11/21/2022 Historic Preservation Commission Meeting

ZACK MULLOCK Mayor City of Cape May STACY D. SHEEHAN National Historic Landmark Deputy Mayor City Hall – 643 Washington Street LORRAINE M. BALDWIN Cape May, New Jersey 08204-2397 MICHAEL J. VOLL Councilmember (609) 884-9525 Fax: (609) 884-8589 SHAINE P. MEIER City Manager www.capemaycity.com Councilmember ERIN C. BURKE MICHAEL G. YEAGER City Clerk Councilmember Historic Preservation Commission Agenda City Hall Auditorium November 21, 2022 - 6:00 p.m. OPENING: In compliance with the Open Public Meetings Act of 1975, adequate notice of this meeting has been provided. If any member has reason to believe that this meeting is being held in violation of this Act they should state so at this time. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE ROLL CALL MINUTES: October 17, 2022 RESOLUTIONS: Varady, 289 Windsor Avenue, 1027/22, Resolution 2022-49 Muriaka and McLaughlin, 1009 Kearney Avenue, 1097/8,9, Resolution 2022-50 Somoza, 1386 Lafayette Street, 1145/7, Resolution 2022-51 APPLICATIONS APPROVED/DENIED IN REVIEW: Aissaui, 1014 Washington Street, 1110/4, Contributing – Porch roof and ceiling Black, 912 Corgie Street, 1090/21, Contributing – Siding Broadway Beach Inc, 7 First Avenue, 1016/20, Contributing – Siding, windows, deck, railings Cape May Marlin & Tuna Club Inc, 1145/8, Non-contributing – Siding, soffits, facia, window trim, doors Cawley, DENIED, 221 Grant Street, 1022/28.01, Contributing – Windows Davis, 3 S. Lafayette Street, 1021/8 C-02, Contributing – Condensers Davis, 3 S. Lafayette Street, 1021/8 C-02, Contributing – Porch ceiling, post repair Galestock, 1025 Washington Street, 1112/13, Contributing – windows GEA Family Trust, 1409 Beach Avenue, 1161/1.14, Non-contributing – Condensers GEA Family Trust, 1409 Beach Avenue, 1161/1.14, Non-contributing – Fence George & McKinney, 918 Lafayette Street, 1094/9, Contributing – Fence, gutters Gordon, DENIED, 664 Washington Avenue, 1058/5, Contributing – Patio Green, 814 Kearney Avenue, 1068/2, Contributing – Roof Harry’s Beach House LLC, 104 Howard Street, 1064/9 & 10, Contributing – Windows, doors, siding, facia, soffits Hector, 213 S Broadway, 1023/1, Contributing – Windows Jeca Too Properties LLC, 640 Hughes Street, 1066/3, Contributing – Accessory building roof, windows, siding, doors Jones, 20 Patterson Avenue, 1018/1 & 2, Non-contributing – Roof Maher, 1033 Lafayette Street, 1061/63.03 C-1, Contributing – Roof Maloy, 917 Stockton Avenue, 1082/16, Contributing – Crawl space wind barrier Marquis de Lafayette Hotel Condo, 501 Beach Avenue, 1047/1 C-106, Non- Contributing – Roof Our Lady Star of the Sea, 500-520 Lafayette Street (school), 1052/15, Non-Contributing – Replace soffit Pontin, 30 Gurney Street, 1056/4, Key Contributing – Windows Pontin, 30 Gurney Street, 1056/4, Key Contributing – Accessory building windows Powell, 312 Congress Street Unit 4, 1026/17.02, Contributing – windows Reinert, 216 Perry Street, 1031/34, Contributing – Porch deck, columns, railings, facia, soffit Rymer, 1417 Beach Avenue, 1161/1.12, Non-contributing – Generator Smokowski, 309 Franklin Street, 1073/25, Contributing – Fence Soul to Soul Estates LLC, 653 Washington Street, 1059/10, Contributing – Roof Steger, 905 Page Street, 1090/57, Contributing – Windows 1 The Mad Batter Inc, 19 Jackson Street, 1041/27, Key Contributing – Partial siding Ternove, 719-721 Franklin Street, 1050/32, Contributing – Shed 10 Jackson LLC, 12 Jackson Street, 1033/1, Contributing – Siding Worell-Taylor, 304 Franklin Street, 1070/3, Contributing - Condenser 106 Decatur Realty LLC, 106 Decatur Street, 1041/11,12,13,14,15, Contributing 220 S. Lafayette St LLC, 220 S Lafayette Street, 1029/5, Contributing – Front porch roof APPLICATIONS: Adis Inc. – 1317 Beach Avenue, Block 1146, Lots 6,7, 11-24, Non-contributing Relocate pool, pool deck, patio, paving, landscaping Formica – 1125 New York Avenue, Block 1117, Lots 22, 23, 24, Contributing Rear addition Marks – 821 Washington Street, Block 1092, Lots 20, 21 & 22, Contributing Front porch repair Hobrow Inc – 301 S. Beach Avenue, Block 1014/1, Non-contributing Fence OPEN TO PUBLIC DISCUSSION HPC Design Standards Update Grant HPC Training Session – Photo Roundtable ADJOURNMENT All applications are on file and available for inspection in City Hall 2  ZACK MULLOCK Mayor City of Cape May STACY D. SHEEHAN National Historic Landmark Deputy Mayor City Hall – 643 Washington Street LORRAINE M. BALDWIN Cape May, New Jersey 08204-2397 MICHAEL J. VOLL Councilmember (609) 884-9525 Fax: (609) 884-8589 SHAINE P. MEIER City Manager www.capemaycity.com Councilmember ERIN C. BURKE MICHAEL G. YEAGER City Clerk Councilmember City of Cape May, County of Cape May, State of New Jersey NOTIFICATION OF IN-PERSON MEETINGS & INSTRUCTIONS Please be advised that the City of Cape May Historic Preservation will be holding all scheduled meetings in person at the City of Cape May City Hall Auditorium, 643 Washington Street, Cape May, NJ, 08204, unless otherwise advised. Meetings will also be streamed live on the City’s YouTube account. To watch and listen to Historic Preservation Commission Meetings: - Prior to or after the start of the meeting, visit the City’s website, www.capemaycity.com , and click the yellow Livestream tab on the left-hand side of the screen and select the meeting you wish to observe (may have to click Videos for a full listing). You must attend the scheduled meeting in-person to make your public comment. Further notice is given that this notice is posted on the Cape May City website, www.capemaycity.com, in the Meeting Agendas tab. Judith E. Decker Secretary, Historic Preservation Commission 3