Harbor Commission
Regular MeetingManistee, MI · January 21, 2014
Minutes
HARBOR COMMISSION MINUTES
MEETING OF JANUARY 21, 2014
A regular meeting of the Manistee Harbor Commission was held on Tuesday, January 21, 2014
at 1 p.m. in the Second Floor Conference Room, City Hall, 70 Maple Street, Manistee MI 49660.
Roll Call Present Excused Absence Unexcused Absence
Commissioner Bachman
Commissioner Cook
Commissioner Daniels
Commissioner Memberto
Commissioner Smith
Commissioner Zaccanelli
Commissioner Zielinski
City Manager Mitch Deisch
OTHERS PRESENT: CVB Maralee Cook, AES Director Kathy Morin, Manistee News
Advocate Eric Sagonowsky
APPROVAL OF AGENDA
MOTION by Roger Zielinski, second by Alex Zaccanelli to approve the agenda as presented.
Voice vote - Motion carried.
PUBLIC COMMENTS ON AGENDA ITEMS
Maralee Cook – Thought AES report was nicely done.
ELECTION OF OFFICERS
As required in the bylaws, the election of officers shall occur at the first meeting of each calendar
year and officers shall take office upon selection and shall hold office for a term of one year.
For the position of Chair:
Alex Zaccanelli nominated Thom Smith
No further nominations. All voted in favor of Thom Smith as Chair.
For the position of Vice-Chair:
Rosemary Daniels nominated Shelly Memberto
No further nominations. All voted in favor of Shelly Memberto as Vice-Chair.
APPROVAL OF MINUTES
MOTION by Alex Zaccanelli, second by Rosemary Daniels to approve the minutes for the
October 15, 2013 meeting as presented. Voice vote - Motion carried.
Harbor Commission Minutes – January 21, 2014 Page 1
STAFF REPORTS
Harbormaster / City Manager. Dave Bachman not able to attend today but supplied information
to the Commission via email regarding damages at the marina due to frozen water lines.
Mitch Deisch reported that the USACOE is optimistic about higher water levels for 2014.
Marina dredging paperwork has been completed and is slated to be completed in March/April
weather permitting. Materials removed from the larger western slips will be deposited at the
compost area. Repair work at the marina is expected to be completed prior to the start of the
boating season and is covered by insurance with a $250 deductible. Sensors will be replaced
with new technologies allowing notification capabilities. General discussion on water freeze-
ups, potholes, and snow plowing.
COMMITTEE REPORTS Update provided by the Marketing Committee:
1. Decided to try marketing slips for the shoulder seasons at a lower price. The first attempt
will target veterans and will utilize the mailing list for Tight Lines for Troops. Limited
scope for this first year.
2. Discussed using promotional sites like Up North Live to offer discounts in the shoulder
seasons. Using the LRCR as a sponsor is being investigated.
3. Press release will be going out soon and continues to work with the CVB.
In other discussion:
Ty Cook noted that there is a lot of outdated and bad information on the web. Will send a list
to the City Manager who will check with IT personnel to see if there is a way to delete or
update information.
Two visits from cruise ships are anticipated in August. Ty Cook would like to see some sort
of “meet and greet” scheduled. Chamber Victorians in Person used to do this.
Ty Cook suggested dockage or mooring balls along the north side of the river channel
adjacent to Memorial Park. Roger Zielinski will work with the Parks and Beautification
Commission on this idea.
The wet triangle area next to the marina facility needs to be addressed. Drainage still an
issue and the area should be made more attractive.
Ty Cook suggested welcome signage to be located in the harbor. This is the third entrance
way to our community. USACOE regulates signage on their navigational structures which
would complicate these locations. Maralee Cook said the CVB is willing to discuss and
suggested that Pure Michigan might also be an option. City has used Amor Signs in the past
to provide signage concepts. Deisch suggested that Katherine Kenny, Maralee Cook, Ty
Cook and Dave Bachman meet with Amor to look at concepts and costs.
Briefly discussed DDA Design Committee concept of two-way traffic on River Street.
Roger Zielinski sees a revenue opportunity by creating a section of the parking lot at First
Street for long term parking of boats, trailers, campers, etc.
