Brownfield Redevelopment Authority
Regular MeetingManistee, MI · June 4, 2013
Minutes
MANISTEE CITY BROWNFIELD REDEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY
70 Maple Street
Manistee, MI 49660
MEETING MINUTES
June 4, 2013
A meeting of the Manistee City Brownfield Redevelopment Authority was held on Tuesday,
June 4, 2013 at 2 pm in the Council Chambers, City Hall, 70 Maple Street, Manistee, Michigan.
Meeting was called to order at 2:00 pm by Chair Clinton McKinven-Copus
Roll Call:
Members Present: Steve Brower, Donald Kuk, Marlene McBride, Clinton McKinven-Copus,
Michael Mackin, Jeffrey Stege
Members Absent: Dave Carlson (excused), Lynn Reinhardt, Vacancy
Others: T. Eftaxiadis (Consultant), Jon R. Rose (Community Development Director),
Denise Blakeslee (Planning & Zoning) and others
T. Eftaxiadis attended the meeting via Skype.
APPROVAL OF AGENDA
Motion by Don Kuk, seconded by Michael Mackin that the agenda be approved as prepared.
With a Voice Vote this MOTION PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
APPROVAL OF MINUTES
Motion by Michael Mackin, seconded by Don Kuk that the minutes of the March 5, 2013
Brownfield Redevelopment Authority Meeting be approved as prepared.
Ms. Blakeslee verified that the last meeting that minutes were taken at was August 7, 2013,
there was no quorum at the December 4, 2012 meeting and other scheduled meetings have
been cancelled due to lack of quorum.
With a Voice Vote this MOTION PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
City of Manistee Brownfield Redevelopment Authority
Meeting Minutes of June 4, 2013 Page 1
PUBLC HEARING
None
FINANCIAL REPORTS
Steve Brower entered the meeting at 2:05 pm
NTH Rate Increase Request
On March 22, 2013 a request was received from NTH Consultants, LTD to increase the billing
rate for Staff Professional labor category from $62 to $70.
MOTION by Michael Mackin, seconded by Don Kuk, that the Brownfield Redevelopment
Authority approves the request from NTH Consultants, LTD to increase the billing rate for Staff
Professional services from $62 to $70 for Scott Venman only.
Discussion included:
Member Kuk noted the proposed rate increase is 13% not 4%.
T. Eftaxiadis updated the BRA on changes that have been happening at NTH Consultants Ltd.
(NTH). NTH has had reduction and changes in its Grand Rapids staff that have been providing
environmental services to the BRA under the USEPA grants; NTH is now using staff from SE
Michigan to cover the BRA’s projects. Due to staffing limitations NTH has informed us that they
are unable to continue performing Phase I ESAs for the EPA grants; Phase I ESAs have been
performed at a lump sum basis.NTH will continue to provideg Phase II ESA, BEA, Due Care Plan
services on a time and material basis per its contract terms with the BRA.
Mr. Eftaxiadis recommends that the requested Staff Professional rate increase be approved
only for the work performed by Mr. Scott Venman, currently a Staff Professional functioning at
a higher level.
In 2008 the BRA contracted with EC&S of Traverse City for Phase I E.S.A.’s (lump sum rate).
NTH was contracted at that time to perform Phase II ESAs as well as other environmental
services (time and material basis); the contract also allowed for NTH to perform Phase I ESAs on
a lump sum basis, at the BRA’s discretion. EC&S ceased operations in 2010. Since the BRA’s
contract with NTH allowed the performance of Phase I ESAs, several Phase I ESAs were assigned
to, and performed byNTH. NTH did a good job on the Phase I ESAs until recently when they
informed us that they will can no longer efficiently provide this service.
Because the Grants run out at the end of September, and we only expect to need few more
City of Manistee Brownfield Redevelopment Authority
Meeting Minutes of June 4, 2013 Page 2
Phase I ESAs,T. Eftaxiadis offered to perform the few remaining Phase I ESAs through Eftaxiadis
Consulting Inc.
The members agreed to discuss how Phase I ESAs were to be addressed under New Business.
With a Voice Vote this MOTION PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Approval of Invoices
Members reviewed the summary of Invoices Submitted for Payment.
MOTION by Don Kuk, seconded by Marlene McBride to approve payment of invoices as follows:
With a Voice Vote this MOTION PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
City of Manistee Brownfield Redevelopment Authority
Meeting Minutes of June 4, 2013 Page 3
NEW BUSINESS
Phase I E.S.A.’s
The Authority needed to determine how Phase I ESAs were to be handled since EC&S is no
longer in business and NTH is no longer able to perform them.
MOTION by Don Kuk, seconded by Michael Mackin
WHEREAS, EC&S is no longer able to provide Phase I ES.As, and
WHEREAS, NTH Consultiants Ltd is no longer able to provide Phase I ESAs to the BRA’s USEPA
Grants, and
WHEREAS, there are four months remaining in the USEPA Grants, and
WHEREAS, the single Phase I ESA. rate from EC&S was $2,400, and
WHEREAS, the single Phase I ESA. rate from NTH was $2,100, and
WEHREAS, there is not sufficient time to advertise and procure a new vendor to provide Phase I
ESAs, therefore, be it
RESOLVED that the City of Manistee Brownfield Redevelopment Authority authorizes T.
Eftaxiadis, of Eftaxiadis Consulting Inc. to complete remaining Phase I ESAs for a lump sum rate
of $2,000 each, be it further
RESOLVED that Eftaxiadis Consulting Inc. will finish Phase I ESAs for 166 Cleveland Street and
133 16th Street plus up to four additional Phase I ESAs for a total of six by the end of the USEPA
Grants period.
With a Voice Vote this MOTION PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
US EPA Grant Status
T. Eftaxiadis prepared a Status Memo for the Members of the Brownfield Redevelopment
Authority which updated them on the status of current projects. The memo read as follows:
1. USEPA Grants.
a. Our request to amend the grant budgets has been approved by USEPA. Unused
funds in the Personnel, Supplies, Travel and Other budgeted categories were shifted
to the Contractual budget category. The original and amended budget categories for
each Grant are shown below.
