Special City Council
Special MeetingPort St. Lucie, FL · October 21, 2019
Minutes
121 SW Port St. Lucie
City of Port St.Lucie Blvd.
Port St. Lucie, Florida
34984
Special City Council
Meeting Minutes
Gregory J. Oravec, Mayor
Stephanie Morgan, Councilwoman, District I
John Carvelli, Councilman, District II
Shannon Martin, Vice Mayor, District III
Jolien Caraballo, Councilwoman, District IV
Monday, October 21, 2019 1:30 PM Council Chambers, City Hall
1. Meeting Called to Order
A Special Meeting of the CITY COUNCIL of the City of Port St. Lucie was called to
order by Mayor Oravec on October 21, 2019, at 1:30 p.m., at Port St. Lucie City
Hall, 121 SW Port St. Lucie Boulevard, Port St. Lucie, Florida.
2. Roll Call
Council Members
Present: Mayor Gregory J. Oravec
Vice Mayor Shannon Martin
Councilman John Carvelli
Councilwoman Stephanie Morgan
Council Members
Not Present: Councilwoman Jolien Caraballo
3. Pledge of Allegiance
Mayor Oravec led the assembly in the Pledge of Allegiance.
4. Public to be Heard
No one signed up to speak under this item.
5. Special Presentation
Page 1 of 8
Special City Council Meeting Minutes October 21, 2019
5.a Accept the 2019 State of the Civic Center Report. 2019-943
Civic Center Director McCarthy presented a PowerPoint presentation,
and gave an overview of the Mission Statement and explained the
reorganization that occurred when she came onboard. She gave an
overview of each Division of the Civic Center and explained the
accomplishments in each Division. She said that the Civic Center was
trending upwards in revenue, event days, and attendance, and was
trending downward in expenses and subsidies. Mayor Oravec asked if
the decline in total operating expenses was a real decrease, or was
due to accounting and putting some of the expenses under the Parks
and Recreation Department. Ms. McCarthy replied that it was both, and
explained that Parks and Recreation was picking up $250,000 of the
cost of the facility from operating expenses, the café was reduced by
$165,000, and deferred maintenance was now under the Facilities
Maintenance Department. She said that before, 100% of expenses
were placed on the books and the bills were split out, but now, only the
Civic Center’s portion of expenses were placed on the book, so it was
split on the front end instead of the back end. Mayor Oravec asked Ms.
McCarthy what she reduced, other than the $165,000 for the café, to
which she replied that the budget for the last fiscal year was $3.2
million, and it was $2.8 million for the current fiscal year, due to
contractual services and streamlining of inflated items in the budget.
Mayor Oravec asked if the savings were around $350,000, to which Ms.
McCarthy responded in the affirmative.
Councilman Carvelli said that he was glad to see steady increases.
Mayor Oravec asked if the operating revenue shown was truly
operating revenue, and did not count any transfers in, to which Ms.
McCarthy replied that it was truly operating revenue, and that part of
the reason why it increased was because 17 events were recaptured
and there were 34 new events, as well as self-promotion. Mayor
Oravec said that he was happy to see an increase in the occupancy
rate. He pointed out that in 2016/2017, the occupancy rate was not
calculated, and said that he had been advocating for the occupancy
rate to be calculated for a long time. He asked how the occupancy rate
was calculated, to which Ms. McCarthy replied that the total amount of
square footage that was available to rent for the year was divided by
the actual number of square footage rented, and explained how event
days were determined. Mayor Oravec asked if move out days were
figured into the calculation, to which Ms. McCarthy replied that it
depended on whether the client or the Civic Center was doing the
set-up. Mayor Oravec asked to meet with Civic Center Director
Page 2 of 8
Special City Council Meeting Minutes October 21, 2019
McCarthy in the future to go over how the occupancy rate is
determined. Ms. McCarthy stated that she had a breakdown of the
figures, and would send them to Mayor Oravec.
