Legislative Hearings
Regular MeetingSt. Paul, MN · April 19, 2016
Minutes
15 West Kellogg Blvd.
City of Saint Paul Saint Paul, MN 55102
Minutes - Final
Legislative Hearings
Marcia Moermond, Legislative Hearing Officer
Mai Vang, Hearing Coordinator
Jean Birkholz, Hearing Secretary
legislativehearings@ci.stpaul.mn.us
651-266-8585
Tuesday, April 19, 2016 9:00 AM Room 330 City Hall & Court House
9:00 a.m. Hearings
Remove/Repair Orders
1 RLH TA 16-187 Ratifying the Appealed Special Tax Assessment for Property at 201
SNELLING AVENUE NORTH (File No. VB1608, Assessment No.
168808).
Sponsors: Stark
Peter P. Nadimi, owner, appeared.
Ms. Nhia Vang:
-asked Mr. Nadimi how far along his was with this property
Mr. Nadimi:
-he waiting for approval from the city re a permit; there are some changes; he thinks
that they are meeting today to review his site plan
-it won't take much time after he's done with the city - 2-10 days after that
Inspector Joe Yannarelly:
-checked in the file: site plan review is in progress per Larry Zangs
Mr. Nadimi:
-every city you go to, they help their residents; but in St. Paul.......
Ms. Nhia Vang:
-if the rehab is done by the end of May, she will reduce the assessment by half;
you've already had more than 180 days to complete it already
Mr. Nadimi:
-if it were my fault, I could accept that; but it took 3 months just to get the results of
the fire investigation; then, from there it went to the insurance company; it took them
3 months to do what they thought they had to do; then,..... everything was out of my
control
Ms. Nhia Vang:
-will think about this more
-Recommendation is forthcoming.
Referred to the City Council due back on 5/18/2016
City of Saint Paul Page 1
Legislative Hearings Minutes - Final April 19, 2016
2 RLH TA 16-193 Ratifying the Appealed Special Tax Assessment for Property at 1294
BOHLAND PLACE (File No. J1608E, Assessment No. 168309).
Sponsors: Tolbert
Approve; no show.
Referred to the City Council due back on 5/18/2016
3 RLH TA 16-174 Ratifying the Appealed Special Tax Assessment for Property at 1231
FARRINGTON STREET (File No. J1608A, Assessment No. 168517).
Sponsors: Brendmoen
Approve; no show.
Referred to the City Council due back on 5/18/2016
4 RLH TA 16-179 Ratifying the Appealed Special Tax Assessment for Property at 907
FIFTH STREET EAST (File No. J1608A, Assessment No. 168517).
Sponsors: Prince
Chou Kue, tenant, appeared. (Mai Vang interpreted.)
Inspector Paula Seeley:
-Summary Abatement Order issued Jan 21, 2016; compliance Jan 26; re-checked
Jan 26
-work done Jan 28m 2016 for a cost of $344 + $160 service charge = $504
-remove bags of garbage/rubbish on ground in rear yard near alley
-sent to Kong Vang, 8184 9th St N, Oakdale, MN; and Occupant
-no returned mail
VIDEO - crew picked up bags of garbage/rubbish on ground in rear yard near alley
Mr. Kue:
-has not been in this country long
-he didn't understand the Notice; the owner, Kong Vang, gave him the Notice
Ms. Nhia Vang:
-going forward, does he understand that he needs to pick up the garbage; he can't
leave the bags on the ground
Mr. Kue:
-when he came, he was aware of these situations but he was in the process of
moving and the trash company didn't pick it up; he didn't think that it was an issue
-the owner, Mr. Vang, told him that he had to pay for the fee but at that time, he had
already moved to Mpls
-he is not living here; he lives in North Mpls
-he apologizes
Ms. Nhia Vang:
-will recommend deletion
-Mpls is different
City of Saint Paul Page 2
Legislative Hearings Minutes - Final April 19, 2016
Delete the assessment.
Referred to the City Council due back on 5/18/2016
5 RLH TA 16-200 Ratifying the Appealed Special Tax Assessment for Property at 675
HALL AVENUE (File No. J1608A, Assessment No. 168517).
Sponsors: Noecker
Carolyn E. Curtis, owner, appeared.
