Historic Design Review Commission

City of San Antonio AGENDA Historic and Design Review Commission Meeting Development and Business Service Center 1901 South Alamo San Antonio, Texas 78204 Wednesday, September 6, 2023 3:00 PM The Historic and Design Review Commission will hold its regular meeting in the Board Room at 1901 South Alamo, beginning at 3:00 p.m. Once a quorum is established, the Historic and Design Review Commission will take up the following items no sooner than the designated times. To watch and listen to this meeting, visit www.sanantonio.gov/DSD/Boards/MeetingVideos. To call to listen to audio only, in English or Spanish, call 210­206­LIVE (5483). Members of the public can comment on items on the agenda, consistent with procedural rules governing HDRC meetings and state law. Public comments may also be provided as follows: 1. Leave a voice message a maximum of two minutes by dialing 210­206­HDRC(4372) by 12 noon on the day of the meeting. Voicemail messages will be played during the meeting. Please include your full name, home or work address, the item number and item address of the request. 2. Submit written comments to HistoricDesignReviewCommission@sanantonio.gov by 12 noon on the day of the meeting. Please include your full name, home or work address, the item number and item address of the request. Written comments will be part of the official written record only. 3. Attend the in­person hearing and signup to speak before the meeting begins at 3 PM. Each member of the public will have two minutes to speak unless otherwise directed by the Chair. 3:00 P.M. – Call to Order Roll Call Chairman’s Statement Public Comments Approval of Minutes Approval of minutes for the April 5, 2023, and August 16, 2023, Historic and Design Review Commission meetings. 3. Attend the in­person hearing and signup to speak before the meeting begins at 3 PM. Each member of the public will have two minutes to speak unless otherwise directed by the Chair. 3:00 P.M. – Call to Order Roll Call Chairman’s Statement Public Comments Approval of Minutes Approval of minutes for the April 5, 2023, and August 16, 2023, Historic and Design Review Commission meetings. CONSENT AGENDA Items are placed on the consent agenda when staff recommends approval or recommends approval with stipulations that the applicant agrees to. Any member of the public desiring to speak on a consent agenda item may sign up and be heard prior to voting on the consent agenda. Commissioners may request to remove any item from the consent agenda and have it placed on the individual consideration agenda. All items on the consent agenda will be considered for approval by one motion adopting the items with staff findings and recommendations. 1. Address/Description: River Road Historic Design Guidelines (POSTPONED) HDRC Case No.: 2023­362 City Council Dist.: 1 Applicant: City of San Antonio – Office of Historic Preservation Type of Work: Historic Design Guidelines 2. Address/Description: 228 ODELL ST HDRC Case No.: 2023­339 Applicant: Mitch Ford/FORD MITCHELL SCOTT Request: Landmark Designation City Council Dist.: 1 3. Address/Description: 319 W LULLWOOD AVE HDRC Case No.: 2023­328 Historic District Name: Monte Vista Applicant: Dustin Brisco/Dubri enterprises Inc Request: Demolition of rear accessory structure City Council Dist.: 1 4. Address/Description: 2620 N MAIN AVE HDRC Case No.: 2023­333 Historic District Name: Monte Vista Applicant: Josh Campbell /Mangold roofing Request: Roof replacement (shingle to metal) City Council Dist.: 1 5. Address/Description: 314 FLORIDA ST HDRC Case No.: 2023­294  City Council Dist.: 1 4. Address/Description: 2620 N MAIN AVE HDRC Case No.: 2023­333 Historic District Name: Monte Vista Applicant: Josh Campbell /Mangold roofing Request: Roof replacement (shingle to metal) City Council Dist.: 1 5. Address/Description: 314 FLORIDA ST HDRC Case No.: 2023­294 Historic District Name: Lavaca Applicant: Jason Moran/Jason Moran Collaborative Ventures LLC Request: Construction of a detached, rear accessory structure City Council Dist.: 1 6. Address/Description: 623/643 E NUEVA – CIVIC PARK HDRC Case No.: 2023­340 Historic District Name: Hemisfair RIO District: RIO­3 Applicant: Kara Weaver/GGN Request: Hemisfair Civic Park ­ Phase 2 City Council Dist.: 1 7. Address/Description: 875 E ASHBY PLACE HDRC Case No.: 2023­342 RIO District: RIO­2 Applicant: Ashley Farrimond Request: Installation of recognition markers City Council Dist.: 1 8. Address/Description: 519 MISSION ST HDRC Case No.: 2023­140 Landmark Name: Individual Landmark Historic District Name: King William Applicant: Matthew Thomson Request: Historic Tax