Historic Review Board

AGENDA TOWN OF FORT MILL HISTORIC REVIEW BOARD July 31, 2018 112 Confederate Street 4:30 PM AGENDA CALL TO ORDER OLD BUSINESS 1. Request for Certificate of Appropriateness [Pages 2-6] Applicant Name: Amor Artis Brewing Owner Name: Main Street – Fort Mill LLC Property Address: 204-101 Main Street Purpose: Request to review and approve an extension of the previously approved screening at the rear of the property Zoning: LC / Historic INFORMATION / DISCUSSION 1. Discussion of Potential Standardized Color Palette [Pages 7-36] ADJOURN The following press was notified of the meeting by email or fax in accordance of the Freedom of Information Act: The Herald; CN2; WRHI; Fort Mill Times and WBTV. The agenda was also posted at the entrance to Town Hall the required length of time and on the Town website. The Town of Fort Mill is committed to assuring accessibility with reasonable accommodation, of Town services and facilities for all individuals, in compliance with federal law. Please contact the Town Manager’s Office at 803-547- 2116 if you need assistance. 1  Historic Review Board Applicant: Amor Artis Brewing 204-101 Main Street Tax Map # 020-03-01-015 Zoning: Local Commercial / Historic District Request: Amor Artis Brewing is requesting approval of a revision to a previously approved Certificate of Appropriateness (COA) for screening surrounding the service areas at the rear of the property. The COA was originally approved at the HRB’s August 8, 2017 meeting and subsequently was reviewed and approved in conjunction with the applicant’s proposed deck expansion on April 10, 2018. The applicant now intends to expand the screening to fully enclose the landscaped area at the rear of the property in order to better screen areas being utilized as service areas. Historic District Design Guidelines Review The Historic District Design Guidelines state that service areas and building equipment will be a part of both historic and new construction projects. They should be visually unobtrusive and should be integrated with the design of the site and the building. This equipment should be screened from public view to avoid negative effects on all properties. • 6.13 – Minimize the visual impacts of service areas. o Screen a service area with an enclosure. It should be designed to be compatible with the context and of durable materials. • 6.14 – Minimize the visual impacts of building equipment on the public way and the surrounding neighborhood. o Screen equipment from view o Do not locate equipment on the primary façade o Locate utility lines and junction boxes on secondary and tertiary walls and group them, when feasible. 2 Bailey Bill Review The property, York County Tax Map # 020-03-01-015, is subject to a pending request to receive a special tax assessment for rehabilitated historic properties (Bailey Bill). The property has been approved for Preliminary Certification but has not yet received Final Certification approval. Any substantive changes made to the property during rehabilitation (prior to Final Certification approval), such as those proposed with this request, shall be reviewed and approved based upon the standards for rehabilitation outlined in Chapter 2, Article IV, Division 3, Section 2-202. Any changes not meeting those standards may disqualify the property from eligibility during the Final Certification process. Should the proposed improvements be scheduled for construction after the property has received Final Certification approval, the proposed improvements would still need to be reviewed based upon the standards for rehabilitation outlined in Chapter 2, Article IV, Division 3, Section 2-202. The Historic Review Board shall make a determination as to whether the proposed improvements are consistent with the standards for rehabilitation. If determined to be consistent, the proposed improvements may be approved and constructed without affecting the special tax assessment on the property. If the proposed improvements are determined to be inconsistent, their construction would disqualify the property from its eligibility for the special tax assessment. (a) Standards for rehabilitation. To be eligible for the special tax assessment, historic rehabilitations must be conducted according to the following standards: (1) The historic character of a property shall be retained and preserved. The removal of historic materials or alterations or of features and spaces that characterize each property shall be avoided. (2) Each property shall be recognized as a physical record of its time, place and use. Changes that create a false sense of historical development shall not be undertaken. (3) Most properties change over time. Those changes that have acquired historic significance in their own right shall be retained and preserved. (4) Distinctive features, finishes, and construction techniques or examples of craftsmanship that characterize a property should be preserved. (5) Deteriorated historic features shall be repaired rather than replaced. Where the severity of deterioration requires replacement or of a distinctive feature, the new should match the old in design, color, texture, and other visual qualities and, where possible, materials. Replacement of missing features shall be substantiated by documentary, physical or pictorial evidence. 