City of Canyon Commission Meetings
Regular MeetingCanyon, TX · December 19, 2016
Minutes
City Commission Meeting
December 19, 2016
The City Commission of the City of Canyon met in regular session at 5:30 p.m. in the City
Commission Chambers of the Civic Complex. Mayor Pro-Tem Gary Hinders presided over the
meeting with the following Commissioners in attendance, David Logan, Justin Richardson and
Joseph Shehan. Mayor Quinn Alexander was unable to attend.
Also present were the following City Staff: City Manager Randy Criswell, Assistant City Manager
Chris Sharp, City Secretary Gretchen Mercer, Director of Code Enforcement Danny Cornelius,
Public Works Director Dan Reese, Palo Duro Creek Golf Course Director of Golf Casey Renner,
Palo Duro Creek Golf Course Superintendent John Haun,and City Attorney Chuck Hester.
Item 1. Call to Order.
Mayor Pro-Tem Hinders called the meeting to order at 5:32 p.m.
Item 2. Invocation.
Commissioner Logan gave the invocation.
Item 3. Pledge of Allegiance.
The Pledge of Allegiance was led by Mayor Pro-Tem Hinders.
Item 4. Approval of Minutes of the Meeting of December 5, 2016.
Commissioner Shehan moved, duly seconded by Commissioner Logan, to approve the minutes
of December 5, 2016 as presented. Motion carried unanimously.
Item 5. Public Comment – Comments from In Interested Citizens.
No comments were made.
Item 6. Consider and Take Appropriate Action on Plat for Back Road Acres Unit No. 1.
Code Enforcement Director Danny Cornelius presented a plat for Back Road Acres Unit No. 1 for
consideration. Mr. Cornelius stated the property is not within the city limits, but the city has the
authority to approve plats within the city’s Extraterritorial Jurisdiction (ETJ). Mr. Cornelius said
the addition is located west of Brown Road, west of Canyon. Mr. Cornelius said the property
owner has signed a Developers Agreement. Mr. Cornelius said the Planning and Zoning
Commission voted unanimously to recommend approval of the plat to the City Commission at
their meeting December 12, 2016.
After discussion, Commissioner Logan moved, duly seconded by Commissioner Richardson to
approve the plat as recommended by the Canyon Planning and Zoning Commission. Motion
carried with Commissioner Shehan abstaining.
Item 7. Consider and Take Appropriate Action on Resolution No. 21-2016, Approving AXM
Settlement Rates.
City Commission Meeting
December 19, 2016
Page 2 of 4
City Manager Randy Criswell presented Resolution No. 21-2016 for consideration.
After discussion, Commissioner Richardson moved, duly seconded by Commissioner Shehan to
adopt Resolution No. 21-2016 as presented. Motion carried unanimously.
RESOLUTION NO. 21-2016
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY OF CANYON APPROVING A SETTLEMENT
AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE ALLIANCE OF XCEL MUNICIPALITIES (“AXM”) AND
SOUTHWESTERN PUBLIC SERVICE COMPANY (“SPS” OR “COMPANY”)
REGARDING THE COMPANY’S STATEMENT OF INTENT TO CHANGE ELECTRIC
RATES IN ALL CITIES EXERCISING ORIGINAL JURISDICTION; DECLARING
EXISTING RATES TO BE UNREASONABLE; ADOPTING TARIFFS THAT REFLECT
RATE ADJUSTMENTS CONSISTENT WITH THE SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT AND
FINDING THE RATES TO BE SET BY THE ATTACHED TARIFFS TO BE JUST AND
REASONABLE; FINDING THE CITY’S RATE CASE EXPENSES REASONABLE;
DIRECTING SPS TO REIMBURSE THE CITY ITS REASONABLE RATE CASE
EXPENSES; DETERMINING THAT THIS RESOLUTION WAS PASSED IN
ACCORDANCE WITH THE REQUIREMENTS OF THE TEXAS OPEN MEETING ACT;
DECLARING AN EFFECTIVE DATE; REPEALING ANY PRIOR RESOLUTIONS
INCONSISTENT WITH THIS RESOLUTION AND REQUIRING DELIVERY OF THIS
RESOLUTION TO THE COMPANY AND LEGAL COUNSEL.
Item 8. Palo Duro Creek Golf course Annual Golf Report 2016.
Palo Duro Creek Golf Course Director Casey Renner answered a few questions about the Annual
Golf Report for 2016.
Item 9. Consider and Take Appropriate Action on Palo Duro Creek Golf Course Fee
Schedule.
Palo Duro Creek Golf Course Director Casey Renner presented proposed fees for Palo Duro
Creek Golf Course for 2017.
After discussion, Commissioner Logan moved, duly seconded by Commissioner Richardson to
approve the fees for 2017 for Palo Duro Creek Golf Course as presented. Motion carried
unanimously.
Item 10. Consider and Take Appropriate Action on Ordinance No. 1053, Repealing Ordinance
No. 1040 of the City of Canyon, Texas, Amending Chapter 51 of the Code of
Ordinances of the City of Canyon, Texas, Section 51-21, Defining Charges and Rates
for Bulk Water and Fire Hydrant Meters; Providing a Severability Clause, and
Establishing an Effective Date.
Director of Public Works Dan Reese presented Ordinance No. 1053 for consideration. Mr. Reese
stated the city has been behind on what contractors are charged for bulk water and meter/fire
hydrant use. Mr. Reese said the current deposit for a bulk water meter is $200 while a new meter
costs $1,100. Mr. Reese also said the fees for hydrant meters has never been addressed in the
City Commission Meeting
December 19, 2016
Page 3 of 4
City of Canyon Code of Ordinances. Mr. Reese said Ordinance No. 1053 would raise the deposit
from $200 to $1,000 which would replace a hydrant meter if lost, stolen or destroyed. Mr. Reese
said the Ordinance would add a minimum fee of $50 per month in the hope that it will encourage
customers to return meters not in use. Commissioner Shehan asked if the language for the $50
minimum should be a $50 “fee” instead of a minimum since it was the intent for each customer
with a hydrant meter in their possession be charged this fee on top of the bulk water use. Mr.
Reese agreed that was the intent. Commissioner Logan stated the deposit should be enough to
cover the total cost of a new hydrant meter and proposed it be $1,200 instead of $1,000.
After discussion, Commissioner Logan moved, duly seconded by Commissioner Shehan to adopt
Ordinance No. 1053 with changing the language in the second paragraph of Section 1;(B)
changed to “$50 monthly minimum charge “fee” will apply to all customers with City of Canyon
issued fire hydrant meters”; and the language in Section 1;(C) be changed to “A refundable
deposit of $1,000.00 “$1,200.00” will be required when the meter is issued”. Motion carried
unanimously.
ORDINANCE NO. 1053
AN ORDINANCE REPEALING ORDINANCE NO. 1040 OF THE CITY OF
CANYON, TEXAS; AMENDING CHAPTER 51 OF THE CODE OF ORDINANCES
OF THE CITY OF CANYON, TEXAS, SECTION 51-21, DEFINING CHARGES AND
RATES FOR BULK WATER AND FIRE HYDRANT METERS; PROVIDING A
SEVERABILITY CLAUSE; AND ESTABLISHING AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
Item 11. Consider and Take Appropriate Action on Resolution No. 22-2016 Increasing the
Rental Fees at the Cole Community Center.
Assistant City Manager Chris Sharp presented Resolution No. 22-2016 for consideration. Mr.
Sharp said the fees for the Cole Community Center haven’t changed in 10 years. Mr. Sharp said
the rates needed to be increased to keep up with the maintenance and technology improvements.
Mr. Sharp said an additional deposit of $500.00 will be required for the use of any audio or visual
equipment. Mr. Sharp verified that if a person does not request the use of audio/visual
equipment, it will be disabled. Mr. Sharp stated security cameras have been installed throughout
the Community Center so if any vandalism occurs we can capture it on video.
After discussion, Commissioner Shehan moved, duly seconded by Commissioner Logan to adopt
Resolution No. 22-2016 as presented. Motion carried unanimously.
