Board of Administrative Appeals

Agenda prepared by: Office of the City Clerk (925) 779-7009 BOARD OF ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS ADMINISTRATIVE REVIEW PANEL Council Chambers 200 “H” Street JUNE 6, 2019 3:00 P.M. 3:00 P.M. ROLL CALL Deborah Simpson, Chairperson Ademuyiwa “Ade” Adeyemi, Vice Chairperson Marie Livingston Darrell Goodbeer Vacant Vacant, Alternate PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE 1. CONSENT CALENDAR A. APPROVAL OF ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS MEETING MINUTES FOR APRIL 4, 2019 STAFF REPORT Recommended Action: Motion to approve the Meeting Minutes. B. APPROVAL OF ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS MEETING MINUTES FOR MAY 2, 2019 Recommended Action: Motion to approve the Meeting Minutes. STAFF REPORT C. CODE ENFORCEMENT – APPROVAL OF THE LEVY OF SPECIAL ASSESSMENTS ON CERTAIN PROPERTIES FOR UNPAID ADMINISTRATIVE CITATIONS & LIEN PROCESSING FEES FOR THE MONTHS OF MARCH AND APRIL 2019 Recommendation: The Board of Administrative Appeals shall confirm each assessment and the amount thereof, as proposed or as corrected and modified, and order it assessed against the property. The Board shall also direct that the same be recorded with the Contra Costa County Recorder’s Office and thereafter the assessment shall constitute a special assessment and lien against the property. STAFF REPORT  CONSENT CALENDAR – Continued D. BUSINESS LICENSE – APPROVAL OF THE LEVY OF SPECIAL ASSESSMENTS ON CERTAIN PROPERTIES FOR UNPAID BUSINESS LICENSE TAXES AND/OR ADMINISTRATIVE CITATION(S) FOR THE MONTH OF MAY 2019 Recommendation: The Board of Administrative Appeals shall confirm each assessment and the amount thereof, as proposed or as corrected and modified, and order it assessed against the property. The Board shall also direct that the same be recorded with the Contra Costa County Recorder’s Office and thereafter the assessment shall constitute a special assessment and lien against the property. STAFF REPORT STAFF REPORT PUBLIC COMMENTS—Only unagendized issues will be discussed during this time WRITTEN/ORAL COMMUNICATIONS ADJOURNMENT Notice of Availability of Reports This agenda is a summary of the discussion items/actions proposed to be taken by the Board of Administrative Appeals. Materials provided regarding the agenda items will be available at the following website: https://www.antiochca.gov/government/agendas-and-minutes/board-of- administrative-appeals/ or at the City Clerk’s Office, City Hall, 200 H Street, Antioch, CA 94509, Monday through Friday, 8:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m., for inspection and copying (for a fee). Copies are also made available at the Antioch Public Library for inspection. The meetings are accessible to those with disabilities. Auxiliary aides will be made available for persons with hearing or vision disabilities upon request in advance at (925) 779-7009 or TDD (925) 779-7081. Notice of Opportunity to Address the Committee The public has the opportunity to address the Board on each agenda item. To address the Board, fill out a yellow Speaker Request form, available on each side of the entrance doors, and place in the Speaker Card Tray. This will enable us to call upon you to speak. Each speaker is limited to not more than 3 minutes. Comments regarding matters not on this Agenda may be addressed during the "Public Comments" section on the agenda. No one may speak more than once on an agenda item or during “Public Comments”. PLEASE TURN OFF CELL PHONES BEFORE ENTERING COUNCIL CHAMBERS.  BOARD OF ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS ADMINISTRATIVE REVIEW PANEL Regular Meeting April 4, 2019 3:00 P.M. Council Chambers Vice Chairperson Adeyemi called the meeting to order at 3:00 P.M. on Thursday, April 4, 2019 in the Council Chambers. ROLL CALL: Present: Board Members Goodbeer, Livingston and Vice Chairperson Adeyemi Absent: Chairperson Simpson Staff Present: City Attorney, Thomas Lloyd Smith Minutes Clerk, Kitty Eiden Police Captain, Tony Morefield Police Officer, William Dee Code Enforcement Manager, Curt Michael Finance Services Supervisor, Lisa Saunders Finance Services Supervisor, Laurie McNeil Business License Representative, Claudia Argenal Business License Representative, Vanessa Rosales Code Enforcement Officer, Justine Sidie Administrative Analyst, Tammy Leach PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE Vice Chairperson Adeyemi led the board, staff and public in the Pledge of Allegiance. 1. CONSENT CALENDAR A. APPROVAL OF ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS MINUTES FOR MARCH 7, 2019 On motion by Board Member Goodbeer, seconded by Board Member Livingston, the Board of Administrative Appeals approved the Minutes for March 7, 2019. The motion carried the following vote: Ayes: Goodbeer, Livingston and Adeyemi Absent: Simpson B. CODE ENFORCEMENT – APPROVAL OF THE LEVY OF SPECIAL ASSESSMENTS ON CERTAIN PROPERTIES FOR UNPAID ADMINISTRATIVE CITATIONS & ABATEMENTS FOR THE MONTH OF JANUARY 2019. On motion by Board Member Livingston, seconded by Board Member Goodbeer, the Board of Administrative Appeals confirmed each assessment and the amount thereof, as proposed or as corrected and modified, and ordered it assessed against the property. The Board also directed 1A 06-06-19 BOARD OF ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS Regular Meeting March 7, 2019 Page 2 of 5 that the same be recorded with the Contra Costa County Recorder’s Office. The motion carried the following vote: Ayes: Goodbeer, Livingston and Adeyemi Absent: Simpson C. BUSINESS LICENSE – APPROVAL OF THE LEVY OF SPECIAL ASSESSMENTS ON CERTAIN PROPERTIES FOR UNPAID BUSINESS LICENSE TAXES AND/OR ADMINISTRATIVE CITATION(S) FOR THE MONTH OF MARCH 2019. In response to Vice Chairperson Adeyemi, Minutes Clerk Eiden clarified that the Board would be considering the supplemental staff report this afternoon. On motion by Board Member Livingston, seconded by Board Member Goodbeer, the Board of Administrative Appeals confirmed each assessment and the amount thereof, as proposed or as corrected and modified, and ordered it assessed against the property. The Board also directed that the same be recorded with the Contra Costa County Recorder’s Office in the amount of $25,447. The motion carried the following vote: Ayes: Goodbeer, Livingston and Adeyemi Absent: Simpson In response to Vice Chairperson Adeyemi, Business License Representative Rosales clarified that the supplemental staff report replaced the original staff report. 