Community Tree Council
Regular MeetingAthens-Clarke County, GA · September 14, 2020
Minutes
1
Community Tree Council (CTC) Meeting Minutes
Meeting Date: September 14th, 2020
Location: ACC Cisco Webex online meeting,
You Tube Streaming Link:
https://youtu.be/PKutOYfO878
In Attendance -
Members: Rodney Walters, Edith Jackson, Shawn Doonan,
Victoria Goff, Pam Knox, Nina Wurzburger, Jim Weck,
Phil Hale, Mary Songster, Joe Perloff, Russell Edwards
(A Quorum Was Present)
Staff, Guests, and
Ex-Officio Members: Stacee Farrell, Stacee Farrell, Andrew Saunders (Central Services Director)
Absent: Jessie McClellan, Mary Attaway, Lea Clark, Marc Beechuk
Call to Order and Welcome:
Shawn Doonan 4:00 - 4:05
● Introductions/Welcome
Housekeeping (Secretary) Rodney Walters 4:05 - 4:10
● Roll Call Sign in (3 minutes): Attending members written on attendance list
● (Action Item: Vote to approve the August 10th CTC meeting minutes and the August 17th CTC Committee
Meetings
Minutes ), (3 minutes): After the July CTC meeting minutes and the July CTC committees meetings minutes
were distributed to the CTC members for review, the CTC voted unanimously to approve the August 10th CTC
meeting minutes and the August 17th CTC committees meetings minutes.
Information- 2 Minutes: Review motions that were passed during the August meeting:
● Action Item - Vote to a dissolve the CTC Ad-Hoc Interview Committee and Replace it with a CTC Interview
Work Group: Motion was passed unanimously to dissolve the Ad-Hoc CTC Interview Committee and
Replace it with a CTC Work Group of 3-4 CTC members who will advertise open CTC membership
positions, conduct interviews to select member nominees, and report directly to the CTC.
Action Item- A motion was passed by unanimous vote to dissolve to dissolve the TFT Ad-Hoc Committee
and replace it with a work group to administer the Carl Jordan Grove tree planting obligations and other
ACC tree related planting groves.
Treasurer’s Report (Information – 5 minutes) Pam Knox 4:10 – 4:15
● Treasurer reported that the accounts remain unchanged from last month with the exception that 25cents have
been added for interest.
● The Paypal account is not working and Pam is troubleshooting it with Jessie
CTC Committee Reports (Information and Discussion) Shawn Doonan 4:15 – 4:30
● CTC Executive Committee {Shawn (chair), Joe Perloff, Pam, Rodney – 2 minutes
Priority of funding sources (such as grants)
(Action Item and Discussion – CTC agreement to be involved with Involvement in the ACC iTree Eco
Study as a partner to communicate some of the analyses findings to the public)
The CTC unanimously passed a motion for the CTC to officially accept the invitation to become a partner
in the ACC iTree Eco project by committing at least ten hours to the development and delivery of a
community outreach activity (or activities) in Athens in October 2021 and to communicate selected findings
from the study that informs citizens about features of their urban/community forests (if funding is
awarded).
2
● CTC Steering Committee {(Shawn (Chair) Executive Committee and Standing Committee
(See Fundraising detail in Promotions Committee)
Committee Meeting agendas and minutes back to the secretary on time 09/23/2020, which the Wednesday
following the committee meeting.
Steering Committee agreed that an Educational Short on a tree related topic (5 minutes) (1-3 slides, 5 minutes
maximum) conducted by various Council members would be a good thing to add to the agenda.
Steering committee agreed that it would be nice if the President added a A Day in the Life section (5 minutes
max) where members can talk about what an average day looks like in their professional or retired life.
President may also take the option of adding a Forester’s section to the agenda were the forester reports aspects
of the Community Forestry program
● CTC Interview Work Group Meeting {Shawn (leader), Phil, Pam, Marc, Mary Attaway}-5 min. (4:35)
Discussion:
Who will serve on the work group? [Shawn, Edith, Jim and Rodney]
Advertise For Openings [WUGA, CTC Website, Flagpole, ACC Public Information Outlets
-Create verbiage for the advertisement.
Revise the interview questions, currently redundant.
-Change interview questions into CTC member expectations as part of the interview letter. Include CTC
Mission and By-laws as a prep for the interview
-Distribute information prior to the interview (allows applicants time to review CTC Mission and By-
laws.
