Retiree Health Care Investment Board
Regular MeetingRoyal Oak, MI · August 6, 2019
Minutes
CITY OF ROYAL OAK RETIREE HEALTH CARE INVESTMENT BOARD
MINUTES OF THE REGULAR MEETING OF THE BOARD OF TRUSTEES
A meeting of the Retiree Health Care Investment Board of Trustees was conducted in the city hall
conference room 309, Royal Oak MI, Tuesday, August 6, 2019 at 8:30 a.m.
The meeting was called to order at 8:30 a.m.
Attendance
PRESENT: Lee Collick- Chairperson
Bret Nelson- Vice Chairperson
Kim Gibbs- Trustee
Kyle DuBuc- Trustee
Corey O’Donohue – Police Chief / Assistant City Manager / Acting City
Manager
ALSO PRESENT: Julie Rudd - Bd Chief Administrative Officer/ Bd Secretary/Bd Treasurer
Lisa Genord- Administrative Assistant / Pension Technician
Tom Michaud – Bd attorney with VanOverbeke Michaud and Timmony
Chris Kuhn - AndCo
Public Comment
None
Board approval of the agenda for August 6, 2019 meeting
Moved by Bret Nelson to approve the August 6, 2019 meeting agenda
Supported by Kyle DuBuc
MOTION ADOPTED UNANIIMOUSLY 5/0
Board approval of the draft minutes for July 1, 2019 meeting
Moved by Bret Nelson to approve the July 1, 2019 meeting minutes
Supported by Kyle DuBuc
MOTION ADOPTED UNANIIMOUSLY 5/0
INVESTMENTS
Investment performance review as of June 30, 2019 provided by Chris Kuhn of AndCo
Market value/allocation of assets as of June 30, 2019 is $132,621,935.
Current month – total portfolio underperformed the benchmark: 4.60% vs. 4.87% index.
Three-month performance – total portfolio underperformed the benchmark: 3.04% vs. 3.35% index.
YTD performance – total portfolio underperformed the benchmark: 12.53% vs. 13.00% index.
One-year performance – total portfolio underperformed the benchmark: 5.35% vs. 7.11% index.
Inception – total portfolio underperformed the benchmark: 5.14% vs. 6.84% index.
Chris reported that despite the recent market volatility, the 2nd quarter performance was very good.
AQR and First Eagle were paying dividends despite the market volatility, however both Seizert and
Ancora mid-caps trailed for the quarter.
Investment performance review as of July 31, 2019 provided by Chris Kuhn of AndCo
Market value/allocation of assets as of July 31, 2019 is $132,797,922.
Current month – total portfolio outperformed the benchmark: 0.54% vs. 0.43% index.
Three-month performance – total portfolio underperformed the benchmark: 1.01% vs. 1.40% index.
YTD performance – total portfolio underperformed the benchmark: 13.24% vs. 13.57% index.
One-year performance – total portfolio underperformed the benchmark: 4.05% vs. 5.42% index.
Inception – total portfolio underperformed the benchmark: 5.24% vs. 6.82% index.
Chris reported that we were off to a good start in July up until the last day or so, and that August is
off to a rocky start. Seizert Capital Mid Cap outperformed the index for the month of July, while
Ancora Small Mid-Cap underperformed in July. Chris / AndCo did not recommend any changes
considering the ongoing market volatility.
The complete AndCo Investment Performance Review reports dated June 30, 2019 and July 31,
2019 are on file in Finance Office.
Moved by Kyle DuBuc to receive and file
Supported by Bret Nelson
MOTION ADOPTED UNIANIMOUSLY 5/0
PGIM Real Estate – Asset & Investment Report 2nd Quarter 2019
Moved by Kyle DuBuc to receive and file
Supported by Bret Nelson
MOTION ADOPTED UNIANIMOUSLY 5/0
PGIM Real Estate – 2018 ESG Highlights
Moved by Kyle DuBuc to receive and file
Supported by Bret Nelson
MOTION ADOPTED UNIANIMOUSLY 5/0
PGIM Real Estate – Prisa II Flash Report 2nd Quarter 2019
Moved by Kyle DuBuc to receive and file
Supported by Bret Nelson
MOTION ADOPTED UNIANIMOUSLY 5/0
Seizert Capital Partners (SCP) - Quarterly Report dated June 30, 2019
Moved by Kyle DuBuc to receive and file
Supported by Bret Nelson
MOTION ADOPTED UNIANIMOUSLY 5/0
Seizert Capital Partners (SCP) – Mid Cap Commentary 2Q 2019 as of June 30,2019
Moved by Kyle DuBuc to receive and file
Supported by Bret Nelson
MOTION ADOPTED UNIANIMOUSLY 5/0
Seizert Capital Partners (SCP) – Directions Newsletter 2Q 2019 as of June 30, 2019
Moved by Kyle DuBuc to receive and file
Supported by Bret Nelson
MOTION ADOPTED UNIANIMOUSLY 5/0
LEGAL
None
OTHER
2019 Fiduciary Liability Insurance Policy
Moved by Bret Nelson to receive and file.
Supported by Kyle DuBuc
MOTION ADOPTED UNIANIMOUSLY 5/0
NEXT MEETING AND ADJOURNMENT
Next regular meeting is scheduled immediately following the retirement system board meeting at
approximately 8:30am on Monday, September 9, 2019 at city hall room 309.
Moved by Lee Collick to adjourn the meeting (8:37 a.m.) and confirm next meeting for September 9,
2019 immediately following retirement system board meeting at approximately 8:30 a.m.
Supported by Bret Nelson
MOTION ADOPTED UNIANIMOUSLY 5/0
Agenda
AGENDA OF THE CITY OF ROYAL OAK
RETIREE HEALTH CARE INVESTMENT BOARD MEETING
Tuesday – August 6, 2019
Immediately following the Retirement Board Meeting at approx. 8:30 AM
City Hall conference room 309 - Royal Oak, MI
1) PUBLIC COMMENT
2) REQUEST THAT THE BOARD APPROVE THE AGENDA FOR AUGUST 6, 2019
3) REQUEST THAT THE BOARD APPROVE THE MINUTES FOR JULY 1, 2019
4) INVESTMENTS
Market value and performance update presented by Chris Kuhn of AndCo
(Report to be provided at meeting)
Request that the Board receive and file.
PGIM Real Estate – Asset & Investment Report 2nd Quarter 2019 (enclosed)
Request that the Board receive and file.
PGIM Real Estate – 2018 ESG Highlights (enclosed)
Request that the Board receive and file.
PGIM Real Estate – Prisa II Flash Report 2nd Quarter 2019 (enclosed)
Request that the Board receive and file.
Seizert Capital Partners (SCP) - Quarterly Report dated June 30, 2019 (enclosed)
Request that the Board receive and file.
Seizert Capital Partners (SCP) – Mid Cap Commentary 2Q 2019 as of June 30, 2019 (enclosed)
Request that the Board receive and file.
Seizert Capital Partners (SCP) – Directions Newsletter 2Q 2019 as of June 30, 2019 (enclosed)
Request that the Board receive and file.
5) LEGAL
None
6) OTHER
2019 Fiduciary Liability Insurance Policy (enclosed)
Request that the Board receive and file.
7) ADJOURN
Next regular meeting (first Monday of each month) is scheduled for immediately following the
retirement system board meeting at approximately 8:30 am on Monday September 9, 2019 at City Hall
room 309.
Request that the Board establish the next meeting.
Get email alerts for Royal Oak
A daily email when new agendas and minutes are posted.