2. REGULAR AGENDA City Attorney Smith explained the manner in which the proceedings would be conducted. OATH for all intending to testify Administrative Services Director Mastay administered the Oath to all those intending to testify. A. APPLICATION OF REGISTRATION FOR “FAR EAST MASSAGE” LOCATED AT 2329 BUCHANNAN ROAD, ANTIOCH, CA – APPEAL FILED BY HUMBERTO ROMERO, 2329 BUCHANNAN ROAD/ 4762 BELFORD PEAK COURT, ANTIOCH, CA., TO OVERTURN THE NOTICE OF DENIAL DETERMINATION MADE BY ANTIOCH POLICE DEPARTMENT [§5-19.14(1)]. Officer Dee, Antioch Police Department, introduced himself and clarified that this item was not related to a citation issued, it was a denial of process for application. He presented the staff report dated April 4, 2019 recommending that the Board of Administrative Appeals uphold the denial issued to Humberto Romero based on Antioch Municipal Code 5-19.18. Humerto Romero, Appellant, distributed exhibits to the Board. He explained that the recommendation to uphold the denial was based on an assumption that his application was in partnership with the current owners. He clarified that his application was submitted prior to the current owner’s permit being revoked. He reported that prior to receiving the denial letter, he BOARD OF ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS Regular Meeting March 7, 2019 Page 3 of 5 spoke with Code Enforcement (CE) Officer Sidie, who stated that as an applicant for the new massage business, he could continue to submit the required forms and employee certificates for review. He noted that Code Enforcement Officer Sidie reviewed his background checks and certificate, visited the business site, and indicated that the business looked good. She also reminded him that once he received the permit, he needed to call for an inspection prior to opening for business; however, two days later he received the denial letter. He stated he then contacted Code Enforcement Officer Sidie who requested that he email her the denial letter so that she could investigate. He noted five days later, Code Enforcement Officer Sidie replied that the application was denied by Officer Dee and he would now need to speak with him regarding this issue. He stated that he contacted Officer Dee who informed him that renewing the original permit was not an option and following two inspections, the municipal code violations had not been resolved. Additionally, he noted that the current massage manager did not show any interest with complying with the City Ordinance. He noted that he discussed his openness with Officer Sidie as well as his completion of the required forms. He noted Officer Dee responded that the only option at this point, would be to file an appeal. In rebuttal to the denial letter, Mr. Romero clarified the following:  In regards to Municipal Code - his application for a new business was submitted prior to the revocation and therefore the code should not apply to him.  In regards to The Antioch Police Department registration letter dated November 2018 – this letter did apply to him nor his 2019 business permit application because the letter was not addressed to him.  In regards to the reference to Police Report 19-002 – this was hear say as no criminal activity was logged or charges filed and no statement was taken from the business.  In regards to the municipal code violations at the business – this was not his business; however, he resolved a majority of the issues prior to the inspection by Code Enforcement. In conclusion, Mr, Romero reiterated that he applied for a new business, not a renewal of the permit. Additionally, he noted the failing business did not belong to him. He further noted that he had submitted a certified license to Code Enforcement Officer Sidie and he had corrected a majority of the municipal code violations. The Board and City Attorney Smith took three minutes to review the handouts provided by the appellant. In response to Board Member Goodbeer, Mr. Romero clarified that his interest was with purchasing the business name and surprise his fiancé who was getting certified in massage. He noted he became aware of the property’s availability because the owner had contacted his fiancés school. He stated he had provided the Board with a business plan to show that he intended to operate in a safe manner. In speaking to the police report, he clarified that the violations had not occurred at his business and he was surprised they were included in the staff report since when he reviewed the history of the business, for the past two years, no violations were found. He added that no charges were filed in the case referenced and he doubted the validity of the narrative provided by the reporting party. He noted that the manager or person in BOARD OF ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS Regular Meeting March 7, 2019 Page 4 of 5 question was never interviewed by the police and the reporting party had only requested a refund. Board Member Goodbeer stated that he understood the appellant’s position; however, section 5-19.16 of the Ordinance indicated that the burden of proof was on the applicant. Additionally, he noted that it was a sensitive business and the guidelines were set out to be adhered to. Mr. Romero stated that he agreed with Board Member Goodbeer; however, he believed the new application was accepted because he was told to proceed. He noted if he had been told there was an issue, he would not have moved forward. He stated he felt the violations had been placed on him; however, he was a new business applicant. He commented that he understood the purpose of Chapter 19 of Title 5 of the Antioch Municipal Code. Board Member Goodbeer commented that the Ordinance was for the protection of the community. In response to Board Member Goodbeer, Mr. Romero stated he did not contact the City regarding their position on his application, prior to receiving the denial letter, because he was busy getting people certified and improving the business. He clarified that the employees mentioned in the police report were employed by the