City Council
Regular MeetingDuluth, MN · April 27, 2020
Minutes
411 West First Street
City of Duluth Duluth, Minnesota 55802
Minutes - Final
City Council
MISSION STATEMENT: The mission of the Duluth City Council
is to develop effective public policy rooted in citizen
involvement that results in excellent municipal services and
creates a thriving community prepared for the challenges of the
future.
TOOLS OF CIVILITY: The Duluth City Council promotes the use
and adherence of the tools of civility in conducting the business
of the council. The tools of civility provide increased
opportunities for civil discourse leading to positive resolutions
for the issues that face our city. We know that when we have
civility, we get civic engagement, and because we can’t make
each other civil and we can only work on ourselves, we state
that today I will: pay attention, listen, be inclusive, not gossip,
show respect, seek common ground, repair damaged
relationships, use constructive language, and take
responsibility. [Approved by the council on May 14, 2018]
Monday, April 27, 2020 7:00 PM Council Chamber
NOTICE: The Duluth City Council will be holding its April 23, 2020 Agenda Session and April 27, 2020 City Council
Meeting by other electronic means pursuant to Minnesota Statutes Section 13D.021 in response to the COVID-19
emergency. Some members of the City Council will be participating through video conference. Due to the
COVID-19 emergency and the closure of City facilities, public comment will not be taken in person. However,
members of the public can monitor the meeting and provide public comment on agenda items through WebEx
Events. Visit https://duluthmn.gov/live-meeting to access the meeting. The public is also encouraged to submit
written comment to council@duluthmn.gov prior to the meeting. Please include “Council Agenda” in the subject
line, and include your name and address and the agenda item you are speaking to. Please note that all public
comment is considered Public Data. The public is also encouraged to watch both meetings online at
https://duluthmn.gov/city-council/ (Select "Council Meeting Media") or by tuning into Public Access Television,
Channel 180.
ROLL CALL
Present: 8- Councilor Zack Filipovich, Councilor Arik Forsman, Councilor Janet Kennedy,
Councilor Derek Medved, Councilor Roz Randorf, Councilor Joel Sipress, Vice
President Renee Van Nett and President Gary Anderson
PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
APPROVAL OF MINUTES
1. 20-032 Meeting Minutes of the Duluth City Council
Indexes:
Attachments: April 13, 2020 - Council Meeting
City of Duluth Page 1
City Council Minutes - Final April 27, 2020
These Minutes were approved.
REPORTS FROM THE ADMINISTRATION
20-033 COVID - 19 Budget Implications Presentation
Indexes:
Attachments: COVID-19 Budget Implications FINAL
REPORTS FROM OTHER OFFICERS
REPORTS OF COUNCIL COMMITTEES
REPORTS OF COUNCIL OPEN ISSUES
OPPORTUNITY FOR CITIZENS TO BE HEARD
Carmen Sharp spoke in regard to library technician layoffs. Shawn Weintz
spoke in regard to supporting small businesses. Kevin Malmquist spoke in
regard to budget decisions. John Hill spoke in regards to the budget and
lay-offs.
20-034 Citizen Written Comment
Indexes:
Attachments: 2020-04-27, Citizen Written Comments
CONSENT AGENDA
BY COUNCILOR KENNEDY (PERSONNEL)
2. 20-0342R RESOLUTION CONFIRMING THE APPOINTMENT OF MEREDITH
ANDERSON AND BRANDON HARTUNG TO THE HERITAGE
PRESERVATION COMMISSION.
This Resolution was adopted unanimously.
3. 20-0344R RESOLUTION CONFIRMING THE APPOINTMENT OF BRIAN
FREDRICKSON TO THE NATURAL RESOURCES COMMISSION.
This Resolution was adopted unanimously.
(PLANNING & ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT)
City of Duluth Page 2
City Council Minutes - Final April 27, 2020
4. 20-0329R RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING AN AGREEMENT WITH CIRRUS DESIGN
CORPORATION FOR TEMPORARY CLOSURE OF AIRPORT
APPROACH ROAD.
Indexes:
Attachments: Exhibit A_Agreement
This Resolution was adopted unanimously.