Ms. McCarthy gave an overview of the operational improvements that
were made to the Civic Center. She explained the changes made to the
client booking documents, event insurance processes, documents for
customers, the Consumer Show Priority Program, and targeted sales
materials. She reiterated that 17 events that had gone away were
recaptured, and 34 new events were booked. She said that she could
provide a list, if desired. Councilwoman Morgan suggested having
those who attend events fill out surveys, including vendors and clients.
Mayor Oravec cautioned that the questions should be tailored to elicit
input about the facility and not have the feedback tainted by the
production of the event.
Ms. McCarthy presented a slide that illustrated marketing efforts, and
said that the City was in negotiations with Mid-Florida Credit Union for
naming rights and a rebranding of the Civic Center. She said that a
newsletter was being sent out to the City’s subscriber list, as well as 5
Chambers of Commerce. She said that website content was updated,
and showed a video regarding the We Love Lucie Concert Series and
the Community Band Series. She said that there would be a Kids
Festival Event with the Treasure Coast Sports Commission, and the
Parks and Recreation Department would be involved with it. Mayor
Oravec suggested that the Kids Festival Event be a one-stop shop for
the Youth Leagues to provide information to the public. Ms. McCarthy
said that there were some event sponsorship negotiations taking place
to offset the costs for the Concert Series. She said that the Civic
Center’s website URL was changed to www.pslciviccenter.com, but it
would change when the agreement with Mid-Florida Credit Union was
executed. She said that the Civic Center was nominated for Business
of the Year in the Tourism category by the St. Lucie Chamber. She
added that a CBS 12 Weather Cam was installed, and showed a video
of a news segment in which the Weather Cam was referenced. Vice
Mayor Martin commented that being nominated for an award by the
Chamber was very positive.
Ms. McCarthy gave an overview of the food and beverage services and
costs. Mayor Oravec asked how many outside caterers had provided
services, to which Ms. McCarthy replied that 20 open cater events were
held during the 2018 calendar year, and it generated about $50,000 in
Page 3 of 8
Special City Council Meeting Minutes October 21, 2019
revenue. She presented a video with feedback from clients who had
rented space at the Civic Center. Vice Mayor Martin commended Ms.
McCarthy for all of her hard work. Councilman Carvelli said that he was
happy to see the measurables, and suggested that with the Crosstown
Bridge being opened, there were more opportunities for partnerships
with golf courses and hotels in the City, as travel times would be
reduced. Mayor Oravec suggested opportunities for collaboration with
the Saints Golf Course.
Vice Mayor Martin moved to accept the 2019 State of the Civic Center
Report. Councilwoman Morgan seconded the motion. Assistant City
Manager Graham stated that staff intended to give an update with the
Civic Center's year-end numbers at the Winter Retreat. Mayor Oravec
said that he'd like to hear presentations for all of the City's business
units at the Winter Retreat. There being no further discussion, the
motion passed unanimously by voice vote.
6. New Business
Page 4 of 8
Special City Council Meeting Minutes October 21, 2019
6.a Request for Naming the E/W #3 Roadway in the SW 2019-942
Annexation Area by Mattamy Homes
Steve Garrett, Lucido and Associates, stated that he represented
Mattamy Palm Beach, LLC. He said that Tony Palumbo, Mattamy
Homes, was also present. He said that the proposed roadway was
named Open View Drive in the DRI documents, and explained that in
Southern Grove, Polte was developing housing and when they reached
out to get addressing, concern was expressed by St. Lucie County
regarding addressing and 911, as on the east side, there was a small
section of roadway that was also named Open View Road. He said that
when the planning was done for Southern Grove, it was thought that if a
potential interchange was placed, Open View Road would continue, but
the interchange did not currently exist. Mr. Garrett said that the name
Marshall Parkway was being proposed in honor of World War II
General George C. Marshall. He said that alternate names were also
being proposed, and all 3 names were validated by St. Lucie County for
availability.
Vice Mayor Martin said that she did not have an issue with the request.
Mayor Oravec asked if there were other alternate names, as one name
was hanging out for some time. Mr. Garrett said that the problem faced
with this roadway may affect Paar Drive at some point. Vice Mayor
Martin said that the name was not a hill to die on for her. Mayor Oravec
said that there was a movement to name the Crosstown Parkway
something else, and that Don Cooper passed away, and it may be a
conversation for the community to have. He added that some sources
named General Marshall as the most respected military person in
history, besides George Washington, so he was okay with it if the
Council was. Councilman Carvelli stated that he did not like the options
of Positivity Way or Candes Parkway for road names. He thanked Mr.
