Rental Housing Committee
Regular MeetingMountain View, CA · February 22, 2021
Minutes
City of Mountain View
Minutes
Rental Housing Committee
Monday, February 22, 2021 7:00 PM Video Conference with No Physical Meeting Location
1. CALL TO ORDER
This meeting was called to order at 7:01 p.m.
2. ROLL CALL
Present 5- Committee Member Nicole Haines-Livesay, Committee Member Matthew
Grunewald, Committee Member Julian Pardo de Zela, Committee Member Susyn
Almond, and Chair Emily Ramos
3. MINUTES APPROVAL
MOTION: M/S - Haines-Livesay / Almond - To approve the minutes for the January 25,
2021 RHC meeting.
Yes: 6- Committee Member Haines-Livesay, Committee Member Grunewald, Committee
Member Pardo de Zela, Committee Member Almond, Chair Ramos, and -
4. CONSENT CALENDAR - None
5. ORAL COMMUNICATIONS FROM THE PUBLIC
Bee Hanson urged the RHC to consider a joint session with City Council to pass mobile home
rent control.
Alex Brown states there is no justification for not covering mobile homes with rent control and
expects action from the RHC and City Council.
6. APPEAL HEARINGS
6.1 Appeal of Decision Re: Petitions 2021002, 2021003, 2021005, 2021006,
2021008 and 2021009
City of Mountain View Page 1
Rental Housing Committee Minutes February 22, 2021
Karen Tiedemann, Special Counsel, Goldfarb and Lipman, presented an oral report and
responded to questions.
SPEAKING FROM THE FLOOR WITH COMMENTS:
No public comments received.
PRESENTATION AND ARGUMENTS BY APPELLANT-LANDLORD - Servando Sandoval
PRESENTATION AND ARGUMENTS BY RESPONDENT-TENANTS - Brian Walkker
PRESENTATION AND ARGUMENTS BY APPELLANT-LANDLORD - Servando Sandoval
PRESENTATION AND ARGUMENTS BY RESPONDENT-TENANTS -Brian Walker
MOTION: M/S - Almond/ Ramos - To adopt the Tentative Appeal Decision to affirm the
Hearing Officers decision on appeal elements B.3 - B.6:
B.1 - Denying the appeal request and affirming Decision granting a rent reduction to all
petitioners for the loss of pool access and remand the decision with direction to clarify
the determination on the dollar amount of the rent reduction for pool access between June
4, 2020 and September 30, 2020.
B.2 - Granting the appeal request and remanding the issue to the Hearing Officer to
determine whether the Appellant-Landlord could have reopened the fitness center and if
so to determine the value of the rent reduction based solely on the loss of the fitness
center with specific attention paid to the square footage of the fitness center.
B.3 - Denying appeal request and affirming the Decision granting a rent reduction to all
petitioners for the loss of access to the lawn and surrounding areas of $60 to $75 per
month between June 4, 2020 and September 30, 2020.
B.4 -Granting the appeal request in part and remanding the Decision to the Hearing
Officer solely to establish the appropriate measurement for determining when the housing
service has been restored or the fee eliminated.
B.5 - Granting the appeal request and reversing the Decision with respect to the rent
reduction awarded for lack of management response to maintenance issues.
B.6 - Granting the appeal request and reversing the Decision with respect to the rent
reduction awarded for loss of use of the grassy recreation area.
The Motion was amended by a friendly amendment by Committee Member
Haines-Livesay that the Hearing Officer should consider the square footage of the fitness
center and the square footage limitations in the Health Orders upon consideration of the
issues on B-2 on remand. The Motion was further amended by a friendly amendment by
Committee Member Grunwald that appeal element B-1 be affirmed but remanded to the
hearing officer for further clarification on the determination on the dollar amount of the rent
reduction.
The RHC recessed at 8:57 p.m. and reconvened at 9:05 p.m.