3  (6) Chemical or physical treatments, such as sandblasting, that cause damage to historic materials shall not be used. The surface cleaning of structures, if appropriate, shall be undertaken using the most gentle means possible. (7) New additions, exterior alterations, or related new construction shall not destroy historic materials that characterize the property. The new work shall be differentiated from the old and shall be compatible with the massing, size, scale and architectural features to protect the historic integrity of the historic property and its environment. (8) New additions and adjacent new construction shall be undertaken in such a manner that, if removed in the future, the essential form and integrity of the historic property and its environment would be unimpaired. Staff Recommendation Should the Board wish to approve the request for a revised Certificate of Appropriateness, staff would request that the approval motion include a condition to allow staff the ability to approve minor modifications to the plan so as to accommodate the comments and concerns of the various plan reviewers for the Town of Fort Mill. Attachments Photograph of the existing deck structure Sketches and rendering of the proposed screening and deck expansion 4 5 6 Historic Review Board Request The Historic Review Board (HRB) and Planning Staff have had previous discussion regarding the potential adoption of an approved color palette to facilitate the efficient review and approvals of Certificates of Appropriateness (COA) within the Historic District of the Town of Fort Mill. To that end, Staff has put together four-color palette examples from historic districts across the country. These examples include paint guidelines from the following communities: 1. Grapevine, TX Historic District 2. Hyannis Mainstreet Waterfront Historic District (Barnstable, MA) 3. Marietta, GA Historic District 4. Richmond, VA Historic District These guidelines range from Grapevine, TX which provides a narrative and references their adopted historic color palettes based on that of several paint manufacturers, to that of Richmond, VA which has taken the Sherwin Williams palette and provided very detailed guidance on using it within their respective historic district. We will discuss the use of such a palette and how adopting an approved paint color selection will aid the decision making process within the Town of Fort Mill Historic District. 7  Grapevine, TX PAINT GUIDELINES Adding Character The exterior surfaces of historic buildings are painted for two primary reasons – to protect and preserve the exterior materials and to create color schemes appropriate for the building’s architectural style. An appropriate paint scheme on an historic building will accentuate its architectural details and add to the character of the historic district. The paint colors selected for a historic building will greatly contribute to the historic character of the building and surrounding historic district, and as such should reflect the historical age, period and style of a building, accentuate the architectural features of the design, and represent the current owner’s taste. The articulation and details of exterior walls, window and door openings, trim, scale, and texture of exterior materials can be enhanced or obscured by appropriate and inappropriate paint colors selected for a building. Select and locate paint colors that are appropriate to the style, period, and type of building and its district or area. Selection and location of paint colors based on research of historic finishes is encouraged. Paint colors should be complementary to each other and used to accentuate a building’s significant features. This method of selecting colors and locations of colors does not mean that every house or building in a historic district or of a particular period or style should be painted the same color. There is a wide range of attractive colors, which may be combined in hundreds of ways to provide for individuality with overall continuity. While Grapevine did not have as great a selection of historic paint colors (most houses in town were painted white, both body and trim, while window screens or shutters were painted dark green or black), the selected colors are based on paint companies’ available color palettes for the period when Grapevine’s historic buildings were being constructed. Note Original stone or masonry surfaces should be maintained and not be painted, unless severe deterioration of the brick or stone can be shown to require painting and other consolidation or stabilization methods cannot be shown to be appropriate. If masonry was previously painted, it is often not appropriate or possible to remove paint and appropriate repainting should be considered. Paint Color Location 8  Having selected a base or body color that is appropriate to the period and style of your historic building, the next decision is for a trim color to contrast and compliment that of the body color. Trim Nearly all houses and some commercial