City Council
Regular MeetingPalm Coast, FL · November 15, 2022
Minutes
City Hall
City of Palm Coast 160 Lake Avenue
Minutes Palm Coast, FL 32164
www.palmcoastgov.com
COUNCIL BUSINESS
MEETING
AMENDED AGENDA
Mayor David Alfin
Vice Mayor Eddie Branquinho
Council Member Ed Danko
Council Member John Fanelli III
Council Member Nick Klufas
Tuesday, November 15, 2022 9:00 AM COMMUNITY WING
City Staff
Denise Bevan, City Manager
Neysa Borkert, City Attorney
Virginia A. Smith, City Clerk
Public Participation shall be in accordance with Section 286.0114 Florida Statutes.
Other matters of concern may be discussed as determined by City Council.
If you wish to obtain more information regarding the City Council’s agenda, please contact the City Clerk's Office at 386-986-
3713.
In accordance with the Americans with Disabilities Act and Section 286.26, Florida Statutes, persons needing a reasonable
accommodation to participate in any of these proceedings or meeting should contact the City Clerk at 386-986-3713, at least
48 hours prior to the meeting.
City Council Meetings are streamed live on YouTube at https://www.youtube.com/user/PalmCoastGovTV/live.
It is proper meeting etiquette to silence all electronic devices, including cell phones while meeting is in session.
Any person who decides to appeal any decision of the City Council with respect to any matter considered at this meeting will
need a record of the proceedings, and for such purpose, may need to hire a court reporter to ensure that a verbatim record of
the proceedings is made, which record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based.
A. CALL TO ORDER
Mayor Alfin called the meeting to order at 9:00 a.m.
B. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE TO THE FLAG
C. ROLL CALL
Kaley Cook, Deputy City Clerk, called the roll. All members were present.
D. PUBLIC PARTICIPATION
Public Participation shall be held in accordance with Section 286.0114 Florida Statutes. And
pursuant to the City Council’s Meeting Policies and Procedures:
City of Palm Coast Created on 12/6/22
(1) Each speaker shall at the podium, provide their name and may speak for up to 3 minutes.
(2) The Public may provide comments to the City Council relative to matters not on the
agenda at the times indicated in this Agenda. Following any comments from the public, there
may be discussion by the City Council.
(3) When addressing the City Council on specific, enumerated Agenda items, speakers shall:
(a) direct all comments to the Mayor;
(b) make their comments concise and to the point;
(c) not speak more than once on the same subject;
(d) not, by speech or otherwise, delay or interrupt the proceedings or the peace of the City
Council;
(e) obey the orders of the Mayor or the City Council; and
(f) not make any irrelevant, impertinent or slanderous comments while addressing the City
Council; which pursuant to Council rules, shall be considered disorderly.
(4) Any person who becomes disorderly or who fails to confine his or her comments to the
identified subject or business, shall be cautioned by the Mayor and thereafter must conclude
his or her remarks on the subject within the remaining designated time limit.
Any speaker failing to comply, as cautioned, shall be barred from making any additional
comments during the meeting and may be removed, as necessary, for the remainder of the
meeting.
Members of the public may make comments during the public comment portion of the
meeting. Please be advised that public comment will only be permitted during the public
comment portions of the agenda at the times indicated by the Chair during the meeting.
Mayor Alfin provided the rules and procedures of public comment.
Jim Petochick shared about the upcoming boat parade and encouraged
residents to join the parade if they have a boat. Mr. Petochick thanked Council
Member Fanelli for meeting with the Cimmaron safety group and shared traffic
numbers in the area.
Robert MacDonald shared complementary comments regarding Council Member
Fanelli and thanked him and Vice Mayor Branquinho for their time as Council
Members.
George Mayo thanked Council Member Fanelli and Vice Mayor Branquinho and
shared congratulations to the incoming board members. Mr. Mayo also shared
about an art event in town center and its success. Additionally, Mr. Mayo
provided suggestions for bathroom signage in town center.
E. MINUTES
1. MINUTES OF THE CITY COUNCIL:
NOVEMBER 1, 2022 BUSINESS MEETING
Pass
City of Palm Coast Created on 12/6/22
Motion made to approve by Council Member Danko and seconded by Vice
Mayor Branquinho
Approved - 5 - Mayor David Alfin, Vice Mayor Eddie Branquinho, Council
Member Ed Danko, Council Member Nick Klufas, Council Member John Fanelli
III
F. PRESENTATIONS AND PROCLAMATIONS
2. PRESENTATION OF AWARD FOR THE 2022 FMIT PARTNERSHIP
Evan Mcllelan, FMIT Representative, presented the City with an award for risk
and safety management.
City Manager Bevan shared compliments to City staff.
Vice Mayor Branquinho shared about conditions years ago and the
improvements.
Ms. Fuller shared about safety throughout the City.
Mayor Alfin shared about becoming a model for other cities.
3. PROCLAMATION - PALM COAST HOLIDAY BOAT PARADE DAY
Mayor Alfin presented the Proclamation to members of the Palm Coast Yacht
Club.
Mayor Alfin shared additional comments about the parade and hopes that
residents will attend.
Sarah Yulis, Chair of the Palm Coast Holiday Boat Parade, shared additional
comments. Ms. Yulis thanked Mayor Alfin, City Council, and various City Staff for
their assistance with the event.
4. PROCLAMATION - NOVEMBER AS BE LOCAL, BUY LOCAL MONTH
Council Member Fanelli presented the Proclamation to local business owners.
Mayor Alfin asked Council Member Klufas to share about small businesses .
Council Member Klufas shared about the digital world we live in today and the
ability to start businesses.
City of Palm Coast Created on 12/6/22
Council then moved to item H7.
G. ORDINANCES SECOND READ
5. ORDINANCE 2022-XX AMENDING THE FUTURE LAND USE MAP DESIGNATION
FOR 30+/- ACRES OF PROPERTY FROM FLAGLER COUNTY DESIGNATION OF
AGRICULTURE & TIMBERLANDS AND CONSERVATION TO CITY OF PALM
COAST DESIGNATION OF MIXED USE AND CONSERVATION - US 1 AND
WHITEVIEW
O20220022
City Attorney Borkert read the title into the record.
Jose Papa, Senior Planner, was available for any questions and reminded
Council of the location and Planning Board recommendation.
