City Council
Regular MeetingManistee, MI · September 26, 2017
Minutes
MANISTEE CITY COUNCIL
MANISTEE COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
JOINT WORK SESSION
MINUTES OF SEPTEMBER 26, 2017
The Manistee City Council met with the Manistee County Board of Commissioners in a special
joint work session on Tuesday, September 26, 2017 at 7: 00 p. m., Council Chambers, City Hall,
70 Maple Street, Manistee, Michigan 49660.
COUNCIL PRESENT: Dale Cooper, Lynda Beaton, Roger Zielinski, Robert
Goodspeed, James Smith, Mark Wittlieff, Erin Pontiac
COMMISSIONERS PRESENT: Pauline Jaquish, Richard Schmidt, Brook Shafer, Mark
Bergstrom, Jeff Dontz, Karen Goodman, Margaret Batzer
ALSO PRESENT: City Manager Thad Taylor, County Administrator Tom
Kaminski, Manistee Area Chamber of Commerce
Representatives, Staff, Public, and Media
Public Comments on Work Session Related Items.
Jim Matthews, 334 River St. / has attended several visioning sessions; would like to see
an actionable plan and guidelines; need measurable success.
Glen Zaring, 321 Fifth St. / echoed Mr. Matthews statement; stop studying and start
doing; spell out what needs to be done and do it.
Kelly Smith, chair of AES / introduced Lisa Leedy as the new AES executive director
candidate.
Lisa Leedy/ gave a brief background of her qualifications and ideas to move forward.
Terry Walker, Filer Township supervisor / has worked with AES on several township
issues such as Explore the Shores Magoon Creek project and the US- 31 Corridor Project;
need to give careful consideration to what benefits the community, county wide, and
regionally.
Tamara Buswinka, Manistee Township/ decision should be made which would create the
best prosperity for all of us; asked for thoughtful and careful deliberations.
Dennis terHorst, 63 Clay St. / in favor of economic development; cautioned of the
difference between economic development and community development; defined
economic development as payroll and tax base.
Presentation by the Manistee Area Chamber of Commerce. Dennis McCarthy, Brandon Jensen,
and Crystal Young, board members of the Manistee Area Chamber of Commerce made a
presentation on proposed economic development services through the Chamber. Some of the
points outlined include:
Organization is already in place
300+ members
Strong focus on deliverable outcomes
Diverse funding source, public and private
Council Work Session - September 26, 2017 Page 1
Streamline operations
Initiative came from their members
Building upon what is already there, prior success
Would become a 501( c) 3
Funding request: $ 32, 563 — City and $ 63, 538 — County
30% reduction in current costs
Questions/ Comments:
Have there been any studies done to help make an informed decision?
Do we straighten it out or start out with something new?
This is also a reflection on our own actions.
Not seeing a lot of new ideas that are different from the regular Chamber duties.
Concerned about AES, how do they determine what county/ direction they would point a
developer to.
Everyone in the room wants the same thing for the county.
Both Chamber boards are independent.
Create a management agreement.
Questioned membership retention and diversity in the county, is growth stagnant?
Discussed how Chamber members react with concerns or questions.
AES is doing well with community development and growth funding, give them an
opportunity to continue.
Appreciates the enthusiasm of the Chamber spokespeople.
Is there a Plan B?
This is about people and relationships, need to work together.
Mayor Smith thanked the Chamber for their presentation; thanked the Commissioners and the
public for attending; more discussion on the AES will be done at the October 10th work session.
County Commissioner Chair Dontz encouraged everyone to please reach out and talk to the AES
and the Chamber to help make our decision.
Meeting adjourned at 8: 38 p.m.