RESOLUTION NO. 22-2016
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF CITY OF CANYON, TEXAS,
AMENDING RENTAL FEES FOR THE COLE COMMUNITY CENTER, AND SETTING
AN EFFECTIVE DATE
Item 12. Adjournment
There being no further business, Commissioner Logan moved this meeting be adjourned.
______________________________
City Commission Meeting
December 19, 2016
Page 4 of 4
Gary Hinders, Mayor Pro-Tem
ATTEST:
________________________________
Gretchen Mercer, City Secretary
Agenda
AGENDA
NOTICE OF MEETING
Notice is hereby given that the governing body of the City of Canyon will meet at 5:30 p.m. on the 19th day of
December 2016, in the Commission Chambers of City Hall at 301 16th Street in the City of Canyon to discuss
the following agenda items:
1. Call to Order
2. Invocation.
3. Pledge of Allegiance.
4. Approval of Minutes of the Meeting December 5, 2016.
5. Public Comment – Comments from Interested Citizens.
6. Consider and Take Appropriate Action on Plat for Back Road Acres Unit No. 1.
7. Consider and Take Appropriate Action on Resolution No. 21-2016, Approving AXM Settlement.
8. Palo Duro Creek Golf Course Annual Golf Report FY 2016.
9. Consider and Take Appropriate Action on Palo Duro Creek Golf Course Golf Fees and Tournament Fees.
10. Consider and Take Appropriate Action on Ordinance No. 1053, Repealing Ordinance No. 1040 of the
City of Canyon, Texas, Amending Chapter 51 of the Code of Ordinances of the City of Canyon, Texas,
Section 51-21, Defining Charges and Rates for Bulk Water and Fire Hydrant Meters; Providing a
Severability Clause, and Establishing an Effective Date.
11. Consider and Take Appropriate Action on Resolution No. 22-2016 Increasing the Rental Fees at the
Cole Community Center.
12. Adjournment.
Randy Criswell, City Manager
I certify that the above Notice of Meeting was posted on the bulletin board of the Civic Complex of the City of
Canyon, Texas on the 16th day of December 2016.
Gretchen Mercer, City Clerk
City of Canyon
CITY MANAGER’S EXECUTIVE SUMMARY OF AGENDA
To: Mayor and City Commission
From: Randy Criswell, City Manager
Date: December 19, 2016
Re: Executive Summary of Agenda Packet for December 19, 2016
Item Number 6
Consider and Take Appropriate Action on Plat For Back Road Acres Unit No. 1. You have
a recommendation from the Planning and Zoning Commission to approve this plat. It’s a
small, 3-lot plat, south of the City Limits, west of Brown Road. There are maps and a copy
of the plat in your packet. We do have a signed Developer’s Agreement with the owner, so
we have no concerns about this development. The Planning and Zoning Commission
voted unanimously on December 12 to recommend approval of the Plat. The draft Minutes
are included in your packet. I concur with the recommendation to approve the Plat for
Back Road Acres Unit No. 1.
Item Number 7
Consider and Take Appropriate Action on Resolution No. 21-2016, Approving AXM
Settlement. We were finally able to negotiate a settlement with SPS on the rate case they
filed in February. The settlement was for a $35 million increase, instead of the $72 million
they originally presented. There is explanation in your packet that covers the main points of
the settlement. I recommend adoption of Resolution No. 21-2016, approving the
Settlement Agreement.
Item Number 8
Palo Duro Creek Golf Course Annual Reports. John has prepared an annual FY report for
the outdoor portion of the golf course, and Casey has prepared a report with the fiscal and
golf totals. These reports are for your information only, and will not be presented
formally. John and Casey will be available for questions if needed. No action is
required.
Item Number 9
Consider and Take Appropriate Action on Palo Duro Creek Golf Course Fees and
Tournament Fees. John and Casey have prepared a new fee schedule for the golf course
for 2017. They are proposing an increase in basically all fees. They will be here to present
their recommendations to you on Monday night. The increases also apply to Tournament
costs. We’ve held back on increasing our rates for a while, but with the cost of golf in
Amarillo, and the quality of our course and our overall experience, it’s time to raise our fees.
I can’t tell you how many people have told me our golf course is priced too low. So that
needs to change. I concur with the recommendation to approve the new Fee
Schedule and Tournament Fees as presented.
(See next page)
City of Canyon
CITY MANAGER’S EXECUTIVE SUMMARY OF AGENDA
Item Number 10
Consider and Take Appropriate Action On Bulk Water Rates. This item basically pertains
to bulk water sales from a fire hydrant. Dan’s memo is very descriptive, but to summarize,
we currently have many meter assemblies that we basically give out to contractors so they
can purchase water from our fire hydrants. The meter assemblies are constructed by our
Water Department, and a small deposit is required to get the meter. I would encourage you
to read Dan’s memo to get fully informed. The bottom line is, we’ve never had Bulk Water
rates included in our Water Rate Ordinance. We felt some changes to the Bulk Water
program were warranted, including increasing of fees and deposit, so I told Dan we needed
to get that information into the Water Rate Ordinance, so there’s only one Ordinance that
addresses all water meter deposits, rates, policies, etc. I concur with the
recommendation to adopt Ordinance No. 1053.
Item Number 11
As Chris describes in his memo and information, based on the increased technology that’s
available at the Community Center, and the overall increased cost of maintaining such a
facility, he is proposing a fee increase. The numbers are more consistent than previously,
and it makes much more sense. I concur with the recommendation to adopt
Resolution No. 22-2016, Increasing the Rental Fees at the Community Center.
City of Canyon
City Commission Meeting
December 5, 2016
The City Commission of the City of Canyon met in regular session at 1:00 p.m. in the Adobe
Room at the Cole Community Center, 300 16th Street, City of Canyon. Mayor Alexander
presided over the meeting with the following Commissioners in attendance. Mayor Pro-Tem Gary
Hinders, Commissioners David Logan, Justin Richardson and Joseph Shehan.
Also present were the following City Staff: City Manager Randy Criswell, Assistant City Manager
Chris Sharp, City Secretary Gretchen Mercer, Assistant City Manager for Special Projects Jon
Behrens, Director of Code Enforcement Danny Cornelius, Public Works Director Dan Reese,
Director of Parks and Recreation Brian Noel, Librarian Sandra Munger, Chief of Police Dale
Davis, Business and Community Development Director Evelyn Ecker, Fire Chief Mike Webb and
City Attorney Chuck Hester.
Item 1. Lunch for Commission 1:00 to 2:00 pm.
Item 2. Call to Order.
Mayor Alexander called the meeting to order at 2:00 p.m.
Item 3. Invocation.
Commissioner Shehan gave the invocation.
Item 4. Pledge of Allegiance.
The Pledge of Allegiance was led by Fire Chief Mike Webb.
Item 5. Approval of Minutes of the Meeting of November 21, 2016.
Commissioner Shehan moved, duly seconded by Commissioner Logan, to approve the minutes
of November 21, 2016 as presented. Motion carried unanimously.
Item 6. Public Comment – Comments from In Interested Citizens.
Commissioner Logan recognized all involved with the Chamber of Commerce Christmas in
Canyon on a great job of bringing the community together and the programs presented.
Item 7. Commission/Staff Training, conducted by Underwood Law Firm.
Slater Elza, Attorney for Underwood Law Firm, presented training for the City Commission and
City Staff. Mr. Elza covered the City of Canyon Charter, Local Government Code pertaining to
Municipal Commission/Manager type government and Open Meetings.
Mayor Alexander moved to Item 9.
Item 9. Consider and Take Appropriate Action on Resolution No. 20-2016, Suspending the
Effective Date of A Proposed Rate Increase by West Texas Gas, Inc, Under the GRIP
Statute.
City Commission Meeting
December 5, 2016
Page 2 of 3
City Manager Randy Criswell presented Resolution No. 20-2016 for consideration.
After discussion, Commissioner Logan moved, duly seconded by Mayor Pro-Tem Hinders to
adopt Resolution No. 20-2016 as presented. Motion carried unanimously.
