Municipal Civil Service Commission
Regular MeetingAlbany, NY · January 19, 2022
Minutes
January 19, 2022 CS Commission Meeting Minutes
Meeting of the Albany Municipal Civil Service Commission held on Tuesday, January 19,
2022 at 4:30pm via video conference in accordance with legislation (S.50001/A.40001)
extending virtual access to public meetings under New York State's Open Meetings Law.
ATTENDEES: Thomas McNaughton, Commissioner and Chair
Linda Jackson-Chalmers, Commissioner
Michael Cassidy, Commissioner
Phillip Banaszek, City of Albany Assistant Corporation Counsel
Tatiana Diaz, City of Albany Human Resources Generalist III
Tolani Elumade, City of Albany Human Resources Director
I. Call to order
Meeting was called to order at 4:32 pm
Executive session commenced at 4:33 pm to discuss items listed under old business,
session ended at 4:45 pm
II. Approval of December 29, 2021 meeting minutes
• Commissioner Cassidy moved to approve the meeting minutes from 12/29/21,
Commission McNaughton seconded the motion. Minutes approved.
III. Report of appointments to the Competitive, Non-Competitive, Exempt and Labor Class
The Civil Service Office reported on the following Permanent Appointments in the
Competitive Class:
Name Title Agency/Department Date
Owen Fingar Library Clerk Albany Public Library 08/21/2021
Daniel Barker Librarian II Albany Public Library 12/19/21
Vincent Thompson Director of School Security Albany School District 12/23/2021
The Civil Service Office reported on the following Permanent Promotions in the
Competitive Class:
Name Title Agency/Department Date
Meaghan DePaula Human Resources Generalist III Police Department 01/01/2022
The Civil Service Office reported on the following Provisional Appointments in the
Competitive Class:
Name Title Agency/Department Date
Abdul Gross Hall Monitor Albany School District 11/19/2021
Kevin Parker Hall Monitor Albany School District 11/19/2021
Emily Wilwerth Senior Library Clerk Albany Public Library 12/19/2021
Alexandra Storm Telecommunications Specialist Police Department 12/20/2021
City of Albany Municipal Civil Service Commission
January 19, 2022 Meeting Agenda
Name Title Agency/Department Date
Tamir Davis-Kimbrough Telecommunications Specialist Police Department 12/20/2021
Malachi Brooks Telecommunications Specialist Police Department 12/20/2021
Dominic Ingegni Telecommunications Specialist Police Department 12/20/2021
Toni Garcia Telecommunications Specialist Police Department 12/20/2021
Mustafa Abdullah Telecommunications Specialist Police Department 12/26/2021
Dept. of General
William Lavigne City Arborist 01/01/2022
Services
Dept. of General
Justin Epstein Communications Coordinator 01/01/2022
Services
Dept. of General
Molli Powers Information Clerk III 01/01/2022
Services
Dept. of Water & Water
Justin Schievelbein Operations Manager 01/01/2022
Supply
Dept. of General
Timothy Finnegan Safety & Training Coordinator 01/01/2022
Services
Water Treatment Plant Dept. of Water & Water
Trent Shaver 01/03/2022
Maintenance Supervisor Supply
Dept. of Administrative
Nikki Jones Purchasing Agent 01/24/2022
Services
The Civil Service Office reported on the following Provisional Promotions in the
Competitive Class:
Name Title Agency/Department Date
Dept. of General
Jackie Beattie Information Clerk III 01/01/2022
Services
The Civil Service Office reported on the following Non-Competitive Class
appointments:
Name Title Agency/Department Date
Dept. of General
Issiah Cain Laborer I 05/27/2021
Services
Dept. of Water & Water
Cory Lee Laborer III 12/13/2021
Supply
Scott Lasher Boxing Aide Dept. of Recreation 01/01/2022
The Civil Service Office reported on the following Labor Class appointments:
Name Title Agency/Department Date
Lisa Berdine Food Service Helper Albany School District 08/31/2021
Daquan Johnson Custodial Worker Albany School District 11/1/2021
Victoria Ruiz Custodial Worker Dept. of Recreation 12/06/2021
Simon Robinson Recreation Aide Dept. of Recreation 01/01/2022
Darra Thomas Recreation Aide Dept. of Recreation 01//01/2022
Darra Thomas Recreation Aide Dept. of Recreation 01/10/2022
IV. Establishment of Eligible Lists
2
City of Albany Municipal Civil Service Commission
January 19, 2022 Meeting Agenda
Engineer
Recycling Specialist
Commissioner McNaughton moved to establishes eligible lists noted above,
Commission Cassidy seconded the motion. Eligible lists established.
