Planning, Economic Development and Land Use Committee
Regular MeetingAlbany, NY · July 16, 2020
Minutes
COMMON COUNCIL COMMITTEE MEETING
PLANNING, ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT AND LAND USE COMMITTEE
Cathy Fahey, Chair
Meeting called by: Cathy Fahey, Chair Date: 07-16-20 Time: 5:30PM
Committee Members
Present: Fahey, Chair ☒ Doesschate ☒ Balarin ☒ Love ☐ Hoey ☒
Brad Glass – Deputy Director of Department of Planning
Amy Lavine – Assistant Corporation Counsel
Stephanie Ferradino
James Garrison
Kelsey Carr
Jahkeen Hoke
Joseph A. Granich
Invitees/Speakers Anthony DeThomasis
Council Members
Present: Frederick, O’Brien and Farrell
City Personnel
Present: Danielle Gillespie and John-Raphael Pichardo
Minutes
Agenda Item (s):
RESOLUTION NUMBER 62.71.20R
RESOLUTION OF THE COMMON COUNCIL REGARDING POTENTIAL BROWNFIELD SITES
ORDINANCE 9.61.20
AN ORDINANCE AMENDING CHAPTER 375 OF THE CODE OF THE CITY
OF ALBANY (UNIFIED SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT ORDINANCE) CHANGING
THE ZONING CLASSIFICATIONS AND AMENDING THE ZONING MAP
ACCORDINGLY
Questions and Discussion
• Council member O’Brien provided justification for Resolution 62.71.20R
• Brad Glass spoke on Resolution 62.71.20R which Mike O’Brien has responded to
• Joseph A. Granich and Anthony DeThomasis presented information on the potential Brownfield at 60 Colvin
• Council Members Balarin, Doeeschate, Hoey, and O’Brien asked questions which Joseph A. Granich, Anthony
DeThomasis and Brad Glass answered
• Council President Ellis spoke on the Resolution
• Council member O’Brien, Fahey, Doesschate, Balarin and O’Brien spoke on the Resolution
• Council Member Doesschate made a motion to table Resolution 62.71.20R, which was seconded by Council
Fahey. Two in aye and two in abstain, motion failed.
• Stephanie Ferradino, Kelsey Carr and James Garrison reviewed presented on zoning map amendment review
standards 375-5(E)24(c)
• Council members Fahey, Balarin spoke on Ordinance 9.61.20
• Council member Balarin and Fahey asked question which James Garrison and Stephanie Ferradino answered
• Jahkeen Hoke, Stephanie Ferradino and James Garrison spoke on Ordinance 9.61.20
• Council member Doesschate, and Balarin provide some final thoughts on Ordinance 9.61.20
Public Comment:
Joseph A. Granich, Esq, 21 Colvin Ave, Albany, NY 12206 (Oppose Resolution 62.71.20R)
Anthony DeThomasis, 1 Rapp Rd, Albany, NY (Oppose Resolution 62.71.20R)
Debra Hollner, 40 Clermont St, Albany, NY (Support Resolution 62.71.20R)
Lisa Somerville, 40 Clermont St, Albany, NY (Support Resolution 62.71.20R)
MaryJo Ehrlich, 109 Colonial Avenue, Albany, NY (Support Resolution 62.71.20R)
Mark Castiglione, 50 Parkwood Street, Albany, NY (Oppose Resolution 62.71.20R)
Eugene Smith, 43 Danker Ave, Albany, NY (Support Resolution 62.71.20R)
Ellen Smith, 34 Danker Avenue, Albany, NY (Support Resolution 62.71.20R)
Stephen Burke, 11 Clarendon Road, Albany, NY (Support Resolution 62.71.20R)
Amy Lolik, 23 Tudor Road, Albany, NY (Support Resolution 62.71.20R)
Maura McNulty, 108 Clermont St, Albany, NY (Support Resolution 62.71.20R)
Elizabeth Berberian, 25 Clarendon Road, Albany, NY (Support Resolution 62.71.20R)
Juliet Turner, 5 Tudor Road, Albany, NY (Support Resolution 62.71.20R)
Catina Mavodones, 59 Melrose Avenue, Albany, NY (Support Resolution 62.71.20R)
Eugene Smith, 43 Danker Ave, Albany, NY (Support Resolution 62.71.20R)
Mark Earmer & Paul Lamar, 143 Rosemont St, Albany, NY (Support Resolution 62.71.20R)
Mary Beilby, 9 David Ct, Albany, NY 12208 (Support Resolution 62.71.20R)
Gene Solan, 16 Prospect Ter, Albany, NY 12208 (Support Resolution 62.71.20R)
Adjourn:
The chairperson asked for a motion to adjourn, which was duly made, seconded, and passed.