City of Manistee Brownfield Redevelopment Authority
Meeting Minutes of June 4, 2013 Page 4
NEW
BUDGET TASK ORIGINAL BUDGET BUDGET
PERSONNEL $36,000.00 $10,000.00
FRINGE BENEFITS $0.00 $0.00
TRAVEL $7,000.00 $3,000.00
EQUIPMENT $4,000.00 $0.00
SUPPLIES $12,000.00 $10,000.00
CONTRACTUAL $130,000.00 $174,000.00
CONSTRUCTION $0.00 $0.00
OTHER $8,000.00 $0.00
TOTAL DIRECT
CHARGES $197,000.00 $197,000.00
b. We have completed or we are working on Phase I and II Environmental Site
Assessments (ESA) and Baseline Environmental Assessments (BEA), at the following
properties:
i. Veterans Memorial Park. The Phase I ESA is complete. We do not anticipate
conducting a Phase II ESA at this property.
ii. Former Hotel Chippewa. The Phase I ESA is complete. The prospective
property buyer has not provided a redevelopment plan, therefore, we do not
plan to conduct a Phase II ESA or a BEA at this property.
iii. North Channel Outlet. We are still waiting for formal access to the property
from the property owner.
iv. Seng’s Marina. The Phase I ESA has been completed. The property is a
“facility” per MDEQ rules. No BEA is needed since no change in ownership is
pending.
v. MAPS Vocational Training Facility. At the request of the buyer and
prospective redeveloper of this property, we have completed a Phase I ESA, a
Phase II ESA, and an Asbestos & Lead Survey. The property is a “facility” per
MDEQ rules, therefore we also prepared a BEA.
vi. Former Tuscan Grill. At the request of the DDA-Main Street and the new
owners and prospective redevelopers of this property, we have completed a
Phase I ESA and a Phase II ESA. The property is a “facility” per MDEQ rules,
therefore, we also prepared a BEA.
vii. 166 Cleveland Street Property (former Auto Value store). At the request of
the new owners and their financial institution, we are currently working on
City of Manistee Brownfield Redevelopment Authority
Meeting Minutes of June 4, 2013 Page 5
Phase I and Phase II ESAs. The property is a “facility” per MDEQ rules,
therefore, we are currently finalizing a BEA. An Asbestos & Lead Survey has
been completed.
viii. 133 16th Street Property (former DRK Cabinetry). At the request of the new
owners and their financial institution, we are currently working on Phase I.
Based on the preliminary findings of the Phase I ESA, we anticipate that a
Phase II ESA and a BEA will be needed.
2. OTHER. At this time, we have not received any formal requests for future ESAs or BEAs.
However, based on preliminary inquiries and discussions, we anticipate working on few
more ESAs and BEAs before the Grants expire at the end of September.
Jon Rose reported that a 48” color scanner/printer has been purchased using BRA Grant Funds.
The cost was under the $8,000 estimate and the invoice will be on the next financial statement
for the BRA to approve.
Membership
The City of Manistee Brownfield Redevelopment Authority (BRA) Board of Directors currently is
a nine member board (eight members/one vacancy). Under the Brownfield Redevelopment
Financing Act, the membership in a BRA can be not less than five nor more than nine persons.
Article II Directors, Section 2 - Board of Directors, of the City of Manistee BRA By-Laws reads the
same.
Council recently reduced the number of members on the Planning Commission from nine to
seven to make it easier to maintain full membership and reduce training costs. Due to ongoing
difficulties in getting applicants for the BRA Board of Directors and to ensure quorums at
meetings staff proposes that the BRA recommends that City Council reduce the number of the
Board of Directors members from nine to seven.
Mr. Eftaxiadis reported that other communities have been reducing the number of BRA
members from nine to seven or even to five.
MOTION by Don Kuk, seconded by Michael Mackin that the Brownfield Redevelopment
Authority recommends to City Council to reduce the number of Board of Directors members
from nine to seven.
With a Voice Vote this MOTION PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Appointment of a Recording Secretary 2013
Sarah Wojciechowski was the Recording Secretary for the Brownfield Redevelopment Authority
until she retired on March 31, 2013. Denise Blakeslee is currently the Recording Secretary for
City of Manistee Brownfield Redevelopment Authority
Meeting Minutes of June 4, 2013 Page 6
the Planning Commission, Historic District Commission and Zoning Board of Appeals. Ms.
Blakeslee works in the Community Development Department which provides support staff for
the Brownfield Redevelopment Authority.
MOTION by Don Kuk, seconded by Marlene McBride that Denise Blakeslee be appointed as the
Brownfield Redevelopment Authority Recording Secretary for 2013.
With a Voice Vote this MOTION PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
ByLaw Review
Staff is recommending that the Brownfield Redevelopment Authority amend Section 2.7
Meetings and Section 3.2. These changes are similar to how the Planning Commission, Historic
District Commission and Zoning Board of Appeals handle their annual election of officers and
would establish quarterly meetings for the BRA with the option to call additional meetings as
needed.
Motion by Don Kuk, seconded by Michael Mackin that the Brownfield Redevelopment Authority
could amend their By-Laws as follows:
2.7 Meetings. Meetings of the Board may be called by or at the request of
the Chairperson of the Board or any two Directors. The meetings of the Board
shall be public, and the appropriate notice of such meetings shall be provided to
the public. Regular meetings of the Brownfield Redevelopment Authority shall
be held in each calendar quarter of each year. In no event shall there be less
than four (4) meetings per year. The Board shall hold an Annual Meeting in
January in the third calendar quarter of each year at which time officers of the
Board shall be elected as provided in Article 3, Section 2.
AND
3.2 Nomination, Election and Term of Office. The officers of the Authority
shall be elected by the Board at an Annual Meeting held in January during the
third calendar quarter of each year. Candidates shall be nominated by any
Brownfield Redevelopment Authority Board member present at the meeting.
With a Voice Vote this MOTION PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Schedule Meetings for July 2013 and October 2013
In an effort to eliminate quorum problems and meeting cancellations the Brownfield
Redevelopment Authority discussed scheduling quarterly meetings. If a special meeting is
necessary to address an unexpected issue, staff will work around members’ schedules to secure
a quorum. Members discussed dates.
MOTION by Michael Mackin, seconded by Don Kuk that the Brownfield Redevelopment
City of Manistee Brownfield Redevelopment Authority
Meeting Minutes of June 4, 2013 Page 7
Authority schedules meetings for July 30, 2013 and October 29, 2013.
