Ann Arbor Public Art Commission
Regular MeetingAnn Arbor, MI · November 8, 2023
Minutes
City of Ann Arbor 301 E. Huron St.
Ann Arbor, MI 48104
http://a2gov.legistar.com/
Meeting Minutes - Draft Calendar.aspx
Ann Arbor Public Art Commission
Wednesday, November 8, 2023 7:00 PM Electronic Meeting
Wednesday November 8 at 7pm
Live Public Art Commission Meeting Live
on CTN Channel 19
Wednesday November 8 at 7pm
Webinar ID 927 4816 0648
Join from a PC, Mac, iPad, iPhone or Android device:
Please click this URL to join.
iPhone or Android device: Please click this URL to join.
https://a2gov.zoom.us/j/92748160648?pwd=b3
ROLL CALL
Approved
Present: 10 - John Kotarski, Allison Buck, Venita Harrison, Peggy
Wier-Leonard, Sophie Grillet, Sarah Fuller, Marianetta
Porter, Cynthia Harrison, Mary Thiefels, and Fang Zhang
Absent: 1- Jamall Bufford
APPROVAL OF AGENDA
Additions:
*Sculpture Donation by Ann Arbor Art Fair
*Introduction of Commissioner Fung Zhang - In Ann Arbor since 2016
invited by the University of Michigan as a scholar. Works at U-M as
adjunct lecturer and taught at EMU this past semester. Currently
preparing for a ZOOM conversation with the Curator of Contemporary Art
with the Center for Chinese Studies and co-sponsored by UMMA. Desire
to return to teaching contemporary art this coming winter. Mother of three
and will contiue reachcer of Asia art to her students.
Approved with changes
City of Ann Arbor Page 1
Ann Arbor Public Art Commission Meeting Minutes - Draft November 8, 2023
PUBLIC COMMENT
Presenters;
Manny Montoya, City Cellular Infrastructure Manager
Melissa Schacht, Adopt-a-Park Coordinator
The City of Ann Arbor will celebrate its bicentennial in 2024, and as part
of the celebrations, City staff are seeking artists to submit proposals for
mural designs that recognize the past, present, and future of our
community and celebrate 200 years of Ann Arbor! One selected artist will
receive a $25,000 contract with the City for the purchase and installation
of their design on two basketball courts in City parks.
Bicentennial Murals installed at Leslie Park and Southeast Area park on
the basketball courts with NCAA court standards. With inclusion of the
City Bicentennial logo in the center of the court and the use of
water-based traffic paint. Proposals must be submitted by 5 p.m. on
Monday, December 4, 2023.
Proposals should be submitted by email to
bicentennialmurals@a2gov.org.
Must include:
I. Photos or sketches of proposed mural design.Only one design per
entry.
II. A written description of the design’s inspiration and relation to the
city’s bicentennial.
III. A written description of the proposed installation process,including:
*list of proposed materials
*plan for incorporating at least 10 volunteer hours
IV. A brief description of the artist’s connection to AnnArbor.
V. A proposed budget breakdown.
The City will allocate $25,000 for the installation of both identical
murals,inclusive of all materials,labor,and creative effort.
The City will select three finalists from the proposals submitted which
meet the criteria below. Finalist entries will be displayed online and at
Larcom City Hall for community input, which will begin Friday, January
12, 2024. The City will consider this community input when selecting the
winning proposal, which will be announced in March 2024. The two
runners-up will each receive $500.
City of Ann Arbor Page 2
Ann Arbor Public Art Commission Meeting Minutes - Draft November 8, 2023
Questions/Recommendations and Discussion;
*Three weeks does not seem long enough for an artist - can more time be
added?
Staff - Yes, we can be flexible and work with the artist on their needs. The
final timeline sets announcement in July of 2024. Call for art ask for a list
of materials and this will allow staff time to assist.
Commissioner Kotarski -
*Call out and requirements will guide this process
*Survey out to the community
*Materials have been shared with Art Commissioners
*Located on the surface of the court (2) half courts and (1) full court
(Leslie) (Court could be identical or elect to change design.