Harbor Commission Minutes – January 21, 2014 Page 2
UNFINISHED BUSINESS
Kathy Adair-Morin of the Alliance for Economic Success presented the draft Strategic Plan for
the Harbor Commission. The purpose of this exercise is to align the Harbor Commission goals
with the City’s Strategic Plan. Reviewed past minor changes and discussed what the document
will mean to the Harbor Commission.
MOTION by Alex Zaccanelli, second by Rosemary Daniels to adopt the Harbor Commission
Strategic Plan. Voice vote – Motion carried.
NEW BUSINESS
Annual Bylaw Review: Consensus that no changes were needed at this time.
PUBLIC COMMENTS
None.
COMMENTS BY HARBOR COMMISSIONERS
Roger Zielinski and Ty Cook asked about the Peninsula Plan. City Manager advised that the
plan includes private marinas on private property and would not be under the jurisdiction of the
Harbor Commission.
ADJOURNMENT
Next meeting is scheduled for Tuesday, April 15, 2014. MOTION by Roger Zielinski, second by
Rosemary Daniels to adjourn at 2:15 p.m.
Respectfully submitted,
Cynthia Lokovich, CAP-OM
Recording Secretary
Harbor Commission Minutes – January 21, 2014 Page 3
Agenda
Manistee Harbor Commission
Established - November 1931
70 Maple Street, Manistee, Michigan 49660
Agenda
Tuesday, January 21, 2014 at 1 p.m. – Second Floor Conference Room, City Hall
____________________________________________________________________
Call to Order
Approval of Agenda
Public Comments on Agenda Items (5 minute limit)
Election of Officers
Approval of Minutes
Minutes of October 15, 2013
Staff Reports
Harbormaster
City Manager
Committee Reports
Marketing Committee
Unfinished Business
Strategic Plan Review – AES Office Final Draft
New Business
Annual Bylaw Review
Public Comment (5 minute limit)
Comments by Harbor Commissioners
Adjourn
Commissioners are encouraged to participate in the preparation of the monthly agendas for Harbor
Commission meetings. Please contact the City Manager’s Office at least two weeks prior to the scheduled
meeting to discuss agenda items.
HARBOR COMMISSION MINUTES
MEETING OF OCTOBER 15, 2013
A regular meeting of the Manistee Harbor Commission was held on Tuesday, October 15, 2013
at 1 p.m. in the Second Floor Conference Room, City Hall, 70 Maple Street, Manistee MI 49660.
Roll Call Present Excused Absence Unexcused Absence
Commissioner Bachman
Commissioner Cook
Commissioner Daniels
Commissioner Memberto
Commissioner Smith
Commissioner Zaccanelli
Commissioner Zielinski
City Manager Mitch Deisch
OTHERS PRESENT: Maralee Cook, VCB
APPROVAL OF AGENDA
MOTION by Roger Zielinski, second by Alex Zaccanelli to approve the agenda as presented.
Voice vote - Motion carried.
PUBLIC COMMENTS ON AGENDA ITEMS
Maralee Cook – Has reviewed the draft strategic plan for the Harbor Commission. The VCB is
working on linking up Northwest Michigan harbors; this would be a chance to work together
toward a common goal.
APPROVAL OF MINUTES
MOTION by Roger Zielinski, second by Ty Cook to approve the minutes for the July 16, 2013
and the August 20, 2013 meetings as presented. Voice vote - Motion carried.
STAFF REPORTS
Harbormaster. The marina has closed for the season. Marina reports for August and September
were distributed. Frank Post will attend the Harbormasters conference in December. Anticipates
that Mr. Post will bring back better information on what the City can offer regarding seasonal
docks and incentives. Will lose two college students next season and will advertise in the spring.
City Manager. City Manager Mitch Deisch reviewed the Boat Launch Revenue Report for
2013. Only one bid was received for the marina dredging from Luedtke in Frankfort for the
amount of $83,500; way too high for the removal of only 300 yards of material. Will rebid in the
spring for completion by the end of May. All permits have been received.
COMMITTEE REPORTS None.
Harbor Commission Minutes – October 15, 2013 Page 1
UNFINISHED BUSINESS
Kathy Adair-Morin of the Alliance for Economic Success presented the draft Strategic Plan for
the Harbor Commission. The purpose of this exercise is to align the Harbor Commission goals
with the City’s Strategic Plan.
