3101 0.950 0.950 0.1448 0.90 0.725 0.590% $69,894.50 33-01-01-11-451-021 3125 0.986 0.986 0.90 0.887 0.722% $85,588.64 33-01-01-14-226-071 3130 0.999 0.999 0.90 0.899 0.732% $86,717.09 33-01-01-11-451-031 3201 0.507 0.507 0.90 0.456 0.371% $44,009.58 33-01-01-14-226-067 3220 1.090 1.090 0.90 0.981 0.798% $94,616.25 33-01-01-14-226-082 3240 1.035 1.035 0.1739 0.90 0.775 0.631% $74,746.84 33-01-01-14-226-001 3100 1.414 1.414 0.90 1.273 1.036% $122,740.71 33-01-01-11-476-071 3435 1.338 1.338 0.90 1.204 0.980% $116,143.62 33-01-01-11-476-062 3415 2.588 2.588 0.90 2.329 1.896% $224,648.49 FAIRWAY COURT PARCEL ADDRESS TOTAL PARCEL ACRES IN EASEMENT AREA DETENTION LAND USE NUMBER NUMBER ACRES DISTRICT FOR LID/R.G'S CREDIT FACTOR 33-01-01-11-428-082 3106 0.276 0.276 0.30 0.083 0.067% $7,985.96 33-01-01-11-428-132 3109 0.423 0.423 0.28 0.118 0.096% $11,423.39 33-01-01-11-428-061 3116 0.247 0.247 0.30 0.074 0.060% $7,146.85 33-01-01-11-428-111 3107 0.338 0.338 0.28 0.095 0.077% $9,127.91 33-01-01-11-428-071 3110 0.201 0.201 0.30 0.060 0.049% $5,815.86 FAIRWAY LANE EQUIVALENT PARCEL ADDRESS TOTAL PARCEL ACRES IN EASEMENT AREA DETENTION LAND USE ASSESSMENT APPROX. TOTAL RUNOFF NUMBER NUMBER ACRES DISTRICT FOR LID/R.G'S CREDIT FACTOR (% OF TOTAL) ASSESSMENT ACRES 33-01-01-11-429-161 936 0.128 0.128 0.33 0.042 0.034% $4,074.00 33-01-01-11-429-151 1001 0.307 0.307 0.90 0.276 0.225% $26,648.80 33-01-01-11-429-151 1008 0.160 0.160 0.33 0.053 0.043% $5,092.50 33-01-01-11-476-001 1009 0.251 0.251 0.90 0.226 0.184% $21,787.78 33-01-01-11-429-141 1014 0.184 0.184 0.33 0.061 0.049% $5,856.37 33-01-01-11-428-142 1019 0.377 0.377 0.28 0.106 0.086% $10,181.13 33-01-01-11-429-131 1020 0.184 0.184 0.30 0.055 0.045% $5,323.97 33-01-01-11-429-121 1028 0.216 0.216 0.30 0.065 0.053% $6,249.88 33-01-01-11-429-111 1032 0.212 0.212 0.30 0.064 0.052% $6,134.14 33-01-01-11-429-101 1036 0.268 0.268 0.30 0.080 0.065% $7,754.48 33-01-01-11-429-091 1040 0.220 0.220 0.30 0.066 0.054% $6,365.62 33-01-01-11-428-052 1043 0.136 0.136 0.33 0.045 0.037% $4,328.62 33-01-01-11-429-081 1102 0.338 0.338 0.28 0.095 0.077% $9,127.91 33-01-01-11-428-042 1107 0.284 0.284 0.28 0.080 0.065% $7,669.61 33-01-01-11-429-071 1108 0.348 0.348 0.28 0.097 0.079% $9,397.97 33-01-01-11-429-061 1114 0.256 0.256 0.28 0.072 0.058% $6,913.45 33-01-01-11-428-031 1119 0.226 0.226 0.30 0.068 0.055% $6,539.23 [SEE NEXT PAGE] DRAFT SPECIAL ASSESSMENT ROLL FOR MONTGOMERY DRAIN This list serves as a draft roll for the Montgomery Drain assessments. The information is in alphabetical order based on street name. 33-01-01-11-429-051 1120 0.249 0.249 0.30 0.075 0.061% $7,204.72 33-01-01-11-428-022 1127 0.490 0.490 0.25 0.122 0.100% $11,814.97 33-01-01-11-429-041 1128 0.242 0.242 0.30 0.073 0.059% $7,002.18 33-01-01-11-429-031 1136 0.248 0.248 0.30 0.074 0.061% $7,175.79 33-01-01-11-428-012 1141 0.369 0.369 0.28 0.103 0.084% $9,965.09 33-01-01-11-429-021 1144 0.248 0.248 0.30 0.074 0.061% $7,175.79 33-01-01-11-429-011 1202 0.231 0.231 0.30 0.069 0.056% $6,683.90 33-01-01-11-429-001 1210 0.290 0.290 0.28 0.081 0.066% $7,831.64 33-01-01-11-476-021 3101 3.261 3.261 0.90 2.935 2.389% $283,067.51 FRESNO LANE EQUIVALENT PARCEL ADDRESS TOTAL PARCEL ACRES IN EASEMENT AREA DETENTION LAND USE RUNOFF ASSESSMENT APPROX. TOTAL NUMBER NUMBER ACRES DISTRICT FOR LID/R.G'S CREDIT FACTOR ACRES (% OF TOTAL) ASSESSMENT 33-01-01-11-476-131 6107 0.207 0.207 0.33 0.068 0.056% $6,588.42 FRIENDSHIP CIRCLE EQUIVALENT PARCEL ADDRESS TOTAL PARCEL ACRES IN EASEMENT AREA DETENTION LAND USE RUNOFF ASSESSMENT APPROX. TOTAL NUMBER NUMBER ACRES DISTRICT FOR LID/R.G'S CREDIT FACTOR ACRES (% OF TOTAL) ASSESSMENT 33-01-01-13-151-036 200 3.900 3.900 0.90 3.510 2.857% $338,535.20 33-01-01-13-151-034 0.849 0.849 0.90 0.764 0.622% $73,696.51 HILLGATE CIRCLE EQUIVALENT PARCEL ADDRESS TOTAL PARCEL ACRES IN EASEMENT AREA DETENTION LAND USE RUNOFF ASSESSMENT APPROX. TOTAL NUMBER NUMBER ACRES DISTRICT FOR LID/R.G'S CREDIT FACTOR ACRES (% OF TOTAL) ASSESSMENT 33-01-01-11-427-011 3201 0.379 0.379 0.28 0.106 0.086% $10,235.14 33-01-01-11-427-021 3209 0.267 0.267 0.28 0.075 0.061% $7,210.51 33-01-01-11-427-031 3213 0.313 0.313 0.28 0.088 0.071% $8,452.77 HILLGATE WAY EQUIVALENT PARCEL ADDRESS TOTAL PARCEL ACRES IN EASEMENT AREA DETENTION LAND USE RUNOFF ASSESSMENT APPROX. TOTAL NUMBER NUMBER ACRES DISTRICT FOR LID/R.G'S CREDIT FACTOR ACRES (% OF TOTAL) ASSESSMENT 33-01-01-11-429-271 1105 0.256 0.256 0.30 0.077 0.063% $7,407.27 33-01-01-11-427-081 1114 0.191 0.191 0.33 0.063 0.051% $6,079.17 33-01-01-11-429-281 1115 0.307 0.307 0.28 0.086 0.070% $8,290.74 33-01-01-11-427-071 1122 0.237 0.237 0.30 0.071 0.058% $6,857.51 33-01-01-11-429-291 1123 0.303 0.303 0.28 0.085 0.069% $8,182.71 33-01-01-11-429-301 1131 0.247 0.247 0.30 0.074 0.060% $7,146.85 33-01-01-11-427-061 1132 0.275 0.275 0.28 0.077 0.063% $7,426.56 33-01-01-11-429-311 1139 0.237 0.237 0.30 0.071 0.058% $6,857.51 33-01-01-11-427-052 1142 0.209 0.209 0.30 0.063 0.051% $6,047.34 33-01-01-11-429-321 1147 0.245 0.245 0.30 0.074 0.060% $7,088.98 33-01-01-11-429-331 1155 0.219 0.219 0.30 0.066 0.053% $6,336.68 [SEE NEXT PAGE] DRAFT SPECIAL ASSESSMENT ROLL FOR MONTGOMERY DRAIN This list serves as a draft roll for the Montgomery Drain assessments. The information is in alphabetical order based on street name. 33-01-01-11-429-352 1211 0.166 0.166 0.33 0.055 0.045% $5,283.46 33-01-01-11-429-342 1203 0.250 0.250 0.30 0.075 0.061% $7,233.66 HOLIDAY DRIVE EQUIVALENT PARCEL ADDRESS TOTAL PARCEL ACRES IN EASEMENT AREA DETENTION LAND USE RUNOFF ASSESSMENT APPROX. TOTAL NUMBER NUMBER ACRES DISTRICT FOR LID/R.G'S CREDIT FACTOR ACRES (% OF TOTAL) ASSESSMENT 33-01-01-11-476-241 3100 0.327 0.327 0.90 0.294 0.240% $28,384.87 33-01-01-11-476-231 3106 0.292 0.292 0.90 0.263 0.214% $25,346.74 33-01-01-11-476-201 3115 0.209 0.209 