Standing Committees
Regular MeetingPittsburgh, PA · November 15, 2017
Minutes
510 City-County Building
414 Grant Street
City of Pittsburgh Pittsburgh, PA 15219
Meeting Minutes - Final
Wednesday, November 15, 2017 10:00 AM Council Chambers
STANDING COMMITTEES AGENDA
PUBLIC COMMENT
PRE-AGENDA - APPOINTMENTS AND/OR RE-APPOINTMENTS
2017-1880 Resolution appointing Khalif Ali as a Commissioner of the Ethics Hearing Board of
the City of Pittsburgh for a term to expire June 30, 2020.
Interview Held.
2017-1882 Resolution appointing Fred W. Brown as a Commissioner of the Ethics Hearing
Board of the City of Pittsburgh for a term to expire on June 30, 2018.
Interview Held.
2017-1884 Resolution appointing Orlando G. Portela Valentin as a Commissioner of the Ethics
Hearing Board of the City of Pittsburgh for a term to expire June 30, 2019.
Interview Held.
2017-2082 Resolution informing City Council of the appointment of Jennie Sweet-Cushman as a
member of the Pittsburgh Equal Opportunity Review Commission with a term to
expire September 30, 2021.
Interview Held.
ROLL CALL
Present 6 - Mrs. Harris, Mr. Kraus, Mr. Lavelle, Mr. O'Connor, Ms. Rudiak, and Mrs.
Kail-Smith
Absent 3 - Rev. Burgess, Mr. Gilman, and Ms. Gross
City of Pittsburgh Page 1 Printed on 12/11/2017
Standing Committee Meeting Minutes - Final November 15, 2017
FINANCE AND LAW COMMITTEE, MS. RUDIAK, CHAIR
DEFERRED PAPERS
2017-2033 Resolution further amending Resolution No. 816 of 2015, effective December 18,
2015, as amended, entitled “Resolution adopting and approving the 2016 Capital
Budget and the 2016 Community Development Block Grant Program; and
approving the 2016 through 2021 Capital Improvement Program,” by reducing
FACILITY IMPROVEMENTS by $200,000.00 and increasing HILL HOUSE by
$200,000.00.
(Briefing Held 11-8-17)
A motion was made that this matter be Affirmatively Recommended. The
motion carried by the following vote:
Aye: 3 - Mr. Kraus, Mr. Lavelle, and Mr. O'Connor
No: 0
Abstain: 3 - Mrs. Harris, Ms. Rudiak, and Mrs. Kail-Smith
Absent: 3 - Rev. Burgess, Mr. Gilman, and Ms. Gross
2017-2034 Resolution authorizing the Mayor and the Director of the Office of Management &
Budget to enter into a Contract or Contracts, or use of existing Contracts, providing
for an Agreement or Agreements, or use of existing Agreements with the Hill House
Association in connection with the rehabilitation of the Blakey Program Center for a
sum not to exceed Two Hundred Thousand Dollars and Zero Cents ($200,000.00)
for the payment of the costs thereof.
(Briefing Held 11-8-17)
A motion was made that this matter be Affirmatively Recommended. The
motion carried by the following vote:
Aye: 3 - Mr. Kraus, Mr. Lavelle, and Mr. O'Connor
No: 0
Abstain: 3 - Mrs. Harris, Ms. Rudiak, and Mrs. Kail-Smith
Absent: 3 - Rev. Burgess, Mr. Gilman, and Ms. Gross
City of Pittsburgh Page 2 Printed on 12/11/2017
Standing Committee Meeting Minutes - Final November 15, 2017
2017-2037 Resolution authorizing the issuance of a warrant in favor of Cliff Jobe Consulting LLC,
204 Kennan Drive, Greensburg, PA 15601, in an amount not to exceed Twelve
Thousand Eight Hundred Twenty-Seven Dollars and 00/100 Cents ($12,827.00) for
consultation services in connection with trial appearance and related expenses for
USDC #2:16-cv-01364.
(Executive Session Held 11-8-17)
A motion was made that this matter be Affirmatively Recommended. The
motion carried.