Shelly Memberto arrived at 1:17 p.m.
Extensive discussion on draft plan noting the importance of the harbor to the community and
collaborating with the Live Here/Work Here/Visit Here program being implemented in the
community.
Discussion on items in the plan including: Peninsula plan, dinghy dock, mooring balls,
involvement of stakeholders, collaboration with VCB on harbors of refuge, sister city in
Wisconsin, tri-port collaborative, and promotional signage for this third entrance to the City.
The AES Office will make minor modifications to the plan and bring the final document back to
the Harbor Commission.
NEW BUSINESS
2014 Meeting Schedule – approved as presented: January 21, April 15, June 17, July 15, August
19 and October 21. This schedule complies with the quarterly meetings as required by ordinance
and adds two dates to meet during the marina operating season. Other meetings can be
scheduled as necessary.
Following a discussion on marketing the marina facility, MOTION was made by Dave Bachman,
second by Alex Zaccanelli to form a Marketing Committee that will meet on a monthly basis and
report back to the Harbor Commission. Committee members are: Chair Ty Cook, Dave
Bachman, and Shelly Memberto. Maralee Cook and Kathy Adair Morin will assist this
committee.
PUBLIC COMMENTS None.
COMMENTS BY HARBOR COMMISSIONERS None.
ADJOURNMENT
Next meeting is scheduled for Tuesday, January 21, 2014. MOTION by Dave Bachman, second
by Shelly Memberto to adjourn at 2:15 p.m.
Respectfully submitted,
Cindy Lokovich, Recording Secretary
Harbor Commission Minutes – October 15, 2013 Page 2
City of Manistee
Harbor Commission
Strategic Plan
2013 - 2016
October 2013
Strategic Plan Purpose and Use
Manistee’s Harbor is an important gateway to the City of Manistee and Manistee County.
Approximately 1,000 jobs directly rely upon the use of the harbor for commercial navigation. The
harbor is traditionally one of the most significant in the entire Great Lakes for landings of migratory
species of trout and salmon, a $4 billion industry in Michigan. The harbor is also the attraction and
destination for countless events, vacations, beach-goers, shoppers, joggers and for people who simply
want to escape to our Lake Michigan and Manistee River shores.
This is the first Strategic Plan of the Manistee Harbor Commission. The Commission created under the
Codified Ordinances – Part Two Administrative Code, Chapter 266 of the City of Manistee
Consistent with that charter and the Strategic Plan of Manistee’s City Council, it is the intent of the
Harbor Commission that this Strategic Plan:
Covers the period 2013 – 2016 and be subject to annual review and update as conditions
warrant.
Serve as the “guiding light” for decisions and stewardship of the City’s harbor and harbor
facilities.
Provides a vehicle for input from all interests as well as recommendations to City Council and
City government about needs and priorities involving Manistee’s harbors.
We are pleased to offer this Strategic Plan for input and participation by all who have an interest in the
City of Manistee’s harbor.
Sincerely,
Dave Bachman, Harbormaster ___________________________________________________
Ty Cook ___________________________________________________
Rosemary Daniels ___________________________________________________
Mitch Deisch, Ex-Officio ___________________________________________________
Shelly Memberto ___________________________________________________
Thom Smith ___________________________________________________
Alex Zaccanelli ___________________________________________________
Roger Zielinski ___________________________________________________
City of Manistee Harbor Commission Strategic Plan 2013-2016 Page 2/5
Purpose of the Harbor Commission
It is important for all interests in the City of Manistee’s harbor to understand the purposes of the City’s
Harbor Commission. The City’s Codified Ordinance establishes that the Harbor Commission’s purposes
are to provide recommendations to City Council concerning:
Operation, maintenance and policy about the City Municipal Marina and City owned boat
launches
Improvements involving the City Municipal Marina and boat launches
Acquisition of waterfront property, wharves and docks
Use of waterways, channels, municipal docks and other city navigational facilities
Ordinances/rules regarding public safety
Relationship to City Strategic Plan
In addition to the City Charter, the City of Manistee’s Strategic Plan establishes an important focus for
the Harbor Commission. Specifically, the current Strategic Plan of the City establishes that the vision of
the City is to be “a community of choice along the Lake Michigan shoreline” and that a strategic goal is
to have the “finest port facilities” along the Lake Michigan coast. In forming its strategic plan, the
Harbor Commission is mindful of this vision and goal that establish overarching direction for the City.