buildings built in Grapevine prior to WWII were defined by trim colors. Trim color, for houses, was used to define wood elements such as porch features, corner boards, window, and door trim and fascia boards. All of these elements were usually painted the trim color to provide a contrast or to define the main body (or base) color of the house. Porches were also painted a trim color to provide an outline or contrast of color to the main body color. Commercial buildings typically had their body color defined by the material the building was constructed of (i.e. brick and stone) while a trim color was utilized for defining windows, doors and other architectural elements such as cast iron. Body and trim colors should not be similar in hue or tone intensity (i.e. two shades of colors that are closely related like green and red or two dark or light shades of color that are similar in darkness or lightness). Accent A third color, commonly called an accent color, was quite often utilized to accentuate or highlight a particular feature of a house or building. On houses, the accent color typically was painted on doors, window sashes or special decorative wood trim. It was also common to see the front doors stained a natural color so as to accentuate the natural grain of the wood on the door. On commercial buildings, the accent color was also used to highlight particular architectural features of the building façade. Color Palettes The Grapevine Historic Preservation Commission has approved the following paint manufacturer’s preservation color palettes for Historic Landmarks and buildings within Historic Districts: o Sherwin Williams - Preservation Palette o Pittsburgh Paints - Historic Paints o Do It Best Paints - American Historical Restoration Colors (Exteriors only) 9 o Valspar - American Tradition HIstoric Colors (Lights only) A good rule of thumb to follow is the simpler the design of the building or house, the fewer colors used. Certificate of Appropriateness Any exterior modifications, including new paint colors, to buildings and properties that are designated Historic Landmarks or within Grapevine’s Historic Districts require a Certificate of Appropriateness (CA) be approved before modifications may begin. Many modifications are simple and routine and can be approved by City of Grapevine Staff within a few days after the CA application is submitted. More significant projects require review and approval by the Historic Preservation Commission, which meets monthly. The Commission has approved various preservation color palettes to assist the building owner with appropriate colors for their historic buildings. For further information on approved color palettes or Grapevine’s Historic Preservation Programs, or to obtain a Certificate of Appropriateness application package, please contact the Historic Preservation Office at 817.410.3197. 10  Barnstable, MA Hyannis Main Street Waterfront Historic District Guidelines for Exterior Building Materials and Colors The majority of the residential structures the district have wood siding, either shingle, clapboard, or a combination of the two. Commercial buildings on Main Street and the waterfront feature a variety of façade materials, the most common being cedar clapboards and red brick.  High quality and authentic natural materials, such as wood, stone, and brick are recommended for the District. Buildings on Hyannis Main Street have historically  Original siding on historically significant featured a variety of building materials and colors. structures should be maintained and restored when possible. If siding must be replaced, the original design should be replicated with authentic materials. In most cases, modern material substitutes will not be permitted on historically significant structures.  Cedar shakes and clapboards are preferred materials for most residential structures. Many homes have clapboards on the front elevation and cedar shingles on side elevations.  Quality fiber cement or composite siding may be appropriate for renovations of structures with limited historic value.  Modern materials, such as PVC composites, are acceptable for surfaces prone to weathering, rotting, or excessive wear.  Siding materials such as aluminum or vinyl siding are prohibited. Vinyl or polymer cedar shake- style siding is not appropriate for the District.  Masonry that has not been painted in the past should not be painted without review by the HHDC.  Stucco-coating a historic building is typically not an appropriate treatment if it has not been previously stuccoed. Traditional Main Street storefronts with Brick Colonial Revival buildings built A Queen Anne style home, built 1876, clapboard siding, built around 1900. along Main Street in the 1920s and 1930s. sided with cedar clapboards and shakes. 