City Council
Regular MeetingMichigan City, IN · September 20, 2022
Minutes
Page 1 September 20, 2022
REGULAR “HYBRID/ZOOM” MEETING
September 20, 2022
The Common Council of the City of Michigan City, Indiana, met in Regular session on
Tuesday evening, September 20, 2022, at the hour of 6:30 p.m., Hosted by
“Hybrid/Zoom” and streamed live on “My Michigan City” Facebook Page.
The meeting was called to order at 6:30 p.m. by Vice President D. Przybylinski.
Roll call was authorized, and the following were noted present and/or absent.
PRESENT: COUNCIL MEMBERS Bryant Dabney, Sean Fitzpatrick, Michael Mack,
Angie Nelson Deuitch (zoom), Don Przybylinski, Gene Simmons, Dalia Zygas, Paul
Przybylinski, and Tracie Tillman (zoom) (9).
ABSENT: COUNCIL MEMBERS None (0).
A QUORUM WAS NOTED PRESENT
ALSO, PRESENT: Council Attorney Jewel Harris, Gale Neulieb City Clerk.
APPROVAL OF MINUTES
Vice President D. Przybylinski stated that we will be approving the Regular
“Hybrid/Zoom” Meeting Minutes that were held on September 6, 2022; asking if
anyone had any additions, deletions or corrections at this time, there was no response.
Councilman Dabney made a motion to approve the minutes of the “Hybrid/Zoom”,
regular meeting held on September 6, 2022; a second was made by Councilman P.
Przybylinski.
The motion carried and the minutes from the September 6, 2022 meeting were
approved by the following vote: AYES: Council members Dabney, Fitzpatrick, Mack,
Deuitch, D. Przybylinski, Simmons, Zygas, P. Przybylinski, and Tillman (9) NAYS:
Council member None (0).
REPORTS of STANDING COMMITTEES
Vice President D. Przybylinski asked if there were any reports of standing committees,
there was no response.
FINANCE REPORT
Vice President D. Przybylinski asked Finance Chair Tracie Tillman if she had anything
to report on this evening.
Page 2 September 20, 2022
Councilwoman Tillman stated the Finance Committee did a final wrap up with the
Sanitary Department and they addressed the questions that the committee received
from them; commenting on the City’s Finance Committee meeting held on September 6,
2022 (due to a family emergency was unable to stay) was carried out by Councilman P.
Przybylinski and that in regards to the Riverboat fund # 2042 claim docket in the amount
of $17,753.26 was approved during the September 6th Council meeting with a vote of 7 -
0.
Councilman Tillman advised that this evening we are going to be on second reading for
the City’s 2023 budget and will make amendments when read.
CLAIMS DOCKET
Vice President Przybylinski stated there were no claims for the September 20, 2022,
from the Riverboat Fund #2042 or the Boyd Development fund #2031.
September 20, 2022
September 20, 2022
Fund #2042 – Riverboat – Claims - $ 00.00
EFT $ 00.00
Fund #2031 – Boyd Development - $ 00.00
EFT $ 00.00
TOTAL CLAIMS $ 00.00
REPORTS OF SPECIAL or SELECT COMMITTEES
Vice President D. Przybylinski asked if there were any reports of standing committees,
there was no response.
REPORTS FROM THE MAYOR OR OTHER CITY OFFICERS AND DEPARTMENTS
Vice President D. Przybylinski asked if there were any reports from the mayor or other
city officers and departments, there was no response
PETITIONS
Vice President D. Przybylinski asked Clerk Neulieb if there were any petitions.
Clerk Neulieb stated that there are no petitions this evening.
COMMUNICATIONS
Vice President D. Przybylinski asked if there was any correspondence received in the
Clerk’s Office for the Council.
Correspondence was received in the Clerk’s Office from Attorney Harris Law Firm
regarding concerns of the Council’s lack of authority to enact Ordinance No. 4637 &
4638
Councilman P. Przybylinski asked for this letter to be read in its entirety for the record
Page 3 September 20, 2022
Clerk Neulieb reading the letter received in its entirety as follows.
To: Attorney James B. Meyer, representing the Sanitary Districts
RE: Michigan City Common Council
Ordinance Nos. 4637 and 4638
Dear Attorney Meyer:
Please be advised that I am in receipt of your correspondence to the Board of
Commissioners of the Michigan City Sanitary District dated September 6, 2022. In your
memo, you express concern regarding the Michigan City Common Council’s lack of
authority to enact Ordinances 4637 and 4638 as they represent an attempt by the
Council to limit the authority of the Michigan City Sanitary District Board of
Commissioners.
Having reviewed your memo and researched and relevant statutes, it is my
opinion that the City Council does indeed have the authority to adopt Ordinances 4637
and 4638. Under Indiana home rule statute, the City has both the powers granted
expressly to it by statute and “all other powers necessary or desirable in the conduct of
its affairs, even though not granted by statute.” I.C.36-1-3-4. Further, “any doubt as to
the existence of a power of a (municipality) shall be resolved in favor of its existence.
“I.C. 36-1-3-3. Therefore, in light of the fact that there is no state that specifically
restricts the City Council’s ability to limit the Sanitary Board’s discretion, the City Council
retains that power.
It is worth nothing the Council is taking this position as it leads to a more
cohesive approach to providing city services and managing the costs associated
therewith. Should you wish to discuss these matter in more detail, please do not
hesitate to contact me.
Very truly yours,
HARRIS LAW FIRM, P.C.
Attorney for the Michigan City Common Council
Jewell Harris, JR.
Correspondence was received in the Clerk’s Office on September 15, 2022 from Mayor
Parry vetoing Ordinance No. 4637 AMENDING SEC. 98-85 OF THE MICHIGAN CITY
MUNICIPAL CODEKNOWN AS ADDITIONS TO THE SANITARY DISTRICT TO
AMEND THE ANNEXATION CONDITIONS AND PROCEDURES
Vice President D. Przybylinski stated the council received a letter from Mayor Parry
advising the council why he was vetoing these two (2) ordinances.
Vice President D. Przybylinski asked if the Council had anything to add at this time.
Councilman Fitzpatrick made a motion to override the veto, motion was second by
Councilman P. Przybylinski.
Vice President D. Przybylinski asked if there were any questions or comments from the
public.
Roberta Lee Conover, 224 ½ W. 10th Street address the council regarding the $500,000
the Town of Long Beach owes the City for the Lakeshore Drive sewer project.
Discussion ensued between Ms. Conover and Council members Deuitch, D.
Przybylinski, Fitzpatrick, and Dabney regarding the project and how much the Town of
Long Beach owes the Sanitary District.
Page 4 September 20, 2022
The motion carried to override Ordinance No. 4637 by the following vote: AYES:
Council members Mack, Deuitch, D. Przybylinski, Simmons, Zygas, P. Przybylinski,
Tillman, Dabney, and Fitzpatrick (9) NAYS: Council member None (0).
Correspondence was also received from Mayor Parry vetoing Ordinance No. 4638
CREATING SEC. 98-86 AND SEC. 98-87 IN THE MICHIGAN CITY MUNICIPAL
CODE TO ESTATBLISH THECONDITIONS AND PROCEDURES FOR ADDITIONS
TO THE SANITARY DISTRICT.
The motion carried to override Ordinance No. 4638 by the following vote: AYES:
Council members Deuitch, D. Przybylinski, Simmons, Zygas, P. Przybylinski, Tillman,
Dabney, Fitzpatrick, and Mack (9) NAYS: Council member None (0).
Correspondence was received in the Clerk’s Office on September 14, 2022 from
Attorney Guy S DiMartino, PC regarding an accident with an MCPD vehicle
RESOLUTIONS
The Clerk read the following resolution by title only.
