CT Municipal Electric Energy Cooperative CMEEC
Regular MeetingNorwich, CT · November 17, 2022
Minutes
SUBJECT TO BOARD APPROVAL
MINUTES OF THE
JOINT ANNUAL AND REGULAR MEETING OF THE
BOARDS OF DIRECTORS OF
CONNECTICUT MUNICIPAL ELECTRIC ENERGY COOPERATIVE
AND
CONNECTICUT TRANSMISSION MUNICIPAL ELECTRIC ENERGY COOPERATIVE
November 17, 2022
The Joint Annual and Regular Meeting of the Boards of Directors of Connecticut Municipal
Electric Energy Cooperative (“CMEEC”) and Connecticut Transmission Municipal Electric
Energy Cooperative (“CTMEEC” dba Transco) was held on Thursday, November 17, 2022, in
person at The Madison Beach Hotel, 94 West Wharf Road, Madison, CT and via Zoom at 10:00
a.m.
The meeting was legally noticed in compliance with Connecticut General Statutes and all
proceedings and actions thereafter recorded occurred during the publicly open portions of the
meeting.
The following Member Representatives / Alternate Member Representatives / Municipal
Representatives participated in person or via Zoom:
Groton Utilities: Ronald Gaudet, Jeffrey Godley
Groton Municipal Representative: Mark Oefinger
Norwich Public Utilities: Christopher LaRose, Stewart Peil, Robert Staley
Norwich Municipal Representative: David Eggleston
Bozrah Light & Power: Seymour Adelman, William Ballinger, Scott Barber
Bozrah Municipal Representative: Joseph Cirrito
South Norwalk Electric & Water: Alan Huth, David Westmoreland
South Norwalk Municipal Representative: Dawn DelGreco
Third Taxing District, East Norwalk: Kevin Barber, Michele Sweeney
East Norwalk Municipal Representative: Pete Johnson
Jewett City Department of Public Utilities: Louis Demicco, Richard Throwe
Jewett City Municipal Representative: George Kennedy
The following CMEEC Staff participated in person or via Zoom:
Dave Meisinger, CMEEC CEO
Robin Kipnis, Esquire, CMEEC General Counsel
Bella Chernovitsky, CMEEC Director of Business Intelligence
Michael Cyr, CMEEC Director of Portfolio Management
Patricia Meek, CMEEC Director of Finance & Accounting
Joanne Menard, CMEEC Controller
Michael Rall, CMEEC Director of Asset Management
Gabriel Stern, CMEEC Director of Technical Services
Candice DiVita, CMEEC Financial Analyst
Margaret Job, CMEEC Paralegal and Compliance Specialist
Heidi Winnick, CMEEC Financial and Treasury Analyst
Ellen Kachmar, CMEEC Office and Facilities Manager
Others participating in person:
David Silverstone, Esquire, Municipal Electric Consumer Advocate
Guest Speakers:
Brian Forshaw, Energy Market Advisors
Mike Hyland, Executive Director, NEPPA
Ms. Job recorded.
Chair Kevin Barber called the meeting to order at 10:04 a.m. He stated today’s meeting is being
held in person at the Madison Beach Hotel in Madison, Connecticut as well as via Zoom. He
thanked everyone for participating in the first in-person Board meeting in almost 2.5 years. He
explained that there are three meetings to be conducted today. He added that we have two guest
speakers presenting with the agenda allowing for questions.
Chair Barber noted that there is a Board member present that has not yet been introduced to the
members of the Board and asked Member Representative Scott Barber to do so. Member
Representative Scott Barber introduced Alternate Member Representative Bill Ballinger stating
that Mr. Ballinger is a former first selectman of Bozrah and is a member of the Bozrah Utility
Commission.
Specific Agenda Items
A Public Comment Period
No public comment was made.
B Conduct Voting Roster / Roll Call
Ms. Job conducted roll call identifying the voting persons at today’s meeting. Chair
Barber confirmed a quorum was present.
C Approve Minutes of the Regular October 27, 2022 Joint CMEEC and CTMEEC
Boards of Directors’ Meeting
A motion was made by Municipal Representative Mark Oefinger, seconded by
Member Representative Scott Barber to Approve the Minutes of the Regular
October 27, 2022 Joint CMEEC and CTMEEC Boards of Directors’ Meeting.
Motion passed unanimously. 22-11-01
D Possible Executive Session Pursuant to C.G.S. § 1-200(6)(B) and § 1-210(b)(4) to
Discuss Subase Fuel Cell Project
A motion was made by Member Representative Louis Demicco, seconded by
Member Representative Scott Barber to enter Executive Session.
Motion passed unanimously. 22-11-02
The basis for entering Executive Session is as identified above.
Mr. Silverstone agreed that he is exercising his right under his Non-Disclosure
Agreement dated May 24, 2021 to remain in Executive Session.
Members of the Board, CMEEC Staff in attendance as well as Mr. Silverstone
remained. Messrs. Forshaw and Hyland were excused until invited back at the
conclusion of Executive Session.
The Board entered Executive Session at 10:10 a.m. with instructions to return to
Public Session upon completion of discussion in Executive Session.
