Board of Review

City of Manistee December 2016 of Review Minutes December 14, 2016 Meeting was called to order by Chairperson Sibley at 9: 00 A.M. Members present: Judianne Sibley, Ed Kriskywicz, Mary Kowalski-Wilhelm and Assessor Whetstone Motion by Mary with support by Ed to approve the December 2015, March 2016 and July 2016 minutes as presented. All Aye Call for public comment: None given Petition 1 Garry Brown: 51- 146- 712- 11 Petition was presented by Assesso- r Whetstone; Veterans Exemption was presented for 2016. Assessed Value from $ 37, 300 to $ 0 and Taxable Value from $ 29, 040 to $ 0. Motion by: Ed Kriskywicz support by: Kowalski-Wilhelm. Motion passed. Petition 2 Debra Harnishfeger, 51- 147- 790- 20 Petition was presented by Assessor Whetstone to grant the Principal Residence Exemption for 2016. Motion by: Kowalski- Wilhelm support by Kriskywicz. Motion passed. Petition 3 Dawn Stauffer— 51- 259- 011- 37 Petition was presented by Assessor Whetstone to grant the Principal Residence Motion Kriskywicz by Kowalski- Wilhelm. Motion Exemption for 2016. by: support passed. Petition 4 Hartman, Darrel& Amber 51- 270- 706- 01 Petition was presented by Assessor Whetstone to grant the Principal Residence for 2016. Motion Kriskywicz by Kowalski- Wilhelm. Motion Exemption by: support passed. Petition 5 Emelander, David and Deberina 51- 270- 722- 13 Petition was presented by Assessor Whetstone to grant the Principal Residence Exemption for 2016 Petition was presented by Assessor Whetstone to grant the Principal Residence Exemption for 2016. Motion by: Kriskywicz support by Kowalski-Wilhelm. Motion passed. Petition 6 Elaine Sutherland: 51- 270- 707- 04 Petition was presented by Assessor Whetstone; Hardship Exemption was presented for 2016. Kriskywicz support by Kowalski-Wilhelm to deny petition. Petitioner income was over the income guidelines. Motion passed. Petition 7 Oleiczak, Mark& Jennifer 581- 270- 723- 11 Petition was presented by Assessor Whetstone to grant the Principal Residence Exemption for 2016. Motion by: Kowalski- Wilhelm support by Kriskywicz. Motion passed. Petition 8 Connell, Jason E& Shelly: 51- 274- 714-01 1-  Petition was presented by Assessor Whetstone to grant the Principal Residence Exemption for 2016. Motion by: Kowalski-Wilhelm support by Sibley. Motion passed. Petition 9 Woroniak, Breanna: 51- 358- 707- 10 Petition was presented by Assessor Whetstone to grant the Principal Residence Exemption for 2015 and 2016 . Motion by: Kriskywicz support by Kowalski-Wilhelm. Motion passed. Petition 10 Dipple, David& Lee: 51- 364- 703- 11 Petition was presented by Assessor Whetstone to grant the Principal Residence Exemption for 2016& 2015. Motion by: Kowalski-Wilhelm support by Kriskywicz. Motion passed. Petition 11 Conklin, Christopher J& Susan: 51- 364- 709- 01 Petition was presented by Assessor Whetstone to grant the Principal Residence Exemption for 2015, 2014, 2013. Motion by: Kowalski-Wilhelm support by Kriskywicz. Motion passed. Petition 12 McColl, Terry& Kelly: 51- 371- 705- 05 Petition was presented by Assessor Whetstone to grant the Principal Residence Exemption for 2016. Motion by: Kowalski-Wilhelm support by Kriskywicz. Motion passed. Petition 13 Rennie, Robert: 51- 448- 706- 04 Petition was presented by Assessor Whetstone