Vice Mayor Branquinho shared the he hopes this will help to balance Palm
Coast.
There were no public comments.
Mayor Alfin called for a roll call vote. The motion passed 5-0.
6. ORDINANCE 2022-XX AMENDING THE ZONING MAP DESIGNATION FOR A 30+/-
ACRE PARCEL FROM FLAGLER COUNTY DESIGNATION OF AGRICULTURE TO
CITY OF PALM COAST DESIGNATION OF HIGH INTENSITY COMMERCIAL (COM-
3) AND PRESERVATION (PRS) - US 1 AND WHITEVIEW
O20220023
City Attorney Borkert read the title into the record. Ms. Borkert called for any ex-
parte communication. There were none.
Mr. Papa shared information on the topic.
Public Comment:
George Mayo spoke about a recent County Commission meeting and discussed
parking density in the new Planet Fitness area. Mr. Mayo asked what high
density commercial means, and suggested considering additional parking
spaces.
Mayor Alfin asked if there is an initiative to underline code and zoning
requirements between the City and the County. Would the comp lpan review be
an appropriate time to raise these questions?
Mr. Papa responded yes, that is a great time to converse with surrounding
Counties. Part of the comp plan requires interlocal collaboration.
City of Palm Coast Created on 12/6/22
Mayor Alfin called for a roll call vote. The motion passed 5-0.
H. ORDINANCES FIRST READ
7. ORDINANCE 2022-XX HARBORSIDE MASTER PLANNED DEVELOPMENT
This item was heard after item F4.
City Attorney Borkert read the title into the record.
Ms. Borkert shared about a request to move the forward to continued to a date
certain.
Mayor Alfin opened for public comment.
Irene Balladin, owner of Palm Coast Reserve Condos, shared that owners are
really concerned about safety. Ms. Balladin asked Council to think about the
problem of increased traffic.
Steve Carr shared concerns of increased traffic on Palm Harbor and the overflow
to traffic on Florida Park Drive.
Motion made to Table by Council Member Danko and seconded by Vice
Mayor Branquinho
Approved - 5 - Mayor David Alfin, Vice Mayor Eddie Branquinho, Council
Member Ed Danko, Council Member Nick Klufas, Council Member John Fanelli
III
I. RESOLUTIONS
8. RESOLUTION 2022-XX PROVIDING AUTHORIZATION TO INITIATE LEGAL
PROCEEDINGS FOR THE HOLLAND PARK SPLASH PAD
R20220150
City Attorney Borkert read the title into the record.
Attorney Borkert provided background of the item. Mr. Arnold presented
information to Council on the topic.
Council held discussion on including lost value, loss of revenue, loss of use,
timeline, legal fee costs, punitive damages, and cost reimbursement.
City of Palm Coast Created on 12/6/22
Mr. Arnold provided details.
Mayor Alfin asked that City Manager Bevan provide an update to Council at the
earliest possible date for opening the park despite the proceedings.
Public Comment:
Michael Arnold asked if this would be eligibile for citzens to piggyback to become
a class action lawsuit?
Attorney Borkert provided details.
Mayor Alfin called for a roll call vote. The motion passed 5-0.
Pass
Motion made to approve by Vice Mayor Branquinho and seconded by
Council Member Fanelli III
Approved - 5 - Mayor David Alfin, Vice Mayor Eddie Branquinho, Council
Member Ed Danko, Council Member Nick Klufas, Council Member John Fanelli
III
9. RESOLUTION 2022-XX APPROVING A BUDGET AMENDMENT FOR FISCAL
YEAR 2021/2022 RELATING TO THE DISASTER RESERVE FUND
R20220148
Attorney Borkert read the title into the record.
Helena Alves, Finance Director, provided details to Council.
Public Comment:
Robert MacDonald asked why the City doesn't prepare for hurricanes.
Ms. Alves and Mayor Alfin provided details regarding budgeting and reserves.
Mr. MacDonald asked additional budget questions.
Ms. Alves provided answers to the finacial questions.
Mayor Alfin called for a roll call vote. The motion passed 5-0.
Pass
Motion made to approve by Vice Mayor Branquinho and seconded by
Council Member Danko
Approved - 5 - Mayor David Alfin, Vice Mayor Eddie Branquinho, Council
Member Ed Danko, Council Member Nick Klufas, Council Member John Fanelli
III
City of Palm Coast Created on 12/6/22
10. RESOLUTION 2022-XX APPROVING A COST-SHARE AGREEMENT WITH ST.
JOHNS RIVER WATER MANAGEMENT DISTRICT FOR THE LONDON
WATERWAY EXPANSION PROJECT
R20220149
Pass
Motion made to approve by Vice Mayor Branquinho and seconded by
Council Member Fanelli III
Approved - 5 - Mayor David Alfin, Vice Mayor Eddie Branquinho, Council
Member Ed Danko, Council Member Nick Klufas, Council Member John Fanelli
III
Attorney Borkert read the title into the record.
Carl Cote, Director of Stormwater & Engineering provided details to Council.
Council Member Fanelli thanked staff for going for the grant
Public Comment:
There were none.
J. CONSENT
Public Comment:
Robert MacDonald spoke about an item on the consent agenda and its
importance.
Mayor Alfin shared comments about how the item came to Council and that
Council recognizes the importance of the item.
Pass
Motion made to to be adopted on consent by Vice Mayor Branquinho and
seconded by Council Member Klufas
Approved - 5 - Mayor David Alfin, Vice Mayor Eddie Branquinho, Council
Member Ed Danko, Council Member Nick Klufas, Council Member John Fanelli
III
11. RESOLUTION 2022-XX APPROVING PIGGYBACKING THE LAKE COUNTY
CONTRACT WITH TEN-8 FIRE & SAFETY, LLC FOR TWENTY (20) NEW BUNKER
GEAR JACKETS AND TWENTY (20) NEW BUNKER GEAR PANTS FOR FIRE
OPERATIONS
R20220151
City of Palm Coast Created on 12/6/22
12. RESOLUTION 2022-XX APPROVING A WORK ORDER WITH CONNECT
CONSULTING, INC., FOR THE REHAB AND PUMP REPLACEMENT FOR WELL
SW-38 AND REPLACEMENT OF WELL SW-7
R20220152
K. PUBLIC PARTICIPATION
Remainder of Public Comments is limited to three (3) minutes each.