Verification City Council Dist.: 1 9. Address/Description: 3853 N ST MARYS ST HDRC Case No.: 2023­351 RIO District: RIO­1 Applicant: James Torres/Don B. McDonald Architects Request: New construction of a 2­story restroom structure City Council Dist.: 2 10. Address/Description: 1010 BURNET ST HDRC Case No.: 2023­047 Historic District Name: Dignowity Hill Applicant: Markus Lopez Request: Historic Tax Verification City Council Dist.: 2  RIO District: RIO­1 Applicant: James Torres/Don B. McDonald Architects Request: New construction of a 2­story restroom structure City Council Dist.: 2 10. Address/Description: 1010 BURNET ST HDRC Case No.: 2023­047 Historic District Name: Dignowity Hill Applicant: Markus Lopez Request: Historic Tax Verification City Council Dist.: 2 11. Address/Description: 1902 W KINGS HWY HDRC Case No.: 2023­260 Historic District Name: Monticello Park Applicant: JT McFarland Request: Historic Tax Certification & Verification City Council Dist.: 7 12. Address/Description: 303 DARTMOUTH ST/Rosedale Park HDRC Case No.: 2023­352 Public Property: Rosedale Park Applicant: Beth Wells/Bender Wells Clark Design Request: Park improvements City Council Dist.: 5 13. Address/Description: 910 S ALAMO ST HDRC Case No.: 2023­334 Historic District Name: King William Applicant: Iris Ornelas/Luna Rosa Puerto Rican Grill y Tapas Request: Signage City Council Dist.: 1 14. Address/Description: 11777 SPRING RAIN DR/Al Rhodes Park and Buddy Calk Trailhead Park HDRC Case No.: 2023­350 Public Property: Al Rhodes Park and Buddy Calk Trailhead Park Applicant: Beth Wells/Bender Wells Clark Design Request: Park improvements City Council Dist.: 8 15. Address/Description: 211 WICKES HDRC Case No.: 2023­341 Historic District Name: King William Applicant: Elaine Lutton/Lutton Properties LLC Request: Rear addition City Council Dist.: 1 16. Address/Description: 2171 W SUMMIT AVE HDRC Case No.: 2023­332 Historic District Name: Monticello Park Applicant: Mike O'Leary/Mike O'Leary Construction Services 15. Address/Description: 211 WICKES HDRC Case No.: 2023­341 Historic District Name: King William Applicant: Elaine Lutton/Lutton Properties LLC Request: Rear addition City Council Dist.: 1 16. Address/Description: 2171 W SUMMIT AVE HDRC Case No.: 2023­332 Historic District Name: Monticello Park Applicant: Mike O'Leary/Mike O'Leary Construction Services Request: Retaining wall installation City Council Dist.: 7 17. Address/Description: 216 CAMARGO HDRC Case No.: 2023­345 Historic District Name: Lavaca Applicant: Henry Tijerina /Tijerina Construction Request: Sidewalk modifications, driveway modifications City Council Dist.: 1 18. Address/Description: 446 E HILDEBRAND AVE HDRC Case No.: 2023­356 Historic District Name: Monte Vista Applicant: Phil Solomon/Phil Solomon Inc Request: Driveway, curb cut, landscaping, hardscaping, and wall modifications City Council Dist.: 1 19. Address/Description: 2030 W MULBERRY AVE HDRC Case No.: 2023­357 Historic District Name: Monticello Park Applicant: Jerry Woolf/H­919700 Request: Modification to a previously approved garage design, driveway modifications, and rear driveway installation City Council Dist.: 7 INDIVIDUAL CONSIDERATION Returning cases 20. Address/Description: 620 S PRESA ST HDRC Case No.: 2023­279 Historic District Name: Lavaca Applicant: Eluterio Tenorio/ETDesign Studio Request: Exterior cladding modifications City Council Dist.: 1 New cases 21. Address/Description: 2900 ROOSEVELT AVE 2901 ROOSEVELT AVE 20. Address/Description: 620 S PRESA ST HDRC Case No.: 2023­279 Historic District Name: Lavaca Applicant: Eluterio Tenorio/ETDesign Studio Request: Exterior cladding modifications City Council Dist.: 1 New cases 21. Address/Description: 2900 ROOSEVELT AVE 2901 ROOSEVELT AVE 2835 ROOSEVELT AVE 1018 E SOUTHCROSS BLVD 992 E SOUTHCROSS BLVD/958 E SOUTHCROSS HDRC Case No.: 2023­343 Historic District Name: Mission RIO District: RIO­5 Applicant: Michael Clancy/Alamo Architects Request: Construction of a mixed­use development with multiple structures, site and landscaping modifications City Council Dist.: 3 22. Address/Description: 205 W HUISACHE AVE HDRC Case No.: 2023­358 Historic District Name: Monte Vista Applicant: Ronald Suarez/INTEGRITY RSM CORP, LLC Request: Siding replacement City Council Dist.: 1 23. Address/Description: 506 STIEREN HDRC Case No.: 2023­322 Historic District Name: King William Applicant: IDOWU NTOKA/ION HOMES AND RESORT USA LLC Request: New construction of a 2.5­story, multifamily development City Council Dist.: 1 24. Address/Description: 133 E WOODLAWN AVE HDRC Case No.: 2023­318 Historic District Name: Monte Vista Applicant: John Chalfant/NPC