Respectfully Submitted,
Michele Andre
Senior Legislative Aide to Common Council
This meeting was held following Governor Cuomo’s executive order 202.1 and Mayor Sheehan’s emergency
order 315-1b. It live streamed on Facebook using Zoom as the meeting platform.
Agenda
COMMON COUNCIL MEETING
PLANNING, ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT AND LAND USE COMMITTEE
Cathy Fahey, Chair
DATE: Thursday, July 16, 2020
TIME: 5:30 p.m.
TOPIC(S) OF DISCUSSION/CONSIDERATION:
RESOLUTION NUMBER 62.71.20R
RESOLUTION OF THE COMMON COUNCIL REGARDING POTENTIAL
BROWNFIELD SITES
ORDINANCE 9.61.20
AN ORDINANCE AMENDING CHAPTER 375 OF THE CODE OF THE CITY
OF ALBANY (UNIFIED SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT ORDINANCE) CHANGING
THE ZONING CLASSIFICATIONS AND AMENDING THE ZONING MAP
ACCORDINGLY
PUBLIC COMMENT PERIOD: YES
The meeting is being held in accordance to Executive Order 202.15 which prohibits in-person
attendance at public meetings, if executive order 202.15 expires before July 16, 2020, this will be an in-
person meeting in City Hall, please check our website and Facebook for updates. Please submit your
public comment via email commoncouncil@albanyny.gov or on our website
https://www.albanyny.gov/Government/CityOfficials/CommonCouncil.aspx by Thursday, July 16, 2020
12pm which will be read for the record at the meeting.
Meeting will be held using Zoom and streamed through the Albany Common Council’s Facebook. To
stream this video please visit: https://www.facebook.com/albany.commoncouncil
If any technical problems, the video will then be streamed to YouTube:
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC-rQHp1fBLPcdk_4N6J4XbQ
Council Member O’Brien introduced the following:
RESOLUTION NUMBER 62.71.20R
RESOLUTION OF THE COMMON COUNCIL REGARDING POTENTIAL
BROWNFIELD SITES
WHEREAS, Albany 2030, the City of Albany Comprehensive Plan, was adopted by the Common
Council on April 2, 2012 as the foundation and reference point for the city’s policy and decision-making
over the next approximately two decades; and
WHEREAS, the Plan was put together over a three year process in six phases of development,
enlisting much community and professional input; and
WHEREAS, preparation of a Brownfield Nomination Study was integrated into the Albany 2030
planning process; and
WHEREAS, of the various potential brownfield sites in Albany, the 2030 Plan chose seven sites
pursuant to the NYS Department of State’s Brownfield Opportunities Areas Program. Among the seven
sites is land identified as Site E consisting of 60 Colvin Ave (1.8 acres) and land immediately behind it (2.4
acres) identified as 60B Colvin Ave which property currently belongs to the City of Albany and is used as
the dog park area of Westland Hills Park; and
WHEREAS, this area was used by a wrecking company and by an auto company that stored
building debris and auto components. According to Albany 2030 Plan Appendix A, environmental
assessment of the property, which was done several years ago, shows that subsurface soils on site have
been impacted by asbestos, heavy metals, and other hazardous materials. Additionally, old maps of Albany
show wetlands on this area identified as Schafers Pond; and
WHEREAS, currently a developer is seeking approval to construct 63 apartments and some
commercial space on the 60 Colvin Ave portion of the site and the matter is currently scheduled before the
City of Albany Planning Board as Project #00357; and
WHEREAS, the developer’s application makes no mention of the site’s listing in the Brownfield
Appendix A of the 2030 Plan but public comment submitted at the June 22, 2020 Planning Board meeting
requested that the site should be reviewed by consultants independent of the applicant developer to
determine whether proper mitigation standards will be met in developing this site; and
WHEREAS, the Planning Director stated “Reference to a site location as a brownfield, or as in the
case of the Comprehensive Plan, a potential brownfield, is not de-facto evidence of contaminants at the
site. The designations are sometimes based upon perception alone if that perception is encumbering of a
higher and better use of the site”; and
WHEREAS, it appears that the Albany Planning Board is preparing to override the 2030 Plan’s
declaration of this site as a potential brownfield cleanup area;
NOW THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED, the Common Council declares that if the Planning
Department and/or the Planning Board believes that any 2030 Plan site designation or characterization is
in error, it should not make any such ruling on its own, but instead refer the matter for consideration in the
same manner by which the 2030 Plan itself was enacted.