With a Voice Vote this MOTION PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
The previous monthly meetings scheduled for the first Tuesday of each month at 2pm will be
cancelled.
OLD BUSINESS
None
PUBLIC COMMENTS AND COMMUNICATIONS
None
CORRESPONDENCE
None
STAFF REPORTS
None
MEMBERS DISCUSSION
None
The next regular meeting of the Brownfield Redevelopment Authority will be held on July 30,
2013 at 2 pm in the Council Chambers.
ADJOURNMENT
Motion by Marlene McBride, seconded by Steve Brower that the meeting be adjourned.
MOTION PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Meeting adjourned at 3:02 pm
MANISTEE CITY BROWNFIELD REDEVLOPMENT AUTHORITY
____________________________________
Denise J. Blakeslee, Recording Secretary
City of Manistee Brownfield Redevelopment Authority
Meeting Minutes of June 4, 2013 Page 8
Agenda
MANISTEE CITY BROWNFIELD REDEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY
Meeting of June 4, 2013
2:00 pm - Council Chambers, City Hall, 70 Maple Street,
Manistee, Michigan
AGENDA
I CALL TO ORDER
II ROLL CALL
III APPROVAL OF AGENDA
At this time the Brownfield Redevelopment Authority can take action to approve the June 4, 2013 Agenda.
IV APPROVAL OF MINUTES
At this time Brownfield Redevelopment Authority can take action to approve the March 5, 2013 meeting
Minutes.
V PUBLIC HEARING
None
VI FINANCIAL REPORTS
NTH Rate Increase Request
On March 22, 2013 a request was received from NTH Consultants, LTD to increase the billing rate for Staff
Professional services from $62 to $70.
At this time the Brownfield Redevelopment Authority can take action on the request from NTH
Consultants, LTD to increase the billing rate for Staff Professional services from $62 to $70.
Approval of Invoices
At this time the Brownfield Redevelopment Authority can take action to approve invoices for payment
VII NEW BUSINESS
US EPA Grant Status
Staff will update the Brownfield Redevelopment Authority on the status of current projects.
Page 1 of 2
Membership
Staff will discuss with the members the option of reducing the number of members from nine to seven.
Appointment of a Recording Secretary 2013
At this time the Brownfield Redevelopment Authority may appoint a Recording Secretary for 2013.
By Law Review
Staff is recommending that the Brownfield Redevelopment Authority amend Section 2.7 Meetings and
Section 3.2.
At this time the Brownfield Redevelopment Authority could take action to make changes to their By-Laws
as recommended by staff.
VIII OLD BUSINESS
IX PUBLIC COMMENTS AND COMMUNICATIONS
At this time the Chair will ask if there are any public comments.
X CORRESPONDENCE
At this time the Chair will ask if any correspondence has been received to be read into the record.
XI STAFF REPORTS
At this time the Chair will ask Staff for their report.
XII MEMBERS DISCUSSION
At this time the Chair will ask members of the Brownfield Redevelopment Authority if they have any items
they want to discuss.
XIII ADJOURNMENT
Page 2 of 2
CITY OF MANISTEE BROWNFIELD REDEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY
70 Maple Street
Manistee, MI 49660
MEETING MINUTES
March 5, 2013
A regularly scheduled meeting of the Manistee City Brownfield Redevelopment Authority was held on
Tuesday, March 5, 2013 at 2pm in the Council Chambers, City Hall, 70 Maple Street, Manistee, Michigan.
Meeting was called to order at 2:03 pm by Chair McKinven-Copus
Roll Call:
Members Present: Steve Brower, Don Kuk, Marlene McBride, Michael Mackin, Clinton McKinven-
Copus, Jeffrey Stege,
Members Absent: Dave Carlson, Lynn Reinhardt (excused), Vacancy
Others: T. Eftaxiadis (Environmental & Brownfield Consulting), Jon R. Rose (BRA
Administrator), and Denise Blakeslee (Temporary Recording Secretary)
APPROVAL OF AGENDA
Motion by Jeff Stege, seconded by Steve Brower that the agenda be approved as prepared.
With a voice vote this motion passed unanimously.
PUBLC HEARING
None
APPROVAL OF MINUTES
Motion by Don Kuk, seconded by Jeff Stege that the minutes of the August 7, 2012 Brownfield
Redevelopment Authority Meeting be approved as prepared.
With a voice vote this motion passed unanimously.
FINANCIAL REPORTS
Invoices for payment - Members reviewed the Summary of Invoices Submitted for Payment.
City of Manistee Brownfield Redevelopment Authority
Meeting Minutes March 5, 2013 Page 1
MOTION by Don Kuk, seconded by Jeff Stege to approve payment of invoices as follows:
VENDOR NAME INVOICE INVOICE INVOICE SERVICE DESCRIPTION
DATE NUMBER AMOUNT
Fibertec Environmental 14-Sep-12 11136 $16.00 Polarized light microscopy-334 River Street
Services project, floor and mastic samples
Fibertec Environmental 19-Sep-12 92415 $10.00 334 River Street project; flaking paint sample
Services
Environmental Data 11-Sep-12 3402665 $325.00 Research service, Veterans Memorial Park,
Resources Maple Street/Memorial Drive.
Environmental Data 11-Sep-12 3403230 $325.00 Research service, River Parc Place, 86
Resources Washington St.
Environmental Data 10-Sep-12 3402660 $325.00 Research service, City of Manistee Industrial
Resources Park area, Duffy Park Drive, Duffy Park/S.
Glocheski Drive.
Environmental Data 11-Dec-12 3470615 $375.00 EPA Hazardous Grant Task H2B-CH1 - Hotel
Resources Chippewa; Phase I ESA
Geotech 11-Oct-12 383785 $312.47 Environmental equipment (handle, cross;
extension; auger)
NTH Consultants 10-Aug-12 584657 $6,642.91 Phase II Bookmark $1,510.22; Phase II Hotel
Northern $2,098.54.
NTH Consultants 10-Aug-12 584658 $3,700.00 Bookmark Phase 1; 23 Ashland Site Phase I;
US-31 Sand Pit Phase I; Rodeway Inn Phase
I; Hotel Northern Phase I,
NTH Consultants 26-Oct-12 586144 $2,150.95 River Parc Place II Phase BEA Update and
BEA 86 Washington.
