Personnel Board
Regular MeetingHialeah, FL · December 7, 2015
Minutes
PERSONNEL BOARD SUMMARIZED MINUTES
Monday, December 7, 2015 – 6:00 p.m.
Call to Order/Roll Call of Members: Pat Carnevale, Chairperson; Norberto Alvarez, Vice-Chairperson;
Stephen Dielmann, Member; Luis Zubieta, Member. ALSO PRESENT: Gelien Perez, Acting HR Director;
Owen Kohler, Assistant City Attorney; and Annette Otaño, Secretary. Absent: Zoraya Pena, Member.
AGENDA
1. Request to amend Item No. 5 of the November 2, 2015 Agenda.
APPROVED. Motion by Mr. Dielmann. Second by Mr. Alvarez. Passed by unanimous vote.
2. Request to approve the minutes of the November 2, 2015 Personnel Board meeting.
APPROVED. Motion by Mr. Zubieta. Second by Mr. Alvarez. Passed by unanimous vote.
3. Request to approve leave with pay, because of death in the immediate family, for the listed
employees, in accordance with Rule 13, Section5 (f) of the Civil Service Rules and regulations,
received November 2015.
1. Patricia Mera Education and Community Services
2. William Carter Police Department
3. Angela Diaz Public Safety Communications
APPROVED. Motion by Mr. Alvarez. Second by Mr. Dielmann. Passed by unanimous vote.
4. Report of Leave without Pay for November 2015.
SO NOTED.
5. Report of Civil Service Appointments for November 2015.
1. Roberto Gonzalez Community Development
2. Hector Ranzola Streets Department
SO NOTED.
6. Report of Civil Service Resignations for November 2015.
1. Betty Redondo Finance Department
2. Mark S. Colon Fire Department
3. Rickie A. Garcia Fire Department
4. Alejandro A. Heredia Fire Department
5. Norma E. Diaz Office of Management & Budget Department
6. Bryan Gonzalez Police Department
7. Rey Quintero Police Department
8. Hansel Verdud Police Department
9. Cesar Castillo Public Works
SO NOTED.
PERSONNEL BOARD SUMMARIZED MINUTES
Monday, December 7, 2015
Page 2 of 7
7. Report of Maternal/Paternal Leave for November 2015. None.
SO NOTED.
8. Report of Leave of Absence for November 2015. None.
SO NOTED.
9. Request to certify the eligibility list for Accounting Clerk I.
APPROVED. Motion by Mr. Alvarez. Second by Mr. Dielmann. Passed by unanimous vote.
10. Request to certify the eligibility list for Parks and Crew Journeyman.
APPROVED. Motion by Mr. Zubieta. Second by Mr. Alvarez. Passed by unanimous vote.
11. Request to certify the eligibility list for Receptionist.
APPROVED. Motion by Mr. Zubieta. Second by Mr. Dielmann. Passed by unanimous vote.
12. Request to conduct a Civil Service examination for the Assistant Director of Education &
Community Services (Elizabeth Miro) position with the following criteria:
a. In-house, Non-competitive
b. 60% Oral
c. 40% Education/Experience
d. Must obtain a minimum of 70% on the oral portion.
e. Must obtain a minimum combined score of 70% to be placed on the eligibility list.
Copy of the job description and resume are attached. (No eligibility list on file.)
Range – Management
APPROVED. Motion by Mr. Alvarez. Second by Mr. Dielmann. Passed by unanimous vote.
13. Request to conduct a Civil Service examination for the Assistant Director of Recreation (Edward
R. Acosta) position with the following criteria:
a. In-house, Non-competitive
b. 60% Oral
c. 40% Education/Experience
d. Must obtain a minimum of 70% on the oral portion.
e. Must obtain a minimum combined score of 70% to be placed on the eligibility list.
Copy of the job description and resume are attached. (No eligibility list on file.)
Range – Management
APPROVED. Motion by Mr. Zubieta. Second by Mr. Alvarez. Passed by unanimous vote.
PERSONNEL BOARD SUMMARIZED MINUTES
Monday, December 7, 2015
Page 3 of 7
14. Request to conduct a Civil Service examination for the Budget Analyst (Melissa Hernandez)
position with the following criteria:
a. In-house, Non-competitive
b. 60% Oral
c. 40% Education/Experience
d. Must obtain a minimum of 70% on the oral portion.
e. Must obtain a minimum combined score of 70% to be placed on the eligibility list.