0.30 0.063 0.051% $6,047.34 33-01-01-11-476-221 3120 0.578 0.578 0.90 0.520 0.423% $50,172.65 33-01-01-11-476-211 3208 0.646 0.646 0.90 0.581 0.473% $56,075.32 33-01-01-11-476-201 3218 0.920 0.920 0.90 0.828 0.674% $79,859.59 33-01-01-11-476-191 3225 0.476 0.476 0.90 0.428 0.349% $41,318.66 33-01-01-11-476-181 3227 0.417 0.417 0.90 0.375 0.305% $36,197.23 MELODY LANE EQUIVALENT PARCEL ADDRESS TOTAL PARCEL ACRES IN EASEMENT AREA DETENTION LAND USE RUNOFF ASSESSMENT APPROX. TOTAL NUMBER NUMBER ACRES DISTRICT FOR LID/R.G'S CREDIT FACTOR ACRES (% OF TOTAL) ASSESSMENT 33-01-01-11-476-121 3320 0.193 0.193 0.30 0.058 0.047% $5,584.38 33-01-01-11-476-111 3328 0.215 0.215 0.30 0.064 0.052% $6,220.95 33-01-01-11-430-241 3201 0.255 0.255 0.30 0.076 0.062% $7,378.33 33-01-01-11-476-171 3206 0.256 0.256 0.90 0.230 0.188% $22,221.80 33-01-01-11-430-251 3207 0.243 0.243 0.30 0.073 0.059% $7,031.12 33-01-01-11-430-261 3211 0.202 0.202 0.30 0.061 0.049% $5,844.80 33-01-01-11-476-161 3212 0.166 0.166 0.33 0.055 0.045% $5,283.46 33-01-01-11-430-271 3215 0.215 0.215 0.30 0.064 0.052% $6,220.95 33-01-01-11-476-151 3220 0.178 0.178 0.33 0.059 0.048% $5,665.40 33-01-01-11-430-282 3301 0.332 0.332 0.28 0.093 0.076% $8,965.88 33-01-01-11-430-292 3307 0.257 0.257 0.30 0.077 0.063% $7,436.20 33-01-01-11-476-141 3308 0.207 0.207 0.33 0.068 0.056% $6,588.42 33-01-01-11-430-301 3313 0.249 0.249 0.30 0.075 0.061% $7.204.72 33-01-01-11-430-321 3331 0.220 0.220 0.30 0.066 0.054% $6,365.62 33-01-01-11-430-311 3321 0.281 0.281 0.28 0.079 0.064% $7,588.59 N. CLIPPERT STREET EQUIVALENT PARCEL ADDRESS TOTAL PARCEL ACRES IN EASEMENT AREA DETENTION LAND USE RUNOFF ASSESSMENT APPROX. TOTAL NUMBER NUMBER ACRES DISTRICT FOR LID/R.G'S CREDIT FACTOR ACRES (% OF TOTAL) ASSESSMENT 33-01-01-14-256-080 125 0.549 0.549 0.90 0.494 0.402% $47,655.34 33-01-01-14-256-102 203 0.274 0.274 0.90 0.247 0.201% $23,784.27 33-01-01-14-256-111 211 0.129 0.129 0.90 0.116 0.094% $11,197.70 33-01-01-14-256-121 215 0.124 0.124 0.90 0.112 0.091% $10,763.68 33-01-01-14-256-022 223 1.112 1.112 0.90 1.001 0.815% $96,525.93 [SEE NEXT PAGE] DRAFT SPECIAL ASSESSMENT ROLL FOR MONTGOMERY DRAIN This list serves as a draft roll for the Montgomery Drain assessments. The information is in alphabetical order based on street name. N. HOMER STREET EQUIVALENT PARCEL ADDRESS TOTAL PARCEL ACRES IN EASEMENT AREA DETENTION LAND USE RUNOFF ASSESSMENT APPROX. TOTAL NUMBER NUMBER ACRES DISTRICT FOR LID/R.G'S CREDIT FACTOR ACRES (% OF TOTAL) ASSESSMENT 33-01-01-14-256-042 200 0.664 0.664 0.90 0.598 0.486% $57,637.79 NO FRONTAGE EQUIVALENT PARCEL ADDRESS TOTAL PARCEL ACRES IN EASEMENT AREA DETENTION LAND USE RUNOFF ASSESSMENT APPROX. TOTAL NUMBER NUMBER ACRES DISTRICT FOR LID/R.G'S CREDIT FACTOR ACRES (% OF TOTAL) ASSESSMENT 33-01-01-11-426-037 0.413 0.114 0.22 0.025 0.020% $2,418.94 OAKRIDGE DRIVE EQUIVALENT PARCEL ADDRESS TOTAL PARCEL ACRES IN EASEMENT AREA DETENTION LAND USE RUNOFF ASSESSMENT APPROX. TOTAL NUMBER NUMBER ACRES DISTRICT FOR LID/R.G'S CREDIT FACTOR ACRES (% OF TOTAL) ASSESSMENT 33-01-01-13-151-041 1275 0.774 0.774 0.90 0.697 0.567% $67,186.22 RANDOR AVENUE EQUIVALENT PARCEL ADDRESS TOTAL PARCEL ACRES IN EASEMENT AREA DETENTION LAND USE RUNOFF ASSESSMENT APPROX. TOTAL NUMBER NUMBER ACRES DISTRICT FOR LID/R.G'S CREDIT FACTOR ACRES (% OF TOTAL) ASSESSMENT 33-01-01-14-256-015 300 32.000 32.000 0.719 0.90 28.153 22.913% $2,715,312.72 S. CLIPPERT STREET EQUIVALENT PARCEL ADDRESS TOTAL PARCEL ACRES IN EASEMENT AREA DETENTION LAND USE RUNOFF ASSESSMENT APPROX. TOTAL NUMBER NUMBER ACRES DISTRICT FOR LID/R.G'S CREDIT FACTOR ACRES (% OF TOTAL) ASSESSMENT 33-01-01-14-426-001 203 20.000 20.000 0.00 0.000 0.000% $0.00 33-01-01-14-426-001 203 35.440 31.280 0.1 0.90 26.982 21.960% $2,602,380.85 SHELTER LANE EQUIVALENT PARCEL ADDRESS TOTAL PARCEL ACRES IN EASEMENT AREA DETENTION LAND USE RUNOFF ASSESSMENT APPROX. TOTAL NUMBER NUMBER ACRES DISTRICT FOR LID/R.G'S CREDIT FACTOR ACRES (% OF TOTAL) ASSESSMENT 33-01-01-11-430-221 1000 0.254 0.254 0.30 0.076 0.062% $7,349.40 33-01-01-11-429-171 1001 0.245 0.245 0.30 0.074 0.060% $7,088.98 33-01-01-11-430-211 1004 0.180 0.180 0.33 0.059 0.048% $5,729.06 33-01-01-11-429-181 1005 0.259 0.259 0.30 0.078 0.063% $7,494.07 33-01-01-11-430-201 1010 0.180 0.180 0.33 0.059 0.048% $5,729.06 33-01-01-11-429-191 1011 0.321 0.321 0.28 0.090 0.073% $8,668.82 33-01-01-11-430-191 1016 0.207 0.207 0.33 0.068 0.056% $6,588.42 33-01-01-11-429-201 1019 0.247 0.247 0.30 0.074 0.060% $7,146.85 33-01-01-11-430-181 1020 0.221 0.221 0.30 0.066 0.054% $6,394.55 33-01-01-11-429-211 1025 0.245 0.245 0.30 0.074 0.060% $7,088.98 33-01-01-11-430-171 1026 0.196 0.196 0.30 0.059 0.048% $5,671.19 33-01-01-11-430-161 1028 0.199 0.199 0.30 0.060 0.049% $5,757.99 33-01-01-11-429-221 1029 0.270 0.270 0.30 0.081 0.066% $7,812.35 [SEE NEXT PAGE] DRAFT SPECIAL ASSESSMENT ROLL FOR MONTGOMERY DRAIN This list serves as a draft roll for the Montgomery Drain assessments. The information is in alphabetical order based on street name. 33-01-01-11-430-151 1030 0.176 0.176 0.33 0.058 0.047% $5,601.74 33-01-01-11-430-141 1032 0.233 0.233 0.30 0.070 0.057% $6,741.77 33-01-01-11-430-131 1034 0.330 0.330 0.28 0.092 0.075% $8,911.87 33-01-01-11-429-231 1035 0.353 0.353 0.28 0.099 0.080% $9,533.00 33-01-01-11-430-121 1036 0.336 0.336 0.28 0.094 0.077% $9,073.90 33-01-01-11-429-241 1037 0.388 0.388 0.28 0.109 0.088% $10,478.19 33-01-01-11-429-251 1039 0.262 0.262 0.28 0.073 0.060% $7,075.48 33-01-01-11-430-111 1044 0.271 0.271 0.30 0.081 0.066% $7,841.29 33-01-01-11-430-101 1048 0.248 0.248 0.30 0.074 0.061% $7,175.79 33-01-01-11-429-261 1049 0.219 0.219 0.30 0.066 0.053% $6,336.68 33-01-01-11-430-091 1056 0.248 0.248 0.30 0.074 0.061% $7,175.79 33-01-01-11-430-081 1100 0.185 0.185 0.33 0.061 0.050% $5,888.20 33-01-01-11-427-091 1103 0.279 