Planning and Zoning Commission

PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION REGULAR MEETING AUGUST 22, 2018 13133 E. ARAPAHOE ROAD MINUTES 1 CALL TO ORDER Chair Sims called the meeting to order at 6:03 PM. 2 ROLL CALL Those present were: Chair Sims Commissioner Beatty Commissioner Larimer Commissioner Rewerts Commissioner Roberts Commissioner Scales Commissioner Suhaka Commissioner Urtz Also present were: Jill Hassman, Assistant City Attorney Andrew Firestine, Assistant City Manager Derek Holcomb, Deputy Director of Community Development Alex Grimsman, Planner II Lisa Gajowski, Recording Secretary Those absent were: Commissioner Cohen a Alternate Selection for Voting Purposes Commissioner Roberts was appointed a voting member in the absence of Commissioner Cohen. 3 CONSENT AGENDA Commissioner Suhaka moved approval of the CONSENT AGENDA. Commissioner Beatty seconded the motion. With Commissioners Beatty, Larimer, Rewerts Roberts Suhaka, Urtz and Chair Sims voting AYE, and (None) voting NAY; the motion was approved by a vote of seven (7) AYE and none (0) NAY. a Consideration of Resolutions i 2018-PZ-R-12: Hometown Tire Pros Site Plan Ratification (LU- 18-00090) b Consideration of Other Items Minutes – Planning and Zoning Commission 8/22/2018 6:00:00 PM Page 2 c Approval of Minutes i August 8, 2018, Planning and Zoning Commission Meeting Minutes 4 LAND USE APPLICATIONS/PUBLIC HEARINGS a Village Cooperative of Centennial Site Plan Recommendation (LU-17- 00300) Alex Grimsman, Planner II, presented and responded to questions, from the Commission. The Applicant, Shane Wright of Real Estate Equities, presented and responded to questions. Chair Sims opened the public hearing. Michael Glass, 6680 S Abilene Way, asked questions. John Dubue 6483 S Abilene St. spoke in opposition. Annette Jewell, representing Valley Club Acres, 6393 S. Helena St. spoke in opposition. Reed Roberts, 6484 S. Abilene St. spoke in opposition. Tyler Burton, 6661 S Abilene Way spoke in opposition. Anne Burton, 6661 S. Abilene Way spoke in opposition. Gregory Lansky 6453 S. Potomac Ct. spoke in opposition. John Schwarzenberger, 6462 S. Potomac Ct. asked questions. There being no one else present wishing to speak Chair Sims closed the public hearing. Mr. Grimsman and Mr. Holcomb responded to questions. Mr. Wright and Ben Jenkins, Engineer, responded to questions. Commissioner Larimer moved that Case Number LU-17-00300, Village Cooperative of Centennial Site Plan, be recommended for approval based on the Planning and Zoning Commission’s finding that the Site Plan meets all applicable criteria for approval set forth in Section 12-14-602(D) of the Land Development Code, as summarized in the staff report and recommendation dated August 22, 2018. Commissioner Roberts seconded the motion. With Commissioners Larimer, Roberts and Chair Sims voting AYE and Commissioners Beatty, Rewerts, Suhaka and Urtz voting NAY; the motion FAILED by a vote of three (3) AYE and four (4) NAY. Commissioner Suhaka moved that Case Number LU-17-00300, Village Cooperative of Centennial Site Plan be recommended to City Council for denial based on the following findings of fact: Minutes – Planning and Zoning Commission 8/22/2018 6:00:00 PM Page 3 The Site Plan does not meet all of the criteria of approval set forth in Section 12-14-602(D) of the Land Development Code and Chapter 11, Section 11-1-10 of Centennial Municipal Code including but not limited to: 12-14-602(D)(2) – The proposed site plan shall be designed to minimize impacts on the reasonable development expectations or the use and enjoyment of adjacent land or the public interest, consistent with the applicable standards of this LDC. 12-14-602(D)(5) – The proposed site plan provides for compatibility between the proposed development, surrounding land uses (existing or planned), and the natural environment. 12-14-602(D)(8) – The proposed site plan provides for accessibility within the proposed development and appropriate connectivity or buffering or both between the development and existing adjacent uses. 12-14-602(D)(10) – If the site plan includes buildings that are more than 30 feet in height and the parcel proposed for development abuts existing residential development with existing views of the mountains, then the site plan shall distribute the mass of the buildings that are taller than 30 feet in a manner that allows for sight lines to the mountains from the residential development. Commissioner Rewerts seconded the motion. With Commissioners Beatty, Rewerts, Suhaka and Urtz voting AYE and Commissioner Larimer, Roberts and Chair Sims voting NAY the motion was APPROVED by a vote of four (4) AYE and three (3) NAY. b Airport Influence Area (AIA) Code Amendments Andy Firestine, Assistant City Manager, presented and responded to questions. Chair Sims opened the public hearing. Dylan Heberlein, Noise Attenuation Specialist for Centennial Airport expressed concerns. There being no one else present wishing to speak Chair Sims closed the public hearing. Commissioner Urtz moved to recommend approval of Ordinance 2018-O-05; an ordinance of the City Council of the City of Centennial, Colorado concerning the Centennial Airport Influence Area District and amending Article 16 (Definitions), Division 3-9, and Sections 12-2-201(D) and12-14- 803 of Chapter 12 of the Centennial Municipal Code (also known as the Centennial Land Development Code), and amending Chapter 18 of the Centennial Municipal Code to regulate the use of land within the Airport Influence Area Overlay District, the granting of variances to use restrictions within the Airport Influence Area, and the establishment of noise sensitive construction requirements. With Commissioners Beatty, Larimer, Rewerts, Roberts, Suhaka, Urtz, and Chair Sims voting AYE, and none voting NAY; the motion was approved by a vote of seven (7) AYE and none (0) NAY. 5 UPDATES Mr. Holcomb provided updates. Minutes – Planning and Zoning Commission 8/22/2018 6:00:00 PM Page 4 6 LONG RANGE AGENDA 7 ADJOURNMENT The meeting adjourned at 8:42 PM. Respectfully submitted, _____________________________ Lisa Gajowski, Recording Secretary