V. Creation of New Job Specifications
Director of Human Resources (Albany Public Library)
Director of Finance (Albany Public Library)
Commissioner McNaughton moved to accept job specifications noted above,
Commission Cassidy seconded the motion.
VI. Firefighter list #63-185 Non-Selections
Not Recommended for Hire after Psychological Testing & Evaluation: 2
candidates
Failing to Appear for Psychological Testing & Evaluation: 1 candidate - Andrew
Doyle
Ineligible for Hire due to Residency: 1 candidate- Travis Harnischfeger
No EMT Certification: 7 candidates
Ryan Katinas Noah Seeley
Adam McGuire Michael Wright
Timothy Robertson Phillip Farrell
John Alfano
Withdrew: 2 candidates- Paul Caperna and Brody Delorenzo
Commissioner McNaughton moved to approve all non-selections noted
above, Commission Cassidy seconded the motion.
VII. Firefighter list #63-185 Appeals
Not recommended for hire after psychological testing and evaluation- 1 candidate
appealing
Commissioner McNaughton moved to uphold non-selection for appeal noted
above, Commission Cassidy seconded the motion. Candidate’s non-
selection was upheld.
VIII. Old Business
No old business reported.
3
City of Albany Municipal Civil Service Commission
January 19, 2022 Meeting Agenda
IX. New Business
Residency exemption request for exam #63-185 Firefighter (current round of hiring
only)
Albany Public Library residency exemption request for continuous recruitment exam
#10-418 Library Clerk
• Commissioner McNaughton moved to approve both exemptions noted,
Commission Cassidy seconded the motion. Exemptions approved.
X. Adjournment
• The Commission adjourned at 5:02 p.m.
Next regular meeting: Wednesday, February 23, 2022
• The Commission discussed possible of a special meeting . Date TBD.
4
Agenda
AGENDA
Meeting of the Albany Municipal Civil Service Commission held on Tuesday, January 19,
2022 at 4:30pm via video conference in accordance with legislation (S.50001/A.40001)
extending virtual access to public meetings under New York State's Open Meetings Law.