0.279 0.28 0.078 0.064% $7,534.58 33-01-01-11-430-071 1110 0.234 0.234 0.30 0.070 0.057% $6,770.70 33-01-01-11-427-101 1115 0.218 0.218 0.30 0.065 0.053% $6,307.75 33-01-01-11-430-061 1118 0.234 0.234 0.30 0.070 0.057% $6,770.70 33-01-01-11-427-112 1123 0.238 0.238 0.30 0.071 0.058% $6,886.44 33-01-01-11-430-051 1126 0.234 0.234 0.30 0.070 0.057% $6,770.70 33-01-01-11-427-123 1129 0.315 0.315 0.28 0.088 0.072% $8,506.78 33-01-01-11-430-041 1132 0.234 0.234 0.30 0.070 0.057% $6,770.70 33-01-01-11-427-132 1139 0.293 0.293 0.28 0.082 0.067% $7,912.66 33-01-01-11-430-031 1140 0.234 0.234 0.30 0.070 0.057% $6,770.70 33-01-01-11-427-141 1145 0.230 0.230 0.30 0.069 0.056% $6,654.97 33-01-01-11-430-021 1148 0.234 0.234 0.30 0.070 0.057% $6,770.70 33-01-01-11-427-151 1151 0.230 0.230 0.30 0.069 0.056% $6,654.97 33-01-01-11-430-011 1152 0.234 0.234 0.30 0.070 0.057% $6,770.70 33-01-01-11-427-161 1159 0.244 0.244 0.30 0.073 0.060% $7,060.05 33-01-01-11-430-001 1164 0.235 0.235 0.30 0.070 0.057% $6,799.64 STONEWOOD DRIVE EQUIVALENT PARCEL ADDRESS TOTAL PARCEL ACRES IN EASEMENT AREA DETENTION LAND USE RUNOFF ASSESSMENT APPROX. TOTAL NUMBER NUMBER ACRES DISTRICT FOR LID/R.G'S CREDIT FACTOR ACRES (% OF TOTAL) ASSESSMENT 33-01-01-11-427-001 3208 0.240 0.240 0.30 0.072 0.059% $6,944.31 33-01-01-11-426-035 3211 0.316 0.316 0.28 0.088 0.072% $8,533.79 33-01-01-11-427-201 3218 0.203 0.203 0.33 0.067 0.055% $6,461.10 33-01-01-11-426-042 3221 0.426 0.186 0.28 0.052 0.042% $5,023.05 33-01-01-11-427-191 3226 0.233 0.233 0.30 0.070 0.057% $6,741.77 33-01-01-11-426-052 3227 0.263 0.140 0.30 0.042 0.034% $4,050.85 33-01-01-11-426-061 3231 0.230 0.127 0.30 0.038 0.031% $3,674.70 [SEE NEXT PAGE] DRAFT SPECIAL ASSESSMENT ROLL FOR MONTGOMERY DRAIN This list serves as a draft roll for the Montgomery Drain assessments. The information is in alphabetical order based on street name. 33-01-01-11-427-181 3232 0.239 0.239 0.30 0.072 0.058% $6,915.38 33-01-01-11-426-071 3237 0.230 0.117 0.30 0.035 0.029% $3,385.35 33-01-01-11-427-171 3240 0.239 0.239 0.30 0.072 0.058% $6,915.38 33-01-01-11-426-081 3245 0.258 0.100 0.30 0.030 0.024% $2,893.46 33-01-01-11-436-092 3251 0.215 0.042 0.30 0.013 0.010% $1,215.25 33-01-01-11-426-102 3301 0.215 0.041 0.30 0.012 0.010% $1,186.32 33-01-01-11-426-111 3307 0.230 0.057 0.30 0.017 0.014% $1,649.27 33-01-01-11-426-121 3315 0.230 0.060 0.30 0.018 0.015% $1,736.08 33-01-01-11-430-481 3322 0.234 0.234 0.30 0.070 0.057% $6,770.70 33-01-01-11-426-022 0.435 0.435 0.00 0.000 0.000% $0.00 VINE STREET EQUIVALENT PARCEL ADDRESS TOTAL PARCEL ACRES IN EASEMENT AREA DETENTION LAND USE RUNOFF ASSESSMENT APPROX. TOTAL NUMBER NUMBER ACRES DISTRICT FOR LID/R.G'S CREDIT FACTOR ACRES (% OF TOTAL) ASSESSMENT 33-01-01-14-256-001 3000 0.618 0.618 0.90 0.556 0.453% $53,644.81 100% $11,850,307.04 [END] Name Address (If given) Type Parcel Number Date Issue Response Assessment is for the existing Montgomery Drain network. Private property issues are generally the responsibility of the property owner, or may be Joel Sharkey 1139 Hillgate Way email 33‐01‐01‐11‐429‐311 10/7/2020 Invested significant amount of money to address water issues on his property addressed by ICDC as an assessable project. Assessment methodology based on accepted standard runoff coefficients. It Pat Barnes 3301 Melody Lane letter 33‐01‐01‐11‐430‐282 10/21/2020 Property drains to back yard does not take typography into account. Project addresss both water quantity and quality. The assessment menthodology treats all water falling on a parcel the same and does not assign Sean Zielinski 3328 Melody Lane email 33‐01‐01‐11‐476‐111 10/7/2020 Bad timing, Doesn't believe lot is creating pollution, issue from commercial properties separate amounts for each aspect of the system Sean Zielinski 3312 Melody Lane email 33‐01‐01‐11‐476‐131 10/7/2020 Bad timing, Doesn't believe lot is creating pollution, issue from commercial properties See above Assessment methodology based on accepted standard runoff coefficients. It Chris & Kristen Umphlett 1037 Shelter Lane unknown 33‐01‐01‐11‐429‐241 unknown Assessment factor too high. Presented calculations based on impervious area does not take typography into account. Kathryn Lipnicki/Bernice Gottschalck 3321 Melody Lane email 33‐01‐01‐11‐430‐311 10/12/2020 Financial hardship There is no provision for financial hardship within the assessment approach Assessment methodology used parcel size and accepted runoff coefficients, David Fisher 1151 Shelter Lane email 33‐01‐01‐11‐427‐151 10/12/2020 General appeal with 50% paid for by all taxpayers in the city Assessment methodology used parcel size and accepted runoff coefficients. If additional information is provided as to what calculation is incorrect, it can be Elizabeth Florkowski/Fauseon Bohn LLP 3125 E Saginaw Street email 33‐01‐01‐11‐451‐021 10/12/2020 Methodology imprecise, runoff calculations incorrect reviewed. The stormwater system accepts all water coming from the properties and the roads within Frandora Hills. It then transports and treats this water. This is the Barbara Powers 1140 Shelter Lane email 33‐01‐01‐11‐430‐031 10/12/2020 Does not believe there is a direct benefit to the property owners in Frandora Hills benefit to the residents of Frandora Hills. Based on the cost of the project, the City could not absorb the cost into its existing budget, so 50% is to be paid by all property owners and 50% assessed Gerald & Deborah Foster 1127 Fairway Lane email 33‐01‐01‐11‐428‐022 10/12/2020 General appeal. Does not believe residents shoud have to pay for any of the project to the property owners within the drainage area. Assessment methodology based on accepted standard runoff coefficients. It Tim Musson 1131 Hillgate Way email 33‐01‐01‐11‐429‐301 11/12/2020 Water ponds in back yard, only driveway drains to the street