RESOLUTION NO. 20-2016
A RESOLUTION BY THE CITY OF CANYON, TEXAS, ("CITY") RESPONDING TO THE
APPLICATION OF WEST TEXAS GAS, INC., TO INCREASE RATES UNDER THE GAS
RELIABILITY INFRASTRUCTURE PROGRAM; SUSPENDING THE EFFECTIVE DATE
OF THIS RATE APPLICATION FOR FORTY-FIVE DAYS; AUTHORIZING THE CITY’S
PARTICIPATION IN A COALITION OF CITIES KNOWN AS THE "ALLIANCE OF WEST
TEXAS GAS COMPANY MUNICIPALITIES;" REQUIRING THE REIMBURSEMENT OF
COSTS; DETERMINING THAT THE MEETING AT WHICH THE RESOLUTION WAS
ADOPTED COMPLIED WITH THE TEXAS OPEN MEETINGS ACT; MAKING SUCH
OTHER FINDINGS AND PROVISIONS RELATED TO THE SUBJECT; AND DECLARING
AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
Mayor Alexander moved to Item 8.
Item 8. Presentation from Republic Waste Services on Plans for Future Expansion of Landfill.
City Manager Randy Criswell introduced Jason Strough, General Manager of Allied Waste. Mr.
Strough presented plans for expansion of the current landfill north of Canyon. Mr. Strough stated
the useable life of the landfill would increase from approximately 10 years to 100 years. Mr.
Strough said the boundary would expand from 124.3 acres to 473.4 acres and the height would
increase 28.5 feet about the current height.
Item 10. Executive Session Pursuant to Texas Government Code §551.071, Consultation with
Attorney, §551.072 Real Property and §551.074 Personnel, Appointments to Boards
and Committees (Board of City Development; Canyon Housing Authority; and Parks,
Open Space and Recreation Advisory Committee).
Mayor Alexander indicated the Commission would adjourn into executive session at 6:32 pm.
Item 11. Consider and Take Appropriate Action on Items Discussed in Executive Session.
Upon returning from executive session at 7:00 pm, the following action was taken.
Commissioner Logan moved, duly seconded by Mayor Pro-Tem Hinders to reappoint Kent
Bridenstine, Gerry Nickell, Medina Ortiz and Jerry Robinson to the Canyon Housing Authority.
Motion carried unanimously.
Commissioner Shehan moved, duly seconded by Commissioner Logan to appoint Christina Cox
to the Board of City Development replacing outgoing member Helen Campsey and reappoint
Steve Weigand. Motion carried unanimously.
City Commission Meeting
December 5, 2016
Page 3 of 3
Commissioner Richardson moved, duly seconded by Mayor Alexander to appoint Liz Moore to
the Parks, Open Space and Recreation Advisory Committee replacing outgoing member Howard
Morris. Motion carried unanimously.
Item 12. Consider and Take Appropriate Action on Meeting Dates for January and February
2017
Commissioners decided to meet January 9th and 23rd, 2017 and February 6th, 2017.
Item 13. Adjournment
There being no further business, Mayor Pro-Tem Hinders moved this meeting be adjourned at
7:12 pm.
______________________________
Quinn Alexander, Mayor
ATTEST:
________________________________
Gretchen Mercer, City Secretary
REGARDING ITEM 6 AGENDA
To: Randy Criswell, City Manager
From: Danny Cornelius, Director of Code Enforcement
Date: December 13, 2016
Re: Consider and Take Appropriate Action on Plat for Back Road Acres Unit
No. 1.
The attached plat for Back Road Acres Unit No. 1 has been submitted. Although the
property is not within our city limits, the city does have the authority to approve plats within
our Extraterritorial Jurisdiction (ETJ). The ETJ for the City of Canyon is 1 mile. This addition
is located west of Brown Road, just west of Canyon.
The Planning and Zoning Commission voted unanimously to recommend approval of
the plat.
City of Canyon
Planning and Zoning Commission Meeting
Minutes – December 12, 2016
The Planning and Zoning Commission of the City of Canyon met in regular session at 4:00 pm
in the City Commission Chambers of the Civic Complex. Chairman Bill Craddock presided over
the meeting with the following Commissioners in attendance: Leesa Wood Calvi, Jon Davis,
Bobbie Jo Krutsch, Mike Wartes, Charles Munger, and Laurie Sharp. Commissioners Kevin
Luetkahans and John Pletcher were unable to attend.
Also present were the following City Staff: City Manager Randy Criswell, Assistant City
Manager Chris Sharp, Assistant City Manager Jon Behrens, and Combination Inspector Rob
Standley.
Item 1: Call to Order.
Chairman Craddock called the meeting to order at 4:02 pm.
Item 2: Approval of Minutes from October 10, 2016 Meeting.
Commissioner Krutsch moved, duly seconded by Commissioner Calvi, to approve the minutes
of October 10, 2016. Motion passed unanimously.
Item 3: Consider and Take Appropriate Action on a Plat for Back Road Acres Unit No. 1.
The commission considered a plat for Back Road Acres Unit No. 1. The property is located
within the City of Canyon’s 1 mile Extraterritorial Jurisdiction, west of Brown Road, just west of
Canyon.
After discussion, Commissioner Krutsch moved, duly seconded by Commissioner Munger, to
recommend approval of the plat. The motion passed unanimously.
Item 4: Adjourn.
Chairman Craddock adjourned the meeting at 4:10 pm.
Bill Craddock, Chairman
Planning and Zoning Commission
ATTEST:
Gretchen Mercer
City Clerk
REGARDING ITEM 7 AGENDA
To: Mayor and City Commission
From: Randy Criswell, City Manager
Date: December 19, 2016
Re: Consider and Take Appropriate Action on Resolution 22-2016, Approving a
Settlement Agreement Between the Alliance of Xcel Municipalities (AXM)
and Southwestern Public Service Company (SPS), Regarding Electric
Rates.
On or about February 16, 2016, SPS filed an application to increase its base rates by
approximately $71.9 million in annual revenue, representing an increase of 14.21%.
As is typical, you adopted a Resolution to suspend the effective date of that increase.
Since that time, we’ve been negotiating with SPS, attempting to reach a negotiated
settlement that is agreeable to all parties. In reality, Cities are really the “small players”
in the electric utility ratemaking process. We’ve been told that SPS has one industrial
customer that uses more electricity than all of the SPS cities combined. However, we
do have a place at the negotiating table, and all intervenors work well together, with
the State to attempt to reach a suitable settlement instead of going to litigation.
In November, that settlement was reached and ultimately approved by the PUC. The
final result was a total increase of $35 million (instead of $71.9), which dropped to
about a 7% increase. SPS has invested millions in their infrastructure over the past
few years, and they do have a right to recover those expenses, the same as we do
when we upgrade our infrastructure. All parties feel like this is a fair settlement. As
you know, if it goes to litigation at the PUC, there’s no way to predict the outcome, so
it’s much better to settle when we can.
The impact on an average home is between $3 and $5/month, depending on summer
or winter usage. I’ve included two pages showing the results of the negotiations, with
the proposed increase per customer class versus the ultimate outcome.
These rate case filings will continue, and this settlement does not preclude them from
filing future cases. We’ll work through those as they come, just like we did this one.
Resolution No. 22-2016 has been prepared for the purpose of ratifying the Settlement.
(Just FYI, the Resolution refers to the Settlement Agreement which is 137 pages long,
so we did not include it in your packets. If you’d like to see it, I’ll be happy to forward it
to you.)
It is staff’s recommendation that Resolution No. 22-2016 be adopted.