Ms. Harris Absatained
2017-2055 Resolution authorizing the issuance of a warrant in favor of Pittsburgh Collision &
Reconstruction Services, LLC, 10 Grandview Avenue, Pittsburgh, PA 15214, in an
amount not to exceed Three Thousand One Hundred Twenty-Nine Dollars and
68/100 Cents ($3,129.68) for consultation services in connection with trial
appearance and related expenses for USDC #2:16-cv-01364.
(Executive Session Held 11-8-17)
A motion was made that this matter be Affirmatively Recommended. The
motion carried.
Ms. Harris Absatained
2017-2056 Resolution authorizing the issuance of a warrant in favor of Marshall Dennehey
Warner Coleman & Goggin, Union Trust Building, 501 Grant St., Suite 700,
Pittsburgh, PA in an amount not to exceed Eight Thousand Five Hundred Dollars and
No Cents ($8,500.00) for a trial transcript in a litigation case.
(Executive Session Held 11-8-17)
A motion was made that this matter be Affirmatively Recommended. The
motion carried.
Ms. Harris Absatained
NEW PAPERS
City of Pittsburgh Page 3 Printed on 12/11/2017
Standing Committee Meeting Minutes - Final November 15, 2017
2017-2073 Ordinance amending the Pittsburgh City Code, Article VII, Personnel, Chapters
701 and 702; Title One, Administrative, Article III, Chapters 111, 116, 140 and
145; Title One, Administrative, Article V, Chapter 152; Title One, Administrative,
Article VII, Chapters 161 and 170; Title One, Administrative, Article IX, Chapters
174A, 176A, 177A, 177C, 178C, and 179; and Title One, Administrative, Article
XI, Chapters 180, 182, 186, 190, 197, and 199, to establish the Department of
Human Resources and Civil Service to encompass current Department of Personnel
and Civil Service Commission employees, responsibilities, and functions in order to
adjust the name of the Department to better reflect its current functions and to clarify
the roles, responsibilities, and functions of its Director.
A motion was made that this matter be Affirmatively Recommended. The
motion carried.
Councilwoman Harris & Kail-Smith Abstained
2017-2074 Resolution providing for the conveyance by the City of Pittsburgh of certain property,
having been placed for sale to adjoining property owners in conjunction with the City
of Pittsburgh Side Yard Program. ITEMS A through F: A: 406 N Graham, B: 7043
Hermitage, C: 1332 Beechview, D: 3130 McClure, E: 1524 Superior, F: 1526
Superior
A motion was made that this matter be AMENDED. The motion carried.
A motion was made that this matter be Affirmatively Recommended as
Amended. The motion carried.
2017-2075 Resolution authorizing the issuance of a warrant in favor of Campbell Durrant Beatty
Palombo & Miller, P.C., 535 Smithfield St., Suite 700, Pittsburgh, PA 15222 for
professional legal services and expert advice regarding labor matters in an amount not
to exceed Three Thousand Nine Hundred Forty Dollars and Twelve Cents
($3,940.12).
(Executive Session Held 11-16-17)
A motion was made that this matter be Held for Executive Session. The
motion carried.
City of Pittsburgh Page 4 Printed on 12/11/2017
Standing Committee Meeting Minutes - Final November 15, 2017
2017-2076 Resolution authorizing the issuance of a warrant in favor of Curtin & Heefner, LLP,
2005 S. Easton Road, Suite 100, Doylestown, PA l8901 for professional legal
services and expert advice regarding Building Owners and Managers in an amount not
to exceed Five Thousand Four Hundred Four Dollars and Seventy-Two Cents
($5,404.72).
(Executive Session Held 11-16-17)
A motion was made that this matter be Held for Executive Session. The
motion carried.
City of Pittsburgh Page 5 Printed on 12/11/2017
Standing Committee Meeting Minutes - Final November 15, 2017
2017-2077 Resolution authorizing the issuance of a warrant in favor of Pepper Hamilton LLP,
Suite 5000, 500 Grant St., Pittsburgh, PA l5219 for professional consulting and legal
services in relation to False Claims Act litigation in an amount not to exceed Sixty
Nine Thousand Nine Hundred Twenty Four Dollars and Forty Three Cents
($69,924.43).
(Executive Session Held 11-16-17)
A motion was made that this matter be Held for Executive Session. The
motion carried.