does not take typography into account. Based on the cost of the project, the City could not absorb the cost into its existing budget, so 50% is to be paid by all property owners in the city and 50% Steve Dembski 1016 Shelter Lane email 33‐01‐01‐11‐430‐191 10/12/2020 Excessive burden assessed to the property owners within the drainage area. Assessment is for the existing Montgomery Drain network. Private property issues are generally the responsibility of the property owner, or may be Brad & Liz Lamacchia 1123 Hillgate Way email 33‐01‐01‐11‐429‐291 10/11/2020 Invested significant amount to address water issues on property addressed by ICDC as an assessable project. wireless caller ‐ sent to Clerk 10/7/2020 ?? wireless caller ‐ sent to Clerk 10/7/2020 ?? Lucille Nilan 1101 Coolidge Road email 33‐01‐01‐11‐430‐401 10/12/2020 Financial hardship There is no provision for financial hardship within the assessment approach Assessment methodology used parcel size and accepted runoff coefficients, Jason Armistead 3335 E Michigan Avenue email 33‐01‐01‐13‐151‐014 10/9/2020 General appeal with 50% paid for by all taxpayers in the city Jason Armistead 3433 E Michigan Avenue email 33‐01‐01‐13‐151‐023 10/9/2020 General appeal See above Jason Armistead 3131 E Michigan Avenue email 33‐01‐01‐14‐226‐021 10/9/2020 General appeal See above Assessment methodology used parcel size and accepted runoff coefficients. Connie Frantz 1233 Coolidge Road email 33‐01‐01‐14‐430‐471 10/12/2020 Methodology, calculations Council can review calculations provided. Assessment methodology used parcel size and accepted runoff coefficients, Hallahan & Associates/Lansing Retail LLC 300 Frandor Ave email 33‐01‐01‐14‐226‐015 10/12/2020 General appeal with 50% paid for by all taxpayers in the city Hallahan & Associates/Lansing Retail LLC Morgan Lane email 33‐01‐01‐14‐226‐051 10/12/2020 General appeal See above Hallahan & Associates/Lansing Retail LLC 3100 E. Saginaw email 33‐01‐01‐14‐226‐001 10/12/2020 General appeal See above Assessment methodology used parcel size and accepted runoff coefficients, Hallahan & Associates/3301 E MI Partnership 3315 E. Michigan Ave email 33‐01‐01‐13‐151‐038 10/12/2020 General appeal with 50% paid for by all taxpayers in the city Hallahan & Associates/3301 E MI Partnership Friendship Circle email 33‐01‐01‐13‐151‐034 10/12/2020 General appeal See above Hallahan & Associates/3301 E MI Partnership 3301 E. Michigan Ave email 33‐01‐01‐13‐151‐002 10/12/2020 General appeal See above Information on the stormwater credit will be provided to Council for Hallahan & Associates/Frandorson Properties Coolidge Road email 33‐01‐01‐11‐476‐053 10/12/2020 Failure to receive storm water credit consideration Information on the stormwater credit will be provided to Council for Hallahan & Associates/Frandorson Properties 3415 E. Saginaw email 33‐01‐01‐11‐476‐062 10/12/2020 Failure to receive storm water credit consideration Assessment methodology used parcel size and accepted runoff coefficients to calculate the benefit to individual properties within the drainage district. 50% Renee and Peter Hoffman 3307 Melody Lane email 33‐01‐01‐11‐430‐292 10/30/2020 Assessment too high based on benefit of the project cost is paid for by all property owners in the city Assessment methodology used parcel size and accepted runoff coefficients, Selin Family Trust 1049 Shelter Lane email 33‐01‐01‐11‐429‐261 11/3/2020 General appeal with 50% of the project cost paid for by all property owners in the city Assessment methodology used parcel size and accepted runoff coefficients. Raymond and Karenn Vernagus 3322 Stonewood Dr email 33‐01‐01‐11‐429‐261 10/12/2020 Methodology, calculations Council can review calculations provided. Chris Umphlett hearing ?? Nancy Parson‐Mahlow hearing ?? Dan Dekker hearing ?? David Fisher hearing ?? Stan Shuck hearing ?? 1 OFFICIAL PROCEEDINGS OF THE CITY COUNCIL CITY OF LANSING November 9, 2020 PUBLIC COMMENT ON LEGISLATIVE MATTERS Legislative Matters included the following public hearings: Via ZOOM Conferencing, Meeting ID 1. In consideration of the Lease Agreement; Lansing The City Council of the City of Lansing met in regular session and was Shuffleboard and Social Club, LLC 325 Riverfront Drive called to order at 7:01 p.m. by President Spadafore 2. In consideration of a Downtown Lansing Riverfront Project; Lansing Shuffleboard and Social Club, LLC 325 Riverfront PRESENT: Council Members Betz, Dunbar, Garza, Hussain, Jackson, Drive Spadafore, Spitzley, Wood 3. In consideration of the Special Assessment; Montgomery Drainage District Improvements ABSENT: Council Member 4. In consideration of the Commercial Rehabilitation District; 329-337 S. Washington Square for Washington Square at A quorum was present. Kalamazoo, LLC 5. In consideration of the Commercial Rehabilitation Certificate; During the moment of meditation, Council Member Wood asked people 329-337 S. Washington Square for Washington Square at to remember Mark Brown, who recently passed away. Council Member Kalamazoo, LLC Hussain asked people to remember Mike Smith, who recently passed 6. In consideration of an Ordinance to Amend Chapter 602, away. Mayor Schor asked people to remember Kim Coleman, whose Section 602.11, To Prevent Disease, Prolong Life and daughter recently passed away. The Council observed a moment of Promote Public Health by Providing for Enforcement of Local Meditation followed by the Pledge of Allegiance led by President Health Orders or Regulations issues pursuant to the Michigan Spadafore. Public Health Code COMMENTS BY COUNCIL MEMBERS Council Member Hussain gave an overview of the public hearings. AND THE CITY CLERK Public Comment on Legislative Matters: Council Member Hussain spoke about the Southwest Action Group’s spaghetti dinner fundraiser. Chris Umphlett spoke about the