The Board re-entered Public Session at 10:32 a.m. Messrs. Forshaw and Hyland
were invited back to Public Session.
Chair Baber entertained a motion to Authorize the CEO to enter into the following:
(i) Amended & Restated PPA with Fuel Cell Energy, Inc.;
(ii) EUL Modification #18 with the Navy; and
(iii) Amendment to Sublease, if needed.
With the necessary conforming changes, if any, on substantially the same terms and
conditions as discussed in Executive Session, with such minor changes and modifications
as the CEO, with the advice of legal counsel, deems reasonable and appropriate.
A motion was made by Municipal Representative Pete Johnson, seconded by
Member Representative Stewart Peil to Authorize the CEO to enter into the
aforementioned items in accordance with the accompanying directives as noted
above.
Motion passed unanimously. 22-11-03
E October 2022 Objective Summary
Mr. Meisinger explained that for the month of October, Regional Competitiveness TMR
View came in at 43% versus the target of 30% and projected year-end moved up to 34%
versus the target of 30%. He stated that the primary drivers were the higher and volatile
forward energy, spot energy and gas prices; however, he noted that these were somewhat
mitigated by solid hedging practices and lower than expected LMPs during the month.
Mr. Meisinger added that Customer Fulfillment “All-In” Cost TMR View came in
$4/MWH higher than the target for the month, and that the projected year-end came in
$104/MWh versus the target of $90/MWh. He explained that these results were driven by
the same factors along with solid project performance.
F October 2022 Project Portfolio Summary
Mr. Rall stated that the project portfolio came in below budget with the biggest driver
being MicroGen. He explained that MicroGen came in below budget for the month due to
mild weather in October causing more run time than budgeted to capture the peak. He
added that actual fuel costs were double the budgeted amount and additional interest and
debt service coverage for the 2022 bonds were also contributing factors to MicroGen
performance in October. Mr. Rall added that Transmission Project #1 came in lower than
budget due to lower than budgeted pool network peak load in September. Community
Solar Garden also came in lower than budgeted due to higher than budgeted PPA and
REC expenses.
Mr. Rall further explained that year-to-date performance of the project portfolio,
excluding Subase Fuel Cell, is 14% lower than budget due to transmission true up earlier
in the year. He added that projected year end, excluding Subase Fuel Cell, the portfolio
came in at 14% lower than budget due to the transmission true-up and MicroGen
performance in October.
G October 2022 Energy Market Update
Mr. Cyr provided a high-level overview of the Energy Market Analysis for October,
highlighting the results of the previous month and how they were impacted by Load,
Energy Costs, Natural Gas costs, and Oil costs.
Mr. Cyr then explained hedging practices enlisted by the Portfolio Management
Department. He highlighted the volatility of the gas market prices as driving factors in
costs of energy going into the winter months.
H Budget & Finance Committee Report
Possible Vote to Approve 2023 CMEEC Operating and Capital Budgets
Member Representative Christopher LaRose, Budget & Finance Committee Chair,
explained that the Committee held its last budget review meeting on November 4, 2022.
He thanked CMEEC staff for their thorough and transparent preparation of the budget
and review materials and acknowledged the Board for their participation at each of the
budget review meetings.
Ms. Meek thanked the Committee and the Board for their attentive participation to the
budget review process. She then walked the Board through the slide deck highlighting
the Proposed 2023 CMEEC Budget provided to the Board in advance of today’s meeting.
She explained that the slide deck before the Board today is the same as was presented at
the Budget & Finance Committee meeting held on November 4, 2022.
Discussion ensued regarding the impact to the budget if the matters voted on at today’s
meeting are finalized. Ms. Meek stated that she would present the impact of those
changes to the Budget & Finance Committee at its January meeting for consideration and
would revise the budget if the Committee deemed it necessary.
Chair Barber entertained a motion to approve the 2023 CMEEC Operating and Capital
Budgets.
A motion was made by Member Representative LaRose, seconded by Municipal
Representative Johnson to Approve the 2023 CMEEC Operating and Capital
Budgets.
Motion passed unanimously. 22-11-04
Chair Barber also thanked CMEEC staff and the Committee stating that they conducted a
thorough review of the budget that encouraged hearty discussion.
I Governance Committee Report
Possible Vote to Approve:
• 2023 Joint CMEEC and CTMEEC Officers
• 2023 Joint CMEEC and CTMEEC Committee Members
• 2023 Joint CMEEC and CTMEEC Boards of Directors’ Meeting Dates
• 2023 Joint CMEEC and CTMEEC Committee Meeting Dates
Member Representative Ronald Gaudet, Governance Committee Chair, explained the
Committee met on November 3, 2022. He stated that each year, the Committee develops
Committee and Officer slates based on the Board Interest survey. The Committee
ensures each Board Committee has representation from each of the Member utilities. He
stated that the Committee also develops the meeting schedules for both the Board and the
Committees. Member Representative Gaudet noted that the Committee also heard an
update of the Strategic Plan, which Mr. Meisinger will present at the December 15, 2022
Joint meeting of the Boards.