NTH Consultants 26-Dec-12 587311 $8,238.65 Engineering & Consulting Services Phase II
Environmental Services
NTH Consultants 7-Jan-13 587548 $4,464.16 Engineering & Consulting Services, Phase II
Environmental Services
Abonmarche 31-Oct-12 105545 $400.00 Professional Services, Century Terrace
Monitor Wells
Eftaxiadis Consulting 17-Oct-12 CMBRA- $2,132.00 Consulting Services - USEPA 2007 Grant -
Inc. 1209H Hazardous
Eftaxiadis Consulting 17-Oct-12 cmbra- $2,214.00 Consulting - USEPA Grant - Petroleum
Inc. 1209p
Eftaxiadis Consulting 15-Nov-12 CMBRA- $328.00 Technical Service - MDEQ Grant, 334 River
Inc. 1209D Street, Sept 12 misc. technical services
Eftaxiadis Consulting 14-Dec-12 CMBRA- $3,280.00 Consulting Services - USEPA 1007 Grant -
Inc. 1211H Hazardous
Eftaxiadis Consulting 14-Dec-12 CMBRA- $1,414.50 Consulting Services - USEPA 1007 Grant -
Inc. 1211P Hazardous
Eftaxiadis Consulting 29-Jan-13 CMBRA1212- $287.00 USEPA 2007 Grant - Petroleum
Inc. P
Eftaxiadis Consulting 14-Jan-13 CMBRA- $1,619.50 Environmental Consulting and Consulting -
Inc. 1212-H USEPA 2007 Grant - Hazardous
Eftaxiadis Consulting 30-Jan-13 CMBRA- $233.75 Technical Services _ MDEQ Grant (334 River
Inc. 1212D St.)233.75
City of Manistee Brownfield Redevelopment Authority
Meeting Minutes March 5, 2013 Page 2
Eftaxiadis Consulting 3-Dec-12 CMBRA- $471.50 Technical Service - MDEQ Grant, 3334 River
Inc. 1211D Street. Oct and Nov 2012 misc technical
services
TOTAL: $39,265.39
With a voice vote motion passed unanimously.
NEW BUSINESS:
US EPA Grants Status
Mr. Eftaxiadis gave the members an update on the following projects:
Harbor View – Phase II Environmental Site Assessment (ESA) was completed. Low levels of heavy
metals were detected in few soil and groundwater samples at concentrations exceeding cleanup
criteria; the site is a “facility”. The metals are associated with fill materials, typical throughout
City.
Century Terrace - Phase II Environmental Site Assessment (ESA) was completed. Low levels of
heavy metals and PNAs were detected in soils at several locations; the site is a “facility”. No
contamination was detected in the groundwater.
Seng’s Marina – A Phase II ESA was requested by owner, due to future expansion considered for
portions of the property. The ESA has been completed and we have just received the draft
report for review. We will discuss it at next meeting.
River Park Place II – Mr. Eftaxiadis stated that he represents the developer; has cleared potential
conflict of interest with attorney. As part of the property transfer, the new owners requested a
Baseline Environmental Assessment (BEA) through the EPA grant. The BEA, including an updated
Phase I ESA was performed by NTH as required before submitting the BEA to the State. The
developer has had discussions with City on collaborating on Brownfield Plan to include Public
Infrastructure Improvements in the vicinity of the site. The BRA Plan approved in 2005 through
the County BRA was never “activated”, as the former developer completed “eligible” activities
but did not request reimbursement of eligible costs, therefore the old BRA Plan can be
terminated; a new one may be developed for the new and expanded project . This issue will be
addressed at a future meeting.
Former Hotel Chippewa – The prospective buyer and its financial institution have requested
Phase I & Phase II ESAs and a BEA, if needed. The property had a greenhouse on it and has
potential environmental issues associated with pesticides and other chemicals used. We will
begin a Phase II ESA when the weather permits, subject to receiving a better redevelopment
plan from the developer, in order to justify funding from the EPA grant.
Veterans Memorial Park – A Phase I ESA is being performed at this site, to assist the DDA with
assessing the suitability of site conditions for placing buildings or other structures on the site at
a future. There are past Leaking UST issues associated with nearby properties that may impact
City of Manistee Brownfield Redevelopment Authority
Meeting Minutes March 5, 2013 Page 3
the park site. We just received the draft ESA report from NTH for review. We will report on the
findings at the next meeting.
MAPS Vocational Training Building – A redeveloper who has a purchase agreement on the
property, has requested the BRA’s assistance with performing ESAs at the site due to the past
uses of the building (auto dealership and garage). The proposed future use is for an eating and
drinking establishment. There are hoists with hydraulic oils, used motor oil, stained floors with
floor drains, and asbestos on site. The preliminary findings of the ESAs will be available in the
next two weeks. A BRA Plan will be probably required to deal with site environmental
conditions, removal of hoists, asbestos, cleaning floors, etc. An application for BRA’s financial
assistance and a development plan will be required prior to processing a BRA Plan.
Tuscan Grill – We are working with the City , the buyers and the DDA in dealing with the
environmental due diligence issues related to the acquisition of the property We are currently
conducting the Phase I & Phase II ESAs; NTH completed the sampling last week. We anticipate
the need for a BEA. We are operating under an extremely tight schedule, due to the anticipated
purchase of the property in May, wanting to open the restaurant in June. Previous sampling in
2008 (Phase I & II) was done by bank; however we have to have new samples and a Phase I ESA
to move forward with the BEA.
Prospective River Parc Place II BRA Plan – as discussed earlier a request may be received for a BRA Plan.
Prospective MAPS Vocational Training BRA Plan - as discussed earlier a request may be received for a
BRA Plan
UNFINISHED BUSINESS
None
OTHER COMMUNCATIONS
None
STAFF COMMUNICATIONS
Scanner/Plotter
Mr. Rose spoke to the members about purchasing a large document sized scanner/plotter with grant
funds. Mr. Eftaxiadis said that there is money from both grants that could be used for the purchase, and
that the scanner is needed to deal with many large size documents generated under the grant work.
