Muyni
← Back to Wichita

District 6 Advisory Board

Regular Meeting

Wichita, KS · June 17, 2020

AgendaMinutes

Minutes

District 6 Advisory Board Minutes Wednesday, June 17, 2020 • 6:30 p.m. Virtual Meeting • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • Order of Business The District 6 Advisory Board meeting was held online at 6:30 p.m. via the GoToMeeting platform. Council Member Cindy Claycomb, eight DAB members, two City staff, and six members of the public were present. Members Present Staff Present Linda Matney Philip Zevenbergen, Associate Planner, Sergio Devora-Najera Metropolitan Area Planning Department Melinda Kellogg Scott Lucas Ana Lopez, Community Services Bill Washburn Representative, City Manager’s Office James Deckard Angela Martinez Greg Boyajian Alayna Welch (Youth) Members Absent Bill Longnecker Gisela Pena Shaun Rojas • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • Public Agenda 1. Scheduled Items There are no scheduled Public Agenda items this month. 2. Off-Agenda Items Any individual present that did not request to speak on the Public Agenda prior to the meeting may speak at this time. Action Taken: Received and filed. • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • New Business DAB 6 • June 17, 2020 • Minutes • Page 1 3. ZON2020-00015 and CUP2020-00017 Philip Zevenbergen, Associate Planner, Metropolitan Area Planning Department will present an application on behalf of South Harbor, LLC / Harbor Properties, LLC (Applicant) / Baughman Company c/o Russ Ewy (agent) for a rezone request from SF-5 Single Family Residential, SF-20 Single Family Residential, and MF-18 Multi-Family Residential with CUP DP-94 to LC Limited Commercial, and CUP DP-355: Harbor Isle Commercial 1 Community Unit Plan. (North of I-235 and on the east of North Meridian Avenue) The Metropolitan Area Planning Commission public hearing for this item will be on June 18, 2020. ZON2020-00015 and CUP2020-00017 Staff Report: https://www.wichita.gov/Council/DABAgendasMinutes/2020-06-17%20DAB%206%20ZON2020- 00015%20and%20CUP2020-00017%20Staff%20Report.pdf Recommended Action: Based upon the information available at the time the staff report was prepared it is recommended that the request for GC General Commercial be APPROVED, subject to the following conditions: 1. The Development Guidelines shall be modified to read in accordance with the attached recommendation. 2. The site shall be developed in substantial conformance with the revised development guidelines and general provisions of the approved CUP. 3. The applicant shall record a CUP certificate with the Register of Deeds indicating that this tract (referenced as DP-355: Harbor Isle Commercial 1 Community Unit Plan has special conditions for development on the property. A copy of the recorded certificate along with four copies of the approved CUP shall be submitted to the Metropolitan Area Planning Department within 60 days of final approval to the Metropolitan Area Planning Department or the amendment shall be deemed null and void. The DAB heard the request so that adjacent property owners and Wichita residents had an opportunity to express their concerns. After the presentation by Associate Planner, Philip Zevenbergen, the following questions were asked by DAB VI Board Members: Bill Washburn, Sherwood Glen is a neighborhood that has a tremendous amount of interest and concern over drainage into that Woodward Creek because of a history of flooding in that area prior to the big pump station. I would like to fully understand what the planning process is when drainage gets addressed. How would residents get involved, and get more information during the process? Zevenbergen, I can take down contact information and send it to Neil Strahl who works with subdivision through the plots that come in to Planning Department. Anybody who is interested can get notified when the, plat comes in for review. Washburn, has there been any concerns from neighbors in Harbor Isle? Zevenbergen, no, the only concerns that we have received, are those neighbors to the south of the highway. Brad Bachman, the neighbor’s form Moorings and Harbor Isle have a very positive reaction, and are excited about having development in the area. DAB 6 • June 17, 2020 • Minutes • Page 2 Zevenbergen, between the residential development and this commercial development there will be a large pond. Gregory Boyajian, is there a particular item from that, which will be used in the area that's going to be plotted? Zevenbergen, General Commercial. The agent for the applicant might be able to address that question. Russ Ewy, Baughman Company, we felt like that although it's a separate developer that particular property, most likely would have more of your retail orientation. Looking at the general Commercial zoning district will provide the ability to do more office warehouse, self-storage, contractor sales and service. Those uses that are heavier commercial type and have less of a retail, less of a traffic impact backed up in that neighborhood where visibility from the highways isn't necessary. Most of the zoning cases that we've had over the years dealt with the constraint of the Seneca Street Bridge. Now that KDOT has opened up that access point, all the uses that we have talked about over the last 20 years become available and more practical for this property. A lot of developers, especially the near term development most likely will surface drain into the lake. The water doesn't go south, it goes to the north-east, towards the riverbed. Scott Lucas, are there any traffic constrains? Ewy, the peak hours of the development is not going to line up with the more intensive truck traffic. So oftentimes we see that phased approach to traffic. We have plenty of capacity on meridian, almost an ideal location for traffic capacity. Council Member Claycomb asked if there are further questions or comments from the board. None. Questions or comments from the audience. None. Action Taken: James Deckard made a motion to APPROVE staff’s recommendation. The motion was seconded by William Washburn. MOTION PASSED 8-0 4. ZON2020-00016 Philip Zevenbergen, Associate Planner, Metropolitan Area Planning Department will present an application on behalf of Progressive Opportunities, LLC (Owner) and Abbott Land Survey, Chad Abbott (Agent) for a rezone request from SF-5 Single Family Residential (SF-5) to TF-3 Two Family Residential (TF-3), generally located west of Zoo Boulevard and north of West Central Avenue in the 700 Block of Kessler Street (792 N. Kessler Street) The Metropolitan Area Planning Commission public hearing for this item will be on June 18, 2020. ZON2020-00016 Staff Report: https://www.wichita.gov/Council/DABAgendasMinutes/2020-06- 17%20DAB%206%20ZON2020-00016%20Staff%20Report.pdf Recommended Action: Based upon the information available at the time the staff report was completed, staff recommends APPROVAL of the request, with a Protective Overlay #350 as follows: 1. The following conditions shall apply to ZON2020-00016: a. Garages. The garage face shall occupy no more than 50 percent of the ground-level façade facing the street and may not project more than five feet in front of the main facade. b. Corner lot Duplexes. Duplexes located on corner lots shall place pedestrian entries on opposite street frontages so that the structure appears to be a single-family dwelling. DAB 6 • June 17, 2020 • Minutes • Page 3 c. Entrances. Pedestrian scaled entry shall be a prominent feature of the front elevation. Front doors shall be oriented to the street in front of the units. d. Architectural Variety. Developments shall achieve architectural variety by accommodating a variety of architectural styles that are compatible or consistent with the surrounding neighborhood, variation of the same architectural style, and through the use of multiple design elements. Duplicative house designs adjacent to each other are highly discouraged. Simple reverse configurations of the same house design on adjacent lots are not sufficient to meet this standard. e. Windows and Transparency. Transparent windows and/or doors facing the street are required. To meet this requirement, at least 10 percent of the façade must be transparent. The façade is measured from the base of the house to the start of the roofline and any other vertical walls facing the street, except for gabled portions of the facade not containing livable floor area. Garages facing the street shall count as part of the façade. f. Roof Design. Roofs shall have variation in roof planes in order to break up the large roof mass through dormers, gables, or changes in elevation. Roof forms and roof pitches of porches, dormers and garages shall be consistent and complement the building style within the neighborhood. g. Siding materials. Siding materials shall be appropriate to the architectural style of the structure. Traditional materials consistent with the neighborhood architectural styles are encouraged such as wood, masonry and brick. Siding materials and window trim should be consistent on all sides of the structures. h. HVAC. HVAC units shall be located away from the front of the buildings and screened from public view through landscaping and/or screen walls. 2. The parking area shall not cover more than 50% of the front yard and trash dumpsters shall not be permitted in front of the duplex building. 3. A site plan shall be approved by the Director of Planning before any building permits are issued. 