5. 20-0353R RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THAT PROPER CITY OFFICIALS
DISCHARGE $69,000 IN COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT BLOCK GRANT
LOAN DEBT OWED BY CENTER CITY WINDWOOD PARTNERS, LP.
This Resolution was adopted unanimously.
6. 20-0369R RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THAT PROPER CITY OFFICIALS
DISCHARGE $53,364 IN HOME PROGRAM LOAN DEBT OWED BY
CENTER CITY WINDWOOD PARTNERS, LP.
This Resolution was adopted unanimously.
7. 20-0375R RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING A FIRST AMENDMENT TO LAKE
AVENUE PLAZA DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT WITH MINNESOTA
POWER FOR THE OPERATION AND MAINTENANCE OF THE EAST
AND WEST PLAZAS IN DOWNTOWN DULUTH.
Indexes:
Attachments: Exhibit 1-First Amendment
This Resolution was adopted.
Councilor Forsman abstains stating employer conflict.
8. 20-0380R RESOLUTION REPLACING RESOLUTION NO. 19-0423 VACATING ALL
OF THE SKYWALK EASEMENTS AFFECTING MINNESOTA POWER’S
BUILDING LOCATED AT 30 WEST SUPERIOR STREET IN
DOWNTOWN DULUTH.
Indexes:
Attachments: Exhibit 1-Skywalk Resolution
Exhibit 2-Skywalk vacation resolution final
Exhibit 3-Aerial Map
Exhibit 4-Skywalk Vacation Resolution
This Resolution was adopted.
Councilor Forsman abstains stating employer conflict.
City of Duluth Page 3
City Council Minutes - Final April 27, 2020
9. 20-0391R RESOLUTION APPROVING DEDA RESOLUTION 20D-41 AUTHORIZING
AN AGREEMENT WITH THE NORTHEAST ENTREPRENEUR FUND,
INC.TO IMPLEMENT THE DULUTH SMALL BUSINESS EMERGENCY
FUND IN THE AMOUNT OF $443,000.
Indexes:
Attachments: Exhibit A
This Resolution was adopted unanimously.
10. 20-0392R RESOLUTION APPROVING DEDA RESOLUTION 20D-42 AUTHORIZING
A GRANT AGREEMENT WITH THE NORTHEAST ENTREPRENEUR
FUND, INC. TO IMPLEMENT A COVID-19 EMERGENCY LOAN
PROGRAM IN THE AMOUNT OF $125,000.
Indexes:
Attachments: Exhibit A
This Resolution was adopted unanimously.
BY COUNCILOR SIPRESS (PUBLIC WORKS & UTILITIES)
11. 20-0294R RESOLUTION AWARDING A CONTRACT TO NORTHLAND
CONSTRUCTORS OF DULUTH, INC. FOR THE SECOND STREET
RECONSTRUCTION PROJECT IN THE AMOUNT OF $7,888,777.
Indexes:
Attachments: 20-0294R Map
This Resolution was adopted unanimously.
12. 20-0295R RESOLUTION AWARDING A CONTRACT TO ULLAND BROTHERS,
INC. FOR THE 2020 STREET PRESERVATION PROJECT IN THE
AMOUNT OF $2,787,576.76.
Indexes:
Attachments: 20-0295R Maps
This Resolution was adopted unanimously.
13. 20-0327R RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING SUBSTITUTION OF REVISED SCHEDULE
“I” TO MNDOT AGREEMENT NO. 1036093 FOR STATE PROJECT
6982-331, INCREASING THE CITY’S SHARE OF COSTS IN THE
AMOUNT OF $37,577.38 FOR A NEW TOTAL OF $141,037.70.
Indexes:
City of Duluth Page 4
City Council Minutes - Final April 27, 2020
Attachments: 20-0327R Map
20-0327R Exhibit A
This Resolution was adopted unanimously.
14. 20-0338R RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE SOLE SOURCE PURCHASE OF
ACTUATORS FROM VESSCO, INC. IN THE AMOUNT OF $68,049.40
This Resolution was adopted unanimously.