MICHIGAN CITY COMMON COUNCIL
RESOLUTION 4855
A RESOLUTION INCREASING AND DECREASING CERTAIN APPROPRIATIONS
WITHIN THE BUDGET OF THE CITY HALL DEPARTMENT OF THE GENERAL
FUND #1001 FOR THE YEAR 2022 IN MICHIGAN CITY, INDIANA
WHEREAS, there exists certain circumstances within the budget of the City Hall
Department of the General Fund #1001 of Michigan City which require increasing and
decreasing appropriations for certain line items in that Fund for the year 2022.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the Common Council of the City of
Michigan City, La Porte County, Indiana, that:
Section 1. Because it is deemed advisable and necessary, in order to meet the circumstances
facing the budget of City Hall of the General Fund of the City, the Common Council approves
the following transfer of appropriations, as listed, to-wit:
CITY HALL DEPARTMENT OF THE GENERAL FUND #1001
DECREASE: A/C #1001 109 411.013
Salaries & Wages Regular $10,000.00
A/C #1001 109 422.031
Operating Supplies Household $ 3,211.00
INCREASE: A/C #1001 109 436.010
Repairs & Maintenance - Building $13,211.00
This Resolution shall be in full force and effect after passage by the Michigan City Common
Council and approval by the Mayor.
INTRODUCED BY: /s/ Bryant Dabney, Member
Vice President D. Przybylinski asked if the sponsor had anything to add.
Councilman Dabney stated that this is a transfer of $13,211.00 within the City Hall’s
Page 5 September 20, 2022
general fund and is not asking for any additional funds for a project being done.
Vice President D. Przybylinski asked if there were any comments from the public, there
was no response.
Vice President D. Przybylinski asked if the Council had any questions or comments.
Councilman D. Przybylinski asked what exactly the transfer is being used for.
Yvonne Hoffmaster, City Controller advised that this transfer in the City Hall Building
fund is to replace the carpet in the suites upstairs in city hall; that the carpeting is over
twenty years old, attesting that the condition of the carpet is bad and a safety hazard to
our employees.
Councilman D. Przybylinski stated that he walked around city hall in each suite and
didn’t think the carpet was dirty but and needs to be cleaned but didn’t think it needed to
be replaced at this time; asking what the total cost of this project was.
Controller Hoffmaster advised the cost of the carpet is a little over $40,000.
Councilman Dabney made a motion to approve the transfer in the amount of
$13,211.00, second by Councilman Fitzpatrick; with the motion being approved by the
following vote: AYES: Council members Deuitch Simmons, Zygas, Dabney, Fitzpatrick,
and Mack (6) NAYS: Council member D. Przybylinski, P. Przybylinski, and Tillman (3).
Vice President D. Przybylinski stated that the proposed ordinance was placed at each
council members seat; asking if there was no objection, he would like to add this to the
agenda on first reading; that Skyler York Planning Director is present to explain what
the ordinance is and why we need to move forward in timely manner.
Councilwoman Deuitch made a motion to wave the rules and have first reading on the
proposed ordinance that she is sponsoring for the amended FEMA floodplain, second
by Councilwoman Tillman.
The motion carried and was approved to have the proposed ordinance on first reading
AYES: Council members D. Przybylinski, Simmons, Zygas, P. Przybylinski, Tillman,
Dabney, Fitzpatrick, Mack, and Deuitch (9) NAYS: Council member None (0).
Vice President D. Przybylinski asked Clerk Neulieb to read the proposed ordinance on
first reading.
The Clerk reading the following proposed ordinance on first reading by title only.
REPEALING AND REPLACING ARTICLE VIII IN CHAPTER 46 IN THE MICHIGAN
CITY MUNICPAL CODE COMMONLY KNOWN AS THE “FLOODPLAINS”
INTRODUCED BY: Angie Nelson Deuitch
Vice President D. Przybylinski asked if the sponsor had anything to add at this time.
Councilwoman Deuitch advised that every few years we have to update and amend the
floodplain plan ordinance; advising that this is an existing ordinance that the city has
been following and needs to adopt the proposed ordinance by September 29, 2022 to
make sure our residents have a floodplain ordinance adopted when they file an
insurance claim, or if something happens that they aren’t able to be compensated for
any losses and what has happened is over the course of the transition between emails
were being sent to former employees and is the reason we have a hard deadline so
there is no laps our deadline is September 29, 2022 and is detrimental to our residents
that reside in those floodplains.
Page 6 September 20, 2022
Councilwoman Deuitch advised that this council will be holding a “Special Meeting” at
the beginning of this next week to move forward and get this ordinance adopted so
there is no lap; stating the Skyler York City Planner is present to explain about what the
changes are.
Vice President D. Przybylinski asked if there were any questions or comments from the
public.
Skyler York, City Planner addressed the Council regarding the proposed ordinance
explaining that this is the same ordinance that is existing today which has been created
by DNR and FEMA and has added a coastal flood zone section addressing flooding not
located near or around the ocean.
Discussion ensued between Mr. York and Council members Fitzpatrick and P.
Przybylinski regarding Michigan City limits having a buffer along the lake which protects
a lot of our coastal area that are prone to flooding, not allow digging out and ruin this
nature, the correction of Chaney Run, flood insurance.
ORDINANCE
The Clerk read the following proposed ordinance on first reading by title only.
APPROVING ADDITIONAL APPROPRIATION IN THE BUDGET OF THE PLANNING
AND INSPECTION DEPARTMENT OF THE GENERAL FUND TO FUND THE LEASE
OF NEW VEHICLES
Introduced by: Angie Nelson Deuitch
(DECREASE General Fund # 1001 Unappropriated balance $34,000.00 INCREASE ACCOUNT
#1001.106.439.090 $34,000.00 Other Services & Charges Other Contractual Services)
Vice President D. Przybylinski asked if the sponsor had anything to add.
Councilwoman Deuitch advised the $34,000 in this proposed ordinance is the amount
received for the trade in value of the vehicles they had previously traded in by the
Planning/Inspection Department to lease new vehicles; and to make it cleaner instead
of having a credit with the dealership the City received a check in this amount with it
being deposited into the unappropriated balance fund and are requesting the $34,000
for the trade in vehicles be transferred to pay for the new leased vehicles for the
remaining time of the lease contract.
Vice President D. Przybylinski asked if there were any questions or comments from the
public.
Tommy Kulivak, 1316 Ohio Street stated that he knows the council must approve this
but don’t let the mayor drive any of the inspection vehicles.
Vice President D. Przybylinski asked if the Council had any questions or comments at
this time, there was no response; stating that this ordinance will be held over on second
reading at the October 4, 2022 Council meeting.
The Clerk read the following proposed ordinance on first reading by title only.
Page 7 September 20, 2022
APPROVING ADDITIONAL APPROPRIATION IN THE BUDGET OF THE DEA
FORFEITURE FUND TO FUND PURCHASE OF CARGO VAN
Introduced by: Angie Nelson Deuitch
(DECREASE DEA Forfeiture Fund #2337 Unappropriated balance $55,000.00 INCREASE
ACCOUNT #2337 000.445.020 $55,000.00 Capital Outlay – Other Machinery & Equipment –
Motor Equipment)
Vice President D. Przybylinski asked if the sponsor had anything to add.
Councilwoman Deuitch advised that this is a specialized fund with the police department
and will replace the patty wagon they have now that is in bad shape.
Vice President D. Przybylinski asked if the public had any questions or comments.
Tommy Kulivak, 1316 Ohio Street, advised that he saw the Patty Wagon at the Wolves
football game last week and he was glad they are replacing it, that it is in very poor
condition and needs to be replaced.
Vice President D. Przybylinski asked to be added as a Co-sponsor to this ordinance.
Vice President D. Przybylinski asked if there were any comments from the council, there
was no response; stating the ordinance will be held over on second reading until the
October 4, 2022 Council meeting.
The Clerk read the following proposed ordinance on first reading by title only.
APPROVING ADDITIONAL APPROPRIATION IN THE BUDGET OF THE GENERAL
FUND FOR LEGAL EXPENSES FOR THE CITY’S ESPLANADE
Introduced by: Dalia Zygas
(DECREASE General Fund #1001 Unappropriated balance $175,000.00 INCREASE
ACCOUNT#1001 112.431.010 $175,000.00 Professional Services – Legal)
Vice President D. Przybylinski asked if the sponsor had anything to add at this time.
Councilwoman Zygas stated this issue needs to be completed and move forward.
