City Council

GRAND HAVEN CHARTER TOWNSHIP REGULAR BOARD MEETING AGENDA May 13, 2024 BOARD WORK SESSION – 6:00 P.M. – CANCELLED REGULAR BOARD MEETING – 7:00 P.M. Persons wishing to speak at public hearings, on I. CALL TO ORDER agenda items, or extended comments, must fill out a “Speakers Form” located on the counter. II. PLEDGE TO THE FLAG Completed forms must be submitted to Township Staff prior to the meeting. III. ROLL CALL IV. APPROVAL OF MEETING AGENDA V. CONSENT AGENDA 1. Approve April 22, 2024, Board Minutes 2. Approve April 29, 2024 Special Joint Board/Planning Commission Minutes 3. Approve Payment of Invoices in the amount of $919,666.72 (A/P checks of $759,917.19 and payroll of $159,749.53) 4. Approve – Appointment of Trustee Howard Behm to NORA Board and Parks and Recreation Committee 5. Approve – Low Bid from Jackson-Merkey for DDA Watermain Project at Buchanan Street and US-31 ($1,381,718.50) 6. Approve – Fire/Rescue Station Exhaust System Purchase ($95,598) VI. PRESENTATION – Economic Development Update – Elizabeth Butler VII. OLD BUSINESS 1. Discussion (possible decision) Regarding Open Trustee Position on Township Board VIII. NEW BUSINESS 1. Discussion – Suggestions to Supervisor Reenders for Business Recognition Recipient IX. REPORTS & CORRESPONDENCE 1. Committee Reports 2. Manager′s Report a. April Building Report b. April Enforcement Report 3. Other X. PUBLIC COMMENTS – (Non-Agenda Items) XI. ADJOURNMENT NOTE: The public will be given an opportunity to comment on any agenda item when the item is brought up for discussion. Please complete Speaker Information Sheet. The supervisor will initiate comment time.  GRAND HAVEN CHARTER TOWNSHIP BOARD MONDAY, APRIL 22, 2024 REGULAR MEETING I. CALL TO ORDER Supervisor Reenders called the regular meeting of the Grand Haven Charter Township Board to order at 7:00 p.m. II. PLEDGE TO THE FLAG III. ROLL CALL Board members present: Meeusen, Kieft, Behm, Wagenmaker, and Reenders Board members absent: Larsen Also present was Manager Cargo, Public Services Director Wade and Community Development Director Thibault. Motion by Trustee Meeusen supported by Trustee Behm to appoint Treasurer Kieft as the Temporary Clerk. Which motion carried. IV. APPROVAL OF MEETING AGENDA Motion Trustee Meeusen and seconded by Trustee Behm to approve the meeting agenda. Which motion carried. V. APPROVAL OF CONSENT AGENDA 1. Approve April 8, 2024, Special Board Minutes 2. Approve Payment of Invoices in the amount of $765,676.75 (A/P checks of $598,565.25 and payroll of $167,111.50) 3. Approve - Project Estimate - Payne Forest Drive and Steves Drive Resurfacing ($106k) 4. Approve - OCRC Project Estimate - 2024 Crack Sealing ($39k) 5. Approve Assessing Contract with Property Assessment Solutions ($85k) 6. Approve Agreement for Joint Northwest Ottawa Recreation Plan ($15k) Motion by Treasurer Kieft and seconded by Trustee Meeusen to approve the items listed on the Consent Agenda. Which motion carried. VI. INTRODUCTIONS 1. The recently appointed Ottawa County Treasurer Cheryl Clark introduced herself to the Township Board noting that she had been appointed to her position in December of 2023. Treasurer Clark distributed a handout regarding the annual report from the County Treasurer Department which served as a basis of a brief presentation. 2. The newly selected Public Services Director Matt Wade was introduced to the Township Board noting that he had served previously with the City of Grand Haven. VII. OLD BUSINESS 1. Motion by Trustee Wagenmaker supported by Trustee Behm to approve the Northstar -1-  Storage Site Plan Review waiver request allowing for reduced glass as shown on the architectural drawing package based on the Board’s determination that the request meets the following items: a. Adequate screening of the building is provided by the Planning Commission’s condition shows the existing trees, to the east of the existing building, are to be preserved. This condition is upheld. b. The applicant desires to maintain safety and security of the contents stored within the accessory structure by reducing the glass area. c. The glass area for the aggregated front facades, meets the Ordinance requirement. Which motion carried, with Treasurer Kieft voting no 2. The Board discussed the vacancy on the NORA Board which must be filled by an elected Township official. VIII. NEW BUSINESS None. IX. REPORTS