Inspector Joe Yannarelly:
-this is a late snow/ice removal
-Notice sent Jan 6, 2016; compliance 48 hours after post mark; re-checked Jan 8
-work done Jan 11, 2016 for a cost of $160 + $160 service charge = #320
VIDEO - saw only tulips the first time
VIDEO - crew cleaned snow/ice; salted & sanded
Ms. Curtis:
-that was just a small amount of snow; must have missed that snow fall
-she is asking for a reduction or forgiveness; she has numerous assessment with this
house;
-is on disability and is renting from her daughter
-there were drugs involved here and house was Condemned last Apr
-after this, she wants to talk about the VB fee renewal too today
-she thought that she would be signing the final loan papers from the city last Fri;
she's been approved for $75,000 for rehab inside & outside of the house
-she is moving into this house as soon as the rehab's done
-she has insurance that will be applied to the rehab
-anticipated that the rehab should take 4-6 weeks; has bids here
-the house is on the historic list; it has good bones; now, it's just filthy inside
-she has re-done this house 2 or 3 times since 1985; her daughter and family has
lived there periodically; there have been struggles with drugs, etc; they were evicted;
it was very stressful and they aren't accepting responsibility for their behavior, etc.
-no one is living in this house at this time; the house is a Cat 2 VB
Mr. Yannarelly:
-your VB fees are due Apr 21, 2016; call Mr. Dornfeld, 266-1902, to ask for an
extension; explain that you have all this money lined up; if you don't get the house
done in the time that he can grant you, you can send in the gold card for an appeal;
call Mr. Dornfeld right away and leave a message
Ms. Nhia Vang:
-given your hard work and the fact that you have everything lined up, she will
recommend deleting this assessment
Delete the assessment.
Referred to the City Council due back on 5/18/2016
6 RLH TA 16-204 Ratifying the Appealed Special Tax Assessment for Property at 985
JENKS AVENUE (File No. CRT1608, Assessment No. 168208).
Sponsors: Bostrom
Reduce the assessment from $953.00 to $449.00.
City of Saint Paul Page 3
Legislative Hearings Minutes - Final April 19, 2016
Referred to the City Council due back on 6/1/2016
7 RLH TA 16-198 Ratifying the Appealed Special Tax Assessment for Property at 716
MAGNOLIA AVENUE EAST (File No. CRT1608, Assessment No.
168208).
Sponsors: Bostrom
Assessment amount is incorrect. Invoices are correct $645.00, and include a $70.00
no entry fee. When failed to pay invoice, $70.00 no entry fee cannot be assessed, so
is deleted but adds $155.00 assessment fees. Total amount to be assessed is:
$575.00 + $155.00 fees = $730.00
Reduce the assessment from $1375.00 to $730.00 per comments above.
Referred to the City Council due back on 6/1/2016
8 RLH TA 16-194 Ratifying the Appealed Special Tax Assessment for Property at 23
TENTH STREET WEST. (File No. CRT1607, Assessment No.
168206)
Sponsors: Noecker
Approve; no show. (Original hearing was March 15, Rescheduled to April 19 per
owner's request). 2 missed hearings so Appellant will need to appeal at City Council.
Referred to the City Council due back on 5/4/2016
9 RLH TA 16-197 Ratifying the Appealed Special Tax Assessment for Property at 1169
UNIVERSITY AVENUE WEST (File No. J1605A2, Assessment No.
168524).
Sponsors: Stark
Approve; no show.
Referred to the City Council due back on 5/18/2016
10 RLH TA 16-199 Ratifying the Appealed Special Tax Assessment for Property at 76
WHEELOCK PARKWAY EAST (File No. J1608E, Assessment No.
168309).
Sponsors: Brendmoen
Approve; no show.
Referred to the City Council due back on 5/18/2016
Special Tax Assessments - ROLLS
11 RLH AR 16-25 Ratifying Property Clean Up service on October 8, 2015 at 1169
UNIVERSITY AVENUE WEST (File No. J1605A2, Assessment No.
168524).
Sponsors: Stark
City of Saint Paul Page 4
Legislative Hearings Minutes - Final April 19, 2016
Approve; no show.
Referred to the City Council due back on 6/1/2016
12 RLH AR 16-26 Ratifying Collection of Fire Certificate of Occupancy fees billed during
November 10 to December 11, 2015. (File No. CRT1608, Assessment
No. 168208)
Sponsors: Stark
Referred to the City Council due back on 6/1/2016
13 RLH AR 16-27 Ratifying Graffiti Removal service during January 21 to February 2,
2016. (File No. J1608P, Assessment No. 168407)
Sponsors: Stark
Referred to the City Council due back on 6/1/2016
14 RLH AR 16-28 Ratifying Tree Removal services from January 2016. (File No. 1604T,
Assessment No. 169003)
Sponsors: Stark
Referred to the City Council due back on 6/1/2016
11:00 a.m. Hearings
Summary Abatement Orders
15 RLH SAO 16-12 Appeal of Tylon Newcomb to a Vehicle Abatement Order at 488
ROBERT STREET SOUTH.