Vice President D. Przybylinski asked if there were any comments from the public, there
was no response.
Vice President D. Przybylinski asked if the council had any questions or comments.
Councilwoman Deuitch asked with adding this new amount of $175,000 advising there
is a balance of $13,000 left from the first amount that was appropriated for $175,000; if
anyone can give a timeframe about how long this is going to continue on till.
Vice President D. Przybylinski stated that no one has an answer at this time and that
our Attorney will address the attorneys working on these legal issues regarding the
esplanade.
Councilman P. Przybylinski stated that the council needs to have an Executive Session
with our City Legal Department to find out how many tort claims and lawsuits are
pending in our liability.
Vice President D. Przybylinski asked if there were any other comments from the council,
there was no response; stating that the proposed ordinance will be held over on second
reading at our October 4, 2022 council meeting.
Page 8 September 20, 2022
The Clerk read the following proposed ordinance on second reading by title only.
AMENDING MUNICIPAL CODE SECTION 22-606 REGARDING THE RATE OF PAY
FOR THE LICENSING BOARD MEMBERS
Introduced by: Angie Nelson Deuitch
Dalia Zygas
Vice President D. Przybylinski asked if either of the sponsors had anything to add.
Councilwoman Zygas stated that this will bring the pay for the members of the Licensing
Board to the same pay as all City Boards and Commission members receive.
Vice President D. Przybylinski asked if anyone from the public wished to speak on this
ordinance, there was no response.
Vice President D. Przybylinski asked if the Council had any comments.
Councilwoman Deuitch made a motion to wave the council rules to have second and
third reading this evening, second by Councilwoman Tillman; the motion carried to have
second and third reading this evening by the following vote: AYES: Council members
Simmons, Zygas, P. Przybylinski, Tillman, Dabney, Fitzpatrick, Mack, Deuitch, and D.
Przybylinski (9) NAYS: Council member None (0).
The Clerk read the following proposed ordinance on third reading by title only.
MICHIGAN CITY COMMON COUNCIL
ORDINANCE NO. 4644
AMENDING MUNICIPAL CODE SECTION 22-606 REGARDING THE RATE OF PAY
FOR LICENSING BOARD MEMBERS
WHEREAS, pursuant to Sec. 22-606, members of the Licensing Board are compensated
in the amount of $25.00 per meeting; and
WHEREAS, other boards/commissions, such as the Plan Commission, Board of Zoning
Appeals, Human Rights Commission, Social Status of African American Males, Women’s
Commission, Tree Board, and Sustainability Commission are compensated in the amount of
$50.00 per meeting; and
WHEREAS, the Common Council finds that it is in the best interest to amend Sec. 22-
606 to amend the rate of pay for licensing board members to $50.00 per meeting.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED by the Common Council of the City of
Michigan City, Indiana that Section 22-606 of the Michigan City Municipal Code shall be
amended to now read as follows:
Compensation of appointed members to the licensing board shall be $50.00 per member
per meeting attended.
This Ordinance to be effective upon passage by the Council and approval by the Mayor.
INTRODUCED BY: /s/Angie Nelson Deuitch, President
Michigan City Common Council
INTRODUCED BY: /s/Dalia Zygas, Member
Michigan City Common Council
Page 9 September 20, 2022
Vice President D. Przybylinski asked if either of the sponsors had anything to add, there
was no response.
Vice President D. Przybylinski asked if there were any comments from the public, there
was no response.
Vice President D. Przybylinski asked if the Council had anything to add at this time.
Councilwoman Deuitch made a motion to adopt the proposed ordinance, second by
Councilwoman Tillman.
The motion carried and the proposed ordinance was approved by the following vote:
AYES: Council members Zygas, P. Przybylinski, Tillman, Dabney, Fitzpatrick, Mack,
Deuitch, D. Przybylinski and Simmons (9) NAYS: Council member None (0).
The Clerk read the following proposed ordinance on second reading by title only.
ORDINANCE OR RESOLUTION FOR APPROPRIATION AND TAX RATES
Introduced by: Tracie Tillman
Sean Fitzpatrick
Paul Przybylinski
Bryant Dabney
Vice President D. Przybylinski asked if any of the sponsors had anything to add.
Councilwoman Tillman advised that when the Finance Committee had their wrap up
meeting there were no recommendations and currently since then there has been
recommendations in the proposed ordinance.
Vice President D. Przybylinski advised that we will open the formal public hearing at this
time (with this being posted on Gateway”); repeating three times “Is there anyone from
the public that wish to speak on the proposed ordinance at this time”, there was no
response, and the formal public hearing was closed.
Vice President D. Przybylinski asked if there were any comments or questions from the
council.
Clerk Neulieb advised Councilwoman Deuitch that each council member received a
hard copy this evening of the following proposed amendments from Councilwoman
Tillman.
Councilwoman Tillman made a motion to amend (1) Fund #0101 – General Fund in the
2023 budget estimate amend from $30,200,478.00 to $29,350,000.00. A difference of
$850,478.00, second by Councilwoman Deuitch.
Vice President D. Przybylinski asked if there were any questions or comments from the
public, there was no response.
Vice President D. Przybylinski asked if the Council had any comments or questions.
Councilman Dabney advised that he sees what is being done and he doesn’t see a
point where it’s coming from; asking we’re going to cut from 30 million to 29 million
dollars with a difference of $850,000; asking who is making these cuts.
Councilwoman Deuitch stated that she is assuming that is the City’s Administration’s go
ahead.
Page 10 September 20, 2022
Councilwoman Tillman agreed that this will be on the city’s administration; as we have
been told to us from the administration prior to budget hearings that they have the
experience, and know what is needed to operate and what the departments will need
on a daily basis; stating with these cuts they should be able to gate for each department
and how to run the city.
Councilman Dabney questioned if this is how the following amendments were arrived at,
so he doesn’t ask the same question after each amendment; with Councilwoman
Tillman advising, “yes”.
Councilman Mack advised that he didn’t have time to look at his email, since he worked
all day, questioning if the email included the basis for the cuts and where the cuts were
coming from.
Councilwoman Tillman advised that these cuts and recommendations began when we
started our budget hearing workshops; this was the consensus of information that we
obtained and gathered from the controller’s office and took in the consideration the
letters that went out to all departments asking their needs and wants that were returned
back to the Council’s Finance committee members; stating again that this would
something that the administration should be able to navigate through to make the
necessary appropriations that would be needed for each department.
Councilwoman Deuitch stated that she will be supporting this because this is to the
general fund; advising that this administration was going to deplete the general fund by
the end of next year (2023) and that she feels that if there is another issue or an
emergency like covid which was devastating; we want to make sure as the fiscal
responsible parties for the city that we don’t go into our reserves.
Councilman P. Przybylinski commented on going through the 2023 budget hearings and
the workshop addressing what the city’s responsibility for the fiscal plan (water/sewer) is
going to cost for the annexation of the 426 acres on the east side of our city that was
just adopted.
Councilman Dabney stated that he is looking over the amendments and that none of
these are cuts a Council’s Finance Committee has ever made before; explaining how
budget hearings were done in the past and how they only presented proposed salary
cuts to the Council; that cuts should be identified and reviewed with the different
departments and now we are making cuts and sending it back to the administration;
explaining again the process of how a budget should be done and that he knows the
Controller’s Office can do it, but is sad that this is being done this way.
Councilwoman Deuitch stated that it’s statutorily, we don’t have to follow that process
but her concern was she didn’t want to cut the wrong thing from a department, that she
would rather see the administration talk with their own department heads and prioritize
those items with them; instead of this council cutting one thing from a department and it
is an item they need and the department heads which they did a great job filling out the
forms for this council regarding their needs and wants.
Vice President D. Przybylinski stated that he knows what Councilman Dabney is talking
about; that when he was on the Finance Committee with Councilman Dabney that was
the way the budget was proposed and that was the past and this finance committee
decided they want to do it this way; advising that he has a concern with the amount of
money that is going to be left in the general fund that was proposed for the 2023 budget
by the mayor; commenting on the cost of the fiscal plan that the city has to address to
the new annexed land of 426 acres; agreeing with this amendment.