4. Prior to publishing the ordinance establishing the zone change, the applicants shall record a document with the Register of Deeds indicating that this tract includes special conditions for development on this property. The DAB heard the request so that adjacent property owners and Wichita residents had an opportunity to express their concerns. After the presentation by Associate Planner, Philip Zevenbergen, the following questions were asked by DAB VI Board Members: Bill Washburn, I'm assuming concerns from residents in that neighborhood is because staff is recommending approval. Zevenbergen, we take into consideration neighborhood opposition, but we also have to take into consideration the other golden factors of planning. Other things that we look at are the guiding documents we have, which are the Comprehensive Plan that indicate this area is no good for residential development. The Places for People plan is the Planning Department infill strategy and we want to make sure that that building looks, and it has the feel of the residential neighbor router. Gregory Boyajian, as that relates to the neighborhood, how does planning department go through what the characteristics of duplex is going to look like. Zevenbergen, a new site plan that conforms to the protected overlay, Boyajian, how does anyone that has opposition can ask questions about this, how do they know what's going to be built? DAB 6 • June 17, 2020 • Minutes • Page 4 Zevenbergen, they can get in touch with planning staff. Through this public hearing process, we can retain their contact information and anything that we receive from as part of the file becomes available to the public. Boyajian, does the Board have any input with respect to Places for People. Council Member Claycomb, DAB can make any additional recommendations, that then would be forwarded to the Planning Commission and then onto City Council. Ana Lopez, CSR presented a letter in opposition with comments regarding the change from single-family residential to a two-story two-family duplex from Melissa Armstrong and Damon Puetz that reside at 789 N. Kessler, Wichita, KS 67203 Zevenbergen, the way the protective overlay is written is that the conditions apply that a garage cannot be more than 50% of the facade. The Places for People Plan went through and assessed, what is a visually appealing residential dwelling unit related to duplexes to come up with guidelines so that it fits a standard looking house and kind of an older part of the neighborhood would look like. Boyajian, just because this is written down it does not mean, from my experience in one case on 9th street that it will be help. 70% of the houses in the neighborhood are probably brick. Will the duplexes have brick facade upfront? Council Member Claycomb, DAB could add that to the motion. Keeping in mind that DAB does not have final say and MAPC or City Council could vote some other way. Boyajian, what we're being presented today are guidelines. Zevenbergen, unless the Planning Commission were to change them, then they will hold as rule, and not as a guideline. Scott Lucas, the staff report say that they must meet architectural variety, how do you really do that when everything's single level? Zevenbergen, the architectural variety talks about tying into the character of how do those buildings look and having similar or same treatments to the building that the applicant will be constructing. Lucas, we have a design that shows actual parking, parking spots on premises but then there's a concern of parking on the street. Zevenbergen, the developer will have to meet off street parking requirements for duplex. Council Member Claycomb, typically during in person meetings, DAB members would have a copy of the Golden rules. Neighborhood opposition is only one of those golden rules, and it cannot stand on its own. Zevenbergen, there are six of them that we cover in the staff report. Explains the golden rules. Linda Matney, how much of a rush is there to get this done? We’re voting on what we think the documentation is going to say, but it makes me a little bit nervous that we don't have current documentation. Boyajian, when this goes before the Metropolitan Area Planning Commission, will an updated site plan, be presented? Zevenbergen, it is required before any building permit could be issued, they have to update the parking area to make sure it's not 50% of the front area. DAB 6 • June 17, 2020 • Minutes • Page 5 Melinda Kellogg, could we add a stipulation that it cannot be two story? Boyajian, the two story was documented in the public notice that went out to the residents and anybody who's part of local neighborhood association. Council Member Claycomb, is the applicant proposing a two story structure? Zevenbergen, yes. Washburn, is there an interest in DAB members of putting in restriction that it cannot be a two story duplex? Boyajian, I don't think it's out of place. It will still be up to the MAPC to come back and say what is appropriate for the applicant, or what they are willing to accept from the applicant. Action Taken: made a motion to APPROVE staff’s recommendation with the condition that the duplexes are single story. The motion was seconded by Kellogg. MOTION PASSED 7-1 5. ZON2020-00018 Philip Zevenbergen, Associate Planner, Metropolitan Area Planning Department will present an application on behalf of Dianne K. Bolain; Luke Robert/Dingers Roofing and Construction (Applicants) and Mark A. Savoy (Agent) for a rezone request from SF-5 Single Family Residential to LC Limited Commercial in order to redevelop the existing building for limited commercial uses. The site is generally located one quarter-mile south of West 53rd Street North on the east side of North Meridian Avenue and is addressed 5130 North Meridian Avenue. The Metropolitan Area Planning Commission public hearing for this item will be on June 18, 2020. ZON2020-00018 Staff Report: https://www.wichita.gov/Council/DABAgendasMinutes/2020-06- 17%20DAB%206%20ZON2020-00018%20Staff%20Report.pdf Recommended Action: Based upon the information available at the time the staff report was prepared it is recommended that the request for LC Limited Commercial zoning be APPROVED. The DAB heard the request so that adjacent property owners and Wichita residents had an opportunity to express their concerns. After the presentation by Associate Planner, Philip Zevenbergen, the following questions were asked by DAB VI Board Members: Bill Washburn, this site is completely surrounded by property that is zoned residential, and it's a fairly high value property already, in existence and in development. It doesn't make sense to me to approve a commercial property and part of that just because the current owner has a desire to sell the property. Zevenbergen, something to note, when it comes to rezoning a subject property that is surrounded by residential is that there is buffering and screening requirements that will in place and upheld. For example at least a 6 to 8 foot wood, or wood fence or masonry wall, In addition to a 15 foot screening buffer with vegetation. Brad Bachman, I’m speaking as the owner of the property that wraps around this site on all sides, except Meridian. This property is in pretty easy view of the houses at the North End of Harbor Isle, second edition. I'm very familiar with the property, both the subject property here, as well as the area around it, and I disagree with the staff comments as to the screening property that the tree lines along the north South East DAB 6 • June 17, 2020 • Minutes • Page 6 property lines appear to meet the credit standards? The tree lines that staff considers to be adequate for landscaping screening standards are basically kind of adjacent to this property. The East side of the property is currently screened by deciduous trees, which, again, appear to be on my property rather than his. During late spring through fall, we have tree cover. Generally during the winter seasons to late fall, we don't have any cover. My understanding would be that the screening shouldn't be on the property that is making the application to go between LLC and residential, is that correct? Zevenbergen, that is actually not correct. Existing vegetation, whether it's on the applicant's property or below it can be used. The difference being that if those trees were to die or be pulled out then they would have to go back and put trees in on their property. A note about screening, the requirement is just a six foot fence or wall. The landscaping is just a landscape buffer with a one tree every 40 feet. It doesn't have to be evergreen, and it can be a shade tree or two ornamental trees. Screening requirements by the code is a 6 to 8 foot made of wood or masonry, or some other approved material that is in the zoning code. In addition to that, they have to plant a minimum of once every 40 feet along the property line. Bachman, if the trees are removed or they die than the replanting would be on the applicant's property? Zevenbergen, correct, and they are required to maintain. Brad Bachman, the property is also very visible with any lighting requirements. I know that they were saying that no post higher than 15 feet within 200 feet of the property line, and that all lighting will be faced down so it's not visible from the residential areas. Zevenbergen, that is correct. That's the standard out of the zoning code. Bachman, I do have some concern about the various LC uses being noise and with residential properties right beside it. I believe it would be reasonable to impose some kind of hours, say six AM to 8 PM, so that there's not noise late into the night that would impact the residential property around. How would someone do that? Council Member Claycomb, I’ve seen cases like that before where there are hours imposed. Zevenbergen, they are used for event type base uses that go later into the night. When you think of a retail store it is typically from 9:00 am to 10:00 pm. There could be stipulations related to hours that trash can be picked up. Gregory Boyajian, these are some uses that may have some controversy; entertainment or establishment within the city limits nightclubs in the city, nightclub in the country, pawnshop, personal employment services, tavern drinking and drinking establishments, vehicle repair, sexual oriented business, animal care, banking, financial institutions are all permitted within limited commercial without restrictions. Council Member Claycomb, would anybody else in the audience that wants to speak on this? Mark Savoy, applicant or agent for the applicant. Mr. Bachman owns the property across the street zoned LC. Those items that could be allowed in LC are actually recommended as a protective overlay to avoid having those types of uses there. The existing building is 7700 square feet and the gentleman that wants to buy has a roofing business. The use for the property would be for his business, primarily. They do not have a lot of traffic in this property. The access to the property is limited to one driveway right in the center of the property and properly controlled by access control. There's not going to be any more driveways. They are very interested in buying this property for a light commercial use for their business. I'd be glad to answer any other questions. Council Member Claycomb, any questions for the applicant? None. If I read this right, the staff report list uses that could not be used. Reads a list of uses under recommendation, number one. DAB 6 • June 17, 2020 • Minutes • Page 7 Zevenbergen, that is correct. Council Member Claycomb, let me bring it back to the board, additional questions, comments or a motion. Action Taken: Gregory Boyajian made a motion to APPROVE staff’s recommendation. The motion was seconded by Linda Matney. MOTION PASSED 6-2 6. ZON2020-00019 Philip Zevenbergen, Associate Planner, Metropolitan Area Planning Department will present an application on behalf of R&R Realty, Jay Russell (owner) and Baughman Company, P.A. Philip Meyer (Agent) for a rezone request from SF-5 Single-Family Residential to TF-3 Two-Family Residential. Generally located approximately one-half mile north of West 53rd Street North on the west side of North Meridian Avenue (W. 5735 N. Meridian) The Metropolitan Area Planning Commission public hearing for this item will be on June 18, 2020. ZON2020-00019 Staff Report: https://www.wichita.gov/Council/DABAgendasMinutes/2020-06- 