Sponsors: Noecker
Tylon Newcomb, owner, appeared.
Inspector Lisa Martin:
-Vehicle Abatement Order issued on Apr 13, 2016 for an unlicensed trailer parked on
an unapproved surface by Inspector Mark Kaisersatt
-the inspector had talked with the owner previously regarding storing this trailer and
shack on an unapproved surface; and the shack looks as though it could be intended
for a candy shack, which is also not allowed in the City of Saint Paul
-not the first time we've issued Orders or talked with the owner about this same
situation
-we would like to see this removed
-photos
Mr. Newcomb:
-this is his first time buying a property; he is trying to do something positive to stay
out of the street
-he wants to put a food stand/food truck there but he thought that he could just go
ahead and do it; now, he is learning that there are a lot of rules and regulations that
he needs to abide by; he sees that he needs more knowledge in order to move
City of Saint Paul Page 5
Legislative Hearings Minutes - Final April 19, 2016
forward; this is basically, why he scheduled this hearing; he needs some
understanding about what he can do to move forward
-he is not moving the trailer; he will fix what he needs to fix but the trailer is going
nowhere
-he talked with code enforcement; they told him that all he had to do was to put down
gravel, pavers, etc, which he attempted to do and it's still a problem
Ms. Nhia Vang:
-asked if he got an approved plan from Zoning
Mr. Newcomb:
-that's why he's here now - to see what he needs to do
-he's gotten over 17 tickets; he gets tickets for everything; he doesn't know where
they're coming from
Ms. Nhia Vang:
-if you want to make this into a food truck or something like that, you need to talk with
the proper people
Mr. Newcomb:
-I have a lifetime license on the trailer (in her name: Ms. Qui Lewis)
-it's licensed with the DMV - the sticker is on the side where it's most visible
-he emailed a photo of the sticker to LH
Ms. Nhia Vang:
-noted that if the sticker is not in the proper place, an inspector may not see it
-try to put it in the right place
-submit a site plan for approval with Zoning
Ms. Lisa Martin:
-Inspector Kaisersatt has talked with them before about the parking on an
unimproved surface; and the Vehicle Abatement Order shows "No parking permitted
on the vacant lot without site plan approval;" no site plan has even been applied for at
this point; the parking area needs to be concrete or asphalt after the sit plan is
approved
-we could probably give them another week to get that site plan in; otherwise, the
vehicle will be towed
Ms. Nhia Vang:
-go to Zoning today and submit a site plan - draw it up and measure it; we can give
you time
Mr. Newcomb:
-when I talked to Kevin in Zoning (not sure of his title); he told me asphalt, pavement
or pavers
Ms. Nhia Vang:
-will Lay this Over to next Tue, Apr 26, 2016 LH
Ms. Martin:
-just so you know, too, it appears that a food/candy stand cannot be on the property
-go to DSI and let them know that you want to open a business and they can give you
all that information as far as what licenses you will need, etc; there's all different
types of Zoning and uses that allowed in that Zoning
Ms. Nhia Vang:
City of Saint Paul Page 6
Legislative Hearings Minutes - Final April 19, 2016
-talk with DSI about your plans and they can guide you
Layover so appellant can get a site plan to Zoning for review of unapproved parking
surface as well any business plan for a food truck. Appellant will need to relocate the
license plate for the trailer so that it's visible to the public.
Laid Over to the Legislative Hearings due back on 4/26/2016
Correction Orders
16 RLH CO 16-12 Appeal of Gene Marault to a Correction Notice at 937 CHARLES
AVENUE.
Sponsors: Thao
Gene Marault, owner, appeared.