Vice President D. Przybylinski asked if there were any other council comments, there
was no response.
There is a motion on the floor to amend Fund 0101 of the General Fund from
$30,200,000.00 to $29,350,000.00 with a difference of $850,478.00 and second with
Page 11 September 20, 2022
this amendment being approved by the following vote: AYES: Council members P.
Przybylinski, Tillman, Dabney, Fitzpatrick, Mack, Deuitch, D. Przybylinski, Simmons and
Zygas (9) NAYS: Council member None (0).
Councilwoman Tillman made a motion to amend (2) Fund 0005 – Riverboat Fund in the
2023 budget estimate from $10,081,550.00 to $6,081,550.00. A difference of
$4,000,000.00, second by Councilman P. Przybylinski.
Vice President D. Przybylinski asked if there were any questions or comments from the
public on the proposed amendment, there was no response.
Vice President D. Przybylinski asked if the Council had any questions or comments at
this time.
Controller Hoffmaster advised Councilman Mack of the expectation of the monies they
we’re planning or estimating and would be receiving from the Riverboat an estimated
9.9 million dollars and anticipate a little over 5 million balance at the end of this year.
Controller Hoffmaster advised Councilwoman Deuitch that the amount wouldn’t change
in the budget that they would still put 25% into the Rainy-Day Fund.
Controller Hoffmaster advised Councilwoman Deuitch there are a couple large projects
being proposed in 2023 with those departments having to come to the council for their
approval of an additional appropriation and that there are no monies coming out of the
Riverboat fund for salaries.
Vice President D. Przybylinski asked if there were any other questions or comments
from the council, there was no response.
A motion and second was made to amend (2) Fund 0005 – Riverboat Fund in the 2023
budget estimate from $10,081,550.00 to $6,081,550.00. A difference of $4,000,000.00,
second by Councilman P. Przybylinski and was approved by the following vote:
AYES: Council members Tillman, Fitzpatrick, Deuitch, D. Przybylinski, Simmons and P.
Przybylinski (6) NAYS: Council member Dabney, Mack, and Zygas (3).
Councilwoman Tillman made a motion to amend (3) Fund 9513 – LIT Public Health in
the 2023 budget estimated from $800,000.00 to $400,000.00 or more. A difference of
$400,000.00, second by Councilman P. Przybylinski.
Vice President D. Przybylinski asked if there were any questions or comments from the
public, there was no response.
Vice President D. Przybylinski asked if anyone from the Council had any questions or
comments.
Councilman Dabney stated that he voted “I” for this ordinance when he said he should
have voted against it due to not knowing where these monies are going to be spent and
what cuts are going to be proposed.
Councilwoman Deuitch stated that she has a technical question from Attorney Harris;
that when we come back for our next reading, we already voted to have amendments
on third reading; wanting to schedule a workshop after these cuts have been done
because she wants to make sure our City employees aren’t being impacted by the cut.
Vice President D. Przybylinski asked since we want to amend the LIT tax from $800,000
to $400,000 the balance left will be $400,000 and we will put that into the Riverboat;
with Councilwoman Tillman answer “yes”.
Page 12 September 20, 2022
Councilwoman Tillman advised that hopefully by the end of this year going into 2023 an
increase of the LIT public health and safety, that the purpose being proposed is not to
deplete the LIT fund; advising there will be graphic news that will increase that amount.
The motion to amend Fund 9513 – LIT Public Health to amend 2023 estimate from
$800,000.00 to $400,000 or more. A difference of $400,000.00. was approved by the
following vote: AYES: Council members Fitzpatrick, Deuitch, D. Przybylinski, Simmons,
and P. Przybylinski (6) NAYS: Council member Dabney, Mack, and Zygas (3).
Attorney Harris advised that since we haven’t moved forward to the next ordinance
someone can make a motion to be able to do amendments on third reading on the
following proposed ordinance: “ORDINANCE OR RESOLUTION FOR
APPROPRIATION AND TAX RATES”
Councilman Przybylinski made a motion to be able to make amendments on third
reading at the October 4, 2022 Council meeting to this proposed ordinance.
“ORDINANCE OR RESOLUTION FOR APPROPRIATION AND TAX RATES”, second
by Councilwoman Deuitch.
The motion carried and was approved to have amendments on third reading to the
proposed ordinance “ORDINANCE OR RESOLUTION FOR APPROPRIATION AND
TAX RATES” by the following vote: AYES: Council members Fitzpatrick, Mack,
Deuitch, D. Przybylinski, Simmons, Zygas, P. Przybylinski, Tillman, and Dabney (9)
NAYS: Council member None (0).
The Clerk read the following proposed ordinance on second reading by title only.
AN ORDINANCE SETTING SALARIES AND WAGES FOR APPOINTED OFFICIALS
AND EMPLOYEES OF THE CITY OF MICHIGAN CITY, INDIANA, FOR THE
CALENDAR YEAR 2023
Introduced by: Tracie Tillman
Paul Przybylinski
Bryant Dabney
Sean Fitzpatrick
Vice President D. Przybylinski asked if the sponsors had anything to add.
Councilman P. Przybylinski made a motion to be able to have amendments on third
reading on this proposed ordinance, second by Councilman Fitzpatrick.
The motion carried to have amendments to this proposed ordinance on third reading by
the following vote: AYES: Council members Mack, Deuitch, D. Przybylinski, Simmons,
Zygas, P. Przybylinski, Tillman, Dabney, and Fitzpatrick (9) NAYS: Council member
None (0).
Councilwoman Tillman made a motion to amend the (6) Mayor’s administrator from
$59,160.00 to $53,500.00 (being a 2% increase), second by Councilman P.
Przybylinski.
Vice President D. Przybylinski asked if there were any questions or comments from the
public on the amendment, there was no response.
Vice President D. Przybylinski asked if there were any questions or comments from the
Council.
Councilman P. Przybylinski advised that we’re trying to stay at a 2% raise, a guideline
that has been proposed by the administration for several employees.
Page 13 September 20, 2022
Councilwoman Deuitch asked where these cuts came from that she didn’t have any
information about them until now.
Councilman Mack also stated that he was at work and didn’t get a chance to look at his
emails asking where these cuts are coming from, that this is not the future; advising in
his opinion is not to minimize but should be to maximize and try to get the best people in
some of these positions as we can; stating that he would not be voting in favor of what
is being proposed.
Councilman Dabney asked that everyone is going to get a 2% raise moving forward on
the 2023 budget and correct me if I’m wrong.
Councilwoman Tillman advised the 2% was recommended from the administration for
our employees; stating that she does concur with what Councilman Mack said and
totally agrees that our administration and department heads in these positions were an
astronomical increase last year, but yet we’re only approving a 2% pay raise for our
hourly employees who actually are out in the fields doing all the hard work; that 2%
should have been increased to at least 6%; but it is ok for the Mayor Administrator to
get a much higher increase; that is an insult.
Discussion ensued between Councilwoman Tillman and Council members Zygas, D.
Przybylinski, Deuitch, Fitzpatrick, Simmons, regarding the 2% increases being proposed
to the hourly employees, employees that received astronomical increases in the 2022
budget, understanding the list that was received regarding the proposed decreases and
deletions to the proposed 2023 salary ordinance, recommendations presented at the
last Finance Workshop, the adoption of the maximum amount of the request by the
administration for hourly employees in 2022 unlike what we did with salaried
employees, not enough time to review proposed amendments received this evening
from the Finance Committee.
Councilwoman Tillman withdrew her motion to decrease the City’s Administrator
proposed increases at this time.
Councilman P. Przybylinski (tentatively) removed his motion to decrease the City’s
Administrator proposed increase at this time.
Attorney Harris advised Councilwoman Deuitch that it was approved this evening to
have amendments to this proposed ordinance on third reading.
Councilwoman Tillman stated that she doesn’t have any other amendments at this time.
Councilman Dabney commented for the public’s knowledge and is having trouble
himself understanding some of the process that is being addressed this evening in
regards to the proposed 2023 budget; he explained to the public about how last year’s
budget for hourly and salaried employees was adopted and what is being proposed for
2023 budget by Mayor Parry, and what was addressed during the 2023 finance budget
hearings.
