Board of Review

City of Manistee July 2016 f Review Minutes July 20, 2016 Meeting was called to order by Chairperson Sibley at 1: 00 P. M. Members present: Judianne Sibley, Ed Kriskywicz, Mary Kowalski- Wilhelm and Assessor Whetstone Call for public comment: None given Petition 1 Garry Brown: 51- 362- 717- 11 Petition was presented by Assessor Whetstone; Hardship Exemption was presented for 2016. Assessed Value from$ 88, 100 to$ 0 and Taxable Value from$ 82,446 to$ 0. The Board deviated from Asset Determination# 2 petitioner has Liquid Assets of 6, 873. 21 that exceed the guidelines with no income. This is an exemption for one year only. Motion by: Sibley support by Kriskywicz. Motion passed. Petition 2 Boehm Family Chiropractic: 51- 900- 009- 42 Petition presented by Assessor Whetstone to remove the value of the Personal Property, The L- 4031 was filed timely and not processed. Motion by: Kriskywicz support by Sibley to take the Assessed and Taxable Value from$ 10, 000 to$ 0. Motion passed. Petition 3 Pinkerton Ann: 51- 647- 714- 05 Petition was presented by Assessor Whetstone to grant the Veterans Exemption for 2016. Assessed Value$ 53, 300 to$ 0 and Taxable Value from$ 48,200 to$ 0. Motion by: Kriskywicz, support Sibley to grant the Veterans exemption for 2016. Motion passed. Petition 4 Pinkerton Ann: 51- 572- 703- 02 Petition was presented by Assessor Whetstone to remove the Veterans Exemption for 2016. Assessed Value$ 0 to$ 24,800 and Taxable Value from$ 0 to$ 21, 853. Motion by: Kriskywicz, support Sibley to grant the Veterans exemption for 2016. Motion passed. Petition 5 Daunis, Anthony: 51- 770- 702- 03 Petition was presented by Assessor Whetstone to grant the Veterans Exemption for 2016. Assessed Value$ 17, 500 to$ 0 and Taxable Value from$ 16, 304 to$ 0. Motion by: Kriskywicz, support Sibley to grant the Veterans exemption for 2016. Motion passed. Petition 6 Mark Lijewski: 51- 647- 720- 01 Petition was presented by Assessor Whetstone; Hardship Exemption was presented for 2016. Assessed Value from$ 58,600 to$ 0 and Taxable Value from$ 53, 295 to$ 0. The Board deviated from Eligibility# 2 Income, due to the Tax bill being 15% of his income, and letter from Doctor. Motion by: Kowalski- Wilhelm support Sibley. Motion passed. 1- Petition 7 Thomas Batzer: 51- 340- 709- 05 Petition was presented by Assessor Whetstone to grant the Veterans Exemption for 2016. Assessed Value$ 79, 200 to$ 0 and Taxable Value from$ 69, 788 to$ 0. Motion by: Kriskywicz, support by Sibley to grant the Veterans Exemption 2016. Motion passed Petition 8 Soley Thomas& Laura Ann: 51- 150- 159- 00 Petition was presented by Assessor Whetstone to grant the Principal Residence Exemption for 2015. Motion by: Kowalski- Wilhelm support by Sibley. Motion passed. Petition 9 Rice, Stephen& Diane: 51- 270- 712- 09 Petition was presented by Assessor Whetstone to grant the Principal Residence Exemption for 2015. Motion by: Sibley support by Kriskywicz. Motion passed. Petition 10 Manistee Crossfit: 51- 900- 012- 17 Petition was presented by Assessor Whetstone to