Inspector Paula Seeley:
-received a complaint about a deficient garage
-Summary Abatement Order was issued Mar 7, 2016; compliance May 2
-garage is structurally deficient; garage roof is deteriorated - replace under permit;
garage roof has failed and is severely sagging; garage eaves and soffits are in
disrepair
Ms. Marault:
-when she bought the house, the garage was in bad shape; she bought the property
with a loan through the City of St. Paul and she had to pay for a lot of different
inspections; so, if the garage was that bad, why didn't code enforcement catch it
before she bought the house
-she was in the back yard when the inspector came and she talked with him; he said
that her garage was no worse than half the garages on her block but that someone
had complained, so he had to come out and write it up; ordinarily, he said that he
wouldn't do anything about it but someone had complained; he said that the
complaint was probably retaliation
Inspector Lisa Martin:
-looks like the property was purchased around 1998 - has been around for some time
-usually, before you buy a property from the City of St. Paul, you will actually look at
the property and probably get a pretty good deal on it, especially, if there's some
repairs that need to be made
Ms. Marault:
-when I bought the property, there was snow on the roof, so, she couldn't tell what
shape the roof was in and the previous owners had the garage packed with stuff from
floor to ceiling, she couldn't see that the floor was dirt; she had less information about
the garage than the city did and I had hoped to get a good deal on this property, too
because the house needed some work; but a week before closing, the city told her
that they decided that her purchase price was too low and charged her an extra
$4000 for the property; she had to come up with that on the spur of the moment in
cash a week before closing in 1999
-when she realized the condition of the garage, she searched around for 0
interest/low interest home improvement loan programs for the garage but none cover
garage replacement/repair and she doesn't have the money to fix it or to tear it down
Ms. Nhia Vang:
-there's no financing that could help because garages are an accessory building to
City of Saint Paul Page 7
Legislative Hearings Minutes - Final April 19, 2016
the house
-the garage is in bad shape; it's unfortunate; she's afraid that someone could get hurt
Ms. Marault:
-no one can really get in the garage; the door is on the back and they're nailed shut; I
just go in and grab equipment to use on the yard
Ms. Nhia Vang:
-understands her financial situation but the garage either needs to be repaired or
demolished
Ms. Marault:
-she has had several contractors out there and it can't be repaired
-for 17 years, she's been trying to figure out how to replace it
Ms. Nhia Vang:
-the only recourse seems to be to have the city demo it and the cost assessed
Ms. Marault:
-she's been told that the city charges 3 times more than local contractors and then
charges interest on it, which she can't afford to pay
Ms. Nhia Vang:
-the city's charge is very comparable and we can talk about the assessment and can
give you time, say 5 years to pay it
-will recommend that it be demolished
Ms. Seeley:
-have the city tear it down; they are very comparable to any other contractor; it's a
small garage and have it assessed over 5 years; and it will cost a lot less if it's empty
from debris; she estimates about $2000
Ms. Marault:
-and, I'll have to get a shed for about $500 and then, I have to pay someone to put it
together for her; also, I"ll have to pay for permits - one cost right after another
-she has volunteered for many years doing work for her community; when there was
a need, I stepped up and here..............
Ms. Seeley:
-thinks that's there's something for people who have disabilities
-you can go in front of City Council
-you can have one of the Parks crew go out and give you a rough estimate of what
it's going to cost
-she doesn't think the garage roof will take another snow load
Ms. Marault:
-I live on about $1000 a month; she is trying to keep up the property
-it's just not possible to come up with more money
Ms. Nhia Vang:
-will Lay this Over 4 weeks to May 17 LH
Layover for appellant to provide bids for the cost of the garage if she was to have it
demoed.
Laid Over to the Legislative Hearings due back on 5/17/2016
City of Saint Paul Page 8
Legislative Hearings Minutes - Final April 19, 2016
17 RLH CO 16-11 Appeal of Jenneh Matthews to a Correction Notice at 1036
MINNEHAHA AVENUE WEST.
Sponsors: Thao
Jenneh Matthews, owner, appeared.
Inspector Paula Seeley:
-our office got a complaint Mar 24, 2016 that there was a large sink hole in the back
yard
-photos
-not sure what caused the sink hole
Ms. Matthews:
-as far as she knows, nature caused the sink hole
-she called the city and talked with a guy about it; he said that he could see it on his
computer screen (and it was the middle of winter)
-a guy came over from the city and said that it couldn't be filled up during the winter;
she should wait until the ground warmed up
-a couple days later, she got a letter in the mail
-is requesting an extension; needs until May 15, 2016 for sure
-she's a single mother
Ms. Nhia Vang:
-will recommend granting until May 15, 2016 to fill the sink hole and plant grass
-suggested that she talk with a surveyor; it could get bigger
Deny and grant until May 15, 2016 to bring the large sinkhole in the rear yard into
compliance.
Referred to the City Council due back on 5/4/2016
18 RLH CO 16-16 Appeal of Shoua T. Khang to a Correction Notice at 861 HUDSON
ROAD.
Sponsors: Prince
Shoua T. Khang, owner of 861 Hudson Road, appeared.
Cynthia M. Perron, tax owner of 726 Plum Street, appeared.