Palumbo for working with the City during Hurricane Dorian
preparations.
Councilwoman Morgan moved to approve the request to name the
East/West Roadway in the Southwest Annexation Area by Mattamy
Homes to Marshall Parkway. Councilman Carvelli seconded the
motion, which passed unanimously by voice vote.
Page 5 of 8
Special City Council Meeting Minutes October 21, 2019
6.b Accept the One Half-Cent Sales Tax Third-Quarter Projects 2019-955
Update
Assistant City Manager Graham stated that Assistant Public Works
Director Stocton would present the item. Mr. Stocton stated that the
item was for the 3rd Quarter Update of the Sales Tax Projects. He said
that the Sales Tax Action Team, which was the internal project
management team, met every two weeks. He said that the
Council-appointed Citizens’ Oversight Committee met quarterly. Mr.
Stocton gave an update of the Prima Vista Boulevard and Cashmere
Boulevard projects in St. Lucie West. He said that once Prima Vista
and Cashmere were done, the work on Bayshore would start, and it
was projected to be done by Spring Training. Mayor Oravec asked if
the oaks on Cashmere were relocated, to which Mr. Stocton replied
that they were relocated to Lake Harvey. He said that the sidewalks for
Torino were still under design, and per Council direction, the width was
increased from 6 feet to 8 feet, where possible. He said that the design
was expected to be complete by February, and construction would
begin this fiscal year. he said that Tiffany, Hilmoor, and Morningside
were accomplished last fiscal year.
Mr. Stocton stated that regarding repaving, the only remaining roadway
at the end of the year was Thornhill, which was completed the Monday
after Crosstown Parkway was completed. He said that staff was getting
ready for the Fiscal Year 19/20 Sales Tax-funded projects, which
comprised about 3 miles. He said that the City was trying to use
remaining funds from the Crosstown Bond to fund adaptive
signalization along the Crosstown Parkway. He said that if the money
was not available, it was still planned in the Sales Tax. He said that
there were proposals ready to go, but staff was waiting to true up at the
end of the job and see how much money was left. He said that Port St.
Lucie Boulevard was slated for installation in 2028. Vice Mayor Martin
asked what the timeline was for the true up, to which Assistant City
Manager Roebling replied that it would probably be January.
Mr. Stocton said that the design of Phase 1 of the Floresta Project was
underway, and staff was working through permitting issues with South
Florida Water Management District as well as utility relocations. He
said that the selection of a design engineer for Phases 2 and 3 was
underway and he was unsure of the timeframe. He presented a slide
which illustrated the Torino Boulevard Intersection Improvements, and
said that the project began on October 14th. He said that they were
Page 6 of 8
Special City Council Meeting Minutes October 21, 2019
projected to be complete in July. He said that if funding was leftover
from Crosstown, beautification projects would take place on the US1
intersections. He said that there were additional funds from the Sales
Tax Budget to do improvements along US1 in 2021.
Mr. Stocton said that the Prima Vista Project was underway, and the
expected completion date was in September of 2020. Councilman
Carvelli asked if sidewalks were part of the project, to which Mr.
Stocton replied that safety improvements were being made, but the
look of the road was not being changed under this project. He said that
there would be another project later, but the County only had a 2 or
3-year plan, and the projects that would dramatically change the look of
Prima Vista were out past 3 years. Councilman Carvelli asked if
curbing was going to be done as part of the Prima Vista Project, to
which Assistant Public Works Director Stocton replied that he was not
sure, but he would bring more information back. Mayor Oravec said
that FPL was working on their Hardening Project, and utility providers
had to provide a 1 or 3-year plan, so it was unknown what FPL’s plan
would look like.