7. PUBLIC HEARINGS - None
8. NEW BUSINESS
City of Mountain View Page 2
Rental Housing Committee Minutes February 22, 2021
8.1 Capital Improvement Petition Process Study Session
Analyst Black presented a report and responded to questions.
SPEAKING FROM THE FLOOR WITH COMMENTS:
Edie Keating
Alex Brown
The RHC receive background information and consider potential policy options related to
a Capital Improvement Petition Process for Temporary Upward Adjustment of Rent and
provided feedback.
MOTION: M/S - Grunewald/ Pardo de Zela - To move agenda item 8.2, Bi-Annual Review of
Consumer Price Indices for Fair Return Calculations of Petitions for Upward Adjustment, and
agenda item 8.3, Quarterly Financial Expenditures FY 2020-21 through December 31, 2020, to
the next RHC meeting on March 22, 2021.
8.2 Bi-Annual Review of Consumer Price Indices for Fair Return Calculations
of Petitions for Upward Adjustment
This agenda item has moved to the March 22, 2021 RHC meeting.
8.3 Quarterly Financial Expenditures FY 2020-21 through December 31, 2020
This agenda item has moved to the March 22, 2021 RHC meeting.
9. COMMITTEE/STAFF ANNOUNCEMENTS, UPDATES, REQUESTS, AND COMMITTEE
9.1 Monthly Status Report January 2021
Analyst Black presented the monthly status reports for January 2021.
9.2 Update on City’s COVID-19 Landlord/Tenant Programs
Analyst Kennedy presented an update on the City's landlord and tenant COVID19 programs.
9.3 Upcoming Monthly Workshops and Office Hours
Analyst Black presented the upcoming workshop, clinic and office hours.
10. ADJOURNMENT - At 10:30 p.m., Chair Ramos adjourned the meeting to the next
RHC meeting to be held on Monday March 22, 2021 at 7:00 p.m. via video conference.
City of Mountain View Page 3
Agenda
City of Mountain View
Agenda
Rental Housing Committee
Monday, February 22, 2021 7:00 PM Video Conference with No Physical Meeting
Location
This meeting will be conducted in accordance with State of California Executive Order N-29-20,
dated March 17, 2020. All members of the Rental Housing Committee will participate in the
meeting by video conference, with no physical meeting location.
Members of the public wishing to observe the meeting may do so at
https://mountainview.legistar.com, on YouTube at www.MountainView.gov/YouTube and on
Comcast Channel 26.
Members of the public wishing to comment on an item on the agenda may do so in the following
ways:
1. Email comments to RHC@mountainview.gov by 5:00 p.m. on the meeting date. Emails will be
forwarded to the RHC. Please identify the Agenda Item number in the subject line of your email.
All emails received will be entered into the record for the meeting.
2. Provide oral public comments during the meeting: Online - Register in advance to access the
meeting via Zoom Webinar: https://mountainview.gov/RHC_speakers
You will be asked to enter an email address and a name. Your email address will not be
disclosed to the public. After registering, you will receive an email with instructions on how to
connect to the meeting.
When the Chair announces the item on which you wish to speak, click the “raise hand” feature in
Zoom. Speakers will be notified of their turn shortly before they are called on to speak.
1. CALL TO ORDER
2. ROLL CALL
Chair Emily Ramos, Vice-Chair Susyn Almond, Committee Members Matthew
Grunewald, Nicole Haines-Livesay, and Julian Pardo de Zela
City of Mountain View Page 1 Printed on 2/24/2022
Rental Housing Committee Agenda February 22, 2021
3. MINUTES APPROVAL
3.1 Approve the minutes for January 25, 2021 RHC Meeting
Recommendation: Copies of the minutes for the above noted meetings have been
delivered to Committee Members and copies are available online or by
request. If there are no corrections or additions, a motion is in order to
approve these minutes.
Attachments: Minutes RHC Meeting for January 25, 2021
4. CONSENT CALENDAR - None
5. ORAL COMMUNICATIONS FROM THE PUBLIC
This portion of the meeting is reserved for persons wishing to address the Committee on
any matter not on the agenda. Speakers are allowed to speak on any topic for one
three-minute period during this section. State law prohibits the Committee from acting on
non-agenda items.