City of Manistee Brownfield Redevelopment Authority
Meeting Minutes March 5, 2013 Page 4
Mr. Rose asked if the members would authorize up to $10,000 of grant funds for the purchase of the
equipment.
MOTION by Don Kuk, seconded by Marlene McBride that the BRA authorizes the spending up to $10,000
to purchase a large document sized scanner/plotter with grant funds. Motion unanimously approved.
Brownfield Act Amendments
T. Eftaxiadis discussed with the members recent amendments to the Brownfield Redevelopment
Financing Act (P.A. 381 of 1996), and the implications of the amendments to the business of the BRA.
Training
New members on the Authority asked about training. Mr. Eftaxiadis spoke to the members about
providing a training that would last approximately two hours. Discussion followed and will confirm with
members a training session following the April 2, 2013 meeting starting around 4pm.
CITIZEN QUESTIONS, CONCERNS AND CONSDERATION:
None
WORK/STUDY SESSION
None
The next regular meeting of the Brownfield Redevelopment Authority will be held on Tuesday, April 2,
2013 at 2pm in the Council Chambers.
ADJOURNMENT
Motion by Don Kuk, seconded by Marlene McBride that the meeting be adjourned.
MOTION PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Meeting adjourned at 3:25 pm
BROWNFIELD REDEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY
____________________________________
Denise J. Blakeslee
Temporary Recording Secretary
City of Manistee Brownfield Redevelopment Authority
Meeting Minutes March 5, 2013 Page 5
BROWNFIELD REDEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY
P.O. Box 358, Manistee, Michigan 49660-0358 www.mansiteemi.gov
City Hall, 70 Maple Street * 231.398.2805 Phone* 231.723.1546 FAX
TO: Brownfield Redevelopment Authority Members
FROM: Jon R. Rose
Community Development Director
DATE: May 3, 2013
RE: NTH – Rate Increase Request
Good Morning!
We have received a request from NTH Consultants, LTD requesting a rate increase for their services.
Our contract with NTH allows them a maximum 4% annual rate increase for each labor classification.
They are only requesting a rate increase for Staff Professional from $62 to $70.
I have reviewed the request and feel that the increase is reasonable and recommends the BRA to
authorize the rate increase effective April 1, 2013.
:djb
Invoice Summary for BRA Meeting 6/4/13
INVOICE INVOICE INVOICE
VENDOR NAME SERVICE DESCRIPTION
DATE NUMBER AMOUNT
Environmental Data Resources 02/27/13 3527753 $325.00 EPA Grant - PETROLEUM; Phase I ESA Database; Tuscan Grill
Inc
Environmental Data Resources 02/27/13 3527752 $325.00 EPA Grant - PETROLEUM; Phase I ESA Database; MAPS Voc Center
Inc
Eftaxiadis Consulting Inc. 03/12/13 CMBRA-1302-H $2,465.00 EPA Grant - HAZARDOUS; technical project coordination and Brownfield
redevelopment assistance; Hotel Chippewa, North Channel Outlet, 401
River St, Kennedy School; services for Jan-Feb '13
Eftaxiadis Consulting Inc. 03/12/13 CMBRA-1302-P $7,458.75 EPA Grant - PETROLEUM; technical project coordination and Brownfield
redevelopment assistance; 166 Cleveland, Hokanson, MAPS Voc Center,
Tuscan Grill, Veterans Memorial Park, Century Terrace; services for Jan-
Feb '13
Fibertec Industrial Hygiene 03/04/13 13149 $20.00 EPA Grant - PETROLEUM; Asbestos samples analysis; MAPS Voc Center
Services Inc.
NTH Consultants Ltd 03/20/13 588520 $2,178.73 EPA Grants HAZARDOUS & PETROLEUM; Phase II ESAs; Century Terrace
and Seng's Marina
NTH Consultants Ltd 03/15/13 588424 $3,700.00 EPA Grants HAZARDOUS & PETROLEUM; Phase I ESAs; Former Hotel
Chippewa and Veterans Memorial Park
Eftaxiadis Consulting Inc. 03/26/13 CMBRA-1303-D $1,851.94 MDEQ Grant - 334 RIVER; technical project coordination and support;
334 River Street Project (close-out); services for Jan-Mar '13
Environmental Data Resources 04/03/13 3561674 $325.00 EPA Grant - PETROLEUM; Phase I ESA Database; 166 Cleveland
Inc
NTH Consultants Ltd 04/12/13 588828 $1,850.00 EPA Grant - PETROLEUM; Phase I ESA; MAPS Voc Center
NTH Consultants Ltd 04/12/13 588829 $5,980.38 EPA Grant - PETROLEUM; Phase II ESA (partial); MAPS Voc Center
NTH Consultants Ltd 04/12/13 588830 $1,850.00 EPA Grant - PETROLEUM; Phase I ESA; Tuscan Grill site
NTH Consultants Ltd 04/12/13 588831 $5,326.42 EPA Grant - PETROLEUM; Phase II ESA (partial); Tuscan Grill site
Eftaxiadis Consulting Inc. 04/03/13 CMBRA-1303 $580.00 BRA Admin and Technical Support Services
Eftaxiadis Consulting Inc. 04/03/13 CMBRA-1303-H $637.50 EPA Grant - HAZARDOUS; technical program mgmt; services for Mar '13
Eftaxiadis Consulting Inc. 04/03/13 CMBRA-1303-P $3,102.50 EPA Grant - PETROLEUM; technical project coordination and Brownfield
redevelopment assistance; 166 Cleveland, MAPS Voc Center, Tuscan
Grill, Veterans Memorial Park, General Chemical, Rodway Inn; technical
program mgmt; services for Mar '13
Environmental Data Resources 05/01/13 3589111 $325.00 EPA Grant - HAZARDOUS; Phase I ESA Database; 133 16th Street
Inc
TOTAL: $38,301.22
Memo
To: Jon Rose, City of Manistee Brownfield Redevelopment Authority
From: T. Eftaxiadis, Eftaxiadis Consulting Inc.
Date: June 4, 2013
Re: Projects and Grants Status
1. USEPA Grants.
a. Our request to amend the grant budgets has been approved by USEPA. Unused funds in
the Personnel, Supplies, Travel and Other budgeted categories were shifted to the
Contractual budget category. The original and amended budget categories are shown
below.