Councilman P. Przybylinski made a comment in reference to Councilman Dabney’s
statement that was just made about the individual that received a 90% increase last
year.
Councilwomen Tillman and Zygas stated that we did have an excellent chart prepared
by Ms. Smith from the Controller’s Office at our last workshop.
Councilman Dabney commented that there seems to be a correlation between
proposed salary and hourly increases; with this council being the fiscal controlling body,
it would seem we should be consistent of how we do procedures every year; and what
is being proposed and the direction that is being taken.
Page 14 September 20, 2022
Councilwoman Tillman advised Councilwoman Zygas that she only has two (2)
amendments that she will be proposing as we move forward that was in her email and
will be recommending to remove/delete the recreational director; that if there are other
amendments being proposed that a council member will bring them to the table.
Councilwoman Tillman made a motion to remove the Recreational Director from the
park budget in the amount of $55,000.00, second by Councilwoman Deuitch.
Vice President D. Przybylinski asked if there were any comments from the public, there
was no response.
Vice President D. Przybylinski asked if there were any questions or comments from the
Council.
Councilman Mack stated that he would like to see the city have a recreational director;
that a lack of programming for our youth is directly tied to not having this position; that to
get better at programing we need this director; there is a recreational center being
proposed to be built in our community and would seem the future we would like for our
kids and adults would be a recreational director asking to move this forward.
Councilman Simmons concurred with Councilman Mack that we need to get a
recreational director back in the Park Department.
Councilwoman Deuitch stated that she supports this amendment that we cancelled our
summer camps this summer and there are organizations in our community; advising
she would rather allow to widen and expand free programming for our residents and us
support these organizations in the meantime until we have a better understanding of
what our plan is; that when the Park Department split the roles and increased the pay
for the assistant superintendent the recreational duties was part of that deal, with her
trying to understand that she realizes they are busy in the summer but would like to see
small programs before creating a brand new position.
Councilwoman Zygas agrees with Councilwoman Deuitch’s comments; could we even
get someone to fill this position that is qualified and what amount of money are we
willing to commit at this time for programming not only for kids but adults in our
community.
Councilman P. Przybylinski stated after sitting through our budget hearings and this
position was a new position and was brought forth, there were questions brought up, not
seeing a plan or a format on what this recreational director would be doing; stating there
is several programs that the city could get started in our community.
Councilman Dabney stated reasons why he feels that this position would be an asset
and should be brought back to the park department to see what programs we could get
within our community.
Councilman Fitzpatrick asked if the proposed recreational director that is in the
proposed 2023 budget and is being created again and the additional salary that was
given to the Parks Assistant Superintendent when this position was removed during the
last administration was in office; will those monies that were given to the Asst.
Superintendent go toward this new created position, since that was an agreement to be
reflective on the pay rate as doing part of the recreation director duties.
Councilwoman Tillman directed Councilman Fitzpatrick’s question to Controller
Hoffmaster.
Councilwoman Hoffmaster advised that we would not be reducing anyone’s salary.
Vice President D. Przybylinski asked if there were any other comments on this
proposed amendment by the council. There was no response and the amendment to
Page 15 September 20, 2022
delete the proposed position in the Park Department’s 2023 Budget to delete the new
position for a “Park Director” in the amount of $55,000.00 failed by the following vote:
AYES: Council members Deuitch, P. Przybylinski, Tillman, Fitzpatrick, (4) NAYS:
Council member D. Przybylinski, Zygas, Simmons, Dabney and Mack (5).
Vice President D. Przybylinski stated the amendment to delete the “Recreation Director”
was approved 5 – 4.
Councilman P. Przybylinski asked to reconsider his vote; stating that he wanted to vote
NAY.
Attorney Harris advised that he would have to make a motion to reconsider the vote and
would need a second and take the roll call to redo the vote.
Councilman Mack made a motion to reconsider the vote, second by Councilman
Fitzpatrick asking for the amendment to be re-read before taking the reconsidered vote.
The motion to reconsider the vote was approved by the following vote: AYES: Council
members D. Przybylinski, Simmons, Zygas, P. Przybylinski, Tillman, Dabney,
Fitzpatrick, Mack and Deuitch (9) NAYS: Council member None (0).
Vice President D. Przybylinski stated that we will be voting on eliminating/deleting the
“Recreational Director” from the Park Departments budget.
The motion carried to eliminate/delete the Recreation Director from the Park
Departments in the 2023 budget by the following vote: AYES: Council members P.
Przybylinski, Tillman, Fitzpatrick, Deuitch and D. Przybylinski (5) NAYS: Council
member Simmons, Zygas, Dabney, Mack (4).
NOTE: VICE PRESIDENT CALLED A FIVE (5) MINUTE RECESS
Councilman P. Przybylinski made a motion to amend Fund 101 Controller Salary –
current salary at $71,000.00 with the 2023 budget salary of $79,560.00 decreasing the
amount to $75,290.00, second by Councilwoman Tillman.
Vice President D. Przybylinski asked if anyone from the public wish to speak on the
proposed amendment.
Yvonne Hoffmaster, City Controller wanted to let the council know that the statement
that was made regarding the money the Controller’s Office receives from the Sanitary
District and Water Department doesn’t go towards any salaries in the Controller’s Office
Controller Hoffmaster advised Councilman P. Przybylinski the money received from
these entities go into the general fund as miscellaneous revenue to assist with funding
the budget, but specifically for the Controller’s Office; with MOU between the Sanitary
District and the city is for the Assistant Controllers position.
Vice President D. Przybylinski asked if the public had any other questions or comments,
there was no response.
Vice President D. Przybylinski asked if the Council had any questions or comments,
there was no response.
The motion was carried to amend Fund 101 Controller Salary – current salary at
$71,000.00 with the 2023 proposed budget salary of $79,560.00 decreasing that
amount to $75,290.00 and was approved by the following vote:
NOTE: Councilwoman Tillman lost contact with hybrid/zoom (the council is
waiting) with the vote taking place as follows
Page 16 September 20, 2022
Vice President D. Przybylinski asked Councilwoman Deuitch if Councilwoman Tillman
could call her and they do face time with her; and show her face so she can vote; with
Councilwoman Deuitch stating that for the integrity of this meeting that Councilwoman
Tillman would have to log into the Council’s Zoom and get on the meeting that way.
Discussion ensued between Attorney Harris, Councilwoman Deuitch, and Vice
President D. Przybylinski regarding this matter.
NOTE: Councilwoman Tillman face timed with Councilwoman Deuitch and the
vote was completed
The motion was approved by the following vote to amend the 2023 budget for the
Controller Fund 101 to be $75,290.00 AYES: Council members P. Przybylinski,
Fitzpatrick, Deuitch, D. Przybylinski, and Tillman (5) NAYS: Council member Zygas,
Dabney, Mack, Simmons (4).
Vice President D. Przybylinski asked if there were anymore amendments to the
proposed ordinance
Councilman P. Przybylinski made a motion to delete the (9) Event Planners
Administrative Assistant II from the 2023 budget in the amount of $40,768.00, second
by Councilman Fitzpatrick.
Vice President D. Przybylinski asked if there are any comments from the public, there
was no response.
Vice President D. Przybylinski asked the Council had any comments or questions, there
was no response, with the amendment failed by the following vote: AYES: Council
members P. Przybylinski, Tillman, Fitzpatrick, D. Przybylinski, and Tillman (5) NAYS:
Council member Dabney, Mack, Deuitch, and Simmons (4).
Councilman P. Przybylinski made a motion to delete the (8) Mayor’s Administrative
Assistant III from the 2023 budget in the amount of $42,889.00, second by Councilman
Fitzpatrick.
NOTE: COUNCILWOMAN TILLMAN WAS ABLE TO CONNECT ON ZOOM TO
CONTINUE IN THE MEETING
Vice President D. Przybylinski asked if there was anyone from the public that wished to
speak on this proposed amendment.
Tamiko Smith, Controller Assistant II, advised that this position isn’t filled in the mayor’s
office at this time.