Copy of the job description and resume are attached. (No eligibility list on file.)
Range 32 – $1,418 - $2,904 Bi-weekly
APPROVED. Motion by Mr. Alvarez. Second by Mr. Zubieta. Passed by unanimous vote.
15. Request to conduct a Civil Service examination for the Director of Human Resources (Gelien
Perez) position with the following criteria:
a. In-house, Non-competitive
b. 60% Oral
c. 40% Education/Experience
d. Must obtain a minimum of 70% on the oral portion.
e. Must obtain a minimum combined score of 70% to be placed on the eligibility list.
Copy of the job description and resume are attached. (No eligibility list on file.)
Range – Management
APPROVED. Motion by Mr. Alvarez. Second by Mr. Dielmann. Passed by unanimous vote.
16. Request to conduct a Civil Service examination for the Director of Parks & Recreation (Joseph
M. Dziedzic) position with the following criteria:
a. In-house, Non-competitive
b. 60% Oral
c. 40% Education/Experience
d. Must obtain a minimum of 70% on the oral portion.
e. Must obtain a minimum combined score of 70% to be placed on the eligibility list.
Copy of the job description and resume are attached. (No eligibility list on file.)
Range – Management
APPROVED. Motion by Mr. Alvarez. Second by Mr. Zubieta. Passed by unanimous vote.
17. Request to conduct a Civil Service examination for the Education Supervisor (Maria Toca and
Sharon J. Dziedzic) position with the following criteria:
a. In-house, Non-competitive
b. 60% Oral
c. 40% Education/Experience
d. Must obtain a minimum of 70% on the oral portion.
PERSONNEL BOARD SUMMARIZED MINUTES
Monday, December 7, 2015
Page 4 of 7
e. Must obtain a minimum combined score of 70% to be placed on the eligibility list.
Copy of the job description and resume are attached. (No eligibility list on file.)
Range – Management
APPROVED. Motion by Mr. Alvarez. Second by Mr. Dielmann. Passed by unanimous vote.
18. Request to conduct a Civil Service examination for the Office Coordinator (Lia M. Garcia -
Education & Community Services) position with the following criteria:
a. In-house, Non-competitive e
b. 60% Oral
c. 40% Education/Experience
d. Must obtain a minimum of 70% on the oral portion.
e. Must obtain a minimum combined score of 70% to be placed on the eligibility list.
Copy of the job description and resume are attached. (No eligibility list on file.)
Range – Management
APPROVED. Motion by Mr. Zubieta. Second by Mr. Alvarez. Passed by unanimous vote.
19. Request to conduct a Civil Service examination for the Parks & Recreation Supervisor (William
Sanchez) position with the following criteria:
a. In-house, Non-competitive
b. 60% Oral
c. 40% Education/Experience
d. Must obtain a minimum of 70% on the oral portion.
e. Must obtain a minimum combined score of 70% to be placed on the eligibility list.
Copy of the job description and resume are attached. (No eligibility list on file.)
Range – Management
APPROVED. Motion by Mr. Alvarez. Second by Mr. Zubieta. Passed by unanimous vote.
20. Request to conduct a Civil Service examination for the Police Extra Duty Coordinator (Natalie
Ruiz) position with the following criteria:
a. In-house, Non-competitive
b. 60% Oral
c. 40% Education/Experience
d. Must obtain a minimum of 70% on the oral portion.
e. Must obtain a minimum combined score of 70% to be placed on the eligibility list.
Copy of the job description and resume are attached. (No eligibility list on file.)
Range – Management
APPROVED with recommended revision to the job description. Motion by Mr. Dielmann.
Second by Mr. Alvarez. Passed by unanimous vote.
PERSONNEL BOARD SUMMARIZED MINUTES
Monday, December 7, 2015
Page 5 of 7
21. Request to conduct a Civil Service examination for the Recreation Programs Supervisor (Jose E.
Garcia) position with the following criteria:
a. In-house, Non-competitive
b. 60% Oral
c. 40% Education/Experience
d. Must obtain a minimum of 70% on the oral portion.
e. Must obtain a minimum combined score of 70% to be placed on the eligibility list.
Copy of the job description and resume are attached. (No eligibility list on file.)
Range – Management
APPROVED. Motion by Mr. Zubieta. Second by Mr. Alvarez. Passed by unanimous vote.