original owners and he had no relationship with them. City Attorney Smith read section 5-19.18 of the Ordinance, “If a registration issued under this Chapter is revoked, no massage establishment shall be authorized to locate in the same location of the establishment where the registration was revoked for a period of 2 years from the effective date of the revocation.” Mr. Romero responded that he had contacted Code Enforcement Officer Sidie in regards to his application and in conversation, she mentioned the Ordinance. He noted he informed her that he was not seeking renewal of the permit because he was applying for a new business license with new employees. He noted at that time she mentioned something to the affect that the permit was submitted prior to the revocation and it was his understanding that she was telling him that he would be all right for him to move forward with the application process. City Attorney Smith stated that he appreciated the explanation; however, the ordinance stated “no massage establishments shall be authorized to locate in the same location of an establishment where the registration was revoked for a period of two years from the effective date of the revocation.” Mr. Romero stated he was unsure of the date of revocation because it was not provided in the staff report and he believed he submitted his application prior to revocation occurring. City Attorney Smith responded that what mattered was whether the application fell within the window of two years after the revocation. He requested staff provide the appellant with the date of revocation. BOARD OF ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS Regular Meeting March 7, 2019 Page 5 of 5 Officer Dee reported that the incident that resulted in the police report being taken occurred on January 3, 2019, the inspection occurred on January 17, 2019, the application was denied on February 4, 2019 and the application was received from the appellant on January 30, 2019. In response to Vice Chairperson Adeyemi, Officer Dee explained that the massage ordinance was adopted in 2018. In response to Board Member Livingston, Officer Dee confirmed the violations occurred under the previous owner; however, under the Ordinance, there was a two-year prohibition against a massage establishment locating in the same location. In response to City Attorney Smith, Officer Dee stated that the revocation occurred approximately one week after an inspection on January 17, 2019. He noted the previous owners came in the following week to reapply for a business license and at that time, they were told the business would be kept closed based on the Antioch Municipal Code. Vice Chairperson Adeyemi stated that within a week after the business was closed, Mr. Romero was applying for a new ownership permit for a business with the same name at the same location. In response to Vice Chairperson Adyemi, City Attorney Smith stated that the Ordinance clearly stated that if a registration issued was revoked, that no massage establishments shall be authorized to locate in the same location for a period of two years after the effective date of revocation. He noted in this case, the revocation occurred in January 2019 and in less than one month the business was attempting to locate in the same location. He clarified that the ordinance did not speak to ownership and in terms of what mattered for the set of facts before the Board; it was the business being located in the same location. On motion by Board Member Livingston, seconded by Board Member Goodbeer, the Board of Administrative Appeals denied the appeal based on Antioch Municipal Code 5-19-18. The motion carried the following vote: Ayes: Livingston, Adeyemi Noes: Goodbeer Absent: Simpson PUBLIC COMMENTS – None WRITTEN/ORAL COMMUNICATIONS – None ADJOURNMENT Vice Chairperson Adeyemi adjourned the Administrative Board of Appeals meeting at 3:45 P.M. to the next regularly scheduled meeting on May 2, 2019. Respectfully submitted: Kitty Eiden KITTY EIDEN, Minutes Clerk  BOARD OF ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS ADMINISTRATIVE REVIEW PANEL Regular Meeting May 2, 2019 3:00 P.M. Council Chambers Chairperson Simpson called the meeting to order at 3:00 P.M. on Thursday, May 2, 2019 in the Council Chambers. ROLL CALL: Present: Board Members Adeyemi, Livingston, and Chairperson Simpson Absent: Board Member Goodbeer Staff Present: Deputy City Clerk, Christina Garcia Administrative Services Director, Nickie Mastay Finance Services Supervisor, Laurie McNeil Business License Representative, Claudia Argenal Code Enforcement Manager, Curt Michael PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE Chairperson Simpson led the board, staff and public in the Pledge of Allegiance. 1. CONSENT CALENDAR A. APPROVAL OF ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS MINUTES FOR APRIL 4, 2019 On motion by Board Member Adeyemi, seconded by Board Member Livingston, the Board of Administrative Appeals approved to continue the April 4, 2019 Meeting Minutes to the next meeting. The motion carried the following vote: Ayes: Adeyemi, Livingston , Simpson Absent: Goodbeer B. BUSINESS LICENSE – APPROVAL OF THE LEVY OF SPECIAL ASSESSMENTS ON CERTAIN PROPERTIES FOR UNPAID BUSINESS LICENSE TAXES AND/OR ADMINISTRATIVE CITATION(S) FOR THE MONTH OF APRIL 2019 Chairperson Simpson reported that the Board had received a supplemental staff report dated May 2, 2019 recommending the Board of Administrative Appeals confirm each assessment for an amended amount of $44,098.00. On motion by Board Member Adeyemi, seconded by Board Member Livingston, the Board of Administrative Appeals unanimously confirmed each assessment and the amount thereof, as proposed or as corrected and modified, and ordered it assessed against the property for the month of April 2019. The Board also directed that the same be recorded with the Contra Costa 1B 06-06-19 BOARD OF ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS Regular Meeting May 2, 2019 Page 2 of 3 County Recorder’s Office in the amended amount of $44,098.00. The motion carried the following vote: Ayes: Adeyemi, Livingston , Simpson Absent: Goodbeer PUBLIC COMMENTS Mark Boyd stated that he wanted to speak about the liens that were passed and that he did not arrive at the meeting on time to speak because