11 Colors Hyannis Main Street and the waterfront A History of Color in the Hyannis Historic District have a varied color palate that helps bring During each period in the HHD’s architectural history, vibrancy and interest to the area. architects and builders took advantage of the impact of  For historically significant buildings, color. Before 1870 they typically painted the small original paint colors for the structure or Cape Cod houses and early buildings in white or light style of structure should be researched and earth tones (grays, yellows, tans) as well as some reds used as a starting point for color selection. and browns. They also selected light earth tones as Colors historically appropriate for the age trim colors compatible with the natural red brick walls and style of the structure are recommended. of some of the commercial buildings. Generally, historic color schemes are fairly simple, often utilizing only two or three After 1870, commercial and residential architecture colors. evolved and flourished, adding noticeably darker colors to the HHD’s palette: greens, dark reds, and  Palettes of historic colors and color olives. Almost always, trim painted in a darker color guides for common architectural styles are complemented the lighter color of the house. published by the group Historic New From about 1880 to 1900, highly ornamented buildings England. Several leading paint brands provided the opportunity for a more lively and offer historic color series. Colors in these collections are recommended in the imaginative use of color. The late 19th-century palette District. included pale yellow or light green on frame buildings with dark green or maroon trim. Some brick buildings  In general, avoid painting surfaces that also had dark green or maroon, brown or brown-red have never been painted. For example, trim. stone lintels and sills or masonry in good After 1900, architects generally moved away from the condition should not be painted. previous era’s complexity and ornateness. Adopting plain, simple, classical forms, they chose lighter colors  Gutters and downspouts should be the same color as the trim. such as cream, yellow, and white. Historic colors of the Iyanough Hotel, formerly located at Main Street and Ocean Street. 12 CHAPTER SEVEN: PAINT COLOR Paint is utilized on buildings for two primary reasons: 1) to protect and preserve the exterior materials and 2) to create color schemes appropriate to a building’s architectural style. Paint can also accentuate architectural details, provide variety in a neighborhood and allow for personal expression. The color scheme utilized on a building influences the historic character of a building, as well as the surrounding district and neighborhood. Whenever possible the color scheme should reflect the period and the architectural style of the building or structure. A variety of colors are available to an applicant that will be appropriate for a historic building in the City of Marietta. When choosing a paint scheme for a building or structure, an applicant may consult historic photographs of their building, if available. Many paint manufacturers have researched historic color schemes and have created color palettes appropriate to time periods in the United States. For example, Sherwin-Williams has developed an “Arts & Crafts” color palette that is appropriate to the early twentieth century era in the United States. This palette would be an appropriate choice for a house built during this era. This palette provides numerous color combinations so that no Craftsman-era building in the Figure 7.1: This is an example of what happens when masonry is cleaned improperly by sandblasting of the city need look exactly the same. surface. Masonry has a protective “skin” which protects against infiltration of moisture. If this skin is removed, as Historically, the painting of masonry was not typically done except in certain situations where the is the case with sandblasting, the brick can no longer original masonry (typically brick) was so porous that moisture could easily penetrate the masonry repel moisture. causing damage to the interior of the building. This resulted in increased maintenance and expense because to keep the masonry properly sealed against moisture penetration, the paint finish would need to be periodically reapplied. In the mid- to late twentieth century, paint was sometimes used because deterioration of mortar joints allowed for moisture to penetrate a structure. Another scenerio leading to painted masonry is when it is improperly cleaned by abrasive methods, such as sandblasting, the masonry can become porous leading to moisture penetration. It is recognized that many masonry buildings in downtown Marietta have been painted for a variety of reasons. 7.01: An applicant should utilize a paint scheme appropriate to the structure’s time period or appropriate to a historic period when major alterations were undertaken to the building. 7.02: When choosing a color scheme, an applicant should consider that the simpler a building was the simpler the color scheme would have been. For example, a simple Gabled Wing Cottage would likely have a trim and body color while a Queen Anne House would likely have a trim color, accent color(s) and a body color. 7.03: Porches should be painted with one of the colors, typically the trim color,of the building. 7.04: Colors should complement each other and be used to accentuate a building’s significant MARIETTA DESIGN GUIDELINES • CHAPTER 7: PAINT COLOR 7-  architectural detail. 