2017-2078 Resolution authorizing the issuance of a warrant in favor of Michael E. Zobrak, Labor
Arbitrator, 1217 Pleasant Street, Aliquippa, PA 15001-9425 for arbitration fees for a
two day hearing related to Grievance 15-024 in an amount not to exceed Three
Thousand Fifty Two Dollars and Forty-Five Cents ($3,052.45).
(Executive Session Held 11-16-17)
A motion was made that this matter be Held for Executive Session. The
motion carried.
2017-2079 Resolution authorizing the issuance of a warrant in favor of Heckman Enterprises, 116
Claremont Drive, Lower Burrell, PA 15068, in an amount not to exceed Four
Thousand Five Hundred Dollars and 00/100 Cents ($4,500.00) for consultation
services in connection with trial appearance and related expenses File No. 12-0289.
(Executive Session Held 11-16-17)
A motion was made that this matter be Held for Executive Session. The
motion carried.
2017-2080 Resolution authorizing the issuance of a warrant in favor of Micklow Consulting, 4017
Washington Road, PMB 1300, McMurry, PA 15317, in the amount not to exceed
Twenty-Two Thousand one Hundred Thirty-Four Dollars and 25/100 Cents
($22,1324.25) for consultation services in connection with trial appearance and
related expenses File No. 12-0289.
(Executive Session Held 11-16-17)
A motion was made that this matter be Held for Executive Session. The
motion carried.
City of Pittsburgh Page 6 Printed on 12/11/2017
Standing Committee Meeting Minutes - Final November 15, 2017
2017-2081 Resolution amending the Rules of Council by adding purview over the Department of
Mobility and Infrastructure to the responsibilities of the Council Standing Committee
on Public Works
SPONSOR /S: MR. KRAUS
A motion was made that this matter be Affirmatively Recommended. The
motion carried.
INVOICES
A motion was made to Approve. The motion carried.
INTRA DEPARTMENTAL TRANSFERS
None
P-CARD APPROVALS
A motion was made to Approve. The motion carried.
PUBLIC SAFETY SERVICES COMMITTEE, MR. LAVELLE, CHAIR
NEW PAPERS
2017-2072 Resolution amending Resolution 688 of 2016, entitled “Authorizing the Mayor and the
Director of Public Safety to enter on behalf of the City of Pittsburgh into a one-year
Professional Services Agreement or Agreements with Family Life Empowerment
Community Development Corporation for the purpose of implementation of the
Pittsburgh Group Violence Intervention Street Outreach Program,” so as to extend
the contract an additional year, and increase the total cost from $150,000.00 to
$300,000.00.
A motion was made that this matter be Affirmatively Recommended. The
motion carried.
PUBLIC WORKS COMMITTEE, MRS. KAIL-SMITH, CHAIR
DEFERRED PAPERS
City of Pittsburgh Page 7 Printed on 12/11/2017
Standing Committee Meeting Minutes - Final November 15, 2017
2017-1996 Resolution amending Resolution No. 457, effective July 27, 2017, entitled
“Authorizing the Mayor and the Director of the Department of Mobility and
Infrastructure to enter into a Transfer Agreement or Agreements with the Pennsylvania
Department of Transportation (“PennDOT”), under which PennDOT will make
improvements to and transfer to the City of Pittsburgh portions of State Route 4084
from East Street to the West End Bridge, including Allegheny Circle.”
A motion was made that this matter be Held in the Committee on Public
Works , due back by 12/6/2017. The motion carried.
City of Pittsburgh Page 8 Printed on 12/11/2017
Standing Committee Meeting Minutes - Final November 15, 2017
2017-2003 Resolution authorizing the Mayor and the Director of the Department of Public Works
to enter into a Project Cooperation Agreement with Tree Pittsburgh for the purpose
of supporting Tree Pittsburgh’s efforts to promote and advance the City of
Pittsburgh’s Urban Forest Master Plan.
A motion was made that this matter be Affirmatively Recommended. The
motion carried.
LAND USE AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT COMMITTEE, MS. GROSS,
CHAIR
DEFERRED PAPERS
2017-1999 Ordinance amending the Pittsburgh Code, Title Nine, Zoning, Article I, Section
902.03 Zoning Map, by changing from AP, Mixed-Use Planned Unit Development to
GPR-C, Grandview Public Realm sub-district C, a certain property on Grandview
Avenue, Block Number 6-H, lot number 43; in the Allegheny County Block and Lot
System.