Ed Fuller thanked the City for a recent Veterans event- It was well done and
dignified. Mr. Fuller thanked Vice Mayor Branquinho and Council Member Fanelli
for their service. Mr. Fuller also thanked Patrick Juliano for the send off of a
member who lost his life.
Robert MacDonald spoke about a City vehicle and its driving. Mr. MacDonald
spoke with staff and thanked staff for doing the right job. Additionally, Mr.
MacDonald provided well wishes for Vice Mayor Branquinho.
L. DISCUSSION BY CITY COUNCIL OF MATTERS NOT ON THE AGENDA
Council Member Fanelli shared about the boat parade.
Vice Mayor Branquinho thanked his colleagues, incoming candidates, and City
of Palm Coast Directors. Vice Mayor Branquinho also thanked Fire Chief
Berryhill and Flagler County Sheriff Rick Staly, and spoke about the
accomplishments staff has made during his time. Vice Mayor Branquinho also
wished residents happy holidays.
Council Member Klufas thanked Council Member Fanelli and Vice Mayor
Branquinho for their time as Council members.
Mayor Alfin asked Ms. Bevan to speak about staff effort during the Tropical
Storm Nicole.
Ms. Bevan shared comments and asked Chief Berryhill to provide updates.
Chief Berryhill provided updates to Council.
M. DISCUSSION BY CITY ATTORNEY OF MATTERS NOT ON THE AGENDA
There were none.
N. DISCUSSION BY CITY MANAGER OF MATTERS NOT ON THE AGENDA
Ms. Bevan provided the emergency and sole source purchases.
Ms. Bevan thanked Council Member Fanelli and Vice Mayor Branquino for their
service as Council Members.
City of Palm Coast Created on 12/6/22
13. REPORTING OF EMERGENCY AND SOLE SOURCE PURCHASES FOR
OCTOBER 2022
O. ADJOURNMENT
The meeting was adjourned at 10:46 a.m.
Respectfully submitted by: Kaley Cook, Deputy City Clerk
City of Palm Coast Created on 12/6/22
Agenda
City Hall
City of Palm Coast 160 Lake Avenue
Agenda Palm Coast, FL 32164
www.palmcoastgov.com
COUNCIL BUSINESS
MEETING
AMENDED AGENDA
Mayor David Alfin
Vice Mayor Eddie Branquinho
Council Member Ed Danko
Council Member John Fanelli III
Council Member Nick Klufas
Tuesday, November 15, 2022 9:00 AM COMMUNITY WING
City Staff
Denise Bevan, City Manager
Neysa Borkert, City Attorney
Virginia A. Smith, City Clerk
• Public Participation shall be in accordance with Section 286.0114 Florida Statutes.
• Other matters of concern may be discussed as determined by City Council.
• If you wish to obtain more information regarding the City Council’s agenda, please contact the City Clerk's Office at 386-986-
3713.
• In accordance with the Americans with Disabilities Act and Section 286.26, Florida Statutes, persons needing a reasonable
accommodation to participate in any of these proceedings or meeting should contact the City Clerk at 386-986-3713, at least
48 hours prior to the meeting.
• City Council Meetings are streamed live on YouTube at https://www.youtube.com/user/PalmCoastGovTV/live.
• It is proper meeting etiquette to silence all electronic devices, including cell phones while Council is in session.
• Any person who decides to appeal any decision of the City Council with respect to any matter considered at this meeting will
need a record of the proceedings, and for such purpose, may need to hire a court reporter to ensure that a verbatim record of
the proceedings is made, which record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based.
A. CALL TO ORDER
B. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE TO THE FLAG
C. ROLL CALL
D. PUBLIC PARTICIPATION
Public Participation shall be held in accordance with Section 286.0114 Florida Statutes. And
pursuant to the City Council’s Meeting Policies and Procedures:
(1) Each speaker shall at the podium, provide their name and may speak for up to 3 minutes.
(2) The Public may provide comments to the City Council relative to matters not on the
City of Palm Coast Created on 11/14/22
1
agenda at the times indicated in this Agenda. Following any comments from the public,
there may be discussion by the City Council.
(3) When addressing the City Council on specific, enumerated Agenda items, speakers shall:
(a) direct all comments to the Mayor;
(b) make their comments concise and to the point;
(c) not speak more than once on the same subject;
(d) not, by speech or otherwise, delay or interrupt the proceedings or the peace of the City
Council;
(e) obey the orders of the Mayor or the City Council; and
(f) not make any irrelevant, impertinent or slanderous comments while addressing the City
Council; which pursuant to Council rules, shall be considered disorderly.
(4) Any person who becomes disorderly or who fails to confine his or her comments to the
identified subject or business, shall be cautioned by the Mayor and thereafter must conclude
his or her remarks on the subject within the remaining designated time limit.
Any speaker failing to comply, as cautioned, shall be barred from making any additional
comments during the meeting and may be removed, as necessary, for the remainder of the
meeting.
Members of the public may make comments during the public comment portion of the
meeting. Please be advised that public comment will only be permitted during the public
comment portions of the agenda at the times indicated by the Chair during the meeting.