Montgomery Drainage District Special Assessment. Council Member Jackson thanked the public for their input. Emily Syria spoke about the resolution to invest in the people of Lansing. Council Member Spadafore thanked Clerk Swope for his administration of the election. Cathleen Edgerly spoke about various city matters. City Clerk Swope spoke about the administration of the election. John spoke about the resolution to invest in the people of Lansing. Julia Kramer spoke about the resolution to invest in the people of COMMUNITY EVENT ANNOUNCEMENTS Lansing. Mike Lynn spoke about a Lansing for Black Lives event. Meghan Martin spoke about various city matters. SPEAKER REGISTRATION FOR Chris Sell spoke in support of the Lansing Shuffleboard and Social Club. PUBLIC COMMENT ON LEGISLATIVE MATTERS Nancy Parson-Mahlow spoke about the Montgomery Drainage District Special Assessment. City Clerk Swope announced that the public needed to electronically “raise their hand” in order to speak during public comment period. Dan Dekker spoke about the Montgomery Drainage District Special Assessment. MAYOR’S COMMENTS Merry Stanford spoke about the resolution to invest in the people of Mayor Schor spoke about neighborhood cleanups, walk-in Lansing. Wednesdays, City Academy graduates, Veterans Day, and COVID-19 policies. David Fisher spoke about the Montgomery Drainage District Special Assessment. Executive Assistant to Mayor Schor, Samantha Harkins, spoke about Erica Lynn spoke about the resolution to invest in the people of Lansing. Sarah Williams spoke about the resolution to invest in the people of REFERRAL OF SHOW CAUSE HEARINGS Lansing. Ethan Schmidt spoke about the resolution to invest in the people of Lansing. _____________, 2020 COUNCIL PROCEEDINGS 2 Loretta Stanaway spoke about various city matters. Motion Carried by the following roll call vote: Michael Lynn spoke about various city matters. Yeas: Council Members Betz, Dunbar, Garza, Hussain, Jackson, Spadafore, Spitzley, Wood Beth Kuiper spoke about various city matters. Nays: None Stan Shuck about the Montgomery Drainage District Special Assessment. Rachel Diskin spoke about the resolution to invest in the people of By Council Member Lansing. Motion Carried by the following roll call vote: Apryl Pooley spoke about the resolution to invest in the people of Lansing. Yeas: Council Members Betz, Dunbar, Garza, Hussain, Jackson, Spadafore, Spitzley, Wood Toren Chenault spoke about the resolution to invest in the people of Lansing. Nays: None Daniel spoke about various city matters. By Council Member Anna Parker spoke about the resolution to invest in the people of Lansing. Motion Carried by the following roll call vote: Angie spoke about various city matters. Yeas: Council Members Betz, Dunbar, Garza, Hussain, Jackson, Spadafore, Spitzley, Wood LEGISLATIVE MATTERS Nays: None REFERRAL OF PUBLIC HEARINGS By Council Member CONSENT AGENDA Motion Carried by the following roll call vote: By Council Member ____ Yeas: Council Members Betz, Dunbar, Garza, Hussain, Jackson, To approve all items on the Consent Agenda. OR To approve items Spadafore, Spitzley, Wood ____ on the Consent Agenda. Nays: None Council Member ____ asked that items 1a, 1b, 1c, 2a, 2b, 2c, 2d, 2e, and 3a be removed from the Consent Agenda. Vice President Hussain asked that items all items be removed from the By Council Member Consent Agenda. Motion Carried by the following roll call vote: There were no items remaining on the Consent Agenda. Yeas: Council Members Betz, Dunbar, Garza, Hussain, Jackson, Spadafore, Spitzley, Wood Nays: None Adopted as part of the Consent Agenda Adopted as part of the Consent Agenda By Council Member Motion Carried by the following roll call vote: Adopted as part of the Consent Agenda Yeas: Council Members Betz, Dunbar, Garza, Hussain, Jackson, Spadafore, Spitzley, Wood Adopted as part of the Consent Agenda Nays: None By Council Member Adopted as part of the Consent Agenda Motion Carried by the following roll call vote: RESOLUTIONS Yeas: Council Members Betz, Dunbar, Garza, Hussain, Jackson, Spadafore, Spitzley, Wood Nays: None By Council Member _____________, 2020 COUNCIL PROCEEDINGS 3 By Council Member By Vice President Hussain that all items be considered as being read in Motion Carried by the following roll call vote: full and that President Spadafore make the appropriate referrals Yeas: Council Members Betz, Dunbar, Garza, Hussain, Jackson, Motion Carried by the following roll call vote: Spadafore, Spitzley, Wood Yeas: Council Members Betz, Dunbar, Garza, Hussain, Jackson, Nays: None Spadafore, Spitzley, Wood Nays: None REPORTS FROM COUNCIL COMMITTEES  Reports from City Officers, Boards and Commissions: ORDINANCES FOR INTRODUCTION 1. Letter(s) from the City Clerk re: INTRODUCTION OF ORDINANCE a. Minutes of Boards, Commissions, and Authorities placed on file in the Clerk’s Office PLACED ON FILE xxxxxxx introduced: b. An ordinance 2. Letter(s) from the Mayor re: a. The Ordinance is referred to the Committee XXXXXXXX RESOLUTION #2020- PLACED ON FILE RESOLUTION SETTING PUBLIC HEARING REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE BY CITY COUNCIL REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON DEVELOPMENT AND PLANNING REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON WAYS AND MEANS AND TO THE INTERNAL AUDITOR REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON GENERAL SERVICES By __ REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON INTERGOVERNMENTAL RELATIONS Motion Carried by the following roll call vote: REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC SERVICES REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC SAFETY Yeas: Council Members Betz, Dunbar, Garza, Hussain, Jackson, REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON PERSONNEL Spadafore, Spitzley, Wood