Ideally, interviews would be completed by September, however, late December is the goal for this year.
● CTC Trees for Tomorrow Work Group {Phil Hale (leader), Mary Attaway, Nina, Joe, Rodney} – 5 min (4:40)
Who will serve on the work group? Phil, Nina, Joe Perloff, Mary Attaway, Rodney
Importance of TfT program is that permission does not need to be obtained from the Mayor and Commission each
time the CTC wants to plant (donate) a tree to Athens-Clarke County.
Firefly Trail
-Funds exists in TfT account specifically for this purpose
- many planting opportunities with more sections of the trail completed (Todd Miller added information
about newly completed Firefly trail section and agreed to meet with CTC members on site to identify
new planting sites. )
Dogpark
- CTC decided it would plant trees outside the fence as funds become available (each
year) until intended design (outside the fence) has been completed
- Trees planted inside the fence will be much more expensive (due to necessity of tree
protection fencing or boulders that need to be installed until the trees become
established (still an option for planting but will require this explanation)
Finding a Memorial Grove? – not at this time
● CTC Promotions Committee {Mary Attaway (Chair), Joe Perloff, Phil Hale, Jessie, Tori} -15 min (4:55)
Chair was absent but a committee member mad a motion to (ACTION ITEM) approve the spending of $250
on promotional materials (prints of Tree that owns Itself, stickers, pens). The motion passed unanimously
● CTC Policy Committee: {Shawn, Joe Bates, Lea Clark, Mary Songster, Marc Beechuk, Rodney Walter}
- 10 min (5:05)
(Action Item and Discussion – Select new Promotions Committee Chair) Rodney is no longer to serve as Chair
for the Promotions committee. Who will serve as Promotions Committee Chair?
A motion was made to accept Mary Songster as the new Policy Committee Chair. The motion was passed
unanimously.
3
● Education committee: {Stacee Farrell, Lea Clark, Edith Jackson, Marc Beechuk, Seth Hawkins} – 10 min (5:15)
Chair was absent the following comments were made by committee member Stacee Farrell
- Lea is focused on professional education and is reaching out to professional landscapers (reaching out to Marie
Obrien)
Edith is working on virtual education options
- Tree Life Cycle, Urban Tree hacker, Captain Planet Foundation, Karlies Kids Program, National Arbor Day
Foundation
Materials (Stacee, marc)
a. Pamphlets – Discuss what marc found
Dr. Gilman, UF – Not for school, can get a little heady. Some might be better for the website as
background info. GATrees – one pagers. ISA trifolds – packs of 50 for ~ $17. find items geared
toward 8th grade learning level to appeal to larger audience
b. Presentation Materials
Green School Curriculum – Discuss what Stacee found – Tree lessons for in person classroom visits,
elementary, fun activities. Wasn’t a ton, we currently have 2 activities. Stacee will get
New Business: Shawn Doonan 4:20 – 5:35
● Fundraising - 14 minutes (4:29):
Begin a discussion to establish an Ad- hoc grant work group consisting of 3-4 members where each person would
seek out potential donors and fundraising. Assign advertising opportunities
o Mary Songster has been organizing budgeting operations
- reviewing old files to find old donors
- Annual Goals to help define scope and to set targets
- May work better if connected to a set of goals (specific goals for different projects)
- Would work well for a “master maintenance and planting plan”
- Donations often come for specific projects
- More trees could have been planted during past planting projects if more $ was available
- There are limitations on what the council is able to do (logistically)
- Could create a which list for tree maintenance and planting
-Schools
- Athens housing authority
- ACC right-of-way and park planting sites
● Parking Lot Items ( ) Presiding Chair Tabled
Meeting Wrap up – (1 minute) Presiding Chair 5:30
A motion was made, seconded, and approved by unanimous vote to adjourn the meeting
Agenda
ATHENS-CLARKE COUNTY
COMMUNITY TREE COUNCIL
AGENDA
MONDAY, SEPTEMBER 14TH, 2020
4:00 – 5:30 P.M.