E. MINUTES
1. MINUTES OF THE CITY COUNCIL:
NOVEMBER 1, 2022 BUSINESS MEETING
F. PRESENTATIONS AND PROCLAMATIONS
2. PRESENTATION OF AWARD FOR THE 2022 FMIT PARTNERSHIP
3. PROCLAMATION - PALM COAST HOLIDAY BOAT PARADE DAY
4. PROCLAMATION - NOVEMBER AS BE LOCAL, BUY LOCAL MONTH
G. ORDINANCES SECOND READ
5. ORDINANCE 2022-XX AMENDING THE FUTURE LAND USE MAP DESIGNATION FOR
30+/- ACRES OF PROPERTY FROM FLAGLER COUNTY DESIGNATION OF AGRICULTURE
& TIMBERLANDS AND CONSERVATION TO CITY OF PALM COAST DESIGNATION OF
MIXED USE AND CONSERVATION - US 1 AND WHITEVIEW
6. ORDINANCE 2022-XX AMENDING THE ZONING MAP DESIGNATION FOR A 30+/- ACRE
City of Palm Coast Created on 11/14/22
2
PARCEL FROM FLAGLER COUNTY DESIGNATION OF AGRICULTURE TO CITY OF PALM
COAST DESIGNATION OF HIGH INTENSITY COMMERCIAL (COM-3) AND PRESERVATION
(PRS) - US 1 AND WHITEVIEW
H. ORDINANCES FIRST READ
7. ORDINANCE 2022-XX HARBORSIDE MASTER PLANNED DEVELOPMENT
I. RESOLUTIONS
8. RESOLUTION 2022-XX PROVIDING AUTHORIZATION TO INITIATE LEGAL PROCEEDINGS
FOR THE HOLLAND PARK SPLASH PAD
9. RESOLUTION 2022-XX APPROVING A BUDGET AMENDMENT FOR FISCAL YEAR
2021/2022 RELATING TO THE DISASTER RESERVE FUND
10. RESOLUTION 2022-XX APPROVING A COST-SHARE AGREEMENT WITH ST. JOHNS
RIVER WATER MANAGEMENT DISTRICT FOR THE LONDON WATERWAY EXPANSION
PROJECT
J. CONSENT
11. RESOLUTION 2022-XX APPROVING PIGGYBACKING THE LAKE COUNTY CONTRACT
WITH TEN-8 FIRE & SAFETY, LLC FOR TWENTY (20) NEW BUNKER GEAR JACKETS AND
TWENTY (20) NEW BUNKER GEAR PANTS FOR FIRE OPERATIONS
12. RESOLUTION 2022-XX APPROVING A WORK ORDER WITH CONNECT CONSULTING,
INC., FOR THE REHAB AND PUMP REPLACEMENT FOR WELL SW-38 AND
REPLACEMENT OF WELL SW-7
K. PUBLIC PARTICIPATION
Remainder of Public Comments is limited to three (3) minutes each.
L. DISCUSSION BY CITY COUNCIL OF MATTERS NOT ON THE AGENDA
M. DISCUSSION BY CITY ATTORNEY OF MATTERS NOT ON THE AGENDA
N. DISCUSSION BY CITY MANAGER OF MATTERS NOT ON THE AGENDA
13. REPORTING OF EMERGENCY AND SOLE SOURCE PURCHASES FOR OCTOBER 2022
O. ADJOURNMENT
14. AGENDA WORKSHEET AND CALENDAR
City of Palm Coast Created on 11/14/22
3
City of Palm Coast, Florida
Agenda Item
Agenda Date : November 15, 2022
Department CITY ADMINISTRATION Amount
Division Account
#
Subject MINUTES OF THE CITY COUNCIL:
NOVEMBER 1, 2022 BUSINESS MEETING
Presenter : Virginia Smith, City Clerk
Background :
Recommended Action :
ADOPT THE MINUTES OF THE CITY COUNCIL:
NOVEMBER 1, 2022 BUSINESS MEETING
4
City of Palm Coast, Florida
Agenda Item
Agenda Date : November 15, 2022
Department HUMAN RESOURCES Amount
Division RISK AND SAFETY Account
#
Subject PRESENTATION OF AWARD FOR THE 2022 FMIT PARTNERSHIP FOR RISK
AND SAFETY
Presenter : Tim Wilsey, Human Resource Manager
Background :
The City of Palm Coast has been selected as the winner of the 2022 FMIT Partnership Award
for Risk and Safety.
FMIT Partnership Award
The Florida Municipal Insurance Trust (FMIT), administrated by the Florida League of Cities
(FLC), is recognizing its valued partners with a new award. The FMIT Partnership Award is
designed to recognize members' successful insurance processes, risk management efforts, and
other proactive measures that improve the quality of life in their community and working
environment.
The FMIT is a partnership of local governments in Florida, so these efforts should align with the
FLC's mission to serve the needs of Florida's cities. All members with at least one line of related
coverage through the FMIT are eligible for this award.
The award selection criteria:.
Award Categories
• Innovation Award - Recognizing creative processes that turn problems into progress,
reduce costs, and keep staff and the community safe.
• Risk & Safety Award - Recognizing the implementation of FMIT Risk & Safety
Management frameworks with proven results.
• Insurance Leader Award – Honoring long-term support of FMIT services and improved
insurance processes that meet specific needs of public entities.
Members who receive this award are publicly recognized on the FMIT website, in the League's
Quality Cities magazine, and at the FMIT booth in the Exhibit Hall at the FLC Annual
Conference. Awards are presented at council meetings, regional league meetings, or FLC
Annual Conference breakfast events.
12
City of Palm Coast – Risk & Safety Award
Human Resources and Risk & Safety Management Processes
After several years of elevated workers’ compensation claims frequency and related experience
mod increases, the City of Palm Coast's Human Resources and Risk Management team, led by
Tim Wilsey and Renina Fuller, partnered with the Florida Municipal Insurance Trust (FMIT) Risk
and Safety Management department to implement needed changes. Focus areas included:
• A renewed emphasis on employee safety and a concentrated effort on return-to-work
policies and programs.
• An increase in the City's employee safety training.
• A renewed and more narrowly focused Safety Committee.
These changes brought about a significant reduction in employee-related injuries (both
frequency and severity) over three years, lower financial costs associated with those claims,
and a continuing decrease in the City's workers’ compensation experience mod (elevated
experience mods often result in increased premiums). Palm Coast has also been a strong
advocate of all services and programs provided by the FMIT and the Florida League of Cities
(FLC).
Recommended Action :
FOR PRESENTATION ONLY.
13
City of Palm Coast, Florida
Agenda Item
Agenda Date : November 15, 2022
Department CITY ADMINISTRATION Amount
Division Account
#
Subject PROCLAMATION - PALM COAST HOLIDAY BOAT PARADE DAY
Presenter : Mayor and City Council
Background :
The Palm Coast Yacht Club requested the City of Palm Coast proclaim December 3, 2022, as
“Palm Coast Holiday Boat Parade Day.”
