Central Oklahoma Master Conservancy District Meeting
Regular MeetingNorman, OK · November 7, 2024
Minutes
MINUTES OF THE REGULAR BOARD MEETING
CENTRAL OKLAHOMA MASTER CONSERVANCY DISTRICT
Thursday, November 7, 2024
6:30 P.M.
Location: 12500 Alameda Dr. Norman, OK 73026
A. Call to Order
President Amanda Nairn called the meeting to Order at 6:30 pm.
Roll Call
Board Members Present:
Amanda Nairn
Michael Dean
Dave Ballew
Espaniola Bowen
Edgar O’Rear
Steve Carano
Bryan Hapke
Board Members Absent:
Staff Present:
Kyle Arthur, General Manager
Kelley Metcalf, Office Manager
Tim Carr, Operations & Maintenance Supervisor
Others Present:
Dean Couch
Mark Roberts, Midwest City
Rachel Croft, Norman
Carrie Evenson, Midwest City
Virtual
None
B. Statement of Compliance with Open Meeting Act
Kelley Metcalf, Office Manager, stated the notice of the monthly board meeting had been posted in
compliance with the Open Meeting Act.
Page 1 of 7
C. Administrative
1. Public Comment
None
2. Report- September 2024 financials
Mr. Ballew stated he compared the September Balance Sheet with the August Balance Sheet and found
no significant changes.
Mr. Ballew is reconsidering the decision to only provide the Board with quarterly LPL Financial
statements due to the Fed’s announcement of another ½ a point. Mr. Ballew recommended including the
latest LPL Statement at the next board meeting and having a more detailed discussion about our
investment portfolio at the next meeting.
Mr. Arthur communicated that a Treasury Bill (T-Bill), in the amount of $500,000 matured, but due to the
agenda items that are forthcoming, those monies were not reinvested and are currently in the BancFirst
0014 account (Sweep acct).
Mr. Ballew then moved to the Profit and Loss statement. He asked Mr. Arthur regarding the $7,000
increase in employees’ wages. Mr. Arthur said it was due to his bonus and salary increase retroactive to
July 1, 2024.
Mr. Ballew asked Mr. Arthur to clarify the Non-Budgeted Expense, 5834-ARPA Project, in the amount
of $153,669.52. Mr. Arthur said the expense was related to the construction costs of the new equipment
building. Ms. Nairn shared that the associated labor costs, that were previously thought to not be
reimbursable, are reimbursable, thanks to Mr. Arthur’s determination.
Mr. Ballew asked if there were any questions on the Budget vs Actuals, and hearing none, Ms. Nairn
moved to the action portion of the meeting.
D. Action: Pursuant to 82 OKLA. STATUTES, SECTION 541 (D) (10), the Board of Directors
shall perform official actions by resolution and all official actions including final passage and
enactment of all resolutions must be approved by a majority of the Board of Directors, a quorum
being present, at a regular or special meeting. The following items may be discussed, considered,
and approved, disapproved, amended, tabled or other action taken:
3. Minutes of the regular board meeting held on Thursday, October 3, 2024, and corresponding
Resolution
Ms. Nairn asked if there were any questions, comments, or edits, hearing none she entertained a motion.
Bryan Hapke made a motion seconded by Michael Dean to approve the minutes and corresponding
Resolution.
Roll call vote:
Page 2 of 7
Amanda Nairn Yes
Michael Dean Yes
Dave Ballew Yes
Edgar O’Rear Yes
Espaniola Bowen Yes
Steve Carano Yes
Bryan Hapke Yes
Motion Passed
4. Creation of a dedicated Large Equipment Asset Fund, and corresponding Resolution
Ms. Nairn reminded the Board that this subject was discussed in detail at the last meeting. She also stated
Mr. Ballew has been subsequently informed since he was not present at the last Board meeting.
Mr. Arthur stated the Resolution is intended to capture three actions: (1) consideration of the creation of
the fund, (2) an initial deposit of $325,000, and (3) the mechanisms by which the fund may be financed.
Mr. Arthur proposed on the anniversary of the creation of the fund, monies needed for that year’s
purchases could be withdrawn. Mr. Arthur stated budget planning would begin in February or March, and
funding preference could be determined by the Board at that time.
Ms. Nairn asked Mr. Arthur the gains on the equity mutual funds, so far, this fiscal year. Mr. Arthur
stated at the end of October 2024, slightly under $30,000.00.