take the 2015 Assessed Value$ 2, 500 to$ 0 and Taxable Value from$ 2, 500 to$ 0, not there on tax day. Motion by: Sibley support by Kriskywicz. Motion passed. Petition 11 State Farm: 51- 900- 010- 75 Petition was presented by Assessor Whetstone to take the 2015 Assessed Value$ 1, 500 to$ 0 and Taxable Value from$ 1, 500 to$ 0, not there on tax day. Motion by: Sibley support by Kriskywicz. Motion passed. Petition 12 Play it Again Johnny: 51- 900- 011- 58 Petition was presented by Assessor Whetstone to take the 2015 Assessed Value$ 1, 000 to$ 0 and Taxable Value from$ 1, 000 to$ 0, not there on tax day. Motion by: Sibley support by Kriskywicz. Motion passed. Petition 13 PJ' S Books: 51- 900- 011- 58 Petition was presented by Assessor Whetstone to take the 2015 Assessed Value$ 100 to 0 and Taxable Value from$ 100 to$ 0, not there on tax day. Motion by: Kriskywicz support by Kowalski- Wilhelm. Motion passed. Petition 14 St. Joseph Civic Club: 51- 900- 012 Petition was presented by Assessor Whetstone to take the 2015 Assessed Value$ 5,000 to$ 0 and Taxable Value from$ 5, 000, not there on tax day. Motion by: Kriskywicz support by Sibley. Motion passed. Petition 15 American Cleaners: 51- 900- 009- 19 Petition was presented by Assessor Whetstone to take the 2015 Assessed Value 20, 900 to$ 0 and Taxable Value from$ 20, 900 to$ 0, not there on tax day. Motion by: Kriskywicz support by Kowalski- Wilhelm. Motion passed Petition 16 Oliver, Patricia: 51- 574- 711- 11 2-  Petition was presented by Assessor Whetstone to grant the Principal Residence Exemption for 2016. Motion by: Sibley support by Kriskywicz. Motion passed. Petition 17 Grenell, Connie: 51- 146- 724- 07 Petition was presented by Assessor Whetstone to grant the Veterans Exemption for 2016. Assessed Value$ 42, 200 to$ 0 and Taxable Value from$ 32, 983 to$ 0. Motion by: Kriskywicz, support by Sibley to grant the Veterans Exemption 2016. Motion passed Petition 18 Hansen, Vickers: 51- 352- 703- 05 Petition was presented by Assessor Whetstone to correct a conflict from hand written notes of March Board of Review and what was posted on the Petition by member Pontiac. Sibley confirmed that the board intended the Assessed and Taxable value to be 7,400. Motion by: Sibley to change the Assessed and Taxable Value from$ 13, 500 to 7,400 support by Kriskywicz. Sibley made a motion to adjourn at 2: 10 with a second by Kriskywicz, motion passed. Respectfully submitted, Marlene Whetston , Assessor Date Approved 941, 4Ilo 3- 07/ 20/ 2016 2016 July BOR Change Summary Page: 1/ 2 12: 57 PM DB: City Of S.- nistee 2017 Year Parcel l/ Nu3`__ _r c Corrected Corrected 1/ Comments Petition Assessed Taxable Assessed Taxable Corrected Corrected Owner Docket Class School Value Value PRE/ MBT Transfer Value Value PRE/ MBT EX Transfer 2016 51- 146- 724- 07 • 2016- 020 401 51070 42, 200 32, 983 100. 000 0. 000 0 0 100. 000 0. 000 VETERANS EXEMPTION GRANTED GRENELL FAMILY TRUST 2015 51- 150- 159- 00 2016- 008 401 51070 65, 500 65, 500 0. 000 0. 000 65, 500 65, 500 100. 000 0. 