17%20DAB%206%20ZON2020-00019%20Staff%20Report.pdf Recommended Action: Based upon the information available at the time the staff report was completed, staff recommends APPROVAL of the request, as submitted. The DAB heard the request so that adjacent property owners and Wichita residents had an opportunity to express their concerns. After the presentation by Associate Planner, Philip Zevenbergen, the following questions were asked by DAB VI Board Members: Scott Lucas, as far as actual construction, the only thing that's actually there is the TF-3 to the south? Zevenbergen, correct to the south and south-west. Action Taken: Scott Lucas made a motion to APPROVE staff’s recommendation. The motion was seconded by James Deckard. MOTION PASSED 7-0 7. ZON2020-00021 and CUP2020-00019 Philip Zevenbergen, Associate Planner, Metropolitan Area Planning Department will present an application on behalf of Broadmoor One, LLC (Applicant) and Baughman Company (Agent) for an amendment request of Womer Plaza Shopping Center (DP-29) and zone change from SF-5 Single Family Residential to LC Limited Commercial, generally located on the west side of North Womer Street and south of West 37th Street North. The Metropolitan Area Planning Commission public hearing for this item will be on June 18, 2020. ZON2020-00021 and CUP2020-00019 Staff Report: https://www.wichita.gov/Council/DABAgendasMinutes/2020-06-17%20DAB%206%20ZON2020- 00021%20and%20CUP2020-00019%20Staff%20Report.pdf DAB 6 • June 17, 2020 • Minutes • Page 8 Recommended Action: Based upon the information available at the time the staff report was prepared it is recommended that the request be APPROVED, subject to the following conditions: 1. The CUP drawing shall be revised to include the details of this amendment. General Provision 13 shall be amended to state the following: 13. The number of buildings shall not exceed twelve. 2. The site shall be developed in substantial conformance with the revised provisions of the approved CUP. 3. The applicant shall submit four copies of the amended and approved CUP within 60 days of final approval to the Metropolitan Area Planning Department or the amendment shall be deemed null and void. The DAB heard the request so that adjacent property owners and Wichita residents had an opportunity to express their concerns. After the presentation by Associate Planner, Philip Zevenbergen, the following questions were asked by DAB VI Board Members: Bill Washburn, what type of screening or separation will be required If this is approved? Russ Ewy, Agent for the applicant, a solid Missouri screening wall at the property line, so it'll have a combination of landscape landscaping but it you will see the six foot, 6 to 8 foot tall, standard screening, masonry screening wall, not just a fence. Washburn, will the undeveloped block be the drainage/collection pond? Ewy, Yes, and it will go into the to the regional storm water drainage system to the south-east. Washburn, the maximum number of buildings in the development area would be 12? Ewy, correct. Washburn, will all of the provisions in the old CUP transfer over and be applicable to the new property? Ewy, yes, we are simply expanding it and everything form the old CUP Community Unit Plan will apply to this parcel as well. Bill Washburn, are there any concerns from property owners nearby? Zevenbergen, only from one resident. Council Member Claycomb asked if there are further questions or comments from the board. None. Questions or comments from the audience. None. Action Taken: William Washburn made a motion to APPROVE staff’s recommendation. The motion was seconded by James Deckard. MOTION PASSED 7-1 • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • Board Agenda 8. Updates, Issues, and Reports DAB 6 • June 17, 2020 • Minutes • Page 9 Reports from Council Member Cindy Claycomb and the DAB on any activities, events, resources, issues, or concerns in the neighborhoods, council district, and/or city. Angela Martinez, we'll be having a voter registration rally on July 27th at Woodland Park from 4:00 pm to 7:00 pm. We're going to have performances A few cultural performances, The Wichita League of Women Voters will be there to do the registration. Mask and social distancing will be encouraged. Sergio Devora-Najera, will help promote the event on the radio. Council Member Cindy Claycomb, Amelia Earhart's neighborhood have been advocating for a sidewalk along Arkansas Avenue that leads to the Amelia Earhart School. City Council voted this week to put that sidewalk in from 41st street to 46th street. Ana and I met with some neighborhoods neighbors in North Riverside to talk about South Woodland Park. There were some suggestions for some changes to be made to that park, and the neighborhood would like to be a little bit more involved. Parks department has agreed to put together a small group of neighbors and community policing and look at some changes there. We’re also looking at adding some additional shade structures at Nomar Plaza. The virtual District 6 Coffee is coming up on June 20, 2020. We’ll have MABCD Director Chris Labrum and staff that can answer questions about neighborhood issues, environmental court and how those are addressed. Ana Lopez, CSR District 6, Neighborhood Night Out was tentatively moved to the first week in October. We have a quick survey that will let us know how resident feel about attending this event. Please take a few minutes to complete this survey and forward it to friends and neighbors. Recommended Action: Receive and file. • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • Adjournment The meeting was adjourned at 8:29 p.m. The next District 6 Advisory Board meeting will be held at 6:30 p.m., Monday, July 6, 2020 virtually. • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • Respectfully submitted, Ana Lopez, Community Services Representative, District 6 DAB 6 • June 17, 2020 • Minutes • Page 10

Agenda

District 6 Advisory Board Agenda Wednesday, June 17, 2020 • 6:30 p.m. (CDT) Online Instructions for viewing and giving comments Please join my meeting from your computer, tablet or smartphone. https://www.gotomeet.me/AnaLopez3/district-6-advisory-board---midmonth-meeting You can also dial in using your phone. (For supported devices, tap a one-touch number below to join instantly.) United States: +1 (786) 535-3211 Access Code: 257-656-557  It is advisable to have your microphone on “mute” to keep out background noises, until you wish to speak.  Should you wish to speak on an agenda item, send your request through the “chat” option (balloon quip) located at the top right of your screen. You will be called on when it is your turn.  All votes will be taken by stating “Aye” or “Nay”. • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • Order of Business  Call to Order • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • Public Agenda This portion of the agenda provides an opportunity for citizens to present issues that are not part of the regular agenda for the meeting. There is a five minute time limit for each speaker. 1. Scheduled Items There are no scheduled Public Agenda items this month. DAB 6 • June 17, 2020 • Agenda • Page 1 2. Off-Agenda Items Any individual present that did not request to speak on the Public Agenda prior to the meeting may speak at this time. Recommended Action: Receive and file. New Business 3. ZON2020-00015 and CUP2020-00017 Philip Zevenbergen, Associate Planner, Metropolitan Area Planning Department will present an application on behalf of South Harbor, LLC / Harbor Properties, LLC (Applicant) / Baughman Company c/o Russ Ewy (agent) for a rezone request from SF-5 Single Family Residential, SF-20 Single Family Residential, and MF-18 Multi-Family Residential with CUP DP- 94 to LC Limited Commercial, and CUP DP-355: Harbor Isle Commercial 1 Community Unit Plan. (North of I-235 and on the east of North Meridian Avenue) The Metropolitan Area Planning Commission public hearing for this item will be on June 18, 2020. ZON2020-00015 and CUP2020-00017 Staff Report: https://www.wichita.gov/Council/DABAgendasMinutes/2020-06-17%20DAB%206%20ZON2020- 00015%20and%20CUP2020-00017%20Staff%20Report.pdf Recommended Action: Based upon the information available at the time the staff report was prepared it is recommended that the request for GC General Commercial be APPROVED, subject to the following conditions: 1. The Development Guidelines shall be modified to read in accordance with the attached recommendation. 2. The site shall be developed in substantial conformance with the revised development guidelines and general provisions of the approved CUP. 3. The applicant shall record a CUP certificate with the Register of Deeds indicating that this tract (referenced as DP-355: Harbor Isle Commercial 1 Community Unit Plan has special conditions for development on the property. A copy of the recorded certificate along with four copies of the approved CUP shall be submitted to the Metropolitan Area Planning Department within 60 days of final approval to the Metropolitan Area Planning Department or the amendment shall be deemed null and void. 4. ZON2020-00016 Philip Zevenbergen, Associate Planner, Metropolitan Area Planning Department will present an application on behalf of Progressive Opportunities, LLC (Owner) and Abbott Land Survey, Chad Abbott (Agent) for a rezone request from SF-5 Single Family Residential (SF-5) to TF-3 Two Family Residential (TF-3), generally located west of Zoo Boulevard and north of West Central Avenue in the 700 Block of Kessler Street (792 N. Kessler Street) DAB 6 • June 17, 2020 • Agenda • Page 2 The Metropolitan Area Planning Commission public hearing for this item will be on June 18, 2020. ZON2020-00016 Staff Report: https://www.wichita.gov/Council/DABAgendasMinutes/2020-06- 17%20DAB%206%20ZON2020-00016%20Staff%20Report.pdf Recommended Action: Based upon the information available at the time the staff report was completed, staff recommends APPROVAL of the request, with a Protective Overlay #350 as follows: 1. The following conditions shall apply to ZON2020-00016: a. Garages. The garage face shall occupy no more than 50 percent of the ground- level façade facing the street and may not project more than five feet in front of the main facade. b. Corner lot Duplexes. Duplexes located on corner lots shall place pedestrian entries on opposite street frontages so that the structure appears to be a single- family dwelling. c. Entrances. Pedestrian scaled entry shall be a prominent feature of the front elevation. Front doors shall be oriented to the street in front of the units. d. Architectural Variety. Developments shall achieve architectural variety by accommodating a variety of architectural styles that are compatible or consistent with the surrounding neighborhood, variation of the same architectural style, and through the use of multiple design elements. Duplicative house designs adjacent to each other are highly discouraged. Simple reverse configurations of the same house design on adjacent lots are not sufficient to meet this standard. e. Windows and Transparency. Transparent windows and/or doors facing the street are required. To meet this requirement, at least 10 percent of the façade must be transparent. The façade is measured from the base of the house to the start of the roofline and any other vertical walls facing the street, except for gabled portions of the facade not containing livable floor area. Garages facing the street shall count as part of the façade. f. Roof Design. Roofs shall have variation in roof planes in order to break up the large roof mass through dormers, gables, or changes in elevation. Roof forms and roof pitches of porches, dormers and garages shall be consistent and complement the building style within the neighborhood. g. Siding materials. Siding materials shall be appropriate to the architectural style of the structure. Traditional materials consistent with the neighborhood architectural styles are encouraged such as wood, masonry and brick. Siding materials and window trim should be consistent on all sides of the structures. h. HVAC. HVAC units shall be located away from the front of the buildings and screened from public view through landscaping and/or screen walls. 