22. Request to conduct a Civil Service examination for the Recreation Special Programs Supervisor
(Sharon J. Dziedzic) position with the following criteria:
a. In-house, Non-competitive
b. 60% Oral
c. 40% Education/Experience
d. Must obtain a minimum of 70% on the oral portion.
e. Must obtain a minimum combined score of 70% to be placed on the eligibility list.
Copy of the job description and resume are attached. (No eligibility list on file.)
Range – Management
WITHDRAWN.
23. Request to approve the new civil service classification and job description for the position of
Assistant to the Director - ADM.
Copy of new job description is attached.
Range - Management
APPROVED. Motion by Mr. Zubieta. Second by Mr. Alvarez. Passed by unanimous vote.
24. Request to approve the new civil service classification and job description for the position of
Business Tax Specialist I.
Copy of new job description is attached.
Range 48 - $1,099 - $2,213 Bi-weekly
APPROVED. Motion by Mr. Zubieta. Second by Mr. Alvarez. Passed by unanimous vote.
25. Request to approve the new civil service classification and job description for the position of
Business Tax Specialist II.
Copy of new job description is attached.
PERSONNEL BOARD SUMMARIZED MINUTES
Monday, December 7, 2015
Page 6 of 7
Range 49 - $1,138 - $2,402 Bi-weekly
APPROVED. Motion by Mr. Zubieta. Second by Mr. Dielmann. Passed by unanimous vote.
26. Request to approve the new civil service classification and job description for the position of
Engineer II.
Copy of new job description is attached.
Range 54 - $1,671 - $3,316 Bi-weekly
TABLED. Motion by Mr. Alvarez. Second by Mr. Dielmann. Passed by unanimous vote.
27. Request to approve the new civil service classification and job description for the position of
Senior Accountant.
Copy of new job description is attached.
Range 55 – $1,785 - $3,486 Bi-weekly
APPROVED. Motion by Mr. Alvarez. Second by Mr. Dielmann. Passed by unanimous vote.
28. Request to approve the new civil service classification and job description for the position of
Water and Sewer Engineer.
Copy of new job description is attached.
Range 49 - $1,138 - $2,402 Bi-weekly
TABLED. Motion by Mr. Alvarez. Second by Mr. Dielmann. Passed by unanimous vote.
29. Request to approve the revised job description for the position of Business Tax Inspector I.
Copy of revised job description is attached. (No eligibility list on file.)
Range 50 - $1,303 - $2,535 Bi-weekly
APPROVED. Motion by Mr. Zubieta. Second by Mr. Dielmann. Passed by unanimous vote.
30. Request to approve the revised job description for the position of Business Tax Inspector II.
Copy of revised job description is attached. (No eligibility list on file.)
Range 51 - $1,320 - $2,692 Bi-weekly
APPROVED. Motion by Mr. Zubieta. Second by Mr. Dielmann. Passed by unanimous vote.
31. Request to hear Unfinished Business.
32. Request to hear New Business.
PERSONNEL BOARD SUMMARIZED MINUTES
Monday, December 7, 2015
Page 7 of 7
NEXT PERSONNEL BOARD MEETING: Monday, January 4, 2016 at 6:00 P.M.
If any person decides to appeal any decision made by the Personnel Board with respect to any matter considered at this meeting, he/she will
need a record of the proceedings and, for such purpose, may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made, which record
includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based. In accordance with the Americans and Disabilities A ct of 1990,
persons needing a special accommodation to participate in this proceeding should contact the Office of the City Clerk no later than seven (7)
days prior to the proceeding. Telephone (305) 883-5820 for assistance; if hearing impaired, telephone the Florida Relay Service Numbers (800)
955-8771 (TDD) OR (800) 955-8770 (VOICE), for assistance.
Agenda
PERSONNEL BOARD MEETING
Monday, December 7, 2015 – 6:00 p.m.
Call to Order/Roll Call of Members: Pat Carnevale, Chairperson; Norberto Alvarez, Vice-Chairperson;
Zoraya Pena, Member; Stephen Dielmann, Member; Luis Zubieta, Member
AGENDA
1. Request to amend Item No. 5 of the November 2, 2015 Agenda.
2. Request to approve the minutes of the November 2, 2015 Personnel Board meeting.
3. Request to approve leave with pay, because of death in the immediate family, for the listed
employees, in accordance with Rule 13, Section5 (f) of the Civil Service Rules and regulations,
received November 2015.