Recommended Action :
PROCLAIM DECEMBER 3, 2022 AS PALM COAST HOLIDAY BOAT PARADE DAY
14
City of Palm Coast, Florida
Agenda Item
Agenda Date: November 15, 2022
Department CITY ADMINISTRATION Amount
Division Account
#
Subject PROCLAMATION - NOVEMBER AS BE LOCAL, BUY LOCAL MONTH
Presenter: Brittany Kershaw, Director of Communications & Marketing
Background:
“Be Local Buy Local” is an annual effort on the Saturday after Thanksgiving that promotes local,
small businesses that have contributed to the financial success of the City of Palm Coast by
contributing close to $9 million last year alone in sales tax collections.
The funds generated to the City by our small businesses have contributed to our spacious
Community Center and similar projects, as well as street and sidewalk improvements.
Small businesses have created 65.1 percent of net new jobs since the turn of the century, and
2022 marks the 13th annual Small Business Saturday. The City of Palm Coast appreciates and
honors small businesses with this Proclamation.
Recommended Action:
PROCLAIM NOVEMBER 2022 AS “BE LOCAL, BUY LOCAL” MONTH
16
City of Palm Coast, Florida
Agenda Item
Agenda Date: November 15, 2022
Department COMMUNITY Amount
DEVELOPMENT
Division Account
#
Subject ORDINANCE 2022-XX AMENDING THE FUTURE LAND USE MAP
DESIGNATION FOR 30+/- ACRES OF PROPERTY FROM FLAGLER COUNTY
DESIGNATION OF AGRICULTURE & TIMBERLANDS AND CONSERVATION TO
CITY OF PALM COAST DESIGNATION OF MIXED USE AND CONSERVATION –
US 1 AND WHITEVIEW
Presenter : Jose Papa, AICP, Senior Planner
Background:
UPDATE FROM THE NOVEMBER 1, 2022 BUSINESS MEETING
This item was heard by City Council at their November 1, 2022 Business Meeting. There were
no changes suggested to this item.
ORIGINAL BACKGROUND FROM THE NOVEMBER 1, 2022 BUSINESS METTING
The subject area is an approximately 30-acre site located on the westside of US-1 at the
terminus of Whiteview Pkwy. The application is a proposed FLUM amendment to change the
current Flagler County designation of Agriculture & Timberlands and Conservation to City of
Palm Coast designation of Mixed Use and Conservation. There is a companion zoning map
amendment for the subject parcel to change the current zoning designation from Flagler County
Agriculture to City of Palm Coast High Intensity Commercial (COM-3) and Preservation (PRS).
The proposed amendment was reviewed for the following:
• Analysis of the proposed amendment’s impacts on public facilities and
infrastructure. Consistent with the required analysis to compare the proposed land use
designation with the existing land use designation, staff conducted a maximum potential
development analysis for public facilities and infrastructure. The proposed amendment
will result in higher demand on water and sewer facilities but should have a lower impact
on transportation facilities.
• Impacts on the environmental/cultural resources. There are no significant impact on
the environmental attributes on the subject parcel since the parcel is mainly composed
of planted pine. The amendment does propose to protect a 5.4 acre wetland area which
is interconnected to a larger wetland system.
• Compatibility with surrounding land uses. The proposed FLUM designations are
generally consistent with the surrounding properties.
18
Finally, the proposed amendment is consistent with comprehensive plan policies regarding:
• Directing development where existing infrastructure is available.
Public Process
Neighborhood Meeting
As required by the Land Development Code, a neighborhood meeting was hosted by the
applicant on October 4, 2022. Other than the applicants and City staff, there were no attendees
from the surrounding community.
Planning and Land Development Regulation Board (PLDRB) Public Hearing
The PLDRB held a public hearing on October 19, 2022 to review and hear public comments on
the proposed amendment. There were no public comments and the Board voted 6-1 to
recommend approval.
Recommended Action:
THE PLANNING AND LAND DEVELOPMENT REGULATION BOARD (PLDRB) FINDS
APPLICATION #5190 CONSISTENT WITH THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN AND
RECOMMENDS THAT CITY COUNCIL APPROVE THE FLUM AMENDMENT FROM
AGRICULTURE & TIMBERLANDS, AND CONSERVATION (FLAGLER COUNTY
DESIGNATIONS) TO MIXED USE AND CONSERVATION (CITY OF PALM COAST
DESIGNATION) – US 1 AND WHITEVIEW
19
City of Palm Coast, Florida
Agenda Item
Agenda Date : November 15, 2022
Department COMMUNITY Amount
DEVELOPMENT
Division PLANNING Account
#
Subject ORDINANCE 2022-XX AMENDING THE ZONING MAP DESIGNATION FOR A
30+/- ACRE PARCEL FROM FLAGLER COUNTY DESIGNATION OF
AGRICULTURE TO CITY OF PALM COAST DESIGNATION OF HIGH INTENSITY
COMMERCIAL (COM-3) AND PRESERVATION (PRS) - US 1 AND WHITEVIEW
Presenter : Jose Papa, AICP, Senior Planner
Background :
THIS IS A QUASI-JUDICIAL ITEM. PLEASE REMEMBER TO DISCLOSE ANY EX-PARTE
COMMUNICATION.
UPDATE FROM THE NOVEMBER 1, 2022 BUSINESS MEETING
This item was heard by City Council at their November 1, 2022 Business Meeting. There were
no changes suggested to this item.
ORIGINAL BACKGROUND FROM THE NOVEMBER 1, 2022 BUSINESS METTING
The subject area is an approximately 30 acre site located on the westside of US-1 at the
terminus of Whiteview Pkwy. The zoning map amendment application proposes to change the
current designation from Flagler County designation of Agriculture to City of Palm Coast
designation of High Intensity Commercial (COM-3) and Preservation. There is a companion
Future Land Use Map (FLUM) amendment to change the current designation from the Flagler
County designations of Agriculture & Timberlands, and Conservation to City of Palm Coast
designation of Mixed Use and Conservation.
The proposed High Intensity Commercial (COM-3) zoning mainly permits a variety of
commercial/retail uses along with office uses related to the building industry, as well as
warehouse and distribution facilities.
Staff analyzed the proposed rezoning based on the criteria in the City of Palm Coast Land
Development Code. In summary, staff makes the following findings:
- the proposed rezoning is consistent with the Comprehensive Plan including a policy to
protect large, interconnected wetlands,
- the proposed rezoning is consistent with the surrounding land uses and does not cause
a nuisance or threat to the general welfare and safety of the public. The proposed COM-
3 zoning is generally consistent with the development pattern found to the north (light
industrial, storage, and building industry uses),
39
- the proposed amendment will not cause undue hardship or liability to the City since
public infrastructure (water, sewer, roadways) are adjacent to the site and any extension
will be the responsibility of the property owner.