*Send out to UM and EMU School of Arts. Perhaps students can work
together as a team
*Public Engagement is planned and welcome feedback from the
community
*Selection process is a great way to promote the project, artist and parks.
1) Panel/judges are professionals and rep of parks and community
2) Criteria that the panel will be clear and be distributed out to
community i.e, how this group will evaluate the artist, etc.
3) Public input to select finalists so community will understand that final
selections will vote and one with most votes is selected. This will build
community interest and public input matters.
Commissioner Thiefels - Ground murals are becoming more and more
popular. Best practices on materials and the surface prep and cleaning
should be done ahead of time. City should do in-kind support in this area.
Design examples /complexity can be helpful to the artist. Creative
Washtenaw is a great resource to reach help reach the community.
Timeline may be a little tight. There is a research that will need to take
place and efforts in the proposal - this is a lot of work and need to make
sure this is attainable. Artists usually receive a stipend for their design
work. Must have realistic parameters for the artist to work in. Request for
Qualification might be better as you can look through it and select (25)
artist that you invite to see a design and this is attractive to artist.
Staff - These two courts have been prepped for a mural.
City of Ann Arbor Page 3
Ann Arbor Public Art Commission Meeting Minutes - Draft November 8, 2023
Commissioner Fuller - This is a great project! Potential resources via
non-profit company, Project Backboard out of California has created
these types of projects. They share great examples of designs that
incorporate markings and are still vibrant; good resource.
Commissioner Zhang - Encourage artist to do research on Ann Arbor
200 year history and share more details with the artist to help them
develop artistic themes.
Staff - Staff will review your suggestions and notes to collect information to
share with the team.
_______________________________________________________
Artist, Richard Morgan (Richard Allen Studios) Donation
Ann Arbor Art Fair is made up of three non-profits; Guild of Artisans,
State Street and original Art Fair. All three purchased a sculpture by
Artist, Richard Morgan (Richard Allen Studios) to donate to the City in
celebration of the Bicentennial. This piece is 11.16 feet by 41 inches wide
near the base; with the top point being 62 inches. Recommended
placement would be State St and North University; where all (3) fairs
come together. Input from the artist re for maintenance, placard, etc.
Suggestion for lighting to be added as part of the install. January 19thh
kick off event with Destination Ann Arbor. Time for presentation and an
unveiling to add some additional and excitement from the community.
Approved as presented
APPROVAL OF MINUTES
Approved as presented
City of Ann Arbor Page 4
Ann Arbor Public Art Commission Meeting Minutes - Draft November 8, 2023
OLD BUSINESS
Murals That Bridge - After speaking with Northstar Painting, we have
learned that the containment tarps that are being ordered will take up to 4
weeks before they are completed - this puts our timeline for painting the
murals at the very end of October. We are placing the restoration and
mural work on hold until spring of 2024 but will still move forward with all of
the necessary agreements and paperwork that MDOT's and WATCO.
*Project a has been pushed to back to March. Required MDOT and
Legal items have tied this up. Project is fully funded and will proceed
once MDOT/WATCO requirements are met.
UM Prison Creative Arts Project Donation - This mural, a metamorphosis
of the tree will take place, evolving into a kaleidoscope. Council Member
Harrison and Sarah Unrath reviewed possible locations and placement of
the mural, a metamorphosis of the tree will take place, evolving into a
kaleidoscope of butterflies that were individually created by community
members'. The final product resulted in 3 - 4' x 5' panels that are
designed to be hung as a triptych.
*CM Harrison, Sarah and staff reviewed several locations for the
placement of this piece. Recommended location is Municipal Center
above the security station. Staff has since found out that this location is
actually Ash trees and there is a concern that this area should be
maintained as is. This wall is an art piece and as the emerald ash trees
were removed thorough out the City; this wall commemorates this event
and perhaps a plaque should be installed.
Manhole art Final Castings - Our Public Works team will switch to our
final manhole art- expect to begin seeing these covers during our
upcoming constructions season.
