Municipal Property Corporation - Golf Course
Regular MeetingDouglas, AZ · January 21, 2020
Minutes
MINUTES
Board of Directors Meeting
Douglas Public Facility Municipal Property Corporation
Tuesday, January 21, 2020, at 5:30 p.m.
at
Douglas Golf Course
1372 Fairway Drive
Douglas, AZ 85607
1. Call to Order
Meeting was called to order by Mr. Selchow at 5:33 pm
2. Roll Call
Board Members present were: Bosco Selchow, Ruben and Manny Robles
(arrived at 5:35), Francisco “Tachi” Durazo, Kevin Alvarado. Absent members are
Nick Forsythe and David Arzate, both presumably excused. City Official(s)
present was Juan Pablo Flores, Douglas City Attorney. Robert Forrest (with his
daughter Azlin) and Rhiannon Posada employee of the MPC were also present
along with guests Bill Meeks and Linda Hortner.
3. Persons wishing to address the committee in writing or verbally on any item not on the
agenda.
(NONE)
4. Report on Balance Sheet and/or Bank Balance(s) update/report on current months for the
Douglas Public Facility Municipal Property Corporation, as well as
discussion/presentation on the MPC Golf subsidy.
November 2019 financial numbers were presented by Bosco Selchow with a current
balance of $16,500 along with some current liabilities leaving us with some working
capital that could be used for pre-emergent herbicides and fertilizer. No current
information on the subsidy is available to date. Private cart use refers to trail fees left
over from the Jeff Smythe era, and Bosco Selchow then fielded a question from Mr.
Meeks referring to the pre-emergent herbicides and fertilizer in the financial documents
shown, but the response was that they were included under the supplies for the golf
course.
1
5. Approval of Minutes for the Douglas Public Facility Municipal Property Corporation
(MPC) for board meeting held on September 17, 2019 and possibly for the October 22,
2019 (if these become available).
There was a motion by Manny Robles to approve all the noted minutes as presented and
seconded by Ruben Robles, and the item was approved unanimously.
6. Information/Discussion, Reporting and possible Decision or Direction pertaining to
aspects presented in the periodic standing report from staff regarding maintenance of the
golf course MPC facility, equipment and water delivery system.
Mr. Forrest reported we currently have no water, and repairs are running behind a week
or so, and needs to be approved by the City’s environmental specialist. The leak and
water tanking on 14 were discussed and repairs were debated like filling it in with dirt
after spraying for weeds and the actual fix was discussed in some detail. Tachi Durazo
expressed lack of confidence in the French drain asking it be backfilled, and chair
directed logistics be determined costs of moving forward with fill at a priority level. Mr.
Forrest reported the fill project will be sizeable and then advised that there are broken
boxes and timers due to the shortage of money and other priorities remain that need to be
done. Valves on 2, 7 and 8 have been repaired, with the one at 9 awaiting repairs. Four
water boxes are awaiting repairs, with 2 rain birds in the front that are a cheaper. The
water pump that initially went out has been fixed and returned but has not been made
operational yet. Seeding was discussed with reference to low sprouting and taking to
grow and explained the reasons for failure due to thin seeding and weeding up. Board got
back to prioritization pending matters with of aerating the greens, with help from Mr.
Durazo and then group tuned to talk of number 9 and discussion as when to open. Greens
were targeted for herbicide application and the need to prioritize and correlate the item to
actual costs was once again raised. The clubhouse infrastructure was reported to be
working well with the exception on Wi-Fi still being absent and it was explained that
security reasons is the why City is no longer extending this service to the MPC Golf
facility.
7. Information/Discussion and possible Decision or Direction regarding MPC
Administrative Action Plan to improve the course and overall condition of the facilities.
Board chair asked for members to come up with a list for future meeting discussions.
8. Discussion/Decision regarding facility’s rental property current condition, possible lease
terms and rate.
The facility is rented and MPC Board is awaiting a sample lease from the legal
department, with a suggestion made to loan tenant a golf cart or gator for his local non-
golf use.
9. Information/Discussion and possible Decision or Direction regarding fees of RV Park
and report from City staff on status of talks with City regarding possible access to private
RV Park through golf course property, as well as any report form City Staff.