to grant the Veterans Exemption for 2016. Assessed Value$ 26, 800 to$ 0 and Taxable Value from$ 25,275 to$ 0. Motion by: Kriskywicz, support by Kowalski-Wilhelm to grant the Veterans Exemption 2016. Motion passed Petition 14 Snyder, Julie: 51- 568- 704- 06 Petition was presented by Assessor Whetstone to grant the Principal Residence Exemption for 2016, 2015, 2014. Motion by: Kriskywicz support by Kowalski- Wilhelm. Motion passed. Petition 15 Manistee County Treasurer:: 51- 572-706- 08 Petition was presented by Assessor Whetstone to take the 2016 Assessed Value$ 900 to 0 and Taxable Value from $ 802 to$ 0, as this parcel is owned by Manistee County Treasurer. Motion by: Kowalski-Wilhelm, Kriskywicz support by. Motion passed Petition 16 Manistee County Treasurer:: 51- 572- 706- 08 Petition was presented by Assessor Whetstone to take the 2015 Assessed Value$ 800 to 0 and Taxable Value from $ 800 to$ 0, as this parcel is owned by Manistee County Treasurer. Motion by: Kowalski-Wilhelm, Kriskywicz support by. Motion passed Petition 17 Sievert, Wm.: 51- 574- 712- 07 Petition was presented by Assessor Whetstone to grant the Principal Residence Exemption for 2016. Motion by: Kriskywicz support by Kowalski- Wilhelm. Motion passed. 2- Petition 18 Zaring, Glenn& Catherine; 51- 612- 325- 11 Petition was presented by Assessor Whetstone to grant the Principal Residence Exemption for 2016. Motion by: Kowalski- Wilhelm support by Kriskywicz. Motion passed. Petition 18 Zaring, Glenn& Catherine; 51- 612- 325- 11 Petition was presented by Assessor Whetstone to grant the Principal Residence Exemption for 2016. Motion by: Kowalski- Wilhelm support by Kriskywicz. Motion passed. Petition 19 Franckowiak, Joyce: 51- 647- 702- 05 Petition was presented by Assessor Whetstone; Poverty Exemption was presented for 2016. Assessed Value from $ 19, 800 to $ 0 and Taxable Value from $ 16, 065 to $ 0. Motion by: Ed Kriskywicz support by: Kowalski- Wilhelm. Motion passed. Petition 20 Krolczyk, James Floyd: 51- 655- 706- 08 Petition was presented by Assessor Whetstone to grant the Principal Residence Exemption for 2016. Motion by: Kriskywicz support by Kowalski- Wilhelm. Motion passed. Petition 21 Tomaszewski, Paul Anthony: 51- 670- 706- 05 Petition was presented by Assessor Whetstone to grant the Principal Residence Exemption for 2016. Motion by: Kriskywicz support by Kowalski- Wilhelm. Motion passed. Petition 22 Wilson, Charles: 51- 748- 736- 08 Petition was presented by Assessor Whetstone; Poverty Exemption was presented for 2016. Assessed Value from $ 19, 100 to $ 0 and Taxable Value from $ 18, 138 to $ 0. Motion by: Ed Kriskywicz support by: Kowalski- Wilhelm. Motion passed. Petition 23 Pier 31 LLC: 51- 900- 007- 12 Petition was presented by Assessor Whetstone; Personal Property Affidavit was filed timely and not processed. Assessed Value from$ 11, 700 to$ 0 and Taxable Value from 11, 700 to$ 0 for 2016. Motion by: Ed Kriskywicz support by: Kowalski-Wilhelm. Motion passed. Petition 24 Pier 31 LLC: 51- 900- 007- 12 Petition was presented by Assessor Whetstone; Personal Property was not there on Tax Day. Assessed Value from $ 32, 000 to $ 0 and Taxable Value from $ 32, 000 to$ 0 for 2015. Motion by: Ed Kriskywicz support by: Kowalski-Wilhelm. Motion passed. Petition 25 Advanced