Vice President D. Przybylinski asked if there were any other comments from the public
at this time, there was no response.
Vice President D. Przybylinski asked if there were any comments from the council.
Councilwoman Deuitch stated that this has been funded for over two years and it hasn’t
been filled; but when people go on vacation or other reasons they aren’t in the Mayor’s
Office, not answering the telephones, greeting citizens that she feels this is a necessary
position, and that the office shouldn’t be unattended; stating that this will be the will of
the council.
Kathy Stransky, Barker Avenue asked how the city ended up with so many
administrative positions and assistants to them to the administration to the assistant;
stating it is redundant.
Page 17 September 20, 2022
Vice President D. Przybylinski stated that this position hasn’t been filled since the
current administration took office two (2) years ago; that when Mr. Yagelski is gone it
either goes to the answering machine or Ms. Beutner will answer and that everything is
going smoothly in the mayor’s office on a daily basis and haven’t heard one complaint
and totally agrees that this position isn’t necessary; stating that when our city grows
from getting the NICTD Double Track Project we can revisit it at that time.
The motion failed to delete the Administrative Assistant III in the mayor’s Office by the
following vote: AYES: Council members Fitzpatrick, D. Przybylinski, and P. Przybylinski
(3) NAYS: Council member Tillman, Dabney, Mack, Deuitch, Simmons, and Zygas (6).
Councilman P. Przybylinski made a motion to delete the (14) Arborist Position from the
2023 budget in the amount of $62,377.21 and that the mayor stated that doesn’t have
any intention in filling this position in the near future, that he did have someone
interestedthat would be graduating next spring but they won’t have all certificates they
will need to be the City’s Arborist and at the time the Mayor deems to fill it he can come
to the Council; the motion died due a lack of a second motion.
Councilman P. Przybylinski made a motion to amend the position of the City Engineer in
the 2023 budget deleting this position in the amount of $99,992.00 because it makes
good fiscal sense due to this position not being filled and that the City has two (2)
contracts with engineer firms doing the work for our city; stating at least until we have a
candidate or someone interested to work for the city, the motion was second by Vice
President D. Przybylinski.
Vice President D. Przybylinski asked if there were any comments from the public.
Mayor Parry stated that is incorrect that I have no intentions of hiring a City Engineer,
we are trying to fill this position and wants to remind this council that there is a state
statue for requirements, that on the Planning Commission and the Sanitary District
board; a voting member is supposed to be our PE City Engineer.
Mayor Parry advised Councilman P. Przybylinski that at this time we do not have a PE
engineer filling in and representing the city as a member to the Sanitary Board at this
time.
Vice President D. Przybylinski stated that this falls under the mayor’s direction for a City
Engineer and that $99,000.00 that we’ve discussed, know this isn’t enough money to
attract someone that is experienced or has government experience even graduating
from college with a PE; part-time or full-time.
Discussion ensued between Mayor Parry and Vice President D. Przybylinski and P.
Przybylinski regarding the engineer’s increase in the 2023 budget, if the council is
willing to increase it more, advising that he is sure we will be receiving resumes soon
after the 2023 budget for this position is approved..
Vice President D. Przybylinski asked if there was anyone else that wished to speak on
the proposed amendment, there was no response.
Councilwoman Deuitch stated that being an engineer herself we need to think about
reposting this at the higher rate since it is a part-time position and some people looking
to get experience in government.
The motion to delete the City Engineer from the 2023 budget failed by the following
vote: AYES: Council members P. Przybylinski (1) NAYS: Council member Dabney,
Fitzpatrick, Mack, Deuitch, D Przybylinski, Simmons, Zygas and Tillman (8).
Page 18 September 20, 2022
Vice President D. Przybylinski asked if the Council had anymore amendments at this
time; there was no response; stating that the proposed ordinance will be held over on
third reading at the October 4, 2022 Council meeting.
The Clerk read the following proposed ordinance on second reading by title only.
AN ORDINANCE SETTING THE ANNUAL SALARY FOR THE MAYOR
Introduced by: Tracie Tillman
Paul Przybylinski
Bryant Dabney
Sean Fitzpatrick
Vice President D. Przybylinski asked if any of the sponsors had anything to add.
Councilwoman Tillman made a motion to amend Fund 9513 Mayor’s Salary with the
current 2022 salary of $79,410.00, the budget estimate salary of $101,541.00 and
amend it to $88,000.00, second by Councilman Fitzpatrick.
Vice President D. Przybylinski asked if there was anyone from the public that wish to
speak on this proposed ordinance.
Tommy Kulivak, 1316 Ohio Street, read IC 36-4-3 powers and duties of the city mayor;
Reading this code every year before the passing of the mayor’s salary ordinance.
Vice President D. Przybylinski asked if there were any questions or comments from the
council.
Councilman P. Przybylinski stated this comment is germane; that when Mayor Parry
took office he should of called a meeting/workshop regarding the annexation for 426
acres and was adopted by the last council and administration; or this should have been
something that he should of renewed when he took office, that what the city is facing is
the direct responsibility of this administration to sit down with his new council and this to
our attention with them being the fiscal body, so we could have been preparing
ourselves for the last two (2) years.
Councilman P. Przybylinski agrees in cutting his Mayor’s salary to the $88,000; that his
administration is lacking in what’s going on here in our city and is deeply concerned
about how this annexation is going to affect the rate payers.
Councilman Mack stated that he has said this before, but he doesn’t think these
salaries, especially the mayor’s salary should not be based on past performance, but
future expectations of what the future can hold for everyone in our community.
Councilman Fitzpatrick agreed with what Councilman Mack just said; that it makes a lot
of sense; advising that Mayor Parry’s term doesn’t end until January 1, 2024 and would
be in agreement if an incoming mayor was starting January 1, 2023 but that isn’t
happening, so for right now I can’t support over $100,000.
Vice President D. Przybylinski asked if the council had any other comments or
questions, there was no response.
Vice President D. Przybylinski wanted the public to know that $10,000 of they mayor’s
salary comes from the Sanitary Department and $10,000 comes from the Water
Department which is the legal means toward the mayor’s administrator.
The motion to amend the mayor’s salary to $88,000.00 was approved by the following
vote: AYES: Council members Fitzpatrick, Deuitch, D. Przybylinski, Simmons, P.
Przybylinski, and Tillman (6) NAYS: Council member Mack, Zygas and Dabney (3).
Page 19 September 20, 2022
The Clerk read the following proposed ordinance on second reading by title only.
AN ORDINANCE SETTING THE ANNUAL SALARY FOR THE CITY CLERK
Introduced by: Tracie Tillman
Paul Przybylinski
Bryant Dabney
Sean Fitzpatrick
Vice President D. Przybylinski asked if the sponsors had anything to add.
Councilwoman Tillman stated that she had no recommendations to this proposed
ordinance.
Vice President D. Przybylinski asked if the public had any questions or comments, there
was no response.
Vice President D. Przybylinski asked if there were any comments from the council, there
was no response; stating that this proposed ordinance will be held over on third reading
at our October 4, 2022 Council meeting.
The Clerk read the following proposed ordinance on second reading by title only.
ESTABLISHING THE SALARIES FOR THE MICHIGAN CITY POLICE DEPARTMENT FOR
THE CALENDAR YEAR 2023
Introduced by: Tracie Tillman
Paul Przybylinski
Bryant Dabney
Sean Fitzpatrick
Vice President D. Przybylinski asked if there were any questions or comments from any
of the sponsors, there was no response.
Vice President D. Przybylinski asked if the public had anything to add regarding the
proposed ordinance, there was no response.
Vice President D. Przybylinski asked if the Council had any questions or comments,
there was no response; stating that the proposed ordinance will be held over on third
reading at the October 4, 2022 Council meeting.
The Clerk read the following proposed ordinance on second reading by title only.
AN ORDINANCE ESTABLISHING SALARIES FOR THE FIRE DEPARTMENT OF
THE CITY OF MICHIGAN CITY FOR THE CALENDAR YEAR 2023
Introduced by: Tracie Tillman
Paul Przybylinski
Bryant Dabney
Sean Fitzpatrick
Vice President D. Przybylinski asked if the sponsors had anything to add at this time,
there was no response.