Opinions were exchanged for adding the Large Equipment Asset Fund to the existing financials. Mr.
Dean recommended not creating a separate account for this fund, but rather managing it within the
District’s existing portfolio. Additionally, he suggested creating a subaccount or other notation on the
financial statements, as appropriate, to show the existence of the earmarked funds.
Dave Ballew made a motion seconded by Steve Carano to approve the creation of a dedicated Large
Equipment Asset Fund and corresponding Resolution.
Roll call vote:
Amanda Nairn Yes
Michael Dean Yes
Dave Ballew Yes
Edgar O’Rear Yes
Espaniola Bowen Yes
Steve Carano Yes
Bryan Hapke Yes
Motion Passed
5. Authorization for General Manager to utilize surplus funds for purchase of certain equipment, and
corresponding Resolution
Mr. Arthur stated during the last meeting while discussing the Large Capital Equipment replacement
schedule, two pieces of equipment were identified as needing to be replaced within the next two years: (1)
Page 3 of 7
a 25-year-old backhoe, and (2) a 2012 skid steer track loader. The general opinion of the Board at that
meeting was to consider moving forward with replacing them now. Therefore this action item is to
authorize the General Manager to proceed with the purchase of this equipment from surplus funds.
Mr. Arthur stated that the present need for these pieces of equipment to be replaced is because the
backhoe is 25 years old and has significant wear and tear, and the skid steer is underpowered to be able to
perform needed mulching and tree clearing in the District’s easements and the property fire breaks. The
latter is something that needs to commence once again as some areas are in need of clearing due to the
encroachment of trees over the last several years. Mr. Arthur noted this amount also includes the purchase
of several needed implements, including the mulcher.
Mr. Arthur pointed out that 2028 would be the next time scheduled for any replacement beyond these two
pieces of equipment.
Mr. Arthur has received some quotes on state contracts for the two pieces of equipment and associated
attachments. The amount requested ($300,000) will cover any quoted cost combination.
Steve Carano made a motion seconded by Bryan Hapke to approve the authorization for General Manager
to utilize surplus funds for purchase of certain equipment, and corresponding Resolution.
Roll call vote:
Amanda Nairn Yes
Michael Dean Yes
Dave Ballew Yes
Edgar O’Rear Yes
Espaniola Bowen Yes
Steve Carano Yes
Bryan Hapke Yes
Motion Passed
6. Declaration of certain property as surplus, and corresponding Resolution
Ms. Nairn said this Resolution is to surplus (1) Backhoe and (2) Track Loader. Ms. Nairn asked Mr.
Arthur if he would place the items in the auction before receiving the new equipment, he said no.
Ms. Nairn asked if the proceeds from the auction would be put into the new Large Equipment Asset Fund
and he said yes, it would be his intent and recommendation to do so.
Michael Dean made a motion and Edgar O’Rear seconded the motion to approve the Declaration of
certain property as surplus and corresponding Resolution.
Roll call vote:
Amanda Nairn Yes
Michael Dean Yes
Dave Ballew Yes
Edgar O’Rear Yes
Espaniola Bowen Yes
Page 4 of 7
Steve Carano Yes
Bryan Hapke Yes
Motion Passed
7. New Executive Session Minutes Policy, and corresponding Resolution
Ms. Nairn expressed that after the last Executive Session, the existing Executive Session Policy (Board
approved Dec. 2018), was found to be clunky and non-functional.
Mr. Arthur consulted with Mr. Couch to write the proposed New Executive Session Minutes Policy.
Mr. Couch stated that minutes are required to be taken in an Executive Session. He further stated that the
President of the Board, shall designate the person to take the minutes that summarize the Executive
Session proceeding. Mr. Dean wanted to know if Ms. Metcalf was allowed to take the minutes. Mr.
Couch stated that it must be a member of the Board and, furthermore, allowing anyone else could pose a
problem with attorney client privilege within the Executive Session.
Ms. Nairn requested, for future Executive Sessions, that a copy of the New Executive Session Policy be
provided.
Hearing no other questions, Ms. Nairn entertained a motion.
Steve Carano made a motion and Espaniola Bowen seconded the motion to approve the New Executive
Session Minutes Policy and corresponding Resolution.