Ms. McNeil slowed his entry to the meeting and that he did file his Notice of Intent timely. Chairperson Simpson stated that the Board just passed this item and any other discussion about the liens cannot be held. Mark Boyd then became belligerent stating that he pays the Boards salaries and wanted to know where he could file paperwork to sue the City. Code Enforcement Manager Curt Michael stated that he could file with the City Attorney’s office at which point, Mark Boyd asked who he was and told him to stay out of his business. Chairperson Simpson told Mark Boyd that the Board would listen to what he had to say. Mark Boyd then stated that he objected to the recording of the lien and that the City was violating his right to due process. He stated that the letters sent to him did not have dates or names and that the City was non-responsive to his calls when he objected and complained. He then stated that the only name to appear on a letter was Ms. McNeil’s. He stated that he received a Notice of Intent to Lien and that he was renting residential property and that the City was violating his right to due process. He stated that Ms. McNeil does not respect his rights. Mark Boyd became belligerent. Chairperson Simpson stated to Mark Boyd that he was out of order. Mark Boyd then stated that the Board was out of order. At this time, Code Enforcement Manager Curt Michael called the Police Department. Code Enforcement Manager Curt Michael told Mark Boyd that he had to leave at which time Mark Boyd stood very close to Code Enforcement Manager Curt Michael in a threatening manner. Code Enforcement Manager Curt Michael told Mark Boyd that the Police were on their way to escort him out of the building. Code Enforcement Manager Curt Michael and Mark Boyd were exiting the Council Chambers when the Police arrived. WRITTEN/ORAL COMMUNICATIONS – None BOARD OF ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS Regular Meeting May 2, 2019 Page 3 of 3 ADJOURNMENT Chairperson Simpson adjourned the Administrative Board of Appeals meeting at 3:12 P.M. Respectfully submitted: Nickie Mastay Nickie Mastay, Administrative Services Director 1C  STAFF REPORT TO THE BOARD OF ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS FOR CONSIDERATION AT THE HEARING ON JUNE 6, 2019 DATE: May 20, 2019 APPROVED BY: V. Rosales, Business License Representative SUBJECT: BUSINESS LICENSE – Approval of the Levy of Special Assessments on Certain Properties for Unpaid Business License Taxes and/or Administrative Citation(s) for the Month(s) of May 2019. RECOMMENDATION The Board of Administrative Appeals shall confirm each assessment and the amount thereof, as proposed or as corrected and modified, and order it assessed against the property (Attachment “A”). The Board shall also direct that the same be recorded with the Contra Costa County Recorder’s Office and thereafter the assessment shall constitute a special assessment and lien against the property. FISCAL IMPACT The action will enable the City of Antioch to collect outstanding receivables against properties for Unpaid Business License Taxes and/or Administrative Citation(s) for the month(s) of May 2019 in the amount of $56,399.00. BACKGROUND INFORMATION Pursuant to Antioch Municipal Code §1-5.09 the City may collect any past due Administrative Citation fines, Abatements or late payment charges by use of special assessment liens and all action for recovery of money. A Notice of Intent to Record Lien (Attachment B) was sent to each property owner on May 20, 2019 who is entitled to notice reflecting the property address directly connected to conditions or activities on the subject real property, assessor’s parcel number, the municipal code violation, administrative citation fine and copy of the administrative citations. ATTACHMENTS A: List of Assessments B: Notice of Intent to Record Lien __1D__ 06/06/19 6.6.19 Page 1 BUSINESS LICENSE TAXES AND/OR ADMINISTRATIVE CITATION(S) FOR BOARD OF APPEALS ATTACHMENT A Lien Processing AR Customer # APN Amount Charge Site Address Owner last Owner first Mailing address CHP WIDOWS FUND 2420 SAND CREEK RD #338 153445 C214456 067-223-011-7 1,046.00 411 W 19TH ST LLC CHP WIDOWS FUND LLC BRENTWOOD, CA 94513 CHP WIDOWS FUND 2420 SAND CREEK RD #338 152830 C214456 067-223-011-7 110.00 411 W 19TH ST LLC CHP WIDOWS FUND LLC BRENTWOOD, CA 94513 CHP WIDOWS FUND 2420 SAND CREEK RD #338 152818 C214456 067-223-011-7 220.00 411 W 19TH ST LLC CHP WIDOWS FUND LLC BRENTWOOD, CA 94513 CHP WIDOWS FUND 2420 SAND CREEK RD #338 153901 C214456 067-223-011-7 550.00 296.00 411 W 19TH ST LLC CHP WIDOWS FUND LLC BRENTWOOD, CA 94513 2222.00 CHP WIDOWS FUND 2420 SAND CREEK RD #338 153446 C214456 066-202-001-5 1046.00 800 G ST LLC CHP WIDOWS FUND LLC BRENTWOOD, CA 94513 CHP WIDOWS FUND 2420 SAND CREEK RD #338 152829 C214456 066-202-001-5 110.00 800 G ST LLC CHP WIDOWS FUND LLC BRENTWOOD, CA 94513 CHP WIDOWS FUND 2420 SAND CREEK RD #338 152817 C214456 066-202-001-5 220.00 800 G ST LLC CHP WIDOWS FUND LLC BRENTWOOD, CA 94513 CHP WIDOWS FUND 2420 SAND CREEK RD #338 153900 C214456 066-202-001-5 550.00 296.00 800 G ST LLC CHP WIDOWS FUND LLC BRENTWOOD, CA 94513 2222.00 3440 HILLCREST AVE STE 2423 ROYAL OAKS DR 153861 C218616 052-530-002-6 110.00 100 KARIMIAN SEAN A ALAMO, CA 94507 3440 HILLCREST AVE STE 2423 ROYAL OAKS DR 154200 C218616 052-530-002-6 220.00 100 KARIMIAN SEAN A ALAMO, CA 94507 3440 HILLCREST AVE STE 2423 ROYAL OAKS DR 154751 C218616 052-530-002-6 550.00 296.00 100 KARIMIAN SEAN A ALAMO, CA 94507 1176.00 5680 AUGUSTA CT 156175 C218694 072-190-010-8 1046.00 56 DUNES WAY MALFITANO JOSEPH L & JONI K DISCOVERY BAY, CA 94505 5680 AUGUSTA CT 156176 C218694 072-190-011-8 110.00 303.00 56 DUNES WAY MALFITANO JOSEPH L & JONI K DISCOVERY BAY, CA 94505 1459.00 CLIFTON HILL 22 CLIFTON HL 153837 C214186 072-042-002-5 1046.00 240 BOULDER DR INVESTMENTS CLIFTON HILL INVESTMENTS NW 8 0QG, LO UK CLIFTON HILL 22 CLIFTON HL 153838 C214186 072-042-002-5 110.00 240 BOULDER DR INVESTMENTS CLIFTON HILL INVESTMENTS NW 8 0QG, LO UK CLIFTON HILL 22 CLIFTON HL 154204 C214186 072-042-002-5 220.00 240 BOULDER DR INVESTMENTS CLIFTON HILL INVESTMENTS NW 8 0QG, LO UK CLIFTON HILL 22 CLIFTON HL 154756 C214186 072-042-002-5 550.00 296.00 240 BOULDER DR INVESTMENTS CLIFTON HILL INVESTMENTS NW 8 0QG, LO UK 2222.00 CLIFTON HILL 22 