Inspector Paula Seeley:
-complaint came into office Apr 12, 2016 about a deteriorated retaining wall
-inspector went out and said that the retaining wall at the rear of the property was in
disrepair; remove/repair/replace; remove debris from crumbled retaining wall
immediately; work may require a permit and approval from Heritage Preservation
Commission (HPC)
-her understanding from building official Steve Ubl, is that the retaining wall belongs
to the property whose soil it is holding back
-this is a civil dispute; we don't usually get involved; we tell them that they need to get
their own survey or work it out together
-both parties received the same Order
Ms. Perron:
-did get the Correction Notice
-that retaining wall is not just between us; it goes down the whole block from one end
of the block down to the other end of the block
-we are on the hill; Plum Street goes up the hill; Hudson is a level street; that wall
City of Saint Paul Page 9
Legislative Hearings Minutes - Final April 19, 2016
was put up to give us lateral support
-when the city started to take down trees, they damaged the wall, too
-the wall is about 2 feet high and goes through 4 properties to Maple Street
Ms. Nhia Vang:
-will do some research & would like the Appellants to also do some research
-she needs to know who owns what and who erected it
-will Lay this Over for 4 weeks to May 17, 2016 LH and come back with what we've
found
-asked that both parties have a survey done
-check with Amy Spong, Heritage Preservation Commission (HPC), PED; they may
have some documents because a retaining wall requires HPC review
Ms. Perron:
-has done some research and hasn't found anything
Mr. Khang: (Mai Vang interpreted)
-the fence is his neighbor's, not his
-if it's not on his property, he doesn't have to be paying the cost
-the wall is supporting his neighbor's soil
Ms. Nhia Vang:
-explained that a survey will be clear cut on both sides
-who built it; who owns it; why was it built
-find your pins; it will help
Man from Plum Street:
-it's his understanding that where the wall lies really isn't a determining factor; it's
what was the purpose of the wall; the purpose is for lateral support from Plum Street
to Hudson Road; Hudson is level for a while; basically, the soil was cut and that's why
the wall was needed
-cited Supreme Court decision 1885: a homeowner is entitled to the lateral support of
adjoining street
-the city could own that wall; the city could have built it
Ms. Perron:
-that should have been something that was disclosed at the time
Mr. Khang:
-re to the tree that was cut, he's the one who hired the tree to be cut; the broken
retaining wall is on the opposite side; he was present when the tree was cut
-doesn't have money to pay for a survey
Inspector Lisa Martin:
-sometimes neighbors will share the cost of a shared retaining wall (Ms. Seeley:
roughly costs about $300 for a survey)
-sometimes the city will issue a Summary Abatement Order to remove the wall and
the cost would be divided between/among the properties
-it's in each's best interest to get a survey to make sure that they can prove that it's
not their property so that they are not assessed
Ms. Perron:
-if the wall goes all the way along for the entire block, how can it be ours or his if it's
on everybody's property?
Ms. Martin:
City of Saint Paul Page 10
Legislative Hearings Minutes - Final April 19, 2016
-it's very similar to an alley situation; even though you don't own the alley, you are
responsible for part of the alley
Ms. Perron:
-if that wall were taken down, it would compromise almost the entire block
Ms. Nhia Vang:
-again, the survey is necessary; it will make things clear; we will know what
happened
Layover so Appellants can get a survey done.
Laid Over to the Legislative Hearings due back on 5/17/2016
19 RLH CO 16-13 Appeal of Cynthia M. Perron to a Correction Notice at 726 PLUM
STREET.
Sponsors: Prince
Shoua T. Khang, owner of 861 Hudson Road, appeared.
Cynthia M. Perron, tax owner of 726 Plum Street, appeared.
