Urban Design Commission

By The City of Oklahoma City Office of the City Clerk at 4:38 pm, Sep 18, 2024 The City of OKLAHOMA CITY Urban Design Commission Agenda 3:00 PM September 25, 2024 Council Chambers, City Hall, 200 North Walker Ave., Third Floor Tyler Holmes, Chair Sarah Miller, Vice­Chair Aimee Ahpeatone Anthony Blatt Nathan Cao Jorge Charneco Ashley Dickson Oso Lee Peoples James Varnum Kathryn Friddle, Principal Planner Laura Griggs, Senior Planner Michael Philbrick, Senior Planner Daryl Callaway, Associate Planner Susan Randall, Assistant Municipal Counselor Keith Daniels, Administrative Assistant PARTICIPANT INSTRUCTIONS Free parking is available at the Sheridan­Walker Parking Garage (501 West Sheridan Ave, northwest corner of Sheridan and Walker, immediately north of John Rex School). Parking tickets must be validated by City staff before or after the meeting. Only the south entrance to City Hall will be open. It is the policy of the City to ensure that communications with participants and members of the public with disabilities are as effective as communications with others. Anyone with a disability who requires an accommodation, a modification of policies or procedures, or an auxiliary aid or service, or alternate format of the agenda in order to participate in this meeting should contact the ADA  Keith Daniels, Administrative Assistant PARTICIPANT INSTRUCTIONS Free parking is available at the Sheridan­Walker Parking Garage (501 West Sheridan Ave, northwest corner of Sheridan and Walker, immediately north of John Rex School). Parking tickets must be validated by City staff before or after the meeting. Only the south entrance to City Hall will be open. It is the policy of the City to ensure that communications with participants and members of the public with disabilities are as effective as communications with others. Anyone with a disability who requires an accommodation, a modification of policies or procedures, or an auxiliary aid or service, or alternate format of the agenda in order to participate in this meeting should contact the ADA Coordinator of the Planning Department at 405­297­2406 as soon as possible but not later than 48 hours (not including weekends or holidays) before the scheduled meeting. The Planning Department will give primary consideration to the choice of auxiliary aid or service requested by the individual with disability. If you need an alternate format of the agenda or any information provided at said meeting, please contact the ADA department coordinator listed above 48 hours prior to the scheduled meeting. ADDRESSING THE COMMISSION Citizens may address the Commission on agenda items by responding to Chair’s call for speakers during discussion on each item. All comments must be relevant to the item. The Chair or presiding officer may in his or her discretion prohibit a person from addressing the Commission and/or remove that person from the Council Chambers, if that person commits any disorderly or disruptive behavior. Disorderly conduct includes, but is not limited to, any of the following: speaking without being recognized by the Chair or presiding officer; continuing to speak after notice that the speaker’s allotted time has expired; presenting comments or material not relevant to the item under discussion; failing to comply with the lawful instructions of the Chair or presiding officer; engaging in other conduct, activity or speech that delays, pursuant to 21 O.S. §280, disruptive conduct includes any conduct that is “violent, threatening, abusive, obscene, or that jeopardizes the safety of self or others”. A person may also be subject to arrest and removal from the Municipal Building for violation of Oklahoma City Municipal Code 2020, §30­81­ Disorderly conduct and/or violation of Okla. Stat. tit. 21, §280 – Willfully Disturbing, Interfering With or Disrupting State Business, Agency Operations or Employees. Please limit your comments to three minutes. COMMISSION ACTIONS Official Action can only be taken on items which appear on the Agenda. The Urban Design Commission may adopt, approve, deny, defer, recommend, amend, strike or continue any Agenda item. When more information is needed to act on an item, the Urban Design Commission may refer the matter to Planning Department staff. All items are either approved, denied, continued to a specific later date, or stricken from the Agenda