2. The parking area shall not cover more than 50% of the front yard and trash dumpsters shall not be permitted in front of the duplex building. 3. A site plan shall be approved by the Director of Planning before any building permits are issued. 4. Prior to publishing the ordinance establishing the zone change, the applicants shall record a document with the Register of Deeds indicating that this tract includes special conditions for development on this property. DAB 6 • June 17, 2020 • Agenda • Page 3 5. ZON2020-00018 Philip Zevenbergen, Associate Planner, Metropolitan Area Planning Department will present an application on behalf of Dianne K. Bolain; Luke Robert/Dingers Roofing and Construction (Applicants) and Mark A. Savoy (Agent) for a rezone request from SF-5 Single Family Residential to LC Limited Commercial in order to redevelop the existing building for limited commercial uses. The site is generally located one quarter-mile south of West 53rd Street North on the east side of North Meridian Avenue and is addressed 5130 North Meridian Avenue. The Metropolitan Area Planning Commission public hearing for this item will be on June 18, 2020. ZON2020-00018 Staff Report: https://www.wichita.gov/Council/DABAgendasMinutes/2020-06- 17%20DAB%206%20ZON2020-00018%20Staff%20Report.pdf Recommended Action: Based upon the information available at the time the staff report was prepared it is recommended that the request for LC Limited Commercial zoning be APPROVED. 6. ZON2020-00019 Philip Zevenbergen, Associate Planner, Metropolitan Area Planning Department will present an application on behalf of R&R Realty, Jay Russell (owner) and Baughman Company, P.A. Philip Meyer (Agent) for a rezone request from SF-5 Single-Family Residential to TF-3 Two-Family Residential. Generally located approximately one-half mile north of West 53rd Street North on the west side of North Meridian Avenue (W. 5735 N. Meridian) The Metropolitan Area Planning Commission public hearing for this item will be on June 18, 2020. ZON2020-00019 Staff Report: https://www.wichita.gov/Council/DABAgendasMinutes/2020-06- 17%20DAB%206%20ZON2020-00019%20Staff%20Report.pdf Recommended Action: Based upon the information available at the time the staff report was completed, staff recommends APPROVAL of the request, as submitted. 7. ZON2020-00021 and CUP2020-00019 Philip Zevenbergen, Associate Planner, Metropolitan Area Planning Department will present an application on behalf of Broadmoor One, LLC (Applicant) and Baughman Company (Agent) for an amendment request of Womer Plaza Shopping Center (DP-29) and zone change from SF-5 Single Family Residential to LC Limited Commercial, generally located on the west side of North Womer Street and south of West 37th Street North. The Metropolitan Area Planning Commission public hearing for this item will be on June 18, 2020. DAB 6 • June 17, 2020 • Agenda • Page 4 ZON2020-00021 and CUP2020-00019 Staff Report: https://www.wichita.gov/Council/DABAgendasMinutes/2020-06-17%20DAB%206%20ZON2020- 00021%20and%20CUP2020-00019%20Staff%20Report.pdf Recommended Action: Based upon the information available at the time the staff report was prepared it is recommended that the request be APPROVED, subject to the following conditions: 4. The CUP drawing shall be revised to include the details of this amendment. General Provision 13 shall be amended to state the following: 13. The number of buildings shall not exceed twelve. 5. The site shall be developed in substantial conformance with the revised provisions of the approved CUP. 6. The applicant shall submit four copies of the amended and approved CUP within 60 days of final approval to the Metropolitan Area Planning Department or the amendment shall be deemed null and void. • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • Board Agenda 8. Updates, Issues, and Reports Reports from Council Member Cindy Claycomb and the DAB on any activities, events, resources, issues, or concerns in the neighborhoods, council district, and/or city. Recommended Action: Receive and file. • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • Adjournment The next District 6 Advisory Board meeting will be held at 6:30 p.m., Monday, July 6, 2020 at the at the Evergreen Library, 2601 N. Arkansas, Wichita, KS 67204. • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • DAB 6 • June 17, 2020 • Agenda • Page 5 AGENDA ITEM NO. STAFF REPORT MAPC: June 18, 2020 DAB VI: June 1, 2020 CASE NUMBER: CUP2020-00017 and ZON2020-00015 APPLICANT/AGENT: South Harbor, LLC / Harbor Properties, LLC (Applicant)/ Baughman Company c/o Russ Ewy (agent) REQUEST: LC Limited Commercial, and CUP DP-355: Harbor Isle Commercial 1 Community Unit Plan CURRENT ZONING: SF-5 Single Family Residential, SF-20 Single Family Residential, and MF-18 Multi-Family Residential with CUP DP-94. SITE SIZE: 67.47 acres LOCATION: North of I-235 and on the east of North Meridian Avenue (WCC VI) PROPOSED USE: To amend and expand the CUP to expand the number of permitted uses. BACKGROUND: This application is to change the zoning to LC Limited Commercial (LC) and GC General Commercial (GC) and establish the Harbor Isle Commercial 1 Community Unit Plan (DP-355) for the 67.47 acres zoned SF-5 Single Family Residential (SF-5), SF-20 Single Family Residential (SF-20), and MF-18 Multi-Family Residential (MF-18) with CUP DP-94. The property is located north of I-235 and on the east side of North Meridian Avenue. West 40th Street North has recently been extended to the west to intersect North Meridian and now serves as a frontage road for parcels 1 through 4. Parcels 1 through 5 are proposed to be rezoned to LC. Parcel 6 is proposed to be rezoned to GC. The applicant will be submitting a plat soon. The property immediately east of North Meridian Avenue, which encompasses parcels 1, 2 and a portion of 3 is currently part of the Mallard Cove Community Unit Plan DP-94. This application will replace the Mallard Cove CUP and add additional land to it in the creation of the Harbor Isle Commercial 1 CUP. The text of the CUP states that no parcel within the CUP shall allow the following uses: “Adult Entertainment establishment; Sexually Oriented Business; Correctional Placement Residence; Night Club in the City; Night Club in the County; Reverse Vending Machine; and Tavern and Drinking Establishments” as restricted by General Provision #18. Staff recommends the addition of the following language to the use restrictions: “Manufactured Home; Monument Sales; Cemetery; Marine Facility, Recreational; Pawn Shop; Teen Club in the City; Vehicle and Equipment Sales; Animal Care, General; Kennel, Boarding/Breeding/Training; Storage, Outdoor as a principal use; Vehicle Storage Yard; Asphalt or Concrete Plant, Limited and General; Recycling Collection Station; Event Center; and Recreation and Entertainment, Indoor. Restaurants that serve liquor can be developed and may serve liquor as along as food is the primary service of the establishment.” When platted, the property will contain six parcels and two reserves. The parcels generally grow larger is size west to east on the site with parcels 5 and 6 being the largest. Access controls shall be determined at the time of platting. All parcels without access to the public street will be accessible through internal cross lot access. The applicant’s proposed CUP has the standard landscaping, lighting, drainage, cross-lot circulation, and parking language. Landscaping is to be per the landscape ordinance. Screening with a six to eight foot concrete/masonry wall shall be constructed along the north property line of parcels 5 and 6 because they are adjacent to residential zoning. The wall shall be constructed with a color and pattern compatible with the commercial buildings. The text stipulates that a 40-foot wide landscape buffer per Section IV-B.3.b can be constructed in lieu of a wall. Staff recommends additional language regarding screening along the east property line of parcel 6 should the property be developed residentially. It is zoned SF-5, but is not developed with residential units. Additionally, a 35-foot building setback along the east property line of parcel 6 shall be required if the SF-5 zoned property is developed residentially. Light pole height shall be restricted to 24 feet, except within 200 feet of residential zoning. Then light poles shall be restricted to 15 feet. Rooftop mechanical equipment, trash receptacles, and loading areas shall be reasonably screened from ground level view. Outdoor storage and work areas, mechanical equipment, heating and air conditioning units and dumpsters located within 150 feet of a street require screening. Drainage is being addressed through the platting process. Cross-lot circulation agreements between parcels will be provided. Parking is to be per code unless specified otherwise within the CUP. The CUP drawing must also include the location and labeling of the planned collector street for parcels 5 and 6, the proposed dedicated right-of-way, and provide right-of-way dimensions for all streets depicted. Proposed signage is to be per code for the LC district unless specified otherwise. Monument signs shall be spaced 150 feet apart along the arterial roadway. Flashing, rotating or moving signs, and signs with moving lights or signs which created the illusion of movement are not permitted. Portable, billboards, and CUP2020-00017 and ZON2020-00015 Metropolitan Area Planning Commission Page 2 off site signs are prohibited. Window display signs are limited to 25 percent of the window area. There shall be no signs on the north elevations of any building adjacent to residential zoning. Monument signs are restricted to 25 feet in height except those along the highway frontage, which are permitted to be 35 feet. The CUP establishes certain restrictions for signage as follows. A. Each Parcel is permitted at least one freestanding sign with the following area restrictions:  Parcel 1: 150 sq. ft. of signage along Meridian Avenue. 