Inspector Paula Seeley:
-complaint came into office Apr 12, 2016 about a deteriorated retaining wall
-inspector went out and said that the retaining wall at the rear of the property was in
disrepair; remove/repair/replace; remove debris from crumbled retaining wall
immediately; work may require a permit and approval from Heritage Preservation
Commission (HPC)
-her understanding from building official Steve Ubl, is that the retaining wall belongs
to the property whose soil it is holding back
-this is a civil dispute; we don't usually get involved; we tell them that they need to get
their own survey or work it out together
-both parties received the same Order
Ms. Perron:
-did get the Correction Notice
-that retaining wall is not just between us; it goes down the whole block from one end
of the block down to the other end of the block
-we are on the hill; Plum Street goes up the hill; Hudson is a level street; that wall
was put up to give us lateral support
-when the city started to take down trees, they damaged the wall, too
-the wall is about 2 feet high and goes through 4 properties to Maple Street
Ms. Nhia Vang:
-will do some research & would like the Appellants to also do some research
-she needs to know who owns what and who erected it
-will Lay this Over for 4 weeks to May 17, 2016 LH and come back with what we've
found
-asked that both parties have a survey done
-check with Amy Spong, Heritage Preservation Commission (HPC), PED; they may
have some documents because a retaining wall requires HPC review
Ms. Perron:
-has done some research and hasn't found anything
Mr. Khang: (Mai Vang interpreted)
-the fence is his neighbor's, not his
City of Saint Paul Page 11
Legislative Hearings Minutes - Final April 19, 2016
-if it's not on his property, he doesn't have to be paying the cost
-the wall is supporting his neighbor's soil
Ms. Nhia Vang:
-explained that a survey will be clear cut on both sides
-who built it; who owns it; why was it built
-find your pins; it will help
Man from Plum Street:
-it's his understanding that where the wall lies really isn't a determining factor; it's
what was the purpose of the wall; the purpose is for lateral support from Plum Street
to Hudson Road; Hudson is level for a while; basically, the soil was cut and that's why
the wall was needed
-cited Supreme Court decision 1885: a homeowner is entitled to the lateral support of
adjoining street
-the city could own that wall; the city could have built it
Ms. Perron:
-that should have been something that was disclosed at the time
Mr. Khang:
-re to the tree that was cut, he's the one who hired the tree to be cut; the broken
retaining wall is on the opposite side; he was present when the tree was cut
-doesn't have money to pay for a survey
Inspector Lisa Martin:
-sometimes neighbors will share the cost of a shared retaining wall (Ms. Seeley:
roughly costs about $300 for a survey)
-sometimes the city will issue a Summary Abatement Order to remove the wall and
the cost would be divided between/among the properties
-it's in each's best interest to get a survey to make sure that they can prove that it's
not their property so that they are not assessed
Ms. Perron:
-if the wall goes all the way along for the entire block, how can it be ours or his if it's
on everybody's property?
Ms. Martin:
-it's very similar to an alley situation; even though you don't own the alley, you are
responsible for part of the alley
Ms. Perron:
-if that wall were taken down, it would compromise almost the entire block
Ms. Nhia Vang:
-again, the survey is necessary; it will make things clear; we will know what
happened
Layover so Appellants can get a survey done.
Laid Over to the Legislative Hearings due back on 5/17/2016
1:30 p.m. Hearings
Fire Certificates of Occupancy
City of Saint Paul Page 12
Legislative Hearings Minutes - Final April 19, 2016
20 RLH FCO 16-47 Appeal of Karl Benson, Cooks of Crocus Hill, to a Fire Inspection
Correction Notice at 877 GRAND AVENUE.
Sponsors: Noecker
Angie Wiese can meet with Appellant to go over the counter top ranges and kitchen
hood suppression system issues and give the hearing officer a staff report to make
her recommendation. If a hearing is necessary, it will be on May 17th at 1:30 p.m.
Laid Over to the Legislative Hearings due back on 5/17/2016
21 RLH FCO 16-52 Appeal of Jason MacDonald LLC to a Fire Certificate of Occupancy
Approval With Corrections at 565 ANNAPOLIS STREET EAST.
Sponsors: Noecker
Continued to June 7. Grant until May 17 to have the greenhouse demolished;
Inspector Niemeyer will keep the May 25 reinspection date. At that time, he will need
to inspect the interior of the garage/shed and gazebo for any signs of leakage, water
damage to trusses and how far away the dwellings are from public view.
Laid Over to the Legislative Hearings due back on 6/7/2016
22 RLH FCO 16-55 Appeal of Cornelius Brown to a Fire Inspection Correction Notice at
1694 EDMUND AVENUE.
Sponsors: Stark
Cornelius E. Brown Sr. appeared on behalf of owners Cornelius E. Brown Jr. and Gail
Koslowski.
Fire Inspector A.J. Neis:
-Fire Certificate of Occupancy Correction Notice issued by Inspector Laura Huseby
dated Mar 18,2 016
-appealed is the requirement for installing hard wired smoke detector that had already
been in place and since, been removed; Inspector Huseby cited that the hard wired
smoke detector must be re-installed appropriately
-the hard wired detector had been replaced with a battery operated detector (not
allowable by code)
Mr. Brown:
-he assumed that it would be OK for a battery detector but if that's not in accordance
with city code, we would like 2 weeks to allow time to install a hard wired smoke
detector
-we still have additional painting that needs to be done on the trim - just minor stuff
-he cleaned up all the trash
-the electrical will be taken care of this weekend
-he had a stroke; has high blood pressure
Mr. Neis:
-the inspector didn't expect the exterior work to be done until Jun 30, 2016
-just to be safe, May 30 deadline for interior work
Ms. Nhia Vang:
Grant an extension until May 30 to have everything in compliance with the exception
City of Saint Paul Page 13
Legislative Hearings Minutes - Final April 19, 2016
of the exterior item (painting of the trims) which is granted until June 30, 2016.