Public Process
Neighborhood Meeting
As required by the Land Development Code, a neighborhood meeting was hosted by the
applicant on October 4, 2022. Other than the applicants and City staff, there were no attendees
from the surrounding community.
Planning and Land Development Regulation Board (PLDRB) Public Hearing
The PLDRB held a public hearing on October 19, 2022 to review and hear public comments on
the proposed amendment. There were no public comments and the Board voted 7-0 to
recommend approval.
Recommended Action:
THE PLANNING AND LAND DEVELOPMENT REGULATION BOARD (PLDRB)
FINDS APPLICATION #5192 CONSISTENT WITH THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN
AND RECOMMENDS THAT CITY COUNCIL APPROVE THE ZONING MAP
AMENDMENT FROM AGRICULTURE (FLAGLER COUNTY DESIGNATION) TO HIGH
INTENSITY COMMERCIAL (COM-3) AND PRESERVATION (PRS) (CITY OF PALM COAST
DESIGNATION) – US 1 AND WHITEVIEW
40
City of Palm Coast, Florida
Agenda Item
Agenda Date: November 15, 2022
Department COMMUNITY Amount
DEVELOPMENT
Division PLANNING Account
#
Subject ORDINANCE 2022-XX HARBORSIDE MASTER PLANNED DEVELOPMENT
Presenter: Ray Tyner, Deputy Chief Development Officer and Bill Hoover, Senior Planner,
AICP
Background:
JDI Palm Coast, LLC, as the applicant is proposing to rezone 17.64 +/- acres that has an
existing marina with 84 wet slips, a 72-unit residential condominium building, a 525-space
parking garage, infrastructure, and vacant cleared land. The property is located on the east and
northeast sides of the intersection between Palm Harbor Parkway and Clubhouse Drive. It is
also located adjacent to the south side of the Clubhouse Waterway and along the west side of
the Intracoastal Waterway. The proposed rezoning is from Harborside Inn & Marina PUD to
Harborside Master Planned Development (MPD) for a potential mixed-use project that is
intended to include a marina with ship’s store, townhouses, multi-family units and possibly a
restaurant and/or hotel.
The applicant is requesting two options for the development, one primarily adding residential
units and the second primarily adding residential units and a hotel. Per LDC Section 3.05.03.C,
residential density calculations cannot include lands being used for commercial purposes so in
scenario one 0.7 +/- acre of commercial land area for Lots 1 and 2 are subtracted from the
project size while on scenario two, 2.7 +/- acres of commercial land area for Lots 1 - 3 are
subtracted from the project size. (Note that hotels and commercial uses are governed by
intensity limits, typically using maximum floor area ratios, rather than density limitations.) In
scenario one, the proposed 432 units would have an overall project density on the 16.94 +/-
acres of 25.5 units/per acre. In scenario two, the proposed 432 units would have an overall
project density on the 14.94 +/- acres of 28.9 units/per acre.
Planning and Land Development Regulation Board (PLDRB) Meeting on September 20, 2022:
This project was heard by the PLDRB on September 20, 2022. Planning staff recommended
“denial” of the project due to the proposed very high density and compatibility issues with
neighboring properties which did not meet various goals and policies of the Comprehensive
Plan and sections of the Land Development Code (LDC). After a very lengthy meeting the
PLDRB voted 6-0 to continue the project until the October 19, 2022, PLDRB meeting and
requested that the applicant and Planning staff get together to see if they could minimize their
differences in the MPD Development Agreement.
Updated Information: The applicant and staff held several meetings discussing the issues
between the two parties which resulted in agreement on most all items. However, the major
issue that remains is the maximum project density. The applicant is seeking 25.5 or 28.9
54
units/per acre depending on the applicant’s choice of two development options. Staff and the
applicant differ on the interpretation of the Comprehensive Plan and applicable sections of the
LDC that determine maximum project densities.
On October 6th, City Staff initiated and sent the applicant a proposed new Section 10 to be
included within the MPD Development Agreement. Staff’s professional planning opinion
suggested that if eight development standards were implemented within the project, and the
project was limited to 18.3 units/acre, Staff could consider the project consistent with the
Comprehensive Plan and the LDC; and specifically, with Comprehensive Plan Policy 1.1.2.2.
Staff’s proposed eight development standards are attached in the Staff report as Exhibit “A.”
Staff opines that 18.3 units/acre would be consistent with the Comprehensive Plan and the LDC
if the applicant implemented all eight items listed in Exhibit “A.’ At 18.3 units/per acre this would
yield a maximum of either 310 units on 16.94 acres or 273 units on 14.94 acres. This is an
increase of 22% over the maximum 15 units/per acre allowed in the Mixed Use District, absent
the inclusion of the types of changes allowed in Policy 1.1.2.2 in order to promote and
encourage creatively planned projects and in recognition of special geographical features,
environmental conditions, economic issues, or other unique circumstances.
The 22% increase in density is consistent with the previous PUD approval which permitted a
22% increase in base intensity which increased the Floor Area Ratio from 55% to 67%. Staff
believes their suggested eight development items would make the project equivalent in nature
to the previous project regarding Policy 1.1.2.2. These eight standards would allow staff to
support a 22% increase for density and is based on consistency with the Comprehensive Plan
and LDC. Staff believes the eight standards listed in Exhibit “A”, would make the 18.3 units/ per
acre project compatible with the surrounding neighborhood. In staff’s professional opinion the
applicant’s proposal of 25.5 to 28.9 units per acre is not compatible with neighboring properties,
as required by several sections in the LDC.
The applicant reviewed staff’s proposal for 18.3 units/acre with the eight standards, and on
October 10th, the applicant provided a written response that is attached in the Staff Report as
Exhibit “B”. The applicant suggested that much of staff’s proposed text should be deleted, and
suggested alternative text be included with approximately the same development standards
(one standard was dropped by the applicant). (Note applicant’s proposed MPD DA includes
their proposed alternative standards.) The applicant argued that if they met even some of staff’s
eight standards, the project would be entitled to 432 units and a density of 25.5 or 28.9 units/per
acre.