15. 20-0339R RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING AN AGREEMENT WITH NORDEX USA,
INC. RELATING TO MODIFICATIONS TO THE INTERSECTION OF
GARFIELD AVENUE AND WEST SUPERIOR STREET.
Indexes:
Attachments: 20-0339R Exhibit A
This Resolution was adopted unanimously.
16. 20-0351R RESOLUTION AMENDING CONTRACT L30164 WITH MSA
PROFESSIONAL SERVICES, INC., TO PROVIDE CONSTRUCTION
SURVEYING, CONSTRUCTION ADMINISTRATION AND INSPECTION
FOR THE LIFT STATION 15 RELOCATION PROJECT, TO INCREASE
THE AMOUNT BY $404,185 FOR A NEW TOTAL OF $570,992.
Indexes:
Attachments: 19-0351R Attachment 1
20-0351R Map
This Resolution was adopted unanimously.
17. 20-0377R RESOLUTION ACCEPTING A PERPETUAL EASEMENT FOR STREET
PURPOSES FROM MINNESOTA POWER A DIVISION OF ALLETE, INC.,
OVER, UNDER, AND ACROSS PROPERTY LOCATED IN DOWNTOWN
DULUTH, AT NO COST TO THE CITY.
Indexes:
Attachments: Exhbit 1-Street Easement
Exhibit 2-Street Easement
This Resolution was adopted.
Councilor Forsman abstains stating employer conflict.
18. 20-0378R RESOLUTION ACCEPTING A NON-EXCLUSIVE UTILITY EASEMENT
FOR STEAM AND HOT WATER PURPOSES FROM MINNESOTA
POWER, A DIVISION OF ALLETE, INC., ACROSS PROPERTY
LOCATED IN DOWNTOWN DULUTH, AT NO COST TO THE CITY.
City of Duluth Page 5
City Council Minutes - Final April 27, 2020
Indexes:
Attachments: Steam Easement-Exhibit 1
Steam Easement-Exhibit 2
This Resolution was adopted.
Councilor Forsman abstains stating employer conflict.
19. 20-0379R RESOLUTION ACCEPTING A NON-EXCLUSIVE UTILITY EASEMENT
FOR STORMWATER PURPOSES FROM MINNESOTA POWER, A
DIVISION OF ALLETE, INC., ACROSS PROPERTY LOCATED IN
DOWNTOWN DULUTH, AT NO COST TO THE CITY.
Indexes:
Attachments: Exhibit 1-Storm Easement
Storm Easement-Exhibit 2
This Resolution was adopted.
Councilor Forsman abstains stating employer conflict.
BY COUNCILOR VAN NETT (PUBLIC SAFETY)
20. 20-0345R RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE EXECUTION OF AN AGREEMENT
WITH LEXISNEXIS RISK SOLUTIONS FOR AN ONLINE SUBSCRIPTION
TO THE ACCURINT VIRTUAL CRIME CENTER FOR AN INITIAL TERM
OF THREE YEARS AT AN ANNUAL COST OF $17,800 TOGETHER
WITH AN ANNUAL INCREASE OF 2 PERCENT PER YEAR.
Indexes:
Attachments: Document A
This Resolution was adopted unanimously.
BY COUNCILOR FORSMAN (RECREATION, LIBRARIES & AUTHORITIES)
22. 20-0370R RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING AN AMENDMENT TO AGREEMENT
L30228 WITH KRAUS ANDERSON CONSTRUCTION COMPANY FOR
CONSTRUCTION MANAGER SERVICES FOR THE ZOO BEAR
COUNTRY EXHIBIT RENOVATION FOR AN AMOUNT NOT TO EXCEED
$85,800.
Indexes:
Attachments: Exhibit A
This Resolution was adopted unanimously.
23. 20-0372R RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING A FIRST AMENDMENT TO LEASE
AGREEMENT WITH THE HILLS YOUTH AND FAMILY SERVICES, FOR
USE OF SPACE IN THE WASHINGTON RECREATION CENTER.
City of Duluth Page 6
City Council Minutes - Final April 27, 2020
Indexes:
Attachments: Exhibit 1.pdf
This Resolution was adopted unanimously.
