Historic Preservation Commission
Regular MeetingBuena Vista, CO · May 6, 2021
Minutes
MINUTES
HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION
TOWN OF BUENA VISTA, C OLORADO
May 6, 2021 3:00 PM
Virtual Meeting
Conferencing Access Information: https://zoom.us/j/91956997299 Password: 691731
Listen via phone at: 1‐650‐449‐9052 Meeting ID: 919 5699 7299 Passcode: 691731
I. CALL TO ORDER
John called the meeting to order at 3:09 pm.
II. ROLL CALL
John O’Brien, Nancy Locke, Vic Kuklin, Suzy Kelly, Jo Reese, Melanie Roth, Mark Doering, Katy
Welter, and Mary Therese Anstey. Dan Courtright joi ned mid‐meeting.
III. AGENDA ADOPTION
Suzy moved to approve the agenda and Melanie seconded. The motion passed unanimously.
IV. APPROVAL OF MINUTES – April 1, 2021
Melanie moved to approve the minutes as drafted and Jo Reese s econded. The motion passed
unanimously.
V. PUBLIC COMMENT
None.
VI. BUSINESS ITEMS
A. Commissioner Candidate interview – Mary Therese Anstey
Mary is an architectural historian interested in serving on the Buena Vista Historic
Preservation Commission. She shared her experience, which included serving as staff to
the City of Aurora HPC. Mary’s application is included in the meeting packet. After Mary
and the HPC exchanged a number of questio ns, Katy moved to recommend to the Board
of Trustees that they appoint Mary Therese Anstey as an alternate on the Historic
Preservation Commission on the May 25th agenda. Jo Reese seconded. The motion
passed unanimously.
B. Ethics lesson learning experience
John contacted Erica Duvic (History Colorado CLG Coordinator) to see if she could
provide any training regarding ethics. As Erica is now leaving her position with History
This Agenda may be Amended
Posted at Buena Vista Town Hall and www.buenavistaco.gov
Colorado, John proposed the idea of an experienced commissioner or chair to talk to us
about this subject. Melanie also suggested that we might attend experienced HPC
meetings. John will look into both.
C. Strategic planning updates
Jo Reese updated on the marketing strategic planning goal. Jo proposed that we publicly
and consistently adopt the mission statement “to protect a sense of time and place with
preservation of historic buildings in Buena Vi sta.” She also proposed taking steps toward
making public statements on the Town of Bu ena Vista website, possibly creating a
Facebook page, and other outlets. Mark stressed the importance of any such
communications representing official positio ns from HPC/Town, but not the personal
views of the individual commissioners. John O’Brien moved that Town create an HPC
designated email address and that Jo Reese create a Facebook page for the purpose of
sharing HPC information, with anything to be previously approved by Mark. Jo
seconded. The motion passed unanimously.
The local landmarking update is addressed in item G.
No other updates at this time.
D. Residential Survey update
Front Range Research Associates (Tom and L aurie Simmons) have made significant
progress on the residential surveys, but they noted that many buildings lack historic
integrity, but would still qualify for local land marking under our code. The HPC discussed
whether it would like to propose to the Boar d of Trustees that we make historic
integrity a requirement under the municipal code. The consensus was to leave the code
as is so that we can have a generous standard for local landmarking, and so that
decisions about local landmarking do not hin ge on integrity.
E. Historic Records Grant discussion
Katy updated that the photo archives project volunteers met on Sunday to discuss next
steps. Suzy emphasized that her priority is id entifying the photos using archival pen as
the first priority while the group figures out a strategy to continue scanning the photos.
Katy will attend the BV Heritage meeting on May 25 to discuss the best approach to
storing/sharing the photos.
F. Updates from related organizations
Katy Welter shared that she is representing ( in her professional capacity as an attorney)
the owners of 420 E Main St. She will not be able to discuss with HPC or vote on any
matters pertaining to the project; and she will not advocate for the owners before HPC.
John expressed that these types of situations were a normal part of professionals
volunteering on small town boards, and that accepting that fact is essential to attracting
qualified professionals as volunteers. Mark shared details about the timeline to have a
public hearing; July 1 appears likely.
This Agenda may be Amended
Posted at Buena Vista Town Hall and www.buenavistaco.gov
Vic updated that BV Heritage is making significant progress on restoring the windows in
the courthouse, but that it means the courthouse won’t be open to the public until June
15.
G. Buena Vista Court House landmark application – Set hearing for next meeting
Mark indicated that we would need to publish notice in next week’s paper if we are
going to having a public hearing about the lo cal landmarking. The HPC agreed that it
would like to hear this application on June 3.
H. Next meeting date and location:
The Board discussed where to meet and there was consensus to meet in person in Pinon
Room but offer zoom link option.
I. Next meeting date and location: June 3, 2021 3:00 pm at the Pinon Room, in person!
with additional access via zoom.
J. STAFF UPDATES – Mark noted that the town continues to see a lot of building and
development activity.
K. ADJOURNMENT at 5:05 pm.
Respectfully submitted
John OBrien
____________________
John O’Brien ‐ Chair
This Agenda may be Amended
Posted at Buena Vista Town Hall and www.buenavistaco.gov
Agenda
AGENDA
HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION
TOWN OF BUENA VISTA, COLORADO
May 6, 2021 3:00 PM
Virtual Meeting
(Meeting will not be held at the Buena Vista Community Center)
To participate in Public Comment and/or Public Hearings you must connect to the video
conference.