150 sq. ft. of signage along frontage road.  Parcel 2: 150 sq. ft. of signage along frontage road.  Parcel 3: 150 sq. ft. of signage along frontage road.  Parcel 4: 150 sq. ft. of signage along frontage road.  Parcel 5: 150 sq. ft. of signage along planned collector street  Parcel 6: 150 sq. ft. of signage along planned collector street Property north is zoned LC Limited Commercial and SF-5 Single Family Residential. Land in both zoning classifications has platted lots but is undeveloped. Property south is zoned SF-5 Single Family Residential and GC General Commercial. Said property was recently apart of a zoning action (CUP2020-00002 and ZON2020-00003) to rezone the SF-5 land to GC and create CUP DP-353. The case was approved by City Council, but has yet to be perfected. The majority of the land is undeveloped; however a portion of it is a vacant go-kart track. Property east of is zoned SF-5 Single Family Residential, but is not developed residentially. It is occupied by what appears to be a vehicle driving track. Property west, across North Meridian Avenue, is zoned LC Limited Commercial and is developed as a church. CASE HISTORY: The western 26.8 acres was platted as part of the Mallard Cove Addition with CUP DP-94 for a multi-family development. The property also was part of BZA59-81 which was approved in 1981 to permit soil extraction on residentially zoned property. The eastern 22.81 acres was a portion of CU- 307 which approved the removal of topsoil on the property in 1984. In 1998, CU-501 expanded the area of CU-307 and added land to the north. CU-501 received approval for top soil removal in addition to soil extraction. ADJACENT ZONING AND LAND USE: North: LC and SF-5 Undeveloped land South: SF-5 and GC Vacant or undeveloped land East: SF-5 Vehicle driving track West: LC: Church (west of North Meridian) PUBLIC SERVICES: All of the public utilities are in place in the area but may need to be extended to the subject property. As part of the platting approval, guarantees and arrangements will be made to extend all utilities to this property in conformance with the City of Wichita standards. West 40th Street North is paved, two lane local street. North Meridian Avenue is a paved, five-lane arterial street. CONFORMANCE TO PLANS/POLICIES: The 2035 Wichita Future Growth Concept map indicates the site is appropriate for “new residential.” However, there are areas nearby that are indicated as appropriate for “residential and employment mix” and “commercial.” This area is located within Wichita’s 2035 urban growth area. The residential/employment mix and the commercial encompass areas of land that will likely be developed or redeveloped by 2035 with uses predominately of a mixed nature. CUP2020-00017 and ZON2020-00015 Metropolitan Area Planning Commission Page 3 Community Investments Plan discusses Location Guidelines in section 3 of the Future Land Use Policies. In the subsection titled Development Pattern, guideline 1.a. states “development should occur where necessary supporting infrastructure and services exist or are planned for extension concurrently with development. Guideline 1.c states “Major commercial and employment centers should be located at intersections of arterial streets and along highways and commercial corridors. Guideline 3.c. states “small, neighborhood-serving retail and offices uses and high-density residential uses not located at arterial intersections should be limited to the intersection of an arterial and a collector street. Guideline 3.e. states “new development areas be separated from existing developed areas by major barriers (such as: highways, railroads, waterways, and airports) or by significant open space or undeveloped areas should be discouraged unless the scale of the development is sufficient to support the cost of extending infrastructure and services in a manner that supports additional development on surrounding sites.” In the subsection titled Design, guideline 1.a. states “Commercial centers, office parks, and mixed-use developments should be designed with shared internal vehicular and pedestrian circulation, combined signage, coordinated landscaping and building design, and combined ingress/egress locations.” Guideline 1.b. states “Ingress/egress locations to non-residential uses generally should not access residential streets unless such access will not negatively impact nearby residential areas, except that industrial traffic should not feed directly into local streets in residential areas.” Guideline 1.g. states “Building entrances should be oriented to the street or internal circulation drives that connect to the street and designated pedestrian connections should be provided from building entrances to the street.” RECOMMENDATION: Based upon the information available at the time the staff report was prepared it is recommended that the request for GC General Commercial be APPROVED, subject to the following conditions: 1. The Development Guidelines shall be modified to read in accordance with the attached recommendation. 2. The site shall be developed in substantial conformance with the revised development guidelines and general provisions of the approved CUP. 3. The applicant shall record a CUP certificate with the Register of Deeds indicating that this tract (referenced as DP-355: Harbor Isle Commercial 1 Community Unit Plan has special conditions for development on the property. A copy of the recorded certificate along with four copies of the approved CUP shall be submitted to the Metropolitan Area Planning Department within 60 days of final approval to the Metropolitan Area Planning Department or the amendment shall be deemed null and void. This recommendation is based on the following findings: 1. The zoning, uses and character of the neighborhood: Property north is zoned LC Limited Commercial and SF-5 Single Family Residential. Land in both zoning classifications has platted lots but is undeveloped. Property south is zoned SF-5 Single Family Residential and GC General Commercial. Said property was recently apart of a zoning action (CUP2020-00002 and ZON2020- 00003) to rezone the SF-5 land to GC and create CUP DP-353. The case was approved by City Council, but has yet to be perfected. The majority of the land is undeveloped; however a portion of it is a vacant go-kart track. Property east of is zoned SF-5 Single Family Residential, but is not developed residentially. It is occupied by what appears to be a vehicle driving track. Property west, across North Meridian Avenue, is zoned LC Limited Commercial and is developed as a church. 2. The suitability of the subject property for the uses to which it has been restricted: The subject property is mix of zoning with SF-5 Single Family Residential, SF-20 Single Family Residential, CUP2020-00017 and ZON2020-00015 Metropolitan Area Planning Commission Page 4 and MF-18 Multi-Family Residential and could remain such. However, with the extension of West 40th Street North to have access to North Meridian, it is likely for this land to be redeveloped with more intensity either with residential or commercial. 3. Extent to which removal of the restrictions will detrimentally affect nearby property: LC Limited Commercial zoning is an appropriate base zone for this area given the frontage and proximity to I- 235 highway. With the recommended development standards, approval of the proposed CUP should have minimal detrimental impact on nearby property. 4. Relative gain to the public health, safety and welfare as compared to the loss in value or the hardship imposed upon the applicant: Approval of the request would add commercial and office development to this area, which is generally considered a gain to the public welfare in that it expands the employment and tax base. Denial would presumably represent a loss of economic opportunity to the applicant and/or land owner. 5. Conformance of the requested change to the adopted or recognized Comprehensive Plan and policies: The 2035 Wichita Future Growth Concept map indicates the site is appropriate for “new residential.” However, there are areas nearby that are indicated as appropriate for “residential and employment mix” and “commercial.” This area is located within Wichita’s 2035 urban growth area. The residential/employment mix and the commercial encompass areas of land that will likely be developed or redeveloped by 2035 with uses predominately of a mixed nature. 6. Impact of the proposed development on community facilities: The platting of this property will provide guarantees for needed community facilities to be obtained. Attachment: Recommended Development Guidelines for DP-355 DP-355 Harbor Isle Commercial 1 CUP Aerial Map Zoning Map Land Use Map CUP2020-00017 and ZON2020-00015 Metropolitan Area Planning Commission Page 5 RECOMMENDED DEVELOPMENT GUIDELINES FOR DP-355: 1. Total Land Area: 2,938,855 ± sq. ft. or 67.47 ± acres Net Land Area: 2,801,603 ± sq. ft. or 64.31 ± acres 2. Total Gross Floor Area: 735,780 sq. ft. Total Net Floor Area Ratio: 25 percent ± 3. Parking shall be provided in accordance with Section IV of the Unified Zoning Code, unless otherwise specified in the parcel description. 4. Setbacks are as indicated on the C.U.P. drawing, or as specified in the parcel descriptions. If contiguous parcels are to be developed under the same ownership, setbacks between those parcels will not be required. 5. A Drainage Plan shall be submitted to the appropriate Engineer for approval during the platting process. Required guarantees or drainage shall be provided at the time of platting improvements. 6. Development of the Harbor Isle Commercial 1 Community Unit Plan shall be contingent upon the platting of the subject property. The applicant shall provide four copies of an updated C.U.P. following the plat. 7. Signs will be as allowed by the Sign Code of the City of Wichita, with the following additional conditions/limitations: A. Each parcel is permitted at least one freestanding sign with the following area restrictions: Parcel 1: 150 sq. ft. of signage along Meridian Avenue. 