PowerART! Vinyl Artwork Reproductions - The DDA/City planning for new
round of PowerART! Legal team currently working on Agreement with
Creative Washtenaw. The DDA/City continue to work on a partnership on
a maintenance agreement/schedule.
*Excited to see another round of installations.
Approved as presented
City of Ann Arbor Page 5
Ann Arbor Public Art Commission Meeting Minutes - Draft November 8, 2023
NEW BUSINESS
As IT begins to work in this space, there was an opportunity to install a
mural within the ceiling alcove of Council Chambers. The Ann Arbor Art
Center vetted artists for this installation and selected Tess Marhofer.
City Council chambers is adorned with a new ceiling mural entitled “They
Will All Be Dreaming.” Painted over the weekend of Oct. 20-22 by artist
and Michigan resident, Tess Marhofer, the work stemmed from their
desire to bring a touch of escapism into the everyday environment.
Marhofer used acrylic paint and brushes while perched on scaffolding to
reach the raised portion of Council chambers. Staff and visitors are
encouraged to look for themselves, with the artist’s reminder that, “even
amidst the chaos of life, there’s a tranquil world above, waiting to ignite
our imagination and provide a sanctuary for dreamers and thinkers alike.”
*Staff will add to the online City art tour.
Teams working on Golden Paintbrush, Flag project. As CIP project come
onboard staff reaching out to share upcoming projects.
*Flag project on track. Mayoral committee in place and staff continue to
pull together all submittals for final sharing with the community.
Commissioner Leonard Ann Arbor Public Schools Art great time to talk
about the City and what makes the city great. Great time sharing flag
history lesson on Ann Arbor flag history with the students. Perhaps we
could share this information with the Mural team as they begin the call for
the basketball court murals. Google doc will be shared with Manny and
his team.
REPORT FROM STAFF
City of Ann Arbor Page 6
Ann Arbor Public Art Commission Meeting Minutes - Draft November 8, 2023
REPORT FROM COMMITTEES
Report on Ann Arbor/Ypsilanti Commission Meeting
Mid September Commissioner Marianetta met with Aaron Seagraves as
a leader of the Ypsilanti art Commission. The Ypsilanti Art Commission
has merged with the Parks department. First meeting upcoming and a
have an additional (3) members. Request to meet as a team to
coordinate an introduction meeting and to discuss ways to better
collaborate with one another. Venita will reach out to Aaron and share
2024 AAPAC meeting dates. Interesting that most of our recent projects
have been championed by our Parks teams.
Kudos to Commissioner Grillet for her efforts to recruit young people to
the commission. Interest from a U or M Masters Business student.
Invitation to attend as a non-voting member as well as on some of our
committee meetings. By- laws allow AAPAC to appoint members. We will
share our working groups for him to understand where his interest are.
Golden Paintbrush Award announced presentation to City Council send a
reminder out to commissioners.
Leadership survey out to all. Please review and share your input by the
17th and we'll then need an election of new chair and vice-chair at our
next meeting. Design Review Board did not meet; no update to share.
ANNOUNCEMENTS:
*Successful Westside Art Hop even with the chilly weather. Here forward
planned for 3rd weekend in June.
*Motawi Tile to hold first winter market event. Staff art sales displayed; Mr
and Mrs. Claus will be present, tile signing and partnering with Metzgers
Restaruant for the sell of German delicacies. Saturday, December 9th at
Motawi tile.
*Keep an eye out for all the winter window art throughout town. Over 70
storefront sign ups in Washtenaw County. Mary and her team currently in
Midland right now.
*November 11th Guild of Artisans fundraiser is this weekend at the
Ypsilanti Cocktail Club. Big Top Bizarre! Activities, contortionist, painting,
City of Ann Arbor Page 7
Ann Arbor Public Art Commission Meeting Minutes - Draft November 8, 2023
silent auction and other fun surprises!
