Public Art Commission
Regular MeetingSalem, MA · January 17, 2023
Minutes
Salem Public Art Commission
98 Washington Street
Salem, Massachusetts 01970
(978) 619-5685
KIMBERLEY DRISCOLL
MAYOR
Public Art Commission
January 17, 2023, 6:30pm
Meeting held remotely via zoom
MEETING MINUTES
Note: All proposals, presentations, and/or documentation to be reviewed and discussed
at this meeting can be viewed online at the following link: https://bit.ly/SalemPACProposals
• Meeting called to order at 6:36 pm.
• Roll Call PAC: Norene Gachignard, John Andrews, Janine Liberty, Carly Dwyer-Naik & Gwen Rosemond
in attendance. Currently, there are two open chairs as Catherine and Kurt have given their notice of
leave.
• Meeting Minute Approvals
o December 20, 2022 Meeting Minutes- Norene entertained a motion, Janine made a motion to
approve the meeting minutes, Carly seconded. Motion carried unanimously.
● Jim Chisholm Proposal for Gift of Art
Jim is a Salem resident and local artist. He would like to donate a drawing/painting of the Friendship of
Salem to the City.
Some of the questions posed during the discussion from PAC members include:
-Where does it go?
-What is the process of who gets it?
-What are the accession rules?
-Where would we store items donated?
-If the item is donated to the city, does it need to be displayed in a public space?
Julie is interested in waiting to accept the gift until our gifts and accessioning and deaccessioning policies
are in place. Gwen listed her concern for waiting until the policies are in place. Norene and John both
sought to agree to the gift as to not offend and or turn away such a beautiful piece from a very talented
artist. Janine would love to be fully transparent with the artist and be forthright, “we love the art, give us
some time to find the proper place for it, as this is a start of a much needed process.” Carly agreed with
Janine to accept the piece with the agreement to wait on handing it over until we can find a place for it.
Norene entertained a motion. Carly motioned to accept the donation from Jim, but defer receiving the
painting until we have a location for the painting and until formal accessioning protocol policies have taken
place. Seconded by Janine. Voting was unanimous.
● Chagall PAC Public Piano Proposal
Dennis has a piano that is nearing the end of its life. He would like to donate the piece to let it live out the
rest of its days on Artists Row. The piano would potentially be painted and sealed by a local artist as well to
be played all summer long. Dennis is also committed to disposing of it once it is ‘gone’.
Carly is interested in getting Salem students involved as this could be a rough canvas for those that are
interested in getting into the public arts scene. John asked if the piano was going to be covered up with
something, or if it was going to be inside as the last piano down there was heavily affected by water and
rain. Dennis was brought into the panel to discuss his ideas for maintaining the piano. He suggested a dolly
(which can be purchased for $300) for the large upright piano. He agreed that yes with the rain and
weather, if not taken inside or covered, the piano will only last a season, but could have the potential to last
two years if taken care of properly. Norene stated that there is no one on the PAC that would be able to
commit to moving the piano at every chance of inclement weather. Norene suggested a tarp to cover the
piano instead of moving it with a dolly. Julie suggested a large grill cover to preserve the piano from the
elements as much as possible. John suggested PAC use some of its funds to invest in a dolly to have the
piano moved in case of inclement weather or other piano donations. Norene asked Julie to run the dolly
idea past legal to see if this is a viable option. PAC asked Dennis if he would be willing to be in charge of the
grill cover when it rains and he agreed just as they take care of furniture and art pieces in their display. PAC
asked Dennis when he would like to bring out the piano and it was mutually agreed upon in April.
Julie asked for a two part motion, one for approving the piano to be donated to the Row, and another for
funds to be allocated to the beautification of the piece. John asked to wait on that second vote as Art Fest
was coming up and there might be a way for him and Kylie to incorporate that into the festival. Dennis also
agreed as he may have people interested in painting.