(NEEDS TO BE HELD FOR PUBLIC HEARING)
A motion was made that this matter be Held in the Committee on Land Use
and Economic Development, due back by 12/6/2017. The motion carried.
INNOVATION, PERFORMANCE AND ASSET MANAGEMENT
COMMITTEE, REV. BURGESS, CHAIR
NEW PAPERS
2017-2070 Resolution authorizing the Mayor and the Director of the Department of Finance to
purchase a subscription service from IHS Global, Inc., for economic data to be used
within the City of Pittsburgh’s revenue forecasting models, at a cost not to exceed
Four Thousand Eight Hundred and Three Dollars and Nineteen Cents ($4,803.19).
A motion was made that this matter be Affirmatively Recommended. The
motion carried.
INTERGOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS COMMITTEE, MR. GILMAN, CHAIR
NEW PAPERS
2017-2052 Resolution adopting Plan Addition to the City of Pittsburgh’s Official Sewage
Facilities Plan for the Junction Bloomfield at 5201 Liberty Avenue, Pittsburgh, PA
15224.
A motion was made that this matter be Affirmatively Recommended. The
motion carried.
City of Pittsburgh Page 9 Printed on 12/11/2017
Agenda
City of Pittsburgh 510 City-County Building
414 Grant Street
Pittsburgh, PA 15219
Standing Committee Meeting Agenda - Final
Wednesday, November 15, 2017 10:00 AM Council Chambers
STANDING COMMITTEES AGENDA
PUBLIC COMMENT
PRE-AGENDA - APPOINTMENTS AND/OR RE-APPOINTMENTS
2017-1880 Resolution appointing Khalif Ali as a Commissioner of the Ethics Hearing Board of
the City of Pittsburgh for a term to expire June 30, 2020.
2017-1882 Resolution appointing Fred W. Brown as a Commissioner of the Ethics Hearing
Board of the City of Pittsburgh for a term to expire on June 30, 2018.
2017-1884 Resolution appointing Orlando G. Portela Valentin as a Commissioner of the Ethics
Hearing Board of the City of Pittsburgh for a term to expire June 30, 2019.
ROLL CALL
FINANCE AND LAW COMMITTEE, MS. RUDIAK, CHAIR
DEFERRED PAPERS
2017-2037 Resolution authorizing the issuance of a warrant in favor of Cliff Jobe Consulting LLC,
204 Kennan Drive, Greensburg, PA 15601, in an amount not to exceed Twelve
Thousand Eight Hundred Twenty-Seven Dollars and 00/100 Cents ($12,827.00) for
consultation services in connection with trial appearance and related expenses for
USDC #2:16-cv-01364.
(Executive Session Held 11-8-17)
2017-2055 Resolution authorizing the issuance of a warrant in favor of Pittsburgh Collision &
Reconstruction Services, LLC, 10 Grandview Avenue, Pittsburgh, PA 15214, in an
amount not to exceed Three Thousand One Hundred Twenty-Nine Dollars and
68/100 Cents ($3,129.68) for consultation services in connection with trial
appearance and related expenses for USDC #2:16-cv-01364.
(Executive Session Held 11-8-17)
2017-2056 Resolution authorizing the issuance of a warrant in favor of Marshall Dennehey
Warner Coleman & Goggin, Union Trust Building, 501 Grant St., Suite 700,
Pittsburgh, PA in an amount not to exceed Eight Thousand Five Hundred Dollars and
No Cents ($8,500.00) for a trial transcript in a litigation case.
(Executive Session Held 11-8-17)
Page 1 Printed on 11/8/2017
Standing Committee Standing Committee Meeting November 15, 2017
Agenda - Final
NEW PAPERS
2017-2073 Ordinance amending the Pittsburgh City Code, Article VII, Personnel, Chapters
701 and 702; Title One, Administrative, Article III, Chapters 111, 116, 140 and
145; Title One, Administrative, Article V, Chapter 152; Title One, Administrative,
Article VII, Chapters 161 and 170; Title One, Administrative, Article IX, Chapters
174A, 176A, 177A, 177C, 178C, and 179; and Title One, Administrative, Article
XI, Chapters 180, 182, 186, 190, 197, and 199, to establish the Department of
Human Resources and Civil Service to encompass current Department of Personnel
and Civil Service Commission employees, responsibilities, and functions in order to
adjust the name of the Department to better reflect its current functions and to clarify
the roles, responsibilities, and functions of its Director.