1. Patricia Mera Education and Community Services
2. William Carter Police Department
3. Angela Diaz Public Safety Communications
4. Report of Leave without Pay for November 2015.
5. Report of Civil Service Appointments for November 2015.
1. Roberto Gonzalez Community Development
2. Hector Ranzola Streets Department
6. Report of Civil Service Resignations for November 2015.
1. Betty Redondo Finance Department
2. Mark S. Colon Fire Department
3. Rickie A. Garcia Fire Department
4. Alejandro A. Heredia Fire Department
5. Norma E. Diaz Office of Management & Budget Department
6. Bryan Gonzalez Police Department
7. Rey Quintero Police Department
8. Hansel Verdud Police Department
9. Cesar Castillo Public Works
7. Report of Maternal/Paternal Leave for November 2015. None.
8. Report of Leave of Absence for November 2015. None.
PERSONNEL BOARD AGENDA
Monday, December 7, 2015
Page 2 of 6
9. Request to certify the eligibility list for Accounting Clerk I.
10. Request to certify the eligibility list for Parks and Crew Journeyman.
11. Request to certify the eligibility list for Receptionist.
12. Request to conduct a Civil Service examination for the Assistant Director of Education &
Community Services (Elizabeth Miro) position with the following criteria:
a. In-house, Non-competitive
b. 60% Oral
c. 40% Education/Experience
d. Must obtain a minimum of 70% on the oral portion.
e. Must obtain a minimum combined score of 70% to be placed on the eligibility list.
Copy of the job description and resume are attached. (No eligibility list on file.)
Range 02 – Management
13. Request to conduct a Civil Service examination for the Assistant Director of Recreation (Edward
R. Acosta) position with the following criteria:
a. In-house, Non-competitive
b. 60% Oral
c. 40% Education/Experience
d. Must obtain a minimum of 70% on the oral portion.
e. Must obtain a minimum combined score of 70% to be placed on the eligibility list.
Copy of the job description and resume are attached. (No eligibility list on file.)
Range 01 – Management
14. Request to conduct a Civil Service examination for the Budget Analyst (Melissa Hernandez)
position with the following criteria:
a. In-house, Non-competitive
b. 60% Oral
c. 40% Education/Experience
d. Must obtain a minimum of 70% on the oral portion.
e. Must obtain a minimum combined score of 70% to be placed on the eligibility list.
Copy of the job description and resume are attached. (No eligibility list on file.)
Range 32 – $1,418 - $2,904 Bi-weekly
PERSONNEL BOARD AGENDA
Monday, December 7, 2015
Page 3 of 6
15. Request to conduct a Civil Service examination for the Director of Human Resources (Gelien
Perez) position with the following criteria:
a. In-house, Non-competitive
b. 60% Oral
c. 40% Education/Experience
d. Must obtain a minimum of 70% on the oral portion.
e. Must obtain a minimum combined score of 70% to be placed on the eligibility list.
Copy of the job description and resume are attached. (No eligibility list on file.)
Range 03 – Management
16. Request to conduct a Civil Service examination for the Director of Parks & Recreation (Joseph
M. Dziedzic) position with the following criteria:
a. In-house, Non-competitive
b. 60% Oral
c. 40% Education/Experience
d. Must obtain a minimum of 70% on the oral portion.
e. Must obtain a minimum combined score of 70% to be placed on the eligibility list.
Copy of the job description and resume are attached. (No eligibility list on file.)
Range 02 – Management
17. Request to conduct a Civil Service examination for the Education Supervisor (Maria Toca and
Sharon J. Dziedzic) position with the following criteria:
a. In-house, Non-competitive
b. 60% Oral
c. 40% Education/Experience
d. Must obtain a minimum of 70% on the oral portion.
e. Must obtain a minimum combined score of 70% to be placed on the eligibility list.
Copy of the job description and resume are attached. (No eligibility list on file.)
Range 01 – Management
18. Request to conduct a Civil Service examination for the Office Coordinator (Lia M. Garcia -
Education & Community Services) position with the following criteria:
a. In-house, Non-competitive e
b. 60% Oral
c. 40% Education/Experience
d. Must obtain a minimum of 70% on the oral portion.
e. Must obtain a minimum combined score of 70% to be placed on the eligibility list.