Planning and Land Development Regulation Board (PLDRB) Meeting on October 19, 2022
This project was heard again by the PLDRB on October 19, 2022. Planning staff recommended
“denial” of the project due to the proposed very high density and compatibility issues with
neighboring properties which did not meet various goals and policies of the Comprehensive
Plan and sections of the Land Development Code (LDC). After a lengthy meeting, the PLDRB
voted 7-0 to recommend denial of the project to the City Council.
Public Participation: A neighborhood information meeting was held at 11:00 a.m. on September
8, 2022, at the 3rd floor of the on-site parking garage. By staff’s count 48 persons attended this
meeting including three persons representing the developer and one City staff member. The
developer erected two City provided signs along Palm Harbor Parkway at least 14 days prior to
each of the PLDRB meetings and will do so again 14 days prior to each City Council public
55
hearings. The City ran a news ad 20 days prior to the September 20, 2022, PLDRB meeting
and since the project was continued (“date certain” to October 19, 2022) by the PLDRB no
additional news ad was required. News ads are being run 13 days prior to each City Council
public hearing.
A total of 29 persons from the public spoke at the two PLDRB meetings with 11 speaking at the
first PLDRB meeting and 18 speaking at the second PLDRB meeting. Staff did not notice
anyone speaking at both hearings as the City Attorney announced those speaking at the first
hearing were already on the record and there was no need to speak again. All or nearly all
speakers had concerns with the project and their concerns primarily involved: project density
and number of units, building height, traffic, stormwater and flooding issues, utility concerns,
and lack of specific development plans by the developer.
Recommended Action:
The Planning and Land Development Regulation Board found, by a vote of 7 to 0, the proposed
MPD Application No. 5132 not in compliance with the Comprehensive Plan’s Goal 1.1 and
Policies 1.1.1.2 and 1.1.2.2 and not in compliance with the Land Development Code’s Sections
3.03.04, 3.03.04.B.2, and 3.03.04.D and recommended denial to City Council to rezone 17.64
+/- acres from Harborside Inn & Marina PUD to Harborside MPD.
56
City of Palm Coast, Florida
Agenda Item
Agenda Date : November 15, 2022
Department CITY ADMINISTRATION Amount
Division Account
#
Subject RESOLUTION 2022-XX PROVIDING AUTHORIZATION TO INITIATE LEGAL
PROCEEDINGS FOR THE HOLLAND PARK SPLASH PAD
Presenter : Carl Cote, Director and Trevor Arnold, Attorney
Background :
On April 12, 2022, City staff specialized legal representative, Mr. Trevor B. Arnold of Gray
Robinson, P.A. presented Council with an update on the Splash Pad located at Holland Park.
On June 7, 2022, City staff and Mr. Arnold provided City Council with another update regarding
the Splash Pad located at Holland Park. In addition, City Council approved piggybacking the
Collier County Contract (#18-7432-Aq) with Martin Aquatic Design & Engineering, through June
4, 2025, for professional aquatic design and engineering services.
City staff negotiated a scope and fee per Florida Statute 287.055 ‘Consultants’ Competitive
Negotiation Act’ (CCNA) to complete an assessment of the splash pad. This initial analysis had
been completed and a report identifying the deficiencies is contained within the report. During
the assessment, it was determined that complete removal of the splash pad surfacing material
that has failed be removed, so that further analysis could be conducted. This would be to
determine if there were any concrete deck or drainage issues. The removal occurred the week
of August 22, 2022, and survey work was conducted the week of August 29th. A revised report
was issued in September.
On September 6, 2022, an update was provided to City Council. Council approved a not-to-
exceed amount of $92,470, with Martin Aquatic Design & Engineering contract. This contract
was to complete the design to correct the deficiencies and prepare a bid package to be issued
for construction.
On October 5, 2022, legal mediation with involved parties was conducted with no settlement
reached. This item to provide City Council with an update on the legal process and to obtain
authorization for legal proceedings for the Holland Park Splash Pad.
Recommended Action :
ADOPT RESOLUTION 2022-XX PROVIDING AUTHORIZATION TO INITIATE LEGAL
PROCEEDINGS FOR THE HOLLAND PARK SPLASH PAD
247
City of Palm Coast, Florida
Agenda Item
Agenda Date: November 15, 2022
Department FINANCE Amount
Item Key Account: 2103 – Disaster Reserve
Subject: RESOLUTION 2022-XX APPROVING A BUDGET AMENDMENT FOR FISCAL
YEAR 2021/2022 RELATING TO THE DISASTER RESERVE FUND
Presenter: Helena Alves, Financial Services Director
Background:
As a result from Hurricane Ian, the Disaster Reserve Fund expenditures have exceeded the
projected budget for Fiscal Year 2021-2022 by approximately $500,000 which requires City
Council to amend the Fiscal Year 2021-2022 budget accordingly.
Recommended Action:
ADOPT RESOLUTION 2022-XX APPROVING A BUDGET AMENDMENT FOR FISCAL YEAR
2021-2022 RELATING TO THE DISASTER RESERVE FUND
250
City of Palm Coast, Florida
Agenda Item
Agenda Date: November 8, 2022
Department CONSTRUCTION Amount
MANAGEMENT &
ENGINEERING
Division ENGINEERING Account
Subject RESOLUTION 2022-XX APPROVING A COST-SHARE AGREEMENT WITH ST.
JOHNS RIVER WATER MANAGEMENT DISTRICT FOR THE LONDON
WATERWAY EXPANSION PROJECT
Presenter : Carmelo Morales, Stormwater Engineer III
Background :
In an effort to enhance and stay consistent with the Stormwater Master Plan and to address
drainage related issues, the City wishes to expand the stormwater attenuation and treatment
capacity of the London Waterway. The project objective is to increase the flood storage capacity
within London Waterway to reduce peak elevations, improve water quality in receiving waters
with additional stormwater treatment, enhance the environment to support native fauna and
flora, and deliver an aesthetic project that can serve the immediate neighborhood as a passive
park. The project consists of construction an 11-acre lake along with corresponding storm sewer
for inflow and outflow structures and 4.2 acres of littoral zone.
The St. Johns River Water Management District (SJRWMD) cost-share program is designed to
fund the construction of local stormwater management and alternative water supply projects as
well as conservation implementation projects.