7.05: The HBR encourages applicants to consider the following color palettes: 1) Sherwin Williams – Arts & Crafts; and 2) Sherwin Williams – Classical/Colonial; and 3) Sherwin Williams - Victorian. 7.06: Exterior masonry (stone, brick and composite stones) should not to be painted unless they were historically painted or are currently painted. Masonry should only be painted if there are no other cost-effective consolidation techniques available to the applicant to halt moisture penetration. 7.07: All paint should be applied in an appropriate manner utilizing the manufacturer’s suggested application process and/or professional knowledge so that the paint properly bonds and adheres to the appropriate surfaces to be painted. Figure 7.2: This masonry has been inappropriately painted, causing the paint to peel off within one year of its application. The painting of masonry can cause recurring maintenance issues and may cause damage to the masonry. 7- CHAPTER 7: PAINT COLOR • MARIETTA DESIGN GUIDELINES Figure 7.3: This Sherwin Williams “Arts & Crafts” Color Palette is appropriate to Figure 7.4: This Sherwin Williams “Classical/Colonial” Color Palette is appropriate the Marietta Historic District. to the Marietta Historic District. MARIETTA DESIGN GUIDELINES • CHAPTER 7: PAINT COLOR 7- Figure 7.5: This Sherwin Williams “Victorian” Color Palette is appropriate to the Marietta Historic District. 7- CHAPTER 7: PAINT COLOR • MARIETTA DESIGN GUIDELINES  Richmond, VA Paint Staff representatives of the Commission of Architectural Review (CAR) are authorized to assist Old and Historic District property owners in paint color selection and, where appropriate, grant administrative approval for paint color proposals. If you are considering an exterior color change, please call Commission staff at (804) 646-6335. The chart of paint colors found below represents a palette of paint colors appropriate for use on historic properties. It has been developed to guide property owners and Commission staff in color selection. Not all paint chart colors are appropriate for every historic building. Property owners are strongly encouraged to contact CAR staff in advance of any proposed painting or repainting to ensure that appropriate colors are selected. Colors not found on the palette must be reviewed by staff on a case-by-case basis. If staff members consider a property owner’s preferred colors to be inappropriate, they will forward the proposal to the CAR for full review, noting that administrative approval was not granted. The color palette is based on Sherwin Williams-brand colors. The Commission does not promote a specific brand of paint, and uses these color codes for reference only. Any paint brand with a comparable paint color may be used. Frame Structures 1) High quality paint should be used following directions for preparation and application. A paint professional should be consulted before beginning your project. 2) It is important that color selections blend with and complement the overall color schemes on the street. 3) Fluorescent and obtrusive colors are not appropriate as these were not traditionally used on local historic structures. (The high Victorian “painted ladies” of San Francisco and other western cities represent a phenomenon never adopted in Richmond.) 4) Number and variety of colors should be limited. With the notable exception of the Queen Anne style, traditional paint schemes do not use more than two or three colors. 5) Individual details in cornices and columns should not be emphasized with additional color. 6) The handrails of wooden porch railings are often painted a dark color while the pickets are painted white or off-white. 7) Doors and shutters can be painted a different color than the walls and trim. 8) Enamel “high gloss” paint should be used only on doors. 9) Treating exterior wood elements with clear finishes is not advisable unless the element was historically stained or varnished. 10) Stains are a modern method of protecting and/or coloring wood, and are usually not appropriate for use on historic building exteriors. An exception to this guidance is the use of opaque stains on pressure-treated wood elements (for example, at new fire stairs, or at rear or side porches). 11) Building materials installed as a result of additions and alterations should be painted to match or complement a building’s existing colors. Richmond CAR Guidelines Proposed update to paint colors 27 October 2016 Page 1 Historic Masonry 1) Do not paint historic brick or stone masonry that has not previously been painted. Painting previously unpainted masonry is historically inaccurate and is not permitted. Property owners who wish to remove paint from masonry should work with a qualified contractor knowledgeable in the use of non-abrasive cleaners. 2) Review is required if you wish to change the color of painted brick. If you wish to paint previously painted brick the same color, no review by staff or the CAR is necessary. 