AND CORESPONDENCE a. Committee Reports b. Manager′s Report i. Manager Cargo noted that Ottawa County will host a Legislative Forum on Friday, May 10, 2024, from 8:30 a.m. – 10:00 a.m. in the Main Conference Room at the Ottawa County Fillmore Street Complex. c. Other X. PUBLIC COMMENTS 1. Ottawa County Water Resources Commissioner Joe Bush noted that the Grand Oaks #3 drain project would go to bid at the end of May and would begin construction in July with a tentative completion by the end of October. XI. ADJOURNMENT Motion by Trustee Wagenmaker and seconded by Trustee Behm to adjourn the meeting at 7:31 p.m. Which motion carried. Respectfully Submitted, William Kieft III Grand Haven Charter Township Temporary Clerk Mark Reenders Grand Haven Charter Township Supervisor -2-  GRAND HAVEN CHARTER TOWNSHIP BOARD GRAND HAVEN CHARTER TOWNSHIP PLANNING COMMISSION MONDAY, APRIL 29, 2024 REGULAR MEETING I. CALL TO ORDER Supervisor Reenders called the special joint meeting of the Grand Haven Charter Township Board and Planning Commission to order at 7:00 p.m. II. PLEDGE TO THE FLAG III. ROLL CALL Board members present: Wagenmaker, Larsen, Meeusen, Kieft, Behm, and M. Reenders Board members absent: Planning Commission members present: Frifeldt, Lemkuil, Mesler, D. Reenders, Taylor, Cousins, and Wilson Planning Commission members absent: Hesselsweet Also present was Manager Cargo, Assistant Manager Sherwood, Community Development Director Thibault, Associate Planner Chaphalkar, and Attorney Redick IV. APPROVAL OF MEETING AGENDA Motion Trustee Wagenmaker and seconded by Clerk Larsen to approve the meeting agenda. Which motion carried. V. DISCUSSION ITEMS 1. The Board and Planning Commission members discussed infill development within the Northeast quadrant of the Township. Specifically, amending the PUD portion of the Zoning Ordinance to eliminate the requirement for sanitary sewer and allowing septic systems approved by the Ottawa County Health Department. (This would impact two vacant parcels – i.e., the so-called “Reenders blueberry field” that the Planning Commission has recommended be restricted to the underlying zoning district′s base density, which is about 100 units, and the so-called David Bos development along the Grand River.) After discussion, the members instructed staff to proceed with the proposed amendment, maintaining all other PUD requirements but allowing septic systems for PUDs in the Northeast quadrant because there is not existing municipal sewer infrastructure within the area. 2. The Board and Planning Commission members discussed the US-31 Overlay District and instructed staff to proceed with the amendments as proposed by Community Development Director Thibault that eliminates some conflicting language and provides greater discretion to the Planning Commission members. -1-  3. The Board and Planning Commission members discussed “clubs” in industrial zones. Attorney Redick noted that allowing “assembly” within industrial zones would – pursuant to RLUIPA, i.e., the Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act – if the Township allows assembly in industrial areas for “clubs,” the Township would also be required to allow assembly in industrial areas for churches and other religious institutions. No action was taken. 4. The Board and Planning Commission members discussed chickens in residential areas and instructed staff to draft an ordinance that would allow chickens as proposed but would, as a condition of approval, require a review of subdivision bylaws (or similar provisions) to ensure that prohibitions in the residential development did not prohibit “livestock’. 5. The Board and Planning Commission members discussed cell towers and instructed staff to proceed with the proposed amendment, as presented. 6. The Board and Planning Commission members discussed signage in residential zoned properties and instructed staff to proceed with the proposed amendments, as presented. 7. The Board and Planning Commission members discussed mono-sloped roofs and instructed staff to proceed with the proposed amendments, as presented. 8. The Board and Planning Commission members discussed architectural requirements on industrial additions and instructed staff to proceed with the proposed amendments, as presented. 