150 sq. ft. of signage along frontage road. Parcel 2: 150 sq. ft. of signage along frontage road. Parcel 3: 150 sq. ft. of signage along frontage road. Parcel 4: 150 sq. ft. of signage along frontage road. Parcel 5: 150 sq. ft. of signage Parcel 6: 150 sq. ft. of signage along planned collector street. B. As the frontage develops along the arterial roadways, monument type signs shall be spaced a minimum of 150' apart, irrespective of how land is leased or sold and share similar elements in design. C. Flashing signs, rotating or moving signs, signs with moving lights or signs which create illusions of movement are not permitted. D. Portable, billboards and off-site signs are not permitted. E. Window display signs are limited to 25% of the window area. F. No signs shall be allowed on the north elevations of any building adjacent to residential zoning. G. All freestanding signs must be monument type and shall have a maximum height of 25 feet. Signs CUP2020-00017 and ZON2020-00015 Metropolitan Area Planning Commission Page 6 along the highway frontage may be permitted to be 35 feet in height. 8. Access Controls shall be as shown on the final plat. 9. All exterior lighting shall be shielded to direct light disbursement in a downward direction. 10. All parcels shall share similar or consistent parking lot lighting elements (i.e., fixtures, poles, and lamps, etc.). A. Limited height of light poles, including fixtures, lamps and base, to 24 feet, except within 200 feet of residential zoning said lighting shall be a maximum height of 15 feet. B. Extensive use of back lit canopies and neon or fluorescent tube lighting on buildings is not permitted. 11. Utilities shall be installed underground on all parcels. 12. Landscaping for this site shall be required as follows: A. Development of all parcels within the C.U.P. shall comply with the landscaping requirements of the appropriate jurisdiction, with a shared palette of landscape materials among parcels. All unpaved areas shall be landscaped. B. A landscape plan shall be prepared by a Kansas Landscape Architect for the above referenced landscaping, indicating the type, location, and specifications of all plant material. This plan shall be submitted to the Planning Department for their review and approval prior to issuance of a building permit. B. A financial guarantee for the plant material approved on the landscape plan for that portion of the C.U.P. being developed shall be required prior to issuance of any occupancy permit, if the required landscape has not been planted. 13. Screening: A. A six (6) to eight (8) foot high concrete/masonry wall shall be constructed along the north property line of Parcels 5 and 6 where adjacent to residentially-zoned lots (see plan). This solid wall shall be constructed of a pattern and color that is consistent or compatible with the building walls. C. In lieu of said screening wall, a landscape buffer of a minimum of 40 feet in width may be provided along those property lines abutting residentially-zoned lots, which shall include plantings per Section IV-B.3.b of the U.Z.C. Said buffer shall be a combination of deciduous and evergreen landscaping, per ordinance. D. Screening along the east property line where abutting residential zoning is contingent upon the adjoining property being developed residentially. 14. Rooftop mechanical equipment shall be screened from ground level view with similar materials to the main building per Unified Zoning Code. CUP2020-00017 and ZON2020-00015 Metropolitan Area Planning Commission Page 7 15. Trash receptacles, loading docks, outdoor storage, and loading areas shall be appropriately screened, with similar materials to the main building, to reasonably hide them from ground view. 16. Fire lanes shall be in accordance with the appropriate Fire Code. No parking shall be allowed in said fire lanes, although they may be used for passenger loading and unloading. The Fire Chief or his designated representative shall review and approve the location and design of all fire lanes. Fire hydrant installation and paved access to all building sites shall be provided for each phase of construction prior to the issuance of building permits. 17. Cross-lot circulation agreements shall be required at the time of platting to assure internal vehicular movement between all parcels. 18. No parcel within this C.U.P. shall allow the use of Adult Entertainment Establishments; Sexually Oriented Business; Correctional Placement Residences; Night Club in the City; Night Club in the County; Reverse Vending Machine; and Tavern and Drinking Establishment; Manufactured Home; Monument Sales; Cemetery; Marine Facility, Recreational; Pawn Shop; Teen Club in the City; Vehicle and Equipment Sales; Animal Care, General; Kennel, Boarding/Breeding/Training; Storage, Outdoor as a principal use; Vehicle Storage Yard; Asphalt or Concrete Plant, Limited and General; Recycling Collection Station; Event Center; and Recreation and Entertainment. Restaurants that serve liquor can be developed and may serve liquor, as long as food is the primary service of the establishment. Exterior audio systems that project sound beyond the boundaries of the C.U.P. are prohibited. 19. Amendments, adjustments or interpretations to this C.U.P. shall be done in accordance with the Unified Zoning Code. 20. The Transfer of title of all or any portion of land included within the Community Unit Plan (or any amendments thereto) does not constitute a termination of the plan or any portion thereof, but said plan shall run with the land and be binding upon present owners, their successors and assigns. 21. The development of this property shall proceed in accordance with the development plan as recommended for approval by the Planning Commission and approved by the Governing Body, and any substantial deviation of the plan, as determined by the Zoning Administrator and the Director of Planning, shall constitute a violation of the building permit authorizing construction of the proposed development. 22. Any major changes in this development plan shall be submitted to the Planning Commission and to the Governing Body for their consideration. 23. A plan for a pedestrian walk system shall be submitted and approved by the Director of Planning prior to the issuance of building permits. Said walk system shall link sidewalks along Meridian Avenue with the proposed buildings within the development. 24. Approval of a site circulation plan by the Planning Director is required for each phase of construction prior to the issuance of a building permit. An overall site plan shall be required for review and approval by the Planning Director prior to the issuance of any building permits; the site plan shall ensure internal circulation within the parcels and joint use of ingress/egress openings and that private drive openings are not impacted/blocked by the layout of parking stalls or landscaping. 25. The applicant shall record a CUP certificate with the Register of Deeds indicating that this tract CUP2020-00017 and ZON2020-00015 Metropolitan Area Planning Commission Page 8 (referenced as DP-??? Harbor Isle Commercial 1 CUP) has special conditions for development on the property. A copy of the recorded certificate along with four copies of the approved CUP shall be submitted to the Metropolitan Area Planning Department within 60 days of recording the plat for the subject property, or the request shall be considered denied and closed. 26. Mallard Cove CUP (DP-94) is hereby incorporated into this new CUP by virtue of CUP2020-17. 27. All buildings within Parcels 1 through 4, collectively, and Parcels 5 and 6, collectively, shall share uniform architectural character, color, texture, and the same predominate exterior building material, as determined by the Director of Planning. Building walls and roofs must have predominately earth-tone colors, with vivid colors limited to incidental accent. CUP2020-00017 and ZON2020-00015 Metropolitan Area Planning Commission Page 9 CUP2020-00017 and ZON2020-00015 Metropolitan Area Planning Commission Page 10 CUP2020-00017 and ZON2020-00015 Metropolitan Area Planning Commission Page 11 CUP2020-00017 and ZON2020-00015 Metropolitan Area Planning Commission Page 12 AGENDA ITEM NO. _____ STAFF REPORT MAPC June 18, 2020 DAB VI June 17, 2020 CASE NUMBER: ZON2020-00016 APPLICANT/AGENT: Progressive Opportunities, LLC (owner) Abbott Land Survey, Chad Abbott (Agent) REQUEST: TF-3 Two-Family Residential CURRENT ZONING: SF-5 Single-Family Residential SITE SIZE: 0.1 acre LOCATION: Generally located west of Zoo Boulevard and north of West Central Avenue in the 700 Block of Kessler Street PROPOSED USE: Duplex ZON2020-00016 Metropolitan Area Planning Commission Page 1 BACKGROUND: The applicant/owner is requesting the rezoning of the west 143 feet of Lot 35, except the west 30 feet thereof, West Ridge Acres Addition, (792 N. Kessler Street) from SF-5 Single Family Residential (SF-5) to TF-3 Two Family Residential (TF-3). The property is currently vacant. TF-3 zoning district requires a 25-foot front setback and a 20-foot rear setback. The property is approximately 10,000 square feet, with 70 linear feet of frontage along North Kessler Street. The Unified Zoning Code (UZC) requires a minimum of 6,000 square feet per duplex building. Properties north, south, east and west of the subject site are zoned SF-5 and are developed with single-family residences. There is no TF-3 zoned properties within approximately a 650-foot radius of the property. CASE HISTORY: The subject site is located in the West Ridge Acres Addition, platted in April 1940. A lot split (LSP2006-00070) for Lot 35 was perfected in 2006. No other zoning cases are associated with this site. ADJACENT ZONING AND LAND USE: NORTH: SF-5 Single-family residences SOUTH: SF-5 Single-family residences EAST: SF-5 Single-family residences WEST: SF-5 Single-family Residences PUBLIC SERVICES: North Kessler Street is a local paved street with a 60-foot right-of-way. The closest major intersection to the subject site is West Central Avenue and Zoo Boulevard. The sewer line is located along the east (rear) property line and the water line is located on the west side of North Kessler Street. CONFORMANCE TO PLANS/POLICIES: The Wichita-Sedgwick County Community Investments Plan, identifies the area in which the site is located Established Central Area. The site is located within the urban infill strategy area, where residential development is encouraged. The uses envisioned for redevelopment in this area include duplexes. The Community Investments Plan identifies the property as appropriate for residential and defines residential as a variety of housing types including duplexes. RECOMMENDATION: Based upon the information available at the time the staff report was completed, staff recommends APPROVAL of the request, with a Protective Overlay #350 as follows: 1. The following conditions shall apply to ZON2020-00016: a. Garages. The garage face shall occupy no more than 50 percent of the ground-level façade facing the street and may not project more than five feet in front of the main facade. b. Corner lot Duplexes. Duplexes located on corner lots shall place pedestrian entries on opposite street frontages so that the structure appears to be a single-family dwelling. c. Entrances. Pedestrian scaled entry shall be a prominent feature of the front elevation. Front doors shall be oriented to the street in front of the units. d. Architectural