NEW
BUDGET TASK ORIGINAL BUDGET BUDGET
PERSONNEL $36,000.00 $10,000.00
FRINGE BENEFITS $0.00 $0.00
TRAVEL $7,000.00 $3,000.00
EQUIPMENT $4,000.00 $0.00
SUPPLIES $12,000.00 $10,000.00
CONTRACTUAL $130,000.00 $174,000.00
CONSTRUCTION $0.00 $0.00
OTHER $8,000.00 $0.00
TOTAL DIRECT
CHARGES $197,000.00 $197,000.00
b. We have completed or we are working on Phase I and II Environmental Site Assessments
(ESA) and Baseline Environmental Assessments (BEA), at the following properties:
i. Veterans Memorial Park. The Phase I ESA is complete. We do not anticipate
conducting a Phase II ESA at this property.
ii. Former Hotel Chippewa. The Phase I ESA is complete. The prospective property
buyer has not provided a redevelopment plan, therefore, we do not plan to
conduct a Phase II ESA or a BEA at this property.
iii. North Channel Outlet. We are still waiting for formal access to the property from
the property owner.
iv. Seng’s Marina. The Phase I ESA has been completed. The property is a “facility”
per MDEQ rules. No BEA is needed since no change in ownership is pending.
Page 1 of 2
v. MAPS Vocational Training Facility. At the request of the buyer and prospective
redeveloper of this property, we have completed a Phase I ESA, a Phase II ESA,
and an Asbestos & Lead Survey. The property is a “facility” per MDEQ rules,
therefore we also prepared a BEA.
vi. Former Tuscan Grill. At the request of the DDA-Main Street and the new owners
and prospective redevelopers of this property, we have completed a Phase I ESA
and a Phase II ESA. The property is a “facility” per MDEQ rules, therefore, we
also prepared a BEA.
vii. 166 Cleveland Street Property (former Auto Value store). At the request of the
new owners and their financial institution, we are currently working on Phase I
and Phase II ESAs. The property is a “facility” per MDEQ rules, therefore, we are
currently finalizing a BEA. An Asbestos & Lead Survey has been completed.
th
viii. 133 16 Street Property (former DRK Cabinetry). At the request of the new
owners and their financial institution, we are currently working on Phase I. Based
on the preliminary findings of the Phase I ESA, we anticipate that a Phase II ESA
and a BEA will be needed.
2. OTHER. At this time, we have not received any formal requests for future ESAs or BEAs.
However, based on preliminary inquiries and discussions, we anticipate working on few more
ESAs and BEAs before the Grants expire at the end of September.
Page 2 of 2
BROWNFIELD REDEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY
P.O. Box 358, Manistee, Michigan 49660-0358 www.mansiteemi.gov
City Hall, 70 Maple Street * 231.398.2805 Phone* 231.723.1546 FAX
TO: Brownfield Redevelopment Authority Board Members
FROM: Jon R. Rose, Administrator
DATE: May 6, 2013
RE: City of Manistee Brownfield Redevelopment Authority Board of Directors Membership
Good Morning!
The City of Manistee Brownfield Redevelopment Authority (BRA) Board of Directors currently is a
nine member board (eight members/one vacancy). Under the Brownfield Redevelopment Financing
Act, the membership in a BRA can be not less than five nor more than nine persons. Article II
Directors, Section 2 - Board of Directors, of the City of Manistee BRA By-Laws reads the same.
Council recently reduced the number of members on the Planning Commission from nine to seven to
make it easier to maintain full membership and reduce training costs. Due to ongoing difficulties in
getting applicants for the BRA Board of Directors and to ensure quorum for our meetings, I propose
that the BRA recommends that City Council reduce the number of the Board of Directors members
from nine to seven. This may be accomplished by a motion at the BRA’s next meeting.
We can discuss this further at our next meeting. Please free to contact me if you have questions
concerning this proposal.
:djb
BROWNFIELD REDEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY
P.O. Box 358, Manistee, Michigan 49660-0358 www.manisteemi.gov
City Hall, 70 Maple Street * 231.398.2805 Phone* 231.723.1546 FAX
TO: Brownfield Redevelopment Authority Board Members
FROM: Jon R. Rose, Administrator
DATE: May 6, 2013
RE: Recording Secretary/By Law Changes
Good Morning!
With Sarah’s retirement Denise Blakeslee will provide clerical support to the BRA. Ms. Blakeslee currently is
the Recording Secretary for the Planning Commission, Historic District Commission and Zoning Board of
Appeals. We have discussed how to include the duties of the BRA into her schedule. In an effort to avoid
items falling through the cracks, I have concurred with Denise that the Annual Meeting (Election of Officers
and By Law Review) should be moved from the third calendar quarter to January. Denise has been in the
process of organizing all of the BRA files and reports, she has reformatted the agenda and memos will be
attached to most agenda items.
In an effort to eliminate quorum problems and meeting cancellations, we discussed scheduling quarterly
meetings. It will make it easier for the members to know what dates meetings will be held. If a special
meeting is necessary we will then work around members schedules to obtain a quorum. Please bring your
calendars with you so that we can schedule meetings for the remainder of 2013 and discuss options for 2014.
Denise will be mailing out meeting packets the week before the meeting so that it reminds members that a
meeting is scheduled and gives you time to review materials before the meeting. If members are unable to
attend a meeting they need to contact Denise to be excused.
In order to make these changes, the By Laws will need to be amended. Staff review of the By Laws resulted in
changes to Sections 2.7 and 3.2 to read as follows:
2.7 Meetings. Meetings of the Board may be called by or at the request of the Chairperson of the Board
or any two Directors. The meetings of the Board shall be public, and the appropriate notice of such
meetings shall be provided to the public. Regular meetings of the Brownfield Redevelopment
Authority shall be held in each calendar quarter of each year. In no event shall there be less than
four (4) meetings per year. The Board shall hold an Annual Meeting in January in the third calendar
quarter of each year at which time officers of the Board shall be elected as provided in Article 3,
Section 2.
AND
3.2 Nomination, Election and Term of Office. The officers of the Authority shall be elected by the Board
at an Annual Meeting held in January during the third calendar quarter of each year. Candidates shall
be nominated by any Brownfield Redevelopment Authority Board member present at the meeting.