Meeting to be conducted on Webex (Cisco virtual meeting platform) and broadcast on You Tube
You Tube Streaming link: https://youtu.be/PKutOYfO878
Call to Order and Welcome:
Shawn Doonan 4:00 - 4:05
Introductions/Welcome:
Housekeeping (Secretary) Rodney Walters 4:05 - 4:10
● Roll Call Sign in (3 minutes): Attending members written on attendance list
● (Action Item: Vote to approve August CTC meeting minutes and the August CTC Committee Meeting
Minutes - 2 minutes):
Information- 2 Minutes: Review motions that were passed during the August meeting:
● Action Item - Vote to a dissolve the CTC Ad-Hoc Interview Committee and Replace it with a CTC
Interview Work Group: Motion was passed unanimously to dissolve the Ad-Hoc CTC Interview
Committee and Replace it with a CTC Work Group of 3-4 CTC members who will advertise open
CTC membership positions, conduct interviews to select member nominees, and report directly to the
CTC.
Action Item- A motion was passed by unanimous vote to dissolve to dissolve the TFT Ad-Hoc
Committee and replace it with a work group to administer the Carl Jordan Grove tree planting
obligations and other ACC tree related planting groves.
Treasurer’s Report (Information – 5 minutes) Pam Knox 4:10 – 4:15
CTC Committee Reports (Information and Discussion) Shawn Doonan 4:15 – 4:30
CTC Executive Committee {Shawn (chair), Joe Perloff, Pam, Rodney – 2 minutes
-Priority of funding sources (such as grants)
2
CTC Steering Committee {(Shawn (Chair) Executive Committee and Standing Committee
● (See Fundraising detail in Promotions Committee)
● Committee Meeting agendas and minutes back to the secretary on time 09/23/2020, which the Wednesday
following the committee meeting.
● Educational Short on a tree related topic (5 minutes) (1-3 slides, 5 minutes)
● Forester’s section and also a contribution of other members which will allow CTC members to describe what
they do on a daily basis { A Day in the Life (of a CTC member)}
(Action Item and Discussion – CTC agreement to be involved with Involvement in the ACC iTree Eco
Study as a partner to communicate some of the analyses findings to the public)
ACC iTree Eco project: CTC becoming a community partner in the ACC iTree Eco statistical analysis
project. The grant Rodney is writing for the iTree Eco study is strengthened by the collaborative engagement
of partners. I would like to ask the CTC if they would commit to engaging in community outreach activities
to communicate findings from the study. I am happy to be involved in outreach as both the ACC
Community Forester and CTC secretary.
Motion for the CTC to officially accept the invitation to become a partner in the ACC iTree Eco
project by committing 10 hours to a community outreach activity(s) to communicate selected findings
from the study.
CTC Interview Work Committee Meeting {Shawn (chair), Phil, Pam, Marc, Mary Attaway}-5 min.
(4:35)
Discussion:
● Who will serve on the work group? [Shawn, Edith, Jim and Rodney]
● Advertise For Openings [WUGA, CTC Website, Flagpole, ACC Public Information Outlets
-Create verbiage for the advertisement.
● Revise the interview questions, currently redundant.
-Distribute information prior to the interview. Change interview questions into CTC member
expectations as part of the interview letter. Include CTC Mission and By-laws as a prep for the
interview.
CTC Trees for Tomorrow Work Group Committee {Phil Hale (Chair), Mary Attaway, Nina, Joe,
Rodney} – 5 min (4:40)
● Who will serve on the work group? Phil, Nina, Joe Perloff, Mary Attaway, Rodney
● Explain to the CTC the importance of Mayor and Commission agreement for TfT program
● Firefly Trail
-Funds exists in TfT account specifically for this purpose
- many planting opportunities with more sections of the trail completed
● Dogpark
- CTC decided it would plant trees outside the fence as funds become available (each
year) until intended design (outside the fence) has been completed
- Trees planted inside the fence will be much more expensive (due to necessity of tree
protection fencing or boulders that need to be installed until the trees become
established (still an option for planting but will require this explanation)
▪ Finding a Memorial Grove? – not at this time
3
CTC Promotions Committee {Mary Attaway, Joe Perloff, Phil Hale, Jessie} -15 min (4:55)
● Joe is working on carbon offset calculator for website (Mary will reach out to him for update).