24. 20-0376R RESOLUTION REPLACING RESOLUTION NO. 19-0424, VACATING
PUBLIC PLAZA AREAS CREATED UNDER CERTAIN AGREEMENTS,
AND ACCEPTING THE DEDICATION OF NEW PLAZA EASEMENTS.
Indexes:
Attachments: Exhibit 1-Plaza vacation resolution
Exhibit 2-East Plaza
Exhibit 3-West Plaza
Exhibit 4-Plaza Resolution
Exhibit 5-Plaza Vacation Resolution
This Resolution was adopted.
Councilor Forsman abstains stating employer conflict.
END OF CONSENT AGENDA
BY COUNCILOR FORSMAN (RECREATION, LIBRARIES & AUTHORITIES)
21. 20-0346R RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING A CONTRACT WITH A PLUS
CONTRACTORS FOR SITE IMPROVEMENTS AT MERRITT PARK FOR
AN AMOUNT NOT TO EXCEED $189,669.
This Resolution was adopted unanimously.
COUNCILOR QUESTIONS AND COMMENTS
COUNCILOR PREVIEW OF UPCOMING BUSINESS
City of Duluth Page 7
Agenda
411 West First Street
City of Duluth Duluth, Minnesota 55802
Meeting Agenda - Final
City Council
MISSION STATEMENT: The mission of the Duluth City Council is
to develop effective public policy rooted in citizen involvement
that results in excellent municipal services and creates a thriving
community prepared for the challenges of the future.
TOOLS OF CIVILITY: The Duluth City Council promotes the use
and adherence of the tools of civility in conducting the business
of the council. The tools of civility provide increased
opportunities for civil discourse leading to positive resolutions
for the issues that face our city. We know that when we have
civility, we get civic engagement, and because we can’t make
each other civil and we can only work on ourselves, we state that
today I will: pay attention, listen, be inclusive, not gossip, show
respect, seek common ground, repair damaged relationships,
use constructive language, and take responsibility. [Approved by
the council on May 14, 2018]
Monday, April 27, 2020 7:00 PM Council Chamber
NOTICE: The Duluth City Council will be holding its April 23, 2020 Agenda Session and April 27, 2020 City Council
Meeting by other electronic means pursuant to Minnesota Statutes Section 13D.021 in response to the COVID-19
emergency. Some members of the City Council will be participating through video conference. Due to the
COVID-19 emergency and the closure of City facilities, public comment will not be taken in person. However,
members of the public can monitor the meeting and provide public comment on agenda items through WebEx
Events. Visit https://duluthmn.gov/live-meeting to access the meeting. The public is also encouraged to submit
written comment to council@duluthmn.gov prior to the meeting. Please include “Council Agenda” in the subject
line, and include your name and address and the agenda item you are speaking to. Please note that all public
comment is considered Public Data. The public is also encouraged to watch both meetings online at
https://duluthmn.gov/city-council/ (Select "Council Meeting Media") or by tuning into Public Access Television,
Channel 180.
ROLL CALL
PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
APPROVAL OF MINUTES
1. 20-032 Meeting Minutes of the Duluth City Council
Attachments: April 13, 2020 - Council Meeting
REPORTS FROM THE ADMINISTRATION
REPORTS FROM OTHER OFFICERS
City of Duluth Page 1 Printed on 4/21/2020
City Council Meeting Agenda - Final April 27, 2020
REPORTS OF COUNCIL COMMITTEES
REPORTS OF COUNCIL OPEN ISSUES
OPPORTUNITY FOR CITIZENS TO BE HEARD
CONSENT AGENDA
BY COUNCILOR KENNEDY (PERSONNEL)
2. 20-0342R RESOLUTION CONFIRMING THE APPOINTMENT OF MEREDITH
ANDERSON AND BRANDON HARTUNG TO THE HERITAGE
PRESERVATION COMMISSION.
3. 20-0344R RESOLUTION CONFIRMING THE APPOINTMENT OF BRIAN
FREDRICKSON TO THE NATURAL RESOURCES COMMISSION.
BY COUNCILOR RUSS (PLANNING & ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT)
4. 20-0329R RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING AN AGREEMENT WITH CIRRUS DESIGN
CORPORATION FOR TEMPORARY CLOSURE OF AIRPORT
APPROACH ROAD.