JRR:djb
BYLAWS OF THE CITY OF MANISTEE
BROWNFIELD REDEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY
ARTICLE 1: NAME AND ADDRESS
Name: The name of the Authority is the City of Manistee Brownfield Redevelopment Authority
(hereinafter referred to as the Authority).
Address: The address of the Authority is: 70 Maple Street, P.O Box 358, Manistee, Michigan 49660.
ARTICLE 2: DIRECTORS
2.1 General Powers. The business and affairs of the Authority shall be managed by its Board, except as
otherwise provided by statute or by these Bylaws.
2.2 Board of Directors. The Board of Directors (hereinafter referred to as the Board) of the Authority
shall consist of not less than five (5) persons and not more than nine (9) persons. BRA Board
members are to be city residents or persons with an interest in property in the City of Manistee.
2.3 Terms, Replacement and Vacancies. Of the initial members appointed, an equal number, or as near
as practicable, shall be appointed for one year, two years and three years. Thereafter, each member
shall serve for a term of three years. Subsequent Directors shall be appointed in the same manner
as original appointments at the expiration of each Director’s term of office. A Director whose term
of office has expired shall continue to hold office until his/her successor has been appointed with
the advice and consent of the City Council. A Director may be reappointed with the advice and
consent of the City Council to serve additional terms. If a vacancy is created by death or resignation,
a successor shall be appointed with the advice and consent of the City Council within thirty (30) days
to hold office for the remainder of the term of office so vacated.
2.4 Board Absences. In order to maintain the maximum participation of all appointed Brownfield
Redevelopment Authority members at all scheduled meetings, the following is the attendance guide
and Board member replacement policy for “excused” or “unexcused” absences.
1. When appointed, each Board Member should state his/her willingness and intention to attend
each scheduled meeting of the Brownfield Redevelopment Authority.
2. In the event of unplanned personal matters, business trips, family vacation trips, changed job
requirements, sickness, or other physical disabilities that prohibit the Board Member from
attending the scheduled meeting; the Commission Chair or Staff Liaison to the Brownfield
Redevelopment Authority should be notified as soon as possible prior to the time of the
scheduled meeting of their inability to attend. The Board Member upon this notification will
receive an “excused absence” for the involved scheduled meeting.
3. If any Board Member is absent from three (3) consecutive scheduled meetings without an
“excused absence” for any of the three (3) meetings, the Board Member shall be reported in
writing to the City Manager. The City Manager will contact the Board Member in writing and
question his/her continued ability or interest in being on the Commission, giving the member a
chance to rectify the attendance issue or submit a resignation.
City of Manistee Brownfield Redevelopment Authority By Laws Page 1
4. There will be no limit on the number of consecutive “excused absences” for any Board Member.
However, if the Board Member is repeatedly absent for at least 50% of the yearly scheduled
meetings, that member will also be reported in writing to the City Manager. The City Manager
will contact the Board Member in writing and question the member’s continued ability or
interest to be on the Commission. The Board Member will be considered for an appointment
nullification when the absences total six in the calendar year.
5. The appointment nullification action would be initiated by the City Manager and forwarded on
to the City Council for official action.
2.5 Removal. A Director may be removed form office for inefficiency, neglect of duty, or misconduct or
malfeasance, by a majority vote of the City Council.
2.6 Conflict of Interest. A Director who has a direct interest in any matter before the Authority shall
disclose his/her interest prior to any discussion of that matter by the Authority, which disclosure
shall become a part of the record of the Authority’s official proceedings. The interested Director
shall further refrain from participation in the Authority’s action to the matter. Each Director, upon
taking office and annually thereafter, shall acknowledge in writing that they have read and agree to
abide by this section.
2.7 Meetings. Meetings of the Board may be called by or at the request of the Chairperson of the Board
or any two Directors. The meetings of the Board shall be public, and the appropriate notice of such
meetings shall be provided to the public. Regular meetings of the Brownfield Redevelopment
Authority shall be held in each calendar quarter of each year. In no event shall there be less than
four (4) meetings per year. The Board shall hold an Annual Meeting in January in the third
calendar quarter of each year at which time officers of the Board shall be elected as provided in
Article 3, Section 2.
2.8 Notice. Notice of any meetings shall be given in accordance with the Open Meetings Act (Act No.
267 of the Public Acts of 1976).
2.9 Quorum. A majority of the members of the Directors then in office constitutes a quorum for the
transaction of business at any meeting of the Board, provided, that a majority of the Board present
may adjourn the meeting from time to time without any further notice. The vote of the majority of
the Directors present at a meeting at which a quorum is present constitutes the action of the Board,
unless the vote of a larger number is required by statute or by these Bylaws. Amendment of the
Bylaws by the Board requires the vote of not less than a majority of the members of the Board then
in office.
2.10 Participation by Communication Equipment. A member of the Board or of a committee designated
by the Board may participate in a meeting by means of conference telephone or similar
communications equipment by means of which all persons participating in the meeting can hear
each other. Participation in a meeting pursuant to this provision constitutes presence at the
meeting.
2.11 Committees. The Board may, by resolution passed by a majority of the whole board, designate one
or more committees, each committee to consist of two or more of the Directors of the Authority.
The Board may designate one or more Directors as alternate members of a committee, who may
replace an absent or disqualified member at a meeting of the committee. In the absence or
City of Manistee Brownfield Redevelopment Authority By Laws Page 2
disqualification of a member of a committee, the members thereof present at a meeting and not
disqualified from voting, whether or not they constitute a quorum, may unanimously appoint
another member of the Board to act at the meeting in place of such an absent or disqualified
member. A committee, and each member thereof, shall serve at the pleasure of the Board. A
committee so designated by the Board, to the extent provided in the resolution by the Board, may
exercise all powers and authority of the Board in the management of the business and affairs of the
Authority, except that such committee so may exercise all powers and authority to: (a) recommend
to members a dissolution of the Authority, or revocation of dissolution, (b) amend the Bylaws of the
Authority, or (c) fill vacancies in the Board.
ARTICLE 3: OFFICERS
3.1 Officers. The officers of the Authority shall be elected by the Board and shall consist of a
Chairperson, Vice Chairperson, and Secretary/Treasurer. The Board may also appoint a Recording
Secretary who need not be a member of the Board. Two or more offices may be held by the same
person, but an officer shall not execute, acknowledge, or verify an instrument in more than one
capacity if the instrument is required by law or Bylaws to be excluded, acknowledged, or verified by
two or more officers.
