Public Works Committee
Regular MeetingLouisville, KY · December 3, 2019
Minutes
601 W. Jefferson Street
Louisville Metro Government Louisville, KY 40202
Action Summary - Final
Public Works Committee
Chair Person Brandon Coan (D-8)
Vice Chair Stuart Benson (R-20)
Committee Member Donna L. Purvis (D-5)
Committee Member Bill Hollander (D-9)
Committee Member Mark H. Fox (D-13)
Committee Member Anthony Piagentini (R-19)
Committee Member Nicole George (D-21)
Tuesday, December 3, 2019 4:00 PM Council Chambers
Call to Order
Chair Person Coan called the meeting to order at 4:13 p.m.
Roll Call
Chair Person Coan introduced the committee members and non-committee
members present. A quorum was established.
Committee Member Piagentini left at 4:48 p.m.
Present: 6 - Chair Person Brandon Coan (D-8), Vice Chair Stuart Benson (R-20), Committee
Member Donna L. Purvis (D-5), Committee Member Mark H. Fox (D-13),
Committee Member Anthony Piagentini (R-19), and Committee Member Nicole
George (D-21)
Excused: 1 - Committee Member Bill Hollander (D-9)
Non-Committee Member(s)
Council Member Barbara Sexton Smith (D-4) and Council Member Brent
Ackerson (D-26)
Support Staff
Dee Baltimore, Jefferson County Attorney's Office
Clerk(s)
David B. Wagner, Assistant Clerk
Connie Dearing, Assistant Clerk
Louisville Metro Government Page 1
Public Works Committee Action Summary - Final December 3, 2019
Special Discussion
Louisville Metro Government Page 2
Public Works Committee Action Summary - Final December 3, 2019
1. ID 19-2013
Dockless Vehicles - Jeff O'Brien, Develop Louisville
Attachments: 120319 Scooters_PWC updated.pdf
Jeff O'Brien, Develop Louisville, gave a presentation on dockless vehicles.
Chair Person Coan asked where the revenues go. Jeff O'Brien answered they
are accounted for in the Public Works permit and license fees budget line
item.
Committee Member Purvis asked about enforcement of areas of operation,
age requirements, speed limits, if they can cross the bridges, and the time
limit for riding a scooter. Jeff O'Brien replied scooters may go anywhere a bike
is permitted, speed limits are enforced per the geofencing software in the
scooter upon entrance into those areas, the age requirement is 18 years of
age, enforcement is applied through notification to the police and the
operating company, and ridership time is unlimited.
Committee Member Piagentini commented on the service and inquired if
cyclists pay a license fee. Jeff O'Brien responded they do not. Committee
Member Piagentini stated he was in favor of user fees or comsumption
taxation. He also asked what are the public safety issues. Jeff O'Brien stated
the biggest issues are night time ridership and using scooters while under the
influence.
Committee Member George asked about service providers sharing
demographic data, number of accidents in the last year, and citations issued.
Jeff O'Brien replied Louisville Metro is not currently collecting data in order to
focus on the monitoring safety, there is an equity component that has been
implemented, the scooters are distributed geographically, data on accidents is
not available as there has only been one major crash, and he was unaware of
any citations being issued.
Chair Person Coan inquired if the bike sharing program has been impacted
and about reduced rates and Jeff O'Brien answered generally all mobility is up
and some of the providers offer reduced rates and options for those who do
not have a credit card.
Committee Member Fox asked about fees for revenue to pay for infrastructure
and Jeff O'Brien replied that they issue permits, and can raise fees, but there
are no contracts. Committee Member Fox asked for the agreements to be sent
to him.
Council Member Sexton Smith asked about hours of operation being tied to
stated sunset times on weather apps and using geofencing to stop sidewalk
usage. Jeff O'Brien is unsure if weather apps have been utilized and he
doesn't believe the GPS technology is precise enough to use geofencing to
prevent sidewalk ridership at this time.
Chair Person Coan requested an update in aproximately six months to which
Jeff O'Brien agreed.
Louisville Metro Government Page 3
Public Works Committee Action Summary - Final December 3, 2019
Pending Legislation
2. R-161-19
A RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE MAYOR TO ACCEPT $290,000 OF ADDITIONAL
FUNDING FROM THE COMMONWEALTH OF KENTUCKY TRANSPORTATION
CABINET FOR THE A.B. SAWYER PARK SHARED-USE PATH CONNECTOR TO BE
ADMINISTERED BY PUBLIC WORKS & ASSETS.
Sponsors:Primary Marilyn Parker (R-18)
Attachments: R-161-19 111819 Mayor Accept Funds for AB Sawyer Park Shared
Path.pdf
RES $290,000 KYTC LL AB Sawyer Park Supp No 1 PWA
NOV2019.pdf
A motion was made by Committee Member Piagentini, seconded by
Committee Member Fox, that this Resolution be recommended for approval.