Attachments: Exhibit A_Agreement
5. 20-0353R RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THAT PROPER CITY OFFICIALS
DISCHARGE $69,000 IN COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT BLOCK GRANT
LOAN DEBT OWED BY CENTER CITY WINDWOOD PARTNERS, LP.
6. 20-0369R RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THAT PROPER CITY OFFICIALS
DISCHARGE $53,364 IN HOME PROGRAM LOAN DEBT OWED BY
CENTER CITY WINDWOOD PARTNERS, LP.
7. 20-0375R RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING A FIRST AMENDMENT TO LAKE
AVENUE PLAZA DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT WITH MINNESOTA
POWER FOR THE OPERATION AND MAINTENANCE OF THE EAST
AND WEST PLAZAS IN DOWNTOWN DULUTH.
Attachments: Exhibit 1-First Amendment
City of Duluth Page 2 Printed on 4/21/2020
City Council Meeting Agenda - Final April 27, 2020
8. 20-0380R RESOLUTION REPLACING RESOLUTION NO. 19-0423 VACATING ALL
OF THE SKYWALK EASEMENTS AFFECTING MINNESOTA POWER’S
BUILDING LOCATED AT 30 WEST SUPERIOR STREET IN
DOWNTOWN DULUTH.
Attachments: Exhibit 1-Skywalk Resolution
Exhibit 2-Skywalk vacation resolution final
Exhibit 3-Aerial Map
Exhibit 4-Skywalk Vacation Resolution
9. 20-0391R RESOLUTION APPROVING DEDA RESOLUTION 20D-41 AUTHORIZING
AN AGREEMENT WITH THE NORTHEAST ENTREPRENEUR FUND,
INC.TO IMPLEMENT THE DULUTH SMALL BUSINESS EMERGENCY
FUND IN THE AMOUNT OF $443,000.
Attachments: Exhibit A
10. 20-0392R RESOLUTION APPROVING DEDA RESOLUTION 20D-42 AUTHORIZING
A GRANT AGREEMENT WITH THE NORTHEAST ENTREPRENEUR
FUND, INC. TO IMPLEMENT A COVID-19 EMERGENCY LOAN
PROGRAM IN THE AMOUNT OF $125,000.
Attachments: Exhibit A
BY COUNCILOR SIPRESS (PUBLIC WORKS & UTILITIES)
11. 20-0294R RESOLUTION AWARDING A CONTRACT TO NORTHLAND
CONSTRUCTORS OF DULUTH, INC. FOR THE SECOND STREET
RECONSTRUCTION PROJECT IN THE AMOUNT OF $7,888,777.
Attachments: 20-0294R Map
12. 20-0295R RESOLUTION AWARDING A CONTRACT TO ULLAND BROTHERS,
INC. FOR THE 2020 STREET PRESERVATION PROJECT IN THE
AMOUNT OF $2,787,576.76.
Attachments: 20-0295R Maps
13. 20-0327R RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING SUBSTITUTION OF REVISED SCHEDULE
“I” TO MNDOT AGREEMENT NO. 1036093 FOR STATE PROJECT
6982-331, INCREASING THE CITY’S SHARE OF COSTS IN THE
AMOUNT OF $37,577.38 FOR A NEW TOTAL OF $141,037.70.
Attachments: 20-0327R Map
20-0327R Exhibit A
14. 20-0338R RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE SOLE SOURCE PURCHASE OF
ACTUATORS FROM VESSCO, INC. IN THE AMOUNT OF $68,049.40
City of Duluth Page 3 Printed on 4/21/2020
City Council Meeting Agenda - Final April 27, 2020
15. 20-0339R RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING AN AGREEMENT WITH NORDEX USA,
INC. RELATING TO MODIFICATIONS TO THE INTERSECTION OF
GARFIELD AVENUE AND WEST SUPERIOR STREET.
Attachments: 20-0339R Exhibit A
16. 20-0351R RESOLUTION AMENDING CONTRACT L30164 WITH MSA
PROFESSIONAL SERVICES, INC., TO PROVIDE CONSTRUCTION
SURVEYING, CONSTRUCTION ADMINISTRATION AND INSPECTION
FOR THE LIFT STATION 15 RELOCATION PROJECT, TO INCREASE
THE AMOUNT BY $404,185 FOR A NEW TOTAL OF $570,992.