2017-2074 Resolution providing for the conveyance by the City of Pittsburgh of certain property,
having been placed for sale to adjoining property owners in conjunction with the City
of Pittsburgh Side Yard Program. ITEMS A through F: A: 406 N Graham, B: 7043
Hermitage, C: 1332 Beechview, D: 3130 McClure E: 1524 Superior, F: 1526
Superior
(A)
David & Donna Jordan
LOT: 22 X 80.62
LOCATION: 406 N Graham Street
ACQUIRED: Oct. 1, 1984 T/S# 567
WARD: 11 BLOCK & LOT: 50-H-73
COUNCIL DISTRICT: 9
(B)
Alieyyah Sheffield
LOT: 20 X 93.66
LOCATION: 7043 Hermitage Street
ACQUIRED: July 29, 2011 T/S# 158
WARD: 13 BLOCK & LOT: 174-A-228
COUNCIL DISTRICT: 9
(C)
Todd & Melissa Harmon
LOT: 30 X 100
LOCATION: 1332 Beechview Ave
ACQUIRED: April 28, 2017 T/S# 294
WARD: 19 BLOCK & LOT: 16-P-251
COUNCIL DISTRICT: 4
Page 2 Printed on 11/8/2017
Standing Committee Standing Committee Meeting November 15, 2017
Agenda - Final
(D)
Thomas Stacy & Mary Stacy
LOT: 23.33 X 138.25
LOCATION: 3130 McClure Avenue
ACQUIRED: April 29, 2016 T/S# 416
WARD: 27 BLOCK & LOT: 75-S-151
COUNCIL DISTRICT: 1
(E)
William Dereich
LOT: 24.65 X 100
LOCATION: 1524 Superior Avenue
ACQUIRED: Dec. 16, 2004 T/S# 403
WARD: 27 BLOCK & LOT: 44-M-75
COUNCIL DISTRICT: 1
(F)
William Dereich
LOT: 24.65 X 100
LOCATION: 1526 Superior Avenue
ACQUIRED: May 1, 2009 T/S# 665
WARD: 27 BLOCK & LOT: 44-M-74
COUNCIL DISTRICT: 1
2017-2075 Resolution authorizing the issuance of a warrant in favor of Campbell Durrant Beatty
Palombo & Miller, P.C., 535 Smithfield St., Suite 700, Pittsburgh, PA 15222 for
professional legal services and expert advice regarding labor matters in an amount not
to exceed Three Thousand Nine Hundred Forty Dollars and Twelve Cents
($3,940.12).
(Executive Session Requested)
2017-2076 Resolution authorizing the issuance of a warrant in favor of Curtin & Heefner, LLP,
2005 S. Easton Road, Suite 100, Doylestown, PA l8901 for professional legal
services and expert advice regarding Building Owners and Managers in an amount
not to exceed Five Thousand Four Hundred Four Dollars and Seventy-Two Cents
($5,404.72).
(Executive Session Requested)
2017-2077 Resolution authorizing the issuance of a warrant in favor of Pepper Hamilton LLP,
Suite 5000, 500 Grant St., Pittsburgh, PA l5219 for professional consulting and legal
services in relation to False Claims Act litigation in an amount not to exceed Sixty
Nine Thousand Nine Hundred Twenty Four Dollars and Forty Three Cents
($69,924.43).
(Executive Session Requested)
Page 3 Printed on 11/8/2017
Standing Committee Standing Committee Meeting November 15, 2017
Agenda - Final
2017-2078 Resolution authorizing the issuance of a warrant in favor of Michael E. Zobrak, Labor
Arbitrator, 1217 Pleasant Street, Aliquippa, PA 15001-9425 for arbitration fees for
a two day hearing related to Grievance 15-024 in an amount not to exceed Three
Thousand Fifty Two Dollars and Forty-Five Cents ($3,052.45).