● Website:
- Page for Programs (TfT, future tree fair, green life expo, etc)
- Embed link to county videos of Arbor Day plantings on past projects page
- Bios completed- Mary has organized bios in doc for Jessie to put on website
- Tree Benefits page- including iTree tools link, carbon offset info, social/ societal
benefits of trees
- Past projects page- to commemorate past projects- Date, funding (grants and
donors), number of trees planted, location and photos
- Donor page- goals? temperature gauge? Allow anonymous option for donors
● Organizing a timeline with past projects to post on website - "project completed
page" (Tori)
● ACTION ITEM: vote on approval to spend $250
on promotional materials (prints of Tree that owns Itself, stickers, pens)
● Find a source for stickers, pencils, thank you note cards with logo.
● Update on Social Media plans- start releasing bios / photos of members.
CTC Policy Committee: {Shawn, Joe Bates, Lea Clark, Mary Songster, Marc Beechuk, Rodney Walter}
- 10 min (5:05)
(Action Item and Discussion – Select new Promotions Committee Chair) Rodney is no longer to
serve as Chair for the Promotions committee. Who will serve as Promotions Committee Chair?
Motion to accept _________ to lead the Policy Committee as the CTC Policy Committee Chair
Questionnaires asking “What do you want and why?” from both an Athens Tree Ordinance
perspective and from a strategic perspective were sent out to all the CTC members. Responses were
only received from 3 members (Jim, Edith, and Joe Perloff). Provision of feedback is critical for a
community organization to be able to take a seat at the table and participate in the process of
advancing positive change. If the CTC does not demonstrate leadership in civic engagement, how
may the CTC, citizens, and stakeholders have a voice in the management of the Community
Forests?
Policy Committee Activities/Goals
● Begin planning of organizing discussions and gathering data about larger code changes to find out
what changes may be needed
● Explore the merits of the creation of a Tree Bank (positive and negative aspects of a tree bank)
● Strategic Management Plan suggestions (goals derived from stakeholder and citizen feedback)
Information/Discussion: What changes may be needed: Homework - Read the Tree Ordinance and carefully
write down thoughts for discussion, read selection of historical ordinance development materials
4
Discussion: Possible changes that may be needed and why: (What do you want and why? - possible larger
code changes)
● What does the ACC community want? Who may be effected? Engage Stakeholders and Gather Citizen
Feedback (Legitimacy)
-Begin by formulating and organizing a basic feedback response. Create a process first to
elicit feedback and information from the CTC as a practice run and to gather the first set
of data.
- Prepare questionnaire asking “what do you want and why” for CTC members to answer
as a practice run example of a possible approach and to develop an initial dataset.
● Who will be engaged in the process of gathering this feedback? (Justice-fairness) Who does it effect? Who
gets a say in the process?
▪ Original Ordinance Stakeholders? (Provide stakeholder list – discuss)
- May be some limitations in eliciting feedback from this group alone
▪ Community Groups?
▪ Citizens (important to gather information from this sector)
- Commissioner districts (commissioners)
- Neighborhood Notification Initiative (Marc)
- Human scale notion of city building (tree walk to citizen representation) (Mary)
- Questionnaire attached to water bill (social distancing method) (Joe Bates, Marc)
● (Effectiveness) Once goals/changes are identified, ask the question – Is an ordinance change the best way to
achieve this goal? Why?
Education committee: {Stacee Farrell, Lea Clark, Edith Jackson, marc beechuk, Seth Hawkins} – 10 min
(5:15)
● Materials (Stacee, marc)
a. Pamphlets – Discuss what marc found
i. Dr. Gilman, UF – Not for school, can get a little heady. Some might be better for the
website as background info. GATrees – one pagers. ISA trifolds – packs of 50 for ~
$17. find items geared toward 8th grade learning level to appeal to larger audience
b. Presentation Materials
c. Green School Curriculum – Discuss what Stacee found – Tree lessons for in person classroom
visits, elementary, fun activities. Wasn’t a ton, we currently have 2 activities. Stacee will get
materials to marc’s office
New Business: Shawn Doonan 4:15 – 5:29
Fundraising - 15 minutes (4:29):
● Begin a discussion to establish an Ad- hoc grant work group consisting of 3-4 members where each person
would seek out potential donors and fundraising. Assign advertising opportunities
● Review old files to find old donors.
Parking Lot Items ( ) Presiding Chair
Meeting Wrap up – (1 minute) Presiding Chair 5:30
Get email alerts for Athens-Clarke County
A daily email when new agendas and minutes are posted.