9. The Board and Planning Commission members discussed landscaping requirements in parking lots and instructed staff to proceed with the proposed amendments, as presented. VI. PUBLIC COMMENTS Trustee Wagenmaker opined that the Private Road Ordinance was too strict and that it should be modified to allow private roads to be constructed without requiring water, sewer, or the current road standards. VII. ADJOURNMENT Motion by Clerk Larsen and seconded by Trustee Behm to adjourn the meeting at 8:54 p.m. Which motion carried. Respectfully Submitted, Laurie Larsen Grand Haven Charter Township Clerk -2- Mark Reenders Grand Haven Charter Township Supervisor -3- SUPERINTENDENT'S MEMO DATE: May 9, 2024 TO: Township Board FROM: Cargo SUBJECT: Appointment of Trustee Behm to the NORA Board and the Township Parks and Recreation Committee As you are aware, pursuant to Section 2.11 of the Township′s Administrative Policies and Procedures Manual, the Township Supervisor has broad authority to appoint members to a variety of Committees, Boards, and Commissions. With the resignation of former Trustee Redick, Supervisor Reenders will be appointing Trustee Behm to the North Ottawa Recreation Authority (NORA) Board for a seven-month term ending December 31, 2024, and a seven-month term to the Township Parks and Recreation Committee ending December 31, 2024. I have not included the normal background material since everyone is familiar with Trustee Behm. To approve these appointments, the following motion can be offered: Move to appoint Howard Behm to the North Ottawa Recreation Authority Board and to the Township Parks and Recreation for a seven-month term ending December 31, 2024. If you have any questions or comments, please contact Supervisor Reenders prior to the Board meeting. 1 Manager’s Memo DATE: May 8, 2024 TO: Township Board FROM: Bill RE: 2024 – DDA Watermain Project As you may recall, the DDA budget had $1.875 million allocated to bore and jack a watermain across US-31 and the railroad at Buchanan Street. The bid opening for this project was on Tuesday, May 7th and three (3) firms offered bids on the project. (See below.) The low bid was from Jackson-Merkey Contractors at a contract price of about $1.382 million – which is about $493k (or about 26%) under↓ budget. Jackson-Merkey is a well-established contractor in West Michigan and the Township has worked with this firm on numerous open-cut construction projects. The project would be stating in late summer and early fall – but would be dependent upon the availability of the subcontractor performing the bore and jack work under the highway. The Township′s Engineer (i.e., Kevin Kieft) is recommending that the project be awarded to Jackson-Merkey. To approve the low bid and proceed with the project, the following motion can be offered: Move to approve the low bid of $1,381,718.50 from Jackson-Merkey Contractors for the DDA Bore and Jack Watermain Project under US-31 at Buchanan Street and authorize Superintendent Cargo to execute the necessary contract documents. If you have any questions or comments, please contact Cargo. Page 1 Administrative Memo DATE: May 9, 2024 TO: Township Board FROM: Chief Schrader RE: Fire Station Exhaust System Purchase The station exhaust removal system equipment ensures that vehicle exhaust and contaminates from fire gear get filtered properly. This equipment provides a safe and healthy atmosphere for our staff to work in and follows NFPA 1500 and OSHA standards. Fire contaminates and diesel exhaust are considered occupational carcinogens by the National Institute of Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH). Over the last six (6) months, staff and the building team have evaluated and looked at several different systems. Based on this evaluation, staff is recommending that we purchase the MAGNEGRIP AirHAWK 3000EL-ECM system. This system will include eleven separate units that are suspended throughout the apparatus bay ceiling. This decision was made for the following reasons: ➢ This system continuously filters the air with a variable speed motor. This continuous filtering provides a healthier environment for our staff. ➢ This system allows staff to park apparatus in the station using multiple configurations. ➢ The system will work with all vehicles and does not require apparatus to be retrofitted or connected to hoses. ➢ The pricing, that we have received, is $6,900 below↓ budgeted estimates. If the Board agrees to proceed and authorize the purchase of