Asset Management, LLC: 51- 900- 010- 58 Petition was presented by Assessor Whetstone; Personal Property was not there on Tax Day. Assessed Value from$ 1, 200 to$ 0 and Taxable Value from$ 1, 200 to$ 0 for 2015. Motion by: Ed Kriskywicz support by: Kowalski-Wilhelm. Motion passed. Petition 26 Brooks Willilam PLLC: 51- 900- 010- 92 Petition was presented by Assessor Whetstone; Personal Property was not there on Tax Day. Assessed Value from$ 1, 200 to$ 0 and Taxable Value from$ 1, 200 to$ 0 for 2015. Motion by: Ed Kriskywicz support by: Kowalski-Wilhelm. Motion passed. Petition 27 Rainbow Counseling: 51- 900- 011- 38 Petition was presented by Assessor Whetstone; Personal Property was not there on Tax Day. Assessed Value from$ 1, 200 to$ 0 and Taxable Value from$ 1, 200 to$ 0 for 2015. Motion by: Ed Kriskywicz support by: Kowalski-Wilhelm. Motion passed. 3- Petition 28 Exit Great Lakes Realty: 51- 900- 011- 38 Petition was presented by Assessor Whetstone; Personal Property was not there on Tax Day. Assessed Value from$ 2, 100 to$ 0 and Taxable Value from$ 2, 100 to$ 0 for 2015 and 2016. Motion by: Kowalski- Wilhelm support by Ed Kriskywicz. Motion passed. Kowalski- Wilhelm made a motion to adjourn at 10: 32 am with a second by Kriskywicz, motion passed. Respectfully submitted, Ai, arl- n: Whetstone, Assessor Date Approved 4- 1L/ 1H/ LUlb 2016 Dec. BOR Change Summary Page: 1/ 2 DB: City Of Manistee 2017 10: 31 AM Corrected Corrected Petition Assessed Taxable Assessed Taxable Corrected Corrected Year Parcel Number Docket Class School Value Value PRE/ MBT Transfer Value Value PRE/ MBT EX Transfer 2016- 028 401 51070 37, 300 29, 040 100. 000 0. 000 3 100. 000 0. 000 2016 51- 146- 712- 11 ted ft 2016 51- 146- 719- 20,( 2016- 022 401 51070 29, 200 25, 877 0. 000 0. 000 071124° Z 5t& 3) 7 100. 000 0. 000 2016 51- 259- 011- 37 2016- 018 401 51070 178, 200 170, 624 0. 000 0. 000 178, 200 170, 624 100. 000 0. 000 2016 51- 270- 706- 01 2016- 023 401 51070 58, 200 50, 136 0. 000 0. 000 58, 200 50, 136 100. 000 0. 000 2016 51- 270- 707- 04 1 2016- 030 401 51070 34, 300 29, 347 100. 000 0. 000 34, 300 29, 347 100. 000 0. 000 2016 51- 270- 722- 13./ 2016- 003 401 51070 31, 800 30, 090 100. 000 0. 000 31, 600 30, 090 100. 000 0. 000 2016 51- 270- 723- 11%/ 7 2016- 401 51070 36, 500 32, 100 0. 000 0. 000 36, 500 32, 100 100. 000 0. 000 2016 51- 274- 714- 01/ 2016- 031 401 51070 49, 800 43, 410 0. 000 0. 000 49, 800 43, 410 100. 000 0. 000 2016 51- 358- 707- 2016- 040 401 51070 86, 000 83, 455 0. 000 0. 000 86, 000 83, 455 100. 000 0. 000 104 2015 51- 358- 707- 101 2016- 039 401 51070 18, 500 18, 500 0. 000 100. 000 18, 500 18, 500 100. 000 100. 000 2016 51- 364- 703- 11/ 2016- 009 401 51070 38, 800 36, 509 0. 000 0. 000 38, 800 36, 509 100. 000 0. 000 2015 51- 364- 703- 11 2016- 010 401 51070 36, 400 36, 400 0. 000 0. 000 36, 400 36, 400 100. 000 0. 000 2015 51- 364- 709- 01 2016- 012 401 51070 24, 400 24, 400 0. 000 0. 000 24, 400 24, 400 100. 000 0. 000 2014 51- 364- 709- 01 2016- 013 401 51070 25, 100 25, 100 0. 000 100. 000 25, 100 25, 100 100. 000 100. 000 2013 51- 364- 709- 01‘/ 2016- 014 401 51070 24, 600 24, 600 0. 000 0. 000 24, 600 24, 600 100. 000 0. 000 2016 51- 371- 705- 05I 2016- 021 401 51070 61, 300 55, 843 0. 000 0. 000 61, 300 55, 843 100. 000 0. 