entirely. Urban Design Commission Agenda September 25, 2024 I. Call to Order II. Approval of Minutes A. July 24, 2024, Meeting. the matter to Planning Department staff. All items are either approved, denied, continued to a specific later date, or stricken from the Agenda entirely. Urban Design Commission Agenda September 25, 2024 I. Call to Order II. Approval of Minutes A. July 24, 2024, Meeting. III. Cases Withdrawn A. None. IV. Continuance Requests A. None V. Consent Docket (Anyone may request individual consideration of a consent item.) A. SRCA­24­00017(P2) at 1125 Exchange Avenue (Scenic River/Stockyards District) Application by Shauna Leonard, Native Wrecking Services to: 3) Paint mural on north facade. VI. Cases for Individual Consideration Scenic River: A. SRCA­24­00016 at 735 SE 15th Street (Scenic River/Regatta District) Application by Mike Patterson, AMMP Studio for Sally Goin, FaithWorks, to: 1. Main Building: a) Construct one­story 5,500 sq. ft. pre­engineered metal building clad in brick veneer with fiber cement panel and architectural metal panel accents (variance required from Table 13500.6 front­yard setback regulations requiring a minimum of 80 percent of the front façade of the building to be located at the back of the right­of­way); 2. Parking Lot: a) Revise parking lot and construct additional parking areas; 3. Sidewalks: a) Revise sidewalks as needed; 4. Signage: a) Install attached wall sign and cross, FaithWorks, 80 sq. ft.; 5. Lighting: a) Install parking lot lighting; b) Install building mounted lighting; 6. Landscaping/Site Improvements: a) Install landscaping; b) Construct curb cut on SE 14th St; and 7. Screening/Fencing: a) Install 8’ tall wood fencing; and provide a recommendation to the Board of Adjustment for a variance from Table 13500.6 front­yard setback regulations requiring a minimum of 80 percent of the front façade of the building to be located at the back of the right­of­way. Urban Design: B. UDCA­24­00024 at 908 N Shartel Avenue (Cottage District) Application by Fallon Brooks­Magnus, Jollybird Design, for Kumars Keramati, 908 N Shartel, LLC, to: 1) Construct two, three­story, single­family residential dwelling units with attached garages clad in brick and cementitious planked siding with black metal accent roof, hanger rod awnings, and cable railings.; 2) Construct on­site and off­ site sidewalks; 3) Install landscaping.; and 4a) Construct privacy fencing along the  B. UDCA­24­00024 at 908 N Shartel Avenue (Cottage District) Application by Fallon Brooks­Magnus, Jollybird Design, for Kumars Keramati, 908 N Shartel, LLC, to: 1) Construct two, three­story, single­family residential dwelling units with attached garages clad in brick and cementitious planked siding with black metal accent roof, hanger rod awnings, and cable railings.; 2) Construct on­site and off­ site sidewalks; 3) Install landscaping.; and 4a) Construct privacy fencing along the north, east, and south property lines with added fencing between the two units at the west elevations; and 4b) Construct various low planter walls, retaining walls, and concrete patio walls. C. UDCA­24­00036 (P2) at 1732 NW 16th Street (Plaza District) Application by Rob Elliott, Elliott Architects, for Jonathan Dodson, 1732 NW 16, LLC, to: 6) Install bond brick screen at the north elevation blocking out two existing windows); 7) Install two attached wall signs at the north elevation; and 8) Install dark bronze aluminum awning at the north elevation. VII. Other Business A. SPUD­1662 at 2416 NW 24th Street (NC Tract 4F/Uptown NW 23rd St) Provide a recommendation to the Planning Commission for a request to rezone from NC Tract 4F (with an R­2 base designation) to Simplified Planned Unit Development (SPUD­1662) that will develop in accordance with the C­1 Neighborhood Commercial District. VIII. Communications A. Administrative Approval Report Scenic River: 1. SRCA­23­00003(R1) at 900 Hangar Drive (Western Gateway) Application by Sara Hannah, Gardner Studio for Blair Humphreys, Wheeler District, LLC to: 1) Replace aluminum windows with vinyl windows; 2) Replace hollow metal doors with fiberglass doors; 3) Remove balconies/ patios and replace with windows; 4) Replace brick veneer with cementitious lap siding; 5) Reduce size of awnings; 6) Change solid railing balconies to picket railing; 7) Replace two overhead doors with storefront windows; 8) Replace a door with a window; 9) Eliminate patio railing; 10) Revise location of handicap parking spaces; 11) Revise location of dumpster enclosure and change to cedar slats; and 12) Revise landscaping to the east of the parking lot. 2. SRCA­23­00004(R1) at 901 Hangar Drive (Western Gateway) Application by Sara Hannah, Gardner Studio for Blair Humphreys, Wheeler District, LLC to: 1) Replace aluminum windows with vinyl windows; 2) Replace hollow metal patio doors with fiberglass patio doors; 3) Remove three windows on the west facade; and 4) Remove six balconies/patios on the west facade and replace with windows. 