Chair Barber entertained motions to Approve each of the four bulleted items included in
this Agenda Item as follows:
A motion was made by Municipal Representative George Kennedy, seconded by
Member Representative David Eggleston to Approve the 2023 Joint CMEEC and
CTMEEC Slate of Officers.
Motion passed unanimously. 22-11-05
A motion was made by Member Representative Demicco, seconded by Member
Representative Scott Barber to Approve the 2023 Joint CMEEC and CTMEEC
Committee Members.
Motion passed unanimously. 22-11-06
A motion was made by Member Representative Scott Barber, seconded by Member
Representative Demicco to Approve the 2023 Joint CMEEC and CTMEEC Board
of Directors’ Meeting Dates.
Motion passed unanimously. 22-11-07
A motion was made by Municipal Representative Oefinger, seconded by Municipal
Representative Johnson to Approve the 2023 Joint CMEEC and CTMEEC
Committee Meeting Dates.
Motion passed unanimously. 22-11-08
J MEU Roundtable
No updates were made.
K New Business
There was no new business
L Guest Speaker: Brian Forshaw, Energy Market Advisors
2022 ISO Markets Update
Mr. Forshaw walked the Board through a Status Report on ISO-NE Markets, which slide
deck was provided to the Board in advance of today’s meeting. Mr. Forshaw provided a
brief review of the role of ISO-NE. He also provided high-level reviews of the winter
energy security concerns and market challenges due to decarbonization goals. Mr.
Forshaw also provided updates on the Capacity Markets and Operating Reserves Market.
The presentation was well received by all those in attendance who were provided
opportunities to ask questions.
M Guest Speaker: Mike Hyland, NEPPA Executive Director
An Energized Forecast: Charting your Utility’s EV Future
Mr. Hyland introduced himself providing a brief history of how he became Executive
Director of NEPPA as well as the history of NEPPA’s formation and current
organization. He proceeded to walk the Board through the slide deck provided in advance
of today’s meeting which highlighted his prior work on Electric Vehicles at a Maryland
electric cooperative. He then walked the Board through slides addressing the current
status of EVs and EV charging infrastructure in both Maryland and Connecticut. He
provided national (US) EV outlook and provided lessons learned surrounding
installation/maintenance; rates/peak-use vs. off-peak use; and customer usage.
The presentation was well received by all in attendance who were provided opportunities
to ask questions.
N Adjourn
A motion was made by Member Representative Demicco, seconded by Member
Representative Scott Barber to adjourn.
Motion passed unanimously. 22-11-09
The meeting was adjourned at 12:43 p.m.
Agenda
TO: CMEEC and CTMEEC Boards of Directors
FROM: Kevin Barber, Chair
Dave Meisinger, CMEEC CEO
SUBJECT: Agenda and Notice for the Joint Annual and Regular CMEEC And CTMEEC Boards of Directors’
Meeting, Thursday, November 17, 2022
Attached is the Notice and Agenda for the Joint Annual and Regular CMEEC and CTMEEC Boards of Directors’
Meeting schedule be held in hybrid format at The Madison Beach Hotel, 94 West Wharf Road, Madison, CT.
Participation is also available by Zoom and telephonically. The Joint Annual and Regular CMEEC and CTMEEC
Boards of Directors’ Meeting will begin at 10:00 a.m.
Zoom instructions. Please contact Margaret Job at mjob@cmeec.org
AGENDA
Standard Action Items
Agenda Topic Page
Item Number
A Public Comment Period
B Conduct Voting Roster / Roll Call
C Approve Minutes of the Regular October 27, 2022 Joint CMEEC and
CTMEEC Boards of Directors’ Meeting
Specific Action Items
Agenda Topic Lead Page
Item Number
D Possible Executive Session pursuant to C.G.S. §1-200(6)(B) Dave Meisinger /
and §1-210(b)(4) Robin Kipnis
Subase Fuel Cell Project
E October 2022 Object Summary Dave Meisinger
F October 2022 Project Portfolio Summary Michael Rall
G October 2022 Energy Market Update Michael Cyr
H Budget & Finance Committee Report Christopher LaRose /
Possible Vote to Approve 2023 CMEEC Operating and Capital Patricia Meek
Budgets
I Governance Committee Report Ronald Gaudet /
Possible Vote to Approve: Robin Kipnis
• 2023 Joint CMEEC and CTMEEC Officers
• 2023 Joint CMEEC and CTMEEC Committee Members
• 2023 Joint CMEEC and CTMEEC Boards of Directors’ Meeting Dates
• 2023 Joint CMEEC and CTMEEC Committee Meeting Dates
J MEU Roundtable Kevin Barber
Posted this 11th day of November, 2022
Agenda Topic Lead Page
Item Number
K New Business Kevin Barber
L Guest Speaker: Brian Forshaw, Energy Market Advisors Kevin Barber
2022 ISO Markets Update
M Guest Speaker: Mike Hyland, NEPPA Executive Director Kevin Barber
An Energized Forecast: Charting your Utility’s EV Future
N Adjourn Kevin Barber
Posted this 11th day of November, 2022
Get email alerts for Norwich
A daily email when new agendas and minutes are posted.