Variety. Developments shall achieve architectural variety by accommodating a variety of architectural styles that are compatible or consistent with the surrounding neighborhood, variation of the same architectural style, and through the use of multiple design elements. Duplicative house designs adjacent to each other are highly discouraged. Simple reverse configurations of the same house design on adjacent lots are not sufficient to meet this standard. e. Windows and Transparency. Transparent windows and/or doors facing the street are required. To meet this requirement, at least 10 percent of the façade must be transparent. The façade is measured from the base of the house to the start of the roofline and any other vertical walls facing the street, except for gabled portions of the facade not containing livable floor area. Garages facing the street shall count as part of the façade. f. Roof Design. Roofs shall have variation in roof planes in order to break up the large roof mass through dormers, gables, or changes in elevation. Roof forms and roof pitches of porches, ZON2020-00016 Metropolitan Area Planning Commission Page 2 dormers and garages shall be consistent and complement the building style within the neighborhood. g. Siding materials. Siding materials shall be appropriate to the architectural style of the structure. Traditional materials consistent with the neighborhood architectural styles are encouraged such as wood, masonry and brick. Siding materials and window trim should be consistent on all sides of the structures. h. HVAC. HVAC units shall be located away from the front of the buildings and screened from public view through landscaping and/or screen walls. 2. The parking area shall not cover more than 50% of the front yard and trash dumpsters shall not be permitted in front of the duplex building. 3. A site plan shall be approved by the Director of Planning before any building permits are issued. 4. Prior to publishing the ordinance establishing the zone change, the applicants shall record a document with the Register of Deeds indicating that this tract includes special conditions for development on this property. This recommendation is based on the following findings: 1. The zoning, uses and character of the neighborhood: Properties north, south, east and west of the subject site are zoned SF-5 and are developed with single-family residences. There is no TF-3 zoned properties within approximately a 650-foot radius of the property. 2. The suitability of the subject property for the uses to which it has been restricted: The property is presently zoned SF-5 Single Family Residential and the property could be developed with a new single-family dwelling. 3. Extent to which removal of the restrictions will detrimentally affect nearby property: Most platted subdivisions that were platted prior to 1950s are predominantly single-family residences and duplexes. Because of the similarity of residential use, the UZC does not require screening between SF-5 and TF-3 zoning districts. 4. Length of time the property has been vacant as currently zoned: This lot has been vacant for approximately 20 years. 5. Conformance of the requested change to the adopted or recognized Comprehensive Plan and policies: The Wichita-Sedgwick County Community Investments Plan, identifies the area in which the site is located Established Central Area. The site is located within the urban infill strategy area, where residential development is encouraged. The uses envisioned for redevelopment in this area include duplexes. The Community Investments Plan identifies the property as appropriate for residential and defines residential as a variety of housing types including duplexes. 6. Impact of the proposed development on community facilities: Development of the property would not have any impact on community facilities or resources. On-site parking will be required for the new development. All public improvements are available to serve the property. Attachment: Proposed site plan ZON2020-00016 Metropolitan Area Planning Commission Page 3 ZON2020-00016 Metropolitan Area Planning Commission Page 4 AGENDA ITEM NO. _____ STAFF REPORT MAPC - June 18, 2020 DAB VI – June 17, 2020 CASE NUMBER: ZON2020-000018 APPLICANT/AGENT Dianne K. Bolain; Luke Robert/Dingers Roofing and Construction (Applicants) Mark A. Savoy (Agent) REQUEST: LC Limited Commercial CURRENT ZONING: SF-5 Single-family Residential SITE SIZE: 3.39 acres LOCATION: Generally located one quarter-mile south of West 53rd Street North on the east side of North Meridian Avenue (5130 North Meridian Avenue.) PROPOSED USE: Redevelop existing building for limited commercial uses. ZON2020-00018 Metropolitan Area Planning Commission Page 1 BACKGROUND: This application was filed to rezone the subject property from SF-5 Single Family Residential to LC Limited Commercial in order to redevelop the existing building for limited commercial uses. The site is generally located one quarter-mile south of West 53rd Street North on the east side of North Meridian Avenue and is addressed 5130 North Meridian Avenue. The lot has an existing metal building with garage door entry. The tree lines along the north, south, and east property lines appears to meet the screening standards. Rezoning the site to LC allows for a mixture of residential, public/civic, and commercial uses as outlines in the Unified Zoning Code (UZC). Property to the north, south, and east of the site is zoned SF-5 Single Family Residential and is undeveloped. Property to the west of the site, across North Meridian Avenue, is zoned LC Limited Commercial and is undeveloped. CASE HISTORY: The property was platted at Lot 1, Bolain Addition to Sedgwick County, Kansas on December 15, 2011. ADJACENT ZONING AND LAND USE: North: SF-5; Undeveloped South: SF-5; Undeveloped East: SF-5; Undeveloped West: LC; Undeveloped PUBLIC SERVICES: North Meridian Avenue is a paved, 4-lane arterial street. All municipal services are available for the property. CONFORMANCE TO PLANS/POLICIES: The 2035 Wichita Future Growth Concept map (MAPC approval November 19, 2015) indicates the site is appropriate for “new residential.” The “new residential” designation encompasses areas of land that will likely be developed or redeveloped by 2035 with uses predominately residential. RECOMMENDATION: Based upon the information available at the time the staff report was prepared it is recommended that the request for LC Limited Commercial zoning be APPROVED. This recommendation is based on the following findings: 1. The zoning, uses and character of the neighborhood: Property to the north, south, and east of the site is zoned SF-5 Single Family Residential and is undeveloped. Property to the west of the site, across North Meridian Avenue, is zoned LC Limited Commercial and is undeveloped. 2. The suitability of the subject property for the uses to which it has been restricted: The lot has an existing metal building with garage door entry and it could continue to be used for non-commercial uses. There is, however, LC zoning to the west and the site could be granted LC zoning without being out of context with the surrounding area. 3. Extent to which removal of the restrictions will detrimentally affect nearby property: Approval of LC zoning would allow a wider range of uses to be constructed on the property. It is anticipated that any negative impacts would be minimal. ZON2020-00018 Metropolitan Area Planning Commission Page 2 4. Length of time the property has been vacant as currently zoned: The subject property has not been vacant. 5. Relative gain to the public health, safety and welfare as compared to the loss in value or the hardship imposed upon the applicant: Approval of the request will presumably expand commercial opportunities for the neighborhood which is generally considered a gain to the public welfare. Denial would presumably represent a loss of economic opportunity to the applicant and/or land owner. 6. Conformance of the requested change to the adopted or recognized Comprehensive Plan and policies: The 2035 Wichita Future Growth Concept map (MAPC approval November 19, 2015) indicates the site is appropriate for “new residential.” The “new residential” designation encompasses areas of land that will likely be developed or redeveloped by 2035 with uses predominately residential. 7. Impact of the proposed development on community facilities: Existing municipal facilities are already available to the property. Attachments: 1. Area Map 2. Zoning Map 3. Land Use Map 4. Site Plan 5. Photos ZON2020-00018 Metropolitan Area Planning Commission Page 3 ZON2020-00018 Metropolitan Area Planning Commission Page 4 ZON2020-00018 Metropolitan Area Planning Commission Page 5 ZON2020-00018 Metropolitan Area Planning Commission Page 6 ZON2020-00018 Metropolitan Area Planning Commission Page 7 AGENDA ITEM NO. _____ STAFF REPORT MAPC June 18, 2020 DAB VI June 17, 2020 CASE NUMBER: ZON2020-00019 APPLICANT/AGENT: R&R Realty, Jay Russell (owner) Baughman Company, P.A. Philip Meyer (Agent) REQUEST: TF-3 Two-Family Residential CURRENT ZONING: SF-5 Single-Family Residential SITE SIZE: 2.053 acres LOCATION: Generally located approximately one-half mile north of West 53rd Street North on the west side of North Meridian Avenue PROPOSED USE: Duplex ZON2020-00019 Metropolitan Area Planning Commission Page 1 BACKGROUND: The applicant/owner is requesting the rezoning of a portion of W. 5735 N. Meridian, described as the south 135 feet of the south seven (7) acres of the Northeast Quarter of the Northeast Quarter of the Southeast Quarter (NE1/4 NE1/4 SE1/4), except the East 50 feet for road, all in Section 13, Township Twenty-Six (26), Range One (1) West of the Sixth Principal Meridian, Sedgwick County, Kansas from SF-5 Single Family Residential (SF-5) to TF-3 Two Family Residential (TF-3). The property is currently vacant. TF-3 zoning district requires a 25-foot front setback and a 20-foot rear setback. The property is approximately 10,000 square feet, with 130 linear feet of frontage along North Meridian Avenue. The Unified Zoning Code (UZC) requires a minimum of 6,000 square feet per duplex building. Property north of the subject site is an unplatted four-acre tract zoned SF-5 and developed with a single-family residence and outbuildings. Property to the south is the Northgate 2nd Addition zoned TF-3, platted in 2016 with lots under construction. East of the subject site is zoned SF-5, Anderson Acres Addition platted in August 1951, and is developed with single family residences. West of the site is east and west of the subject site are zoned SF-5, Northgate 3rd Addition platted in 2019, with nine undeveloped lots immediately south of the subject site. CASE HISTORY: The subject site is being platted as the Northgate 4th Addition (SUB2020-15). ADJACENT ZONING AND LAND USE: NORTH: SF-5 Single-family residences SOUTH: TF-3 Duplexes under construction EAST: SF-5 Single-family residences, Anderson Acres Addition WEST: TF-3 Undeveloped PUBLIC SERVICES: North Meridian Avenue is a four-lane arterial street with a 90-foot right-of-way. The property has direct access to North Meridian Avenue. Water and Sewer Utilities are available to the site. CONFORMANCE TO PLANS/POLICIES: The Wichita-Sedgwick County Community Investments Plan, 2035 Future Growth Map identifies the area in which the site as New Residential/Employment Mix. This area will likely be developed or redeveloped by 2035 with uses predominately of a mixed nature. Housing types within this area will likely be developed with higher density. RECOMMENDATION: Based upon the information available at the time the staff report was completed, staff recommends APPROVAL of the request, as submitted. 