To: Danielle Gillespie, City Clerk
From: John-Raphael Pichardo, Esq., Research Counsel
Re: Request for Common Council Legislation
Supporting Memorandum
Date: June 25, 2020
SPONSOR Council Member O’Brien
RESOLUTION NUMBER 62.71.20R
TITLE
RESOLUTION OF THE COMMON COUNCIL REGARDING POTENTIAL BROWNFIELD
SITES
GENERAL PURPOSE OF LEGISLATION
Should the Planning Department and/or the Planning Board believe that any 2030 Plan site
designation or characterization is in error, it should not make any such ruling on its own, but
instead refer the matter back for consideration in the same manner by which the 2030 Plan itself
was enacted.
NECESSITY FOR LEGISLATION AND ANY CHANGE TO EXISTING LAW
See body of text.
FISCAL IMPACT(S)
None.
Council Member Frederick introduced the following:
ORDINANCE 9.61.20
AN ORDINANCE AMENDING CHAPTER 375 OF THE CODE OF THE CITY
OF ALBANY (UNIFIED SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT ORDINANCE) CHANGING
THE ZONING CLASSIFICATIONS AND AMENDING THE ZONING MAP
ACCORDINGLY
The City of Albany, in Common Council convened, does hereby ordain and enact:
Section 1. Chapter 375 of the Code of the City of Albany (Unified Sustainable
Development Ordinance) and the Official Zoning Map are hereby amended to change the zoning
classifications of 90 Second Avenue, 88 Second Avenue, 86 Second Avenue, 84 Second Avenue,
76 Second Avenue from Mixed-Use Neighborhood Edge (MU-NE) to Mixed-Use
Campus/Institutional (MU-CI) said properties being more particularly described as follows:
All that parcel of land situated in the City of Albany, County of Albany and State of New
York, identified on the tax map as follows:
Section: 76.72
Block: 4
Lot: 13
Said premises more commonly known as 90 Second Avenue measuring approximately 25’ by
150’.
Section: 76.72
Block: 4
Lot: 14
Said premises more commonly known as 88 Second Avenue measuring approximately 25’ by
150’.
Section: 76.72
Block: 4
Lot: 15
Said premises more commonly known as 86 Second Avenue measuring approximately 25’ by
150’.
Section: 76.72
Block: 4
Lot: 16
Said premises more commonly known as 84 Second Avenue measuring approximately 25’ by
150’.
Section: 76.72
Block: 4
Lot: 20
Sub lot: 1
Section 2. Chapter 375 of the Code of the City of Albany (Unified Sustainable
Development Ordinance) and the Official Zoning Map are hereby amended to change the zoning
classifications of 8 Leonard Street, 10 Leonard Street, 12 Leonard Street, 4 Leonard Street, 15
Scott Street, 13 Scott Street, 11 Scott Street, 9 Scott Street, 7 Scott Street, 10 Krank Street, 15
Krank Street, 1 Scott Street, 10 Scott Street, 8 Scott Street, 6 Scott Street, 4 Scott Street, 33 Krank
Street, 37 Krank Street, 45 Krank Street, 32 Leonard Street, 17 Leonard Street, 16.5 Leonard
Street, 24 Leonard Street, 22 Leonard Street, 20 Leonard Street, 18 Leonard Street, 2 Leonard
Street, from Townhome (R-T) to Mixed-Use Campus/Institutional (MU-CI) said properties being
more particularly described as follows:
All that parcel of land situated in the City of Albany, County of Albany and State of New
York, identified on the tax map as follows:
Section: 76.72
Block: 4
Lot: 36
Said premises more commonly known as 8 Leonard Street.
Section: 76.72
Block: 4
Lot: 35
Said premises more commonly known as 10 Leonard Street.
Section: 76.72
Block: 4
Lot: 34
Said premises more commonly known as 12 Leonard Street.
Section: 76.72
Block: 4
Lot: 33
Said premises more commonly known as 4 Leonard Street.
Section: 76.72
Block: 4
Lot: 32
Said premises more commonly known as 15 Scott Street.
Section: 76.72
Block: 4
Lot: 31
Said premises more commonly known as 13 Scott Street.
Section: 76.72
Block: 4
Lot: 30
Said premises more commonly known as11 Scott Street.
Section: 76.72
Block: 4
Lot: 29
Said premises more commonly known as 9 Scott Street.