CLIFTON HL 153842 C214186 072-221-003-6 1046.00 404 JADE CT INVESTMENTS CLIFTON HILL INVESTMENTS NW 8 0QG, LO UK CLIFTON HILL 22 CLIFTON HL 153843 C214186 072-221-003-6 110.00 404 JADE CT INVESTMENTS CLIFTON HILL INVESTMENTS NW 8 0QG, LO UK CLIFTON HILL 22 CLIFTON HL 154201 C214186 072-221-003-6 220.00 404 JADE CT INVESTMENTS CLIFTON HILL INVESTMENTS NW 8 0QG, LO UK CLIFTON HILL 22 CLIFTON HL 154754 C214186 072-221-003-6 550.00 296.00 404 JADE CT INVESTMENTS CLIFTON HILL INVESTMENTS NW 8 0QG, LO UK 2222.00 CLIFTON HILL 22 CLIFTON HL 153839 C214186 072-213-006-9 1046.00 405 BOULDER DR INVESTMENTS CLIFTON HILL INVESTMENTS NW 8 0QG, LO UK CLIFTON HILL 22 CLIFTON HL 153840 C214186 072-213-006-9 110.00 405 BOULDER DR INVESTMENTS CLIFTON HILL INVESTMENTS NW 8 0QG, LO UK CLIFTON HILL 22 CLIFTON HL 154203 C214186 072-213-006-9 220.00 405 BOULDER DR INVESTMENTS CLIFTON HILL INVESTMENTS NW 8 0QG, LO UK CLIFTON HILL 22 CLIFTON HL 154755 C214186 072-213-006-9 550.00 296.00 405 BOULDER DR INVESTMENTS CLIFTON HILL INVESTMENTS NW 8 0QG, LO UK 2222.00 CLIFTON HILL 22 CLIFTON HL 153841 C214186 072-350-022-9 1046.00 2417 GREENTREE CT INVESTMENTS CLIFTON HILL INVESTMENTS NW 8 0QG, LO UK CLIFTON HILL 22 CLIFTON HL 157389 C214186 072-350-022-9 110.00 2417 GREENTREE CT INVESTMENTS CLIFTON HILL INVESTMENTS NW 8 0QG, LO UK CLIFTON HILL 22 CLIFTON HL 154202 C214186 072-350-022-9 220.00 2417 GREENTREE CT INVESTMENTS CLIFTON HILL INVESTMENTS NW 8 0QG, LO UK CLIFTON HILL 22 CLIFTON HL 154753 C214186 072-350-022-9 550.00 296.00 2417 GREENTREE CT INVESTMENTS CLIFTON HILL INVESTMENTS NW 8 0QG, LO UK 2222.00  Page 2 6.6.19 BUSINESS LICENSE TAXES AND/OR ADMINISTRATIVE CITATION(S) FOR BOARD OF APPEALS ATTACHMENT A PO BOX 117694 154352 C217688 065-071-020-5 234.00 1205 A ST COLINA IRMA & DON AISH BURLINGAME, CA 94011 PO BOX 117694 154353 C217688 065-071-020-5 110.00 1205 A ST COLINA IRMA & DON AISH BURLINGAME, CA 94011 PO BOX 117694 154765 C217688 065-071-020-5 220.00 1205 A ST COLINA IRMA & DON AISH BURLINGAME, CA 94011 PO BOX 117694 155118 C217688 065-071-020-5 550.00 303.00 1205 A ST COLINA IRMA & DON AISH BURLINGAME, CA 94011 1417.00 1863 PATTERSON MILL WAY 154052 C207906 072-390-039-5 783.00 1758 NANDINA CT LEE LOREEN LAWRENCEVILLE, GA 30044 1863 PATTERSON MILL WAY 154053 C207906 072-390-039-5 110.00 1758 NANDINA CT LEE LOREEN LAWRENCEVILLE, GA 30044 1863 PATTERSON MILL WAY 154305 C207906 072-390-039-5 220.00 1758 NANDINA CT LEE LOREEN LAWRENCEVILLE, GA 30044 1863 PATTERSON MILL WAY 155134 C207906 072-390-039-5 550.00 296.00 1758 NANDINA CT LEE LOREEN LAWRENCEVILLE, GA 30044 1959.00 2012 CERRO CT 154327 C205084 068-071-001-9 1037.00 517 KEAN AVE TRAVIS DARREN WAYNE ANTIOCH, CA 94509 2012 CERRO CT 155130 C205084 068-071-001-9 110.00 517 KEAN AVE TRAVIS DARREN WAYNE ANTIOCH, CA 94509 2012 CERRO CT 155131 C205084 068-071-001-9 220.00 517 KEAN AVE TRAVIS DARREN WAYNE ANTIOCH, CA 94509 2012 CERRO CT 155374 C205084 068-071-001-9 550.00 296.00 517 KEAN AVE TRAVIS DARREN WAYNE ANTIOCH, CA 94509 2213.00 50 ROBINSON AVE 154216 C219366 074-213-001-6 535.00 4701 EISENHOWER WAY HEREDIA SERGIO LAGUNAS PITTSBURG, CA 94565 50 ROBINSON AVE 154740 C219366 074-213-001-6 110.00 4701 EISENHOWER WAY HEREDIA SERGIO LAGUNAS PITTSBURG, CA 94565 50 ROBINSON AVE 155123 C219366 074-213-001-6 220.00 4701 EISENHOWER WAY HEREDIA SERGIO LAGUNAS PITTSBURG, CA 94565 50 ROBINSON AVE 155377 C219366 074-213-001-6 550.00 296.00 4701 EISENHOWER WAY HEREDIA SERGIO LAGUNAS PITTSBURG, CA 94565 1711.00 2955 GROOM DR 155767 C219773 051-243-001-8 284.00 1410 YOSEMITE DR WRIGHT YVONNE SAN PABLO, CA 94806 2955 GROOM DR 155770 C219773 051-243-001-8 110.00 1410 YOSEMITE DR WRIGHT YVONNE SAN PABLO, CA 94806 2955 GROOM DR 155771 C219773 051-243-001-8 220.00 1410 YOSEMITE DR WRIGHT YVONNE SAN PABLO, CA 94806 2955 GROOM DR 156085 C219773 051-243-001-8 550.00 296.00 1410 YOSEMITE DR WRIGHT YVONNE SAN PABLO, CA 94806 1460.00 PO BOX 763 155414 C209976 065-194-018-1 1037.00 1232 GIOVANNI ST YESHAYAHU AARON & KAREN RUBIN ORINDA, CA 94563 PO BOX 763 155415 C209976 065-194-018-1 110.00 1232 GIOVANNI ST YESHAYAHU AARON & KAREN RUBIN ORINDA, CA 94563 PO BOX 763 156048 C209976 065-194-018-1 220.00 1232 GIOVANNI ST YESHAYAHU AARON & KAREN RUBIN ORINDA, CA 94563 PO BOX 763 156137 C209976 065-194-018-1 550.00 303.00 1232 GIOVANNI ST YESHAYAHU AARON & KAREN RUBIN ORINDA, CA 94563 2220.00 PO BOX 763 155416 C209976 065-291-007-6 1007.00 1541 JACOBSEN ST YESHAYAHU AARON & KAREN RUBIN ORINDA, CA 94563 PO BOX 763 1555417 C209976 065-291-007-6 110.00 1541 JACOBSEN ST YESHAYAHU AARON & KAREN RUBIN ORINDA, CA 94563 PO BOX 763 156049 C209976 065-291-007-6 220.00 1541 JACOBSEN ST YESHAYAHU AARON & KAREN RUBIN ORINDA, CA 94563 PO BOX 763 156138 C209976 065-291-007-6 550.00 303.00 1541 JACOBSEN ST YESHAYAHU AARON & KAREN RUBIN ORINDA, CA 94563 2190.00 PO BOX 763 155418 C209976 067-332-020-6 1007.00 112 CATALINE AVE YESHAYAHU AARON & KAREN RUBIN ORINDA, CA 94563 PO BOX 763 155419 C209976 067-332-020-6 110.00 112 CATALINE AVE YESHAYAHU AARON & KAREN RUBIN ORINDA, CA 94563  Page 3 6.6.19 BUSINESS LICENSE TAXES AND/OR ADMINISTRATIVE CITATION(S) FOR BOARD OF APPEALS ATTACHMENT A PO BOX 763 156050 C209976 067-332-020-6 220.00 112 CATALINE AVE YESHAYAHU AARON & KAREN RUBIN ORINDA, CA 94563 PO BOX 763 156139 C209976 067-332-020-6 550.00 303.00 112 CATALINE AVE YESHAYAHU AARON & KAREN RUBIN ORINDA, CA 94563 2190.00 PO BOX 763 155420 C209976 068-123-001-7 1007.00 2401 BEASLEY AVE YESHAYAHU AARON ORINDA, CA 94563 PO BOX 763 155421 C209976 068-123-001-7 110.00 2401 BEASLEY AVE YESHAYAHU AARON ORINDA, CA 94563 PO BOX 763 156051 C209976 068-123-001-7 220.00 2401 BEASLEY AVE YESHAYAHU AARON ORINDA, CA 94563 PO BOX 763 156140 C209976 068-123-001-7 550.00 296.00 2401 BEASLEY AVE YESHAYAHU AARON ORINDA, CA 94563 2183.00 PO BOX 763 155422 C209976 068-243-004-6 1007.00 2801 STAMM DR YESHAYAHU AARON ORINDA, CA 94563 PO BOX 763 155423 C209976 068-243-004-6 110.00 2801 STAMM DR YESHAYAHU AARON ORINDA, CA 94563 PO BOX 763 156052 C209976 068-243-004-6 220.00 2801 STAMM DR YESHAYAHU AARON ORINDA, CA 94563 PO BOX 763 516141 C209976 068-243-004-6 550.00 296.00 2801 STAMM DR YESHAYAHU AARON ORINDA, CA 94563 2183.00 PO BOX 763 155424 C209976 068-242-007-0 1007.00 2724 STAMM DR YESHAYAHU AARON ORINDA, CA 94563 PO BOX 763 155425 C209976 068-242-007-0 110.00 2724 STAMM