REFERRED TO THE AD HOC COMMITTEE ON HOUSING REFERRED TO THE AD HOC COMMITTEE ON DIVERSITY AND Nays: None INCLUSION ORDINANCES FOR PASSAGE PASSAGE OF ORDINANCE  Communications and Petitions, and Other City Related Matters: An Ordinance of the City of Lansing ____[INSERT TITLE OF 1. Notice from the Michigan Liquor Control Commission regarding: ORDINANCE]_______ a. Was read a second time by its title and adopted by the following roll call 2. Affidavit of Disclosure, vote: MOTION OF EXCUSED ABSENCE Yeas: Council Members Betz, Dunbar, Garza, Hussain, Jackson, Spadafore, Spitzley, Wood By Council Member __ to excuse Council Member __ from tonight’s Nays: Council Members proceedings. PUT TEXT OF ORDINANCE AFTER THE ABOVE LANGUAGE Motion Carried by the following roll call vote: PASSAGE OF ORDINANCE Yeas: Council Members Betz, Dunbar, Garza, Hussain, Jackson, Spadafore, Spitzley, Wood Nays: None SPEAKER REGISTRATION FOR PUBLIC COMMENT ON CITY GOVERNMENT RELATED MATTERS PUBLIC COMMENT ON CITY GOVERNMENT RELATED MATTERS City Clerk Swope announced that the public needed to electronically “raise their hand” in order to speak during public comment period. Bill Heighland spoke about retiree healthcare. REPORTS FROM CITY OFFICERS, BOARDS, AND Marshall Clabeaux spoke about various city matters. COMMISSIONS; COMMUNICATIONS AND PETITIONS; AND OTHER CITY RELATED MATTERS Michael Lynn spoke about various city matters. _____________, 2020 COUNCIL PROCEEDINGS 4 Loretta Stanaway spoke about various city matters. Sam Colegrove spoke about retiree healthcare Mary Hemstreet spoke about retiree healthcare Stan Shuck spoke about retiree healthcare Sara Morrison spoke about retiree healthcare Sherri Wiegman spoke about retiree healthcare Tom Wendt spoke about retiree healthcare Zack Whaley spoke about various city matters. Edward Osmar spoke about retiree healthcare. Amy Riedel spoke various city matters. Sue Dyer spoke about various city matters. Amanda Thomashow spoke about various city matters. Erica Lynn spoke about various city matters. James Radick spoke about various city matters. ADJOURNED TIME 11:28 P.M. CHRIS SWOPE, CITY CLERK DRAFT #2 DATE: 8/12/2020 1 ORDINANCE NO. ____________ 2 AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF LANSING, MICHIGAN, TO AMEND THE 3 LANSING CODIFIED ORDINANCES BY AMENDING CHAPTER 608, SECTION 608.04, 4 TO ALLOW FOR CONSUMPTION OF ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGES ON PUBLIC 5 PROPERTY LOCATED IN SOCIAL DISTRICTS ESTABLISHED IN CONFORMITY WITH 6 STATE LIQUOR CONTROL LAWS AND TO CLARIFY THAT, IF A STATE LICENSE OR 7 PERMIT IS OBTAINED, ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGES MAY BE CONSUMED IN A 8 DESIGNATED PUBLIC AREA. 9 THE CITY OF LANSING ORDAINS: 10 Section 1. That Chapter 608, Section 608.04, of the Code of Ordinances of the City of 11 Lansing, Michigan be and is hereby amended to read as follows: 12 (a) EXCEPT AS AUTHORIZED IN DESIGNATED SOCIAL DISTRICTS PURSUANT TO 13 MCL 436.1551, Nno person shall: 14 (1) Sell, consume or possess in an open container alcoholic beverages in the public 15 streets, public places, parks, alleys, sidewalks, City-owned parking facilities or the Turner-Dodge 16 House, except as provided in this section; or 17 (2) Sell, consume or possess in an open container alcoholic beverages in a private parking 18 lot or facility, including, but not limited to, shopping center parking lots or parking areas 19 adjacent to commercial establishments which are utilized by patrons of the commercial 20 establishment, unless such person has in his or her possession, in writing, the express permission 21 or consent of the owner or lessee, or the lawful agent of the owner or lessee, of such lot or 1 DRAFT #2 DATE: 8/12/2020 1 facility. This paragraph shall not apply to any event sponsored or authorized in writing by the 2 owner or lessee of such premises. 3 (3) AS USED IN THIS CHAPTER, “ALOCHOLIC BEVERAGES” MEANS 4 ALCOHOLIC LIQUOR, BEER, AND WINE, AS DEFINED IN THE MICHIGAN LIQUOR 5 CONTROL CODE OF 1998, ACT 58 OF 1998. 6 (b) Beer or wine ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGES may be sold and/or consumed in City parks, 7 upon approval of the Mayor, if: 8 (1) For sales of beer and wine ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGES, a special license for such 9 sale is obtained from the Michigan Liquor Control Commission and if the Mayor approves the 10 license application prior to the issuance of the license. Approval by the Mayor shall be granted 11 only if the license is to be utilized in conjunction with a City-approved cultural, ethnic or 12 community activity open to the public or if the license is to be utilized in conjunction with a 13 City-approved tourist or convention activity; or 14 (2) For consumption only, where no sales occur, approval is granted for the consumption 15 of beer and wine ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGES at a City-approved cultural, ethnic or community 16 activity open to the public, or in conjunction with a City-approved tourist or convention activity, 17 provided that with respect to either the sale of ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGES beer and wine, or 18 consumption, where no sales occur, the requirements set forth in subsections (g), (h) and (i) 19 hereof are met. 20 (3) Prior mayoral approval shall not be required for the sale and/or consumption of beer 21 and wine ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGES at the Turner-Dodge House, Scott Park, Cooley Gardens, 22 South Washington Office Complex, Fenner Nature Center, AND CITY PARKS EQUIPPED 2 DRAFT #2 DATE: 8/12/2020 1 WITH A PAVILION. however, with regard to the South Washington Office Complex such sale 2 and/or consumption of beer and wine may only occur at non-profit events held on May 8, 2018. 