ADJOURN
All persons are encouraged to participate in public meetings. Citizens requiring
translation or sign language services or other reasonable accommodations may
contact the City Clerk's office at 734.794.6140; via e-mail to: cityclerk@a2gov.org; or
by written request addressed and mailed or delivered to:
City Clerk's Office
301 E. Huron St.
Ann Arbor, MI 48104
Requests made with less than two business days' notice may not be able to be
accommodated.
City of Ann Arbor Page 8
Agenda
City of Ann Arbor
301 E. Huron St.
Ann Arbor, MI 48104
http://a2gov.legistar.com/Calendar.aspx
Meeting Agenda - Draft
Wednesday, November 8, 2023
7:00 PM
Wednesday November 8 at 7pm
Electronic Meeting
Webinar ID 927 4816 0648
Ann Arbor Public Art Commission
Join from a PC, Mac, iPad, iPhone or Android device:
Please click this URL to join.
iPhone or Android device: Please click this URL to join.
https://a2gov.zoom.us/j/92748160648?pwd=b3
Ann Arbor Public Art Commission Meeting Agenda - Draft November 8, 2023
ROLL CALL
APPROVAL OF AGENDA
PUBLIC COMMENT
Manual Montoya, OSI and Parks Team presentation on parks Bicentennial Mural Project
APPROVAL OF MINUTES
OLD BUSINESS
Murals That Bridge - After speaking with Northstar Painting, we have learned that the
containment tarps that are being ordered will take up to 4 weeks before they are
completed - this puts our timeline for painting the murals at the very end of October. We
are placing the restoration and mural work on hold until spring of 2024 but will still move
forward with all of the necessary agreements and paperwork that MDOT's and WATCO.
UM Prison Creative Arts Project Donation - This mural, a metamorphosis of the tree will
take place, evolving into a kaleidoscope. Councilmember Harrison and Sarah Unrath
reviewed possible locations and placement of the mural, a metamorphosis of the tree will
take place, evolving into a kaleidoscope of butterflies that were individually created by
community members'. The final product resulted in 3 - 4' x 5' panels that are designed to
be hung as a triptych.
Manhole art Final Castings - Our Public Works team will switch to our final manhole art-
expect to begin seeing these covers during our upcoming constructions season.
PowerART! Vinyl Artwork Reproductions - The DDA/City planning for new PowerART!
Legal team currently working on Agreement with Creative Washtenaw. The DDA/City
continue to work on a partnership on a maintenance agreement/schedule.
NEW BUSINESS
As IT begins to work in this space, there was an opportunity to install a mural within the
ceiling alcove of Council Chambers. The Ann Arbor Art Center vetted artists for this
installation and selected Tess Marhofer.
City Council chambers is adorned with a new ceiling mural entitled “They Will All Be
Dreaming.” Painted over the weekend of Oct. 20-22 by artist and Michigan resident, Tess
Marhofer, the work stemmed from their desire to bring a touch of escapism into the
everyday environment. Marhofer used acrylic paint and brushes while perched on
scaffolding to reach the raised portion of Council chambers. Staff and visitors are
encouraged to look for themselves, with the artist’s reminder that, “even amidst the
chaos of life, there’s a tranquil world above, waiting to ignite our imagination and provide
a sanctuary for dreamers and thinkers alike.”
REPORT FROM STAFF
REPORT FROM COMMITTEES
City of Ann Arbor Page 2 Printed on 11/6/2023 7:53:09AM
Ann Arbor Public Art Commission Meeting Agenda - Draft November 8, 2023
ADJOURN
All persons are encouraged to participate in public meetings. Citizens requiring
translation or sign language services or other reasonable accommodations may
contact the City Clerk's office at 734.794.6140; via e-mail to: cityclerk@a2gov.org; or
by written request addressed and mailed or delivered to:
City Clerk's Office
301 E. Huron St.
Ann Arbor, MI 48104
Requests made with less than two business days' notice may not be able to be
accommodated.
City of Ann Arbor Page 3 Printed on 11/6/2023 7:53:09AM
Get email alerts for Ann Arbor
A daily email when new agendas and minutes are posted.