2
Mr. Flores reported that City had been talking with Jim Schumacher and that out of the 3
options discussed none of the option were decided to be viable to the City. Access is
being considered as to the west side of the Foreman property and that this consideration
is still very preliminary and then Flores explained the land-lock component options under
a litigation scenario. The RV Park seems to have temporary permission to be accessing
through the HOA, Mr. Flores reported in conclusion. Tachi Durazo explained his
perspective on how Jim Schumacher was a bit unreasonable in that he never would
consider an indemnification clause in benefit of the City for through golf course access.
10. Information/Update with a possible Discussion/Decision on current events, updates or
concerns at the golf course since the November, 2019 meeting.
A wedding was held last Saturday, Bob’s party on Saturday with tournaments and the
Fire Department Union rented the facility upcoming rental. The road shooting incident
was briefly discussed with apprehensions taking place. An incident reported by Ruben
Robles from last Sunday of wall contractors abusing the golf course with various golfers
confronting the offenders. Board had a general pros and cons discussion regarding
possible female inmates from ADOC and that group needed to clarify this concept. Some
auditor topics were discussed and the need for Rhiannon to go back to almost 1 year to
accumulate daily activity, as part of the audit new protocols. Some early 2020
tournaments were discussed.
11. Discussion and direction/consensus for items to be discussed at future meetings.
Board wants to keep the agenda items on WIFI update herein numbered as 4,6, 7 on the
action plan and 10 to include ADOC female employee updates for the next meeting.
12. Adjournment
A motion was made by Ruben Robles and seconded by Tachi Durazo to adjourn the
meeting at 6:28 pm, and the motion was approved unanimously.
Prepared by Juan Pablo Flores, Douglas City Attorney
3
Agenda
PUBLIC NOTICE
BOARD OF DIRECTORS MEETING
FOR THE
DOUGLAS PUBLIC FACILITY MUNICIPAL PROPERTY CORPORATION
will meet
Tuesday, January 21, 2020, at 5:30 p.m.
at
Douglas Golf Course
1372 E. Fairway Drive
Douglas, AZ
PURSUANT TO THE AMERICANS WITH DISABILITIES ACT (ADA), THE CITY OF
DOUGLAS DOES NOT, BY REASON OF A DISABILITY, EXCLUDE FROM
PARTICIPATION IN OR DENY BENEFITS OF SERVICES, PROGRAMS OR ACTIVITIES
OR DISCRIMINATE AGAINST ANY QUALIFIED PERSON WITH A DISABILITY.
INQUIRIES REGARDING COMPLIANCE WITH ADA PROVISIONS, ACCESSIBILITY OR
ACCOMMODATION CAN BE DIRECTED TO RENE MOLINA WITHIN 72 HOURS AT
520.417.7312, FAX 520.417.7143, 425 10TH STREET, DOUGLAS, ARIZONA 85607.
1
AGENDA
Board of Directors Meeting
Douglas Public Facility Municipal Property Corporation
Tuesday, January 21, 2020, at 5:30 p.m.
at
Douglas Golf Course
1372 Fairway Drive
Douglas, AZ 85607
1. Call to Order
2. Roll Call
3. Persons wishing to address the committee in writing or verbally on any item not on the
agenda.
4. Report on Balance Sheet and/or Bank Balance(s) update/report on current months for the
Douglas Public Facility Municipal Property Corporation, as well as discussion/presentation
on the MPC Golf subsidy.
5. Approval of Minutes for the Douglas Public Facility Municipal Property Corporation
(MPC) for board meeting held on September 17, 2019 and possibly for the October 22,
2019 (if these become available).
6. Information/Discussion, Reporting and possible Decision or Direction pertaining to aspects
presented in the periodic standing report from staff regarding maintenance of the golf
course MPC facility, equipment and water delivery system.
7. Information/Discussion and possible Decision or Direction regarding MPC Administrative
Action Plan to improve the course and overall condition of the facilities.
8. Discussion/Decision regarding facility’s rental property current condition, possible lease
terms and rate.
9. Information/Discussion and possible Decision or Direction regarding fees of RV Park and
report from City staff on status of talks with City regarding possible access to private RV
Park through golf course property, as well as any report form City Staff.