Roll call vote:
Amanda Nairn Yes
Michael Dean Yes
Dave Ballew Yes
Edgar O’Rear Yes
Espaniola Bowen Yes
Steve Carano Yes
Bryan Hapke Yes
Motion Passed
8. Amending an Employee Retirement System, Defined Benefit Plan and Joinder Agreement and
corresponding Resolution
Mr. Arthur explained this is a standard periodic matter that comes before the Board and any other Board
that participates in the Oklahoma Municipal Retirement Fund (OkMRF). The District’s primary
retirement plan is a Defined Benefit Plan administrated by OkMRF.
Mr. Arthur stated every 6 years the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) requires all members to formally
adopt this new plan language. The effective date for the new agreement is January 1, 2025. The
Resolution is provided by OkMRF. Mr. Arthur said the Plan is available for anyone interested.
Page 5 of 7
Mr. O’Rear asked a question about the Joinder Agreement. On the rule of 80 it states at age 65 with
completion of five (5) years of service you can retire, however the vesting schedule is 7 years. Mr. Arthur
confirmed that it was one of the newly added changes and that it is his understanding that in such a case,
the vesting age is lowered to five years.
Mr. O’Rear asked for clarification on the Resolution, on page 2 that the “This Board of Directors”
referenced there was not the Central Oklahoma Master Conservancy District board of directors, but the
OkMRF Board of Directors. Mr. O’Rear found the wording ambiguous since the document is signed by a
representative of COMCD and “This” would seem to be a self-referral. It was confirmed that it is the
OkMRF Board of Directors.
Michael Dean made a motion seconded by Bryan Hapke to approve the Amending Employee Retirement
System, Defined Benefit Plan and Joinder Agreement and corresponding Resolution.
Roll call vote:
Amanda Nairn Yes
Michael Dean Yes
Dave Ballew Yes
Edgar O’Rear Yes
Espaniola Bowen Yes
Steve Carano Yes
Bryan Hapke Yes
Motion Passed
E. Discussion
9. Legal Counsel’s Report
October 2 communication with Kyle Arthur about CEC consultant and procurement requirements
October 3 provide Legal Counsel report to Kelley Metcalf and attend monthly Board meeting
October 3 follow up communication to Oklahoma Water Resources Board staff about provisional
temporary permit for City of Norman
October 7 attorney Certifications for Worth Hydrochem contract and communication to Kyle Arthur
about procurement of engineering consultant services
October 8 conference call to Sara Gibson about consultant services for CEC Phase 2 with quote
under bid requirements
October 9 file Annual Report of activities with Cleveland County District Court
October 23 communication with Jacob Batchelor about CEC Phase 2 consultant work
October 29 draft policy on executive session minutes to replace previous policy about notes taken
During executive session
October 29 review and provide revisions to draft resolution on establishing large equipment fund and
authorizing use of surplus funds to acquire two pieces of equipment and disposal of
surplus equipment
October 30 communication to Jacob Batchelor about CEC Phase 2 consultant work
Page 6 of 7
Mr. Couch said he was happy to answer any questions.
Hearing no further questions, Ms. Nairn proceeded to the General Manager’s Report.
10. General Manager’s Report
Please see document titled “Manager’s Report” in the packet.
Mr. Arthur stated he would be happy to answer any questions.
11. President’s Report
Ms. Nairn stated, Ms. Metcalf, shared the annual audit, by Finley & Cook, began the week of the fish fry.
Ms. Nairn informed the board that on Tuesday (Oct. 5th) Mr. Arthur participated in a meeting, with the
Bureau of Reclamation (BOR), to discuss firm yield, paleo hydrology, and drought responses thresholds.
The finished report is expected to be complete by the beginning of 2025. Ms. Nairn would like to have a
subcommittee assigned to this subject matter. Mr. Hapke, Mr. O’Rear and Mr. Dean have stated that they
want to serve on the sub-committee.
Ms. Nairn stated Mr. Ballew mentioned interest in developing an Emergency Response Plan (ERP). Mr.
Arthur would like to have a sub-committee to assist with this task. Ms. Nairn encouraged the board to
think about who may want to volunteer. Ms. Nairn stated she would prefer a representative from each
city. Mr. Arthur was encouraged to reach out to the other Conservancy District’s to inquire if they have a
plan in place. Mr. Arthur contacted BOR to say that the District is working on this plan.