Norene has entertained a motion to accept a piano to be acquired for Artist’s Row, and for Dennis to be
responsible for preserving the piece by covering it during inclement weather. Janine motioned, and John
seconded. Voting was unanimous.
● Public Art Work Plan Updates & CLC Mural Design Vote
-Making It Public: Julie is still trying to confirm the panelists. It’s coming together slowly. Right now she is
focusing on all panelists confirmed and having the meeting scheduled by early February. Julie ideally would
like PAC to confirm the finalists at the February meeting. Julie also spoke to NEFA about the public voting
on the place and piece, and because it wasn’t articulated in the call as part of the process, we are not
allowed to change the review process once posted due to procurement regulations. So unfortunately,
because it wasn’t built in on the onset, we won’t be able to bring this for public vote. This is good food for
thought as in the future, if we would like to involve the public in voting processes, we would need to be
deliberate in the call about such ideas. Janine brings up once the piece has been decided, and if it lasts
more than one season, if THEN we would be able to bring it to the public to ask where it would go next.
Julie confirms that that would be completely legal as the piece has already been procured, and PAC would
already own it, therefore if would be our choice. Gwen, Janine and John are all still interested in being on
the panel.
-Charlotte Forten Park Memorial Project: On January 10th the NEA announced their grants and we were
one of them. We have received a grant for $30,000.00 from the National Endowment of the Arts towards
this project. We have $50,000.00 in City Lost ARPA revenue funds. In total we have about $80,000.00 but
we need $125,000.00 so we are looking to do some fundraising to close that financial gap. Gwen is working
with the MAPC now to articulate Charlotte's story and how we are going to tell that story in the call for
artists. Julie will bring that call for artists for PAC to review at the next meeting, before making it live.
Before the call can be released publicly, we will have to close the gap in funding first. Julie is currently
working on that and there are a couple of grants that she is currently seeking and possibly some other
avenues within City funding. In the same aspect, we are working with the City to come up with a separate
shade structure of some sort for that space, as well as putting out a call for activation of the space. Over
the next month you may see a RFQ or RFP coming from the city calling for a bid to activate the space.
A call for engagement, we are looking for community members to join the artist selection committee, the
commemoration committee, and the technical review committee who will be working with DPW and legal
as well as possible landscape architects to advise on the technical aspects of it (ADA accessible, weight and
structure of concrete, ect). Janine and Carly both stated their interest in the Commemoration Committee.
Rotating Sculpture Garden: The application has been submitted to the Parks and Rec Commission and Julie
will let PAC know when we are going to be on their agenda. Artists will be contacted soon with installations
happening in April.
Ana Dugan and the CLC Mural Project: Ana has already begun her preliminary work with the Community
Center. She has done about 4 workshops total in allowing the community to vote and have input in the
piece getting their opinions. She has been meeting with CLC staff to direct the project. There are two
design options that she has presented. One of which she has gotten the favor of the CLC staff. PACs weigh
in and approval of the design is now needed in order to move forward. Julie pulled up the two proposed
designs. PAC has agreed on the proposal of the first piece presented, however the second one is admired,
but it was agreed that it may be too busy for the space.
Norene entertained a motion to approve the “Four Seasons of Salem” piece. Gwen moved, and Carly
seconded. Voting was unanimous. John vows to make it over to the CLC while Ana paints to capture the
process.
-Winter Activations: Kylie is working on what fits best with Salem So Sweet, live window painters during
the festival, and potentially an added performance. John is hoping that we are able to bring back window
displays “Love Letters for Salem”, a collection of love letters that are still on some windows two years later.
Artists would complete one small window in advance and complete one large painting live during the
festival, 4 murals in total. Selected windows would be on Washington Street or Essex Street, live painting
would be scheduled on Friday, with a rain date for Saturday. This would be a way for PAC to sponsor art
during the festival.
-Spring activations: Julie asked for thoughts regarding activations in April and May. She has reached out to
the Lynn Music Foundation for a hip-hop showcase, which is just conversational, and very preliminary. John
loves the idea of working with Lynn Music, but he would like to look into local Salem projects instead.