3.2 Nomination, Election and Term of Office. The officers of the Authority shall be elected by the
Board at an Annual Meeting held in January during the third calendar quarter of each year.
Candidates shall be nominated by any Brownfield Redevelopment Authority Board member present
at the meeting.
3.3 Vacancies. A vacancy in any office because of death, resignation, removal, disqualification or
otherwise, may be filled at any meeting of the Board for the unexpired portion of the terms of such
office.
3.4 Chairperson and Vice Chairperson. The Chairperson shall be the chief executive officer of the
Authority, but he or she may from time to time delegate all or any part of his/her duties to the Vice
Chairperson. He or she, or in his/her absence, the Vice Chairperson, shall preside at all meetings of
the Board, he or she shall have general and active management of the business of the Authority and
shall perform all the duties of the office as provided by law or these Bylaws. He or she shall be ex-
officio a member of all standing committees, and shall have the general powers and duties of
supervision and management of the Authority.
3.5 Secretary/Treasurer and Recording Secretary. The Secretary/Treasurer shall attend all meetings of
the Board and record all votes and the minutes of all proceedings in a book to be kept for that
purpose, and shall perform like duties for the standing committees when required. They shall
further perform all duties of the office of Secretary/Treasurer as provided by law or these Bylaws.
They shall be sworn to the faithful discharge of these duties. For the purposes of recording minutes
the Secretary/Treasurer may appoint a Recording Secretary.
3.6 Delegation of Duties of Offices. In the absence of any officer of the Authority, or for any other
reason that the Board may deem sufficient, the Board may delegate, from time to time and for such
time as it may deem appropriate, the powers or duties, or any of them, of such officer to any other
officer, or to any Director, provided a majority of the Board then in office concurs therein.
City of Manistee Brownfield Redevelopment Authority By Laws Page 3
3.7 Executive Committee. The Chairperson, Vice Chairperson and Secretary/Treasurer shall comprise
the Executive Committee. The Executive Committee, may upon a majority vote, authorize the
expenditure of up to $500.00 for any expense listed as an eligible item for expenditure under the
approved Authority funding guidelines. The Executive Committee must report any such
expenditures to the Board at the next regularly scheduled Board meeting.
ARTICLE 4: CONTRACTS, LOANS, CHECKS AND DEPOSITS
4.1 Contracts. The Board may authorize any officer or officers, agent or agents, to enter into any
contract or execute and deliver any instrument in the name of and on behalf of the Authority, and
such authority may be general or confined to specific instances.
4.2 Loans/Grants. No grant or loan shall be contracted on behalf of the Authority and no evidence of
indebtedness shall be issued in its name unless authorized by a resolution of the Board and
approved by the City Council. Such authority may be general or confined to specific instances.
4.3 Checks, Drafts, etc. All checks, drafts or other orders for the payment of money, notes or other
evidence of indebtedness issued in the name of the Authority, shall be signed by such officer or
officers, agent or agents of the Authority and in such manner as shall from time to time be
determined by resolution of the Board.
4.4 Deposits. All funds of the Authority not otherwise employed shall be deposited from time to time
to the credit of the Authority in such banks, trust companies or other depositaries as the Board may
select.
ARTICLE 5: FISCAL YEAR
The fiscal year of the Authority shall correspond at all times to the fiscal year of the City of Manistee.
ARTICLE 6: Miscellaneous
6.1 Seal. The Board shall provide a corporate seal which shall be the official seal of the Authority.
6.2 Waiver of Notice. When the Board or any committee thereof may take action after notice to any
person or after lapse of a prescribed period of time, the action may be taken without notice and
without lapse of the period of time, if at any time before or after the action is completed the person
entitled to notice or to participation in the action to be taken submits a signed waiver of such
requirements.
ARTICLE 7: REVIEW AND AMENDMENTS
These Bylaws will be reviewed annually at the Annual Meeting. These Bylaws may be altered, amended or
repealed by the affirmative vote of a majority of the Board then in office at any regular or special meeting
called for that purpose. Any proposed changes are subject to review and approval of the City Council.
City of Manistee Brownfield Redevelopment Authority By Laws Page 4
I HEREBY CERTIFY that the above Bylaws were adopted the 4th day of June, 2013.
_______________________________________
Jon Rose, BRA Administrator
[Annotation: Article III Officers, Section 7 Executive Committee amended to be authorized to spend up to $5,000.00. Approved by
BRA 7/27/06]
[Annotation: As approved by the City Council at their June 2, 2009 Meeting – Council authorized the bylaw amendments for all
Boards and Commissions to include the new Board Absences language; directed all boards or commissions to implement and follow
these changes as Council has requested; and authorized the Mayor to sign the amended bylaws. Approved by BRA 7/7/09]
[Annotation: Article II Directors, Section 2, Board of Directors was amended to add “BRA Board members are to be city residents or
persons with an interest in property in the City of Manistee.” Article III Officers, Section 2. Nomination, Election and Term of Office
was amended by adding “any Brownfield Redevelopment Authority Board member present at the meeting” DELETING “a
nomination committee composed of three members appointed by the Chairperson. The term of each office shall be for one (1) year.
Each officer shall hold office until his/her successor is appointed. No persons shall hold the same office for more than three
successive terms.” Approved by BRA 9/7/10]
[Annotation: Article II, Directors, Section 2, Board of Directors was amended to delete “unless an EDC, DDA, TIFA, or LDFA board was
appointed.” Section 7, Meetings, was amended to delete ”second calendar quarter of each year” and add “third calendar quarter of
each year.” Article VII, Review and Amendments, was amended to change “Organizational Meeting” to “Annual Meeting.” Article
III, Officers, Section 2, Nomination, Election and Term of Office was amended to delete “during the second calendar quarter of each
year” and add “during the third calendar quarter of each year.” Approved by BRA 6/7/11]
Approved by the City of Manistee Council
_________________________________
Date
_________________________________
Colleen Kenny, Mayor
City of Manistee Brownfield Redevelopment Authority By Laws Page 5
Get email alerts for Manistee
A daily email when new agendas and minutes are posted.