City of Canyon
RESOLUTION NO. 21-2016
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY OF CANYON APPROVING A
SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE ALLIANCE OF
XCEL MUNICIPALITIES (“AXM”) AND SOUTHWESTERN
PUBLIC SERVICE COMPANY (“SPS” OR “COMPANY”)
REGARDING THE COMPANY’S STATEMENT OF INTENT TO
CHANGE ELECTRIC RATES IN ALL CITIES EXERCISING
ORIGINAL JURISDICTION; DECLARING EXISTING RATES TO
BE UNREASONABLE; ADOPTING TARIFFS THAT REFLECT
RATE ADJUSTMENTS CONSISTENT WITH THE SETTLEMENT
AGREEMENT AND FINDING THE RATES TO BE SET BY THE
ATTACHED TARIFFS TO BE JUST AND REASONABLE;
FINDING THE CITY’S RATE CASE EXPENSES REASONABLE;
DIRECTING SPS TO REIMBURSE THE CITY ITS REASONABLE
RATE CASE EXPENSES; DETERMINING THAT THIS
RESOLUTION WAS PASSED IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE
REQUIREMENTS OF THE TEXAS OPEN MEETING ACT;
DECLARING AN EFFECTIVE DATE; REPEALING ANY PRIOR
RESOLUTIONS INCONSISTENT WITH THIS RESOLUTION
AND REQUIRING DELIVERY OF THIS RESOLUTION TO THE
COMPANY AND LEGAL COUNSEL
WHEREAS, the City of Canyon, Texas (“City”) has exclusive original
jurisdiction as a regulatory authority over Southwestern Public Service Company (“SPS”
or “Company”) rates, operations, and services within the City; and
WHEREAS, the City is also an electric utility customer of SPS, and has an
interest in SPS’s rates and charges; and
WHEREAS, SPS filed a Statement of Intent with the City on or about February
16, 2016 to increase its annual revenue requirement by approximately $71.9 million on a
Texas retail jurisdictional basis, which represents an increase in base revenues of
approximately 14.41%, and which included an increase in residential base rates of
approximately 11.23%; and
WHEREAS, the City took action to suspend the effective date and to coordinate
a response to SPS’s filing with other similarly situated municipalities (such participating
cities are referred to herein as the Alliance of Xcel Municipalities (“AXM”)); and
WHEREAS, the City took action on or before March 22, 2016 to suspend the
effective date; and
PAGE 1 of 5
WHEREAS, one of AXM’s goals is to minimize rate-case expenses to the extent
reasonable, that otherwise would result from lengthy, contested rate-case proceedings
before the Public Utility Commission of Texas (“PUCT”) and through the appellate
process in the courts for the pending rate case; and
WHEREAS, AXM authorized its attorneys and experts to formulate and review
reasonable settlement positions to resolve SPS’ pending request to increase rates; and
WHEREAS, AXM’s attorneys met numerous times with the Company to
negotiate a Settlement Agreement resolving the issues raised by the Company’s
Statement of Intent filing; and
WHEREAS, after extensive review and analysis, AXM’s attorneys and experts
found that SPS’s initially proposed increase in revenue and its initially proposed rates are
unreasonable; and
WHEREAS, AXM’s attorneys and experts have evaluated what a likely outcome
from a fully-litigated proceeding would be and are of the opinion that the increase of
approximately $35 million noted in the negotiated Settlement Agreement compares
favorably with a likely outcome from a fully-litigated proceeding; and
WHEREAS, after extensive review and analysis, AXM’s attorneys and experts
found that the significantly lower increase of approximately $35 million instead of the
$71.9 million increase initially proposed by SPS is reasonable; and
WHEREAS, under applicable law, the settlement rates are effective retroactively
for consumption on or after July 20, 2016; and
WHEREAS, AXM’s attorneys and experts and AXM’s Steering Committee,
based on the advice of its attorneys and experts, recommend that AXM’s members
approve the negotiated Settlement Agreement and attached tariffs; and
WHEREAS, under the Public Utility Regulatory Act, the City has a right to
reimbursement of its reasonable rate-case expenses and SPS has an obligation to
reimburse the City’s reasonable rate-case expenses; and
WHEREAS, the attached tariffs implementing new rates are consistent with the
Settlement Agreement and are just, reasonable, and in the public interest; and
PAGE 2 of 5
WHEREAS, the Settlement Agreement as a whole is in the public interest;
NOW THEREFORE, THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF CANYON,
TEXAS HEREBY RESOLVES THAT:
Section 1. The findings set out in the preamble are in all things approved and
incorporated herein as if fully set forth.
Section 2. That the City Commission finds that the Settlement Agreement, which is
attached hereto EXHIBIT A and incorporated herein, is in the public interest and is
hereby endorsed in all respects.
Section 3. That SPS’s existing rates are found unreasonable upon the implementation
of the rates set forth in the Settlement Agreement.
Section 4. That the revenue and resulting rates set forth in the Settlement Agreement
and schedule of rates and tariffs for electric service provided by SPS, which are attached
to the Settlement Agreement as “Attachment B,” are just and reasonable, and are hereby
adopted for consumption on and after July 20, 2016.
Section 5. That the baseline amounts set forth in the Settlement Agreement and
attached to the Settlement Agreement as “Attachment D” are approved subject to the
conditions stated in the Settlement Agreement.
Section 6. That rates under the Settlement Agreement shall be effective for
consumption on and after July 20, 2016.
Section 7. That SPS shall seek the City’s approval of any surcharge that may be
necessary to recover revenue foregone by SPS under rates pursuant to the Settlement
Agreement and its current rates from July 20, 2016 to the date when the rates under the
Settlement Agreement are approved.
PAGE 3 of 5
Section 8. That to the extent any resolution or ordinance previously adopted by the
Commission is inconsistent with this Resolution, it is hereby repealed.
Section 9. That the meeting at which this Resolution was approved was in all things
conducted in strict compliance with the Texas Open Meetings Act, Texas Government
Code, Chapter 551.
Section 10. That if any one or more sections or clauses of this Resolution is adjudged
to be unconstitutional or invalid, such judgment shall not affect, impair or invalidate the
remaining provision of this Resolution and the remaining provisions of the Resolution
shall be interpreted as if the offending section or clause never existed.
Section 11. That this Resolution shall become effective from and after its passage.
Section 12. The City Secretary or other appropriate city official shall notify SPS of
this Resolution by sending a copy of the Resolution to Evan Evans, Regional Vice
President, Rates and Regulatory Affairs, Southwestern Public Service Company,
P.O. Box 1261, Amarillo, Texas 79105-1261 and AXM shall be notified by sending a
copy of this Resolution to Mr. Alfred R. Herrera, Herrera & Boyle, PLLC, 816
Congress Ave., Suite 1250, Austin, Texas 78701.
PASSED AND APPROVED this 19th day of December, 2016.
