Architectural & Historic Board of Review

City of Hudson, Ohio Meeting Minutes - Final Architectural & Historic Board of Review David Drummond, Chair Allyn Marzulla, Vice Chair Arthur Morris, Secretary Christopher Bach John Caputo Nicole Davis James Grant Nicholas Sugar, Associate Planner Wednesday, October 10, 2018 7:30 PM Town Hall I. Call To Order II. Roll Call . III. Public Comment Add Nicole Davis and Chris BAch to the Historic Subcommittee for this evening. Move to Roll Call. Anything on or not on the agenda. None IV. Consent Applications A. 4592 110 West Streetsboro Street Sign (Face Replacement on Existing Ground Sign - McIntyre Insurance) Submitted by Michael McIntyre. Attachments: 110 West Streetsboro Street Submittal Signs. Consent application Caputo/Davis. Approved B. 5035 5107 Darrow Road Sign (Ground Sign - Saint Herman of Alaska) Submitted by Karen Becker, Becker Signs Attachments: 5107 Darrow Road Submittal City of Hudson, Ohio Page 1 Architectural & Historic Board of Review Meeting Minutes - Final October 10, 2018 V. Old Business A. 2509 178 N. Main Street (Historic District) Alteration (Siding, Windows, Doors) Submitted by Nadeem Baig, Hudson Oriental Rug - Historic District . Attachments: 178 N Main Street Submittal 2509, 178 N. Main Street Nadeem Baig, Mr. Sugar. Late last year case. Work proposed, main was HardiBoard siding. Now revised poroposal that deals with wood replacements, painting, 2 wood sills in the front of the building. Mr. Sugar showed pictures. Damage to siding on the South side, this is replacement area. Shutters on the front, applicant proposes to remove. Historical photos show no shutters. Repair of existing gutter. Clarification of: Foundation material, parged coating of the foundation. Go over the existing foundation. Discussion of the south side, near the new concrete that have heavy damage. Replacement of South East side wood. Will stop sideing at the original building line. Sand and repair the South West side of the building. Clear cedar to be used. Some sections of siding to be replaced on the front, as needed. Patch and repair as needed. Wood frame window on the rear. Grant, historic district subcommittee. Caputo accept, Davis 2nd. Approved. Foundation, repair what is exposed. B. 4882 128 Hudson Street (Historic District) Alteration (Front Porch) Submitted by Barb Lochridge, Historic. Attachments: 128 Hudson Street Submittal 128 Hudson Street Barb Lochridge, applicant. Mr. Sugar, site visit week of October 6th. Noted the use of the Azek material for replacement of deteriorated materials. Three season room on the rear of the home using the same materials. Board commented that the Azek material matches the existing material of the house. Ballisters City of Hudson, Ohio Page 2 Architectural & Historic Board of Review Meeting Minutes - Final October 10, 2018 will be 1/4 inch wider and deeper than the existing. Columns to be wrapped for greater depth. Will frame the lattes used at the base of the porch. Historic, subcomm, issue certifcute of app. Davis/Caputo. Approved. VI. New Business A. 4778 5611 Darrow Road (Waterway Car Wash) Alteration (Exterior Alterations) Submitted by Jason Steigerwald. Attachments: 5611 Darrow Road Submittal 4778 Darrow Mike Goldman, Vice President and council of Waterway Car Wash and Jason Steigerwald, applicant. Mr. Sugar introduced the case for a metal paneling system and a metal standing seam roof. Reconfiguring the bay area in the front. Sign question, Sign is an addition to the building. Conditions: 1. that the paneling and garage doors are centered on the wall (exit). 2. Add window to the drawing Colors, Dark blue metal. Roof is light gray. Overhead doors is clear plastic Polycarbonate. Davis, motion to approve w/ window in drawing, centering of the west elevation large garage door, proper drainage for the roof and sign addition. Grant second. Approve. 4776 SAME Place Signs, many on the property, directional some. In the island, Ground sign, building signs. see comments. Matte finish, material of the sign. LDC minor standards, work with staff. Mr. .... stated did revise sign over the window, made smaller. Enter and Exit signs size, not before AHBR. Will remove from the plan. Lighting is all external. City of Hudson, Ohio Page 3 Architectural & Historic Board of Review Meeting Minutes - Final October 10, 2018 Monument sign is prefinished metal of matte finish. Grant as submitted. Davis. Approved. B. 4776 5611 Darrow Road (Waterway Car Wash) Signs (Building, Ground, Directional) Submitted by Jason Steigerwald Attachments: 5611 Darrow Road Submittal East elevation sign over the entryway is scalled approp and not overlapping the window. Condition. C. 4949 77 Maple Drive (Historic District) Alteration (Front/Rear Stoop - Printer’s Devil Inc.) Submitted by Bill Stemple - Historic. Attachments: 77 Maple Drive Submittal 4949 77 Maple Drive Paul Mills. Bill Stemple, owner. Mr. Sugar, series of entryways with plans for work. Replace metal rails and posts. Rear, tuck points and new metal rails, tread replacements and stair railings replaced. Also, replace two front doors - new doors to be fiberglass. Six or nine panel doors similar to existing, in fiberglass. Mr. Mills stated new railings to be higher 42 inch, to meet code. Custom fabricated railings. Brick will be repaired as necessary. Cannot tell the condition behind the brick. Will match brick as close as possible. Will save brick as possible. Historic, Grant, issue certificate of app, waive 2 week. Caputo/Davis. Approve 1622 Barlow Road Kevin and Laura Toth, applicants. Mr. Sugar, exterior alteration. Some work done. Wood siding to be replaced with siding. All shake, vinyl that is a shade darker. Caputo as submitted / Davis. Approved. D. 4991 1622 Barlow Road Alteration (Exterior Siding & Façade) Submitted by Kevin Toth. Attachments: 1622 Barlow Road Submittal City of Hudson, Ohio Page 4 Architectural & Historic Board of Review Meeting Minutes - Final October 10, 2018 E. 4950 300 Cheshire Road Addition (Screened Porch) Submitted by Stephen Detzel. Attachments: 300 Cheshire Road Submittal 300 Cheshire no one F. 4959 6368 Ridgeline Drive (The Reserve of River Oaks, Phase III, Lot 127) New Residential Construction (Two-Story, Single Family Home). Attachments: 6368 Ridgeline Drive Submittal 6338 Ridgeline Jamey Heinzman, Pulte Mr. Sugar, no comments. Grant as /// caputo. Approved G. 4971 2164 Middleton Drive (Lot 86 S of RD) New Residential Construction (Two-Story, Single Family Home) Submitted by Angela Difranco, LDA Builders. Attachments: 2164 Middleton Drive Submittal 2164 Middleton Adriana Lacona, LDA Builders Question the gable and hip roof combination. Caputo, as ... Davis. Approved. Mr. Sugar, not specified if chimney is brick or stone. As long as it matches the existing brick. Caputo, if brick. Grant. Approved. Staff, 1. Stakeholder sessions to be planned 2. LDC rewrite continues with PC 3. Code enforcement with _____ continues 4. House with incorrect siding. VII. Other Business A. 3790 Minutes of Previous Architectural & Historic Board of Review Meeting: City of Hudson, Ohio Page 5 Architectural & Historic Board of Review Meeting Minutes - Final October 10, 2018 September 26, 2018 Attachments: AHBR Minutes September 26, 2018 - Draft Sept 26 minutes Caputo, Grant. Approved Caputo, DAvis. at 8:32 VIII. Adjournment * * * Note Note Not Marzulla or Morris City of Hudson, Ohio Page 6