Board of Review of Real Estate Assessments

BOARD OF REVIEW OF REAL ESTATE ASSESSMENTS CITY OF HAMPTON, VIRGINIA CHAIRMAN: David Richards VICE-CHAIRMAN: Asa Jenrette Jr. SECRETARY: Aimee Hower MEMBERS: Julianne Routten formerly Julianne Cyr, George C. Moore, Carl Burt HEARING MEETING MINUTES June 6, 2022 8:30 AM - Veterans Conference Room Ruppert Leon Sargent Building I. Call to Order The meeting was called to order by David Richards. II. Roll Call Present: David Richards, Asa Jenrette Jr., Julianne Cyr, George C. Moore Sr., Carl Burt Mr. Burt arrived to meeting at 8:33 am, roll call had already been called and last meeting minutes were approved by the quorum present. III. Reading of Minutes of Preceding Meeting The May 20, 2022 meeting's minutes were approved. IV. Unfinished Business None V. Appeal Hearings 1 Case: FY2023 - 10000603 Owner: MWB INC T/A BELL ISLE MARINA PIN: 10000603 Address: 2 BELLS ISLAND DR Assessment Office Review Requested Recommended Decision Change Land $887,800 NA $500,000 $887,800 Improvement(s) $342,500 NA $250,000 $342,500 Total $1,230,300 NA $750,000 $1,230,300 The owner spoke before the Board. The appeal was made on the basis of Equalization and Incomplete or Incorrect Data. A report for the Office of the Assessor of Real Estate was presented by Eric Sullivan. Board Vote: The motion was made by and seconded by to the current assessment based on equalization. After discussion the Board of Review voted: Other Notes: June 6: The Board unanimously voted to defer the case until June 8 to give the property owner time to obtain tangible personal property values for certain equipment on the property and supply those values to the City Assessor for review and valuation consideration. The information will be brought to the Board for consideration in determining a valuation decision. Page 1 of 5 2 Case: FY2023 - 13001446 Owner: STUKES ROBERT J III & MEI C PIN: 13001446 Address: 216 KOVE DR Assessment Office Review Requested Recommended Decision Change Land $70,700 $70,700 $70,700 $70,700 $70,700 $0 0% Improvement(s) $309,400 $309,400 $288,300 $309,400 $309,400 $0 0% Total $380,100 $380,100 $359,000 $380,100 $380,100 $0 0% The owner spoke before the Board. The appeal was made on the basis of Incomplete or Incorrect Data. A report for the Office of the Assessor of Real Estate was presented by Andrew Connelly. Board Vote: The motion was made by Carl Burt and seconded by Asa Jenrette Jr. to affirm the current assessment based on fair market value. After discussion the Board of Review voted: Carl Burt Yea George C. Moore Yea Asa Jenrette Jr. Yea Julianne Cyr Nay David Richards Nay 3 Case: FY2023 - 4001802 Owner: HASSELL JAMES M PIN: 4001802 Address: 321 WINCHESTER DR Assessment Office Review Requested Recommended Decision Change Land $60,000 $60,000 $60,000 $60,000 $60,000 $0 0% Improvement(s) $134,500 $134,500 $129,500 $134,500 $134,500 $0 0% Total $194,500 $194,500 $189,500 $194,500 $194,500 $0 0% The owner or agent did not make a presentation. The appeal was made on the basis of Equalization. A report for the Office of the Assessor of Real Estate was presented by Joe Mahan. Board Vote: The motion was made by George C. Moore and seconded by Julianne Cyr to affirm the current assessment based on equalization. After discussion the Board of Review voted: George C. Moore Yea Asa Jenrette Jr. Yea Julianne Cyr Yea Carl Burt Yea David Richards Yea 4 Case: FY2023 - 12001529 Owner: CARNEGIE STANLEY G PIN: 12001529 Address: 44 BAINBRIDGE AVE Assessment Office Review Requested Recommended Decision Change Land $75,000 $75,000 $42,000 $75,000 $75,000 $0 0% Improvement(s) $254,200 $180,300 $180,300 $180,300 $180,300 $0 0% Total $329,200 $255,300 $222,300 $255,300 $255,300 $0 0% The owner spoke before the Board. The appeal was made on the basis of Equalization. A report for the Office of the Assessor of Real Estate was presented by Libby Griebel. Board Vote: The motion was made by Julianne Cyr and seconded by George C. Moore to affirm the current assessment based on equalization. After discussion the Board of Review voted: Julianne Cyr Yea Carl Burt Yea George C. Moore Yea Asa Jenrette Jr. Yea David Richards Yea Page 2 of 5 5 Case: FY2023 - 1006701 Owner: ROBINSON SUSIE B PIN: 1006701 Address: 414 ALLEGHANY RD Assessment Office Review Requested Recommended Decision Change Land $40,000 $40,000 $40,000 $40,000 $0 0% Improvement(s) $58,100 $58,100 $58,100 $58,100 $0 0% Total $98,100 $98,100 $98,100 $98,100 $0 0% The owner spoke before the Board. The appeal was made on the basis of Incomplete or Incorrect Data. A report for the Office of the Assessor of Real Estate was presented by Graham Shearin. Board Vote: The motion was made by George C. Moore and seconded by Julianne Cyr to affirm the current assessment based on fair market value. After discussion the Board of Review voted: George C. Moore Yea Asa Jenrette Jr. Yea Julianne Cyr Yea Carl Burt Yea David Richards Yea Other Notes: After the owner and City Assessor presentations, the Board deferred the case until the end of the day's scheduled hearings in order for the City appraiser, Graham Shearin, to gather any needed improvement information on the property. The owner relinquished that the appraiser could do an on- site property inspection and report back before the end of the Board's hearing for a decision. 