CFO/City Treasurer Snyder presented a slide that illustrated how the
Sales Tax was performing, on a cash basis model. He said that
revenues were coming in, and were meeting the projections. He said
that the number provided for revenue was actual cash coming in, and
was about 2 months behind. Councilwoman Morgan said that she did
not see the revenues, to which Mr. Snyder replied that the revenues
were in the monthly report. Mayor Oravec said that he would like to see
the revenue for the Half-Cent Sales Tax, on an annual basis. Mr.
Snyder said that numbers would be provided at the Winter Retreat.
Vice Mayor Martin said that she wanted to see the revenues versus
expenditures. Assistant City Manager Graham informed the Council
that the Citizens’ Oversight Committee would meet to finalize the Final
Year-End Report for the Half-Cent Sales Tax, and staff hoped to bring
the Final Report to the Council on December 9th. Assistant Public
Works Director Stocton stated that the monthly report included a list of
revenues and a quarterly adjustment. Councilman Carvelli said that
when he worked with bonds in the past, he experienced that as the
community grew, the revenues grew, and the bonds were expired early.
He said that he would expect a surplus, as there was likely going to be
growth. Mr. Snyder said that projections from the state were used.
Councilman Carvelli moved to accept the Half-Cent Sales Tax Third
Quarter Report. Vice Mayor Martin seconded the motion. Mayor Oravec
Page 7 of 8
Special City Council Meeting Minutes October 21, 2019
stated that infrastructure was the foundation that the City was being
built upon, and asked Assistant Public Works Director Stocton to
advocate for as much repaving dollars as he could get. There being no
further discussion, the motion passed unanimously by voice vote.
7. Adjourn
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned at 2:28 p.m.
________________________________
Karen A. Phillips, City Clerk
________________________________
Jeannette C. Baechle, Deputy City Clerk
Page 8 of 8
Agenda
City of Port St.Lucie
121 SW Port St. Lucie Blvd.
Port St. Lucie, Florida 34984
Meeting Agenda
Monday, October 21, 2019
1:30 PM
Council Chambers, City Hall
Special City Council
Gregory J. Oravec, Mayor
Stephanie Morgan, Councilwoman, District I
John Carvelli, Councilman, District II
Shannon Martin, Vice Mayor, District III
Jolien Caraballo, Councilwoman, District IV
Special City Council Meeting Agenda October 21, 2019
1. Meeting Called to Order
2. Roll Call
3. Pledge of Allegiance
4. Public to be Heard
5. Special Presentation
5.a Accept the 2019 State of the Civic Center Report. 2019-943
6. New Business
6.a Request for Naming the E/W #3 Roadway in the SW 2019-942
Annexation Area by Mattamy Homes
6.b Accept the One Half-Cent Sales Tax Third-Quarter Projects 2019-955
Update
7. Adjourn
Page 1 of 2
Special City Council Meeting Agenda October 21, 2019
Notice: No stenographic record by a certified court reporter will be made of the
foregoing meeting. Accordingly, if a person decides to appeal any decision made by the
City Council, board, agency, or commission with respect to any matter considered at
such meeting or hearing, he or she will need a record of the proceedings, and that, for
such purpose, he or she may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings
is made, which record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to
be based. (F.S. 286.0105)
Notice: Public and Press are invited to review all the backup for Council Meetings.
Copies are available in the City Clerk’s Office on Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, and
Monday before Council Meetings. On Meeting nights, a copy of backup material is
available in the reception area of City Hall for public review. Please leave the agenda
and backup material in good order for others to review.
Notice: Anyone wishing to speak during Public to be Heard is asked to fill out a yellow
Participation Card and submit it to the City Clerk. Anyone wishing to speak on any
Agenda Item is asked to fill out a green Participation Card and submit it to the City Clerk.
Participation Cards are available on the side table in Council Chambers, at the reception
desk in City Hall lobby, and in the City Clerk’s Office.
Notice: In accordance with the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990, persons
needing special accommodation to participate in this proceeding should contact the City
Clerk’s Office at 772-871-5157.
As a courtesy to the people recording the meeting, please turn all cell phones to silent
or off. Thank you.
Page 2 of 2
Get email alerts for Port St. Lucie
A daily email when new agendas and minutes are posted.