the AirHAWK station exhaust removal system, the following motion could be offered: Motion to authorize the purchase of the AirHAWK 3000EL- ECM station exhaust removal system of an amount not to exceed $95,598 payable from the Fire Station Construction Fund. Please contact me if you have any questions or concerns. Page 1 Administrative Memo DATE: May 6, 2024 TO: Township Board FROM: Karen Sherwood and Bill Cargo RE: Board Trustee Applicants As previously noted, if the Township Board does not appoint a replacement for the Trustee Redick by May 16th, the Ottawa County Clerk will be required to schedule a Special Election to fill this Board vacancy. Further, the Special Election would occur concurrent with the November 5th General Election – and, as noted by the State Bureau of Elections, the individual elected would serve from November 14th until November 20th – essentially a six-day term. Specifically, under MCL 168.370, the timing of the Special Election would be as follows:  The 45-day deadline for the Board to appoint would be May 16th.  If the Board failed to appoint, the County Clerk would call a special election to fill the vacancy within 5 days, which would be May 21st.  Within 15 days of May 21st, the political parties would each name a candidate, which would be June 5th.  Because this is an election year, the special election would have to occur not less than 70 days after the June 5th deadline, which would be August 14th (i.e., after the August primary had already occurred). That would mean that the Special Election could not occur until the November 5th General Election. That said, Assistant Manager Sherwood notes that five (5) Township residents have applied for this six-month Board of Trustee vacancy. These individuals are listed alphabetically order in the table below: Name Notes  MA of Science – Historic Preservation  BA of Science – History  Executive Director – Midwest Miniatures Museum Kelly Beattie  Manager of Grants and Foundation Relations – Grand Rapids Symphony 15696 Comstock  Annual Fund and Stewardship Manager – Grand Rapids Symphony  City Clerk – City of Grand Haven  Executive Director – The Fort Meigs Association  Projects, Boards and Commissions Coordinator – City of Ann Arbor 1   Human Resources Director – Harbor Transit  Human Resources Director – City of Avondale  Human Resources Director/ Assistant Manager – Grand Haven Charter Township Andrea Dumbrell  Assistant Human Resources Director – Ottawa County 12918 Woodrush  Business Manager/Human Resources Manager – Muskegon Catholic Schools  Business Manager/Human Resources Director – West Michigan Academy of Arts and Academics  BA of Science – Nursing  BA of Science in Biology Frank Durante  Vascular Access Specialist – Mercy Health 14837 Pine Ridge  RN Emergency Department – Mercy Health  Laboratory Manager – Mercey Health  Trustee – Village of Fruitport  State Senator – Michigan  State Representative – Michigan Arlan Meekhof  Trustee & Supervisor – Olive Township 12596 Retreat  Director of Operations – Hudson Lock MWSC  Supervisor of Production – Herman Miller  BA of Business Administration Ryan Tenbrink  Collegiate Athlete 14849 Piper Lane,  Auditor – SpendMend Apt. 310  Warehouse Manager – HME Inc.  Inventory Worker – HME Inc. The Township Board has three (3) basic options: 1. Determine that the position will remain vacant and that the Ottawa County Clerk will schedule a “Special Election.” The candidates for this special election will be decided by the political parties. 2. Select one of the aforementioned applicants at the May 13th Board meeting. 3. Schedule a special meeting (e.g., on Wednesday May 15th) to interview all the candidates (or a select few) and chose one of the candidates based upon the interviews. If you have any questions or concerns, please contact Sherwood or Cargo at your convenience. 