Vice President D. Przybylinski asked if the public had any questions or comments, there
was no response.
Vice President D. Przybylinski asked if the council had any questions or comments,
there was no response; stating that the proposed ordinance will be held over on third
reading at our October 4, 2022 Council meeting.
Page 20 September 20, 2022
The Clerk read the following proposed ordinance on second reading by title only.
AN ORDINANCE SETTING THE ANNUAL SALARIES FOR THE COMMON COUNCIL
MEMBERS
Introduced by: Tracie Tillman
Paul Przybylinski
Bryant Dabney
Sean Fitzpatrick
Vice President D. Przybylinski asked if any of the sponsors had anything to add at this
time.
Councilman P. Przybylinski made a motion to amend the amount that was proposed in
2023 budget in the amount of $15,045.00 ($578.66 bi-weekly); reducing it to (reducing
the 2% increase) $14,552.98 ($559.73 bi-weekly), second by Councilman Fitzpatrick.
Vice President D. Przybylinski asked if the public had any comments regarding this
proposed ordinance, there was no response.
Vice President D. Przybylinski asked if the Council had any questions or comments.
Councilwoman Zygas stated based on the comments that were made earlier and we
want to attract better people, we might want to try to inch these positions up; that it
seems like we’re suffering from a little bit of self-esteem.
Councilman Fitzpatrick stated that he thinks this is one that should not because you
need people up here that don’t need money; advising that you need people serve the
council that are serious about their position and their job objectively, not based on a
paycheck.
Councilman Mack agreed with Councilman Fitzpatrick that you do this for other than
money, but guarantee to get people like us have full time jobs and we need to begin to
get people under 40 to pass the torch of government experience to keep our city
blooming.
Councilwoman Deuitch advised that she just went to a conference and for the younger
group it said it’s not even about the money its about lifestyle quality of life over money
because most, including herself, make six (6) figures because it’s about the impact that
you’re making with people; and that she will be supporting this amendment.
Councilman P. Przybylinski advised that when he was on the council previously, they
would never propose a pay increase when they served their four-year term; that to
serve you must want to make positive impact to our city and care about every citizen in
our community.
Councilman Dabney stated that he has listened to this argument over and over for the
last six (6) years and if its for the council should it be that way for all elected officials,
that is their civic duty as well; advising this argument falls flat for him.
Vice President D. Przybylinski stated when he ran for this office twelve years ago, he
didn’t look at what the salary was going to be, but wanted to make a difference to make
things better in our community; advising if this council wants to give a raise next year for
the 2024 incoming council members, he would be in favor of that.
Vice President D. Przybylinski asked if there were any other comments, there was no
response.
The amendment to reduce the Council’s salary to $14,552.98 (bi-weekly $559.73) was
approved by the following vote: AYES: Council members Deuitch, D. Przybylinski,
Simmons, Tillman, and Fitzpatrick (5) NAYS: Council member Mack, Zygas, P.
Przybylinski and Dabney (4).
Page 21 September 20, 2022
Councilman P. Przybylinski made a motion to reconsider his vote at this time, second by
Councilman Fitzpatrick.
The motion carried to reconsider the vote on the proposed amendment by the following
vote: AYES: Council members Deuitch D. Przybylinski, Simmons, Zygas, P.
Przybylinski, Tillman, Dabney, Fitzpatrick, and Mack (9) NAYS: Council member none
(0).
The amendment to reduce the Council’s salary to $14,552.98 (bi-weekly $559.73) was
approved by the following vote: AYES: Council members D. Przybylinski, Simmons, P.
Przybylinski, Tillman, Fitzpatrick and Deuitch (6) NAYS: Council member Zygas,
Dabney, and Mack (3).
NEW BUSINESS
Vice President D. Przybylinski advised that there was no new business this evening.
UNFINISHED BUSINESS
NOMINATIONS: Vice President D. Przybylinski advised the Council has the following
appointments to the Commission of the Social Status of African American Males (term
expired 2/15/22)
Incumbents:
Ms. Albertine Allen – Minority Health Partners of LaPorte County
(resigned)
Dr. Wendall McCollum- MCAS
COMMENTS FROM THE PUBLIC
Vice President D. Przybylinski asked if there were any comments from the public at this
time.
Tommy Kulavik, 1316 Ohio Street, stated that he turned in an application to the Clerk’s
Office to serve on the Social Status of African American Males Board representing the
Michigan City Area Schools position.
Kathy Stransky, 223 E. Barker Avenue, addressed the Council advising that she has
had to call the police four (4) regarding shots fired by her neighbor/friends and have not
received any cooperation from the police and this administration; asking for help from
this council before someone gets hurt.
Vice President D. Przybylinski asked Ms. Stransky to give him a couple days to contact
Chief Campbell and get back with her then.
Discussion ensued between Councilman P. Przybylinski and Ms. Stransky about solar
lights and the “ECHO” devices that are going to be placed on poles throughout the city
that will let the police department know when shots are being fired and let them know
what kind of vehicle is doing the shooting and people being afraid to call the police for
fear of their own lives.
Tommy Kulavik, 1316 Ohio Street, commented on the county dedicating different
bridges in our county advising the LaPorte County Commissioners nominated Alan
Whitlow; naming the bridge located on Springland Avenue over Tail Creek; stating
several things he did for our community serving for several entities including being City
Council member.
Page 22 September 20, 2022
Mr. Kulavik also invited everyone to the March for Peace on Saturday, October 1st,
2022, at 11:30 a.m. starting at Grace Street walking down Michigan Boulevard to
Westcott Park with the march for people who think violence is the answer.
Vice President D. Przybylinski asked if there were any other comments from the Public
or online, there was no response.
COMMENTS FROM THE COUNCIL
Vice President D. Przybylinski asked if there were any comments from the council.
Councilwoman Zygas stated that the last few days she has been teaching water quality
for Trail Creek Week; teaching hundreds of fourth graders mostly in the area about the
history, aquatics, the safety and they got to go on a canoe.
Councilwoman Zygas advised that there is a canoe race this Saturday September 24,
2022 to raise money for it, and basically the Sanitary District, Mayor Parry, and Laporte
Mayor Dermody are going to be in this race and that it starts at 10:00 a.m.
Councilwoman Zygas thanked Street Director Shong Smith and the Street Department
for putting up our signs, so we are officially Tree City USA and Bird Town, Indiana.
Councilwoman Deuitch reminded everyone that maybe before the Peaceful March
everyone could come and join the Minority Health Partners of LaPorte County
sponsoring their annual “Do the Real Men Where Pink Breast Cancer Walk” at 10:00
a.m. October 1, 2022 starting at 710 Franklin Street.
Attorney Harris advised Councilman P. Przybylinski that the letter the Council received
from Mayor Parry/Attorney Meyer (Sanitation Legal Counsel) is basically explaining the
procedure of the Indiana Attorney General’s Office.
Councilman P. Przybylinski commented that this council has representation on the
Sanitary Board and that being the liaison this person should be made abreast of what is
going on at the Sanitary District and the Water Department due to this being important
to decisions this council must make soon.
Councilman P. Przybylinski announced that September has been Hispanic Culture
month thanking them for all the help they have done in our community to help our
country grow.
Vice President D. Przybylinski stated that the Common Council is going to sponsor
dinner for the Michigan City High School Wolves Football team Thursday, September
22, 2022 that we have a great team and hope they win on Friday, September 23rd.
Vice President D. Przybylinski thanked Clerk Neulieb for staying and getting everything
thing together for tonight’s meeting.
ADJOURNMENT
A motion by President Deuitch, second by Councilman P. Przybylinski and there being
no further business to transact, President Deuitch declared the meeting ADJOURNED
(approximately 10:27 p.m.)