3 (c) Notwithstanding the limitations set forth in subsection (b) hereof, ALCOHOLIC 4 BEVERAGES beer or wine may be sold for consumption at Kircher Field or Ranney Field if a 5 special license for such sale is obtained from the Michigan Liquor Control Commission and if 6 the Mayor approves the license application prior to the issuance of the license. Approval of the 7 Mayor shall be granted for the sale and/or consumption of beer and wine ALCOHOLIC 8 BEVERAGES at Kircher Field or Ranney Field only in conjunction with City-approved district, 9 State, regional or national adult athletic tournaments and if the requirements set forth in 10 subsections (g), (h), and (i) hereof are met. 11 (d) Notwithstanding the limitations set forth in subsection (b) hereof, beer or wine ALCOHOLIC 12 BEVERAGES may be sold for consumption, and may be consumed, within the grounds of the 13 Turner-Dodge House, Scott Park, or Cooley Gardens, OR ANY CITY PARK EQUIPPED WITH 14 A PAVILION, provided that all permits required by the Department of Parks and Recreation 15 have been obtained, a special license, if applicable, has been obtained from the Michigan Liquor 16 Control Commission, and the requirements set forth in subsections (g), (h), and (i) hereof are 17 met. Rental fees for the Turner-Dodge House, the Scott Park, or Cooley Gardens, OR ANY 18 CITY PARK EQUIPPED WITH A PAVILION shall be set by resolution of Council. Use of the 19 Turner-Dodge House, Scott Park, or Cooley Gardens, OR A CITY PARK EQUIPPED WITH A 20 PAVILION in conjunction with the sale of beer or wine ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGES for 21 consumption shall not be limited to public events, but may also include private events. 3 DRAFT #2 DATE: 8/12/2020 1 (e) Sale and consumption of alcoholic beverages is allowable within the concession area or any 2 other area within the perimeter of the Groesbeck Golf Course and Hope Soccer Complex, 3 provided that, if sold, a license for such sale has been obtained from the Michigan Liquor 4 Control Commission, and provided, further, that any such consumption or sale shall be 5 contingent upon approval by the Department of Parks and Recreation and subject to such rules or 6 restrictions as the Department may establish. 7 (f) Sale and consumption of alcoholic beverages may occur within the concession area or any 8 other area within the City Market or its environs, provided that, if sold, a license for such sale 9 has been obtained from the Michigan Liquor Control Commission and the sale and for 10 consumption occurs within a clearly demarcated area in compliance with the license, and 11 provided, further, that any such sales for consumption shall be contingent upon approval by the 12 Lansing Entertainment and Public Facilities Authority (LEPFA) and subject to such rules or 13 restrictions as LEPFA may establish. Notwithstanding section (i) herein, any such applicant shall 14 file with the City Clerk proof of a personal injury and property damage insurance policy insuring 15 such applicant against any liability imposed on such applicant or the City arising out of the sale 16 or consumption of alcoholic beverages, and naming the City and LEPFA as additional insureds. 17 Such policy shall provide for payment in the event of injury to or death of one person or more 18 than one person, and for the payment for property damage in amounts set by Council resolution 19 on the basis of recommendations by the Finance Department. This requirement may be waived 20 or the amounts of such required insurance reduced by resolution of Council finding that such a 21 reduction or waiver is in the public interest. 4 DRAFT #2 DATE: 8/12/2020 1 (g) Beer or wine ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGES may be sold for consumption within the streets, 2 alleys, sidewalks and public places within the boundaries of the Downtown Mall and environs, as 3 defined in Section 812.01 of the Business Regulation and Taxation Code AND IN 4 DESIGNATED SOCIAL DISTRICTS PURSUANT TO MCL 436.1551, provided that the 5 following conditions are satisfied: 6 (1) The request has been approved by the Mayor. 7 (2) The individual, group or organization making the application obtains a special license 8 for such sale and consumption from the Michigan Liquor Control Commission. 9 (3) The individual, group or organization has complied with subsections (g), (h), (i) and 10 (j) hereof. 11 (4) Any other conditions which the Mayor may require have been met. 12 (h) The City Clerk shall provide a form on which the applicant shall provide the following 13 information: 14 (1) The name and address of the applicant; 15 (2) The name of the organization, if applicable; 16 (3) The type of event; 17 (4) The date of the application; 18 (5) The date and time of the event planned; 19 (6) The purpose of the event; 20 (7) The estimated number of persons attending; 21 (8) The name of the insurance company, if applicable, from which the necessary public 22 liability policy will be or has been obtained; 5 DRAFT #2 DATE: 8/12/2020 1 (9) Proof that the proper rental fee has been paid, if applicable; and 2 (10) The security measures which the applicant proposes to utilize. 3 Upon the applicant's payment of an application fee, as determined by resolution of Council, the 4 City Clerk shall forward the completed application form to the Police Department and to the 5 Department of Parks and Recreation for review. 