Board of Architectural Review

Board Members: Jay Claypoole (Chair), Glen Gardner, Julia Martin, Fillmore Wilson Staff: Linda Bennett, Peggy Jordan (recorder), Erin Minnigan RESULTS BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW-SMALL January 25, 2018 4:30 P.M. 2 GEORGE STREET 1. Approval of minutes from the May 25, 2017 meeting. APP. NO. 181-25-1 MOTION: Approval as submitted. MADE BY: Martin SECOND: Wilson VOTE: FOR 3 AGAINST 0 2. 543 Rutledge Avenue - - TMS # 460-07-02-209 APP. NO. 181-25-2 Request approval for demolition of garage structure. Category 4- (West Side) pre-1944 Historic Corridor District Owner: Donald Hill Applicant: Donald Hill MOTION: Denial of demolition. MADE BY: Wilson SECOND: Claypoole VOTE: FOR 2 AGAINST 1 (Martin against.) 3. 90 St. Margaret Street - TMS # 463-10-04-043 APP. NO. ###-##-3 Request approval for partial demolition of a rear addition. Category 4 (Wagener Terrace) pre-1944 N of Line/S of Mt. Pleasant Owner: Whitney & Neil Butler Applicant: LFA Architecture/Laura Altman Withdrawn by staff 4. 144 President Street - - TMS # 460-11-02-095 APP. NO. 181-25-4 Request preliminary approval for new construction of a residential structure. (Cannon-Elliotborough) Old City District Owner: Spring & President, LLC. Applicant: John Douglas Tucker Architect MOTION: Preliminary approval with staff comments 1, 2, 3, 4, 7, 8, and 9 with final review by staff. MADE BY: Martin SECOND: Wilson VOTE: FOR 4 AGAINST 0 (Gardner arrives during this item.) 5. 142 President Street - - TMS # 460-11-02-094 APP. NO. 181-25-5 Request preliminary approval for new construction of a residential structure. (Cannon-Elliotborough) Old City District Owner: Spring & President, LLC. Applicant: John Douglas Tucker Architect MOTION: Preliminary approval with staff comments 1-5 and 8-10, and final review by staff. MADE BY: Martin SECOND: Gardner VOTE: FOR 4 AGAINST 0 BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW-SMALL January 25, 2018 Page |2 6. 18 Felix Street - TMS # 460-12-01-029 APP. NO. 181-25-6 Request conceptual approval for renovation of existing building and new construction of a rear addition. Category 4 (Cannon-Elliotborough) pre-1888 Old City District Owner: 18 Felix Street, LLC. Applicant: Harrison Malpass Deferred by Applicant. 7. 8 Elizabeth Street - - TMS # 460-11-01-066 APP. NO. 181-25-7 Request preliminary approval to modify existing one-story addition and construct new two-story addition. Category 4 (Mazyck-Wraggborough) pre-1888 Old and Historic District Owner: Chase and Cameron Elliott Applicant: Simons Young & Associates MOTION: Preliminary approval with staff conditions 5-8, and board condition to lower eave at north side of hyphen to avoid engaging adjacent rooflines and final review by staff. MADE BY: Martin SECOND: Wilson VOTE: FOR 4 AGAINST 0 8. 22 Charlotte Street - - TMS # 459-13-01-095 APP. NO. 181-25-8 Request appeal of staff decision regarding fence height. Category 3 (Mazyck-Wraggborough) c.1879-1880 Old and Historic District Owner: M. Vaughan Alsbrook Applicant: M. Vaughan Alsbrook MOTION: Denial of appeal with the condition/provision for the applicant to resubmit plans and details of a new wood fence with the maximum height of seven (7’) feet from sidewalk grade which could be solid wood. MADE BY: Gardner SECOND: Martin VOTE: FOR 4 AGAINST 0 9. 36 Hasell Street - - TMS # 458-05-01-035 APP. NO. 181-25-9 Request preliminary approval to reestablish rear bay of the piazza and add a vertical addition over the one-story portion at the rear. Category 3 (Ansonborough) mid-19th century Old and Historic District Owner: Richard T. Hill Applicant: Dufford Young Architects MOTION: Preliminary approval with final review by staff and board conditions to restudy column engaged at infill and to restudy cladding at 2nd floor of East elevation. MADE BY: Martin SECOND: Gardner VOTE: FOR 4 AGAINST 0 10. 15 Council Street - - TMS # 457-11-04-011 APP. NO. 181-25-10 Request conceptual approval to elevate an existing house. Not Rated (Charlestowne) Early 20th Century Old and Historic District Owner: Gardenia Investments, LLC. Applicant: Robert Morris MOTION: Conceptual approval with staff conditions 1 and 4-9, and board condition to restudy the screening under the piazzas. MADE BY: Martin SECOND: Wilson VOTE: FOR 4 AGAINST 0 BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW-SMALL January 25, 2018 Page |3 11. 10 Murray Boulevard - - TMS # 457-16-03-003 APP. NO. 181-25-11 Request final approval to alter second floor piazza doors. Category 4 (Charlestowne) c. 1928-1944 Old and Historic District Owner: Steve McGowen Applicant: Graceworks Construction and Remodeling Withdrawn for staff review 12. 44 Savage Street - - TMS # 457-12-03-129 APP. NO. 181-25-12 Request conceptual approval to modify fenestration and add light fixtures. Category 4 (Charlestowne) pre-1902 Old and Historic District Owner: Peuma, Inc. Applicant: Byers Collaborative/Sandford Byers Withdrawn by staff review 13. 1 Aiken Street - - TMS # 459-09-02-124 APP. NO. 181-25-13 Request conceptual approval to modify fenestration. Category 4 (East Side) c. 1852-1872 Old City District Owner: David Richardson Applicant: William Bates Architect MOTION: Deferral with staff comments. MADE BY: Gardner SECOND: Wilson VOTE: FOR 4 AGAINST 0 14. 19 Reid Street - - TMS # 459-09-04-032 APP. NO. 181-25-14 Request preliminary approval for new construction of two residential structures. (East Side) Old City District Owner: Socurro Partners, LLC Applicant: Clarke Design Group / Phil Clarke MOTION: Preliminary approval with staff conditions 2, 3, 4, 6, and 7, and board recommendation to have the retaining wall be engineered. MADE BY: Martin SECOND: Wilson VOTE: FOR 4 AGAINST 0 15. 32 Ashton Street - - TMS # 460-11-01-066 APP. NO. 181-25-15 Request conceptual approval for new construction of a residential structure at the rear of property. Category 4- (Westside) c. 1885 Old City District Owner: Jason Pennington Applicant: John Sullivan/S. Arch Studio MOTION: Deferral with staff comments 1-4 to restudy height/scale/mass and general architectural direction. MADE BY: Claypoole SECOND: Martin VOTE: FOR 4 AGAINST 0 16. 540 King Street - - TMS # 460-08-04-062 APP. NO. 181-25-16 Request conceptual approval for new construction of a 3-story mixed-use building. (n/a) Old and Historic District Owner: Vanderking 540, LLC. Applicant: The Middleton Group MOTION: Denial as submitted. MADE BY: Gardner SECOND: Wilson VOTE: FOR 3 AGAINST 1 (Martin against)