2  1 Page: Printed: 05/09/2024 Building Permit Report - Monthly Estimated Cost Permit Fee ACCESSORY BUILDING P24BU0115 BESSINGER THOMAS A-JEAN MARIE 16285 LAKE MICHIGAN DR $30,600 $318.01 $30,600 $318.01 Total Permits For Type: 1 ALTERATIONS P24BU0112 CLEMENT KEITH A-DIANE K 13039 152ND AVE $5,000 $89.25 P24BU0116 KULANGARA ABRAHAM 16259 GRAND POINT CT $30,178 $315.12 P24BU0128 CHRISTIANSEN PAUL-TAMMY 13491 FOREST PARK DR $15,000 $211.15 $50,178 $615.52 Total Permits For Type: 3 APARTMENT UNIT LAKESHORE FLATS LLC P24BU-FLATS051 16909 GORDON PATH 103-BLDG I $0 $0.00 LAKESHORE FLATS LLC P24BU-FLATS052 16909 GORDON PATH 104-BLDG I $0 $0.00 LAKESHORE FLATS LLC P24BU-FLATS053 16909 GORDON PATH 105-BLDG I $0 $0.00 LAKESHORE FLATS LLC P24BU-FLATS054 16909 GORDON PATH 106-BLDG I $0 $0.00 LAKESHORE FLATS LLC P24BU-FLATS055 16909 GORDON PATH 107-BLDG I $0 $0.00 LAKESHORE FLATS LLC P24BU-FLATS056 16909 GORDON PATH 108-BLDG I $0 $0.00 LAKESHORE FLATS LLC P24BU-FLATS057 16909 GORDON PATH 109-BLDG I $0 $0.00 LAKESHORE FLATS LLC P24BU-FLATS058 16909 GORDON PATH 110-BLDG I $0 $0.00 LAKESHORE FLATS LLC P24BU-FLATS059 16909 GORDON PATH 111-BLDG I $0 $0.00 LAKESHORE FLATS LLC P24BU-FLATS060 16909 GORDON PATH 112-BLDG I $0 $0.00 LAKESHORE FLATS LLC P24BU-FLATS061 16909 GORDON PATH 113-BLDG I $0 $0.00 LAKESHORE FLATS LLC P24BU-FLATS062 16909 GORDON PATH 114-BLDG I $0 $0.00 LAKESHORE FLATS LLC P24BU-FLATS063 16909 GORDON PATH 115-BLDG I $0 $0.00 LAKESHORE FLATS LLC P24BU-FLATS064 16909 GORDON PATH 116-BLDG I $0 $0.00 LAKESHORE FLATS LLC P24BU-FLATS065 16909 GORDON PATH 117-BLDG I $0 $0.00 LAKESHORE FLATS LLC P24BU-FLATS066 16909 GORDON PATH 118-BLDG I $0 $0.00 LAKESHORE FLATS LLC P24BU-FLATS067 16909 GORDON PATH 201-BLDG I $0 $0.00 LAKESHORE FLATS LLC P24BU-FLATS068 16909 GORDON PATH 202-BLDG I $0 $0.00 LAKESHORE FLATS LLC P24BU-FLATS069 16909 GORDON PATH 203-BLDG I $0 $0.00 LAKESHORE FLATS LLC P24BU-FLATS070 16909 GORDON PATH 204-BLDG I $0 $0.00 LAKESHORE FLATS LLC P24BU-FLATS071 16909 GORDON PATH 205-BLDG I $0 $0.00 LAKESHORE FLATS LLC P24BU-FLATS072 16909 GORDON PATH 206-BLDG I $0 $0.00 LAKESHORE FLATS LLC P24BU-FLATS073 16909 GORDON PATH 207-BLDG I $0 $0.00 LAKESHORE FLATS LLC P24BU-FLATS074 16909 GORDON PATH 208-BLDG I $0 $0.00 LAKESHORE FLATS LLC P24BU-FLATS075 16909 GORDON PATH 209-BLDG I $0 $0.00 LAKESHORE FLATS LLC P24BU-FLATS076 16909 GORDON PATH 210-BLDG I $0 $0.00 LAKESHORE FLATS LLC P24BU-FLATS077 16909 GORDON PATH 211-BLDG I $0 $0.00 LAKESHORE FLATS LLC P24BU-FLATS078 16909 GORDON PATH 212-BLDG I $0 $0.00  2 Page: Printed: 05/09/2024 Building Permit Report - Monthly Estimated Cost Permit Fee LAKESHORE FLATS LLC P24BU-FLATS079 16909 GORDON PATH 213-BLDG I $0 $0.00 LAKESHORE FLATS LLC P24BU-FLATS080 16909 GORDON PATH 214-BLDG I $0 $0.00 LAKESHORE FLATS LLC P24BU-FLATS081 16909 GORDON PATH 215-BLDG I $0 $0.00 LAKESHORE FLATS LLC P24BU-FLATS082 16909 GORDON PATH 216-BLDG I $0 $0.00 LAKESHORE FLATS LLC P24BU-FLATS083 16909 GORDON PATH 217-BLDG I $0 $0.00 LAKESHORE FLATS LLC P24BU-FLATS084 16909 GORDON PATH 218-BLDG I $0 $0.00 LAKESHORE FLATS LLC P24BU-FLATS085 16909 GORDON PATH 301-BLDG I $0 $0.00 LAKESHORE FLATS LLC P24BU-FLATS086 16909 GORDON PATH 302-BLDG I $0 $0.00 LAKESHORE FLATS LLC P24BU-FLATS087 16909 GORDON PATH 303-BLDG I $0 $0.00 LAKESHORE FLATS LLC P24BU-FLATS088 16909 GORDON PATH 304-BLDG I $0 $0.00 LAKESHORE FLATS LLC P24BU-FLATS089 16909 GORDON PATH 305-BLDG I $0 $0.00 LAKESHORE FLATS LLC P24BU-FLATS090 16909 GORDON PATH 306-BLDG I $0 $0.00 LAKESHORE FLATS LLC P24BU-FLATS091 16909 GORDON PATH 307-BLDG I $0 $0.00 LAKESHORE FLATS LLC P24BU-FLATS092 16909 GORDON PATH 308-BLDG I $0 $0.00 LAKESHORE FLATS LLC P24BU-FLATS093 16909 GORDON PATH 309-BLDG I $0 $0.00 LAKESHORE FLATS LLC P24BU-FLATS094 16909 GORDON PATH 310-BLDG I $0 $0.00 LAKESHORE FLATS LLC P24BU-FLATS095 16909 GORDON PATH 311-BLDG I $0 $0.00 LAKESHORE FLATS LLC P24BU-FLATS096 16909 GORDON PATH 312-BLDG I $0 $0.00 LAKESHORE FLATS LLC P24BU-FLATS097 16909 GORDON PATH 313-BLDG I $0 $0.00 LAKESHORE FLATS LLC P24BU-FLATS098 16909 GORDON PATH 314-BLDG I $0 $0.00 LAKESHORE FLATS LLC P24BU-FLATS099 16909 GORDON PATH 315-BLDG I $0 $0.00 LAKESHORE FLATS LLC P24BU-FLATS100 16909 GORDON PATH 316-BLDG I $0 $0.00 LAKESHORE FLATS LLC P24BU-FLATS101 16909 GORDON PATH 317-BLDG I $0 $0.00 LAKESHORE FLATS LLC P24BU-FLATS102 16909 GORDON PATH 318-BLDG I $0 $0.00 LAKESHORE FLATS LLC P24BU-FLATS103 16831 GORDON PATH 101-BLDG J $0 $0.00 LAKESHORE FLATS LLC P24BU-FLATS104 16831 GORDON PATH 102-BLDG J $0 $0.00 LAKESHORE FLATS LLC P24BU-FLATS105 16831 GORDON PATH 201-BLDG J $0 $0.00 LAKESHORE FLATS LLC P24BU-FLATS106 16831 GORDON PATH 202-BLDG J $0 $0.00 LAKESHORE FLATS LLC P24BU-FLATS107 16831 GORDON PATH 301-BLDG J $0 $0.00 LAKESHORE FLATS LLC P24BU-FLATS108 16831 GORDON PATH 302-BLDG J $0 $0.00 LAKESHORE FLATS LLC P24BU-FLATS109 16833 GORDON PATH 103-BLDG J $0 $0.00 LAKESHORE FLATS LLC P24BU-FLATS110 16833 GORDON PATH 