Staff requested grant funding for the London Waterway Expansion project, in an amount not to
exceed $904,500, towards the estimated construction cost of $3,618,000. The district has
determined that providing cost-share funding to recipient will benefit the water resources and
one or more of the district’s missions and initiatives. This request was approved by the
Governing Board (contract#37938).
This item is to approve the cost-share grant agreement with SJRWMD.
Recommended Action :
ADOPT RESOLUTION 2022-XX APPROVING A COST-SHARE AGREEMENT WITH ST.
JOHNS RIVER WATER MANAGERMENT DISTRICT FOR THE LONDON WATERWAY
EXPANSION PROJECT
254
City of Palm Coast, Florida
Agenda Item
Agenda Date: November 15, 2022
Department PUBLIC SAFETY Amount $53,073.80
Division FIRE Account 10014000-052000
#
Subject RESOLUTION 2022-XX APPROVING PIGGYBACKING THE LAKE COUNTY
CONTRACT WITH TEN-8 FIRE & SAFETY, LLC FOR TWENTY (20) NEW
BUNKER GEAR JACKETS AND TWENTY (20) NEW BUNKER GEAR PANTS
FOR FIRE OPERATIONS
Presenter: Fire Chief Berryhill
Background :
The current budget for our Fire Department includes the replacement of aging bunker gear
(protective firefighting equipment). According to the NFPA guidelines, bunker gear has a life
expectancy of approximately ten years, and we are beyond that with some of our older
equipment. The Fire Department’s plan is to consistently replace 20 sets per year to ensure we
have upgraded equipment for our employees.
This year we are requesting 20 replacement sets. The Fire Department formed a committee to
set standards for bunker gear that the firemen are to use.
The Fiscal Year 2023 budget includes $53,073.80 in available funding in the City’s Fire
Department operating budget for the purchase of Fire Equipment – Personal Protective
Equipment (Bunker Gear).
Staff recommends approving a piggyback contract with Lake County and Ten-8 Fire & Safety,
LLC to purchase the Fire Equipment – Personal Protective Equipment (Bunker Gear).
SOURCE OF FUNDS WORKSHEET FY 2023
Improvements – Fire Operating Supplies 10014000…052000…………...…….$317,029.00
Total Expended/Encumbered to Date…………………………………………… $74,030.42
Current (WO/Contract).……………………………………………………..…….. $53,073.80
Balance………………………………………………………………………..…..…$189,924.78
Recommended Action :
ADOPT RESOLUTION 2022-XX APPROVING PIGGYBACKING THE LAKE COUNTY
CONTRACT WITH TEN-8 FIRE & SAFETY, LLC FOR TWENTY (20) NEW BUNKER GEAR
JACKETS AND TWENTY (20) NEW BUNKER GEAR PANTS FOR FIRE OPERATIONS
270
City of Palm Coast, Florida
Agenda Item
Agenda Date: November 15, 2022
Department WATER AND WASTEWATER Amount $312,000.00
UTILITY
Division Account 54029088 063000 81019
#
Subject RESOLUTION 2022-XX APPROVING A WORK ORDER WITH CONNECT
CONSULTING, INC., FOR THE REHAB AND PUMP REPLACEMENT FOR WELL
SW-38 AND REPLACEMENT OF WELL SW-7
Presenter: Peter Roussell, Deputy Utility Director
Background :
This item is for standard operations.
The Utility Department has identified the need to rehab and replace the pump for SW-7 well and
replace the pump for SW-38 well. These well sites are Public Water Supply Wells that supply
raw water to Water Treatment Plant #1. SW-7 was originally constructed in 1973 and has a
production rate of 150 gallons per minute (GPM) with a specific capacity of 7.3 GPM/ft. of
drawdown. The specific capacity has declined to less than 2 with a production rate of
approximately 40 GPM. Connect Consulting, Inc. (CCI) will provide hydrogeological services
and engage in several field duties associated with the rehabilitation and relocation to complete
SW-7. City staff noticed a large amount of sand in the pipeline for SW-38. CCI evaluated SW-38
in September 2022 and determined that the sand was coming from the uppermost portion of the
screen. CCI recommended rehabilitating SW-38 to reduce/eliminate sand production and
improve the specific capacity. The well was originally constructed in 2006 as a screen filter
packed into the confined surficial aquifer. The specific capacity was 12 GPM/ft. of drawdown
when SW-38 was originally constructed.
Under the existing contract RFSQ-CD-20-31, staff negotiated a scope and fee not-to-exceed
$65,000.00 with CCI, for the rehab and pump replacement of well SW-38 and $247,000.00 for
the replacement of well SW-7. City staff has determined that the cost for the services is
reasonable and fair and are consistent with these types of services for a project of this size and
scope. Funds for this project have been budgeted in the FY 2023 Utility Capital Projects-
Improvements-Wellfield and Wells fund.
SOURCE OF FUNDS WORKSHEET FY 2023
Improvements – Wellfield and Wells 54029088 063000 81019………..…….$2,600,000.00
Total Expended/Encumbered to Date…………………………………………… 74,780.00
Current (WO/Contract).……………………………………………………..…….. 312,000.00
Balance………………………………………………………………………..……$2,213,220.00
Recommended Action :
ADOPT RESOLUTION 2022-XX APPROVING A WORK ORDER WITH CONNECT
CONSULTING, INC., FOR THE REHAB AND PUMP REPLACEMENT FOR WELL SW-38
AND THE REPLACEMENT OF WELL SW-7
277
City of Palm Coast, Florida
Agenda Item
Agenda Date : November 15, 2022
Department FINANCIAL SERVICES Amount
Division FINANCE Account
#
Subject REPORTING OF EMERGENCY AND SOLE SOURCE PURCHASES FOR
OCTOBER 2022
Presenter : Denise Bevan, City Manager
Background :
Attached is a list of all emergency and sole source purchases for the month of October 2022,
in accordance with Sec 2.25 of Chapter 2, Article 1 Division 3 of the Code of Ordinances of the
City of Palm Coast (Procurement Policy).
Recommended Action :
FOR REPORTING ONLY - VIA CITY MANAGER COMMENTS
301
Get email alerts for Palm Coast
A daily email when new agendas and minutes are posted.