Copy of the job description and resume are attached. (No eligibility list on file.)
Range 01 – Management
PERSONNEL BOARD AGENDA
Monday, December 7, 2015
Page 4 of 6
19. Request to conduct a Civil Service examination for the Parks & Recreation Supervisor (William
Sanchez) position with the following criteria:
a. In-house, Non-competitive
b. 60% Oral
c. 40% Education/Experience
d. Must obtain a minimum of 70% on the oral portion.
e. Must obtain a minimum combined score of 70% to be placed on the eligibility list.
Copy of the job description and resume are attached. (No eligibility list on file.)
Range 01 – Management
20. Request to conduct a Civil Service examination for the Police Extra Duty Coordinator (Natalie
Ruiz) position with the following criteria:
a. In-house, Non-competitive
b. 60% Oral
c. 40% Education/Experience
d. Must obtain a minimum of 70% on the oral portion.
e. Must obtain a minimum combined score of 70% to be placed on the eligibility list.
Copy of the job description and resume are attached. (No eligibility list on file.)
Range 01 – Management
21. Request to conduct a Civil Service examination for the Recreation Programs Supervisor (Jose E.
Garcia) position with the following criteria:
a. In-house, Non-competitive
b. 60% Oral
c. 40% Education/Experience
d. Must obtain a minimum of 70% on the oral portion.
e. Must obtain a minimum combined score of 70% to be placed on the eligibility list.
Copy of the job description and resume are attached. (No eligibility list on file.)
Range 01 – Management
22. Request to conduct a Civil Service examination for the Recreation Special Programs Supervisor
(Sharon J. Dziedzic) position with the following criteria:
a. In-house, Non-competitive
b. 60% Oral
c. 40% Education/Experience
d. Must obtain a minimum of 70% on the oral portion.
e. Must obtain a minimum combined score of 70% to be placed on the eligibility list.
Copy of the job description and resume are attached. (No eligibility list on file.)
Range 01 – Management
PERSONNEL BOARD AGENDA
Monday, December 7, 2015
Page 5 of 6
23. Request to approve the new civil service classification and job description for the position of
Assistant to the Director - ADM.
Copy of new job description is attached.
Range 01 - Management
24. Request to approve the new civil service classification and job description for the position of
Business Tax Specialist I.
Copy of new job description is attached.
Range 48 - $1,099 - $2,213 Bi-weekly
25. Request to approve the new civil service classification and job description for the position of
Business Tax Specialist II.
Copy of new job description is attached.
Range 49 - $1,138 - $2,402 Bi-weekly
26. Request to approve the new civil service classification and job description for the position of
Engineer II.
Copy of new job description is attached.
Range 54 - $1,671 - $3,316 Bi-weekly
27. Request to approve the new civil service classification and job description for the position of
Senior Accountant.
Copy of new job description is attached.
Range 55 – $1,785 - $3,486 Bi-weekly
28. Request to approve the new civil service classification and job description for the position of
Water and Sewer Engineer.
Copy of new job description is attached.
Range 49 - $1,138 - $2,402 Bi-weekly
29. Request to approve the revised job description for the position of Business Tax Inspector I.
Copy of revised job description is attached. (No eligibility list on file.)
Range 50 - $1,303 - $2,535 Bi-weekly
30. Request to approve the revised job description for the position of Business Tax Inspector II.
Copy of revised job description is attached. (No eligibility list on file.)
Range 51 - $1,320 - $2,692 Bi-weekly
PERSONNEL BOARD AGENDA
Monday, December 7, 2015
Page 6 of 6
31. Request to hear Unfinished Business.
32. Request to hear New Business.
NEXT PERSONNEL BOARD MEETING: Monday, January 4, 2016 at 6:00 P.M.
If any person decides to appeal any decision made by the Personnel Board with respect to any matter considered at this meeting, he/she will
need a record of the proceedings and, for such purpose, may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made, which record
includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based. In accordance with the Americans and Disabilities Act of 1990,
persons needing a special accommodation to participate in this proceeding should contact the Office of the City Clerk no later than seven (7)
days prior to the proceeding. Telephone (305) 883-5820 for assistance; if hearing impaired, telephone the Florida Relay Service Numbers (800)
955-8771 (TDD) OR (800) 955-8770 (VOICE), for assistance.
Get email alerts for Hialeah
A daily email when new agendas and minutes are posted.