3) Colors associated with the colors of natural brick are strongly encouraged and are preferable to less appropriate colors (white, green, blue, etc.). Commission staff must approve any new paint colors before work can begin. Colors appearing on computer screens or printed on standard printers may distort the values of colors. It is best to refer to the color swatches available at any home improvement store. Information on the color’s name, and number can be found on the following page. The Commission does not endorse specific paint brands. Sherwin Williams paint names and codes are provided for reference only. Richmond CAR Guidelines Proposed update to paint colors 27 October 2016 Page 2 Exterior Paint Color Selection Chart The paint chart below is provided with the goal of streamlining paint discussions between property owners, architects / contractors, and City of Richmond staff. The colors are arranged by location on the building, with a full list (name, number, and example) provided at the end of this section. The following color selections generally correspond to the recommendations by the City of Richmond’s Commission of Architectural Review (CAR). This document is intended to be a guide and, as such, can be expanded or contracted as CAR staff and commissioners find appropriate. Colors are for previously painted surfaces only. Existing unpainted brick and stone must remain unpainted per the Secretary of the Interior’s Standards for Rehabilitation. Exterior paint sheens should be semi-gloss. Element Color Notes Wood-frame Buildings (including Stucco-clad buildings) 18C, Georgian, Federal, and Greek Revival styles Body white, Spanish brown, yellow ochre, stone, buff, light grey, green- grey, medium blue, Trim green, light yellow, white, straw, cream, black, dark brown, dark grey, dark green, dark brown Wood-frame Buildings (including Stucco-clad buildings) Italianate, Second Empire, and Queen Anne styles Body Deep blue, medium grey, dark ochre, tan, slate, Trim Golden yellow, dark grey, green-black, tan, deep red, olive green Wood-frame Buildings (including Stucco-clad buildings) Arts and Crafts style Body Off-white, light yellow, light blue, medium blue, light olive, light grey Trim White, off-white, light yellow, light grey, deep red, deep green Richmond CAR Guidelines Proposed update to paint colors 27 October 2016 Page 3 Element Color Notes Wood-frame Buildings (including Stucco-clad buildings) Colonial Revival style Body White, beige, pale green, medium grey, medium blue Trim Green, white, yellow Masonry Buildings (previously painted only) All styles Body Color - Reds, browns, yellow- Previously-painted brick only. Match original brick Brick clay color when possible. Body Color - Browns Previously-painted stone only. Match original stone Stone color when possible. Wood Trim See style chart for appropriate trim color Lintels Natural stone or brick Previously-painted stone only. Match original stone colors, as body colors lintel color. above. Previously-painted brick lintels are to be painted the body brick color. Headers Natural stone or brick Previously-painted stone only. Match original stone colors, as body colors color. above. Previously-painted brick lintels are to be painted the body brick color. Unless the lintel is stone, do not pick out the lintel in a contracting color. Colors appropriate for all buildings Window Whites, Blacks, May match trim color or may be contrasting. Sashes Neutrals Sills Neutrals Painted stone only. Match original stone color. Shutters Blacks, Greens Doors Blacks, Browns, Painted wood only. Stained wood doors must remain Greens, Reds, Yellows, stained and may not be painted. Neutrals Porch Blues Ceilings Porch Floors Neutrals Use non-slip texture for foot traffic. Metal Blacks, Greens May also be used for wood top hand rail. Elements Metal Roofs Blacks, Greens, Reds May also match an existing gray, but not “silver” paint. Wood Fences Whites, Dark Browns, Whites and opaque neutral stains. Gray Richmond CAR Guidelines Proposed update to paint colors 27 October 2016 Page 4 18th Century, Georgian, Federal, and Greek Revival Styles Wood-frame Buildings (including Stucco-clad Buildings) Body Color SW 0046 SW 0050 SW 0053 SW 2829 SW 2833 SW 7008 SW 6385 SW 2829 SW 0050 SW 0078 SW 2834 SW 2865 SW 6128 SW 6394 SW 2807 SW 2808 SW 2838 SW 2856 SW 6069 SW 6146 SW 7020 Wood Trim SW 0046 SW 0050 SW 0053 SW 2829 SW 2833 SW 7008 SW 6385 SW 2829 SW 0050 SW 0023 SW 0024 SW 0037 SW 0038 SW 0049 SW 0054 SW 2805 SW 2821 SW 2844 SW 2845 Masonry Buildings Body Color – Brick (previously painted only) – Reds and Yellow-Clay – all styles SW 0006 SW 0008 SW 0072 SW 2903 SW 2839 SW 0078 SW 2805 SW 2822 SW 2834 Body Color – Stone (previously painted only) – Browns and Grays – all styles SW 2807 SW 2808 SW 2838 SW 2856 SW 6006 SW 6069 SW 6146 SW 2821 SW 2844 Masonry Lintels (previously painted only) - Neutrals SW 0023 SW 0049 SW 0054 SW 0055 SW 0077 SW 2821 SW 2844 SW 2845 SW 2850 SW 6199 Richmond CAR Guidelines Proposed update to paint colors 27 October 2016 Page 5 Masonry Sills (previously painted only) – Neutrals SW 0023 SW 0049 SW 0054 SW 0055 SW 0077 SW 2821 SW 2844 SW 2845 SW 2850 SW 6199 Wood-frame and Masonry Buildings Window Sashes – Whites, Blacks, Neutrals SW 0046 SW 0050 SW 0053 SW 2829 SW 2833 SW 7008 SW 0023 SW 0024 SW 0037 SW 0038 SW 0049 SW 0054 SW 2805 SW 2821 SW 2844 SW 2845 SW 6258 SW 6990 SW 