Conferencing Access Information: https://zoom.us/j/91956997299 Password: 691731
Listen via phone at: 1-346-248-7799 Meeting ID: 919 5699 7299 Passcode: 691731
I. CALL TO ORDER
II. ROLL CALL
III. AGENDA ADOPTION
IV. APPROVAL OF MINUTES – April 1, 2021
V. PUBLIC COMMENT
VI. BUSINESS ITEMS
A. Commissioner Candidate interview – Mary Therese Anstey
B. Ethics lesson learning experience
C. Strategic planning updates
D. Residential Survey update
E. Historic Records Grant discussion
F. Updates from related organizations
G. Buena Vista Court House landmark application – Set hearing for next meeting
H. Next meeting date and location: June 3, 2021 3:00 pm?
VII. STAFF UPDATES
VIII. ADJOURNMENT
This Agenda may be Amended
Posted at Buena Vista Town Hall and www.buenavistaco.gov
MINUTES
HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION
TOWN OF BUENA VISTA, COLORADO
April 1, 2021 3:00 PM
Virtual Meeting
Conferencing Access Information: https://zoom.us/j/91956997299 Password: 691731
Listen via phone at: 1-650-449-9052 Meeting ID: 919 5699 7299 Passcode: 691731
I. CALL TO ORDER
John called the meeting to order at 3:03 pm.
II. ROLL CALL
John O’Brien, Nancy Locke, Vic Kuklin, Jo Reese, Melanie Roth, Katy Welter were present to
start. Suzy Kelly was present at 3:42 pm.
III. AGENDA ADOPTION
John proposed an additional item for discussion: public request to correct minutes from February
2020. Melanie moved and Nancy seconded the motion to adopt the agenda with John’s addition.
The motion passed unanimously.
IV. APPROVAL OF MINUTES – March 4, 2021
Jo Reese moved to approve and Dan Courtright seconded, subject to Melanie’s amendments for
clarity. The motion passed unanimously.
V. PUBLIC COMMENT
Katy relayed a request from a member of the public who requested a correction to the February
2020 minutes. The HPC agreed with the correction and Mark said he would forward corrected
minutes to the BOT.
VI. BUSINESS ITEMS
A. Ethics lesson learning experience
John shared a story about a prospective buyer of a historic property who solicited advice from
John and Katy regarding the likelihood that the building would be deemed historic and/or have a
demolition delayed. John stressed that we might be personally liable for giving advice that the
buyer would rely upon, possibly to their detriment. Mark stressed that it’s very important for
anyone contacted in that way to forward the individual to Town staff.
This Agenda may be Amended
Posted at Buena Vista Town Hall and www.buenavistaco.gov
John will look into training options and report back to the board.
B. Strategic planning subcommittee schedule looking forward.
i. New commissioner. Melanie Roth brought forward a recommendation for a board
candidate: Mary Therese Anstey, an architectural historian who worked for History
Colorado as a survey coordinator and now has a consulting business called History
Matters, LLC. Mark suggested inviting her to a meeting, which John will do.
ii. Local landmarking. Suzy reported that the subcommittee submitted the application for
local landmarking of the old Courthouse. That application will be reviewed at the next
meeting. Suzy also talked to several other property owners about local landmarking and
several were interested in doing so. Katy expressed that she and Rick would like to apply
to place 410 E Main St on the local, state, and national registers this year.
iii. Architectural Design Guidelines. Dan reported that he is going to lead a webinar for
History Colorado about the experience creating ADG’s. He will bring the presentation to
the HPC before presenting. He will make sure that the ADG’s are accessible on the Town’s
website. He would also like to send a copy to local realtors so that they can have it right
on their computers to share with prospective clients.
iv. Marketing. Jo Reese will set up a meeting of the subcommittee for next week to discuss
the steps moving forward. A number of potential opportunities were discussed.
C. 305 Chestnut demo permit discussion
The commissioners discussed the next steps documenting the property prior to demolition.
Melanie recommended that a video of the property is made just prior to demolition once the
interior of the building is cleared of all the stored materials.
D. Residential Survey update
Katy noted that the Chaffee County Courthouse records are opening up and now available for the
Simmons. It is expected that the survey project will be completed by the end of the year.
E. Historic Records Grant discussion
John put together electronic versions of every historic record and distributed them to History
Colorado, BV Library, BV Heritage, Mark and Katy.
Vic and Suzy met with the BV Library Director, who is open to helping promote the digital archives
collection, but may not have the staffing to help with scanning. Katy spoke with the Lake County
Library Director, who is happy to share their experience with digital archiving, and also referred
Katy to a local digital archives professional named Andrew Woods. Katy will follow up with
Andrew.
This Agenda may be Amended
Posted at Buena Vista Town Hall and www.buenavistaco.gov
F. Updates from related organizations
Vic shared that the courthouse window restoration is more costly than anticipated due to the
presence of asbestos.
G. Next meeting date and location: May 6, 2021 3:00 pm
H. STAFF UPDATES
Local landmark plaques are in and look great. John will help to install the first plaque at Nancy
Locke’s house, and there was a consensus that the HPC should take photos and inform the public.
J. ADJOURNMENT at 4:35pm
Respectfully Submitted
_______________________
John O'Brien Chair
This Agenda may be Amended
Posted at Buena Vista Town Hall and www.buenavistaco.gov
Get email alerts for Buena Vista
A daily email when new agendas and minutes are posted.