Municipal Civil Service Commission
Regular MeetingAlbany, NY · February 24, 2021
Minutes
MINUTES
MEETING OF THE MUNICIPAL CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF
ALBANY HELD FEBRUARY 24, 2021, VIA VIDEO CONFERENCE IN ACCORDANCE
WITH THE HEALTH AND SAFETY GUIDELINES ISSUED BY NYS DUE TO COVID-19.
ATTENDEES: Thomas McNaughton, Commissioner, Chair
Linda Jackson-Chalmers, Commissioner
Michael Cassidy, Commissioner
Philip Banaszek, Law Department
Sandra Coleman, Human Resources Generalist III
Peachie Jones, Director of Human Resources (City of Albany)
Rebecca Campbell, Human Resources Generalist II
Anthony Battuello, Police Commander, Albany Police Department
Dylan Hodgkiss
John Dolan
Joshua Shahid
Naomi Hughes
I. Call to order – Commissioner McNaughton called the meeting to order at 4:40 p.m.
II. Approval of minutes – The Commission voted unanimously to accept the minutes
from the February 18, 2021 meeting as written.
III. Report of appointments to the Competitive, Non-Competitive, Exempt and Labor Class
• The Civil Service Office reported on the following Permanent -Competitive Class
appointments:
NAME TITLE AGENCY/DEPARTMENT DATE
Nathan Hearn Library Clerk APL 12/1/2020
Wisdom Johnson Library Assistant APL 12/2/2020
Cecilia Holodak Library Clerk APL 12/3/2020
Michele Newkirk Library Clerk APL 12/3/2020
• The Civil Service Office reported on the following Provisional -Competitive
Class appointments:
NAME TITLE AGENCY/DEPARTMENT DATE
John Dortch Construction Manager AHA 8/11/2020
Kristen Blackwell
Clark Office Manager ASD 1/11/2021
Michele Andre Auditor Audit & Control 2/22/2021
• The Civil Service Office reported on the following Provisional Promotion -
Competitive Class appointments:
NAME TITLE AGENCY/DEPARTMENT DATE
Luis Roldan Senior Planner Planning 2/15/2021
• The Civil Service Office reported on the following Non-Competitive Class
appointments:
NAME TITLE AGENCY/DEPARTMENT DATE
Hilliard Piper Building Maintenance Worker ASD 12/21/20
Ricardo Burciaga Laborer II DGS 2/4/2021
Kevoy Baxter Sanitation Worker DGS 2/11/2021
Irving Slaughter Laborer I DGS 2/11/2021
• The Civil Service Office reported on the following Labor Class appointments:
NAME TITLE AGENCY/DEPARTMENT DATE
Brian Brooks Cleaner ASD 12/21/2020
Asaad Leigh Custodial Worker ASD 1/4/2021
IV. Firefighter Non-Selections
• No EMT Certification
NAME
Jacob Sheridan
V. Executive Session - The Commission went into Executive Session at 4:45 p.m. to
hear/review appeals of the Police Officer candidates that submitted appeals to their
non-selection for disqualification.
VI. Police Officer Appeals
• Candidate J.D. – The Commission unanimously voted to accept the appeal of
the candidate and ordered the Civil Service/HR Office to schedule a second
evaluation for the candidate.
• Candidate N.H. – The Commission unanimously voted to deny the appeal of
this candidate.
• Candidate D.H. - The Commission unanimously voted to deny the appeal of this
candidate.
• Candidate J.S. - The Commission unanimously voted to deny the appeal of this
candidate.
Commissioner McNaughton left the meeting for 10 minutes.
VII. Amendment of Job Specifications – The Commission unanimously voted to amend the
job specifications for the following titles.
• Confidential Legal Secretary
• General Counsel
• Golf Course Superintendent
• Program Aide (Special Events)
• Water Plant Maintenance Mechanic
VIII. Old Business
IX. New Business
• Abolishment of Titles not in use – The Commission unanimously voted to
abolish the list of titles attached to the minutes.
• Police Non-Selects – Discussion.
The Commission unanimously voted to non-select the candidates provided by
APD for disqualification.