1. The zoning, uses and character of the neighborhood: Property north of the subject site is an unplatted four-acre tract zoned SF-5 and developed with a single-family residence and outbuildings. Property to the south is the Northgate 2nd Addition zoned TF-3, platted in 2016 with lots under construction. East of the subject site is zoned SF-5, Anderson Acres Addition platted in August 1951, and is developed with single family residences. West of the subject site is the Northgate 3rd Addition platted in 2019 zoned TF-3 with undeveloped lots. 2. The suitability of the subject property for the uses to which it has been restricted: The property is presently zoned SF-5 Single Family Residential and the property could be developed with a new single-family dwelling. 3. Extent to which removal of the restrictions will detrimentally affect nearby property: Two platted additions adjacent to the subject are zoned TF-3. The re-zoning of the parcel to TF-3 will not detrimentally affect nearby properties. 4. Length of time the property has been vacant as currently zoned: This property has been ZON2020-00019 Metropolitan Area Planning Commission Page 2 agricultural land at least since 1938. 5. Conformance of the requested change to the adopted or recognized Comprehensive Plan and policies: The Wichita-Sedgwick County Community Investments Plan, 2035 Future Growth Map identifies the area in which the site as New Residential/Employment Mix. This area will likely be developed or redeveloped by 2035 with uses predominately of a mixed nature. Housing types within this area will likely be developed with higher density. 6. Impact of the proposed development on community facilities: Development of the property would not have any impact on community facilities or resources. All public improvements are available to be extended to serve the property. ZON2020-00019 Metropolitan Area Planning Commission Page 3 AGENDA ITEM NO. STAFF REPORT MAPC June 18, 2020 DAB VI June 17, 2020 CASE NUMBER: CUP2020-00019 and ZON2020-00021 APPLICANT/AGENT: Broadmoor One, LLC (Applicant)/Baughman Company (Agent) REQUEST: Amendment of Womer Plaza Shopping Center (DP-29) and zone change from SF-5 Single Family Residential to LC Limited Commercial. CURRENT ZONING: SF-5 Single Family Residential and LC Limited Commercial SITE SIZE: 15.5 acres LOCATION: On the west side of North Womer Street and the south side of West 37 th Street North PROPOSED USE: Enlarge CUP with the addition of land for proposed Parcel 6. BACKGROUND: This application is for an amendment to the Womer Plaza Shopping Center CUP (DP- 39) to add land to the south to form Parcel 6 and Reserve A. The property is generally located on the west side of North Womer Street and south of West 37th Street North. North Womer is a street that is a connector between North Amidon and North Meridian Avenues near the I-235 interchange. The new land is currently zoned SF-5 Single Family Residential. This application is also a zone change request to rezone the property for new Parcel 6 to LC Limited Commercial to be consistent with the existing CUP. New Parcel 6 will have a net area of 13.03 acres. The maximum building coverage and floor area ratio percentages are consistent with the other five parcels at 30 percent and 35 percent respectively. Parcel 6 will have a maximum of five buildings permitted. There are no changes to the permitted uses in the CUP. The only change to the general provisions is the increase in the maximum number of buildings allowed. With the addition of Parcel 6, the maximum number of buildings for the entire CUP increases from seven to twelve. General Provision 13 will need to be amended to reflect this change. Reserve A is 2.51 acres in size, located on the south side of Parcel 6, and is reserved for open space, landscaping and drainage purpose. Property to the north is zoned LC and is the original portion of CUP DP-29 and is undeveloped. Property to the south is zoned SF-5 Single Family Residential and is developed with single family homes. Property to the east is a mixture of SF-5 and TF-3 Two Family Residential zoning with single family and duplex development. Property to the west is also a mixture of SF-5 and TF-3 zoning with single family and duplex development. CASE HISTORY: The Womer Plaza Shopping Center CUP was originally approved in May 1968. It has been amended in 1974 as well as 2018. The site was replatted to the Womer 2nd Addition in March 2018 with a subsequent Administrative Adjustment (CUP2018-000012) to realign the parcel boundaries with the new plat. The plat for this property is in Womer 2nd Addition, which was recorded with the Sedgwick County Register of Deeds on April 16, 2018. ADJACENT ZONING AND LAND USE: North: LC: undeveloped land South: SF-5: single family residential East: SF-5 and TF-3: single family and two family residential West: SF-5 and TF-3: single family and two family residential PUBLIC SERVICES: The subject property takes its access and fronts on North Womer, a paved, four- lane arterial street. The Womer 2nd Addition has a street dedication for West 36th Street North, which has yet to be constructed. All public services are available to the site. CONFORMANCE TO PLANS/POLICIES: The 2035 Wichita Future Growth Concept map (MAPC approval November 19, 2015) indicates the site is appropriate for “new residential” and is located just beyond Wichita’s 2035 Established Central area. The “new residential” classification applies to those areas that likely will develop or be redeveloped within the by 2035 for the full diversity of residential development densities and types typically found in a large urban municipality. The range of housing densities and types includes, but is not limited to, single-family detached homes, semi-detached homes, zero lot line units, patio homes, duplexes, townhouses, apartments and multi-family units, condominiums, mobile home parks, and special residential accommodations for the elderly Though the comprehensive plan indicates this for “new residential” there is existing commercial zoning present on property abutting the property to the north. Therefore, the request is not unreasonable. Metropolitan Area Planning Commission Page 2 CUP2020-00019 and ZON2020-00021 RECOMMENDATION: Based upon the information available at the time the staff report was prepared it is recommended that the request be APPROVED, subject to the following conditions: 1. The CUP drawing shall be revised to include the details of this amendment. General Provision 13 shall be amended to state the following: 13. The number of buildings shall not exceed twelve. 2. The site shall be developed in substantial conformance with the revised provisions of the approved CUP. 3. The applicant shall submit four copies of the amended and approved CUP within 60 days of final approval to the Metropolitan Area Planning Department or the amendment shall be deemed null and void. This recommendation is based on the following findings: 1. The zoning, uses and character of the neighborhood: Property to the north is zoned LC and is the original portion of CUP DP-29 and is undeveloped. Property to the south is zoned SF-5 Single Family Residential and is developed with single family homes. Property to the east is a mixture of SF-5 and TF-3 Two Family Residential zoning with single family and duplex development. Property to the west is also a mixture of SF-5 and TF-3 zoning with single family and duplex development. 2. The suitability of the subject property for the uses to which it has been restricted: The subject property is currently zoned SF-5 Single Family Residential and could remain such with single family development. However, the subject property is being redeveloped and this amendment supports that effort. 3. Extent to which removal of the restrictions will detrimentally effect nearby property: The approval of the proposed CUP amendment should have minimal detrimental impact on nearby property. 4. Length of time the property has been vacant as currently zoned: The subject property has been undeveloped for some time. 5. Relative gain to the public health, safety and welfare as compared to the loss in value or the hardship imposed upon the applicant: Approval of the request will permit the continued redevelopment of the property. Denial would presumably represent a loss of economic opportunity to the applicant and/or land owner. 6. Conformance of the requested change to the adopted or recognized Comprehensive Plan and policies: The 2035 Wichita Future Growth Concept map (MAPC approval November 19, 2015) indicates the site is appropriate for “new residential” and is located just beyond Wichita’s 2035 Established Central area. The “new residential” classification applies to those areas that likely will develop or be redeveloped within the by 2035 for the full diversity of residential development densities and types typically found in a large urban municipality. The range of housing densities and types includes, but is not limited to, single-family detached homes, semi-detached homes, zero lot line units, patio homes, duplexes, townhouses, apartments and multi-family units, condominiums, mobile home parks, and special residential accommodations for the elderly Though the comprehensive plan indicates this for “new residential” there is existing commercial zoning present on property abutting the property to the north. Therefore, the request is not unreasonable. Metropolitan Area Planning Commission Page 3 CUP2020-00019 and ZON2020-00021 7. Impact of the proposed development on community facilities: The proposed use will have no detrimental impact on community facilities. Attachments: 1. Aerial Map 2. Zoning Map 3. Land Use Map 4. CUP DP-29 Drawing Metropolitan Area Planning Commission Page 4 CUP2020-00019 and ZON2020-00021 Metropolitan Area Planning Commission Page 5 CUP2020-00019 and ZON2020-00021 Metropolitan Area Planning Commission Page 6 CUP2020-00019 and ZON2020-00021 Metropolitan Area Planning Commission Page 7 CUP2020-00019 and ZON2020-00021 Metropolitan Area Planning Commission Page 8 CUP2020-00019 and ZON2020-00021 Metropolitan Area Planning Commission Page 9 CUP2020-00019 and ZON2020-00021