DR YESHAYAHU AARON ORINDA, CA 94563 PO BOX 763 156053 C209976 068-242-007-0 220.00 2724 STAMM DR YESHAYAHU AARON ORINDA, CA 94563 PO BOX 763 156142 C209976 068-242-007-0 550.00 296.00 2724 STAMM DR YESHAYAHU AARON ORINDA, CA 94563 2183.00 PO BOX 763 155426 C209976 071-032-005-2 1007.00 2724 DOLORES ST YESHAYAHU AARON ORINDA, CA 94563 PO BOX 763 155427 C209976 071-032-005-2 110.00 2724 DOLORES ST YESHAYAHU AARON ORINDA, CA 94563 PO BOX 763 156054 C209976 071-032-005-2 220.00 2724 DOLORES ST YESHAYAHU AARON ORINDA, CA 94563 PO BOX 763 156143 C209976 071-032-005-2 550.00 296.00 2724 DOLORES ST YESHAYAHU AARON ORINDA, CA 94563 2183.00 PO BOX 763 155428 C209976 071-103-008-0 1007.00 2904 PLUMLEIGH AVE YESHAYAHU AARON ORINDA, CA 94563 PO BOX 763 155429 C209976 071-103-008-0 110.00 2904 PLUMLEIGH AVE YESHAYAHU AARON ORINDA, CA 94563 PO BOX 763 156055 C209976 071-103-008-0 220.00 2904 PLUMLEIGH AVE YESHAYAHU AARON ORINDA, CA 94563 PO BOX 763 156144 C209976 071-103-008-0 550.00 296.00 2904 PLUMLEIGH AVE YESHAYAHU AARON ORINDA, CA 94563 2183.00 5197 HANSEN DR 155410 C205420 065-243-004-2 409.00 7 W LAKE CT JOHNSON CHARLES & FRANK DAVI ANTIOCH, CA 94531 5197 HANSEN DR 155411 C205420 065-243-004-2 110.00 7 W LAKE CT JOHNSON CHARLES & FRANK DAVI ANTIOCH, CA 94531 5197 HANSEN DR 156046 C205420 065-243-004-2 220.00 7 W LAKE CT JOHNSON CHARLES & FRANK DAVI ANTIOCH, CA 94531 5197 HANSEN DR 156135 C205420 065-243-004-2 550.00 303.00 7 W LAKE CT JOHNSON CHARLES & FRANK DAVI ANTIOCH, CA 94531 1592.00 834 BRIDLE RIDGE DR 155412 C217638 055-060-040-7 409.00 1011 WOODHAVEN WAY AHMADY STORIE FAIRFIELD, CA 94534 834 BRIDLE RIDGE DR 155413 C217638 055-060-040-7 110.00 1011 WOODHAVEN WAY AHMADY STORIE FAIRFIELD, CA 94534 834 BRIDLE RIDGE DR 156047 C217638 055-060-040-7 220.00 1011 WOODHAVEN WAY AHMADY STORIE FAIRFIELD, CA 94534 834 BRIDLE RIDGE DR 156136 C217638 055-060-040-7 550.00 296.00 1011 WOODHAVEN WAY AHMADY STORIE FAIRFIELD, CA 94534 1585.00  Page 4 6.6.19 BUSINESS LICENSE TAXES AND/OR ADMINISTRATIVE CITATION(S) FOR BOARD OF APPEALS ATTACHMENT A 3566 WOODLEY DR 155430 C219261 076-571-011-6 1037.00 2420 SEQUOIA DR TRAN-NGUYEN KHANH KIM & JOHN B NGUYEN SAN JOSE, CA 95148 3566 WOODLEY DR 155431 C219261 076-571-011-6 110.00 2420 SEQUOIA DR TRAN-NGUYEN KHANH KIM & JOHN B NGUYEN SAN JOSE, CA 95148 3566 WOODLEY DR 156056 C219261 076-571-011-6 220.00 2420 SEQUOIA DR TRAN-NGUYEN KHANH KIM & JOHN B NGUYEN SAN JOSE, CA 95148 3566 WOODLEY DR 156145 C219261 076-571-011-6 550.00 303.00 2420 SEQUOIA DR TRAN-NGUYEN KHANH KIM & JOHN B NGUYEN SAN JOSE, CA 95148 2220.00 3566 WOODLEY DR 155432 C219261 065-102-008-3 1007.00 417 GRANGNELLI AVE TRAN-NGUYEN KHANH KIM & JOHN B NGUYEN SAN JOSE, CA 95148 3566 WOODLEY DR 155433 C219261 065-102-008-3 110.00 417 GRANGNELLI AVE TRAN-NGUYEN KHANH KIM & JOHN B NGUYEN SAN JOSE, CA 95148 3566 WOODLEY DR 156057 C219261 065-102-008-3 220.00 417 GRANGNELLI AVE TRAN-NGUYEN KHANH KIM & JOHN B NGUYEN SAN JOSE, CA 95148 3566 WOODLEY DR 156146 C219261 065-102-008-3 550.00 303.00 417 GRANGNELLI AVE TRAN-NGUYEN KHANH KIM & JOHN B NGUYEN SAN JOSE, CA 95148 2190.00 3566 WOODLEY DR 155434 C219261 065-102-021-6 1007.00 305 GRANGNELLI AVE TRAN-NGUYEN KHANH KIM & JOHN B NGUYEN SAN JOSE, CA 95148 3566 WOODLEY DR 155435 C219261 065-102-021-6 110.00 305 GRANGNELLI AVE TRAN-NGUYEN KHANH KIM & JOHN B NGUYEN SAN JOSE, CA 95148 3566 WOODLEY DR 156058 C219261 065-102-021-6 220.00 305 GRANGNELLI AVE TRAN-NGUYEN KHANH KIM & JOHN B NGUYEN SAN JOSE, CA 95148 3566 WOODLEY DR 156147 C219261 065-102-021-6 550.00 303.00 305 GRANGNELLI AVE TRAN-NGUYEN KHANH KIM & JOHN B NGUYEN SAN JOSE, CA 95148 2190.00 3566 WOODLEY DR 155436 C219261 067-155-013-5 1007.00 1128 KLENGEL ST TRAN-NGUYEN KHANH KIM & JOHN B NGUYEN SAN JOSE, CA 95148 3566 WOODLEY DR 155437 C219261 067-155-013-5 110.00 1128 KLENGEL ST TRAN-NGUYEN KHANH KIM & JOHN B NGUYEN SAN JOSE, CA 95148 3566 WOODLEY DR 156059 C219261 067-155-013-5 220.00 1128 KLENGEL ST TRAN-NGUYEN KHANH KIM & JOHN B NGUYEN SAN JOSE, CA 95148 3566 WOODLEY DR 156147 C219261 067-155-013-5 550.00 303.00 1128 KLENGEL ST TRAN-NGUYEN KHANH KIM & JOHN B NGUYEN SAN JOSE, CA 95148 2190.00 3566 WOODLEY DR 155438 C219261 074-424-024-3 1007.00 1732 SPRINGWOOD WAY TRAN-NGUYEN KHANH KIM & JOHN B NGUYEN SAN JOSE, CA 95148 3566 WOODLEY DR 155439 C219261 074-424-024-3 110.00 1732 SPRINGWOOD WAY TRAN-NGUYEN KHANH KIM & JOHN B NGUYEN SAN JOSE, CA 95148 3566 WOODLEY DR 156060 C219261 074-424-024-3 220.00 1732 SPRINGWOOD WAY TRAN-NGUYEN KHANH KIM & JOHN B NGUYEN SAN JOSE, CA 95148 3566 WOODLEY DR 156149 C219261 074-424-024-3 550.00 303.00 1732 SPRINGWOOD WAY TRAN-NGUYEN KHANH KIM & JOHN B NGUYEN SAN JOSE, CA 95148 2190.00 GRAND TOTAL $56,399.00  STAFF REPORT TO THE BOARD OF ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS FOR CONSIDERATION AT THE HEARING ON JUNE 6, 2019 *** SUPPLEMENTAL *** DATE: June 4, 2019 APPROVED BY: V. Rosales, Business License Representative SUBJECT: BUSINESS LICENSE – Approval of the Levy of Special Assessments on Certain Properties for Unpaid Business License Taxes and/or Administrative Citation(s) for the Month(s) of May 2019 – as Amended to reflect updated information. BACKGROUND INFORMATION As previously indicated in the staff report presented to you dated May 20, 2019 a Notice of Intent to Record Lien was sent to each property owner listed on the attached spreadsheet due to outstanding receivables to the City of Antioch for Unpaid Business License Taxes and/or Administrative Citation(s). As of today, June 4, 2019, ten (10) of those accounts have been paid in full, one (1) of those accounts was sold, and four (4) of those accounts have been postponed to a future hearing date. The purpose of this supplemental report is to remove those fifteen (15) accounts from the list before you today for confirmation of assessment and direction to record said lien. The adjustment amount of accounts receivable before you is $26,159.00. ATTACHMENT A: Supplemental List of Assessments _1D.02_ 06/06/19 6.6.19 **SUPPLEMENTAL** Page 1 BUSINESS LICENSE TAXES AND/OR ADMINISTRATIVE CITATION(S) FOR BOARD OF APPEALS ATTACHMENT A Lien Processing AR Customer # APN Amount Charge Site Address Owner last Owner first Mailing address CHP WIDOWS FUND 2420 SAND CREEK RD #338 153445 C214456 067-223-011-7 411 W 19TH ST LLC CHP WIDOWS FUND LLC BRENTWOOD, CA 