Norene and Gwen commented that is their preference as well. Janine inquired about Drag shows, and John
expressed interests in supporting young performers. Julie suggested a young performers showcase. PAC is
interested in including performing youth up to 21 years old. We are also working with SPS to get
information out about working with Salem United and getting young Salem artists to work with them too.
Julie likes the direction of the call. As she starts to develop the call to be released in February, she will send
it out to this body via email since we will not have another meeting to discuss it internally. She asks for all
feedback to be directed to Julie, so that there isn’t a discourse via email. But if there is a need for a special
meeting, we can arrange that. However, there will still be plenty of time to get the word out through March
if the event is in April. Julie will bring this to the February meeting after all.
Artists Row Updates: Julie just gave the new tenants the keys today and Claudia has her contract, and
Chagall PAC and Shindig have already signed theirs, so we are on track to a new residency on Artists Row.
The 2024 Public Artist in Residence is not selected. So possibly in April or May of this year we will put out
the call.
-Gift of Art Policy: Julie will do her best in moving this forward. March or potentially February would be a
good timeline to look over those policies.
● Public Art Policies Roll Out Plan - Publicity and Community Outreach
We have the individual proposals policy, but it hasn’t been publicized at all. Julie would like to know how
PAC members envision these policies rolling out whether it be a press release, or reinvent the “Meet the
PAC” event. March first is the deadline for submitting proposals to be reviewed at the March meeting. The
next view period isn’t until September. If these policies are going to be rolled out this year, Julie suggests
announcing them as soon as possible, hopefully before the end of the month. PAC may even consider
postponing the deadline until March 15th if so desired. Norene likes the idea of a press release and would
like to have another go at the “Meet the PAC” event possibly during one of the activations as mentioned
above. John likes the idea of the press release as Julie has had major success in the past. PAC members
have agreed to spread the news to their various outlets about the policy changes as well.
● Vacancies to the PAC-
We have two chairs open, and postings were put on the Salem website. Please spread the word for new
PAC members.
● Other City Updates:
-Old Town Hall: Tom Daniel and Julie Barry are currently working with the finance department to work out
the funding strategy to raise money for the needs of this project. Predevelopment work is moving forward,
to make sure that the predevelopment paperwork is the right size for the project to get the best quote for
getting the project financed. She will be working with councilwoman Caroline Watson-Felt to reach out to
the abutting neighbors in the area to make sure they are aware of the drilling in the area to test the
geothermal. Moving forward they will be operating the building as normal through June 2024. However, we
may be looking to do more programming and call for artists to populate and build out the programming in
that space, creating different opportunities and projects for that space for groups to engage.
● Public Comments-
Dennis wanted to share that his bands the brass quartet and the Dirt Munchers are going to be performing
at Salem So sweet on Friday night, Saturday afternoon and Saturday evening.
● Adjourn- Norene motioned to adjourn. Moved by John, seconded by Carly. Meeting Adjourned at 7:45pm.
Persons requiring auxiliary aids and services for effective communication such as sign language interpreter, an assistive listening device,
or print material in digital format or a reasonable modification in programs, services, policies, or activities, may contact the City of
Salem ADA Coordinator, as soon as possible and no less than 2 business days before the meeting, program, or event.
Know your rights under the Open Meeting Law M.G.L. c. 30A § 18-25 and City Ordinance § 2-2028 through § 2-2033.
Agenda
Salem Public Art Commission
98 Washington Street
Salem, Massachusetts 01970
(978) 619-5685
Robert K. McCarthy NOTICE OF PUBLIC MEETING
ACTING MAYOR
Public Art Commission
January 17, 2023, 6:30 pm
Meeting will be held via Remote Participation
Important Announcement
Notice is hereby given that a meeting of the Salem Public Art Commission will be held via remote participation in
accordance with Chapter 107 of the Act of 2022. Specific information and the general guidelines for remote
participation by members of the public and/or parties with a right and/or requirement to attend this meeting can be
found below.