X. Adjournment – The meeting adjourned at 6:42 p.m.
Next regular meeting: Wednesday, March 31, 2021
Sandra Coleman
Human Resources Generalist III
Positions in City of Albany Civil Service Administration
A
Administrative Aide CSC 1-30-02 Final.pdf
Assessment Clerk - CSC 3-31-04 final.pdf
Assistant Boiler Tender - CSC - 1-6-16.pdf
Assistant Karate Instructor - CSC 1-26-05 FINAL.pdf
Assistant Property Manager - CSC 12-28-05 Final.pdf
Assistant to the City Clerk - CSC 9-25-02 FINAL.pdf
B
Benefits Administrator - CSC 6-27-18.pdf
Budget Analyst - CSC 2-26-14 Final.pdf
Business Systems Analyst CSC 12-20-17.pdf
C
Chauffeur CSC 11-19-03 FINAL.pdf
Chief Inspector CSC 1-6-16.pdf
Chief of Staff to the Commissioner
Chief Recreation Maintenance Repair Worker -1-6-16-CSC- FINAL.pdf
Civil Service Administrator CSC 1-16-19.pdf
Computer Operator I - CSC 6-27-01 Final.pdf
Computer Specialist - CSC 2-25-98.pdf
Constituent Services Assistant - CSC 12-27-17.pdf [fix typo]
Contract Specialist- CSC-9-21-88 Final.pdf
Contract and Supply Aide.pdf
D
Department Liaison (Code Enforcement) CSC 5-26-04 Final.pdf
Deputy Director of Buildings CSC 2-22-17.pdf
Deputy Director of Codes - CSC 2-22-17.pdf
Director Of Mainstream Operations.pdf
Director Of Manpower Planning.pdf
Director of Finance (APL) spec draft 5-6-09 (2).pdf
Director of Finance - CSC 10-25-00 FINAL.pdf
Director of Maintenance.pdf
Director of Recycling - CSC 6-30-10 Draft.pdf
E
Environmental Services Coordinator - CSC 10-25-00 FINAL.pdf
Environmental Services Specialist- CSC 10-25-00 FINAL.pdf
Equal Employment Opportunity.pdf
F
Financial Operations Specialist - CSC 9-25-02 FINAL.pdf
Fire Alarm Operator.pdf
G
Grounds Helper.pdf
Group Fitness Instructor CSC 4-29-15 FINAL.pdf
I
Information Specialist - CSC 6-28-06 Final.pdf
Information Technology Assistant - CSC 1-5-15.pdf
J
Job Development Specialist CSC 9-26-01 Final.pdf
K
Karate Instructor CSC 5-22-02 Final.pdf
Karate and Weightlifting Instructor - Justification.pdf
Keyboard Assistant CSC 9-27-06 Final.pdf
M
Modernization Assistant CSC 6-26-02 FINAL.pdf
Modernization Intern CSC 6-27-01 final.pdf
N
Neighborhood Development Specialist CSC 1-30-08 Final.pdf
Neighborhood Resource Coordinator CSC 7-28-04 Final.pdf
O
Operations Analyst CSC 6-29-11 Final.pdf
Operations Assistant CSC 3-31-04 Final.pdf
Operations Specialist - CSC 3-27-02 FINAL.pdf
P
Payroll Clerk CSC 8-26-15 Final.pdf
Photographer - CSC 6-28-06 Final.pdf
Planner (Historic Preservation and Neighborhood) CSC 5-27-15 Final.pdf
Policy - Fiscal Analyst CSC 8-27-14 Final.pdf
Principal Economic Developer - CSC 03-30-05 Final.pdf
Program Aide - Volunteer Coordinator - CSC 2-25-04 FINAL.pdf
Program Aide - Volunteer Services CSC 11-30-05 Final.pdf
Program Analyst CSC 8-29-01 Final.pdf
Program Compliance Officer CSC 9-26-01 Final-2.pdf
Program Instructor.pdf
R
Recreation Facilities Supervisor CSC 8-28-13 Final.pdf
Refrigerant Recovery Technician CSC 2-23-05 Final RES B.pdf
Registrar of Vital Statistics - CSC 8-30-16 Final.pdf
Rehabilitation & Environmental Services Manager, CSC 1-30-08 Final-2.pdf
Rehabilitation Construction Director - CSC 9-25-02 FINAL-2.pdf
Rehabilitation Finance Director 9-12-01-2.pdf
Resource Materials Clerk - CSC 11-17-04 Final.pdf
Resource Materials Coordinator CSC 2-23-05 Final.pdf
Riverfront Program Manager CSC 1-15-03 Final.pdf
S
Senior Gang Prevention Coordinator - CSC 5-22-02 Final.pdf