7020 SW 7069 Shutters – Blacks, Greens SW 6258 SW 6990 SW 7020 SW 7069 SW 0014 SW 2809 SW 2816 SW 2846 SW 2847 SW 6207 Doors – Blacks, Browns, Greens, Reds, Yellows, Neutrals SW 6258 SW 6990 SW 7020 SW 7069 SW 2807 SW 2808 SW 2838 SW 2856 SW 6006 SW 6069 SW 6146 SW 0014 SW 2809 SW 2816 SW 2846 SW 2847 SW 6207 SW 0006 SW 0008 SW 0072 SW 2903 SW 2839 Richmond CAR Guidelines Proposed update to paint colors 27 October 2016 Page 6 SW 0078 SW 2834 SW 2865 SW 6128 SW 6394 Porch Ceilings - Blues SW 0052 SW 0059 SW 0068 SW 6477 SW 6478 Porch Floors – Neutrals SW 0023 SW 0024 SW 0037 SW 0038 SW 0049 SW 0054 SW 2805 SW 2821 SW 2844 SW 2845 Metal Elements – Blacks, Greens SW 6258 SW 6990 SW 7020 SW 7069 Metal Roofs – Blacks, Greens, Reds SW 6258 SW 6990 SW 7020 SW 7069 SW 0014 SW 2809 SW 2816 SW 2846 SW 2847 SW 6207 SW 0006 SW 0008 SW 0072 SW 2903 SW 2839 Wood Fences – Whites and opaque neutral stains SW 0046 SW 0050 SW 0053 SW 2829 SW 2833 SW 7008 SW 2807 SW 2808 SW 2838 SW 2856 SW 6006 SW 6069 SW 6146 SW 0023 SW 0024 SW 0037 SW 0038 SW 0049 SW 0054 SW 2805 SW 2821 SW 2844 SW 2845 Richmond CAR Guidelines Proposed update to paint colors 27 October 2016 Page 7 Italianate, Second Empire, and Queen Anne Styles Wood-frame Buildings (including Stucco-clad Buildings) Body Color SW 2807 SW 2808 SW 2838 SW 2856 SW 6006 SW 6069 SW 6146 SW 0014 SW 2809 SW 2816 SW 2846 SW 2847 SW 6207 SW 0006 SW 0008 SW 0072 SW 2903 SW 2839 SW 6244 SW 9178 SW 9179 Wood Trim SW 0046 SW 0050 SW 0053 SW 2829 SW 2833 SW 7008 SW 0023 SW 0024 SW 0037 SW 0038 SW 0049 SW 0054 SW 2805 SW 2821 SW 2844 SW 2845 SW 0078 SW 2834 SW 2865 SW 6128 SW 6394 SW 0014 SW 2809 SW 2816 SW 2846 SW 2847 SW 6207 SW 0006 SW 0008 SW 0072 SW 2903 SW 2839 Masonry Buildings Body Color – Brick (previously painted only) – Reds and Yellow-Clay – all styles Richmond CAR Guidelines Proposed update to paint colors 27 October 2016 Page 8 SW 0006 SW 0008 SW 0072 SW 2903 SW 2839 SW 0078 SW 2805 SW 2822 SW 2834 Body Color – Stone (previously painted only) – Browns and Grays – all styles SW 2807 SW 2808 SW 2838 SW 2856 SW 6006 SW 6069 SW 6146 SW 2821 SW 2844 Masonry Lintels (previously painted only) - Neutrals SW 0023 SW 0049 SW 0054 SW 0055 SW 0077 SW 2821 SW 2844 SW 2845 SW 2850 SW 6199 Masonry Sills (previously painted only) – Neutrals SW 0023 SW 0049 SW 0054 SW 0055 SW 0077 SW 2821 SW 2844 SW 2845 SW 2850 SW 6199 Wood-frame and Masonry Buildings Window Sashes – Whites, Blacks, Neutrals SW 0046 SW 0050 SW 0053 SW 2829 SW 2833 SW 7008 SW 0023 SW 0024 SW 0037 SW 0038 SW 0049 SW 0054 SW 2805 SW 2821 SW 2844 SW 2845 SW 6258 SW 6990 SW 7020 SW 7069 Shutters – Blacks, Greens SW 6258 SW 6990 SW 7020 SW 7069 SW 0014 SW 2809 SW 2816 SW 2846 SW 2847 SW 6207 Richmond CAR Guidelines Proposed update to paint colors 27 October 2016 Page 9 Doors – Blacks, Browns, Greens, Reds, Yellows, Neutrals SW 6258 SW 6990 SW 7020 SW 7069 SW 2807 SW 2808 SW 2838 SW 2856 SW 6006 SW 6069 SW 6146 SW 0014 SW 2809 SW 2816 SW 2846 SW 2847 SW 6207 SW 0006 SW 0008 SW 0072 SW 2903 SW 2839 SW 0078 SW 2834 SW 2865 SW 6128 SW 6394 Porch Ceilings - Blues SW 0052 SW 0059 SW 0068 SW 6477 SW 6478 Porch Floors – Neutrals SW 0023 SW 0024 SW 0037 SW 0038 SW 0049 SW 0054 SW 2805 SW 2821 SW 2844 SW 2845 Metal Elements – Blacks, Greens SW 6258 SW 6990 SW 7020 SW 7069 Metal Roofs – Blacks, Greens, Reds SW 6258 SW 6990 SW 7020 SW 7069 SW 0014 SW 2809 SW 2816 SW 2846 SW 2847 SW 6207 Richmond CAR Guidelines Proposed update to paint colors 27 October 2016 Page 10 SW 0006 SW 0008 SW 0072 SW 2903 SW 2839 Wood Fences – Whites and opaque neutral stains SW 0046 SW 0050 SW 0053 SW 2829 SW 2833 SW 7008 SW 2807 SW 2808 SW 2838 SW 2856 SW 6006 SW 6069 SW 6146 SW 0023 SW 0024 SW 0037 SW 0038 SW 0049 SW 0054 SW 2805 SW 2821 SW 2844 SW 2845 Richmond CAR Guidelines Proposed update to paint colors 27 October 2016 Page 11 Arts and Crafts Style Wood-frame Buildings (including Stucco-clad Buildings) Body Color SW 0046 SW 0050 SW 0053 SW 2829 SW 2833 SW 7008 SW 0078 SW 2834 SW 2865 SW 6128 SW 6394 SW 0014 SW 2816 SW 2846 SW 6207 SW 2861 SW 0023 SW 0024 SW 0037 SW 0038 SW 0049 SW 0054 SW 2805 SW 2821 SW 2844 SW 2845 Wood Trim SW 0046 SW 0050 SW 0053 SW 2829 SW 2833 SW 7008 SW 0023 SW 0024 SW 0037 SW 0038 SW 0049 SW 0054 SW 2805 SW 2821 SW 2844 SW 2845 SW 0078 SW 2834 SW 2865 SW 6128 SW 6394 Masonry Buildings Body Color – Brick (previously painted only) – Reds and Yellow-Clay – all styles SW 0006 SW 0008 SW 0072 SW 2903 SW 2839 SW 0078 SW 2805 SW 2822 SW 2834 Body Color – Stone (previously painted only) – Browns and Grays – all styles Richmond CAR Guidelines Proposed update to paint colors 27 October 2016 Page 12 SW 2807 SW 2808 SW 2838 SW 2856 SW 6006 SW 6069 SW 6146 SW 2821 SW 2844 Masonry Lintels (previously painted only) - Neutrals SW 0023 SW 0049 SW 0054 SW 0055 SW 0077 SW 2821 SW 2844 SW 2845 SW 2850 SW 6199 Masonry Sills (previously painted only) – Neutrals SW 0023 SW 0049 SW 0054 SW 0055 SW 0077 SW 2821 SW 2844 SW 2845 SW 2850 SW 6199 Wood-frame and Masonry Buildings Window Sashes – Whites, Blacks, Neutrals SW 0046 SW 0050 SW 0053 SW 2829 SW 2833 SW 7008 SW 0023 SW 0024 SW 0037 SW 0038 SW 0049 SW 0054 SW 2805 SW 2821 SW 2844 SW 2845 SW 6258 SW 6990 