Referred to the City Council due back on 5/18/2016
23 RLH FCO 16-46 Appeal of Steven Thorson, attorney for Patricia J. Jordan, Chief
Manager, to a Correction Notice-Complaint Inspection at 2446
UNIVERSITY AVENUE WEST.
Sponsors: Stark
An occupancy load signed affidavit and plan for compliance has been submitted to
Fire inspector and has been approved; therefore, the referral is closed and there is
no issue anymore. Appeal withdrawn.
Withdrawn
2:30 p.m. Hearings
Vacant Building Registrations (NONE)
City of Saint Paul Page 14
Agenda
15 West Kellogg Blvd.
City of Saint Paul Saint Paul, MN 55102
Meeting Agenda - Final-revised
Legislative Hearings
Marcia Moermond, Legislative Hearing Officer
Mai Vang, Hearing Coordinator
Jean Birkholz, Hearing Secretary
legislativehearings@ci.stpaul.mn.us
651-266-8585
Tuesday, April 19, 2016 9:00 AM Room 330 City Hall & Court House
9:00 a.m. Hearings
Remove/Repair Orders
1 RLH TA Ratifying the Appealed Special Tax Assessment for Property at 201
16-187 SNELLING AVENUE NORTH (File No. VB1608, Assessment No.
168808).
Sponsors: Stark
2 RLH TA Ratifying the Appealed Special Tax Assessment for Property at 1294
16-193 BOHLAND PLACE (File No. J1608E, Assessment No. 168309).
Sponsors: Tolbert
Attachments: 1294 Bohland Pl.Correction Notice.7-8-15
1294 Bohland P.EC Ltr.11-30-15
1294 Bohland Pl.Photo.10-6-15
3 RLH TA Ratifying the Appealed Special Tax Assessment for Property at 1231
16-174 FARRINGTON STREET (File No. J1608A, Assessment No. 168517).
Sponsors: Brendmoen
Attachments: 1231 Farrington St.SA 1-22-16
1231 Farrington St.Photo 1-27-16
4 RLH TA Ratifying the Appealed Special Tax Assessment for Property at 907
16-179 FIFTH STREET EAST (File No. J1608A, Assessment No. 168517).
Sponsors: Prince
Attachments: 907 Fifth St E.Summary Abatement Order.1-21-16
907 Fifth St E.Photos.1-26-16
5 RLH TA Ratifying the Appealed Special Tax Assessment for Property at 675
16-200 HALL AVENUE (File No. J1608A, Assessment No. 168517).
Sponsors: Noecker
Attachments: 675 Hall Ave.Snow Walk Letter.1-6-16
City of Saint Paul Page 1 Printed on 4/18/2016
Legislative Hearings Meeting Agenda - Final-revised April 19, 2016
6 RLH TA Ratifying the Appealed Special Tax Assessment for Property at 985
16-204 JENKS AVENUE (File No. CRT1608, Assessment No. 168208).
Sponsors: Bostrom
Attachments: 985 Jenks Ave.Fee invoice.11-18-15
985 Jenks Ave.Final invoice.12-18-15
7 RLH TA Ratifying the Appealed Special Tax Assessment for Property at 716
16-198 MAGNOLIA AVENUE EAST (File No. CRT1608, Assessment No.
168208).
Sponsors: Bostrom
Attachments: 716 Magnolia Ave E.Fee Invoice.11-23-15
716 Magnolia Ave E.Final Invoice.12-23-15
8 RLH TA Ratifying the Appealed Special Tax Assessment for Property at 23
16-194 TENTH STREET WEST (File No. CRT1607, Assessment No. 168206).
Sponsors: Noecker
Attachments: 538 St Peter St.Fee invoice.10-19-15
538 St Peter St.Final invoice.11-18-15
9 RLH TA Ratifying the Appealed Special Tax Assessment for Property at 1169
16-197 UNIVERSITY AVENUE WEST (File No. J1605A2, Assessment No.
168524).
Sponsors: Stark
Attachments: 1169 University Ave W.SA 10-1-15
1169 University Ave W.Photos 10-1-15
1169 Univ Av W.Graffiti Waiver 9-28-15
10 RLH TA Ratifying the Appealed Special Tax Assessment for Property at 76
16-199 WHEELOCK PARKWAY EAST (File No. J1608E, Assessment No.
168309).