Senior Personnel Assistant CSC 2-23-05 Final .pdf
Senior Programmer.pdf
Senior Stenographer CSC 6-26-02 Final.pdf
Senior Typist - CSC 6-26-02 final.pdf
Skating Rink Manager.pdf
Solid Waste Manager 4-6-2017.pdf
Special Projects Manager-Water - CSC 1-30-02 FINAL (pdf).pdf
Staff Professional Engineer (Solid Waste) - CSC 5-27-15.pdf
Summer Recreation Staff.pdf
Supervising Custodian - 1978.pdf
Support Services Coordinator.pdf
System Support Specialist - CSC 9-24-08 FINAL-Asst. Systems Specialist.pdf
T
Tax Record Clerk 7-25-01 final.pdf
Telephone Operator-1-6-16 - CSC - Final.pdf
W
Waste Acquisition Assistant - CSC 8-29-01.pdf [fix typo]
Y
Youth Basketball Coordinator - CSC 1-26-05 FINAL.pdf
Youth Programs Coordinator 8-02.pdf
Agenda
AGENDA
MEETING OF THE MUNICIPAL CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF
ALBANY HELD FEBRUARY 24, 2021, VIA VIDEO CONFERENCE IN ACCORDANCE
WITH THE HEALTH AND SAFETY GUIDELINES ISSUED BY NYS DUE TO COVID-19.
ATTENDEES: Thomas McNaughton, Commissioner, Chair
Linda Jackson-Chalmers, Commissioner
Michael Cassidy, Commissioner
Phillip Banaszek, Law Department
Sandra Coleman, Human Resources Generalist III
Peachie Jones, Director of Human Resources (City of Albany)
Rebecca Campbell, Human Resources Generalist II
Anthony Battuello, Police Commander, Albany Police Department
Mark Decker, Police Lieutenant, Albany Police Department
I. Call to order
II. Approval of minutes
III. Report of appointments to the Competitive, Non-Competitive, Exempt and Labor Class
• The Civil Service Office reported on the following Permanent -Competitive Class
appointments:
NAME TITLE AGENCY/DEPARTMENT DATE
Nathan Hearn Library Clerk APL 12/1/2020
Wisdom Johnson Library Assistant APL 12/2/2020
Cecilia Holodak Library Clerk APL 12/3/2020
Michele Newkirk Library Clerk APL 12/3/2020
• The Civil Service Office reported on the following Provisional -Competitive
Class appointments:
NAME TITLE AGENCY/DEPARTMENT DATE
John Dortch Construction Manager AHA 8/11/2020
Kristen Blackwell
Clark Office Manager ASD 1/11/2021
Michele Andre Auditor Audit & Control 2/22/2021
• The Civil Service Office reported on the following Provisional Promotion -
Competitive Class appointments:
NAME TITLE AGENCY/DEPARTMENT DATE
Luis Roldan Senior Planner Planning 2/15/2021
• The Civil Service Office reported on the following Non-Competitive Class
appointments:
NAME TITLE AGENCY/DEPARTMENT DATE
Hilliard Piper Building Maintenance Worker ASD 12/21/20
Ricardo Burciaga Laborer II DGS 2/4/2021
Kevoy Baxter Sanitation Worker DGS 2/11/2021
Irving Slaughter Laborer I DGS 2/11/2021
• The Civil Service Office reported on the following Labor Class appointments:
NAME TITLE AGENCY/DEPARTMENT DATE
Brian Brooks Cleaner ASD 12/21/2020
Asaad Leigh Custodial Worker ASD 1/4/2021
IV. Firefighter Non-Selections
• No EMT Certification
NAME
Jacob Sheridan
V. Police Officer Appeals
• Candidate J.D.
• Candidate N.H.
• Candidate D.H.
• Candidate J.S.
VI. Amendment of Job Specifications
• Confidential Legal Secretary
• General Counsel
• Golf Course Superintendent
• Program Aide (Special Events)
• Water Plant Maintenance Mechanic
VII. Old Business
VIII. New Business
• Abolishment of Titles not in use
IX. Adjournment
Next regular meeting: Wednesday, March 31, 2021
Sandra Coleman
Human Resources Generalist III
Get email alerts for Albany
A daily email when new agendas and minutes are posted.