Michelle Wright MMC I C A, MiCPT
City Clerk I Chief Deputy Treasurer
Council Work Session - September 26, 2017 Page 2
Agenda
SPECIAL JOINT WORK SESSION
MANISTEE CITY COUNCIL
MANISTEE COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
AGENDA
Tuesday, September 26, 2017 - 7:00 p.m. - Council Chambers, City Hall
I. Call to Order.
II. Work Session Items.
a.) PUBLIC COMMENTS ON WORK SESSION RELATED ITEMS.
b.) PRESENTATION BY THE MANISTEE AREA CHAMBER OF COMMERCE ON
PROPOSED ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT SERVICES.
c.) OTHER.
III. Adjourn.
TNT:cl
MANISTEE AREA CHAMBER OF COMMERCE
11 CYPRESS ST
MANISTEE MI 49660
(231) 723-2575
Economic Development Proposal
18h September 2017
OVERVIEW
Over the last several years the Chamber has been expanding its role in economic and workforce
development as a direct result of member and community needs. This proposal is the next logical step
for the Chamber moving forward, filling a gap to become the leader in economic development for
Manistee County.
Adding economic development as a separate enterprise of the Chamber, with two separate Boards, will
increase funding levels. This will be achieved through public and private partnerships, diversifying
funding due to the connectivity with the business community.
The benefits of having the Chamber as the leader in economic development offers a simplified process
for developers and investors, becoming the single point of contact regardless of the type of development.
The Chamber has over 300 public and private business and organizations within our network, which
increases the communication conduit to the business community.
The model the Chamber is developing is in line with many of our partner Chambers throughout the State,
which are the following: Alpena Area Chamber of Commerce, Barry County Chamber of Commerce and
Economic Growth Alliance, Flint and Genesee Chamber of Commerce, Ludington & Scottville Chamber
of Commerce and Traverse CONNECT.
GOALS
1. Build a dynamic and sustainable organization to serve the businesses, workforce, and economic
development needs of the entire Manistee County.
2. Expand and secure private and public sector financial support to diversify funding and
supplement proposed by City and County.
3. Provide a focused approach to Economic Development to include, but not limited to direct
business recruitment and retention, workforce training, funding, and grants, with accountability
and sustainability.
BOARD STRUCTURE
The Board will be made up of 7-9 individuals and will meet on a scheduled monthly basis. The Economic
Development Director will be required to provide monthly reports to the Board. Board members will
represent the following areas:
1
● City and County (1 seat each)
● Private Sector (2-3 seats)
● Little River Band of Ottawa Indians (1 seat)
● Industrial Development Corporation (1 seat)
● Manistee Manufacturers Council (1 seat)
● Chamber Board Director (1 seat)
ORGANIZATIONAL STRUCTURE
*Consultants to be utilized on a per project basis, with a contract outlining scope of work, deadline, and
payment schedule.
ACCOUNTABILITY
The Economic Development Director will provide monthly reports to the Board of Directors and quarterly
reports and presentations as requested. An annual report will be produced on the activity for the year,
progress, and deliverables.
GREATEST AREAS OF GROWTH & SUCCESS
● Business & Career Expo
● Government Affairs & Legislative Advocacy
● Manistee Area Leadership Program
2018 ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT PROJECTS UNDERWAY
● Developer Day
2
● Relocation Guide
● Trainings & Workshops
POTENTIAL PRIORITIES
● Redevelopment of targeted vacant and blighted buildings throughout the County.
● Continue discussion/action on rerouting railroad.
● Expansion of snowmobile/ORV trails in the County.
● Support and develop agritourism in the County.
● Continue to support existing development and infrastructure projects.
● Continue to support and be the fiduciary for County and City grants.
● Provide City specific housing study and address housing developments within City and County.
● Develop and sustain business support services.
FUNDING
The Chamber of Commerce will set up a 501C3 organization to be a fiduciary for existing and new grants
available. A separate set of financials for this new function of the Chamber will be maintained for the
economic development arm of the Chamber. In addition, the annual Chamber dues structure will allow
an allocation for economic development.
The Chamber is seeking $32,563 from the City of Manistee and $63,538 from the County of Manistee,
which is a 30% reduction.
3
Get email alerts for Manistee
A daily email when new agendas and minutes are posted.