94513 CHP WIDOWS FUND 2420 SAND CREEK RD #338 152830 C214456 067-223-011-7 411 W 19TH ST LLC CHP WIDOWS FUND LLC BRENTWOOD, CA 94513 CHP WIDOWS FUND 2420 SAND CREEK RD #338 152818 C214456 067-223-011-7 411 W 19TH ST LLC CHP WIDOWS FUND LLC BRENTWOOD, CA 94513 CHP WIDOWS FUND 2420 SAND CREEK RD #338 153901 C214456 067-223-011-7 411 W 19TH ST LLC CHP WIDOWS FUND LLC BRENTWOOD, CA 94513 PAID CHP WIDOWS FUND 2420 SAND CREEK RD #338 153446 C214456 066-202-001-5 800 G ST LLC CHP WIDOWS FUND LLC BRENTWOOD, CA 94513 CHP WIDOWS FUND 2420 SAND CREEK RD #338 152829 C214456 066-202-001-5 800 G ST LLC CHP WIDOWS FUND LLC BRENTWOOD, CA 94513 CHP WIDOWS FUND 2420 SAND CREEK RD #338 152817 C214456 066-202-001-5 800 G ST LLC CHP WIDOWS FUND LLC BRENTWOOD, CA 94513 CHP WIDOWS FUND 2420 SAND CREEK RD #338 153900 C214456 066-202-001-5 800 G ST LLC CHP WIDOWS FUND LLC BRENTWOOD, CA 94513 SOLD 3440 HILLCREST AVE STE 2423 ROYAL OAKS DR 153861 C218616 052-530-002-6 110.00 100 KARIMIAN SEAN A ALAMO, CA 94507 3440 HILLCREST AVE STE 2423 ROYAL OAKS DR 154200 C218616 052-530-002-6 220.00 100 KARIMIAN SEAN A ALAMO, CA 94507 3440 HILLCREST AVE STE 2423 ROYAL OAKS DR 154751 C218616 052-530-002-6 550.00 296.00 100 KARIMIAN SEAN A ALAMO, CA 94507 1176.00 5680 AUGUSTA CT 156175 C218694 072-190-010-8 56 DUNES WAY MALFITANO JOSEPH L & JONI K DISCOVERY BAY, CA 94505 5680 AUGUSTA CT 156176 C218694 072-190-011-8 56 DUNES WAY MALFITANO JOSEPH L & JONI K DISCOVERY BAY, CA 94505 PAID CLIFTON HILL 22 CLIFTON HL 153837 C214186 072-042-002-5 240 BOULDER DR INVESTMENTS CLIFTON HILL INVESTMENTS NW 8 0QG, LO UK CLIFTON HILL 22 CLIFTON HL 153838 C214186 072-042-002-5 240 BOULDER DR INVESTMENTS CLIFTON HILL INVESTMENTS NW 8 0QG, LO UK CLIFTON HILL 22 CLIFTON HL 154204 C214186 072-042-002-5 240 BOULDER DR INVESTMENTS CLIFTON HILL INVESTMENTS NW 8 0QG, LO UK CLIFTON HILL 22 CLIFTON HL 154756 C214186 072-042-002-5 240 BOULDER DR INVESTMENTS CLIFTON HILL INVESTMENTS NW 8 0QG, LO UK PAID CLIFTON HILL 22 CLIFTON HL 153842 C214186 072-221-003-6 404 JADE CT INVESTMENTS CLIFTON HILL INVESTMENTS NW 8 0QG, LO UK CLIFTON HILL 22 CLIFTON HL 153843 C214186 072-221-003-6 404 JADE CT INVESTMENTS CLIFTON HILL INVESTMENTS NW 8 0QG, LO UK CLIFTON HILL 22 CLIFTON HL 154201 C214186 072-221-003-6 404 JADE CT INVESTMENTS CLIFTON HILL INVESTMENTS NW 8 0QG, LO UK CLIFTON HILL 22 CLIFTON HL 154754 C214186 072-221-003-6 404 JADE CT INVESTMENTS CLIFTON HILL INVESTMENTS NW 8 0QG, LO UK PAID CLIFTON HILL 22 CLIFTON HL 153839 C214186 072-213-006-9 405 BOULDER DR INVESTMENTS CLIFTON HILL INVESTMENTS NW 8 0QG, LO UK CLIFTON HILL 22 CLIFTON HL 153840 C214186 072-213-006-9 405 BOULDER DR INVESTMENTS CLIFTON HILL INVESTMENTS NW 8 0QG, LO UK CLIFTON HILL 22 CLIFTON HL 154203 C214186 072-213-006-9 405 BOULDER DR INVESTMENTS CLIFTON HILL INVESTMENTS NW 8 0QG, LO UK CLIFTON HILL 22 CLIFTON HL 154755 C214186 072-213-006-9 405 BOULDER DR INVESTMENTS CLIFTON HILL INVESTMENTS NW 8 0QG, LO UK PAID CLIFTON HILL 22 CLIFTON HL 153841 C214186 072-350-022-9 2417 GREENTREE CT INVESTMENTS CLIFTON HILL INVESTMENTS NW 8 0QG, LO UK CLIFTON HILL 22 CLIFTON HL 157389 C214186 072-350-022-9 2417 GREENTREE CT INVESTMENTS CLIFTON HILL INVESTMENTS NW 8 0QG, LO UK CLIFTON HILL 22 CLIFTON HL 154202 C214186 072-350-022-9 2417 GREENTREE CT INVESTMENTS CLIFTON HILL INVESTMENTS NW 8 0QG, LO UK CLIFTON HILL 22 CLIFTON HL 154753 C214186 072-350-022-9 2417 GREENTREE CT INVESTMENTS CLIFTON HILL INVESTMENTS NW 8 0QG, LO UK PAID  Page 2 6.6.19 **SUPPLEMENTAL** BUSINESS LICENSE TAXES AND/OR ADMINISTRATIVE CITATION(S) FOR BOARD OF APPEALS ATTACHMENT A PO BOX 117694 154352 C217688 065-071-020-5 1205 A ST COLINA IRMA & DON AISH BURLINGAME, CA 94011 PO BOX 117694 154353 C217688 065-071-020-5 1205 A ST COLINA IRMA & DON AISH BURLINGAME, CA 94011 PO BOX 117694 154765 C217688 065-071-020-5 1205 A ST COLINA IRMA & DON AISH BURLINGAME, CA 94011 PO BOX 117694 155118 C217688 065-071-020-5 1205 A ST COLINA IRMA & DON AISH BURLINGAME, CA 94011 PAID 1863 PATTERSON MILL WAY 154052 C207906 072-390-039-5 783.00 1758 NANDINA CT LEE LOREEN LAWRENCEVILLE, GA 30044 1863 PATTERSON MILL WAY 154053 C207906 072-390-039-5 110.00 1758 NANDINA CT LEE LOREEN LAWRENCEVILLE, GA 30044 1863 PATTERSON MILL WAY 154305 C207906 072-390-039-5 220.00 1758 NANDINA CT LEE LOREEN LAWRENCEVILLE, GA 30044 1863 PATTERSON MILL WAY 155134 C207906 072-390-039-5 550.00 296.00 1758 NANDINA CT LEE LOREEN LAWRENCEVILLE, GA 30044 1959.00 2012 CERRO CT 154327 C205084 068-071-001-9 1037.00 517 KEAN AVE TRAVIS DARREN WAYNE ANTIOCH, CA 94509 2012 CERRO CT 155130 C205084 068-071-001-9 110.00 517 KEAN AVE TRAVIS DARREN WAYNE ANTIOCH, CA 94509 2012 CERRO CT 155131 C205084 068-071-001-9 220.00 517 KEAN AVE TRAVIS DARREN WAYNE ANTIOCH, CA 94509 2012 CERRO CT 155374 C205084 068-071-001-9 550.00 296.00 517 KEAN AVE TRAVIS DARREN WAYNE ANTIOCH, CA 94509 2213.00 50 ROBINSON AVE 154216 C219366 074-213-001-6 535.00 4701 EISENHOWER WAY HEREDIA SERGIO LAGUNAS PITTSBURG, CA 94565 50 ROBINSON AVE 154740 C219366 074-213-001-6 110.00 4701 EISENHOWER WAY HEREDIA SERGIO LAGUNAS PITTSBURG, CA 94565 50 ROBINSON AVE 155123 C219366 074-213-001-6 220.00 4701 EISENHOWER WAY HEREDIA SERGIO LAGUNAS PITTSBURG, CA 94565 50 ROBINSON AVE 155377 C219366 074-213-001-6 550.00 296.00 4701 EISENHOWER WAY HEREDIA SERGIO LAGUNAS PITTSBURG, CA 94565 1711.00 2955 GROOM DR 155767 C219773 051-243-001-8 1410 YOSEMITE DR WRIGHT YVONNE SAN PABLO, CA 94806 2955 GROOM DR 155770 C219773 051-243-001-8 1410 YOSEMITE DR WRIGHT YVONNE SAN PABLO, CA 94806 2955 GROOM DR 155771 C219773 051-243-001-8 1410 YOSEMITE DR WRIGHT YVONNE SAN PABLO, CA 94806 2955 GROOM DR 156085 C219773 051-243-001-8 1410 YOSEMITE DR WRIGHT YVONNE SAN PABLO, CA 94806 PAID PO BOX 763 155414 C209976 065-194-018-1 1037.00 1232 GIOVANNI ST YESHAYAHU AARON & KAREN RUBIN ORINDA, CA 94563 PO BOX 763 155415 C209976 065-194-018-1 110.00 1232 GIOVANNI ST YESHAYAHU AARON & KAREN RUBIN ORINDA, CA 94563 PO BOX 763 156048 C209976 065-194-018-1 220.00 1232 GIOVANNI ST YESHAYAHU AARON & KAREN RUBIN ORINDA, CA 94563 PO BOX 763 156137 C209976 065-194-018-1 550.00 303.00 1232 GIOVANNI ST YESHAYAHU AARON & KAREN RUBIN ORINDA, CA 94563 2220.00 PO BOX 763 155416 C209976 065-291-007-6 1007.00 1541 JACOBSEN ST YESHAYAHU AARON & KAREN RUBIN ORINDA, CA 94563 PO BOX 763 1555417 C209976 065-291-007-6 110.00 