(Executive Session Requested)
2017-2079 Resolution authorizing the issuance of a warrant in favor of Heckman Enterprises, 116
Claremont Drive, Lower Burrell, PA 15068, in an amount not to exceed Four
Thousand Five Hundred Dollars and 00/100 Cents ($4,500.00) for consultation
services in connection with trial appearance and related expenses File No. 12-0289.
(Executive Session Requested)
2017-2080 Resolution authorizing the issuance of a warrant in favor of Micklow Consulting, 4017
Washington Road, PMB 1300, McMurry, PA 15317, in the amount not to exceed
Twenty-Two Thousand one Hundred Thirty-Four Dollars and 25/100 Cents
($22,1324.25) for consultation services in connection with trial appearance and
related expenses File No. 12-0289.
(Executive Session Requested)
2017-2081 Resolution amending the Rules of Council by adding purview over the Department of
Mobility and Infrastructure to the responsibilities of the Council Standing Committee
on Public Works
SPONSOR /S: MR. KRAUS
INVOICES
INTRA DEPARTMENTAL TRANSFERS
P-CARD APPROVALS
PUBLIC SAFETY SERVICES COMMITTEE, MR. LAVELLE, CHAIR
NEW PAPERS
2017-2072 Resolution amending Resolution 688 of 2016, entitled “Authorizing the Mayor and the
Director of Public Safety to enter on behalf of the City of Pittsburgh into a one-year
Professional Services Agreement or Agreements with Family Life Empowerment
Community Development Corporation for the purpose of implementation of the
Pittsburgh Group Violence Intervention Street Outreach Program,” so as to extend
the contract an additional year, and increase the total cost from $150,000.00 to
$300,000.00.
Page 4 Printed on 11/8/2017
Standing Committee Standing Committee Meeting November 15, 2017
Agenda - Final
PUBLIC WORKS COMMITTEE, MRS. KAIL-SMITH, CHAIR
DEFERRED PAPERS
2017-1996 Resolution amending Resolution No. 457, effective July 27, 2017, entitled
“Authorizing the Mayor and the Director of the Department of Mobility and
Infrastructure to enter into a Transfer Agreement or Agreements with the
Pennsylvania Department of Transportation (“PennDOT”), under which PennDOT
will make improvements to and transfer to the City of Pittsburgh portions of State
Route 4084 from East Street to the West End Bridge, including Allegheny Circle.”
2017-2003 Resolution authorizing the Mayor and the Director of the Department of Public
Works to enter into a Project Cooperation Agreement with Tree Pittsburgh for the
purpose of supporting Tree Pittsburgh’s efforts to promote and advance the City of
Pittsburgh’s Urban Forest Master Plan.
LAND USE AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT COMMITTEE, MS. GROSS, CHAIR
DEFERRED PAPERS
2017-1999 Ordinance amending the Pittsburgh Code, Title Nine, Zoning, Article I, Section
902.03 Zoning Map, by changing from AP, Mixed-Use Planned Unit Development to
GPR-C, Grandview Public Realm sub-district C, a certain property on Grandview
Avenue, Block Number 6-H, lot number 43; in the Allegheny County Block and Lot
System.
INNOVATION, PERFORMANCE AND ASSET MANAGEMENT COMMITTEE, REV.
BURGESS, CHAIR
NEW PAPERS
2017-2070 Resolution authorizing the Mayor and the Director of the Department of Finance to
purchase a subscription service from IHS Global, Inc., for economic data to be used
within the City of Pittsburgh’s revenue forecasting models, at a cost not to exceed
Four Thousand Eight Hundred and Three Dollars and Nineteen Cents ($4,803.19).
INTERGOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS COMMITTEE, MR. GILMAN, CHAIR
NEW PAPERS
2017-2052 Resolution adopting Plan Addition to the City of Pittsburgh’s Official Sewage
Facilities Plan for the Junction Bloomfield at 5201 Liberty Avenue, Pittsburgh, PA
15224.
Page 5 Printed on 11/8/2017
Standing Committee Standing Committee Meeting November 15, 2017
Agenda - Final
Page 6 Printed on 11/8/2017