No in-person attendance of members of the public will be permitted, but every effort will be made to ensure that the
public can adequately access the proceedings in real time, via technological means. In the event that we are unable to
do so, despite best efforts, we will post on the city’s website an audio or video recording, transcript, or other
comprehensive record of proceedings as soon as possible after the meeting.
Recordings and presentation materials, if any, can be accessed using the Salem Public Art Commission website using
the following link and clicking on the date for the meeting you wish to view:
https://www.salemma.gov/node/3751/agenda.
Remote Participation Instructions:
Public participation for the Salem Public Art Commission meeting on the date and time listed above will be
conducted via a free remote participation platform called Zoom.
The City of Salem strongly encourages any parties who wish to participate in this meeting to download and familiarize
themselves with Zoom prior to the meeting.
For this meeting, members of the public who wish to watch, listen or provide comment during the meeting may do so
using one of the following methods:
▪ Video & Audio Option 1: Follow this link or enter it into your web browser to join the meeting:
https://us02web.zoom.us/j/81311628967?pwd=T05GeEI2N2RLcE9RR2p4R3FtOVVqZz09
▪ Video & Audio Option 2: Follow this link or enter it into your web browser to open the Zoom
website at https://zoom.us/join or open your Zoom Ap on your smart device. Then enter the
Meeting ID# 813 1162 8967 as directed on the webpage and click “Join”. Follow the on-screen
instructions to join the meeting. Meeting Password is SalemArts.
▪ Audio ONLY – Dial 888-475-4499 (or 877-853-5257 if trouble connecting, both are Toll Free) to join the
meeting using your phone. When prompted, enter Meeting ID# 813 1162 8967 and follow the
instructions to join the meeting. Meeting Password is SalemArts.
Public Comment Protocol:
During portions of the meeting in which public comment is permitted, members of the public who have “raised
their hand” in Zoom will be called on to offer comment. Members of the public who wish to address the
Commission or make a comment may do so only when called upon during the open public comment portion of the
Page 1 of 2
meeting. When the time comes, the Commission Chair will announce that the floor is now open for public comment.
In order to raise a hand, members of the public using the Zoom computer or phone applications may click the “Raise
Hand” feature that can be found next to your name on the participants screen to ‘raise your hand’ then wait to be called
upon for comment. Please make sure to remember to turn your microphone on and unmute yourself before raising your
hand. Those participating by dialing in from their phones my also utilize the “Raise Hand’ feature of this platform by
pressing “ *9 ” on your key pad.
Alternatively, members of the public can email their comments/questions to jbarry@salem.com a minimum of 2
hours before the start of the meeting to have them read into record during the meeting by City Staff.
MEETING AGENDA
Tuesday, January 17, 2023, 6:30 pm
Note: All proposals, presentations, and/or documentation to be reviewed and discussed at this meeting can be viewed
online at the following link: https://bit.ly/SalemPACProposals
• Call to Order & Roll Call
• Meeting Minutes Approval
o December 20, 2022 Meeting Minutes
• James (Jim) Chisholm Proposal for Gift of Art
• Chagall PAC Public Piano Proposal
• Public Art Workplan Updates & CLC Mural Design Vote
• Public Art Policies Roll Out Plan - Publicity and Community Outreach
• Public Comments
• Adjourn
Persons requiring auxiliary aids and services for effective communication such as sign language interpreter, an assistive listening
device, or print material in digital format or a reasonable modification in programs, services, policies, or activities, may contact the City
of Salem ADA Coordinator, as soon as possible and no less than 2 business days before the meeting, program, or event.
Know your rights under the Open Meeting Law M.G.L. c. 30A § 18-25 and City Ordinance § 2-2028 through § 2-2033.
Page 2 of 2
Get email alerts for Salem
A daily email when new agendas and minutes are posted.