1541 JACOBSEN ST YESHAYAHU AARON & KAREN RUBIN ORINDA, CA 94563 PO BOX 763 156049 C209976 065-291-007-6 220.00 1541 JACOBSEN ST YESHAYAHU AARON & KAREN RUBIN ORINDA, CA 94563 PO BOX 763 156138 C209976 065-291-007-6 550.00 303.00 1541 JACOBSEN ST YESHAYAHU AARON & KAREN RUBIN ORINDA, CA 94563 2190.00 PO BOX 763 155418 C209976 067-332-020-6 1007.00 112 CATALINE AVE YESHAYAHU AARON & KAREN RUBIN ORINDA, CA 94563 PO BOX 763 155419 C209976 067-332-020-6 110.00 112 CATALINE AVE YESHAYAHU AARON & KAREN RUBIN ORINDA, CA 94563  Page 3 6.6.19 **SUPPLEMENTAL** BUSINESS LICENSE TAXES AND/OR ADMINISTRATIVE CITATION(S) FOR BOARD OF APPEALS ATTACHMENT A PO BOX 763 156050 C209976 067-332-020-6 220.00 112 CATALINE AVE YESHAYAHU AARON & KAREN RUBIN ORINDA, CA 94563 PO BOX 763 156139 C209976 067-332-020-6 550.00 303.00 112 CATALINE AVE YESHAYAHU AARON & KAREN RUBIN ORINDA, CA 94563 2190.00 PO BOX 763 155420 C209976 068-123-001-7 1007.00 2401 BEASLEY AVE YESHAYAHU AARON ORINDA, CA 94563 PO BOX 763 155421 C209976 068-123-001-7 110.00 2401 BEASLEY AVE YESHAYAHU AARON ORINDA, CA 94563 PO BOX 763 156051 C209976 068-123-001-7 220.00 2401 BEASLEY AVE YESHAYAHU AARON ORINDA, CA 94563 PO BOX 763 156140 C209976 068-123-001-7 550.00 296.00 2401 BEASLEY AVE YESHAYAHU AARON ORINDA, CA 94563 2183.00 PO BOX 763 155422 C209976 068-243-004-6 1007.00 2801 STAMM DR YESHAYAHU AARON ORINDA, CA 94563 PO BOX 763 155423 C209976 068-243-004-6 110.00 2801 STAMM DR YESHAYAHU AARON ORINDA, CA 94563 PO BOX 763 156052 C209976 068-243-004-6 220.00 2801 STAMM DR YESHAYAHU AARON ORINDA, CA 94563 PO BOX 763 516141 C209976 068-243-004-6 550.00 296.00 2801 STAMM DR YESHAYAHU AARON ORINDA, CA 94563 2183.00 PO BOX 763 155424 C209976 068-242-007-0 1007.00 2724 STAMM DR YESHAYAHU AARON ORINDA, CA 94563 PO BOX 763 155425 C209976 068-242-007-0 110.00 2724 STAMM DR YESHAYAHU AARON ORINDA, CA 94563 PO BOX 763 156053 C209976 068-242-007-0 220.00 2724 STAMM DR YESHAYAHU AARON ORINDA, CA 94563 PO BOX 763 156142 C209976 068-242-007-0 550.00 296.00 2724 STAMM DR YESHAYAHU AARON ORINDA, CA 94563 2183.00 PO BOX 763 155426 C209976 071-032-005-2 1007.00 2724 DOLORES ST YESHAYAHU AARON ORINDA, CA 94563 PO BOX 763 155427 C209976 071-032-005-2 110.00 2724 DOLORES ST YESHAYAHU AARON ORINDA, CA 94563 PO BOX 763 156054 C209976 071-032-005-2 220.00 2724 DOLORES ST YESHAYAHU AARON ORINDA, CA 94563 PO BOX 763 156143 C209976 071-032-005-2 550.00 296.00 2724 DOLORES ST YESHAYAHU AARON ORINDA, CA 94563 2183.00 PO BOX 763 155428 C209976 071-103-008-0 1007.00 2904 PLUMLEIGH AVE YESHAYAHU AARON ORINDA, CA 94563 PO BOX 763 155429 C209976 071-103-008-0 110.00 2904 PLUMLEIGH AVE YESHAYAHU AARON ORINDA, CA 94563 PO BOX 763 156055 C209976 071-103-008-0 220.00 2904 PLUMLEIGH AVE YESHAYAHU AARON ORINDA, CA 94563 PO BOX 763 156144 C209976 071-103-008-0 550.00 296.00 2904 PLUMLEIGH AVE YESHAYAHU AARON ORINDA, CA 94563 2183.00 5197 HANSEN DR 155410 C205420 065-243-004-2 7 W LAKE CT JOHNSON CHARLES & FRANK DAVI ANTIOCH, CA 94531 5197 HANSEN DR 155411 C205420 065-243-004-2 7 W LAKE CT JOHNSON CHARLES & FRANK DAVI ANTIOCH, CA 94531 5197 HANSEN DR 156046 C205420 065-243-004-2 7 W LAKE CT JOHNSON CHARLES & FRANK DAVI ANTIOCH, CA 94531 5197 HANSEN DR 156135 C205420 065-243-004-2 7 W LAKE CT JOHNSON CHARLES & FRANK DAVI ANTIOCH, CA 94531 POSTPONED 834 BRIDLE RIDGE DR 155412 C217638 055-060-040-7 409.00 1011 WOODHAVEN WAY AHMADY STORIE FAIRFIELD, CA 94534 834 BRIDLE RIDGE DR 155413 C217638 055-060-040-7 110.00 1011 WOODHAVEN WAY AHMADY STORIE FAIRFIELD, CA 94534 834 BRIDLE RIDGE DR 156047 C217638 055-060-040-7 220.00 1011 WOODHAVEN WAY AHMADY STORIE FAIRFIELD, CA 94534 834 BRIDLE RIDGE DR 156136 C217638 055-060-040-7 550.00 296.00 1011 WOODHAVEN WAY AHMADY STORIE FAIRFIELD, CA 94534 1585.00  Page 4 6.6.19 **SUPPLEMENTAL** BUSINESS LICENSE TAXES AND/OR ADMINISTRATIVE CITATION(S) FOR BOARD OF APPEALS ATTACHMENT A 3566 WOODLEY DR 155430 C219261 076-571-011-6 2420 SEQUOIA DR TRAN-NGUYEN KHANH KIM & JOHN B NGUYEN SAN JOSE, CA 95148 3566 WOODLEY DR 155431 C219261 076-571-011-6 2420 SEQUOIA DR TRAN-NGUYEN KHANH KIM & JOHN B NGUYEN SAN JOSE, CA 95148 3566 WOODLEY DR 156056 C219261 076-571-011-6 2420 SEQUOIA DR TRAN-NGUYEN KHANH KIM & JOHN B NGUYEN SAN JOSE, CA 95148 3566 WOODLEY DR 156145 C219261 076-571-011-6 2420 SEQUOIA DR TRAN-NGUYEN KHANH KIM & JOHN B NGUYEN SAN JOSE, CA 95148 PAID 3566 WOODLEY DR 155432 C219261 065-102-008-3 417 GRANGNELLI AVE TRAN-NGUYEN KHANH KIM & JOHN B NGUYEN SAN JOSE, CA 95148 3566 WOODLEY DR 155433 C219261 065-102-008-3 417 GRANGNELLI AVE TRAN-NGUYEN KHANH KIM & JOHN B NGUYEN SAN JOSE, CA 95148 3566 WOODLEY DR 156057 C219261 065-102-008-3 417 GRANGNELLI AVE TRAN-NGUYEN KHANH KIM & JOHN B NGUYEN SAN JOSE, CA 95148 3566 WOODLEY DR 156146 C219261 065-102-008-3 417 GRANGNELLI AVE TRAN-NGUYEN KHANH KIM & JOHN B NGUYEN SAN JOSE, CA 95148 POSTPONED 3566 WOODLEY DR 155434 C219261 065-102-021-6 305 GRANGNELLI AVE TRAN-NGUYEN KHANH KIM & JOHN B NGUYEN SAN JOSE, CA 95148 3566 WOODLEY DR 155435 C219261 065-102-021-6 305 GRANGNELLI AVE TRAN-NGUYEN KHANH KIM & JOHN B NGUYEN SAN JOSE, CA 95148 3566 WOODLEY DR 156058 C219261 065-102-021-6 305 GRANGNELLI AVE TRAN-NGUYEN KHANH KIM & JOHN B NGUYEN SAN JOSE, CA 95148 3566 WOODLEY DR 156147 C219261 065-102-021-6 305 GRANGNELLI AVE TRAN-NGUYEN KHANH KIM & JOHN B NGUYEN SAN JOSE, CA 95148 POSTPONED 3566 WOODLEY DR 155436 C219261 067-155-013-5 1128 KLENGEL ST TRAN-NGUYEN KHANH KIM & JOHN B NGUYEN SAN JOSE, CA 95148 3566 WOODLEY DR 155437 C219261 067-155-013-5 1128 KLENGEL ST TRAN-NGUYEN KHANH KIM & JOHN B NGUYEN SAN JOSE, CA 95148 3566 WOODLEY DR 156059 C219261 067-155-013-5 1128 KLENGEL ST TRAN-NGUYEN KHANH KIM & JOHN B NGUYEN SAN JOSE, CA 95148 3566 WOODLEY DR 156147 C219261 067-155-013-5 1128 KLENGEL ST TRAN-NGUYEN KHANH KIM & JOHN B NGUYEN SAN JOSE, CA 95148 PAID 3566 WOODLEY DR 155438 C219261 074-424-024-3 1732 SPRINGWOOD WAY TRAN-NGUYEN KHANH KIM & JOHN B NGUYEN SAN JOSE, CA 95148 3566 WOODLEY DR 155439 C219261 074-424-024-3 1732 SPRINGWOOD WAY TRAN-NGUYEN KHANH KIM & JOHN B NGUYEN SAN JOSE, CA 95148 3566 WOODLEY DR 156060 C219261 074-424-024-3 1732 SPRINGWOOD WAY TRAN-NGUYEN KHANH KIM & JOHN B NGUYEN SAN JOSE, CA 95148 3566 WOODLEY DR 156149 C219261 074-424-024-3 1732 SPRINGWOOD WAY TRAN-NGUYEN KHANH KIM & JOHN B NGUYEN SAN JOSE, CA 95148 POSTPONED GRAND TOTAL $26,159.00