QUINN ALEXANDER, MAYOR
ATTEST:
Gretchen Mercer, City Secretary
PAGE 4 of 5
SPS RATE RESOLUTION
Exhibit A
SPS 2016 Statement of Intent
Stipulation and Settlement
Agreement
PAGE 5 of 5
AIS ATTACHMENT A
Comparison of Current Rates vs. Settlement Rates
Current Settled Page 1 of 4
Rates Rates
Residential
Service Availability Charge $9.50 $10.00 / Month
Energy Charge - Summer $0.075114 $0.078572 / kWh
Energy Charge - Winter $0.064895 $0.068353 / kWh
Residential - Space Heating
Service Availability Charge $9.50 $10.00 / Month
Energy Charge - Summer $0.075114 $0.078572 / kWh
Energy Charge - Winter $0.045124 $0.048582 / kWh
Residential - Time of Use
Service Availability Charge $10.50 $10.50 / Month
Energy Charge - All Hours $0.056101 $0.058183 / kWh
Energy Charge - On Peak Adder $0.127314 $0.124929 / kWh
Small Commercial Service (demnd of </= 10kW/month)
Service Availability Charge $11.60 $11.25 / Month
Energy Charge - Summer $0.051033 $0.063138 / kWh
Energy Charge - Winter $0.043326 $0.053482 / kWh
Small Commercial Service -- Time of Use
Service Availability Charge $13.70 $12.25 / Month
Energy Charge - All Hours $0.037379 $0.045384 / kWh
Energy Charge - On Peak Adder $0.114585 $0.137365 / kWh
Small School & Small Municipal Service (demnd of </= 10kW/month)
Service Availability Charge $11.95 $13.20 / Month
Energy Charge - Summer $0.049090 $0.045136 / kWh
Energy Charge - Winter $0.040688 $0.038897 / kWh
Small School & Small Municipal Service -- Time of Use
Service Availability Charge $12.95 $14.20 / Month
Energy Charge - All Hours $0.037197 $0.033458 / kWh
Energy Charge - On Peak Adder $0.116209 $0.117987 / kWh
AIS ATTACHMENT A
Comparison of Current Rates vs. Settlement Rates
Large Municipal Service (demnd of > 10kW/month) -- Secondary Page 2 of 4
Service Availability Charge $24.59 $25.90 / Month
Demand Charge - Summer $11.43 $10.87 / kW-Mo
Demand Charge - Winter $9.01 $8.90 / kW-Mo
Energy Charge $0.006478 $0.007692 / kWh
Power Factor Adjustment Charge - Summer $11.43 $10.87 / kW-Mo
Power Factor Adjustment Charge - Winter $9.01 $8.90 / kW-Mo
Large Municipal Service (demnd of > 10kW/mnth) - Primary
Service Availability Charge $24.59 $25.90 / Month
Demand Charge - Summer $7.06 $10.73 /kW-Mo
Demand Charge - Winter $8.21 $8.80 /kW-Mo
Energy Charge $0.006478 $0.007573 /kWh
Power Factor Adjustment Charge - Summer $10.42 $10.73 /kW-Mo
Power Factor Adjustment Charge - Winter $8.21 $8.80 /kW-Mo
Large Municipal Service (demnd of > 10kW/mnth) - Secondary -- Time of Use
Service Availability Charge $25.59 $26.90 / Month
Demand Charge $7.06 $7.30 /kW-Mo
Energy Charge - On Peak Adder $0.114958 $0.122527 /kWh
Energy Charge - All Hours $0.006478 $0.007692 /kWh
Power Factor Adjustment Charge - Summer $7.06 $7.30 /kW-Mo
Power Factor Adjustment Charge - Winter $7.06 $7.30 /kW-Mo
Large Municipal Service (demnd of > 10kW/mnth) - Primary -- Time of Use
Service Availability Charge $25.59 $26.90 / Month
Demand Charge $7.06 $7.34 /kW-Mo
Energy Charge - On Peak Adder $0.114958 $0.120055 /kWh
Energy Charge - All Hours $0.006478 $0.007573 /kWh
Power Factor Adjustment Charge - Summer $7.06 $7.34 /kW-Mo
Power Factor Adjustment Charge - Winter $7.06 $7.34 /kW-Mo
Large School (demnd of > 10kW/mnth) - Secondary
Service Availability Charge $33.75 $31.30 / Month
Demand Charge - Summer $11.94 $13.66 /kW-Mo
Demand Charge - Winter $9.45 $11.21 /kW-Mo
Energy Charge $0.008437 $0.009577 /kWh
Power Factor Adjustment Charge - Summer $11.94 $13.66 /kW-Mo
Power Factor Adjustment Charge - Winter $9.45 $11.21 /kW-Mo
AIS ATTACHMENT A
Comparison of Current Rates vs. Settlement Rates
Large School (demnd of > 10kW/mnth) - Primary Page 3 of 4
Service Availability Charge $33.75 $31.30 / Month
Demand Charge - Summer $10.40 $11.97 /kW-Mo
Demand Charge - Winter $8.10 $9.85 /kW-Mo
Energy Charge $0.008295 $0.008990 /kWh
Power Factor Adjustment Charge - Summer $10.40 $11.97 /kW-Mo
Power Factor Adjustment Charge - Winter $8.10 $9.85 /kW-Mo
Large School Service (demnd of > 10kW/mnth) - Secondary -- Time of Use
Service Availability Charge $34.70 $32.30 / Month
Demand Charge $8.58 $9.67 /kW-Mo
Energy Charge - On Peak Adder $0.110000 $0.142949 /kWh
Energy Charge - All Hours $0.008437 $0.009577 /kWh
Power Factor Adjustment Charge - Summer $8.58 $9.67 /kW-Mo
Power Factor Adjustment Charge - Winter $8.58 $9.67 /kW-Mo
Large School Service (demnd of > 10kW/mnth) - Primary -- Time of Use
Service Availability Charge $34.75 $32.30 / Month
Demand Charge $7.41 $7.59 /kW-Mo
Energy Charge - On Peak Adder $0.109986 $0.140525 /kWh
Energy Charge - All Hours $0.008295 $0.008990 /kWh
Power Factor Adjustment Charge - Summer $7.41 $7.59 /kW-Mo
Power Factor Adjustment Charge - Winter $7.41 $7.59 /kW-Mo
AIS ATTACHMENT A Page 4 of 4
Comparison of Residential Customer's Bill -
Current Rates vs. Settlement Rates
SPS' Current Average Average
Rates kWh Bill
(without taxes)
Monthly Charge $9.50
Summer $/kWh $0.075114 Summer: 1,125 $120.67 At Current
Winter $/kWh $0.064895 Winter: 777 $80.41 Rates
Space Htg-Summer $/kWh $0.075114 Summer: 1,382 $146.11
Space Htg-Winter $/kWh $0.045124 Winter: 1,375 $107.76
Summer Fuel $/kWh $0.023051
Winter Fuel $/kWh $0.025663
EECRF $/kWh $0.000668 Amounts Shown Below Without Franchise Fees and Taxes
Customer Bill 1000 1500 2000 2500 3000 3500
Non-Spc Heating kWh kWh kWh kWh kWh kWh
Summer $108.33 $157.75 $207.17 $256.58 $306.00 $355.42
Winter $100.73 $146.34 $191.95 $237.57 $283.18 $328.79
Settlement Average Average Increase In Percent
Rates kWh Bill Average Increase In
(without taxes) Bill Avg. Bill
Monthly Charge $10.00
Summer $/kWh $0.078572 Summer: 1,125 $125.06 At Settled $4.39 4%
Winter $/kWh $0.068353 Winter: 777 $83.59 Rates $3.19 4%
Space Htg-Summer $/kWh $0.078572 Summer: 1,382 $151.39 $5.28 4%
Space Htg-Winter $/kWh $0.048582 Winter: 1,375 $113.02 $5.26 5%
Summer Fuel $/kWh $0.023051
Winter Fuel $/kWh $0.025663
EECRF $/kWh $0.000668 Amounts Shown Below Without Franchise Fees and Taxes
Customer Bill 1000 1500 2000 2500 3000 3500
Non-Spc Heating kWh kWh kWh kWh kWh kWh
Summer $112.29 $163.44 $214.58 $265.73 $316.87 $368.02
Winter $104.68 $152.03 $199.37 $246.71 $294.05 $341.39
Proposed Increase in Residential Customer's Total Bill (excluding franchise fees and taxes)
Amounts Shown Below WIthout Franchise Fees and Taxes
Customer Bill 1000 1500 2000 2500 3000 3500
Non-Spc Heating kWh kWh kWh kWh kWh kWh
Summer $3.96 $5.69 $7.42 $9.15 $10.87 $12.60
4% 4% 4% 4% 4% 4%
Winter $3.96 $5.69 $7.42 $9.14 $10.87 $12.60
4% 4% 4% 4% 4% 4%
SPS RATE RESOLUTION
Exhibit A
SPS 2016 Statement of Intent
Stipulation and Settlement
Agreement
PAGE 5 of 5
SUMMARY REGARDING ITEM 8 AGENDA
To: Mayor and City Commission
From: Randy Criswell, City Manager
Date: December 19, 2016
Re: Hear Reports from Palo Duro Creek Golf Course for FY 2016.
John Haun and Casey Renner have prepared brief reports for you regarding Palo Duro
Creek Golf Course for FY 2016. John’s report is related to the grounds and the actual “golf
course”. Casey’s report is oriented to the actual number of rounds and the fiscal
performance of the golf course for the year.
These reports are for informational purposes only and will not be presented
formally.
City of Canyon
REGARDING ITEM 8 AGENDA
To: Randy Criswell, City Manager
From: John Haun, Casey Renner
Date: December 7, 2016
Re: Palo Duro Creek Golf Course Annual Grounds Report for FY 2016.