000 2016 51- 448- 706- 04 2016- 029 401 51070 26, 800 25, 275 100. 000 0. 000 0 0 100. 000 0. 000 2016 51- 568- 704- 061 2016- 006 401 51070 16, 100 15, 998 0. 000 0. 000 16, 100 15, 998 100. 000 0. 000 2015 51- 568- 704- 06 2016- 007 401 51070 16, 500 15, 951 0. 000 0. 000 16, 500 15, 951 100. 000 0. 000 2014 51- 568- 704- 2016- 008 401 51070 15, 700 15, 700 0. 000 0. 000 15, 700 15, 700 100. 000 0. 000 06j 2016 51- 572- 706- 081 2016- 035 402 51070 900 802 100. 000 0. 000 0 0 100. 000 0. 000 2015 51- 572- 706- 08 2016- 036 402 51070 800 800 100. 000 100. 000 0 0 100. 000 100. 000 2016 51- 574- 712- 070( 2016- 024 401 51070 31, 400 30, 190 0. 000 0. 000 31, 400 30, 190 100. 000 0. 000 2016 51- 612- 325- 1142016-037 401 51070 28, 900 24, 423 0. 000 0. 000 28, 900 24, 423 100. 000 0. 000 Wok- a, + e, . per  Guio uec. MVM unange summary Page: 2/ 2 10: 31 AM DB: City Of Manistee 2017 Corrected Corrected Petition Assessed Taxable Assessed Taxable Corrected Corrected Year Parcel Number Docket Class School Value Value PRE/ MBT Transfer Value Value PRE/ MBT EX Transfer 05v/ 2016 51- 647- 702- 2016- 027 401 51070 19, 800 16, 065 100. 000 0. 000 0 0 100. 000 0. 000 2016 51- 655- 706- 08 2016- 026 401 51070 29, 400 26, 882 0. 000 0. 000 29, 400 26, 882 100. 000 0. 000 2016 51- 670- 706- 05 2016- 033 401 51070 55, 600 44, 892 0. 000 0. 000 55, 600 44, 892 100. 000 0. 000 2016 51- 748- 736- 08 2016- 038 401 51070 19, 100 18, 138 100. 000 0. 000 0 0 100. 000 0. 000 2016 51- 900- 007- 12. 2016- 025 250 51070 11, 700 11, 700 100. 000 0. 000 0 0 100. 000 0. 000 2015 51- 900- 007- 23 2016- 004 002 51070 32, 000 32, 000 100. 000 0. 000 0 0 100. 000 0. 000 2015 51- 900- 010- 58 , / V 2016- 019 002 51070 1, 200 1, 200 100. 000 0. 000 0 0 100. 000 0. 000 2015 51- 900- 010- 92! 2016- 017 002 51070 1, 000 1, 000 100. 000 0. 000 0 0 100. 000 0. 000 2015 51- 900- 011- 38 2016- 020 002 51070 500 500 100. 000 0. 000 0 0 100. 000 0. 000 2016 51- 900- 012- 38 2016- 015 250 51070 2, 100 2, 100 100. 000 0. 000 0 0 100. 000 0. 000 2015 51- 900- 012- 38 2016- 016 250 51070 2, 100 2, 100 100. 000 0. 000 0 0 100. 000 0. 000 J 1. 92 7 o 3 c),'4 . '`,, Winter PRE Change THE BOARD OF REVIEW OF CITY OF MANISTEE, MANISTEE COUNTY, MICHIGAN HEREBY AFFIRMS THAT THE ABOVE INFORMATION IS CORRECT TO THE BEST OF OUR KNOWLEDGE Signatures of Board of Review Members Id tin Memb Membe iric-- Member Member Member Dated I 12/ 14/ 2016 2016 Dec. BOR Change Summary Page: 1/ 2 10: 31 AM DB: City Of Manistee 2017 Corrected Corrected Petition Assessed Taxable Assessed Taxable Corrected Corrected Number Docket Class School Value Value PRE/ MBT Transfer Value Value PRE/ MBT EX Transfer Year Parcel 2016 51- 146- 712- 11 2016 401 51070 37, 300 29, 040 100. 000 0. 000 0 0 100. 000 0. 000 2016 51- 146- 719- 20 2016- 401 51070 29, 200 25, 877 0. 000 0. 000 0 0 100. 000 0. 000 2016 51- 259- 011- 37 2016- 401 51070 178, 200 170, 624 0. 000 0. 000 178, 200 170, 624 100. 000 0. 000 2016 51- 270- 706- 01 2016- 401 51070 58, 200 50, 136 0. 000 0. 000 58, 200 50, 136 100. 000 0. 000 2016 51- 270- 707- 04 2016- 401 51070 34, 300 29, 347 100. 000 0. 000 34, 300 29, 347 100. 000 0. 000 2016 51- 270- 722- 13 2016- 401 51070 31, 800 30, 090 100. 000 0. 000 31, 800 30, 090 100. 000 0. 000 2016 51- 270- 723- 11 2016- 401 51070 36, 500 32, 100 0. 