6 (i) Whenever a special license for the sale and/or consumption of ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGES 7 beer or wine in City parks, or within the Downtown Mall and environs or upon the grounds of 8 the Turner-Dodge House, Scott Park, Cooley Gardens, or Fenner Nature Center, OR A CITY 9 PARK EQUIPPED WITH A PAVILION is required, the applicant shall file with the City Clerk 10 proof of a personal injury and property damage insurance policy insuring such applicant against 11 any liability imposed on such applicant or the City arising out of the sale or consumption of 12 ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGES beer or wine. Such policy shall provide for payment in the event of 13 injury to or death of one person or more than one person, and for payment for property damage 14 in amounts set by Council resolution on the basis of recommendations by the Finance 15 Department. Such policy shall have a provision to the effect that the insurance company shall 16 notify the City Clerk at least ten days prior to the expiration of such policy. However, this 17 requirement may be waived or the amounts of such required insurance reduced by resolution of 18 Council finding that such a reduction or waiver is in the public interest. 19 (j) The applicant shall be solely responsible for providing adequate security, in the form of 20 adequate personnel and fencing, as determined by the Department of Parks and Recreation. 21 Approval by the Department of the applicant's plan for security shall be obtained prior to any 22 application being approved or any event being scheduled. 6 DRAFT #2 DATE: 8/12/2020 1 (k) No person shall sell or dispense beer or wine ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGES for consumption 2 in City parks, in any container other than a paper or plastic container. No person shall sell or 3 dispense beer or wine ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGES for consumption within the Turner-Dodge 4 House in any container other than a paper or plastic container unless prior written permission has 5 been received from the Department of Parks and Recreation. 6 (l) (1) Notwithstanding any provision set forth in this Section 608.04 to the contrary, beer or 7 wine ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGES may be sold for consumption on the premises, and may be 8 consumed, at public or private events or functions within the grounds of the Potter Park Zoo 9 Exploration and Discovery Center and Plaza, provided: 10 Dispensing of beer or wine shall be conducted by persons or entities not affiliated with 11 Potter Park Zoo or any of its auxiliary organizations; 12 a. ANY SUCH CONSUMPTION OR SALE SHALL BE CONTINGENT UPON 13 APPROVAL BY THE POTTER PARK ZOO BOARD AND SUBJECT TO SUCH RULES 14 AND RESTRICTIONS AS THE ZOO BOARD MAY ESTABLISH; 15 b. No beer or wine may be sold or dispensed during hours when the Potter Park Zoo is 16 open to the general public; 17 cB. For sales of beer or wine ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGES for consumption on the 18 premises an appropriate license shall be obtained from the Michigan Liquor Control 19 Commission; furthermore, prior mayoral approval is required, which approval shall only be 20 granted in conjunction with a City-approved cultural, ethnic or community activity open to the 21 public, or in conjunction with a City-approved tourist or convention activity; 7 DRAFT #2 DATE: 8/12/2020 1 d. Intoxicating liquors (i.e. distilled rather than fermented alcoholic beverages) may not 2 be sold on the premises. 3 (2) Commencing July 1, 2001, rental fees for the Potter Park Zoo Exploration and 4 Discovery Center and Plaza shall be set by resolution of City Council. 5 Section 2. All ordinances, resolutions or rules, parts of ordinances, resolutions or rules 6 inconsistent with the provisions are repealed. 7 Section 3. Should any section, clause or phrase of this ordinance be declared to be 8 invalid, the same shall not affect the validity of the ordinance as a whole, or any part thereof 9 other than the part so declared to be invalid. 10 Section 4. This ordinance shall take effect on the 30th day after enactment, unless given 11 immediate effect by City Council and, pursuant to Section 3-307 of the City Charter, this 12 Chapter shall expire December 31, 2029. 13 14 Approved as to form: 15 16 __________________________________________ 17 City Attorney 18 19 Dated: ________________________________ 8 INTRODUCTION OF ORDINANCE Council Member Dunbar introduced: An ordinance of the City of Lansing, Michigan, for the purpose of amending the Lansing Codified Ordinances by amending Chapter 608, Section 608.04, to allow for consumption of alcoholic beverages on public property located in social districts established in conformity with state liquor control laws and to clarify that, if a state license or permit is obtained, alcoholic beverages may be consumed in a designated public area. The Ordinance is referred to the Committee on Public Service RESOLUTION SETTING PUBLIC HEARING BY CITY COUNCIL Resolved by the City Council of the City of Lansing that a public hearing be set for January______, 2021 at 7 p.m. in Tony Benavides Lansing City Council Chambers, Tenth Floor, Lansing City Hall, 124 West Michigan Avenue, Lansing, Michigan, for the purpose of amending the Lansing Codified Ordinances by amending Chapter 608, Section 608.04, to allow for consumption of alcoholic beverages on public property located in social districts established in conformity with state liquor control laws and to clarify that, if a state license or permit is obtained, alcoholic beverages may be consumed in a designated public area. BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, due to COVID -19, the public hearing may be held electronically in accordance with the amended Open Meetings Act, as amended n an effort to protect the health and safety of the public. Members of the public wishing to participate in the meeting may do so by logging into or calling into the meetings using the website or phone number and Meeting ID provided on the January , 2021 meeting agenda. Interested Persons are invited to attend this Public Hearing