Milana Boz, Public Works and Assets, gave background information on the
item.
Chair Person Coan asked follow up questions to the total project costs and
Committee Member Piagentini asked if this was part of the main Louisville
Loop. Milana Boz answered the questions.
Chair Person Coan stated his support for the project.
The motion carried by a voice vote and the Resolution was sent to the Consent
Calendar.
3. O-300-19
AN ORDINANCE AMENDING PORTIONS OF LOUISVILLE METRO CODE OF
ORDINANCES (“LMCO”) CHAPTER 164 REGARDING THE SYSTEM DEVELOPMENT
CHARGE TO INCREASE CONTRIBUTIONS AND ELIMINATE THE SUNSET
PROVISION. (AMENDMENT BY SUBSTITUTION.)
Sponsors:Primary Anthony Piagentini (R-19)
Attachments: O-300-19 V.2 CABS 082219 Amending LMCO Chp 164 System
Development Charge.pdf
O-300-19 V.1 082219 Amending LMCO Chp 164 System Development
Charge.pdf
A motion was made by Committee Member Fox, seconded by Committee
Member Piagentini, that this amended Ordinance be untabled. The motion
carried without objection.
Committee Member Piagentini stated he was withdrawing his sponsorship of
the Ordinance but that it would be reintroduced once the study was completed
and all necessary information was available.
The Ordinance died in committee due to the lack of a sponsor.
Louisville Metro Government Page 4
Public Works Committee Action Summary - Final December 3, 2019
Adjournment
Without objection, Chair Person Coan adjourned the meeting at 5:00 p.m.
*NOTE: Items sent to the Consent Calendar or Old Business will be heard
before the full Council at the Metro Council Meeting on December 12, 2019.
Louisville Metro Government Page 5
Agenda
601 W. Jefferson Street
Louisville Metro Government Louisville, KY 40202
Meeting Agenda - Final
Public Works Committee
Chair Person Brandon Coan (D-8)
Vice Chair Stuart Benson (R-20)
Committee Member Donna L. Purvis (D-5)
Committee Member Bill Hollander (D-9)
Committee Member Mark H. Fox (D-13)
Committee Member Anthony Piagentini (R-19)
Committee Member Nicole George (D-21)
Tuesday, December 3, 2019 4:00 PM Council Chambers
Call to Order
Roll Call
Special Discussion
1. ID 19-2013 Dockless Vehicles - Jeff O'Brien, Develop Louisville
Attachments: 120319 Scooters_PWC updated.pdf
Pending Legislation
2. R-161-19 A RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE MAYOR TO ACCEPT $290,000 OF
ADDITIONAL FUNDING FROM THE COMMONWEALTH OF KENTUCKY
TRANSPORTATION CABINET FOR THE A.B. SAWYER PARK
SHARED-USE PATH CONNECTOR TO BE ADMINISTERED BY PUBLIC
WORKS & ASSETS.
Sponsors: Primary Marilyn Parker (R-18)
Attachments: R-161-19 111819 Mayor Accept Funds for AB Sawyer Park Shared Path.pdf
RES $290,000 KYTC LL AB Sawyer Park Supp No 1 PWA NOV2019.pdf
Legislative History
11/21/19 Metro Council assigned to the Public Works Committee
Action Required By: May 2020
Louisville Metro Government Page 1 Printed on 12/3/2019
Public Works Committee Meeting Agenda - Final December 3, 2019
3. O-300-19 AN ORDINANCE AMENDING PORTIONS OF LOUISVILLE METRO
CODE OF ORDINANCES (“LMCO”) CHAPTER 164 REGARDING THE
SYSTEM DEVELOPMENT CHARGE TO INCREASE CONTRIBUTIONS
AND ELIMINATE THE SUNSET PROVISION. (AMENDMENT BY
SUBSTITUTION.)
Sponsors: Primary Anthony Piagentini (R-19)
Attachments: O-300-19 V.2 CABS 082219 Amending LMCO Chp 164 System Development Charge.pdf
O-300-19 V.1 082219 Amending LMCO Chp 164 System Development Charge.pdf
Legislative History
8/22/19 Metro Council assigned to the Public Works Committee
Action Required By: February 2020
8/27/19 Public Works Committee recommended for approval
8/27/19 Public Works Committee tabled
9/17/19 Public Works Committee untabled
9/17/19 Public Works Committee tabled
10/15/19 Public Works Committee tabled
10/29/19 Public Works Committee tabled
11/12/19 Public Works Committee tabled
Adjournment
Note: Agendas are followed at the discretion of the Chair Person. While an item may be listed, it
does not mean all items will be heard and/or acted upon by the Committee.
Louisville Metro Government Page 2 Printed on 12/3/2019