SW 7020 SW 7069 Shutters – Blacks, Greens SW 6258 SW 6990 SW 7020 SW 7069 SW 0014 SW 2809 SW 2816 SW 2846 SW 2847 SW 6207 Doors – Blacks, Browns, Greens, Reds, Yellows, Neutrals SW 6258 SW 6990 SW 7020 SW 7069 SW 2807 SW 2808 SW 2838 SW 2856 SW 6006 SW 6069 SW 6146 Richmond CAR Guidelines Proposed update to paint colors 27 October 2016 Page 13 SW 0014 SW 2809 SW 2816 SW 2846 SW 2847 SW 6207 SW 0006 SW 0008 SW 0072 SW 2903 SW 2839 SW 0078 SW 2834 SW 2865 SW 6128 SW 6394 Porch Ceilings - Blues SW 0052 SW 0059 SW 0068 SW 6477 SW 6478 Porch Floors – Neutrals SW 0023 SW 0024 SW 0037 SW 0038 SW 0049 SW 0054 SW 2805 SW 2821 SW 2844 SW 2845 Metal Elements – Blacks, Greens SW 6258 SW 6990 SW 7020 SW 7069 Metal Roofs – Blacks, Greens, Reds SW 6258 SW 6990 SW 7020 SW 7069 SW 0014 SW 2809 SW 2816 SW 2846 SW 2847 SW 6207 SW 0006 SW 0008 SW 0072 SW 2903 SW 2839 Wood Fences – Whites and opaque neutral stains SW 0046 SW 0050 SW 0053 SW 2829 SW 2833 SW 7008 Richmond CAR Guidelines Proposed update to paint colors 27 October 2016 Page 14 SW 2807 SW 2808 SW 2838 SW 2856 SW 6006 SW 6069 SW 6146 SW 0023 SW 0024 SW 0037 SW 0038 SW 0049 SW 0054 SW 2805 SW 2821 SW 2844 SW 2845 Richmond CAR Guidelines Proposed update to paint colors 27 October 2016 Page 15 Colonial Revival Style Wood-frame Buildings (including Stucco-clad Buildings) Body Color SW 6385 SW 2829 SW 0050 SW 0030 SW 0044 SW 0078 SW 2831 SW 2834 SW 2865 SW 2819 SW 2849 SW 2863 SW 0066 SW 2815 Wood Trim SW 0046 SW 0050 SW 0053 SW 2829 SW 2833 SW 7008 SW 6385 SW 2829 SW 0050 SW 0023 SW 0024 SW 0049 SW 0054 SW 0055 SW 0077 SW 2821 SW 2822 SW 2844 SW 2845 SW 0078 SW 2834 SW 2865 SW 6128 SW 6394 Masonry Buildings Body Color – Brick (previously painted only) – Reds and Yellow-Clay – all styles SW 0006 SW 0008 SW 0072 SW 2903 SW 2839 SW 0078 SW 2805 SW 2822 SW 2834 Richmond CAR Guidelines Proposed update to paint colors 27 October 2016 Page 16 Body Color – Stone (previously painted only) – Browns and Grays – all styles SW 2807 SW 2808 SW 2838 SW 2856 SW 6006 SW 6069 SW 6146 SW 2821 SW 2844 Masonry Lintels (previously painted only) - Neutrals SW 0023 SW 0049 SW 0054 SW 0055 SW 0077 SW 2821 SW 2844 SW 2845 SW 2850 SW 6199 Masonry Sills (previously painted only) – Neutrals SW 0023 SW 0049 SW 0054 SW 0055 SW 0077 SW 2821 SW 2844 SW 2845 SW 2850 SW 6199 Wood-frame and Masonry Buildings Window Sashes – Whites, Blacks, Neutrals SW 0046 SW 0050 SW 0053 SW 2829 SW 2833 SW 7008 SW 0023 SW 0024 SW 0037 SW 0038 SW 0049 SW 0054 SW 2805 SW 2821 SW 2844 SW 2845 SW 6258 SW 6990 SW 7020 SW 7069 Shutters – Blacks, Greens SW 6258 SW 6990 SW 7020 SW 7069 SW 0014 SW 2809 SW 2816 SW 2846 SW 2847 SW 6207 Doors – Blacks, Browns, Greens, Reds, Yellows, Neutrals SW 6258 SW 6990 SW 7020 SW 7069 Richmond CAR Guidelines Proposed update to paint colors 27 October 2016 Page 17 SW 2807 SW 2808 SW 2838 SW 2856 SW 6006 SW 6069 SW 6146 SW 0014 SW 2809 SW 2816 SW 2846 SW 2847 SW 6207 SW 0006 SW 0008 SW 0072 SW 2903 SW 2839 SW 0078 SW 2834 SW 2865 SW 6128 SW 6394 Porch Ceilings - Blues SW 0052 SW 0059 SW 0068 SW 6477 SW 6478 Porch Floors – Neutrals SW 0023 SW 0024 SW 0037 SW 0038 SW 0049 SW 0054 SW 2805 SW 2821 SW 2844 SW 2845 Metal Elements – Blacks, Greens SW 6258 SW 6990 SW 7020 SW 7069 Metal Roofs – Blacks, Greens, Reds SW 6258 SW 6990 SW 7020 SW 7069 SW 0014 SW 2809 SW 2816 SW 2846 SW 2847 SW 6207 SW 0006 SW 0008 SW 0072 SW 2903 SW 2839 Richmond CAR Guidelines Proposed update to paint colors 27 October 2016 Page 18 Wood Fences – Whites and opaque neutral stains SW 0046 SW 0050 SW 0053 SW 2829 SW 2833 SW 7008 SW 2807 SW 2808 SW 2838 SW 2856 SW 6006 SW 6069 SW 6146 SW 0023 SW 0024 SW 0037 SW 0038 SW 0049 SW 0054 SW 2805 SW 2821 SW 2844 SW 2845 Richmond CAR Guidelines Proposed update to paint colors 27 October 2016 Page 19 List of All Colors: Whites Blues White Hyacinth SW 0046 Pearl Gray SW 0052 Classic Light Buff SW 0050 Frostwork SW 0059 Porcelain SW 0053 Copen Blue SW 0068 Classical White SW 2829 Naval SW 6244 Roycroft Vellum SW 2833 Tidewater SW 6477 Alabaster SW 7008 Watery SW 6478 In the Navy SW 9178 Blacks Anchors Aweigh SW 9179 Tricorn Black SW 6258 Caviar SW 6990 Neutrals Black Fox SW 7020 Pewter Tankard SW 0023 Iron Ore SW 7069 Curio Gray SW 0024 Morris Room Grey SW 0037 Browns Library Pewter SW 0038 Rookwood Med Brown SW 2807 Silver Gray SW 0049 Rookwood Dark Brown SW 2808 Twilight Gray SW 0054 Polished Mahogany SW 2838 Light French Gray SW 0055 Fairfax Brown SW 2856 Classic French Gray SW 0077 Black Bean SW 6006 Renwick Beige SW 2805 French Roast SW 6069 Downing Stone SW 2821 Umber SW 6146 Downing Sand SW 2822 Roycroft Mist Gray SW 2844 Greens Bunglehouse Gray SW 2845 Sheraton Sage SW 0014 Chelsea Gray SW 2850 Rookwood Shutter Grn SW 2809 Sawdust SW 6158 Rookwood Dark Green SW 2816 Rare Fray SW 6199 Roycroft Bronze Green SW 2846 Accessible Beige SW 7036 Roycroft Bottle Green SW 2847 Retreat SW 6207 Reds Toile Red SW 0006 Cajun Red SW 0008 Deep Maroon SW 0072 Rookwood Terra Cotta SW 2903 Roycroft Copper Red SW 2839 Yellows Sunbeam Yellow SW 0078 Birdseye Maple SW 2834 Classical Yellow SW 2865 Blonde SW 6128 Sequin SW 6394 Richmond CAR Guidelines Proposed update to paint colors 27 October 2016 Page 20