10. Information/Update with a possible Discussion/Decision on current events, updates or
concerns at the golf course since the November, 2019 meeting.
11. Discussion and direction/consensus for items to be discussed at future meetings.
12. Adjournment
Posted January 17, 2020, at 4:45 p.m. by: Alma Andrade, Acting City Clerk
2
MEETING MINUTES
Douglas Public Facility Municipal Property Corporation
Board of Directors Meeting
Tuesday, September 17, 2019, at 5:30 p.m.
at
Douglas Golf Course
1372 Fairway Drive
Douglas, AZ 85607
1. Call to Order
Meeting was called to order by Mr. Selchow at 5:31 pm
2. Roll Call
Board Members present were: Bosco Selchow, Ruben and Manny Robles (arrived at 5:35),
Francisco “Tachi” Durazo, Kevin Alvarado and new Board Member, Nick Forsythe. Absent and
excused was David Arzate. City Official(s) present was Luis Pedroza, City of Douglas Finance
Director. Robert Forrest, employee of the MPC was also present along with Board guest, Richard
Robles attending.
3. Persons wishing to address the committee in writing or verbally on any item not on the agenda.
Richard Robles commented on condition of the green on 18, that has improved in condition. Mr.
Robles would also like a better assortment of liquor at the bar, as he has noticed Tequila is largely
absent. It was reported that liquor comes in once a month from Phoenix and that the matter would
be looked into administratively.
4. Report on Balance Sheet and/or Bank Balance(s) update/report on current months for the Douglas
Public Facility Municipal Property Corporation.
The current bank balance is $15,000 with anticipated $7K tax bill electronic payment coming in
that will reduce that balance. The MPC Golf Chair reported entity is mostly current on bills and
that a bill from the Jeff Smythe period came in from NutrienAg Solutions, and it seems to be paid
in full.
5. Approval of Minutes for the Douglas Public Facility Municipal Property Corporation (MPC) for
board meeting held on August 20, 2019.
Motion was made by Francisco “Tachi” Durazo and seconded by Kevin Alvarado and the noted
minutes were approved as presented unanimously.
6. Information/Discussion, Reporting and possible Decision or direction pertaining to aspects
presented in the periodic standing report from staff regarding maintenance of the golf course MPC
facility, equipment and water delivery system.
The group discussed a report of foul smell and possible garbage on 17, and it was suspected the
water level got low, there was an algae spike thereby lowering the oxygen content and causing fish
to expire as many large fish were dead and floating.
1
Mr. Selchow noted that the area will be cleaned and fish will be disposed of properly; next the topic
of the pond water being low and the pump on the back 9 has been picking up silt was discussed.
The pond may need to be dredged and the pumps may need maintenance and/or refurbishing. It
was noted that the electrical issue on the pump has been fixed, but not running optimally. It is being
operated manually as the control panel electronic board has been non-functional. The dredging was
pointed out as a priority by Mr. Durazo and Bosco noted that he has been told by City water
technicians that a direct feed to the pump from City water infrastructure would not be legally
compliant per ADEQ (cannot go from potable to non-potable water systems). Per Mr. Forrest, a
good quantity of fertilizer and rye grass has been ordered for the course and electric valves have
slowly been replaced with manual valves due to costs of valves themselves. Green on 6 seems to
be coming around due to seeding and bathrooms have been painted and look much better with all
mowers running at this point. The water on 14 seems to continue to be collecting and by number 8
the water collecting is due to a needed valve replacement. The green on number 6 and 9 will be
needing water and seed; and seems to have a volume of water issue at that point. Hand watering is
not an option per Mr. Forrest, but per Bosco changing sprinkler heads to smaller units requiring
less pressure to get better distribution may be a decent option. Bunkers seem to harden rather
quickly and may need to be allowed to go fully grass bunkers like at Fort Huachuca. It was noted
that Bosco, Ken Herbert and Nick Forsythe were recognized for their work in making the bunkers
playable. Computer issues have been prevalent at the facility and have been spotty for 3-4 weeks
with a system issue problem over the weekend reported by Luis Pedroza. IT staff has been spending
significant time at the facility and computer equipment has been replaced; along with AC
equipment upgrade/replacement.