REO, LLC Request: Construction of a 2­story addition, fenestration modifications City Council Dist.: 1 25. Address/Description: 1231 S ALAMO ST HDRC Case No.: 2023­349 Historic District Name: King William Applicant: Theresa Mauricio/New Day Custom Homes LLC Request: Construction of a 2­story addition City Council Dist.: 1 26. Address/Description: 2030 W MULBERRY AVE HDRC Case No.: 2023­324  City Council Dist.: 1 25. Address/Description: 1231 S ALAMO ST HDRC Case No.: 2023­349 Historic District Name: King William Applicant: Theresa Mauricio/New Day Custom Homes LLC Request: Construction of a 2­story addition City Council Dist.: 1 26. Address/Description: 2030 W MULBERRY AVE HDRC Case No.: 2023­324 Historic District Name: Monticello Park Applicant: Nate Manfred/French and Michigan Request: Window replacement City Council Dist.: 7 27. Address/Description: 814 N OLIVE ST HDRC Case No.: 2023­344 Historic District Name: Dignowity Hill Applicant: Brad Clawson/Elise Construction, LLC Request: Waiver; modifications to previously­approved design City Council Dist.: 2 28. Address/Description: 419 WICKES HDRC Case No.: 2023­337 Historic District Name: King William Applicant: Jacob Williams/WILLIAMS JACOB CHARLES & CHEVALIER KARINA Request: Front porch post installation, handrail installation, and removal of porch plinths City Council Dist.: 1 29. Address/Description: 1407 FULTON AVE HDRC Case No.: 2023­346 Historic District Name: Fulton Applicant: Blanca Tellez /1 SHARPE OPPORTUNITY INTERMEDIATE TRUST Request: Wholesale window replacement, garage door removal, exterior door replacement City Council Dist.: 1 30. Address/Description: 421 SPOFFORD HDRC Case No.: 2023­305 Historic District Name: Government Hill Applicant: Shail Patel/BRATCHER BLAKE MCCALL & PATEL SHAIL Request: Concrete installation, curb cut modification, and carport construction City Council Dist.: 2 31. Address/Description: 312 BURLESON ST HDRC Case No.: 2023­329 Historic District Name: Dignowity Hill Applicant: Jeff Hornbeak/HORNBEAK JEFFERY Request: Landscaping modifications and fence and gates installation City Council Dist.: 2 32. Address/Description: 326 MISSION ST  Request: Concrete installation, curb cut modification, and carport construction City Council Dist.: 2 31. Address/Description: 312 BURLESON ST HDRC Case No.: 2023­329 Historic District Name: Dignowity Hill Applicant: Jeff Hornbeak/HORNBEAK JEFFERY Request: Landscaping modifications and fence and gates installation City Council Dist.: 2 32. Address/Description: 326 MISSION ST HDRC Case No.: 2023­338 Landmark Name: Individual Landmark Historic District Name: King William Applicant: Stanley Marcus Request: Front fence and gates installation, landscape modifications, and hardscape modifications City Council Dist.: 1 33. Address/Description: 240 FURR DR HDRC Case No.: 2023­354 Historic District Name: Monticello Park Applicant: Pauline Canales Request: Front porch awning installation City Council Dist.: 7 Adjourn At any time during the meeting, the Historic and Design Review Commission may meet in executive session for consultation with the City Attorney's Office concerning attorney­client matters under Chapter 551 of the Texas Government Code. ACCESSIBILITY STATEMENT The City of San Antonio ensures meaningful access to City meetings, programs and services by reasonably providing: translation and interpretation, materials in alternate formats, and other accommodations upon request. To request these services call (210) 207​2098 or Relay Texas 711 or by requesting these services online at https://www.sanantonio.gov/gpa/LanguageServices. Providing at least 72 hours’ notice will help to ensure availability. DECLARACIÓN DE ACCESO La Ciudad de San Antonio garantiza acceso a las reuniones, los programas y los servicios de la Ciudad proporcionando: traducción e interpretación, materiales en formatos alternativos y otras adaptaciones a pedido. Para solicitar estos servicios llame al (210) 207¬2098 o Relay Texas 711 o solicite estos servicios en línea en https://www.sanantonio.gov/gpa/LanguageServices. Dando un aviso al menos 72 horas antes ayudará a garantizar la disponibilidad. Posted on: 09/06/2023 11:35 AM La Ciudad de San Antonio garantiza acceso a las reuniones, los programas y los servicios de la Ciudad proporcionando: traducción e interpretación, materiales en formatos alternativos y otras adaptaciones a pedido. Para solicitar estos servicios llame al (210) 207¬2098 o Relay Texas 711 o solicite estos servicios en línea en https://www.sanantonio.gov/gpa/LanguageServices. Dando un aviso al menos 72 horas antes ayudará a garantizar la disponibilidad. Posted on: 09/06/2023 11:35 AM