3. SRCA­24­00014 at 1730 W Reno Avenue (Farmers Market) Application by Brittany Lander, Metro Sign for Pat Snyder, W&W Steel, LLC to: 1) Install attached wall sign, aluminum panel with flush mounted LED lit channel letters; and 2) Install attached wall sign, aluminum panel with flush mounted LED lit channel letters.  3. SRCA­24­00014 at 1730 W Reno Avenue (Farmers Market) Application by Brittany Lander, Metro Sign for Pat Snyder, W&W Steel, LLC to: 1) Install attached wall sign, aluminum panel with flush mounted LED lit channel letters; and 2) Install attached wall sign, aluminum panel with flush mounted LED lit channel letters. 4. SRCA­24­00015 at 801 SE 5th Street (Regatta) Application by Stephen Ball, Riversport Foundation to: 1) Construct 5' tall wood fence. 5. SRCA­24­00017(P1) at 1125 Exchange Avenue (Stockyards) Application by Shauna Leonard, Native Wrecking Services to: 1) Install attached metal wall sign on north facade; or 2) Paint logo sign on north facade. 6. SRCA­24­00018 at 1228 SW 2nd Street (Farmer’s Market) Application by Robert Cosby, Ten Arrows Roofing & Construction for Clay Berks, Powerhouse to: 1) Replace sign on north facade, and on the west façade. NOTE: Per 59­16115.A.2., these nonconforming signs can be replaced as long as not larger than original signs approved in SRCA­14­00006 and SRCA­14­00014. 7. SRCA­24­00019 at 311 S Klein Avenue (Farmers Market) Application by Robert Cosby, Ten Arrows Roofing & Construction for Cristobal Sierra, Pinata Store to: 1) Replace sign, Pinata Store. Stockyards City: 8. SYCA­23­00004(R1) at 1934 Exchange (SYT) Application by Patrick Schoenfeldt, Studio Architecture, P. C. for Lowe Runkel, Oklahoma City Public Works Department to: 1) Revise the site plan to reduce pavement area in front of the building by eliminating the westerly overhead door at the north elevation; and 2) Revise the site plan by widening the curb cut off the alley. 9. SYCA­24­00001(R1) at 1101 S Youngs Boulevard (SYT) Application by Zach Punnett, Punnett Construction for Patrick Raglow, Catholic Charities OKC to: 1) Revise the elevations on all six structures to include structural support bracing at all four corners of each building. 10. SYCA­24­00003 at 1007 S Agnew Avenue (SYT) Application by Lavonna Koger, Shorty’s Caboy Hattery to: 1) Remove existing attached wall sign at the east elevation; and 2) Install two attached wall signs at the east elevation. 11. SYCA­24­00005 at 1007 S Agnew Avenue (SYD) Application by Theresa Bynum, The Cuttin Co. for Theresa Moyers, Oklahoma National Stockyards to: 1) Replace existing storefront windows and entry door at the east elevation in bronze finish frames. 12. SYCA­24­00006 at 1400 S Agnew Avenue (SYT) Application by Ryan Richardson, Boxcar Limited for Jo Slama, Wiens Properties, LLC to: 1) Install temporary attached wall signs at the west and north elevations (90 day maximum). 12. SYCA­24­00006 at 1400 S Agnew Avenue (SYT) Application by Ryan Richardson, Boxcar Limited for Jo Slama, Wiens Properties, LLC to: 1) Install temporary attached wall signs at the west and north elevations (90 day maximum). 13. SYCA­24­00007 at 2300 Exchange Avenue (SYT) Application by James Rhymer, Exchange Pharmacy for Jerry Reynolds, Oklahoma National Stockyards to: 1) Replace window and door glazing with new bronze metal storefront frames. 14. SYCA­24­00008 at 1305 S Agnew Avenue and 2300 Exchange Avenue (SYD) Application by Theresa Bynum, The Cuttin Co. and James Rhymer, Exchange Pharmacy for Jerry Reynolds, Oklahoma National Stockyards to: 1) Change the color of the existing awnings from brown to black. Urban Design: 15. UDCA­24­00011(R1) at 323 NW 23rd Street (Uptown NW 23rd St) Application by Rose Taylor, WGT Concepts, Inc. for Yong Hong, East Valley Enterprises to: 1) Modify the storefront glass at the left side to add blackout film (to block views of the interior void created by fire blocking required by Fire Code to limit occupancy). 