104-BLGJ J $0 $0.00 LAKESHORE FLATS LLC P24BU-FLATS111 16833 GORDON PATH 203-BLDG J $0 $0.00 LAKESHORE FLATS LLC P24BU-FLATS112 16833 GORDON PATH 204-BLDG J $0 $0.00 LAKESHORE FLATS LLC P24BU-FLATS113 16833 GORDON PATH 303-BLDG J $0 $0.00 LAKESHORE FLATS LLC P24BU-FLATS114 16833 GORDON PATH 304-BLDG J $0 $0.00 LAKESHORE FLATS LLC P24BU-FLATS115 16835 GORDON PATH 105-BLDG J $0 $0.00 LAKESHORE FLATS LLC P24BU-FLATS116 16835 GORDON PATH 106-BLDG J $0 $0.00 LAKESHORE FLATS LLC P24BU-FLATS117 16835 GORDON PATH 205-BLDG J $0 $0.00  3 Page: Printed: 05/09/2024 Building Permit Report - Monthly Estimated Cost Permit Fee LAKESHORE FLATS LLC P24BU-FLATS118 16835 GORDON PATH 206-BLDG J $0 $0.00 LAKESHORE FLATS LLC P24BU-FLATS119 16835 GORDON PATH 305-BLDG J $0 $0.00 LAKESHORE FLATS LLC P24BU-FLATS120 16835 GORDON PATH 306-BLDG J $0 $0.00 LAKESHORE FLATS LLC P24BU-FLATS121 16837 GORDON PATH 107-BLDG J $0 $0.00 LAKESHORE FLATS LLC P24BU-FLATS122 16837 GORDON PATH 108-BLDG J $0 $0.00 LAKESHORE FLATS LLC P24BU-FLATS123 16837 GORDON PATH 207-BLDG J $0 $0.00 LAKESHORE FLATS LLC P24BU-FLATS124 16837 GORDON PATH 208-BLDG J $0 $0.00 LAKESHORE FLATS LLC P24BU-FLATS125 16837 GORDON PATH 307-BLDG J $0 $0.00 LAKESHORE FLATS LLC P24BU-FLATS126 16837 GORDON PATH 308-BLDG J $0 $0.00 $0 $0.00 Total Permits For Type: 76 BASEMENT FINISH P24BU0108 DODD MARK-SANDRA J 14855 CANARY DR $12,891 $196.70 P24BU0123 CODY JAMES-SHAWN 12943 BOULDERWAY TR $73,500 $611.88 P24BU0125 HAMLIN PATRICK-RENAY TRUST 12745 RIVERTON RD $57,200 $500.22 P24BU0129 GONNELLA JUSTIN-MACARENA 15846 ROBBINS RD $30,000 $313.90 P24BU0140 DONNER THERESA-JOHN 15351 FERRIS ST $17,431 $227.80 $191,022 $1,850.50 Total Permits For Type: 5 COMMERCIAL BUILDING P24BU0150 GRAND HAVEN CHARTER TOWNSHIP 13250 168TH AVE $13,000,000 $0.00 $13,000,000 $0.00 Total Permits For Type: 1 DECK P24BU0026 WESTRA GREGORY 17318 TIMBER DUNE DR $136,000 $982.40 P24BU0095 ALLEN ANNETTE S 15718 GRAND POINT DR $45,000 $416.65 P24BU0109 17580 DUNESIDE DR LLC 17580 DUNESIDE DR $3,162 $75.00 P24BU0113 HAMPTON KRISTI-GREGORY 13562 RAVINE VIEW DR $24,000 $272.80 P24BU0120 BAKER SHIRLEY A TRUST 17863 HIDDEN ACRES LN $8,965 $152.25 P24BU0127 RIVER HAVEN OPERATING COMPANY LLC 13863 PINEWOOD DR $965 $75.00 P24BU0135 SPENGLER PAUL 13034 ACACIA DR $16,708 $322.85 P24BU0137 GOODMAN DONNA J TRUST 17447 LAKE MICHIGAN DR $4,158 $89.25 P24BU0144 PIERSMA RUTH ANNE TRUST 11785 GARNSEY AVE $55,000 $485.15 P24BU0145 CLEMENT KEITH A-DIANE K 13039 152ND AVE $12,994 $197.41 P24BU0160 INNES CHRISTOPHER J 13234 MULBERRY CT $4,000 $75.00 $310,952 $3,143.76 Total Permits For Type: 11 DEMOLITION P24DE0005 ROBERTS KEVIN-KRISTI 15001 PINE RIDGE RD $0 $50.00  4 Page: Printed: 05/09/2024 Building Permit Report - Monthly Estimated Cost Permit Fee $0 $50.00 Total Permits For Type: 1 ELECTRICAL P24EL0087 LAKESHORE FLATS LLC 16941 GORDON PATH BLDG H GAR $0 $187.00 P24EL0088 LAKESHORE FLATS LLC 16941 GORDON PATH BLDG H GAR $0 $187.00 P24EL0098 DODD MARK-SANDRA J 14855 CANARY DR $0 $166.00 P24EL0099 MCDONALD MICHAEL-CARON 10960 LAKESHORE DR $0 $160.00 P24EL0100 RIVER HAVEN OPERATING COMPANY LLC 13591 WINDING CREEK DR $0 $80.00 P24EL0101 RIVER HAVEN OPERATING COMPANY LLC 13765 CLEARWATER LANE $0 $80.00 P24EL0102 RIVER HAVEN OPERATING COMPANY LLC 13527 SPRINGBROOK DR $0 $80.00 P24EL0103 HAMLIN PATRICK-RENAY TRUST 12745 RIVERTON RD $0 $166.00 P24EL0104 GONNELLA JUSTIN-MACARENA 15846 ROBBINS RD $0 $196.00 P24EL0105 SHAPE CORP 14600 172ND AVE $0 $125.00 P24EL0106 HATT DIANE 13484 HIDDEN CREEK CT $0 $186.00 P24EL0107 CHRISTIANSEN PAUL-TAMMY 13491 FOREST PARK DR $0 $155.00 P24EL0108 WELLARD SCOTT-ANN 10377 MESIC DR $0 $165.00 P24EL0109 ROBERTS KEVIN-KRISTI 15001 PINE RIDGE RD $0 $432.00 P24EL0110 RUIZ-VILLANUEVA, ELENA 14664 154TH AVE $0 $85.00 P24EL0111 LAKESHORE GARDENS APARTMENTS LLC 17003 LAKESHORE FLATS DR CLUBHOUSE $0 $90.00 P24EL0112 COOK MICHAEL 16184 MERCURY DR $0 $85.00 P24EL0113 RAUSCHERT STEPHEN-JEANNA 12977 152ND AVE $0 $166.00 P24EL0114 KEUR ALLAN-STEPHANIE 14000 155TH AVE $0 $85.00 P24EL0115 COYNE ROBERT F JR-ANNE M 15335 VINTAGE AVE $0 $181.00 P24EL0117 THORNAPPLE PINES 13111 LAKESHORE DR $0 $489.00 P24EL0118 VANDERVEEN JEFFREY D-ANNE MARIE 15234 161ST AVE $0 $160.00 P24EL0119 CODY JAMES-SHAWN 12943 BOULDERWAY TR $0 $166.00 P24EL0120 LINCOLN STREET HOLDINGS 12706 RIVERTON RD $0 $358.00 P24EL0121 INTERRA HOMES LLC 12578 MANCHESTER DR $0 $353.00 P24EL0122 