000 0. 000 36, 500 32, 100 100. 000 0. 000 2016 51- 274- 714- 01 2016- 401 51070 49, 800 43, 410 0. 000 0. 000 49, 800 43, 410 100. 000 0. 000 2016 51- 358- 707- 10 2016- 401 51070 86, 000 83, 455 0. 000 0. 000 86, 000 83, 455 100. 000 0. 000 2015 51- 358- 707- 10 2016 401 51070 18, 500 18, 500 0. 000 100. 000 18, 500 18, 500 100. 000 100. 000 2016 51- 364- 703- 11 2016- 401 51070 38, 800 36, 509 0. 000 0. 000 38, 800 36, 509 100. 000 0. 000 2015 51- 364- 703- 11 2016 401 51070 36, 400 36, 400 0. 000 0. 000 36, 400 36, 400 100. 000 0. 000 2015 51- 364- 709- 01 2016- 401 51070 24, 400 24, 400 0. 000 0. 000 24, 400 24, 400 100. 000 0. 000 2014 51- 364- 709- 01 2016 401 51070 25, 100 25, 100 0. 000 100. 000 25, 100 25, 100 100. 000 100. 000 2013 51- 364- 709- 01 2016- 401 51070 24, 600 24, 600 0. 000 0. 000 24, 600 24, 600 100. 000 0. 000 2016 51- 371- 705- 05 2016- 401 51070 61, 300 55, 843 0. 000 0. 000 61, 300 55, 843 100. 000 0. 000 2016 51- 448- 706- 04 2016- 401 51070 26, 800 25, 275 100. 000 0. 000 0 0 100. 000 0. 000 2016 51- 568- 704- 06 2016- 401 51070 16, 100 15, 998 0. 000 0. 000 16, 100 15, 998 100. 000 0. 000 2015 51- 568- 704- 06 2016- 401 51070 16, 500 15, 951 0. 000 0. 000 16, 500 15, 951 100. 000 0. 000 2014 51- 568- 704- 06 2016- 401 51070 15, 700 15, 700 0. 000 0. 000 15, 700 15, 700 100. 000 0. 000 2016 51- 572- 706- 08 2016- 402 51070 900 802 100. 000 0. 000 0 0 100. 000 0. 000 2015 51- 572- 706- 08 2016- 402 51070 800 800 100. 000 100. 000 0 0 100. 000 100. 000 51- 574- 712- 07 2016- 401 51070 31, 400 30, 190 0. 000 0. 000 31, 400 30, 190 100. 000 0. 000 2016 2016 51- 612- 325- 11 2016- 401 51070 28, 900 24, 423 0. 000 0. 000 28, 900 24, 423 100. 000 0. 000 53,- 52-,-5 a :- 909-- 12/ 14/ 2016 2016 Dec. BOR Change Summary Page: 2/ 2 10: 31 AM DB: City Of Manistee 2017 Corrected Corrected Petition Assessed Taxable Assessed Taxable Corrected Corrected Year Parcel Number Docket Class School Value Value PRE/ MBT Transfer Value Value PRE/ MBT EX Transfer 2016 51- 647- 702- 05 2016- 401 51070 19, 800 16, 065 100. 000 0. 000 0 0 100. 000 0. 000 2016 51- 655- 706- 08 2016-, 401 51070 29, 400 26, 882 0. 000 0. 000 29, 400 26, 882 100. 000 0. 000 2016 51- 670- 706- 05 2016-' 401 51070 55, 600 44, 892 0. 000 0. 000 55, 600 44, 892 100. 000 0. 000 2016 51- 748- 736- 08 2016- 401 51070 19, 100 18, 138 100. 000 0. 000 0 0 100. 000 0. 000 2016 51- 900- 007- 12 2016- 250 51070 11, 700 11, 700 100. 000 0. 000 0 0 100. 000 0. 000 2015 51- 900- 007- 23 2016- 002 51070 32, 000 32, 000 100. 000 0. 000 0 0 100. 000 0. 000 2015 51- 900- 010- 58 2016- 002 51070 1, 200 1, 200 100. 000 0. 000 0 0 100. 000 0. 000 2015 51- 900- 010- 92 2016- 002 51070 1, 000 1, 000 100. 000 0. 000 0 0 100. 000 0. 000 2015 51- 900- 011- 38 2016- 002 51070 500 500 100. 000 0. 000 0 0 100. 000 0. 000 2016 51- 900- 012- 38 2016 250 51070 2, 100 2, 100 100. 000 0. 000 0 0 100. 000 0. 000 2015 51- 900- 012- 38 2016- 250 51070 2, 100 2, 100 100. 000 0. 000 0 0 100. 000 0. 000 950, 900 887, 132 Winter PRE Change THE BOARD OF REVIEW OF CITY OF MANISTEE, MANISTEE COUNTY, MICHIGAN HEREBY AFFIRMS THAT THE ABOVE INFORMATION IS CORRECT TO THE BEST OF OUR KNOWLEDGE Signatures of Board of Review Members Memb=/ Irl L G , Membe ` "' Ai-17r-- Member Member Member Dated