Section: 76.72
Block: 4
Lot: 28
Said premises more commonly known as 7 Scott Street.
Section: 76.72
Block: 4
Lot: 27
Said premises more commonly known as 10 Krank Street.
Section: 76.72
Block: 4
Lot: 26
Said premises more commonly known as 15 Krank Street.
Section: 76.72
Block: 4
Lot: 78
Said premises more commonly known as 1 Scott Street.
Section: 76.72
Block: 4
Lot: 77
Said premises more commonly known as 10 Scott Street.
Section: 76.72
Block: 4
Lot: 76
Said premises more commonly known as 8 Scott Street.
Section: 76.72
Block: 4
Lot: 75
Said premises more commonly known as 6 Scott Street.
Section: 76.72
Block: 4
Lot: 74
Said premises more commonly known as 4 Scott Street.
Section: 76.72
Block: 4
Lot: 72
Said premises more commonly known as 33 Krank Street.
Section: 76.72
Block: 4
Lot: 70
Said premises more commonly known as 37 Krank Street.
Section: 76.72
Block: 4
Lot: 69
Said premises more commonly known as 45 Krank Street.
Section: 76.72
Block: 4
Lot: 68
Said premises more commonly known as 32 Leonard Street.
Section: 76.72
Block: 4
Lot: 67
Said premises more commonly known as 17 Leonard Street.
Section: 76.72
Block: 4
Lot: 66
Said premises more commonly known as 16.5 Leonard Street.
Section: 76.72
Block: 4
Lot: 65
Said premises more commonly known as 24 Leonard Street.
Section: 76.72
Block: 4
Lot: 64
Said premises more commonly known as 22 Leonard Street.
Section: 76.72
Block: 4
Lot: 63
Said premises more commonly known as 20 Leonard Street.
Section: 76.72
Block: 4
Lot: 62
Said premises more commonly known as 18 Leonard Street.
Section: 76.72
Block: 4
Lot: 61
Said premises more commonly known as 2 Leonard Street.
Section 3. This ordinance shall take effect immediately.
APPROVED AS TO FORM
THIS 22ND DAY OF MAY, 2020
__________________________
Corporation Counsel
To: Danielle Gillespie, City Clerk
From: John-Raphael Pichardo, Esq., Research Counsel
Re: Request for Common Council Legislation
Supporting Memorandum
Date: May 22, 2020
SPONSOR Councilmember Fredrick
ORDINANCE NUMBER
TITLE
AN ORDINANCE AMENDING CHAPTER 375 OF THE CODE OF THE CITY
OF ALBANY (UNIFIED SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT ORDINANCE) CHANGING THE
ZONING CLASSIFICATIONS AND AMENDING THE ZONING MAP ACCORDINGLY
GENERAL PURPOSE OF LEGISLATION
This zoning map amendment proposes to rezone parcels located at 90 Second Avenue, 88 Second
Avenue, 86 Second Avenue, 84 Second Avenue, 76 Second Avenue from Mixed-Use
Neighborhood Edge (MU-NE) to Mixed-Use Campus/Institutional (MU-CI), as well as rezone
parcels located at 8 Leonard Street, 10 Leonard Street, 12 Leonard Street, 4 Leonard Street, 15
Scott Street, 13 Scott Street, 11 Scott Street, 9 Scott Street, 7 Scott Street, 10 Krank Street, 15
Krank Street, 1 Scott Street, 10 Scott Street, 8 Scott Street, 6 Scott Street, 4 Scott Street, 33 Krank
Street, 37 Krank Street, 45 Krank Street, 32 Leonard Street, 17 Leonard Street, 16.5 Leonard
Street, 24 Leonard Street, 22 Leonard Street, 20 Leonard Street, 18 Leonard Street, 2 Leonard
Street, from Townhome (R-T) to Mixed-Use Campus/Institutional (MU-CI)
The purpose of the MU-CI district is to provide for sites or campuses with large public and
institutional facilities such as hospitals, museums, and institutions of higher education. Additional
land uses include a variety of retail, commercial, and residential uses traditionally associated with
these large institutions. The MU-CI districts allow for buildings of upwards of 7 stories to be
erected as well.
NECESSITY FOR LEGISLATIONN AND CHANGES TO EXISTING LAW
Development in the area is highly anticipated. The MU-CI would allow for the area to produce
mixed use residential areas with retail. Also known as “Eat, Play, Work” which has been highly
well received and positively impacted the economies of several municipalities throughout the
nation.
FISCAL IMPACTS:
None.
Get email alerts for Albany
A daily email when new agendas and minutes are posted.