44TH STREET INVESTORS LLC 12366 HAWLEY DR PVT $0 $353.00 P24EL0123 INTERRA HOMES 15680 NORWALK RD $0 $358.00 P24EL0124 44TH STREET INVESTORS LLC 12364 HAWLEY DR PVT $0 $353.00 P24EL0125 EASTBROOK HOMES INC 14694 PINE DEW DRIVE $0 $367.00 P24EL0126 DAHLMAN SARAH E 15613 GROESBECK ST $0 $170.00 $0 $6,184.00 Total Permits For Type: 30 FENCE P20ZL0101 FREEL BRANDON D 16831 WATERSEDGE DR $3,980 $40.00 P23ZL0098 ZONDERVAN JON-KENDRA 13024 WOODRUSH CT $4,000 $40.00 P24ZL0020 OTIS BARBARA A 15214 ARBORWOOD DR $5,000 $40.00  5 Page: Printed: 05/09/2024 Building Permit Report - Monthly Estimated Cost Permit Fee P24ZL0024 WILLIAMS SHYRA-CHRIS 13245 WILLOWVALE DR $100 $40.00 P24ZL0025 BODINE ROBERT 15752 CHARLES CT $4,465 $40.00 P24ZL0032 JOHNSON BRUCE L-JUDITH L 15020 COLEMAN AVE $2,722 $40.00 P24ZL0033 GONNELLA JUSTIN-MACARENA 15846 ROBBINS RD $5,300 $40.00 $25,567 $280.00 Total Permits For Type: 7 HOME BASED BUSINESS (MINOR) P24HBB002 UNIVERSAL PROPERTIES PLA LLC 16824 PIPER LAKES CIR 208-BLDG 1 $0 $25.00 $0 $25.00 Total Permits For Type: 1 MECHANICAL P23ME0138 JACOBSON NELSON C-LANA 13467 WINDCREST LN $0 $135.00 P23ME0306 RIVER HAVEN OPERATING COMPANY LLC 14488 WINTERGREEN DR $0 $110.00 P23ME0340 BODINE MATT 15391 MERCURY DR $0 $110.00 P24ME0098 RIVER HAVEN OPERATING COMPANY LLC 13538 SPRINGBROOK DR $0 $105.00 P24ME0105 DODD MARK-SANDRA J 14855 CANARY DR $0 $105.00 P24ME0109 MERRIMAN BRIAN-MARIA 15351 HOFMA DR $0 $135.00 P24ME0110 ALLEN ANNETTE S 15718 GRAND POINT DR $0 $80.00 P24ME0111 RAUSCHERT STEPHEN-JEANNA 12977 152ND AVE $0 $80.00 P24ME0112 OTTAWA COUNTY 9791 LAKESHORE DR $0 $200.00 P24ME0113 VANDER HEIDE CHERISE D TRUST 11363 LAKESHORE DR $0 $370.00 P24ME0114 RIVER HAVEN OPERATING COMPANY LLC 13613 WINDING CREEK DR $0 $80.00 P24ME0115 RYAN SUSAN P TRUST 17237 BEACH RIDGE WY PVT $0 $140.00 P24ME0116 LINCOLN STREET HOLDINGS 12706 RIVERTON RD $0 $185.00 P24ME0117 PORATH FAMILY PROTECTION TRUST 13530 RAVINE VIEW DR $0 $140.00 P24ME0118 SKINNER JEFFERY T-LINDA M 15332 CANARY DR $0 $105.00 P24ME0119 MURRAY ELIZABETH C TRUST 10777 LAKESHORE DR $0 $105.00 P24ME0120 HARLAN DEAN J TRUST 15249 GRAND OAK RD $0 $105.00 P24ME0121 WISNER DONALD-SHARON TRUST 11629 GARNSEY AVE $0 $105.00 P24ME0122 SACKS JAMES 13499 HIDDEN CREEK DR $0 $110.00 P24ME0123 REENDERS KYLE L-ANDREA M 13752 168TH AVE $0 $80.00 P24ME0124 HORNBY KURT-CHRISTINE 14049 155TH AVE $0 $105.00 P24ME0125 RIVER HAVEN OPERATING COMPANY LLC 13527 SPRINGBROOK DR $0 $105.00 P24ME0126 RIVER HAVEN OPERATING COMPANY LLC 13765 CLEARWATER LANE $0 $105.00 P24ME0127 RIVER HAVEN OPERATING COMPANY LLC 13591 WINDING CREEK DR $0 $105.00 P24ME0128 HARVEST BIBLE CHAPEL SPRING LAKE 12900 US-31 $0 $555.00 P24ME0129 WELLARD SCOTT-ANN 10377 MESIC DR $0 $215.00 P24ME0130 GONNELLA JUSTIN-MACARENA 15846 ROBBINS RD $0 $110.00 P24ME0131 HAMLIN PATRICK-RENAY TRUST 12745 RIVERTON RD $0 $80.00  6 Page: Printed: 05/09/2024 Building Permit Report - Monthly Estimated Cost Permit Fee P24ME0132 ROSEMA BRIAN L-LORI A 13498 GREENBRIAR DR $0 $105.00 P24ME0133 CASTRO CESAR-MARY E LASS 13486 LAKESHORE DR $0 $80.00 P24ME0134 MCDONALD MICHAEL-CARON 10960 LAKESHORE DR $0 $80.00 P24ME0135 CODY JAMES-SHAWN 12943 BOULDERWAY TR $0 $175.00 P24ME0136 HAGER JOHN-TAMMIE 12831 152ND AVE $0 $80.00 P24ME0137 PIPPEL FAMILY TRUST 15445 PINE ST $0 $105.00 P24ME0138 BAILEY MICHAEL J-GAIL M 13048 BOULDERWAY TR $0 $330.00 P24ME0139 DONESELAR MARK-DIANE 16346 MERCURY DR $0 $105.00 P24ME0140 CROSSROADS ACRES LLC 14422 WINANS ST $0 $170.00 P24ME0141 HILGEMAN REBECCA 15210 GRAND OAK RD $0 $170.00 P24ME0142 MAYSE GARY J-YVONNE J 15375 GRAND OAK RD $0 $135.00 P24ME0143 DAHLMAN SARAH E 15613 GROESBECK ST $0 $110.00 P24ME0144 THERASSE PATRICIA 15104 WILLOWWOOD CT $0 $110.00 $0 $5,720.00 Total Permits For Type: 41 MISCELLANEOUS P24MISC001 HARVEST BIBLE CHAPEL SPRING LAKE 12900 US-31 $0 $200.00 $0 $200.00 Total Permits For Type: 1 PLUMBING P24PL0044 DODD MARK-SANDRA J 14855 CANARY DR $0 $165.00 P24PL0045 SCHRADER SHAWN L-KIMBERLY M TRUST13522 WHISPERING PINE TR PVT $0 $155.00 P24PL0046 HAMLIN PATRICK-RENAY TRUST 12745 RIVERTON RD $0 $175.00 P24PL0047 SIGNATURE LAND DEVELOPMENT CO 14700 WINDWAY DRIVE $0 $309.00 P24PL0048 GTDA2 LLC 16750 LINCOLN ST $0 $355.00 P24PL0049 EASTBROOK HOMES INC 14694 PINE DEW DRIVE $0 $309.00 P24PL0050 GONNELLA JUSTIN-MACARENA 15846 ROBBINS RD $0 $205.00 P24PL0051 CHRISTIANSEN PAUL-TAMMY 13491 FOREST PARK DR $0 $165.00 P24PL0052 TEG TIMBERVIEW 1 LLC 17164 DUNE VIEW DR 306-BLDG A $0 $85.00 P24PL0053 INTERRA HOMES 15680 NORWALK RD $0 $330.00 $0 $2,253.00 Total Permits For Type: 10 POOL/SPA/HOT TUB P24BU0111 17580 DUNESIDE DR LLC 17580 DUNESIDE DR $3,500 $75.00 P24BU0133 WESTGATE RICHARD S-RHONDA J 14723 PINE DEW DRIVE $5,000 $89.25 $8,500 $164.25 Total Permits For Type: 2 REMOVAL AND PROCESSING OF NATURAL RESOURCES P23SLU0004 THIRTY-ONE PROPERTIES INC US-31 $0 $1,500.00  7 Page: Printed: 05/09/2024 Building Permit Report - Monthly Estimated Cost Permit Fee $0 $1,500.00 Total Permits For Type: 1 REPLACEMENT WINDOWS/DOORS P24BU0103 SNIDER JESSE 15258 MERCURY DR $10,719 $183.75 P24BU0104 KALLIO FAMILY PROTECTION TRUST 13211 160TH AVE $36,234 $356.60 P24BU0121 ADAMS JUDITH 15375 WINCHESTER CIR PVT $5,100 $105.00 P24BU0122 OCHOA PROPERTIES LLC 15160 GROESBECK ST 15162 $3,800 $75.00 P24BU0124 PAYNE MICHAEL 13935 155TH AVE $3,672 $75.00 P24BU0130 KATT RICHARD H 15889 ROBBINS RD 15893 $7,280 $136.50 P24BU0131 KATT RICHARD H 15879 ROBBINS RD 15875 $7,260 $136.50 $74,065 $1,068.35 Total Permits For Type: 7 RE-ROOFING P24BU0110 LAUTENSCHLAEGER SCOTT 15397 MEADOWLARK DR $12,847 $100.00 P24BU0117 RODGERS KATHLEEN 15762 KITCHEL LN $25,661 $100.00 P24BU0138 ZHENG CHENXI-LIN LI 15258 STEEPLECHASE CT PVT $13,647 $100.00 P24BU0139 CARMEAN CARL D II-KRISTI A 16069 DELTA VIEW DR $15,571 $100.00 P24BU0143 LEINONEN CAROL A 13220 MULBERRY CT $11,838 $100.00 P24BU0148 MCMAHON JAMES P-DEBRA A 13785 LAKE SEDGE DR $16,305 $100.00 P24BU0149 TATER PAUL J-SUSAN M 14860 RIVERSIDE TR $22,000 $100.00 P24BU0151 RIVER HAVEN OPERATING COMPANY LLC 14445 SILVERBROOK DR $5,000 $100.00 P24BU0152 LONG DARREN M 16230 GRAND POINT CT $27,540 $100.00 P24BU0153 PETERS JOHN-KAREN 13732 152ND AVE $31,158 $100.00 P24BU0155 CORWIN CORT-JESSICA 14235 TERRY TRAILS $12,000 $100.00 P24BU0156 CHRISTENSEN DEREK L-ANGELA R 13400 HIDDEN CREEK DR $0 $100.00 P24BU0157 BENES NANCY ET AL 15636 GROESBECK ST $18,428 $100.00 P24BU0161 EILERS JEROME P-JOY TAYLOR 16648 PINE DUNES CT $15,930 $100.00 P24BU0162 BIRKBECK BENJAMIN-GRETCHEN 11097 LAKESHORE DR $20,388 $100.00 P24BU0163 KRUPINSKI JEFFREY 13637 STREAMSIDE CT $25,343 $100.00 $273,656 $1,600.00 Total Permits For Type: 16 RE-SIDING P24BU0118 BUSSELL WILLIAM H-CHRISTINE M 11936 GARNSEY AVE $15,000 $100.00 P24BU0119 PELLEGROM ASA 15952 GROESBECK ST $3,500 $50.00 P24BU0146 NIEMIEC BRUCE J-VONNA M TRUST 17222 BUCHANAN ST $16,903 $100.00 P24BU0154 MCCALEB JOHN-GERARDINA 12014 160TH AVE $5,000 $100.00 $40,403 $350.00 Total Permits For Type: 4 RETAINING WALL  8 Page: Printed: 05/09/2024 Building Permit Report - Monthly Estimated Cost Permit Fee P24ZL0028 ANYS DAVID M-ANN 15141 LAKE AVE $30,000 $75.00 $30,000 $75.00 Total Permits For Type: 1 SHED (<200 SQFT) P24ZL0016 BROWN IRENE 16330 MERCURY DR $200 $40.00 P24ZL0018 LOWE TRUST 9986 LAKESHORE DR $4,500 $40.00 P24ZL0021 PARKER DENNIS-CAROL 13469 GREENLEAF LN $3,700 $40.00 P24ZL0026 THELAN LIFE ESTATE 15273 NICKOLAS DR $5,500 $40.00 P24ZL0027 CROSS JEFF-SARAH 12378 168TH AVE $2,500 $40.00 P24ZL0029 CARTER TIGHE-ASHLEIGH 15311 MILLHOUSE CT $3,840 $40.00 P24ZL0031 FIGURSKI KENNETH 15900 BRUCKER ST $1,000 $40.00 $21,240 $280.00 Total Permits For Type: 7 SINGLE FAMILY DWELLING P24BU0114 LINCOLN STREET HOLDINGS 12540 MANCHESTER DR $455,548 $2,660.03 P24BU0132 INTERRA HOMES 15680 NORWALK RD $376,383 $2,244.41 P24BU0136 LINCOLN STREET HOLDINGS 12343 HAWLEY DR PVT $371,619 $2,219.40 P24BU0141 ROEBUCK ALAN D 14780 LAKESHORE DR $560,419 $3,162.26 P24BU0142 LINCOLN STREET HOLDINGS 12341 HAWLEY DR PVT $373,054 $2,226.93 $2,137,023 $12,513.03 Total Permits For Type: 5 SPECIAL LAND USE P24SLU0001 THIRTY-ONE PROPERTIES INC US-31 $0 $1,500.00 $0 $1,500.00 Total Permits For Type: 1 TEMPORARY LAND USE P24ZL0023 REENDERS LAWRENCE ENT 13279 168TH AVE $0 $0.00 $0 $0.00 Total Permits For Type: 1 VEHICLE SALES P24VS0009 GABRIELSE INVESTMENTS LLC 14847 160TH AVE $0 $0.00 P24VS0010 FERGEN CYNTHIA J 15228 ARBORWOOD DR $0 $0.00 P24VS0011 KAMINSKI JAMES 14830 LAKESHORE DR $0 $0.00 P24VS0012 WHITE WATER GROUP, LLC 13330 168TH AVE $0 $0.00 P24VS0013 SCHMIDT DONALD C-MAXINE M 14845 LINCOLN ST $0 $0.00 P24VS0014 EPPLETT RODNEY-BRENDA 12653 144TH AVE $0 $0.00 $0 $0.00 Total Permits For Type: 6  9 Page: Printed: 05/09/2024 Building Permit Report - Monthly Estimated Cost Permit Fee Totals $16,193,206 $39,690.42 Total Permits In Month: 239