The year started out very dry as we had no significant moisture from October to May.
We received less than 10” of snow last winter and only 14.15” of rain this past growing
season. This is a stark difference to the previous year when we received over 30 inches
of rain and 23 inches of snow. The saving grace was we received 3 to 4 timely rains this
past summer that kept us growing and looking good.
We continue to trim the Siberian elms on the course with a total of 65 trees done. The
removal of 11 trees around the course was necessary due to death, mainly Arborvitae
trees around greens. These trees were replaced with new trees.
This fall we planted 18 new conifer trees, 9 Austrian pine trees and 9 Pinyon pine trees.
We will continue to do this as necessary.
The new irrigation installed this year was the right side rough of #8 and the right side of
#16 green surround. These areas were seeded to perennial rye grass and they are
doing well. These areas get a lot of play and it has improved the playability and
aesthetics of these two holes. We also installed new drains at #2 green, #6 green and
by the cart path on #15 by the green.
New seeding this year was in #12 fairway landing area, upper right side of #17 right
rough with Riveria Bermuda seed. We also over seeded areas around greens and
roughs with perennial rye grass due to wear from high traffic areas and shade.
All the greens are in great shape except #8 green. We continue to have percolation
issues with this green. I feel as though that I solved the problem during the late summer
and early fall on how to deal with this. It requires very judicious watering and the use of
a special fertilizer. This is caused by the location of the green being “tucked” back in a
corner with housing in close proximity causing more morning shade and less daily air
flow across the green.
In November of 2016 we purchased a trained “goose” dog to haze the geese. The dogs
name is Lass and she is a small border collie. So far, this has proven to be a very wise
decision as she has been able to keep a vast majority of the geese off the course.
There has been no damage from geese to any of the greens and tees. Lass and I chase
the geese seven days a week, usually 3 times per day, with the critical time being at
sundown so the geese won’t “roost” on the course all night.
City of Canyon
AGENDA
The irrigation system continues to be the biggest maintenance issue each year. We
continue to have numerous piping leaks and needing to replace many heads and valves.
I did a quick count from my yearly notes and this past year we had 69 leaks, had to fix or
replace 59 heads and or valves and had 18 issues with wiring and controllers. This will
only continue to get worse each year.
We will be leasing some new equipment in the spring of 2017.
Here is a main list of the continued capital needs at the golf course. A new irrigation
system, a master plan, expansion/renovation of the club house, parking lot
improvements, new bridges, new cart storage building, new bathroom on the front nine,
wash area for equipment.
In summary, overall we have the most turf grass cover and the best playability and
aesthetics ever.
Thank you and we look forward to 2017.
City of Canyon
REGARDING ITEM 8 AGENDA
To: City Manager, Randy Criswell
From: Casey Renner and John Haun
Date: December 1, 2016
Re: Palo Duro Creek Golf Course Annual Golf Report FY 2016.
Palo Duro Creek Golf Course had a busy year in 2016. PDC hosted 46 outside events this year, 7 high
school and junior high events, 4 Northern Texas PGA events and the NTPGA Junior Area Championship
and 20 Thursday Night Scrambles. We are also very proud of our involvement in the PGA Jr. League.
We had 2 teams of 16 juniors in the Amarillo League this year. We hosted 10 matches at PDC and
traveled for 10 matches to the Amarillo courses. We also got to participate in the post season and one
of our players was on the state winning team. This program continues to develop and is a huge part in
growing the game of golf.
Our rounds were up this year and the golf course was in great shape all year long. Below is a summary
of our revenues for the fiscal year of 2016:
Rounds in 2016 – 26,655
Cart Revenue in 2016 - $274,275.00
Green Fee Revenue in 2016 - $302,306.00
Pro Shop Revenue in 2016 - $207,649.00
Grill Revenue in 2016 - $176,452.61.00
Please see the attached document that has our yearly comparisons and this year’s totals. If you have
any questions, we’ll be happy to answer them.
Thank you for your time and consideration.
City of Canyon
Month 2010‐2011 2011‐2012 2012‐2013 2013‐2014 2014‐2015 2015‐2016 Avg.
Cart Fees $ 20,130.00 $ 21,858.00 $ 17,706.00 $ 18,426.00 $ 19,992.00 $ 18,519.00 $ 19,622.40
Oc
t. Green Fees $ 17,434.00 $ 27,608.00 $ 16,554.00 $ 18,270.00 $ 21,400.00 $ 20,142.00 $ 20,234.67
Rounds 1857 2325 1964 2250 2472 2067 2156
Cart Fees $ 10,046.00 $ 10,758.00 $ 16,218.00 $ 10,146.00 $ 10,500.00 $ 14,612.00 $ 12,046.67
No Green Fees $ 9,868.00 $ 10,878.00 $ 15,986.00 $ 10,477.00 $ 13,211.00 $ 14,703.00 $ 12,520.50
v.
Rounds 1171 1355 1622 993 1047 1288 1246
Cart Fees $ 11,054.00 $ 5,610.00 $ 9,066.00 $ 6,648.00 $ 7,482.00 $ 7,616.00 $ 7,912.67
Dec. Green Fees $ 7,422.00 $ 5,450.00 $ 8,720.00 $ 4,794.00 $ 8,045.00 $ 7,124.00 $ 6,925.83
Rounds 874 543 776 652 660 780 714
Cart Fees $ 19,848.00 $ 23,052.00 $ 14,400.00 $ 14,665.00 $ 9,038.00 $ 12,289.00 $ 15,548.67
n.
Ja Green Fees $ 9,602.00 $ 10,218.00 $ 6,041.00 $ 7,139.00 $ 3,801.00 $ 8,667.00 $ 7,578.00
Rounds 1106 1286 776 800 466 889 887
Cart Fees $ 9,966.00 $ 8,004.00 $ 9,312.00 $ 14,935.00 $ 16,000.00 $ 18,089.00 $ 12,717.67
Feb. Green Fees $ 8,760.00 $ 7,404.00 $ 7,362.00 $ 9,459.00 $ 10,441.00 $ 15,897.00 $ 9,887.17
Rounds 973 858 891 1103 1143 1542 1085
Cart Fees $ 26,376.00 $ 24,996.00 $ 18,906.00 $ 20,075.00 $ 23,980.00 $ 22,012.00 $ 22,724.17
ar . Green Fees $ 25,140.00 $ 24,812.00 $ 19,700.00 $ 16,648.00 $ 22,061.00 $ 21,403.00 $ 21,627.33
M
Rounds 2775 2574 2312 1958 2294 1981 2316
Cart Fees $ 24,516.00 $ 24,336.00 $ 20,682.00 $ 15,829.00 $ 21,332.00 $ 23,231.00 $ 21,654.33
Ap
r. Green Fees $ 27,240.00 $ 27,446.00 $ 24,914.00 $ 15,305.00 $ 22,122.00 $ 25,876.00 $ 23,817.17
Rounds 2955 2986 2681 1892 2298 2482 2549
Cart Fees $ 29,742.00 $ 33,252.00 $ 25,500.00 $ 29,487.00 $ 21,915.00 $ 27,919.00 $ 27,969.17
ay Green Fees $ 33,504.00 $ 37,322.00 $ 29,537.00 $ 32,488.00 $ 24,248.00 $ 36,737.00 $ 32,306.00
M
Rounds 3482 3614 3129 2802 2157 3010 3032
Cart Fees $ 34,434.00 $ 37,440.00 $ 32,802.00 $ 29,722.00 $ 34,998.00 $ 35,820.00 $ 34,202.67
ne
Ju Green Fees $ 37,296.00 $ 41,784.00 $ 39,149.00 $ 31,146.00 $ 36,585.00 $ 43,270.00 $ 38,205.00
Rounds 3706 4138 3577 3398 3567 3226 3602
Cart Fees $ 41,688.00 $ 41,700.00 $ 33,390.00 $ 40,160.00 $ 37,947.00 $ 32,501.00 $ 37,897.67
Ju
ly Green Fees $ 46,380.00 $ 46,600.00 $ 37,530.00 $ 41,522.00 $ 41,949.00 $ 37,231.00 $ 41,868.67
Rounds 4771 4360 3953 3560 3710 3519 3979
Cart Fees $ 37,002.00 $ 31,848.00 $ 36,528.00 $ 37,100.00 $ 32,065.00 $ 34,511.00 $ 34,842.33
Au
g. Green Fees $ 38,924.00 $ 33,374.00 $ 41,437.00 $ 39,662.00 $ 34,412.00 $ 40,159.00 $ 37,994.67
Rounds 3885 3534 4117 3732 3664 3258 3698
Cart Fees $ 31,980.00 $ 27,828.00 $ 30,858.00 $ 25,968.00 $ 35,498.00 $ 27,156.00 $ 29,881.33
Sept Green Fees $ 36,258.00 $ 33,704.00 $ 35,496.00 $ 29,263.00 $ 39,235.00 $ 31,097.00 $ 34,175.50
.