Sponsors: Brendmoen
Attachments: 76 Wheelock Pkwy E.Vehicle Abatement Order.12-2-15
76 Wheelock Pkwy E.SAO Ltr #2.12-2-16
76 Wheelock Pkwy E.Photos.12-2-15
76 Wheelock Pkwy E.Photos.12-11-15
76 Wheelock Pkwy E.EC Letter.12-11-15
Special Tax Assessments - ROLLS
11 RLH AR Ratifying Property Clean Up service on October 8, 2015 at 1169
16-25 UNIVERSITY AVENUE WEST (File No. J1605A2, Assessment No.
168524).
Sponsors: Stark
Attachments: Assessment Roll
City of Saint Paul Page 2 Printed on 4/18/2016
Legislative Hearings Meeting Agenda - Final-revised April 19, 2016
12 RLH AR Ratifying Collection of Fire Certificate of Occupancy fees billed during
16-26 November 10 to December 11, 2015. (File No. CRT1608, Assessment
No. 168208)
Sponsors: Stark
Attachments: Assessment Roll
13 RLH AR Ratifying Graffiti Removal service during January 21 to February 2,
16-27 2016. (File No. J1608P, Assessment No. 168407)
Sponsors: Stark
Attachments: Assessment Roll
14 RLH AR Ratifying Tree Removal services from January 2016. (File No. 1604T,
16-28 Assessment No. 169003)
Sponsors: Stark
Attachments: Assessment Roll
11:00 a.m. Hearings
Summary Abatement Orders
15 RLH SAO Appeal of Tylon Newcomb to a Vehicle Abatement Order at 488
16-12 ROBERT STREET SOUTH.
Sponsors: Noecker
Attachments: 488 Robert Street S.appeal.04-14-16
Correction Orders
16 RLH CO Appeal of Gene Marault to a Correction Notice at 937 CHARLES
16-12 AVENUE.
Sponsors: Thao
Attachments: 937 Charles Ave.appeal.04-13-16
937 Charles Ave.Photos.3-7-16
17 RLH CO Appeal of Jenneh Matthews to a Correction Notice at 1036
16-11 MINNEHAHA AVENUE WEST.
Sponsors: Thao
Attachments: 1036 Minnehaha Ave W.appeal.04-11-16
1036 Minnehaha Ave W.Photo.3-24-16
18 RLH CO Appeal of Shoua T. Khang to a Correction Notice at 861 HUDSON
16-16 ROAD.
Sponsors: Prince
Attachments: 861 Hudson Rd.appeal.04-18-16
726 Plum St-861 Hudson Rd.Photos.3-18-16
City of Saint Paul Page 3 Printed on 4/18/2016
Legislative Hearings Meeting Agenda - Final-revised April 19, 2016
19 RLH CO Appeal of Cynthia M. Perron to a Correction Notice at 726 PLUM
16-13 STREET.
Sponsors: Prince
Attachments: 726 Plum Street.appeal.04-13-16
726 Plum St.Photos.3-18-16
1:30 p.m. Hearings
Fire Certificates of Occupancy
20 RLH FCO Appeal of Karl Benson, Cooks of Crocus Hill, to a Fire Inspection
16-47 Correction Notice at 877 GRAND AVENUE.
Sponsors: Noecker
Attachments: 877 Grand Ave.appeal.3-16-16
877 Grand Ave.Photos.3-10-16
877 Grand Ave.Benson Ltr.4-7-16
21 RLH FCO Appeal of Jason MacDonald LLC to a Fire Certificate of Occupancy
16-52 Approval With Corrections at 565 ANNAPOLIS STREET EAST.
Sponsors: Noecker
Attachments: 565 Annapolis St E.appeal.4-8-16
565 Annapolis St E.Photos.4-8-16
22 RLH FCO Appeal of Cornelius Brown to a Fire Inspection Correction Notice at
16-55 1694 EDMUND AVENUE.
Sponsors: Stark
Attachments: 1694 Edmund Avenue.appeal.04-14-16
23 RLH FCO Appeal of Steven Thorson, attorney for Patricia J. Jordan, Chief
16-46 Manager, to a Correction Notice-Complaint Inspection at 2446
UNIVERSITY AVENUE WEST.
Sponsors: Stark
Attachments: 2446 University Ave W.appeal.3-16-16
2446 University Ave W.Photos.3-16-16
2446 University Ave W.Eviction Summons.4-5-16
2446 University Ave W.Thorson Ltr.4-7-16
2446 University Ave W.chain emails.4-7-16
2446 University Ave W.signed Affidavit.4-8-16
2:30 p.m. Hearings
Vacant Building Registrations (NONE)
City of Saint Paul Page 4 Printed on 4/18/2016