6. APPEAL HEARINGS
6.1 Appeal of Decision Re: Petitions 2021002, 2021003, 2021005, 2021006,
2021008 and 2021009
Recommendation: Consider the Tentative Appeal Decision and either accept the Tentative
Appeal Decision or modify the Tentative Appeal Decision with
instructions to staff citing appropriate evidence in the record.
Attachments: Staff Report
ATT 1 - Tentative Appeal Decision
ATT 2 - Decision of Hearing Officer, as amended
ATT 3 - Appellant-Landlord Appeal of Decision
ATT 4 - Appellant-Landlord Response to the Tentative Appeal Decision
ATT 5 - Tenant Response to the Tentative Appeal Decision
7. PUBLIC HEARINGS - None
8. NEW BUSINESS
City of Mountain View Page 2 Printed on 2/24/2022
Rental Housing Committee Agenda February 22, 2021
8.1 Capital Improvement Petition Process Study Session
Recommendation: Receive background information and consider potential policy options
related to a Capital Improvement Petition Process for Temporary
Upward Adjustment of Rent.
Attachments: Staff Report
ATT 1 - Policies Options for Capital Improvement Petition Process
ATT 2 - Draft Authorized Expenses and Amortization Schedules
ATT 3 - Cost-Recovery Mechanisms in Rent Stabilized Jurisdictions
ATT 4 - January 25, 2021 RHC Memo
ATT 5 - August 24, 2020 RHC Memo
ATT 6 - CSFRA Regulations: Chapter 6
ATT 7 - CSFRA Regulations: Chapter 9
8.2 Bi-Annual Review of Consumer Price Indices for Fair Return Calculations of
Petitions for Upward Adjustment
Recommendation: To receive an informational review of the Consumer Price Indices for
Fair Return Calculations of Petitions for Upward Adjustment of Rent.
Attachments: Staff Report
ATT 1 - CPI Indicies
ATT 2 - CPI Percentage Instruction Sheet
ATT 3 - July 10, 2017 RHC Memo
8.3 Quarterly Financial Expenditures FY 2020-21 through December 31, 2020
Recommendation: Review the attached Quarterly Financial Expenditures for Fiscal Year
2020-21 through December 31, 2020.
Attachments: Staff Report
ATT 1 - Quarterly Financial Report FY 2020-21 through December 31, 2020
9. COMMITTEE/STAFF ANNOUNCEMENTS, UPDATES, REQUESTS, AND COMMITTEE
No action will be taken on any questions raised by the Committee at this time.
9.1 Monthly Status Report January 2021
Attachments: Monthly Status Report January 2021
9.2 Update on City’s COVID-19 Landlord/Tenant Programs
9.3 Upcoming Monthly Workshops and Office Hours
City of Mountain View Page 3 Printed on 2/24/2022
Rental Housing Committee Agenda February 22, 2021
10. ADJOURNMENT - At 10:30 p.m., Chair Ramos adjourned the meeting to the next
RHC meeting to be held on Monday March 22, 2021 at 7:00 p.m. via video conference.
NOTICE TO THE PUBLIC
The agenda and staff reports are available online at https://mountainview.legistar.com.
Questions and comments regarding the agenda may be directed to the Rental Housing Committee at (650) 903-6125 or
RHC@mountainview.gov.
The Committee may consider and act on items listed on the agenda in any order. Consideration of the matters noticed
herein is not limited by the recommendations indicated herein.
Pursuant to the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), if you need special assistance in this meeting, please contact the
Community Services Department at (650) 903-6400. Notification of 48 hours prior to the meeting will enable the City to
make reasonable arrangements to ensure accessibility to this meeting. (28 CFR 35.160 (b) (1))
City of Mountain View Page 4 Printed on 2/24/2022
Get email alerts for Mountain View
A daily email when new agendas and minutes are posted.