Mr. Carr stated the Bureau of Reclamation has an Emergency Action Plan (EAP) in place that the District
must follow, but the plan is heavily weighted for dam breach, or security breach. Mr. Carr invited anyone
who wishes to review the plan to do so, however, the plan is not allowed to be copied or distributed in any
form. Mr. Carr also shared entities that are relied upon, in the EAP, participate in the tabletop exercises
and practices. Ms. Nairn said that reviewing the EAP would be beneficial.
Ms. Nairn mentioned that the ERP will be revisited at a future meeting.
12. New business (any matter not known prior to the meeting, and which could not have been reasonably
foreseen prior to the posting of the agenda)
None
F. Adjourn
There being no further business, President Nairn adjourned the meeting at 8:23 P.M.
Page 7 of 7
Agenda
CENTRAL OKLAHOMA MASTER
CONSERVANCY DISTRICT
AGENDA FOR REGULAR MEETING
Thursday, November 7, 2024
6:30 P.M.
Kyle Arthur, General Manager
12500 Alameda Dr
Norman, OK 73026
To accommodate the public, including presenters of agenda items, who wish to participate but not to attend
the meeting in person, videoconference and teleconference capability is being made available, but
videoconference and teleconference connections and quality of connections are outside the control of the
District and cannot be assured. Although this accommodation is provided, members of the public including
presenters are welcome to attend the meeting in‐person.
Microsoft Teams meeting information:
Join on your computer, mobile app, or room device
Meeting ID: 288 328 510 43
Passcode: 2dQvcD
Dial in by phone 1‐312‐763‐9891
Phone conference ID: 483 058 692#
Board meeting packet can be found on website: https://comcd.net. This agenda was posted in the notice
enclosure outside the COMCD office gate at 10:00 AM on Friday, November 1, 2024.
A. Call to order and roll call
B. Statement of compliance with Open Meeting Act
C. Administrative
1. Public comment
This is an opportunity for the public to address the COMCD board. Due to Open Meeting Act regulations,
board members are not able to participate in discussion during this comment period. Comments will be
accepted from those persons attending in‐person and through the virtual meeting option. You are required to
sign up in advance of the meeting in order to be eligible to make comment. You may sign‐up by calling the
COMCD office at 405‐329‐5228 during regular business hours (8:00 AM – 4:30 PM) or by contacting the office
via email at admin@comcd.net. Public comment sign‐up will end at 12:00 PM (noon) CDT on Thursday,
November 7, 2024. Any request received after that will not be eligible. When signing up, you must provide
your name, city of residence and topic about which you wish to speak. Each commenter will be limited to
three minutes and the entire comment period will not exceed one hour. Eligible commenters will be called to
address the board in the order in which their request was received. Given the one‐hour time limit, not all
commenters are guaranteed the opportunity to speak. Written comments will also be accepted and kept as a
matter of record for the meeting. If all commenters have addressed the board prior to the one‐hour time limit,
the public comment agenda item will be closed, and the balance of the time yielded back to the remainder of
the agenda. The President reserves discretion during the meeting to make an adjustment to the public
comment schedule.
2. Treasurer Report‐September 2024 financials
D. Action
Pursuant to 82 Okla. Statutes, Section 541 (D) (10), the Board of Directors shall perform official actions by
Resolution and all official actions including final passage and enactment of all Resolutions must be present at a
regular or special meeting. The following items may be discussed, considered, and approved, disapproved,
amended, tabled or other action taken:
3. Minutes of the regular board meeting held on Thursday, October 3, 2024, and corresponding Resolution
4. Creation of a dedicated Large Equipment Asset Fund, and corresponding Resolution
5. Authorization for General Manager to utilize surplus funds for purchase of certain equipment, and
corresponding Resolution
6. Declaration of certain property as surplus, and corresponding Resolution
7. New Executive Session Minutes Policy, and corresponding Resolution
8. Amending an Employee Retirement System, Defined Benefit Plan and Joinder Agreement and
corresponding Resolution
E. Discussion
9. Legal Counsel’s Report
10. General Manager’s Report
11. President’s Report
12. New business (any matter not known prior to the meeting, and which could not have been reasonably
foreseen prior to the posting of the Agenda)
F. Adjourn
Get email alerts for Norman
A daily email when new agendas and minutes are posted.