7. Swearing in of new Board Member, Nick Forsythe.
Motion was made by Ruben Robles and seconded by Francisco “Tachi” Durazo to accept Nick
Forsythe as a new Board member. and seconded by Kevin Alvarado and the noted appointment
was approved as presented unanimously. This item was handled by Luis Pedroza with
documentation being signed and provided to the City legal department.
8. Information/Update with a possible Discussion/Decision on current events, updates or concerns at
the golf course since the August, 2019 meeting.
Current events to report include the Douglas Golf and Social Club having their major function on
September 28-29 with the Cochise College Rodeo team having a meet and greet on September 27,
a Friday with no fee being charged as long as the clean-p was adequate. On October 5th there will
be a DHS baseball team fundraiser tournament and a wedding reception as well, with October 6
being Scotty Babikey’s youth activities fund raiser tournament and on the 11th and 12th of October
the clubhouse facility will host a class reunion. The Labor Day Tournament went very well with
56 teams reportedly participating with the ice machine being the only component that did not
cooperate. The MPC facility is up to six (6) ADOC inmates as part of the labor crew, up from 5
although Bosco had only requested a 4-man crew, so this will have to be looked at per Mr. Selchow,
who also reported an employee had to be released. ADOC also wants to use the facility for periodic
training starting October 2019, and this has been approved administratively at no charge for now,
and closed with general conditions being discussed by the group. General security issues were
discussed by the Board.
9. Discussion/Decision with possible direction regarding the MPC Golf facility’s rental property
readiness condition, and possible lease/rental terms and rate.
Rental property is pending a walk through with minor finish work required and may need new
appliances.
2
10. Discussion/Decision with possible direction regarding upgrade/remodel of the bathroom/laundry
RV Park facilities, as well as other potential amenities at MPC Golf facility.
The electrical upgrades to the RV Park estimates were received in the amount of $42,000 and this
would included pedestals at 50A that could service either side of parking area, and this was
discussed briefly. Board discussed approaching the IDA for funding on this and possibly irrigation
upgrade funding as well, and Tachi Durazo suggested to do a package approach with various bids
to the IDA and Mr. Pedroza agreed, and consensus was to use a licensed/bonded contractor. As for
the irrigation, Mr. Durazo noted the IDA may prefer a local contractor to do upgrades to promote
local employment. A defined scope of work and the schematics are important to program for the
irrigation system repairs/upgrade, and these may be possibly available from the City.
11. Discussion/Decision with possible direction regarding all aspects for the prospective formulation
and presentation of an MPC Golf proposal for funding from the City of Douglas IDA.
Most of this agenda item was discussed under 10 herein above.
12. Information/Discussion, with possible Discussion/Decision or direction Reporting/Feedback
regarding any aspect of the easement (liability and financial aspects included) on the unimproved
path between the private (previously known as Hidden Treasures) RV Park and the Golf Course
parking lot.
Mr. Selchow reported that the HOA complains about private RV Park patrons driving through the
housing development and that the owner of the private RV Park, Mr. Schumacher has asked for
permission for Golf Course to grant an easement to the private RV Park patrons to pass through the
Golf Course. The private outfit charges $100 less per month than the Golf Course RV Park, but has
less amenities that the MPC facility. Board consensus was to remain status quo and not provide
access, and deny access even during the county fair event. Mr. Durazo noted that at the August
2019 meeting Mr. Flores noted this was an opportunity for building revenue, but Tachi Durazo
noted that in Schumacher will not provide indemnity or lower his prices so as to not undercut the
MPC, then MPC should hold firm to insulate itself from liability and continue to deny access. A
motion was made to continue to deny access, as made by Manny Robles and seconded by Ruben
Robles, and the motion was approved unanimously.
13. Discussion and direction/consensus for items to be discussed at future meetings.
None were raised.
14. Adjournment:
A motion was made to continue to deny access, as made by Tachi Durazo and seconded by Kevin
Alvarado to adjourn at 6:32 pm, and the motion was approved unanimously.
Prepared by Juan Pablo Flores, City Attorney
3
Get email alerts for Douglas
A daily email when new agendas and minutes are posted.