6 Case: FY2023 - 13002115 Owner: KERRICK BRENT R & STACY A PIN: 13002115 Address: 107 WIND MILL POINT RD Assessment Office Review Requested Recommended Decision Change Land $225,000 $225,000 $199,000 $225,000 $225,000 $0 0% Improvement(s) $895,800 $895,800 $730,900 $895,800 $895,800 $0 0% Total $1,120,800 $1,120,800 $929,900 $1,120,800 $1,120,800 $0 0% The owner or agent did not make a presentation. The appeal was made on the basis of Equalization and Fair Market Value. A report for the Office of the Assessor of Real Estate was presented by Michele Packard. Board Vote: The motion was made by Julianne Cyr and seconded by Carl Burt to affirm the current assessment based on fair market value. After discussion the Board of Review voted: Julianne Cyr Yea Asa Jenrette Jr. Yea Carl Burt Yea George C. Moore Yea David Richards Yea 7 Case: FY2023 - 10000842 Owner: DUFFY MATTHEW J & DEBBIE PIN: 10000842 Address: 190 HALL RD Assessment Office Review Requested Recommended Decision Change Land $196,700 $196,700 $196,700 $196,700 $196,700 $0 0% Improvement(s) $467,900 $467,900 $400,700 $467,900 $467,900 $0 0% Total $664,600 $664,600 $597,400 $664,600 $664,600 $0 0% The owner spoke before the Board. The appeal was made on the basis of Fair Market Value. A report for the Office of the Assessor of Real Estate was presented by Michele Packard. Board Vote: The motion was made by Julianne Cyr and seconded by Carl Burt to affirm the current assessment based on fair market value. After discussion the Board of Review voted: Julianne Cyr Yea George C. Moore Yea Carl Burt Yea Asa Jenrette Jr. Yea David Richards Yea Page 3 of 5 8 Case: FY2023 - 13001656 Owner: DUFFY MATTHEW J & DEBBIE PIN: 13001656 Address: 184 HALL RD Assessment Office Review Requested Recommended Decision Change Land $90,300 $90,300 $90,300 $90,300 $90,300 $0 0% Improvement(s) $523,100 $523,100 $463,700 $523,100 $523,100 $0 0% Total $613,400 $613,400 $554,000 $613,400 $613,400 $0 0% The owner spoke before the Board. The appeal was made on the basis of . A report for the Office of the Assessor of Real Estate was presented by Michele Packard. Board Vote: The motion was made by George C. Moore and seconded by Carl Burt to affirm the current assessment based on fair market value. After discussion the Board of Review voted: George C. Moore Yea David Richards Yea Carl Burt Yea Asa Jenrette Jr. Yea Julianne Cyr Yea 9 Case: FY2023 - 12000423 Owner: BLACKWELL CLIFTON PIN: 12000423 Address: 15 N JUNIPER ST Assessment Office Review Requested Recommended Decision Change Land $45,000 $45,000 $45,000 $45,000 $45,000 $0 0% Improvement(s) $108,000 $91,800 $84,000 $91,800 $91,800 $0 0% Total $153,000 $136,800 $129,000 $136,800 $136,800 $0 0% The owner spoke before the Board. The appeal was made on the basis of Equalization. A report for the Office of the Assessor of Real Estate was presented by Eric Wynings. Board Vote: The motion was made by Carl Burt and seconded by Asa Jenrette Jr. to affirm the current assessment based on equalization. After discussion the Board of Review voted: Carl Burt Yea Julianne Cyr Yea Asa Jenrette Jr. Yea George C. Moore Yea David Richards Yea 10 Case: FY2023 - 12000567 Owner: BAUER MARTHA S PIN: 12000567 Address: 55 N BOXWOOD ST Assessment Office Review Requested Recommended Decision Change Land $219,800 $219,800 $200,725 $219,800 $219,800 $0 0% Improvement(s) $304,400 $304,400 $288,791 $304,400 $304,400 $0 0% Total $524,200 $524,200 $489,516 $524,200 $524,200 $0 0% The owner spoke before the Board. The appeal was made on the basis of Equalization and Fair Market Value and Incomplete or Incorrect Data. A report for the Office of the Assessor of Real Estate was presented by Eric Wynings. Board Vote: The motion was made by Asa Jenrette Jr. and seconded by Carl Burt to affirm the current assessment based on equalization. After discussion the Board of Review voted: Asa Jenrette Jr. Yea Julianne Cyr Yea Carl Burt Yea George C. Moore Yea David Richards Yea Page 4 of 5 VI. New Business None VII. Announcements None VIII. Adjournment The meeting was adjourned at 1:30 PM. Office of the Assessor of Real Estate 1 Franklin Street, Suite 602 | Hampton, Virginia 23669 www.hampton.gov/assessor | P: (757) 727-8311 Recipient of the Certificate of Excellence in Assessment Administration from the International Association of Assessing Officers Page 5 of 5