Attachments: 19-0351R Attachment 1
20-0351R Map
17. 20-0377R RESOLUTION ACCEPTING A PERPETUAL EASEMENT FOR STREET
PURPOSES FROM MINNESOTA POWER A DIVISION OF ALLETE,
INC., OVER, UNDER, AND ACROSS PROPERTY LOCATED IN
DOWNTOWN DULUTH, AT NO COST TO THE CITY.
Attachments: Exhbit 1-Street Easement
Exhibit 2-Street Easement
18. 20-0378R RESOLUTION ACCEPTING A NON-EXCLUSIVE UTILITY EASEMENT
FOR STEAM AND HOT WATER PURPOSES FROM MINNESOTA
POWER, A DIVISION OF ALLETE, INC., ACROSS PROPERTY
LOCATED IN DOWNTOWN DULUTH, AT NO COST TO THE CITY.
Attachments: Steam Easement-Exhibit 1
Steam Easement-Exhibit 2
19. 20-0379R RESOLUTION ACCEPTING A NON-EXCLUSIVE UTILITY EASEMENT
FOR STORMWATER PURPOSES FROM MINNESOTA POWER, A
DIVISION OF ALLETE, INC., ACROSS PROPERTY LOCATED IN
DOWNTOWN DULUTH, AT NO COST TO THE CITY.
Attachments: Exhibit 1-Storm Easement
Storm Easement-Exhibit 2
BY COUNCILOR VAN NETT (PUBLIC SAFETY)
20. 20-0345R RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE EXECUTION OF AN AGREEMENT
WITH LEXISNEXIS RISK SOLUTIONS FOR AN ONLINE SUBSCRIPTION
TO THE ACCURINT VIRTUAL CRIME CENTER FOR AN INITIAL TERM
OF THREE YEARS AT AN ANNUAL COST OF $17,800 TOGETHER
WITH AN ANNUAL INCREASE OF 2 PERCENT PER YEAR.
Attachments: Document A
City of Duluth Page 4 Printed on 4/21/2020
City Council Meeting Agenda - Final April 27, 2020
BY COUNCILOR FORSMAN (RECREATION, LIBRARIES & AUTHORITIES)
21. 20-0346R RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING A CONTRACT WITH A PLUS
CONTRACTORS FOR SITE IMPROVEMENTS AT MERRITT PARK FOR
AN AMOUNT NOT TO EXCEED $189,669.
22. 20-0370R RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING AN AMENDMENT TO AGREEMENT
L30228 WITH KRAUS ANDERSON CONSTRUCTION COMPANY FOR
CONSTRUCTION MANAGER SERVICES FOR THE ZOO BEAR
COUNTRY EXHIBIT RENOVATION FOR AN AMOUNT NOT TO EXCEED
$85,800.
Attachments: Exhibit A
23. 20-0372R RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING A FIRST AMENDMENT TO LEASE
AGREEMENT WITH THE HILLS YOUTH AND FAMILY SERVICES, FOR
USE OF SPACE IN THE WASHINGTON RECREATION CENTER.
Attachments: Exhibit 1.pdf
24. 20-0376R RESOLUTION REPLACING RESOLUTION NO. 19-0424, VACATING
PUBLIC PLAZA AREAS CREATED UNDER CERTAIN AGREEMENTS,
AND ACCEPTING THE DEDICATION OF NEW PLAZA EASEMENTS.
Attachments: Exhibit 1-Plaza vacation resolution
Exhibit 2-East Plaza
Exhibit 3-West Plaza
Exhibit 4-Plaza Resolution
Exhibit 5-Plaza Vacation Resolution
END OF CONSENT AGENDA
COUNCILOR QUESTIONS AND COMMENTS
COUNCILOR PREVIEW OF UPCOMING BUSINESS
City of Duluth Page 5 Printed on 4/21/2020
Get email alerts for Duluth
A daily email when new agendas and minutes are posted.