16. UDCA­24­00023 at 2717 N Classen Boulevard (Asian District) Application by J. T. Harrison, Shellback General Contracting for Jen When, Theo Properties, LLC to: 1) Install five new windows in new openings at the north elevation; 2) Install one new sliding door in an enlarged existing opening at the north elevation; and 3) Install two new aluminum storefront door/window systems in two new openings at the north elevation. 17. UDCA­24­00028 at 601 NW 7th Street (Cottage District) Application by Kevin Galliant, Trinity Group Architects for Ed Lynn to: 1) Reconstruct roof top trellis; 2) Install new wood louvers on the west wall of the new trellis structure; and 3) Remove tile from elevator penthouse. 18. UDCA­24­00029 at 2524 N Military Avenue (Asian District) Application by Donny Ho, Blue Diamond Signs for Ba Luong, Oriental Group Investment to: 1) Install one attached wall sign at the east elevation. 19. UDCA­24­00030 at 320 SW 25th Street (Capitol Hill) Application by Ricardo Alcantara, 405 Signs for John Autin, T. G. Goth, Inc. to: 1) Install one attached wall sign at the north elevation. 20. UDCA­24­00032 at 2124 NW 23rd Street (Uptown NW 23rd St) Application by Jace Larson, General Lighting and Sign Services for Truong Le, Le Development, LLC to: 1) Install one attached wall sign at the north elevation; and 2) Install one attached wall sign at the west elevation. 21. UDCA­24­00033 at 1624 N Blackwelder Avenue (Plaza District) Application by Kris Kanaly, Oklahoma Mural Syndicate for Jeff Struble, 1630, LLC to: 1) Install a mural at the west elevation.  elevation; and 2) Install one attached wall sign at the west elevation. 21. UDCA­24­00033 at 1624 N Blackwelder Avenue (Plaza District) Application by Kris Kanaly, Oklahoma Mural Syndicate for Jeff Struble, 1630, LLC to: 1) Install a mural at the west elevation. 22. UDCA­24­00035 at 2420 S Robinson Avenue (Capitol Hill) Application by Chad Hodges, Capitol Co­op for Gene Rowland, Gene A Rowland Living Trust to: 1) Install painted sign at the east elevation; 2) Install two projecting wall signs (one at the northwest corner of the building and one at the southwest corner of the building); 3) Install various multiple window signs at the west elevation; 4) Relocate existing lighting fixtures at the west elevation; and 5) Install new metal awning with hangar rods at the west elevation. 23. UDCA­24­00036 (P1) at 1732 NW 16th Street (Plaza District) Application by Rob Elliott, Elliott Architects for Jonathan Dodson, 1732 NW16, LLC to: 1) Construct new trash enclosure (with wood fencing to match the existing adjacent wood fence) at the rear of the site; 2) Construct additional wood fencing (to match existing adjacent wood fencing) with a man gate to screen the proposed dry storage and cooler structures; 3) Install dry storage structure; 4) Install cooler structure; and 5) Replace entry door at the north elevation. 24. UDCA­24­00037 at 1630 and 1634 N Blackwelder Avenue (Plaza District) Application by Patrick Struble, Slate Construction for Jeff Struble, 1630, LLC to: 1) Install four sun shade screens at the second story of the west elevation at 1630 N Blackwelder Ave; 2) Extend the existing metal canopy at the north elevation of 1630 N Blackwelder to the east by an additional 6 1/2 feet; 3) Construct new metal roof over the existing patio between 1630 and 1634 N Blackwelder Ave; 4) Add 1” x 4” wood siding to the existing railings enclosing the existing patios; 5) Install 8 foot tall, galvanized metal posts to support proposed string lighting; and 6) Paint all existing metal awning and railings. 25. UDCA­24­00039 at 1804 NW 16th Street (Plaza District) Application by Robert Morris, J&B Graphics for Jeff Struble, Struble Properties, LLC to: 1) Install one attached projecting wall sign at the north elevation; and 2) Install sign on the entry door for Suite B at the north elevation. B. Comments from Planning Department Staff C. Comments from Commission Members D. Next Meeting Date 1. The next regular Commission meeting is Wednesday, October 23, 2024. New applications are to be submitted to staff by 4:00 p.m., Tuesday, September 24, 2024. Revisions and information on continued projects are to be submitted by Tuesday, October 1, 2024. IX. Adjourn