Shade Tree Commission Meeting
Regular MeetingCape May, NJ · February 14, 2023
Minutes
Shade Tree Commission Meeting
Tuesday, February 14, 2023
Chairman Schatz announced that in compliance with the Open Public Meetings Act of 1975, adequate notice of this meeting
has been provided.
Pledge of Allegiance
Roll Call: Jay Schatz Present
George Ator Present
Barbara Preminger Present
Robert Craft Present
Carole Sick Excused
James Van Pelt Present
George Werner Present
Carol York Present
Shaine Meier – Council Representative Present
Guests:
Kevin Keenan, Ron Menear
1. A motion to approve the minutes of the December 13, 2022 meeting was made by George Ator and seconded by Barbara
Preminger. The motion was approved by all present with three abstentions.
2. Deputy City Clerk, Emily swore in the three new members of the Commission: Bob, George, Jim. Jay will provide ID cards,
parking permits and magnetic car stickers. He mentioned it is good to have your credentials with you when visiting a site.
Jay indicated If there is any doubt about a tree request received from Nancy, he is always available to visit the site. He
restated the mission of the STC: protect and maintain Cape May’s street trees and plant new trees.
3. Kevin Keenan spoke to the Commission about water pooling on his front lawn, and roots of the street tree affecting the
sidewalk and the driveway. He believes the street tree roots are the cause because the roots are invading the sewer/storm
water line. Jay will ask the Water and Sewer Department to check out his concern. Jay also mentioned he might qualify for
the 50/50 sidewalk program.
4. 210 Perry Street: request to remove the street tree at this location was denied. A letter was sent to the homeowner about
the decision.
5. 1237 Washington Street – City Manager supported the Shade Tree decision to deny the removal request
6. Elmira Street: Residents are not happy with the new sub-station. All agreed it looks better than the sub-station on Railroad
in Rio Grande. ACE will put in a sidewalk and plant some bushes not trees at the location in spring. George A. cautioned
about planting too early to avoid tree roots freezing and to select plants that tolerate salt air.
7. Kiwanis Park – Caitlin Dyes contacted the STC about planting trees/bushes in Kiwanis Park to mark the 20th anniversary of
her grandfather’s passing. Shaine indicated a task force was created to direct the refurbishment of the park. Shaine will
coordinate Caitlin’s request with the work of the task force.
8. 329 Congress Street – Commissioners will check out the street trees and this location and report their findings at the next
meeting.
9. Shaine reported on the ordinance sub-committee: Wayne Hoffman from the West Cape May Shade Tree Commission has
been very helpful; construction plans should have a detailed diagram of trees on the property; onsite inspection by the
Shade Tree Commission should be required; does the HPC have the authority to approve a tree removal?
10. Jay confirmed the cost to remove a healthy tree is $75.00, no cost to remove a dead tree or a tree that poses a safety
concern.
A motion to adjourn was made by Barbara and seconded by George W. All were in favor. The meeting adjourned at 3:01PM.
Submitted by Carol York
Agenda
City of Cape May
Shade Tree Commission Agenda
February 14, 2023
_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
OPENING: In compliance with the Open Public Meeting act of 1975, adequate notice of this meeting has been provided.
PLEDGE TO THE FLAG
ROLL CALL: Jay Schatz, Barbara Preminger, George Ator, Carol York, Carole Sick
COUNCIL REPRESENTIVE: Shaine Meier
MINUTES: December 13, 2022
CORRESPONDENCE: Letter to Sherrill, Letter from Owner re: AC Electric Project, Letter from Owner re: Kiwanis Park
Dedication
GUEST:
Finance: YTD Budget 2022, YTD Budget 2023, December 2022 Budget, January 2023 Budget
Bills/Maintenance:
Miscellaneous Bills:
Sidewalk Repair:
• Troiano - $500.00
Tree Maintenance:
Tree Planting:
Tree Removal Permits:
• 1238 Washington Street – Denied (2022)
• 1333 Wisconsin Ave – Denied (2022)
• 925 Corgie Street – Approved (2022)
• 213 Grant Street – Approved (2022)
• 223 Perry Street – Denied (2022)
• 301 Queen Street – Approved (2023)
• 1224 Lafayette Street – Approved (2023)
• 1221 Vermont Ave – Approved (2023)
• 1021 New Jersey Ave – Approved (2023)
• 1000 New York Ave – Approved (2023)
• 1210 New York Ave – Approved (2023)
• 1027 Maryland Ave – Approved w/conditions (2023)
• 1035 Washington Street – Approved (2023)
Planning/Zoning Approval Request:
Street Tree Removal/Trimming Request:
• 1341 Pennsylvania Ave – Denied
• 915 Benton Ave - Denied
Old Business:
New Business:
• Welcome new member – George Werner
• Welcome new DPW member – Robert Craft
• Welcome new member – James Van Pelt
Adjourn
Get email alerts for Cape May
A daily email when new agendas and minutes are posted.