_______________________________
Gale A. Neulieb
Agenda
AGENDA
COMMON COUNCIL - REGULAR MEETING
Tuesday, September 20, 2022
Meeting to be held at 6:30 p.m., local time,
in the Council Chambers, City Hall 100 E. Michigan Blvd.
and Hosted by “Hybrid/Zoom” and Streaming Live on
“My Michigan City” Facebook Page
See attached to connect to “Hybrid/Zoom”
CALL TO ORDER BY COUNCIL PRESIDENT
PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE AND SILENT PRAYER
ROLL CALL
APPROVAL OF MINUTES Approval of Hybrid/Zoom September 6, 2022 Council
Meeting
REPORTS of STANDING COMMITTEES
Agenda September 20, 2022
Posted September 15, 2022
Page 1
FINANCE COMMITTEE MEETING Tracie Tillman-Chair
CLAIMS DOCKET
September 20, 2022
Fund #2042 – Riverboat – Claims - $ 00.00
EFT $ 00.00
Fund #2031 – Boyd Development - $ 00.00
EFT $ 00.00
TOTAL CLAIMS $ 00.00
REPORTS OF SPECIAL or SELECT COMMITTEES
REPORTS from MAYOR OR OTHER CITY OFFICERS AND DEPARTMENTS
PETITIONS
COMMUNICATIONS
Correspondence was received in the Clerk’s Office from Attorney Harris Law Firm regarding
concerns regarding the Council’s lack of authority to enact Ordinance No. 4637 & 4638
Agenda September 20, 2022
Posted September 15, 2022
Page 2
Correspondence was received in the Clerk’s Office on September 15, 2022 from Mayor Parry
vetoing Ordinance No. 4637 AMENDING SEC. 98-85 OF THE MICHIGAN CITY
MUNICIPAL CODEKNOWN AS ADDITIONS TO THE SANITARY DISTRICT TO AMEND
THE ANNEXATION CONDITIONS AND PROCEDURES
AND
Ordinance No. 4638 CREATING SEC. 98-86 AND SEC. 98-87 IN THE MICHIGAN CITY
MUNICIPAL CODE TO ESTATBLISH THECONDITIONS AND PROCEDURES FOR
ADDITIONS TO THE SANITARY DISTRICT.
Correspondence was received in the Clerk’s Office on September 14, 2022 from Attorney Guy
S DiMartino, PC regarding an accident with an MCPD vehichle
RESOLUTIONS A RESOLUTION INCREASING AND DECREASING CERTAIN
APPROPRIATIONS WITHIN THE BUDGET OF THE CITY HALL
DEPARTMENT OF THE GENERAL FUND #1001 FOR THE YEAR 2022
IN MICHIGAN CITY, INDIANA
INTRODUCED BY: Bryant Dabney
ORDINANCES
ORDINANCE APPROVING ADDITIONAL APPROPRIATION IN THE BUDGET OF
1st Reading THE PLANNING AND INSPECTION DEPARTMENT OF THE
GENERAL FUND TO FUND THE LEASE OF NEW VEHICLES
Introduced by: Angie Nelson Deuitch
(DECREASE General Fund # 1001 Unappropriated balance $34,000.00
INCREASE ACCOUNT #1001.106.439.090 $34,000.00 Other Services & Charges
Other Contractual Services)
Agenda September 20, 2022
Posted September 15, 2022
Page 3
ORDINANCE APPROVING ADDITIONAL APPROPRIATION IN THE BUDGET
1st Reading OF THE DEA FORFEITURE FUND TO FUND PURCHASE OF CARGO
VAN
Introduced by: Angie Nelson Deuitch
(DECREASE DEA Forfeiture Fund #2337 Unappropriated balance $55,000.00
INCREASE ACCOUNT #2337 000.445.020 $55,000.00 Capital Outlay – Other
Machinery & Equipment – Motor Equipment)
ORDINANCE APPROVING ADDITIONAL APPROPRIATION IN THE BUDGET OF
1st Reading THE GENERAL FUND FOR LEGAL EXPENSES FOR THE CITY’S
ESPLANADE
Introduced by: Dalia Zygas
(DECREASE General Fund #1001 Unappropriated balance $175,000.00
INCREASE ACCOUNT#1001 112.431.010 $175,000.00 Professional Services
– Legal)
ORDINANCE AMENDING MUNICIPAL CODE SECTION 22-606 REGARDING THE
2nd Reading RATE OF PAY FOR THE LICENSING BOARD MEMBERS
Introduced by: Angie Nelson Deuitch
Dalia Zygas
Agenda September 20, 2022
Posted September 15, 2022
Page 4
ORDINANCE ORDINANCE OR RESOLUTION FOR APPROPRIATION AND TAX
2nd Reading RATES
Introduced by: Tracie Tillman
Sean Fitzpatrick
Paul Przybylinski
Bryant Dabney
Formal Public
Hearing will be
Held September 20, 2022
Posted on
“Gateway”
ORDINANCE AN ORDINANCE SETTING SALARIES AND WAGES FOR
2nd Reading APPOINTED OFFICIALS AND EMPLOYEES OF THE CITY OF
MICHIGAN CITY, INDIANA, FOR THE CALENDAR YEAR 2023
Introduced by: Tracie Tillman
Paul Przybylinski
Bryant Dabney
Sean Fitzpatrick
Agenda September 20, 2022
Posted September 15, 2022
Page 5
ORDINANCE AN ORDINANCE SETTING THE ANNUAL SALARY FOR THE
2nd Reading MAYOR
Introduced by: Tracie Tillman
Paul Przybylinski
Bryant Dabney
Sean Fitzpatrick
ORDINANCE AN ORDINANCE SETTING THE ANNUAL SALARY FOR THE
2nd Reading CITY CLERK
Introduced by: Tracie Tillman
Paul Przybylinski
Bryant Dabney
Sean Fitzpatrick
ORDINANCE ESTABLISHING THE SALARIES FOR THE MICHIGAN CITY POLICE
2nd Reading DEPARTMENT FOR THE CALENDAR YEAR 2023
Introduced by: Tracie Tillman
Paul Przybylinski
Bryant Dabney
Sean Fitzpatrick
Agenda September 20, 2022
Posted September 15, 2022
Page 6
ORDINANCE AN ORDINANCE ESTABLISHING SALARIES FOR THE FIRE
2nd Reading DEPARTMENT OF THE CITY OF MICHIGAN CITY FOR THE
CALENDAR YEAR 2023
Introduced by: Tracie Tillman
Paul Przybylinski
Bryant Dabney
Sean Fitzpatrick
ORDINANCE AN ORDINANCE SETTING THE ANNUAL SALARIES FOR THE
2nd Reading COMMON COUNCIL MEMBERS
Introduced by: Tracie Tillman
Paul Przybylinski
Bryant Dabney
Sean Fitzpatrick
NEW BUSINESS
UNFINISHED BUSINESS NOMINATIONS: The Council has the following appointments to
the Commission of the Social Status of African American Males
(Term expires 2/15/22)
Incumbents:
Ms. Albertine Allen – Minority Health Partners of LaPorte
County (resigned)
Dr. Wendall McCollum- MCAS
Agenda September 20, 2022
Posted September 15, 2022
Page 7
COMMENTS FROM THE PUBLIC
COMMENTS FROM THE COUNCIL
ADJOURNMENT
_________________________________
Gale A. Neulieb, City Clerk
You are invited to a Zoom webinar.
When: September 20, 2022 06:30 PM Central Time (US and Canada)
Please click the link below to join the webinar:
https://us02web.zoom.us/j/86900890058?pwd=MW92Ri9KZDYzajRFR2F3VW1PNVljQT09
Passcode: 617561
Or One tap mobile :
US: +13126266799,,86900890058#,,,,*617561# or +16465588656,,86900890058#,,,,*617561#
Or Telephone:
Dial(for higher quality, dial a number based on your current location):
US: +1 312 626 6799 or +1 646 558 8656 or +1 301 715 8592 or +1 346 248 7799 or +1 669 900 9128 or
+1 253 215 8782
Webinar ID: 869 0089 0058
Passcode: 617561
International numbers available: https://us02web.zoom.us/u/kbaFyn7Iw5
Agenda September 20, 2022
Posted September 15, 2022
Page 8
Get email alerts for Michigan City
A daily email when new agendas and minutes are posted.