000 PRE NOT FILED UNTIL FEBRUARY SOLEY THOMAS A& LAURA ANN TRUST 2015 51- 270- 712- 09 - 2016- 009 401 51070 38, 400 38, 400 0. 000 100. 000 38, 400 38, 400 100. 000 100. 000 PRE FILED LATE RICE STEPHEN & DIANE 2016 51- 340- 709- 05 - 2016- 007 401 51070 79, 200 69, 788 100. 000 0. 000 0 0 100. 000 0. 000 BATZER THOMAS W& LINDA L 2016 51- 352- 703- 05 e 2016- 017 401 51070 13, 500 13, 500 0. 000 100. 000 7, 400 7, 400 0. 000 100. 000 NOTES KEPT BY THE SECRETARY SHOWED A DIFFERENT VALUE THAN ONE BOARD OF REVIEW PUT ON PAPER. HANSEN, VICKERS & 2016 51- 362- 717- 11 2016- 001 401 51070 88, 100 82, 446 100. 000 0. 000 0 0 100. 000 0. 000 BROWN GARRY M • Qnue ext.,- `,/ e o/• I 2016 51- 572- 703- 02 2016- 004 401 51070 j 0 0 100. 000 0. 000 24, 800 21, 853 100. 000 0. 000 REMOVE VETERANS EXEMPTION FROM THIS PARCEL - PURCHASE A DIFFERENT HOUSE IN MANISTEE. 51- 647- 714- 05 PINKERTON DANIEL W& ANNE M 2016 51- 574- 711- 11 2016- 016 401 51070 30, 400 29, 287 0. 000 0. 000 30, 400 29, 287 100. 000 0. 000 OLIVER PATRICIA 2016 51- 647- 714- 05 2016- 003 401 51070 53, 300 48, 200 0. 000 0. 000 0 0 0. 000 0. 000 PURCHASED HOUSE, PUT THE VETERANS EXEMPTION ON THIS PARCEL, REMOVED THE EXEMPTION FROM 51- 572- 703- 02 PINKERTON ANNE M 2016 51- 647- 720- 01 ,' 2016- 006 401 51070 58, 600 53, 295 100. 000 0. 000 0 0 100. 000 0. 000 HARDSHIP GRANTED TAXES ARE 15% OF HIS INCOME, AND EXTRODINARY MEDICAL EXPENSES. LIJEWSKI MARK 2016 51- 770- 702- 03 . i 2016- 005 401 51070 17, 500 16, 304 100. 000 0. 000 0 0 100. 000 0. 000 VETERANS EXEMPTION GRANTED DAUNIS ANTHONY W& JERI 07/ 20/ 2016 2016 July BOR Change Summary Page: 2/ 2 12: 57 PM DB: City Of V- istee 2017 Year Parcel NuA _ l Corrected Corrected 1/ Comments Petition Assessed Taxable Assessed Taxable Corrected Corrected Owner Docket Class School Value Value PRE/ MBT Transfer Value Value PRE/ MBT EX Transfer 2015 51- 900- 009- 19 f 2016- 015 002 51070 20, 900 20, 900 100. 000 0. 000 0 0 100. 000 0. 000 OUT OF BUSINESS GONE AMERICAN CLEANERS 2016 51- 900- 009- 42 2016- 002 250 51070 10, 000 10, 000 100. 000 0. 000 0 0 100. 000 0. 000 PERSONAL PROPERTY STATEMENT FILED TIMELY NOT PROCESSED BOEHM FAMILY CHIROPRACTIC 2015 51- 900- 010- 75 / 2016- 011 002 51070 1, 500 1, 500 100. 000 0. 000 0 0 100. 000 0. 000 OUT OF BUSINESS STATE FARM INSURANCE 2015 51- 900- 011- 58 / 2016- 012 002 51070 1, 000 1, 000 100. 000 0. 000 0 0 100. 000 0. 000 WERE NEVER IN BUSINESS PLAY IT AGAIN JOHNNY 2015 51- 900- 011- 96 2016- 013 002 51070 100 100 100. 000 0. 000 0 0 100. 000 0. 000 OUT OF BUSINESS PJ' S BOOKS 2015 51- 900- 012- 17 2016- 010 002 51070 2, 500 2, 500 100. 000 0. 000 0 0 100. 000 0. 000 OUT OF BUSINESS MANISTEE CROSSFIT 2015 51- 900- 012- 47 2016- 014 002 51070 5, 000 5, 000 100. 000 0. 000 0 0 100. 000 0. 000 OUT OF BUSINESS ST JOSEPH CIVIC CLUB 166, 500 162, 440 Winter PRE Change THE BOARD OF REVIEW OF CITY OF MANISTEE, MANISTEE COUNTY, MICHIGAN HEREBY AFFIRMS THAT THE ABOVE INFORMATION IS CORRECT TO THE BEST OF OUR KNOWLEDGE Signat res of Board of Review Members Me m L lC Me t , Me / .;/_ r/ 1 Member Member Dated 01 • 0• Y 0 1 7 i 7 at) kc.