Rounds 3360 3144 3117 2501 2804 2613 2923
Cart Fees $296,782.00 $290,682.00 $265,368.00 $ 263,161.00 $ 270,747.00 $ 274,275.00 $ 277,348.00
Tota Green Fees $297,828.00 $306,600.00 $282,426.00 $ 256,173.00 $ 277,510.00 $ 302,306.00 $ 284,107.40
l
Rounds 30915 30717 28915 25641 26282 26655 28494
SUMMARY REGARDING ITEM 9 AGENDA
To: Mayor and City Commission
From: Randy Criswell, City Manager
Date: December 19, 2016
Re: Consider and Take Appropriate Action on Proposed Fees for Palo Duro
Creek Golf Course for 2017.
Following this memo is information from John Haun and Casey Renner regarding proposed
fee increases for the golf course.
John and Casey will be here on Monday to present their proposed fee changes for your
approval.
It is staff’s recommendation that the proposed fee schedule be approved as
presented.
City of Canyon
REGARDING ITEM 9 AGENDA
To: City Manager, Randy Criswell
From: John Haun, Casey Renner
Date: December 1, 2016
Re: Consider and Take Appropriate Action on Palo Duro Creek Golf Course
Golf Fees and Tournament Fees.
Casey and I propose a change in Palo Duro Creek golf fees to begin calendar year 2017.
The fee change will increase all green fees by $5 except Junior green fees (increase of $2),
and Twilight green fees (increase $3 from 3 to 5 pm both weekdays and weekends). We
also propose an increase in annual permit fees as follows: Senior single $25, single every
day $75, additional person $25 and Junior permit $60.
It is staff’s recommendation that the fees be approved, effective January 1, 2017.
Casey has updated the PDC tournament fees. Listed below are the old tournament fees and
the new tournament fees. These changes are a direct reflection of the proposed changes in
daily fees. Establishing these new fees with the City Commission means that the fees are
non-negotiable.
It is staff’s recommendation that the fees be approved, effective January 1, 2017.
City of Canyon
AGENDA
Palo Duro Creek Golf Course
Proposed 2017 Fee Schedule
Fee name 2016 Proposed 2017
Permits
Permits- Senior, single 60+, weekday only $550.00 $575.00
Additional per person fee, any category $275.00 $300.00
Single, any day $825.00 $900.00
Jr. Permit High school senior or younger, June thru August,
Monday thru Thursday only $180.00 $240.00
Green fees
Green fee- Monday thru Thursday $15.00
Proposed new daily green fee-Monday thru Thursday $20.00
Green fee- Friday, Saturday, Sunday, Holidays $20.00
Proposed new daily green fee-Friday, Saturday, Sunday, Holidays $25.00
Twilight- Monday thru Thursday-After 5 pm $10.00
Proposed new twilight green fee-from 3 to 5 pm $13.00
Twilight- Friday, Sat, Sun, Holidays-After 5 pm $12.00
Proposed new twilight green fee-from 3 to 5 pm $15.00
Jr. Fee High school senior or younger $8.00
Proposed new Jr. green fee $10.00
College Monday thru Thursday $11.00
Proposed new college green fee-Mon thru Thurs $16.00
Friday, Saturday, Sunday, Holidays $15.00
Proposed new college green fee-Fri, Sat, Sun, Holidays $20.00
Senior 60+ Monday thru Thursday $11.00
Proposed new Sr. daily green fee-Mon thru Thurs $16.00
Senior 60+ Friday, Sat, Sun, Holidays $15.00
Proposed new Sr. daily green fee-Frid, Sat, Sun, Holidays $20.00
Cart fees
Cart fees 18 holes $13/$26 $13/$26
9 holes $7/$13 $7/$13
All above prices include sales tax.
Single permit is defined as a permit that allows golfers to play 7 days a week. The
Senior permit is defined for single golfers age 60 and above to play Monday through
Friday. Additional Family permit is defined by any dependent or co-dependent living in
the same household.
“Additional per person fee” shall be defined as any dependent or co-dependent living in
the same household.
City of Canyon
AGENDA
“Children” shall be defined as a dependent, living in the home, up to age of 18, OR a full
time college student not over the age of 24. Proof of full time college student status will
be required.
“College” shall be defined as a full time college student not over the age of 24. Proof of
full time college student status will be required.
Annual permit fee may be prorated for the purchase of a holder’s first Annual permit.
Proration shall be based on the total number of months (including partial months)
remaining in the year. This policy shall apply to the first purchase only of an Annual
Permit. Anyone previously possessing an Annual Permit will not be eligible for a
prorated purchase the following year or any future year.
Tournament Fees
Old Fee New Fee
Weekday (Monday-Thursday), shotgun start
40 players and up $28.00
Weekday (Monday-Thursday), shotgun start
40 players and up $33.00
Weekend (Friday-Sunday), shotgun start
40 players and up $33.00
Weekend (Friday-Sunday, Holidays) SG start
40 players and up $38.00
Weekday (Monday-Thursday), Tee times start
39 players and under $28.00
Weekday (Monday-Thursday), Tee times start
39 players and under $33.00
Weekend (Friday-Sunday, Holidays), Tee times
39 players and under $33.00
Weekend (Friday-Sunday, Holidays), Tee times
39 players and under $38.00
The administration fee of $3.00 per player to cover the costs of paper, ink, score sheets, etc.,
is still in effect.
City of Canyon
REGARDING ITEM 10 AGENDA
To: Randy Criswell, City Manager
From: Dan Reese, Public Works Director
Date: December 13, 2016
Re: Consider and Take Appropriate Action Ordinance No. 1053, Repealing
Ordinance No. 1040 of the City of Canyon, Texas, Amending Chapter 51 of
the Code of Ordinances of the City of Canyon, Texas , Section 51-21,
Defining Charges and Rates for Bulk Water and Fire Hydrant Meters;
Providing a Severability Clause, and Establishing an Effective Date.
For many years now, we have been behind on what we charge contractors for use of bulk
water / fire hydrant meter use. Our older policy needs updating. As the policy stands now, we
charge only a $200 refundable deposit, when hydrant meters are checked out. This amount
will not even pay for the fittings attached to the meter. Another problem we’re having is getting
the contractors to return the meters, when not in use. This has forced us to stock up on meters,
not knowing how many that we may need from month to month. This is costly because a
hydrant meter, ready to put in service, is costing us around $1,100. Currently, we have
approximately 30 meters out to various contractors in the area.
In previous ordinances, rates and fees for the issuance of fire hydrant meters for bulk water
use has not been addressed in the code. In an attempt to recoup a larger percentage of our
costs associated with these meters, keep up with their maintenance and encourage
contractors to return them when not in use, we’re recommending an amendment to the Bulk
Water section of the Code, Section 51.21(B).
We propose the refundable deposit for a meter to increase from $200 to $1000. At least this
amount would all but replace the meter, should one be lost, stolen or destroyed. We’re also
proposing a monthly minimum of $50 / month. We will be charging for the water used at the
current bulk water rate on top of the minimum. So, for example, you will be charged a $50
minimum plus the current rate of $7.15 per 1000 gals. for every thousand gallons used. For
example, if you use 10,000 gallons, your bill would be $71.15 for the water and $50 for the
minimum, or $121.15, total. Hopefully this will encourage customers that don’t use the meter
for several months to return it. Plus, this minimum charge can help pay for a few parts when
we have to service / repair them.