What Does the Manistee “Harbor” Include?
In keeping with the City Charter and Strategic Plan of the City, the Harbor Commission is concerned
with:
The Municipal Marina located on the Manistee River Channel
The Arthur Street boat launch and fishing pier located on Manistee Lake
The 9th Street Boat Launch located on Manistee Lake
All developments, improvements and the safe use and operations involving the Manistee harbor
from its point of entry through the Federally owned navigation structure into Manistee Lake
within the physical boundary of the City.
It’s important to note that the Harbor Commission does not currently become involved with beach or
park maintenance or signage.
Strategic Goals
The Strategic Goals of the Harbor Commission encompass the 2013 – 2016 period and will be addressed
as noted in the following:
City of Manistee Harbor Commission Strategic Plan 2013-2016 Page 3/5
Commission Representation
Goal: To identify, recruit and develop representation on the Harbor Commission that reflects a cross-
section of participation by key stakeholders and/or stakeholder groups.
Action: Beginning in 2013, continue the open process to seek nominations to fill vacant Commission
positions but also ensure contact is made with key stakeholder groups such as: U.S. Coast Guard;
Manistee County Sheriff’s Department; downtown businesses with a relationship to the harbor; the
Little River Band of Ottawa Indians and others. In addition, the Commission will also encourage all
interests to provide input and participate in meetings of the Commission, including an annual seasonal
kickoff meeting, and assist the Commission in achieving its goals.
Facility Improvements
Goal: Consistent with the City’s priority on universal access, seek funding beginning in 2014 to widen
the skid piers at the First Street Boat Launch to support both universal access and safety in general.
Action: Pursue funding with AES support beginning in 2014.
Goal: To continue to pursue opportunities to improve the 9th Street Boat Launch at such time as long-
term arrangements for use of adjacent property can be made to enable and justify site improvements.
Action: Request AES to assist in facilitating renewal of discussions with private property owners toward
a long-term access agreement enabling pursuit of grant funding for site improvement.
Goal: To make the 1st Street Boat Launch Auto Attendant user friendly.
Action: A new kiosk will be in place in 2014 to distribute stickers. In the event the system is not
functioning the Commission will pursue an envelope-self pay facility that relies upon the integrity of
launch users.
Participation and Collaboration
Goal: To encourage and lead in “around the Lake” discussions with neighboring communities to support
a unifying plan for the Lake regarding access and development and use of complimentary facilities.
Action: Begin/renew discussions in 2014 with facilitation support of AES.
Goal: To assess and pursue added opportunities which enhance use and enjoyment of the harbor and
generate revenues for harbor facilities.
Action: Beginning in 2014, identify a “menu” of possibilities for enhancement with initial priority on the
potential installation and rental of mooring balls to support transient boating, increased tourism, and
revenue generation. Discuss with users and other communities to identify best practices.
Goal: Encourage cooperation among Manistee County’s three port communities (Manistee, Onekama,
and Arcadia) and expand marketing efforts.
City of Manistee Harbor Commission Strategic Plan 2013-2016 Page 4/5
Action: Develop a tri-port collaborative to work with the Manistee County Visitors Bureau to promote
our coastline and the three unique harbor resources available. Additionally, explore options for a “Sister
City” program with communities on Wisconsin’s coastline for possible boater reciprocity. Review
possibilities of “Welcome” signage at port entries.
Forward Looking
Goal: To engage Commission members and all harbor interests in discussions that form the basis for
new goals and areas of focus that may include but not be limited to:
Linkages between the work of the Commission and economic development priorities, such as
implementation of the Peninsula Plan.
Ways to further promote the harbor and capture more market share
An expansion of seasonal dockage in keeping with promotion that brings more boaters to our
Harbor
Ways to address vandalism and ongoing maintenance needs
Understanding “best practices” for Harbor Commissions and Harbor Commission
accomplishments in other ports
Leveraging all resources to encourage boater safety and voluntary boat safety inspections
City of Manistee Harbor Commission Strategic Plan 2013-2016 Page 5/5
Get email alerts for Manistee
A daily email when new agendas and minutes are posted.