ATTENDEES: Thomas McNaughton, Commissioner and Chair
Linda Jackson-Chalmers, Commissioner
Michael Cassidy, Commissioner
Phillip Banaszek, City of Albany Assistant Corporation Counsel
Tatiana Diaz, City of Albany Human Resources Generalist III
Tolani Elumade, City of Albany Human Resources Director
I. Call to order
II. Approval of December 29, 2021 meeting minutes
III. Report of appointments to the Competitive, Non-Competitive, Exempt and Labor Class
The Civil Service Office reported on the following Permanent Appointments in the
Competitive Class:
Name Title Agency/Department Date
Owen Fingar Library Clerk Albany Public Library 08/21/2021
Daniel Barker Librarian II Albany Public Library 12/19/21
Vincent Thompson Director of School Security Albany School District 12/23/2021
The Civil Service Office reported on the following Permanent Promotions in the
Competitive Class:
Name Title Agency/Department Date
Meaghan DePaula Human Resources Generalist III Police Department 01/01/2022
The Civil Service Office reported on the following Provisional Appointments in the
Competitive Class:
Name Title Agency/Department Date
Abdul Gross Hall Monitor Albany School District 11/19/2021
Kevin Parker Hall Monitor Albany School District 11/19/2021
Emily Wilwerth Senior Library Clerk Albany Public Library 12/19/2021
Alexandra Storm Telecommunications Specialist Police Department 12/20/2021
Tamir Davis-Kimbrough Telecommunications Specialist Police Department 12/20/2021
Malachi Brooks Telecommunications Specialist Police Department 12/20/2021
Dominic Ingegni Telecommunications Specialist Police Department 12/20/2021
Toni Garcia Telecommunications Specialist Police Department 12/20/2021
Mustafa Abdullah Telecommunications Specialist Police Department 12/26/2021
Dept. of General
William Lavigne City Arborist 01/01/2022
Services
City of Albany Municipal Civil Service Commission
January 19, 2022 Meeting Agenda
Name Title Agency/Department Date
Dept. of General
Justin Epstein Communications Coordinator 01/01/2022
Services
Dept. of General
Molli Powers Information Clerk III 01/01/2022
Services
Dept. of Water & Water
Justin Schievelbein Operations Manager 01/01/2022
Supply
Dept. of General
Timothy Finnegan Safety & Training Coordinator 01/01/2022
Services
Water Treatment Plant Dept. of Water & Water
Trent Shaver 01/03/2022
Maintenance Supervisor Supply
Dept. of Administrative
Nikki Jones Purchasing Agent 01/24/2022
Services
The Civil Service Office reported on the following Provisional Promotions in the
Competitive Class:
Name Title Agency/Department Date
Dept. of General
Jackie Beattie Information Clerk III 01/01/2022
Services
The Civil Service Office reported on the following Non-Competitive Class
appointments:
Name Title Agency/Department Date
Dept. of General
Issiah Cain Laborer I 05/27/2021
Services
Dept. of Water & Water
Cory Lee Laborer III 12/13/2021
Supply
Scott Lasher Boxing Aide Dept. of Recreation 01/01/2022
The Civil Service Office reported on the following Labor Class appointments:
Name Title Agency/Department Date
Lisa Berdine Food Service Helper Albany School District 08/31/2021
Daquan Johnson Custodial Worker Albany School District 11/1/2021
Victoria Ruiz Custodial Worker Dept. of Recreation 12/06/2021
Simon Robinson Recreation Aide Dept. of Recreation 01/01/2022
Darra Thomas Recreation Aide Dept. of Recreation 01//01/2022
Darra Thomas Recreation Aide Dept. of Recreation 01/10/2022
IV. Establishment of Eligible Lists
Engineer
Recycling Specialist
V. Creation of New Job Specifications
Director of Human Resources (Albany Public Library)
2
City of Albany Municipal Civil Service Commission
January 19, 2022 Meeting Agenda
Director of Finance (Albany Public Library)
VI. Firefighter list #63-185 Non-Selections
Not Recommended for Hire after Psychological Testing & Evaluation: 2
candidates
Failing to Appear for Psychological Testing & Evaluation: 1 candidate - Andrew
Doyle
Ineligible for Hire due to Residency: 1 candidate- Travis Harnischfeger
No EMT Certification: 7 candidates
Ryan Katinas Noah Seeley
Adam McGuire Michael Wright
Timothy Robertson Phillip Farrell
John Alfano
Withdrew: 2 candidates- Paul Caperna and Brody Delorenzo
VII. Firefighter list #63-185 Appeals
Not recommended for hire after psychological testing and evaluation- 1 candidate
appealing
VIII. Old Business
IX. New Business
Residency exemption request for exam #63-185 Firefighter (current round of hiring
only)
Albany Public Library residency exemption request for continuous recruitment exam
#10-418 Library Clerk
X. Adjournment
Next regular meeting: Wednesday, February 23, 2022
3
Get email alerts for Albany
A daily email when new agendas and minutes are posted.