Hopefully, you can see this proposal will help us to minimize our losses and allow us to charge
what we believe to be a fair price for these services.
A copy of the revised ordinance is attached.
The public works department recommends adoption of Ordinance No. 1053 as
presented.
City of Canyon
ORDINANCE NO. 1053
AN ORDINANCE REPEALING ORDINANCE NO. 1040 OF THE CITY OF
CANYON, TEXAS; AMENDING CHAPTER 51 OF THE CODE OF
ORDINANCES OF THE CITY OF CANYON, TEXAS, SECTION 51-21,
DEFINING CHARGES AND RATES FOR BULK WATER AND FIRE
HYDRANT METERS; PROVIDING A SEVERABILITY CLAUSE; AND
ESTABLISHING AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
WHEREAS, the City of Canyon has heretofore adopted a Water and Sewer
Code providing fees to be charged for water service, and the City Commission has
determined that the rates established by Ordinance No. 1040 should be amended, by
defining charges and rates for bulk water and use of fire hydrant meters in order that
such service shall be self-supporting in operation and provide funds for required
maintenance and operation.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED BY THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY
OF CANYON, TEXAS THAT:
Section 1: That the Water and Sewer Code of the City of Canyon, Texas, Chapter 51,
Section 51-21, is hereby amended to read as follows:
51-21. Rates established - For Water
(A) Unless otherwise provided in this Article, the water rates per month to
be charged and collected by the City from all customers obtaining
service from the water system shall be fixed as set forth below:
Base + 2,000 gallons $27.46 minimum
2,001 - 8,000 gallons $4.57 per thousand
8,001 – 20,000 gallons $5.97 per thousand
20,001 – 35,000 gallons $6.13 per thousand
35,001 – 50,000 gallons $6.28 per thousand
Over 50,000 gallons $6.69 per thousand
(B) Bulk Water. Unless otherwise provided in this chapter, the purchase of
bulk water shall be charged and collected by the City from customers
purchasing bulk water and fixes the rate set forth below:
$7.15 per 1,000 gallons
Bulk Water Billing. Beginning with the effective date of this ordinance,
a $50.00 per month minimum charge will apply to all customers with
City of Canyon issued fire hydrant meters. Bulk water use will be billed
in addition to the monthly minimum. The City of Canyon will contact
bulk water customers on a monthly basis to obtain readings from
issued fire hydrant meters, and will be billed accordingly based on the
current bulk water rate. If a customer fails to report the monthly
reading within 30 days of contact, the meter will be assumed to be
lost, the customer will lose their deposit and any outstanding bulk
water bill will immediately become due. Due date, penalties and non-
payment shall be enforced according to Sections 51-24 and 51-66 of
the City of Canyon Code of Ordinances.
(C) Use of fire hydrant meters. Bulk water used for construction or other
purposes, not purchased from the City at other bulk loading facilities,
and obtained from City fire hydrants, shall be metered. Meters shall be
obtained (checked out) from the City of Canyon. Use of meters and
readings from meters not issued by the City of Canyon will not be
permitted or accepted. A refundable deposit of $1,000.00 will be
required when the meter is issued. Upon returning the meter, the
customer will be refunded the deposit at a pro-rated amount based on
the usable condition of the returned meter, up to the full amount. If the
meter is damaged or unusable, the estimated amount to repair the
meter will be deducted from the deposit. If the meter is lost or stolen,
the entire deposit will be forfeited. If desired, the customer will have
the option to apply any remaining deposit amount to their outstanding
bulk water bill. Fire hydrant meter audits may occur to verify meter
condition, accuracy and reading, as deemed necessary by the City. If
requested, the customer shall relinquish the meter to the City for this
purpose.
Section 2: All ordinances and amendments thereto in conflict with the provisions of this
ordinance shall be and are hereby repealed.
Section 3: In the event any part or parts of this ordinance shall be held invalid, no valid
part or parts shall be affected thereby.
Section 4: This Ordinance shall be effective January 1, 2017.
PASSED AND ADOPTED this 19th day of December, 2016.
Quinn Alexander, Mayor
ATTEST:
Gretchen Mercer, City Clerk
REGARDING ITEM 11 AGENDA
To: Randy Criswell, City Manager
From: Chris Sharp, Assistant City Manager
Date: December 12, 2016
Re: Consider and Take Appropriate Action on Resolution No. 22-2016 Increasing
the Rental Fees at the Cole Community Center
It’s has been more than 10 years since we have adjusted the rental rates at the Cole
Community Center. With the improvements that have been made, and with the increased
costs of operating the center, we feel it is time to raise the rates for rental. Included in this
agenda is a Resolution with the proposed rate increase. On average, we have increased the
rates by $20 for a 4-hour rental and increase the hourly rental fee for anything over 4 hours to
$15 an hour.
Additionally, I have included language requiring a $500 deposit for the rental and use of any
city owned electronic equipment that is being used by a renter. Deposits for room rental will
remain the same.
It is staff’s recommendation that the Commission approve Resolution No. 22-2016
authorizing the increase of the rental rate for the Cole Community Center and setting
the effective date for January 1, 2017.
City of Canyon
Proposed Rate Increase for Cole Community Center
Hourly Rental Fee 1st 4hrs 5 6 7 8
Palo Duro Room
Current Rate $ 95.00 $ 107.00 $ 119.00 $ 131.00 $ 143.00
Proposed Increase $ 115.00 $ 130.00 $ 145.00 $ 160.00 $ 165.00
Adobe Room
Current Rate $ 65.00 $ 75.00 $ 85.00 $ 95.00 $ 105.00
Proposed Increase $ 85.00 $ 100.00 $ 115.00 $ 130.00 $ 145.00
Mesa Room
Current Rate $ 40.00 $ 45.00 $ 50.00 $ 55.00 $ 60.00
Proposed Increase $ 60.00 $ 70.00 $ 80.00 $ 90.00 $ 100.00
Texas Room
Current Rate $ 40.00 $ 45.00 $ 50.00 $ 55.00 $ 60.00
Proposed Increase $ 60.00 $ 70.00 $ 80.00 $ 90.00 $ 100.00
Kitchen (Flat Rate)
Current Rate $ 35.00
Proposed Increase $ 65.00
Civic Clubs
Current Rate $ 100.00
Proposed Increase $ 125.00
Audio Visual
Equipment Deposit $ 500.00
RESOLUTION NO. 22-2016
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF CITY OF
CANYON, TEXAS, AMENDING RENTAL FEES FOR THIE
COLE COMMUNITY CENTER, AND SETTING AN EFFECTIVE
DATE
WHEREAS, the Cole Community Center has been available for use by citizens
wishing a place to lease for meetings, reunions, parties, and many other special occasions
since 1992; and
WHEREAS, this building has been used by many since inception and it is the
desire of the City Commission to continue leasing of the building for needs of the
community; and
WHEREAS, there is a need to amend previous rates set by the City Commission
and to guarantee revenue which is generated will be sufficient for the upkeep and
cleanliness of this building.
NOW THREREFORE, the City Commission RESOLVES the fee structure for the
Cole Community Center effective January 1, 2017 will be as follows:
Palo Duro Room first 4 hours - $115.00, then $15.00 per hour for each
additional hour, up to 8 hours per day. Deposit $150.00
Adobe Room first 4 hours - $85.00, then $15.00 per hour. Deposit
$100.00.
Mesa & Texas first 4 hours - $60.00, then $10.00 per hour
Deposit $50.00
Kitchen $65.00
Deposit $50.00
Civic Clubs Regular meetings $125.00/month
Audio Visual $500 Deposit
Equipment
PASSED AND APPROVED this 19th day of December, 2016.
QUINN ALEXANDER, MAYOR
ATTEST:
GRETCHEN MERCER, CITY SECRETARY
Get email alerts for Canyon
A daily email when new agendas and minutes are posted.